The way that the interview framed his questions was amazingly unprofessional for any kind of journalist. It was like, "Well we know that China oppresses its people, butchers and eats its children, and is menacing the world with its aggressive military....So, what do you think of China as a world threat?" He is literally already convicting China of a whole laundry list of crimes and misconducts, and trying to get the Singaporean leader to agree. Glad to see that this high level Singaporean official is far too intelligent to fall into his word trap. He basically destroyed every accusation posed by the interview and made the point that from the Chinese point of view, they have only acted to protect China's own interests and security. He sounds like a very intelligent and informed leader. Clearly, a lot smarter than this journalist with an agenda.
This man was an oncologist turned politician and have been our Defence Minister for the past decade and I hope he will continue on for another decade but alas he is already 66 years old. I'm glad the system was able to identify talent when they met him and put him where he is. Majulah Singapura!
@@yooong He sounds like a seasoned diplomat. He never lost his temper or fell into the journalist's word traps. Instead he skillfully side-stepped all of the journalist's accusations regarding China and made his own points that China has merely been protecting its own interests and security, and has done nothing that other nations have not done or tried to do.
Few would and could understand that Singapore is benefiting from USA insecurity in the region, presenting to the world that it is actually a base for the Americans when it is not. 😊😊😊. Do people actually believe that Malaysia, Indonesia, together with Singapore will close down the Straits of Malacca for the Yankees to the detriment of other countries in Asean.
@josephtan4328 Precisely. Former PM Lee had in 2020 announced that Singapore is NOT an ally of the US and will neither conduct military operations on behalf of the US nor seek direct military support from them. Current PM Wong has also reiterated this recently when he was there. It beats me why some people still fail to comprehend this.
The Indian America tried to act smart n worldly, tried to put difficult questions to d minister but d minister just was able to answer him w short sharp or realistic replies. He is brilliant.
As long asTaiwan does not do anything rash, Asia will stay safe as long as it can. I think we already know which countries are taking sides. No countries can stay neutral.
It seems China is always at the center of the world's attention. If the US has the capability and caliber to compete with China, then show it. Don't just be like the saying, 'Wisdom has been chasing you, but you've always been faster.' This world is large enough to accommodate both China and the US. It's time for Americans to get out of their own country and see the world. Such shallow-mindedness, similar to some Canadians, needs to change.
@a2003cath You are correct. However, since the target audience of this channel are non-English speakers, specifically Cantonese speakers, the Chinese subtitles should be improved for better understanding. Just my two cents worth.
I think he still trying to cover up for US 's wrong doing /action & policy & even show he is on US side by saying "inviting US's military presence to the Pacific. Didn't he know that's how all the Taiwan conflicts started!
America has to decide for itself whether to still be the global leader and allow competition within the system or to have a dual global system. It seems at this trajectory, it is inevitable that a separate system will slowly form.
There's a lot of ignorant comments here. I believe it has a lot to do with the really bad Chinese translations. Both the questioner and the responder made very good points regarding peace for Asia. The attack on the questioner is racist and unwarranted.
With the prosperity comes the better Chinese people's behavior. US and the west has hundreds of years of prosperity to shape their behavior. We still like the ordinary American and European people, they are nice, honest, fair, kind and polite.. China, with more high tech engineers, will catchup and lead the world but will at the same time move more towards market capitalism. If US is willing to work with China, the world will be a better place for all. World stage will be different, BRICs..BRI. will lift the third world's economy. It will be a better world. CCP communism will not be the same. The ball is in US's court. China is always ready to talk and find a win-win solution but you cannot expect China to give up all. Just like BRI. Its popularity is that I show you how to fish, and you need to help yourself.
