Kudos to India for liberating East Pakistan and making it Bangladesh, otherwise our Napak Fauj still have been slaughtering & raping there. I hope for liberation of West Pakistan soon.
i agree - the meaning of that statement has been taken the opposite way by the author of this video or the author of this video is using it for dramatic title lol! fall of a city means surrendering to an occupying force from outside. but if a city is already included in a region before any battle and then it becomes independent, then it's basically becoming independent. so if we use the author's meaning - when the British left subcontinent, it would mean fall of Delhi lol! but it wasnt, it was independence of the subcontinent! actually, it was fall of Delhi in the beginning when the British eventually took over the subcontinent, not when they left in 1947!
I was looking for an English version of Pakistan's "fall of Dhaka" but found none. 70 years ago they forced us for Speaking Urdu, now I feel schadenfreude to realize they are the one who got locked in speaking only "Urdu". Poor Pakistanis can't even make a report in English. :v :v :v Pakistan Murdabad!
Tahir Sir and Hamid Sir , Third Opinion is one the of the GREAT program in the world of Journalism . You both are the benchmarking personality with high level of maturity and demonstrated seasoned journalism .I always thanks to GOD , We got two lotus from mud of Pakistan like both of you . Its really engaged deeply in your discussion and we are getting some new points of knowledge also from it
Same here! I learnt more from him about the history of the princely state of J&K than any one else- from him I went to Arifbhaisaab, then Sanjay Dixit, Tarek Fatahsir, and Puspendra Kulshrestra and Major Gaurav Arya et al
@BharatMata KiJay not disputing - I agree with you. Bashani Sir explained from 1800s to 1947 about J&K - The rest of the facts as you stated now we have to reverse course and get the rest of the original J&K back - with POJK with UT J&K and GB with Laddak
15, दिसंबर 1971 को को. न्याजी भी यही कहा था है, "आपने घबराना नहीं हैं, और इमरान खान भी यही कहता है। अब 1971, में क्या हुआ यह सब जानते हैं, अब इमरान के रहते क्या होगा ? क्या इतिहास दोहराया जाएगा? 😂😂🤔🤔
These two gentleman's video should be viral blatantly in Pakistan. It should reach out to every Pakistani who are still unaware of misdeeds in the past by then Govt and establishments.. Kaum ki sabhi elite politician aur jhooti establishment ke khilaf bagavat hi unko future me progress ki raah par lekar jaegi.
Bashani Saab you are becoming a Legend now. You speak so much sense. Love your thoughts, I carefully listen to you. You know Pakistani law in n out, history well, heard you yesterday too.
*SINCERE REQUEST TAG JI* Pls do an episode on the Birangona Women of Bangladesh. Its a story which needs to be told and for Western Pakistanis to introspect and repent. Please do this episode. Even you may not have heard this story. 🙏
Those are the sons of rajakar (Bengalis who fought for Pakistan) and biharis .If you come to bangladesh you will see there is hatred for India in bangladesh .but yeah we don't like bjp and RSS they are against Islam
Even the violence in Afghanistan since 1979 has also been the result of Pakistan's failed policies of denying fair and peaceful electoral processes in Blochistan,Kashmir,KPK including Sindh.Its pure Punjabi domination and the Martial race mindset.
Thanks to our visionary leaders of indian constituent assembly that they were able to accommodate the driversity of the land mass.....jis desh mei har 100 200km pehnawa aur bhasa badal jati hai us desh ko ek jut kr ke rkhna asan nai tha..... Grateful to Ambedkar ji and his team
No need to worry my friend .. empty belly has no religion. Pakistani coffers are empty and Pakistani army has lost a lot of respect among the masses. The army needs protection in their own country.
We always wanted to live as proud Pakistani since the partition in 1947. But you guys need to go back what you did to us!! 23 years of oppression! You never treated us as Pakistani. Your leaders and military dictators always treated us differently in all aspects. We had no option except independence led by Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman.
