Muslim: Does Judaism Regard Muslims as B’nai Noah (Righteous Gentiles)? Rabbi Tovia Singer Responds
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 พ.ค. 2016
- In this provocative broadcast, Rabbi Tovia Singer answers a Muslim caller’s question: How does Judaism regard the followers of Islam? Are Muslims considered B’nai Noah (righteous gentiles)? In his intriguing response, Rabbi Singer explores the status of two world religions and sharply contrasts the Jewish view of Islam and Christianity.
outreachjudaism.org/ www.toviasinger.tv/
As a Muslim... I pray for you to have happy, healthy, and blessed life.
I grew up as a Muslim and happen to know quite a lot about it, having lived it and having studied Islamic religion, history, literature etc in some depth, even learning Arabic (and Persian and Turkish) just for that purpose. I've watched a number of videos now of Rabbi Singer answering questions on Islam. And I have to say, I'm very impressed! It's quite unusual to come across a person of non-Muslim background able to talk about Islamic belief and practice without making any mistakes. He doesn't slip up in even the nuances! Bravo, Rabbi!
The Christians will say the opposite. Poor them😂
@@mm-qu3ht hahahahaha that was funny
I like Tovia too, he is interesting.
Yeah and his understanding of Quran Arabic is on point. He has extensive knowledge. I like his honesty. He doesn't try to please everyone, he just states the Jewish viewpoint.
U dont have to learn persian and turkish to understand Islam and the Qur'an or Hadith, it doesnt required and no needed, just learn arabic
@@endingwithoutbeginning1683 exactly, Turkish and Persian are not the langauges of the Quran. To study Quran you need to learn Fosha/Quranic Arabic
as a muslim i respect u rabbai for telling the truth may allah bless u
tanvir rahman why the fuck are you thanking that Rabbi for you fool , when the Noahide Laws come in if you even mention Allah in Public you will have your head chopped off !!!
It will be Forbidden for you to Worship Allah as will it be to worship Jesus Christ.
You will only be allowed to Worship the Beast , the Anti-Christ.
Also it only needs one Witness to charge a Person of any of the Seven Laws and you have no Trial , just a Kangeroo Court.
Also are you fully aware none of these Laws apply to Jews , they are encouraged to commit Crime , these Fuckers are like the E.U , they tell us what to do and how to live our lives and Tax us to Death but none of them have to abide by them Rules and they PAY NO TAXES !!!
Don't do what i do , do what i say
Welcome to the Satanic New World Order
@@paulfensome1404 Are you on drugs?
@@paulfensome1404 the fuck u even talking about?
@@paulfensome1404 Calm down please
@@paulfensome1404 umm.....as mentioned here by some Muslims, Allah is Arabic for G-d. We all believe One G-d, the G-d of Abraham. Only difference is that Christians have also declared Jesus as Devine, which in turn makes it Paganism. Both Islam and Judaism worship only One G-d - the,G-d of Abraham. Our differences with Islam pertain to their claims that Jesus is both a messiah and a prophet, for which Jews don't believe in either.
Thank you for sharing I have many Muslim friends who I pray next to. My Zadi alwayd would tell me Just because we disagree with a person this does not mean we cant learn from each other.
Said it totally right :)
We can agree to disagree but that doesn't mean we can't respect each other as we have lots in common 😊
***** Good question was asked Bro :) I think I might need your help putting up my questions to the Rabbi and real challenging ones!
***** I'll be grateful :) Looking forward to the Sundays and my question being put forward to him!
Did you have a question for Sunday??
yeah I do and thanks for the opportunity Rabbi.
My question is regarding the prophecies of Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him in the Hebrew bible as often referred by Muslims and how do you see them for example Songs of Solomon 5:10-15, Isaiah 42, deu 18:18 and deu 34:10 in reference to 18:18.
Rabbi Tovia Singer, Salam Alaikum! I just wanted to take this opportunity to actually admire your vast knowledge of Judaism, Islam, and various other religions of the world. What boggles my mind at times is your absolute dead honesty especially when it comes to Islam, because as as a Muslim who has traveled almost all his life, I can actually testify as to how misunderstood our religion is and how it is so difficult for us to defend our faith in the light of these fanatic groups around the world, which has nothing to do with the true message of Islam itself. It has brought upon a great sense of relief and joy for me to be enlightened by such a knowledge being such as yourself, that as a Muslim I diligently watch and follow your lectures just as much as I would follow any of our prestigious Imams of the Muslim faith. May Allah bless you for the work you're doing, as true monotheism is the only way to the true salvation! Jazāk Allāhu Khayran!