![[Gegagedigedagedago] NEW Help Gegagedigedagedago Nugget escape from Nikocado Avocado Challenge](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hJWnwRC2Fz8/mqdefault.jpg)
我是地地道道的新加坡人，我以此为最大的光荣❤
感恩我国盖世伟人李光耀先生以及每一位睿智政治领导人，如此艰辛捍卫着这个小红点，面对国际上的惊涛骇浪，凶猛威武，霸气凌人的局势。倘若一个不小心，随时皆可被压制，吞没可能性。
感恩我国的国防部长黄永宏先生🙏，智破老美记者陷阱，高情商回答中美纠缠不清的问题。👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
吾爱吾国🇸🇬今生有幸生于此，当以新加坡人无比荣耀🤗🙏🏻
上了一堂很好的外交課。小國的生存之道。言語上不能得罪任何一個大國，但又能顯示他很了解局勢，不卑不亢。厲害
亚州小辣椒！试过就知辣！
@@thomaschongns3505要是面对的是特狼普，小Sing只有听训的份儿😂😂😂
未必 ！
不卑不亢？
這部長基本上是任何問題都遊而不接，問者和答者完全是各自表述，沒有在同一問題內交接。
不過部長也表達了他的本心，就是間接指責美國在亞洲失去了道德合法性。當然使用了外交方式表達，哈哈。
我是新加坡人，这是我的骄傲。感谢已故李光耀先生，把他的理念传承下去
李光耀先生是一位英明的領袖，偉大的政治家。美英西方的陰謀在李先生肚裡一清二楚，只要是事實，在牠們面前也毫不客氣！
去搜尋（李光耀 彭定康）看看，大快人心！
很为他受贿低价购买豪华公寓和把子女教育成反目成仇🎉！
Why there isn't any Chinese military vessels at Changi Base ?
@@YouCCP2eh Changi so small can put what?
@@YouCCP2Singapore still hold one strong stands against Communism.
I am a S’porean. Very proud of our Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen.
Your defense minister is a gentleman indeed,but the moderator is really barbarian！
At least his English is not Singaporean.
@@YuanBo63 what do you mean by English not Singaporean?
Yes I agree! He is darn smart in his responses. Doesn’t lose class, has a solid rationale and a great sense of humour as well!
@@oasislin4587he mean he not as good as Lawrence wong
How smart is minister Ng who throw back a question go the host. Brilliant. 😂
常言道：聽其言，觀其行，提問者的的確確是好人有限…是非曲直不分👉好一個衣冠禽獸👍
美國的阿三，在媒體討飯吃，反華是敲門磚，幾乎無一例外.....
The way that the interview framed his questions was amazingly unprofessional for any kind of journalist. It was like, "Well we know that China oppresses its people, butchers and eats its children, and is menacing the world with its aggressive military....So, what do you think of China as a world threat?" He is literally already convicting China of a whole laundry list of crimes and misconducts, and trying to get the Singaporean leader to agree. Glad to see that this high level Singaporean official is far too intelligent to fall into his word trap. He basically destroyed every accusation posed by the interview and made the point that from the Chinese point of view, they have only acted to protect China's own interests and security. He sounds like a very intelligent and informed leader. Clearly, a lot smarter than this journalist with an agenda.
此位美籍印度主持人，簡直是被人洗了腦，全無國際視野和知識，人云亦云，開始提問話中國越來越嗜戰，欺凌鄰弱小國，簡直是不知所謂，語無論次。
嗯，西方思维不完美，这都是源自不正确的世界观。
這主持人心里只有老一和老三能跨越時空
你可以對這周街大小便（有廁所唔用）物種有什麼期待
在马来西亚叫 keling
:P 在新加坡好像叫ANEH?!
中文字幕错到离谱😅😂😢。。。印裔主持人预设立场，但绝不是黄部长的对手。
而且脸颊被轻轻拍了几下。。
主持人的水准完美的诠释了美国的衰败
完美的展示了印度阿三為了得到一個職位 會多歇斯底里小人行徑 數典忘祖
This man was an oncologist turned politician and have been our Defence Minister for the past decade and I hope he will continue on for another decade but alas he is already 66 years old. I'm glad the system was able to identify talent when they met him and put him where he is. Majulah Singapura!