Tahir sab, your questions are wel regarded. Besides that till date no responsible Pakistani political leader Came forward. We hope " apki kasish & your devoted duty will bring the fruits in futer. Wish you all the best.
As a Kashmiri I agree with my fellow Kashmiri. If I agree with Pak allegations that India crossed international border, then what stopped Pakistani Government not to lodge protest/complaint with International forum. Truth is Punjabi Generals wanted to get of Eastern Pakistan (now BanglaDesh) to have better control of Western Pakistan to make it Garrison state and unfortunately they have succeeded. Yah ya Khan was busy in drinking and enjoying colorful evenings which includes Noorjahan. I am surprised how ignorant Pakistani or are pretending to be ignorant.
What is the literal meaning of "Sakoot" in "Sakoot-e-Dhaka". Looking up the web it seems "Sakoot" means "Silence". So how does the "Silence of Dhaka" mean the "Fall of Dhaka"? Also why call it the "Fall of Dhaka" and not the "Rise of Dhaka" or "Liberation of Dhaka"? I think there is very strong prejudice in the very nomenclature of the event! To my mind, it was the liberation of an enlightened Majority from the oppression of a bigoted Minority!
Koi sochta hai bangladesi India ka hit sochta hai. Ye uski galat fahmi hai.bangladesi social media hinduo ke khilaf jahar ugalta hai. Aur gajwa y hind ka sapna vi dechta hai.in byabkufo ko hinduo ne hi bachaya tha.
@@arafatmahfuj1096 yes brother is harami gula bujhe na khali india credit loy Bangladesh er muktijudhe ata bhai howar e asilo karon shobshomoy India girindi lagay rakhto East o West Pakistan er modhe r Pakistani punjabi bangali o go loge kharap babohar korto tai india ata shubidha nise . Oneke to bhai comment poira dekhlam lekhe j india kan dokhol korlo na 1971 e Bangladesh re . Ora bhuila gese j Pakistan musolman er desh j notun hoibo ata bengal theke shuru hoese 1906 dhaka te 😃
I salute these pakistani thinkers for calling spade a spade.They both have nicely analysed current scenario and 50 year old event of liberation of Bangladesh.But Pakistan will never learn lesson and will never be on right track.It is like dog's tail .Mr.AjKia and Tar ek Date are also thinkers who always slap pakistan .If Pakistan learn lesson from these people's advice, things may change many things in that country.But Army there is main hurdle.Army is in fool's paradise there.They say that pak army is very strong and brave.Then why they lost all battles against India.Pakistan can not become normal or sane nation. Unless it leaves idea of Muslim umma and cut it's army to its size.
The first step to any learning is to accept the mistakes to one's own self. Pakistani elites dominated by the Punjabis and the Military never accepted this. Surprisingly, they are only self-appeasing by putting all blame to India. Education and acceptance of Truth are two basics acknowledged in Islam (In case Pakistanis only rely on Islamic teaching). Forget about Bangladesh, if Pakistan wants to improve as a nation, unbiased history and secular education are two primary preconditions.
Pakistanis must stop whining , "Fall of Dhaka" and transform their perspective into reality as "the RISE of Dhaka' from being a colony of Punjabis/Pakistanis".Pakistan's Jinnah planted the seeds of Dhaka's Rise by declaring in 1948 in Dhaka, "Urdu, and Urdu only will be the language of Pakistan"
When you talk about Dhaka fall , and call general niazi a murderer , please also mention how the bengolies killed 50,000 Biharis Urdu specking people .. also mention how india trained mukti bhani . It was invasion of east pakistan not Dhaka fall
No matter how the Umma has ever carried itself out so far, yet the inherent racist ideology has been so conspicuous, given the burning example of creation of Bangladesh... There's no point in continuing any discussion unless an individual affords to live up to his true consciousness. Just to put everything in the most generic way, what goes around, comes around...😊
Gen. Niazi said " Hum unki nasal badal denge " Cowards only know atrocities on innocent young woman and teenage girls. Show bravery with mobs. Till date these Greedy Coward Hindus converted for easy gains yet don't get it. The majority at any given time does not Govern, only have a atrocity in mind. They had Ahmediyas, now Shias, then I don't have to say. Soon it will street to street.