Our TRUE Jewish cousins are always always will be very very welcome to come to our Mosque & worship the same one GOD together .
@Samuel Levy sure, why not?
@Samuel Levy bruh, what the fuck do you think Islam's all about lmao? I was a Jew, both me and my mother, and we both converted to Islam.
@Samuel Levy Nothing about it is upsetting at all, and it's many steps up. Islam showed me what I already knew was horribly wrong with Judaism, I'm still a jew at heart, my grandma was a holocaust survivor. But Islam is my religion and I'm proud of that. and my mum saw that too and converted with me, so did most of my family. I told you, you haven't got the slightest clue what Islam is all about. Study it, Samuel, study it like I did and you'll see.
Bahahahahaah
@Rashed Ahmed,
Are Jews welcomed in the Great Mosque of Mecca to worship the same GOD together?
Thank you Rabbi Singer for the honest explanation. I am a Muslim from Philippines.
Nash Pitts
salam sis. I am muslim from indonesia.
@@farfumeerah7219i am a Muslim from Ethiopia
Judaism is closer to islam than Christianity
proof???? Islam doesn't believe the same God in the Torah. Christianity says Jesus is the same God in the Torah.
Yiqing Wang I'm sorry but u are clearly Wrong as a Muslim I can confirm that we Muslims do believe in the God of the Torah how can you make such a claim without knowledge!?
Sweety 7866 there is only one god just coz people scriptures change it dies not mean their god has so as a muslim you should know there is only one god and that we have to respect the people of the book ie. jews and christians who are honest
Nadir Kuleli islam is the improved true version of judaism
@@yiqingwang1437
God of the Torah is not a man
it is so beautiful to watch an honest man talking .
may Allah bless you and enlighten you more and more .
Verily, Rabbi spoke absolute truth.
We respect Judaism and love and revere all Jewish Prophets. May peace and blessings be upon all of them :)
yeah I'm aware of it and btw our friend Philip Wall is here and I'm still asking for evidence and being disappointed again and again so why don't you join the party?
umm let me ask you this non religious just logical question I just want a logical minded answer if one who's cultual rendition has lost 6 million of it's own due to religious persecution and will go as far as to make it a law not to openly target Jews for conversion by Christian groups and will Crucify anyone who dares challenge the validity of Israel's status as a nation or the holocaust for that matter will be labeled an antisemite does that make it right to do just the same thing to Christians who had no part in these events in world history and who exercise their own free will does this make you better than us just because over 6000 years ago The Blessed Triune God decided to chose you over the whole world and that you can judge anyone who doesn't share your ideology? also isn't Abraham's name means "All The Nations Will Call You Blessed" Genesis 17:4-5. listen I despise what is going on over there I have Orthodox Sephardic Jewish Friends who Despise Israel today and The Zionist movement who are very Pius people however it is not a condemnation of the whole of Judaism but the majority that says they are Jews and are not aka Ashkenazi Jews who are converts from gentile lands and not real Jews of the twelve tribes which is against The Torah Deuteronomy Chapter 13 listen I'm not Jewish but I know enough by The Blessing of The Trinity "which is not pagan" that Jews don't mingle their blood with gentiles due to the way of Jewish birthright to be born Jewish by way of The Mother if my comments came off as anti-Semitic in anyway it is not meant as such I just am an anger American who's family gave up so much to protect our country and lost a few along the way and a Catholic who does not like to see Eastern Rite Catholics being Impaled and Crucified by Radicalized Moslems who have been trained and armed by Zionism I know it is not Judaism nor Islam t is The Wars Provoked by Zionists I am not against anyone's freedom of thought but by being hypocritical and doing the same things you don't want us doing to you just because Zionism wants the destruction Religion I hope as someone who has lost people of kinship due to Religious persecution I hope you can understand my anger Shabbat Shalom I Will Pray for You Amen
+bink bee thank you I've been arguing with this guy all last night I'll feel for Islam and Judaism I pray for what goes on in the Middle East that Palestine can get their land back. I'm sorry Israel but killing 700000 Muslims to justify 6 Million Jews killed by someone half way across the world and had no connection with the Muslim people is wrong I don't have a problem with The Religions I have a problem with people who use Religion for a power grab and I will as a Catholic acknowledge that My Faith has had it's flaws too but I have to say this Judaism has been Plagued by Zionism which is not Jewish Zionism is a materialistic movement that make us believe that The Judaic Faith is about a Tract of land give to them 4500 years ago and ignores God Islam has it's own problems that can be sorted out but so doesn't all the other Religions of the world The one thing That I will say is that Jews need to get this Hypocritical thought out of them I'm tired of them thinking their better than us