This Singaporean Defence minister is v professional 👍 👍 among international top level
Thus far, our Ministerial team has been outstanding in the world stage. We should be proud....and continue to be vigilant..
典型的美國主持人，一開始便有預設立場，腦袋也不夠靈活，唔夠班。
三哥
典型咖哩阿三思維。
典型咖哩阿三
T V B好過佢
高種姓美國人！毫不意外！😅
他的确智商高。又幽默。
高智慧，髙智商，具有卓越远眼的國防部。
Very impressive of Mr. Ng. His depth of geopolitics is incredible. Well done!.. The subtitles sucks though..
Its sucks in not only Chinese but also English which is what I can't understand 😅
新加坡之所以能在大国中生存，离不开各个领导阶层都是非常有智慧和执行能力，而且务实地为民生利益为己任！
很好的回答技巧，風趣幽默回避陷阱
新加坡外長高智慧👍支持感謝高B哥智慧評論員💪👏👏👏
這個小記者在搞笑😂
He's the defence minister, but he answered the questions effortlessly.
😂 傻傻分不清，外长与国防部长。
傻傻分不清，他的头衔。😂
@@yooong He sounds like a seasoned diplomat. He never lost his temper or fell into the journalist's word traps. Instead he skillfully side-stepped all of the journalist's accusations regarding China and made his own points that China has merely been protecting its own interests and security, and has done nothing that other nations have not done or tried to do.
国防部长，不是外长
Big Bully mentality, Singapore will not be pressured to take sides, our government will always put singaporean interest first.
Few would and could understand that Singapore is benefiting from USA insecurity in the region, presenting to the world that it is actually a base for the Americans when it is not. 😊😊😊. Do people actually believe that Malaysia, Indonesia, together with Singapore will close down the Straits of Malacca for the Yankees to the detriment of other countries in Asean.
@josephtan4328 Precisely. Former PM Lee had in 2020 announced that Singapore is NOT an ally of the US and will neither conduct military operations on behalf of the US nor seek direct military support from them. Current PM Wong has also reiterated this recently when he was there. It beats me why some people still fail to comprehend this.
高B哥的真實資訊增加了不少水份與智慧。仲觀國際軍事局勢的趨勢與發展，那一個運用全球的軍事優勢和佔有28％強大經濟體壓逼其他國家。高B哥智慧如水般提供高素質極之有用的資訊。🙏🙏
人貴自知，國亦都是一樣，所以一個小國跟大國交往，就要運用智慧，在最大的空間之中，爭取自身最大的利益。
哪里有利就往哪里摆动，所以小Sing也叫墙头草😂😂😂
@@SG-APL.GouChuSheng 墻头草虽小但能屈能伸，无论逆境或顺境都能顽强卓壮的成长。您贵国虽土地大而阔，天然资源即丰又富，敢问在全世界的排名榜上，有几回是跑在墙头草前面的呢？🤣🤣🤣
国土虽小，但有自己的尊严和立场，并不会沦为其它大国的附庸，被大国当枪使。无论是面对美国或中国，新加坡都贯彻并表明双方是商业合作关系，是对等的，不是抱团更不是对方的小弟。
大国人民不应该再有这种老旧封建思想。合作关系不是拉帮结派。这是商圈不是江湖。新加坡只是合作关系，不是入你帮派，不需要两肋插刀，恨你所恨，看你脸色办事。这段话是对中国说的，也是对美国说的。
@@SG-APL.GouChuSheng 中国也是墙头草，一度是苏联的小弟，代打了韩战，后来是美国的小弟，996赚辛苦钱，忍辱负重练功。国和人都要知道自己的能力和位置，做适合的事，说适合的话。
@@SG-APL.GouChuSheng 這種邏輯很典型，非黑即白的思維方式。這種思維缺乏智慧，顯得短視，自以為能批評別人。但事實上，這反映了他自身缺乏智慧，與這部長這樣的精英相比。如果我買華為手機，難道就意味著我討厭蘋果嗎？如果我買華為手機，難道就意味著我討厭所有美國的東西嗎？這部長可以對中國或美國發表正面評論，為什麼他非得像大陸人的思維一樣選邊站呢？哦，那麼他就會被指責為兩面派，或騎牆派。
如果有兩棵大樹，我在其中一棵樹下乘涼，這有什麼關係呢？我認為中國社會的問題正是你這種極端的思維方式：非黑即白。
謝高 B 哥智慧之水
滷味要全世界都孤立中國，但世界各國逐漸睇出連滷味自己都擺脫唔到用中國貨，情況類似滷水要全歐唔好用俄能源但佢自己又爆買
So Call freedom of speech and not Translate in English some you to . Why not this one.