Pakisthan ko Parwah kyon nahin hai apne Desh apne Awam ke liye mere hisab se Pak Fouj ko Bhanak lag gayi hai ki aj nahin to kal Pak tutne wala hai to Pak Fouj sochti hai jo karna hai hum karenge jyada kya sochna , jo hona hai ho jaye
![TEEDEE TADA - DIAMOND NARAKORN X LEGO LYKN [Special Dance Performance]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QgtZedFeumA/mqdefault.jpg)
Kudos to India for liberating East Pakistan and making it Bangladesh, otherwise our Napak Fauj still have been slaughtering & raping there. I hope for liberation of West Pakistan soon.
Insallah...!!
Insha Allah
yes , very soon they are also our peoples , we respect their struggle🙏
what a smart lady, very proud of you.
India army chahe to Pakistan ke 4 tukde kr degi agar government kahe to🚩🙏
Why it's "Fall of Dhaka"?? ,It's "Rise of Dhaka " and "Fall of Pakistan begins and continuing".
Exactly
i agree - the meaning of that statement has been taken the opposite way by the author of this video or the author of this video is using it for dramatic title lol! fall of a city means surrendering to an occupying force from outside. but if a city is already included in a region before any battle and then it becomes independent, then it's basically becoming independent. so if we use the author's meaning - when the British left subcontinent, it would mean fall of Delhi lol! but it wasnt, it was independence of the subcontinent! actually, it was fall of Delhi in the beginning when the British eventually took over the subcontinent, not when they left in 1947!
It's war term, not social , like " fall of Berlin"
I was looking for an English version of Pakistan's "fall of Dhaka" but found none. 70 years ago they forced us for Speaking Urdu, now I feel schadenfreude to realize they are the one who got locked in speaking only "Urdu". Poor Pakistanis can't even make a report in English. :v :v :v
Pakistan Murdabad!
@@brhn-me English is not the standard of intelligence and genius.
Love for Bangladesh.
I still have in my memory of the photos of Pakistan's General Niazi surrendering before Jasjit Singh Arora of India. Memorable moments.
Discussion become decent, intellectual and interesting when both Host & guest are well read, decent. Great discussion.
Mr Bashani, always at his best, truly bold, direct and to the point :)
Sir Today is Historic Topic 👍
Tahir Sir and Hamid Sir , Third Opinion is one the of the GREAT program in the world of Journalism . You both are the benchmarking personality with high level of maturity and demonstrated seasoned journalism .I always thanks to GOD , We got two lotus from mud of Pakistan like both of you . Its really engaged deeply in your discussion and we are getting some new points of knowledge also from it
Bashani sab lv u sir. My all time favorite analyst in AP over sub continent history.
Same here! I learnt more from him about the history of the princely state of J&K than any one else- from him I went to Arifbhaisaab, then Sanjay Dixit, Tarek Fatahsir, and Puspendra Kulshrestra and Major Gaurav Arya et al
@BharatMata KiJay not disputing - I agree with you. Bashani Sir explained from 1800s to 1947 about J&K - The rest of the facts as you stated now we have to reverse course and get the rest of the original J&K back - with POJK with UT J&K and GB with Laddak
Very informative video... Thanks From Bangladesh 🙂
Very good analysis and information Tahir sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏👍👍
Tahir Saab, you have chosen an intelligent subject and Bashani Saab’s analysis is out of this world.
Hum Na sudhrey they na hum sudhrengey,guess tag line of which country .
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Tahir Sahab & Bashani Sahab, you both are really genius personality, aapko salam & bahot bahot pyar Sir, from Mumbai, Maharashtra.