Servant of יְהֹוָה - 1 God - 1 Torah okay this is where I draw a line with my patience why is it that you like to throw the pagan comment at people when in 586 B.C. your people bowed down to Moloch and Baal during the time when you sinned against your so-called almighty law when your own books that document your own peoples suffering says you sinned am I right on this 70 years are declared for your people Daniel Chapter 9 which talks about how long you had to suffer in Babylon before you were allowed to leave yet many Jews caved and worshiped moloch and Baal which by the way is a sin is it not as a violation of The First Commandment and Catholics are not pagans we worship The only God of True Israel aka The Catholic Church yes we venerate saints and ask for intercession but no we clearly state they are not God not even Our Blessed Mother would consider herself as such also it was Jews who infiltrated Our Holy Church and perverted our doctrine and liturgy so yeah this is where I stop being sensitive and start being very blunt with you look at yourself before you cast judgements and condemnations on religions you don't know a thing about I took a few courses on So-Called rabbinical Judaism and Rabbi said I aced them with flying colors yet I am do not practice said beliefs I studied them to understand the hypocritical ideology that you follow and I never talked about Jews killing Christ but if you want to go down that road we can have a good discussion about who the Pharisees are and who pilate really is and I can give you a Really good Lesson in Treat your Neighbor as you would treat yourself I'm getting sick and tired of hearing your beliefs thrown upon us to bring America into every damn war you start and American children have to die because your warlike culture reignited a 3000 year old war I' done hearing you call Muslims and Christians pagans just because they don't share your luciferian snake-worshiping ideology so before you go and condemn someone look at your own cultures past written in your own Religious tracts Vivat Jesus and by the way try saying no one met Jesus Christ to the Twelve Apostles or Saul of Tarsus who became St. paul
name these historians give me names
This is what the Quran says about people like Rabbi Tovia
Al-A'raf 7:159
وَمِن قَوْمِ مُوسَىٰٓ أُمَّةٌ يَهْدُونَ بِٱلْحَقِّ وَبِهِۦ يَعْدِلُونَ
And among the people of Moses is a community which guides by truth and by it establishes justice.
i love da joose.
I get Goosebumps just reading that Verse of Chapter 7. So sweet to the tongue and beautiful thats its emotionl. NO God But Allaah.
Heh. Old Mr. Allah also says "Strongest among men in enmity to the believers wilt thou find the Jews and the Pagans; and nearest among them in love to the believers wilt thou find those who say: 'We are Christians'" (Q5:82). I reckon the good rabbi has his own way of explaining away this verse.
@@Verumnondominatus u have to know how Quran is understood. It's understood by cross reference with other verses. When God say strongest enemies to the believers are jews he does not mean all jews, but some part of the jews and not all jews. Read this for example
002.062
"Indeed, those who believe, and those who are Jews, and the Christians and the Sabians, any who believe in God and the Last Day, and work righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord; on them shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve."
ARE ALL THE PEOPLE OF THE BOOK BLASPHEMOUS AND OR EVIL? - NO!
003:113-114
"Not all of them are alike: Of the People of the Book are a portion that stand: They rehearse the verses of God all night long, and they prostrate themselves in adoration. They believe in God and the Last Day; they enjoin what is right, and forbid what is wrong; and they hasten in good deeds: They are in the ranks of the righteous"
Wait until he discusses ischak and esmael.. Everything will change here
Rabbi. May Allah bless you. Greeting from Yangon,Myanmar. Your explanation is great.
I was a former Christian who is now a Muslim, and certainty what Rabbi Singer has stated is correct. The modern day Christian Bible has been altered so much. Sometimes the Bible itself will tell you in the footnotes that a specific verse or passage is not authentic. Look at 1 John 5:7 for example. This verse will have a footnote at the bottom of the page to indicated that it is not an original verse and that it was added into the Latin vulgate. Another passage that is not authentic that the Bible itself admits in the footnotes, is the story of the adulterous woman, (Let he without sin cast the first stone) found in John 5:73-8:11. It will tell you that this passage was not found in any early manuscript.
An in-depth look at these verses and others done by scholars like Dr. Bart Erhman and Dr. Jerald Dirks concludes where and when these were added in.