尤其是美國記者撞下
燦頭。咩隻咖哩雞，好極都有限🤣🤣🤣
你都知印印呀幾x😂😅中國嘅
Proud you have Mr Ng and his Team to lead our military and defense.
Such tremendous improvement.
在 11:05 的 英文字幕之中 ❨所以中文字幕也跟隨著有誤❩，正確的詞語應該是 “pax americana”，這是是一個術语，指的是在二戰之後，美國全面介入東亞事務，並在東亞地區實施的一種政治和軍事影響，形成了所謂的 『美國治下的和平』❨Pax Americana❩ 。
這和二戰日本所謂的「大東亞共榮圈」是必須在日本統治下「共榮」異曲同工，只不過日本做得更決絕。東亞的共榮還沒看到，剝削和屠殺先到位。
支持高B哥智慧如水分析報導👍👍👍
何仁更佳，老练更有阅历。
多謝高B哥時常分享優質資訊❤️👍👍👍
The Indian America tried to act smart n worldly, tried to put difficult questions to d minister but d minister just was able to answer him w short sharp or realistic replies. He is brilliant.
高B哥中肯持平正直正羲兼且博學人格高尚，誠實、客觀公正、實事求是、公義、有良知、勇敢理性、高水平，睿智、幽默、別具生面，特別喜歡重點字幕，超讚👏👏👏👏👏 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
高B哥 👍💯💪
新加坡外長 👍💯💪
裝睡者仍不肯醒的就像這位記者在此獻世着 😏🫢😗
新加坡外長是印度人。
這位是國防部長。
黄永宏医生是新加坡国防部长。外长是印度裔慰问医生。都是我尊敬的部长
@@suetyuewan1481还有一个硬度总统叫伤打慢😂😂😂
很多人都裝睡。。。美國在南海有殖民地？有領土？
支持高B哥 智慧如水 多謝多角度思考和分享詳細講解
支持高B哥頻道，增添智慧，增添水份，智慧如水，多角度思考，多角度分析。
A very typical die hard American Journalist immigrant from India
China has the right to protect herself! Period!!!
As long asTaiwan does not do anything rash, Asia will stay safe as long as it can. I think we already know which countries are taking sides. No countries can stay neutral.
Regardless of point of view, I have always been very impressed with the thoughtfulness and knowledge of Singaporean high-ranking officers.
Amazed by how a small country like Singapore nurtured so many wise statesmen like this Defence Minister.
新加坡人的理性谦虚与智慧，我们中国要想他们学
Thanks for sharing. A lot of wits there.... I particularly like the few works in the last part..."American leadership? not now but later" 😂LOL......
It seems China is always at the center of the world's attention. If the US has the capability and caliber to compete with China, then show it. Don't just be like the saying, 'Wisdom has been chasing you, but you've always been faster.' This world is large enough to accommodate both China and the US. It's time for Americans to get out of their own country and see the world. Such shallow-mindedness, similar to some Canadians, needs to change.
精彩的訪問，thanks for sharing 😊
He reflects the competency of his country's government
Well said
👏👏
新加坡雖小國際視野無人能及，從他們政務官的素質可見一斑，相對台灣的在朝官員遠遠不及
支持高B哥為正義，公平，公正評論時事🥛🥛🥛💧💧💧
Well said
一口咬定中國好戰,係好戰的話射左幾架南海尾國戰機落黎啦
這位所謂記者是印度人，在東南亞有一個講法，當你的生命被一種人和毒蛇威脅時，你要先打的是那種人而不是那條毒蛇！😂
Incredible to hear this from an Oncologist who's also a MinDef. (Dr.Ng)
多謝分享！
If Americans have the knowledge about the Monroe Doctrine, then they will know how hypocritical the US government is.