15, दिसंबर 1971 को को. न्याजी भी यही कहा था है, "आपने घबराना नहीं हैं, और इमरान खान भी यही कहता है। अब 1971, में क्या हुआ यह सब जानते हैं, अब इमरान के रहते क्या होगा ? क्या इतिहास दोहराया जाएगा? 😂😂🤔🤔
Waiting already ❤️
indian military never attack any country. even when pak and china attacked india play defencive. not aggressive
No longer.
India never attacked at first other country at first.
Excellent and intelligent discussion by Barrister Hamid Bashani ji and Tahir Gora ji. Just brilliant
Thanks to Mr. Bashani . Looks like he is an honest , intelligent person.
These two gentleman's video should be viral blatantly in Pakistan. It should reach out to every Pakistani who are still unaware of misdeeds in the past by then Govt and establishments..
Kaum ki sabhi elite politician aur jhooti establishment ke khilaf bagavat hi unko future me progress ki raah par lekar jaegi.
Bashani Saab you are becoming a Legend now. You speak so much sense. Love your thoughts, I carefully listen to you. You know Pakistani law in n out, history well, heard you yesterday too.
I salute Bashani for saying right things.
हमीद बाशानीसर और ताहिर गोरा सर आदाब नमस्कार
जय हिंद जय भारत
Very well said Mr. Bhashani.
These two men are great.
*SINCERE REQUEST TAG JI*
Pls do an episode on the Birangona Women of Bangladesh. Its a story which needs to be told and for Western Pakistanis to introspect and repent.
Please do this episode. Even you may not have heard this story. 🙏
Ap dono ko sun kar main bahut khush hua ji.really ap dono nek insan hain.
jab bangladeshi youth youtube pe comments karta hai, i love pakistan,. un bewkufon ko pata hi nahi ke pak ne bangladesh ke sath kya kia.🤣😂😅
Very true...
Yea
Bhai unke aur hamare youth mei zyada antar nahi hai. Hmare desh mei harami kam hai?
@@divyadharsrivastava3820 ab hindu youth jaag raha hai. youtube ,fb ne acha platform dia hai.
Those are the sons of rajakar (Bengalis who fought for Pakistan) and biharis .If you come to bangladesh you will see there is hatred for India in bangladesh .but yeah we don't like bjp and RSS they are against Islam
Hum Bashani sahab ko sunane keliye jagte rahe hai
Today's temperature of quetta is minus one And there is no gas. kudos to Pakistan govt. It is Criminal
Even the violence in Afghanistan since 1979 has also been the result of Pakistan's failed policies of denying fair and peaceful electoral processes in Blochistan,Kashmir,KPK including Sindh.Its pure Punjabi domination and the Martial race mindset.
Well said Bashani Sahab.
Hamid bashani always has great insight and Tahir gora as usual laser sharp on point
Mr. Bhashani speaks the real real truth.
100% true story
Thanks to our visionary leaders of indian constituent assembly that they were able to accommodate the driversity of the land mass.....jis desh mei har 100 200km pehnawa aur bhasa badal jati hai us desh ko ek jut kr ke rkhna asan nai tha..... Grateful to Ambedkar ji and his team
Hamid Bashani is amazing as usual
We love both of you bade bhai
Solute to both of you great thinkers
Not a word from Imran Khan about dragging Musharraf to Pakistan to serve sentence. Scared?
Both are such a good human being and honest or intelligent also
Great analysis....I wish all Pakistani were to take lesson from it.
No need to worry my friend .. empty belly has no religion. Pakistani coffers are empty and Pakistani army has lost a lot of respect among the masses. The army needs protection in their own country.
Thanks
Hamid B. Zindabaad
Surrender se ek din pahle " Pakistan zindabaad " Kr rha h.... Lol 😂😂😂🤣
Right tok from Bangladesh
We always wanted to live as proud Pakistani since the partition in 1947. But you guys need to go back what you did to us!! 23 years of oppression! You never treated us as Pakistani. Your leaders and military dictators always treated us differently in all aspects. We had no option except independence led by Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman.
I am glad atleast people are aware about what happened in 1971 and yes take care of Balochis .. wrong history should not be repeated..