Another silly claim that Christians make is that Jesus came to completely change all previous law. Of course, this is an English translation, but the Greek text shows even more than these verses supposedly said by Jesus, indicate that nothing from the law will change as long as the earth and heaven exist (which they still do, otherwise I wouldn’t be typing this right now), and that anyone who changes it (Paul) will not see heaven.
Mathew 5:17-20
“Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. 19Therefore anyone who sets aside one of the least of these commands and teaches others accordingly will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.”
Ma shaa'Allah w'elhamduli'Allah.
Jazaak'Allah khayran.
Fear None But ONE thank you brother. Your knowledge is a gift. 🤲🏽
@@stevepolanco9887 I think you need to re visit how the Quran was compiled. The mistakes made with the old and new Testament werent made with the Quran.
You are a liar..
Subhanallah many Christians are leaving their Pagan beliefs and accepting Islam
I bet only Christian Trinitarian polytheist pagans disliked this video :)
Gazi Rehman amén !
Is it not funny that everything that Jesus said would happen in our world is now happening. Including the Jew looking for a Messiah. Guess what the Bible says you're going to find what you're looking for but you're not going to like what you find..
@@awokentruth333 a baby of 1 day old is a sinner. what kind of stupidity is this. a God who need blood to forgive this is not a God.
a true God who is Merciful and Just doesn't need to kill to forgive. he can forgive without that if the believer in him ask for forgiveness. and this is what Jews and Muslims believe. this idea of original sin is the most stupid thing they i ever heard.
BTW we believe in Jesus that he's the Messaiah but he's not God. he was a Prophet and he will return back before the end of the world. end of story
@@awokentruth333
This applies to those who are doing things in the name of Jesus (asws) instead of in the name of the Father ie instead of in the name of Allah (swt).
@@ilhamh4359 What is asws and swt?
as a muslim I never have urge to preach to a Jew. Because our core belief is the same😄
Peace to you Rabbi. May Allah bless you. Muslims never hated Judaism at all.
"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say 'O Muslims, O Abdullah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.'"
Islam and Judaism are very close to each other. We are circumcised, we do eat not pork. Praise to God of Abraham, there is nothing like Him.
by far the greatest video Rabbi! much respect for your honesty! i didn't expect this but as a Muslim you are my favorite Rabbi :)
Servant of יְהֹוָה - 1 God - 1 Torah
Thank you dear brother , i fully understand that Zionism has nothing to do with Judaism even if the Zionists claim they are Jews they are not devoted Jews..i saw Jews protesting against Zionism in New York .
it is interesting that your prayer is similar to ours.. we have lots of things in common as two Monotheistic faiths.
Those Jews you mentioned are Neturei Karta whom are considered a heretical sect in the Torah world. If you define Zionism as a secular political movement then yes, most religious would not agree with this. However if you define Zionism as the belief that the Land of Israel was promied by G-d to teh Jewish people, that the Jewish people have the right to independance and self determination in the Land of Israel, that the Torah and the 613 mitzvot can ONLY be properly fullfilled by living in the Land of Israel...then almost all religious Jews, including the Ultra-Orthodox would be considered Zionists or better still, "Lovers of Zion". Religiois Jews pray three time a day that G-d should bring the Jewish people back to Israel from eth four corners of the would and establish a Davidic kingdom once again.
One more important point. Rabbi Tovia Singer is a Zionist and nationalist.
You are absolutely wrong. Religious Jews pray three times a day for the return of the Jewish people to the Land of Israel, that the Torah can only be properly fulfilled by a Jew living in the Land of Israel under national Jewish sovereignty. This is a central point to a Torah religious Jew like me and Rabbi Tovia Singer. Rabbi Tovia Singer is in fact a Zionist and nationalist.
Reb Mordechai Tovia singer doesn't look Zionist Zionists hate Arab and Muslims, he says he have Muslim friends.
Zionists do not hate Muslims or Arabs. We do consider those Arabs and Chrstians for that matter who wish to exterminate us Jews and destroy the State of Israel our enemies. I live in Israel and work with Arabs. Arabs have full equal rights in Israel, whether Chrstian, Muslim or Druze Arabs. We have Arab high court judges who have sent Jewish politians to prison, we have Arab army officers and police, we have Arab polititians and Arab diplomats who represent Israel around the world. There are many Muslims although they are a tiny tiny minority of Muslims, who love the State of Israel.
You know Rabbi every time I listen to you my faith is renewed when I hear a person of Judaistic faith, confirm that we follow the quintessential principles of the faith that the Quran extensively discusses and the way we love and respect all the semitic prophets starting with Adam (PBUH). Bless you.