在 1:07 的 “...apologies for china...” 應當譯作「為中國作辯護」, 而不是「道歉」。
Where would US be 變成 USB.
@@Raksasaificationsounds correct 😂
早晨高b哥 多謝你努力為我們走就珍貴的資訊❤❤❤😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉
can't stop China from raising 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳💪💪💪
Rising…
No one is trying to stop China from rising, America wants to stop China from threatening the global order, as well as threatening America itself.
but the world should temper CN for their aggression in the SCC....not every inch of this water space belong to China
@@oasislin4587 你应该很讨厌历史！
Many thanks for sharing this video which is insightful
支持高B哥，感謝高B哥分享❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
支持，智慧如水，高B哥，詳盡分享資訊👍🏻👍🏻🥛🥛
If you look at things correctly, you will naturally gain wisdom。😁
Yes. It's not the other way around
支持高B哥分享分析評論正👍👍👍👏👏👏✌️✌️✌️🙏
高b哥你好！多謝你給我們影🙏🙏🙏，👍👍💪💪
支持你支持高b哥
支持高B哥 智慧如水🥛
理性分析分享🙌🏻
感謝你分享一般媒體以外嘅資訊💙
永遠支持高B哥智慧如水, 多角度思考的詳細講解同分析.
支持高B哥智慧如水：👍👍👍👍
Good one thanks ❤
早晨，大家好！
大家好！支持高B哥！增添水份！智慧如水！多角度思考！👍💪🏼🙏
你好！我想問一問高B哥做記者的首要操守是甚麼？是否要終於事實和中立去報道每一件事情的發生和來去。好像這位記者或主持人的問 題是否有問題？明明所發生的情是某國制 做出來。為甚這位造 訪者所發出的問題，明知是假的，都發出來制造語論去導其他人去制造矛盾？這是否從學校教導出來，他們一定要這樣做呢！？這樣我們怎樣'相信學校能教出一些好的學生呢？他們不旦學不到應有的道德觀念，不懂得尊重別人，只有大口連篇。所以現在報導的新聞都帶有正治目的。你以我們多角度去思考每一個新聞的真與假。
It is a very small and practical position that Singapore has chosen. Taiwan, if possible, should choose the same path Singapore has chosen.
great vedio
Singapore ministry are all so brilliant.
Is the interviewer a close relative of the Whitehouse spokesperson? Looks familiar.
美國立國兩百多年，只有二十多年沒有在戰爭…
可惜啲中文字幕錯漏百出。
I think it is machine translate.
@a2003cath You are correct. However, since the target audience of this channel are non-English speakers, specifically Cantonese speakers, the Chinese subtitles should be improved for better understanding. Just my two cents worth.
中英字caption都不好，好多不到位, a lot mistakes！
這部長基本上是任何問題都遊而不接，問者和答者完全是各自表述，沒有在同一問題內交接。
不過部長也表達了他的本心，就是間接指責美國在亞洲失去了道德合法性。當然使用了外交方式表達，哈哈。
的確是。但這裡很多留言（中文的）都突視這個然後大讚特讚的😂
如果是新加坡人還可以了解。但那些cosplay 新加坡人的共產黨國民實在不需要這樣。實事求是看事情說真話就好。
@@fugusanyang5308 可以看到，原來這世界真正擁有獨立思考的人，其實很少，絕大多數人都是人言亦言，你說我又說，人家說甚麼，完全沒經過分柝思考就全盤接收，很好騙。
高b哥早晨
訪員是印度人。
新加坡政府的立場是反對俄羅斯入侵烏克蘭的, 也對俄羅斯採取了金融方面的製裁。
中文翻譯字幕不理想, 出現了好些錯誤。
支持言論自由支持高b哥
👍👍👍👏👏👏
👍✌️✌️💪🙏
左右逢源，不放棄原則，大國夾縫求存，而且活得不錯，難得難得！如何吸引高科技來主宰經濟成長，才是關鍵。
谢谢高B哥，赞👍👍👍
I think he still trying to cover up for US 's wrong doing /action & policy & even show he is on US side by saying "inviting US's military presence to the Pacific. Didn't he know that's how all the Taiwan conflicts started!