Unbiased debate thanx for gora saheb for added in your debate
Two sensible people talking facts
You are great
Unbiased analysis.
Good message and good job
Tahir sab, your questions are wel regarded. Besides that till date no responsible Pakistani political leader
Came forward.
We hope " apki kasish & your devoted duty will bring the fruits in futer. Wish you all the best.
Nice this video i am never seen before
Thanks
Barrister Bashani is right that democracy was denied to bengalis
In 1971.
Nice sir
As a Kashmiri I agree with my fellow Kashmiri. If I agree with Pak allegations that India crossed international border, then what stopped Pakistani Government not to lodge protest/complaint with International forum. Truth is Punjabi Generals wanted to get of Eastern Pakistan (now BanglaDesh) to have better control of Western Pakistan to make it Garrison state and unfortunately they have succeeded. Yah ya Khan was busy in drinking and enjoying colorful evenings which includes Noorjahan. I am surprised how ignorant Pakistani or are pretending to be ignorant.
Pranam to both 'Great '! BD,
What is the literal meaning of "Sakoot" in "Sakoot-e-Dhaka". Looking up the web it seems "Sakoot" means "Silence". So how does the "Silence of Dhaka" mean the "Fall of Dhaka"?
Also why call it the "Fall of Dhaka" and not the "Rise of Dhaka" or "Liberation of Dhaka"? I think there is very strong prejudice in the very nomenclature of the event! To my mind, it was the liberation of an enlightened Majority from the oppression of a bigoted Minority!
Pakistani mass people miss Bangladesh not Pakistan Army. They even don't apologise for xenocide!
Whole world hates this army.
Sukut means silence and suqut means fall...
Alag alag Tarah s likha jata hai Aur meaning bhi dono Ki alag hain
@@tahseenhaider4844 thnx for info
FOR PAKISTAN ITS FALL OF DHAKA. AS WE SAY , "KAHI GIR GAYA"
Punjabi miltry desht ghrd mullah ke sulitkar
Dear, Gora ji , Please use simple URDU for young people as your program for all not just for URDU knowen people .
Greetings .
None of the Pakistanis are watching or reacting. May ne language problem. No English
Nice useful debate sir🚩🙏🙏
Salut to bhasani saab
Very objective
Bangladesh ki freedom ke liye khushi hai. Koshish kisi ko harana aur humiliate karna nahi tha.
Nice show
Koi sochta hai bangladesi India ka hit sochta hai. Ye uski galat fahmi hai.bangladesi social media hinduo ke khilaf jahar ugalta hai. Aur gajwa y hind ka sapna vi dechta hai.in byabkufo ko hinduo ne hi bachaya tha.
Sarein nahi hain waise. Maximum achhe hain. Kuch fringe hain parr haan wahaa ki govt ko is parr control karna hoga
@@pramodkc941 Gazwa e hind or India pakistan ka nam hoga Grater Islamic Republic of Akanda Bangladesh 😂😂
@@arafatmahfuj1096 yes brother is harami gula bujhe na khali india credit loy Bangladesh er muktijudhe ata bhai howar e asilo karon shobshomoy India girindi lagay rakhto East o West Pakistan er modhe r Pakistani punjabi bangali o go loge kharap babohar korto tai india ata shubidha nise . Oneke to bhai comment poira dekhlam lekhe j india kan dokhol korlo na 1971 e Bangladesh re . Ora bhuila gese j Pakistan musolman er desh j notun hoibo ata bengal theke shuru hoese 1906 dhaka te 😃
Rise of Dhaka not fall of Dhaka😀
PAKISTAN SAYS SO COZ THEY LOST DHAKA
Om Shantih
Dear Tahir gora Ji today you are looking tired is there is any health problem take care of your health
Aaj agar aap log Baluchistan ko alag country bna de to
Baluchistan bhi 50 sal me aap se aage nikal jayega 😂
Khalistan and Kashmir be india say aage nikla gha
Ap lajwavb hu
Síir❤❤🎉🎉
Wel come Bashani Sahab
Pakistan committed the genocide of 30 Lakh Bengalis in 1971, which is largest genocide in the Indian subcontinent in the last 200 years.