Salamualaikum Rabbi Tovia Singer , may ALLah bless you.
I'm new to this channel I'm Muslim and that is the best rabbi I ever meet I hope we Muslims and Jews be friends and allies I'm a Arab Iraqi Muslim and I love Jews our cousins we should not fight for politics we should be in unite so the god can be proud of us
Be cause he tell you what you want to hear🤣🤣🤣🤣
Bless u brother. Allah bless u in this life and the here after Ameen
Dear Rabbi, Shalom Aleichem.
I am a muslim and i want to say something; I love the Truth and i respect you for telling truth. May Hashem reward you.
Rabbi Tovia, you chose your words beautifully in answering the caller's question. Praise to the God of Abraham!
You are one of my favourite people to listen to I enjoy your perspective on religion and history. You are so different from most scholars please keep the conversations flowing I’m learning and absorbing valuable knowledge from you.
Thanks for clearing the air Rabbi.
I as a Muslim has enormous amount of respect for the rabbi.
thank you for your explanation Rabbi i am an indonesian muslim. Very happy to know that you are (or were) in our country. I love you and may God bless you always and keep you in good health.
Quran, Surah Taha (20:47) ... wassa laamu 'alaa manit taba'al hudaa (...and peace to all who follow guidance!)
Jews should read surat taha.
@@zillionexre2936surah ta-ha, al qasas, and al isro are about the exodus of bnei israil from egypt.
shalom/salam/peace dear rabbi...
As Moslem, i salute with this Rabbi 👏👏👏
Rabbi Tovi. I am Muslim and I like you. I ask Allah to give you guidance. You are very honest in your answer and I am not saying this because I am a Muslim but just because you speak the truth
This rabbi spoke the truth.
This is very lovely video. As a native in Southeast Asean, I'm very glad that our lineage cames from Keturah of Avraham.
Most of us are Muslim by many generations and we love our motherland so much just like Jewish loves for Holy Land. We are famous for bravery in wars and will die for the sake of home soil.
Shalom from Malaysia 🇲🇾
Keturah dari anak siapa yg menurun melayu? Saba atau Midian?
Allaha almighty bless Rabbi,
He's an honest rabbi , may Allah guide him to the true path ... amen !!
He is on the true path he believes in Allah
@@Ben-jq3ov He also know Muhammed is a Prophet of God. However he will not acknowledge him.
@@amma814 wrong
@@Ben-jq3ov How so? If you recognise a posterior tradition as being strict true monotheism as yours, then necessarily, you implicitly accept that the Prophet, head of said tradition, come from a truthful source. I've seen other Rabbis (from France and the US) affirm that "the Muslims worship the same God as us", and that "they are blessed", but they won't (at least explicitly) acknowledge Muhammed as a Prophet of God. Muhammed came about 1500 after Judaism, how does a Jew give Islam and its teachings any credibility if there was no "implicit knowledge" or "implicit acceptance" that it at least has truth in it?
@@ivanhoe7058 Jesus will not do such thing according to Islam. Don't impost your nonsensical Christian views to Islam
Rabbi tovia singer always make me proud of Muslim ❤🇮🇳👍
God bless you Rabbi Tovia
We muslims are Ishmaelites and we are basically Christian jews. I.e followers of christ but not disbelievers in Judaism, because Jesus peace be upon him was a jew, he never denied or abolished the law, and he never claimed divinity. Muhamed peace be upon him came to confirm and clarify that which came before him.
So, converting to islam is an easier way to follow the only ONE for non-jews? Are you a jew??
Thank you Rabbi Singer for sharing this knowledge. May the Lord continue to bless you and your work.
As a muslim am so happy to hear this from a Jewish Rabbi's mouth because Christians keep thinking jews and them are closer in faith while they are like east and west.
Only American Evangelicals believe that, No actual serious Christians like Orthodox etc think that antichrists are close to Christianity
Over and over may God bless you for telling the truth
Dear Rabbi Singer. I am impressed for what you have started with Dutch Jews in Indonesia. Would you be interested to help join the outreach in Malaysia?
Thank you very much Rabbi Singer for the very insightful video. Perhaps my favorite of yours yet.
Another great video from a great man Rabbi Tovia. You are absolutely building bridges. God bless.
Great lecture, Rabbi! I hope this can be the basis for lasting peace in the Holy Land.