What to cover up? You thought his so powerful ?😅
Rubbish
naive
Sorry to say, Singapore don't take sides.
Don't forget he is speaking to American in America.
这个就是真正印度人。
Thank you for sharing
America has to decide for itself whether to still be the global leader and allow competition within the system or to have a dual global system. It seems at this trajectory, it is inevitable that a separate system will slowly form.
恭賀江劍后成功奪金！❤❤❤❤💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
很喜歡直接貼標籤😂
看看現在台灣的官員水準，汗顏
持中者中肯而正面
There's a lot of ignorant comments here. I believe it has a lot to do with the really bad Chinese translations.
Both the questioner and the responder made very good points regarding peace for Asia.
The attack on the questioner is racist and unwarranted.
魷大國是對外雙標多標，小國則自我設限。能做的不一定能說，如中立。不然，小國就會被有野心的加料泡製，主動權受限外，也可能有各方損耗，諸事不宜。
Could there be an interview with the minister of defence of CCP / 董軍？？
新加坡人才還真不少，已經拋離香港很遠。反看香港現在已經差不多玩完了😅
新加坡的部長們被高估了。香港有更多的人才和政府領導人，但世界卻忽視了他們，並沒有邀請他們參加國際訪談。為什麼？比較新加坡和香港的規模，新加坡只是一個自獨立以來由單一政黨統治的威權城市國家。另一方面，香港應該被邀請參加這樣的論壇和訪談。
@@solaris5655 香港有什麼人材？ 現在香港得返一堆行行企企的人😂
物競天擇▪︎智者生存 !!
There are errors in both english and chinese Subtitles!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
作为防长说话太委婉。李光耀比较直接，不留情面。
时代不一样
嗯，胆识与分量的问题。😂
With the prosperity comes the better Chinese people's behavior. US and the west has hundreds of years of prosperity to shape their behavior.
We still like the ordinary American and European people, they are nice, honest, fair, kind and polite..
China, with more high tech engineers, will catchup and lead the world but will at the same time move more towards market capitalism.
If US is willing to work with China, the world will be a better place for all. World stage will be different, BRICs..BRI. will lift the third world's economy.
It will be a better world. CCP communism will not be the same.
The ball is in US's court.
China is always ready to talk and find a win-win solution but you cannot expect China to give up all.
Just like BRI. Its popularity is that I show you how to fish, and you need to help yourself.
一本正經講咗一堆廢話，不過，要耍足25分鐘太極又真係要有返咁上下技巧😂
新加坡又唔可以講得太白，點都要留兩分薄面給美國😂
對彭博已經講得算不客氣了，以往東盟國家連提都唔敢提
基本係答非所問自說自話。對外是這種pattern,對內就無比傲慢反問:what’s the point behind this question? 或者罵人 sia suay.
官僚們的兩面性格一覽無遺
@@fugusanyang5308so ?
新加坡海軍基地（英語：Singapore Naval Base），全名「新加坡-女王陛下海軍基地」（Her Majesty's Naval Base, Singapore）或「新加坡-國王陛下海軍基地」（His Majesty's Naval Base, Singapore），俗稱「勝寶旺海軍基地」或「三巴旺海軍基地」（Sembawang Naval Base），是位於新加坡北端之三巴旺地區的一個海軍基地，擴建之前為一個軍港，乃英國皇家海軍的陸上設施，也是兩次世界大戰中大英帝國的海軍國防政策（即新加坡戰略）在遠東的一個基石。