Tahir sir
Good evening Basani & Gora sir.
@BharatMata KiJay what do you mean to say? You are just repeating the same statement everywhere which makes no sense at all.
Sir apke video ka title "Fall of Dhaka" galat hai. Instead apko likhna chahiye "Rise of Dhaka, Fall of Pakistan".
A bad workman always quarrels with the tools.
Hamid Bashani
Namaste Sir ji
Please don’t say fall of Dhaka but fall of east pakistan and defeat of pakistan. Present Pakistan is actually west pakistan ( Half part of pakistan)..
Hahahaha 🤣🤣 abinandan 🍵☕ the tea is fantastic hahaha hahaha 🤣😂😆😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😆😆😂😆
I salute these pakistani thinkers for calling spade a spade.They both have nicely analysed current scenario and 50 year old event of liberation of Bangladesh.But Pakistan will never learn lesson and will never be on right track.It is like dog's tail .Mr.AjKia and Tar ek Date are also thinkers who always slap pakistan .If Pakistan learn lesson from these people's advice, things may change many things in that country.But Army there is main hurdle.Army is in fool's paradise there.They say that pak army is very strong and brave.Then why they lost all battles against India.Pakistan can not become normal or sane nation. Unless it leaves idea of Muslim umma and cut it's army to its size.
❤️stan zindabad 😁😁😁😁😁
sabhi ko namastey
The first step to any learning is to accept the mistakes to one's own self. Pakistani elites dominated by the Punjabis and the Military never accepted this. Surprisingly, they are only self-appeasing by putting all blame to India. Education and acceptance of Truth are two basics acknowledged in Islam (In case Pakistanis only rely on Islamic teaching). Forget about Bangladesh, if Pakistan wants to improve as a nation, unbiased history and secular education are two primary preconditions.
Pakistanis must stop whining , "Fall of Dhaka" and transform their perspective into reality as "the RISE of Dhaka' from being a colony of Punjabis/Pakistanis".Pakistan's Jinnah planted the seeds of Dhaka's Rise by declaring in 1948 in Dhaka, "Urdu, and Urdu only will be the language of Pakistan"
🙏🙏🙏🙏
When you talk about Dhaka fall , and call general niazi a murderer , please also mention how the bengolies killed 50,000 Biharis Urdu specking people .. also mention how india trained mukti bhani .
It was invasion of east pakistan not Dhaka fall
No matter how the Umma has ever carried itself out so far, yet the inherent racist ideology has been so conspicuous, given the burning example of creation of Bangladesh...
There's no point in continuing any discussion unless an individual affords to live up to his true consciousness. Just to put everything in the most generic way, what goes around, comes around...😊
Gen. Niazi said " Hum unki nasal badal denge "
Cowards only know atrocities on innocent young woman and teenage girls. Show bravery with mobs.
Till date these Greedy Coward Hindus converted for easy gains yet don't get it. The majority at any given time does not Govern, only have a atrocity in mind. They had Ahmediyas, now Shias, then I don't have to say. Soon it will street to street.
Pakistan should observe as black day as they lost their own family and broken.
Listen to Niazi again.
Nice, intelligent debate.
🙏
Happy surrender de to Pakistan army from my heart ❤️❤️
Pashtun Afghanistan ka part hain or jitni jaldi isse Afghanistan ko lota de Pakistan ke liye achha honga
Pakisthan ko Parwah kyon nahin hai apne Desh apne Awam ke liye mere hisab se Pak Fouj ko Bhanak lag gayi hai ki aj nahin to kal Pak tutne wala hai to Pak Fouj sochti hai jo karna hai hum karenge jyada kya sochna , jo hona hai ho jaye
Basani sir namaskar
Abhi to tumko or zalil hona hain Pakistan
Pakistan came into existence because of the then East Pakistan