Amen
This is clearly false. Why you claim that they are Bnai Noah when they outright reject the Torah and claim that the Religions (Judaism and Xtianity) that came before it are "Battel" or nullified? A true, righteous Bnai Noah has to accept the 7 laws BECAUSE they were given on Mt. Sinai. Muslims claim that the Torah was/is made up by the Jews and that we have re-written the original Torah and made things in our favor instead. Now only the koran is the true book of G-D (or soo they claim). They clearly are not good Bnai Noah, not to mention that MANY of them wish for our destruction and fight against G-D by fighting against Israel. They stop Jews from even praying on the Temple Mt. something you personally witnessed. Soo just because you live in Indonesia (why?) and because Xtianity is easy to pick on as opposed to Islam where they can chopp your head off, doesn't mean you can or should falsify that bad and wrong ideology.
@@TagMahirTzedek
Actually, we don't believe that the Torah was entirely made up by the Jews. We do believe in the original Torah revealed by Allah (swt) to Moses (asws) and in any other scriptures revealed to other Israelite prophets. What we reject are the fabrications introduced by the rabbis and scribes throughout the millennia. These can easily be verified when making a comparison between the text of the Torah and that of the Qur'an, and also within the Torah itself.
@@ilhamh4359 so, you have issue with what in Judaism is called The Oral Law. The Oral Law are laws written by Jewish sages who know how to interpret the laws presented in the Torah. These laws are presented in Jewish texts including Mishnah, Gemarrhah and Talmud. These texts are important because they give meaning to today's events. For example, in the Torah it says you shall do no work on Shabbat. The rabbis have to define "work" as applied to today. Today's work includes turning on electricity which of course did not exist during time Moses received the Ten Commandments on Mt Sinai. It's not uncommon to find religious Talmudic scholars become lawyers because both require the same kind of critical thinking
@@empathy800
I have no issue with the Oral Law, as long as it doesn't contradict the original revelation, and wasn't made up following the whims and personal desires of the rabbis who wrote it.
Much respect honored Rabbi!
Always great from Rabbi Tovia Singer 💫💫
In fact, this rabbi deserves award for being frank. Some people are burning inside, hahaaa
Allah is nit the Hashem if the Tanak, and Yes us idolatry going through a mosque, because us a different god, singer says not because he us scared if Muslims.....
Exactly!!!!!
@@shaggyvillage6960
Only Islam is the Truth-this song will everyone knows, from the Angel of death, when everyone seen the signs from God !!!
Mr.Singer to.
But then is for everyone to late,
to accept what they denied ( have knows deep in they’re hearts )
, they.
The Rabbis knows the last Prophet better then the names of they’re son’s.
Mr.Singer knows the Prophecy about him and that isn’t Joshua ibn Nun.
But he must this later to God tell !
Hope he lose his Humor and wordplay not. I like him and his art sometimes.
When he debates the trinitarian Follower, of Christianity.
Judaism have the real God !
But rejected to many Prophets ( with Gods laws and messages ) !
To think God make only for them different laws - this is Apartheid, this is unjust !!!
My God is a Just God !
and love and gave all Mankind - fairly chances.
But Judaism is not even 0,5 % of the Mankind-and 99,5 % aren’t protected, with the boundary to God !???
Are this a real and just God ?
( not really for me 😂)
This Noahide Laws, the Rabbis can they took in they’re Laboratorium back.
Is no needing for them.
( God have send his real Version - Islam. )
Christianity make from a real Prophet of God, a Semi God and haven’t the Law of the Prophets !
They are Pagans and Gentiles
Without the real God of Abraham !!!
Without the Laws of the Prophets !!
( thanks goes to Saul /Paul )
[ Jesus Christ was send to the Judaism with his Evangelium + him as a Prophet !!!
He was rejected 🙅🏻♂️ ]
Islam is with the real God and all real Prophets of God - to all Mankind.
For all Times !!!
We needed not each other like the Christians Judaism, to verification our religion ( Islam ).
We have Gods book 📖 without a doubt, and is 1:1 from him.
Only Islam/Quran is to hold for the Muslim.
God sends the Prophets-we accepted all of them !
They’re was Black, Yellow or White and between them. We accepted and make not a difference between them.
P.S.the Chosen was always and only, the Prophets not the ordinary people.
But when they followed they’re Prophets with the actual Laws of God, than they where chosen to.
But since Islam comes is only Islam accepted by God !
We lived no longer in the darkest ages.
But to be honest Judaism heard not much at Moses ....!
Think manny think have changed and manny thinks, are still the same.
We will seen when the film called life is over. Where was Mr.Right and where Mr.Wrong.
Ma sha Allah, