Rise and Fall of MQM | Sindhi-Urdu Conflict | Imtiaz Chandio
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ม.ค. 2024
- Rise and Fall of MQM | Sindhi-Urdu Conflict | Imtiaz Chandio
#imtiazchandiovlog #mqm #altafhussain #sindh #pakistan #history
For Business: imtiazchandio.official@gmail.com
آج بھی عام سندھی اور مہاجر بھاٸیوں کی طرح رہتے ہیں٠❤
خان ھی عوام کی امید ھے
خان ملک کو سیدھے رستے پر چلانا چاتے ھیں لیکن بدکاروں کو یہ بات پسند نہیں
Sindhi muahjir Bhai bahi Sindh se Nikalo pathan aur Punjabio ko
@@umairahmed1809
جعلی ڈومیساٸل اور جرائم میں ملوث جانوروں کو٠
Imtiaz Bhai har Urdu bolnay Wala MQM Wala nahi jese har Sindhi bolnay Wala PPP Wala nahi hota.
Secondly, no doubt Sindh has a great history but it was history not present. I have studied in interior Sindh and I have countless Sindhi speaking friends. They all r humble and extremely friendly ppl but sadly most of them (more than 90%) are lazy, unprofessional, good-for-nothing ppl.
I respect Sindhi ppl, I love them and I wish they could wake-up and rise to their lost greatness again.
Zabardast tajziyah 👏👏👏👏. Baghair mehnat k sub kuch hasil karna chahtay hain, bilkul bhi mehnat nahi kartsy, sehal pasand hain. Kisi bhi CHORAY CHAMAAR ko Sain Sain kar k POOJNA shuroo kar detay hain. Eh sub Masjiron kee BADDUAON ka natijah hai, eh QUOTA SYDTEM kee maar hai. Alkah kabhi GHASIB ko pasand nahi karta aur na hee izzat miltee hai. Aaj Sindhi ZALALAT KEE ALAMAT hain😱😱😱😱
Im proud of my sindh ❤ As a urdu speaking ❤
Bro why Indian Sindhi hindus are unique central asian type some have middle Eastern type face features and Pakistani sindhi muslims are completely different then them most Pakistani sindhi muslims have dark, darkest brown tan skin with asteroid features why is such difference????????????!????????!!!!!!!!!!!.........
No choice bro 🤣🤣🤣
Panjabi midia Black ko White aur White ko Black kis tara banya Jara ha
@@MuhammadAbbas-wx1rd ???? Kya matlub ap Kon hain kahan say hain kis province say???
یہ سرزمین اللہ ربالعزت کی طرف سے اردو لوگوں کٸلیے انعام ھے ھم سندھی بھاٸیوں اور سندہ سے محبت کرتے ھیں سندہ میں انصاف ھوگا تو سندھ اور سندھی مضبوط ھونگے مہاجرین ایک عالمی معاٸدے کے سبب سندہ میں آۓ جس میں سندہ کے سیاستدانوں آقابرین کے دستخط موجود ھیں سندہ نے سب سے پہلے پاکستان کے حق میں قرارداد پیش کی سندہ سے لاکھوں ھندو انڈیا چلے گٸے جنکی زرعی زمینوں اور کاروبار پر سندھی وڈیرے جو انگریز کے غلام تھے حاکم بن گیۓ ۔
😂 pir Jo pagaro ki histroy Pharo unho kitni kitni angrezon KY headquarters police stations or schools jalye thy pory India me unki army thi siwaye Sindh ky
@@hussainsiddiqui1 پیر پگارا کو صرف سندھی جانتے ھیں مگر ٹیپو سلطان کو پوری دنیا جانتی ھم مہاجر ٹیپو سلطان کے وارث ھیں جنہوں نے سب سے پہلے انگریزوں سے جنگ لڑی اور شہادتیں پاٸیں شیر کی ایک دن کی زندگی گیڈر کی سو سال کی زندگی سے بہتر ھے ۔
I Am Urdu Speaking I Love Sindhi Speaking
There’s no one nation. Iranian say he is IRANI, Chinese say from China & they proud, indian say he/she is indian proud but in Pakistan no one say as proud from Pakistani. Teach us become Sindhi not Pakistani.
Dear Mr.Chandio, it was a wonderful experience listening to you today. It was time that someone openly spoke about Sindhi and Mohajir problems. May God bless you.
Significant number of 1947 settled in Punjab as well but later they were mixed in local community. They not only learnet Punjabi but also done inter marriages. They are now enjoying lives here without any discrimination.
True, I'm urdu speaking from punjab.
They were all Punjabies so they had cultural resemblance. But in Urban Sindh there was discrimination and genocide from time to time
But now they are Punjabis
@@saleemsuliman3062 No! they are still urdu speaking and no one wants them to change their culture and values. They live together like brothers.
Quota system ruined our brotherhood....
سر ماشاءاللہ بہت عمدہ معلومات حاصل ھوئی آپ سے
Superb vlog, I am an urdu speaking who has lived with Sindhis... Excellent people, very friendly and very respectable..❤
This video; I see it as more of an effort to start a conversation at least.
Bhutto used the state force against all his political opponent. Benazir and Zardari were no different.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they had much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
True but laziest to mention the least
I am a Kashmiri and have sympathy with people of Sindhi . Like Sindhi ,Kashmiri loves his culture and language. We feel bad when Punjabi or U P people show disrespect for Kashmiri or Kashmir. People of Sindhi helped Muslims from other parts of India and so Urdu speaking should be grateful to Sindhies.
I’m urdu speaking but I believe that Sindh has a historic background Mohammad SAW also told hadith about Sindh.
Right
Same
Chandio Khush hua
@@imtiazchandiovlogیہ ساری حدیثیں جھوٹی اور من گھڑت ہیں بالکل تُمھاری جھوٹی من گھڑت تاریخ کی طرح 😑
Chandio sahab masla ye ha ky me bhi muhajir ho magr ap johar ain apko btao sari bdamshi ye Punjabi karty ha aur ap log kuch bolty hi nhi ..kam az kam sindhio ko muahjio ky sath aik hojae phir dekhty hain ha kon lasani fasad karwata ha@@imtiazchandiovlog
It's true, I am from Urdu speaking family, but belongs to Sindh, means sindhie
Real desaster was created initially, by Ayub Khan when riots started. Later Zia, who created pressure groups like MQM & Punjabi Pukhtoon Etihad to prolong his rule.
This video, I see it as more of an effort to start a conversation at least.
Bhutto used the state force against all his political opponent. Benazir and Zardari were no different.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they had much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
Chandio saheb you are fully mutassib.pakistan was made for muslim not for sindhi punjabi pathan baloch.we know what was your condition under hindus.all industry colleges business made by muhajirs.thswhy bhutto nationalized all.hum log really are full chootiya
Liyari was baloch area only one sindhi house was in karachi belonged to GM syed.chandio you are lyinng.in india hindu mohajirs were treated equally no tassub at all.tum baloch are captured sindh.you guys are kurd came to india and became baloch
ہمیں ایک دوسرے سے نفرت کرنے کی بجائے مل جل کر رہنے کا سوچنا چاہیے۔
امتیاز چانڈیو تمہارا یہ کلپ حقیقت پر مشتمل نہیں لگتا
تمہارا کلپ بہت تعصب سے بھرپور ھے
❤we are Urdu speaking and we love you
Yes, you talked very well. It is obvious that you know a lot about films. You and I also live in the city. We are Sindhis, but the fact is that Urdu speaking people will not get government jobs. This is about the quota system. This is also about this.
بهترين پروگرام
سلامت رہین ۔ حق پر ثابت قدم للہ تعلی کی حفاظت مین رہین۔
Very good historical analysis. All local languages should be promoted. Sindhi is the original culture.
to bridge the gap between sindhis n urdu speaking sindhis people like you should come forward from both communities to work fr shining and rising sindh
Rich history of Sindh👍well done💐🤔
I Love all the Pakistan's Languages and Cultures and I am proud of it Awesome VLOG Chandio Sir 😂😂❤❤❤❤❤
It is not Awesome. I see it as more of an effort to start a conversation at least.
Bhutto used the state force against all his political opponent. Benazir and Zardari were no different.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they had much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
Well, dear Imtiaz, I am a urdu speaking and have subscribed you.
See, there are many things that you are saying are true. Nevertheless, there are many more things that require debate and clarification to see things with different perspectives. That's why this divide occurred between Sindhis and urdu speaking people.
However, to cut it short, there are many issues but the most important and dirty part played was by Bhutto/PPP in the early 1970s with a policy of divide and rule.
I wish I could have seated in front of you and had a detailed discussion to better understand the dynamics of Sindh politics. 🤔😐
U catch my words
Yes too much to talk about imriaz bahi is good person but missing a lot of info but I don’t blame hime can’t talk everything in one TH-cam video
Agreed 👍🏼
Yes You Right
Ye kabhi b apni koom k Bure Leaders Bhutto ki Buri harkato pe baat nahi kare ga.
Iski video mein tamam batai jane wali buri baate Aur Zalim sirf Urdu speaking k leaders hi honge bas.
@@arifhussain8540apny abba Altaf ki khabar le us ny Kya gul khilay
Jinnah first offered Urdu speakers to have their own province in Pakistan, but the Urdu speakers rejected the idea, because to them province do not matter, Islamic country matter. Those urdu speakers who settled in Karachi back in 1947-1960 were the most educated people in Pakistan and in Sindh. It was Jinnah idea to settled them in Karachi, because Karachi became the capital of Pakistan per Jinnah wish, and Urdu speakers were the one who literally helped Pakistan economy, still to this day Karachi alone give 60% of Pakistan revenue, rest of the Sindh do not. Why majority young Sindhis are still not going to school, it is because of these landlords who send their own kids abroad, so they can continue to rule them for generations.
Well agreed 1000000%
Zindabad ❤
Sain very nicely explained the issue deligently with historically.👍❤
I am belong to Urdu speaking family and I have been living in USA for 35 years and over here hundreds of different ethnicities live here but no one hates no one, I wish Pakistan be same we live together and give and take respect each other.
I am Urdu speaking we love our sindhi culture but Urdu speaking also were well educated Sind and Punjabi supposed to take advantage of Urdu speaking people and learn good things from them instead of putting them down we all made big mistakes by hating each others 😢 let’s put future kids not grown up in hate
This video; I see it as more of an effort to start a conversation at least.
Bhutto used the state force against all his political opponent. Benazir and Zardari were no different.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they had much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
Agreed brother may we get rid of this hatred Inshallah as the hand behind these puppets have been exposed.
l' m urdu speaking but I love Sindh Culture also you are my favorite journalist love you ❤
باری تعالیٰ آپ کو حق سچ بات کرنے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے آمین
MQM was birthed through ISI political wing. I saw with my own eyes Army personnel carriers APCs guarding Altaf procession and jalsa in Defence Karachi before 1988 elections. He was then the Army ladla required to keep PPP jn check.
This video; I see it as more of an effort to start a conversation at least.
Bhutto used the state force against all his political opponent. Benazir and Zardari were no different.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they had much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
Excellent vlog Chandio sahib,I am an Urdu speaking and very much like you.
This video; I see it as more of an effort to start a conversation at least.
Bhutto used the state force against all his political opponent. Benazir and Zardari were no different.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they had much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
SHUKRAN…WELL APPRECIATED
Good histrorical velog about Sindh from 1947 to now..
Imtiaz Chandio sb apki reseach biht shandar he Sindh ne hamesha sab ko welcome kia he Allah Sindh ko achay Hukmaran ata farmay Ameen
Iqbal Ahmed Qureshi here from US jiye SINDH jiye PAKISTAN 🇵🇰
Ma urdu speaking ho ap na bilkul sahi bat ki ha sindhi methi zaban ha or sindh log bhi zaban ki tarah metha ha or dost ha Allah hum sub apnay hifzoaman ma rakhay ameen
Great history &
Imtiaz chandio.
I love u.
Urdu speaking also living in south Punjab they are living peacefully,
Great work
i like your view point and always anxious to listen and watch our videos.
me Urdu Speaking hun aur Sindhi Speaking buhut achi aur mohabbat karne wali qom hai ❤
Bilkul shai baat ha nuqsan howa urdu bolney waley or sindhi bhaio ko ALLAH hum sb apas ma mil kr rahen
One small question...please share with me the location where can I buy a Land for farming
Very nice
❤Wah سنڌي ۔ Wah❤
YOU ARE ABSLOTLY RIGHT
Thanks Bhia very good information telling us
I love may sindh ❤❤
Nice disc
Zabardast..
Mashallah
اسلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ ہو۔ امتیاز صاحب۔ آپ نے کچھ کہا بلکل ٹھیک فرمایا ہے۔ ہم سب پاکستانی ہیں اللہ تعالٰی آپس میں محبتوں کو کامیابی رہے۔ اللہ تعالٰی پاکستان کو کامیابی دے۔ میں پاکستان کا سینئر سیٹیزن ہوں۔ میں آپنے آپکو سندھ کا شہری سمجھتا ہوں۔ میرے خاندان میں سندھیوں شادیاں ہوئی ہے۔ سر جب ھم اس دنیا سے جائیں گے اللّٰہ یہ سوال نہیں کرینگے۔ اللہ تعالٰی نے دنیا بھیجا تھا ۔ اسلام کے کیا۔ 🤲🤲🤲
Nice Information 👍
Zabardast
17:15
Bhutto ney mahajiron ka mashi qatal kia, sindhion ko foqiat dilwai or purey sindh m cheating system ko aam kia. bhutto ney sarey fesley sindhion k lye against the merit jakay kiye or uska khamiaza aaj tak pakistan or sindhi qom khud bhugat rahi h.
Good job 👍
Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was a complex person and has a complex role in the political and cultural history of Pakistan. Pakistanis seem to be divided between those who love him for his political rhetoric and those who hate him for his political actions.
In his speech, and in his pledge to the people, Bhutto pledged to uphold civil rights and democratic liberties. In his true ways as a ruler, he did the opposite. His regime insulted, humiliated, harassed, assaulted, imprisoned and in some cases tortured critics and opponents. He vowed to respect the law, but his agents used lawlessness against his opponents. Even old comrades, who had become critics, were not spared. Miraj Muhammad Khan remained in jail, and Mukhtar Rana almost died of torture. Federal Security Force personnel infiltrated JA Rahim. They went to Rahim's house and beat him up so much that he had to be hospitalized
When Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was studying at Berkeley University, at the same time Martin Luther King was leading the human rights movement in America and he was emphasizing three points in his movement that humanity was facing in the world.
1- Racism
2- Economic exploitation
3- Militantism
If we examine the wars of 1965 and 1971 in Pakistan, the quota system in Sindh and the discrimination against the Qadianis, Bhutto's role can be clearly seen as the founder of apartheid, economic exploitation and militancy in Pakistan.
Let us look for a moment at Sindh’s quota system, which is in force as a state law in Sindh, to recapitulate its true impact on Pakistani society, where the state excludes deserving candidates from among its citizens from educational opportunities. The state is also telling its citizens that they will not even give jobs to qualified people, they will only give jobs to unqualified people, which is causing massive brain drain from the country. When the jobs of the country are given to incompetent people, they will also make the policies of the country, then see its real effect in Pakistan that Pakistan is ruined.
I heard the whole Vlog, it is really good. Just one Question; Altaf Hussain is a Criminal, what did Bhutto or Benazir do to amend this gap?. Pretty much nothing, although they has much more authority then Altaf Hussain.
@@omargarcia5863
- [ ] Almost all politicians in Pakistan are hand-picked by agencies and play specific roles. Altaf Hussain was one of them and he brought in to counter the MRD movement and do the dirty work of the agencies. Altaf Hussain did both the tasks with great effort and tied the dead bodies of the citizens of Karachi in sacks and gave them to the people of Karachi.
- [ ] We are deeply grateful to all those who blocked our paths of education and employment, we left Pakistan and internationalized our families. Now our children study at Columbia, MIT and Howard and have the best businesses and jobs in the world.
- [ ] May Allah grant Bhutto and his successors a place in Jannat al-Firdus, if they had not made life difficult for Urdu speakers, we would not have left Pakistan.
@@omargarcia5863Agreed none of them was a true hero that we needed.
Urdu speaking are denied job in civil government, if you visit DC offices in Karachi you won't find local folks in there. Go to Police stations you will find Sindhis and Punjabis. In educational institutions in Karachi they will suppress the merit of local students so others can take their
seats. How come they get 90 plus percentage in exams in interior but cannot pass entrance exam 😆.Everyone from interior has two domiciles Urban and Rural, so they can apply on both seats. I had once looked at job listing of Karachi Port trust, ironically the only domicile that was not eligible was from Karachi. They had the quota for people all over the Pakistan but the one that is not listed was Karachi. It is easy for people like Chandio to play victim card but reality on the ground is different. SIndh is robbed at the hands of Sindhis not Mohajirs. The one who claims to be the son of soil what have they done to interior Sindh. The roads of Larkana the hub of PPP is worse than the thousand years old civilization of Mohenjo-Daro. These remnant of Bhutto are to be blamed for this but they are the star and darling of Sindhi people.
@@confusious7433Again there are thousands of people who protested but the urdu-speaking media barely flinches an eye towards those incidents as they think people in interior Sindh are sub-humans. But as far as educational jobs is concerned go visit Khi Uni, u will find out who are the professors & VCs there. MQM if thats what ur guys represents u guys, u must have known by now how they always scream & cry over Kiranchi ka Haq kha gaye, but at the same time whenever the elections happen their perspectives always seem to change. They no longer talk abt Karachi, just shake hands with the establishment & continue on as if nothing happened. So it's completely foolishness of one to put the blame of everything on race, while not talking abt the flaws within themselves.
Good luck Chandio Sahab
❤
Well explained, Imtiaz Chandio
بھترين
Very well said. Benazir didn’t changed anything so you’re expecting from ALTAF
Masahallah great man
For me, Bhutto and Zia were the same... Just bcoz Bhutto was a Sindhi, we can't forget that he was a traitor.
واہ چانڈیو صاحب ❤😊👍 توسی گریٹ ہو جی ۔۔۔
سندھ دھرتی نے ھم مہاجروں کو اپنے دل میں جگہ دی۔ اور اس سے بے وفائی کا کوئی نہیں سکتا۔
very very excellant ideas. Allah help you.
Sir Pakistan me Rule Of Law kab ahega 😢 please answer my question? And Sir Salute your bravery and honesty we want journalists like you in Pakistan Love you from Shikarpur
Kabhi nae Pakistan say bhago movement join karein
Like this
امتیاز چانڈیو بھائی رادھن اسٹیشن اور سیتا۔اسٹیشن میں بھی اردو اسپیکنگ رھتے ھیں اور آج تک کوئی لڑائی نہیں آپس میں محبت سے رھتے ھیں
Nice vlog, i lived in Karachi from 1987-1998 during that time, experienced “Quota system” and one time police told me that count myself Mahajir not Pakistan - I am not Mqm fan or any other political party
Jia Sindh midia
شاباش
Right sir
Nice video brother, thanks 🙏
Mashaa Allah
Bohot acha explain kia.
Me Landhi me rehta ho, or me urdu speaking ho, i like peer sahab pagara
Very good
Great ❤❤❤
Bahi AP bilkul theek kehrahe Hain mahajir lafz se Sirf qatal o gharat zehan main ata he main bhi Urdu speaking Hun mager main apne apko mahajir nhi keti magr Kal or AJ main logon ko Sirf mazhab or zaban per larwaya jata he usmain hameesha kamzoor pissta he bare to Sahi rehty hain
Right
کسی کو سندھی ہونے پر فخر ہے, کسی کو اردو اسپیکنگ ہونے پر, کسی کو پٹھان ہونے پر کسی کو بلوچ اور کسی کو پنجابی ہونے پر, مسلمان کہاں ہیں کچھ نہیں پتہ
Well Said
Good
Very nice 🎉
Nawaz Sharif became a de facto PM. He was given the protocol of the King. His party claims that they already talked about his premiership and winning the election. The facilitation of Sharif and the government's efforts to block PTI from participating in the election process is a clear indication of this management. Stability cannot be created by a state that denies its citizens' basic rights. This disaster has the potential to increase extremism in society
Masla Niyat ka hai. Jail se bhage hue Qaidi ko Laya gaya aur "chothi waari'' ka bandobast kiya jaa raha hai. Teen Wari me jo tabaahi machi - kya phir mache ? ABSOLUTELY NOT.
Excilenr
Truth
Excellent...
Altaf bhai abhe bhe dilon maim basta ha sagheer hussain shah
zabar dast
zaberdast ❤
Assalamu Alaiqum, Love you Brother, Imtiaz Bhai, really Sindh Including Karachi Is International Orphanage House and Sindh Assembly is International Company Of Punjab
Regards from Gilgit Baltistan
Good work bro
Love chanduo
Thanks for weldon knowledgable video for Nation as per fact find after scrutiny
#ReleaseNisarAndMohsinPanhwar
Imtiaz bhai you are very right and this is fact.💞💕💕💯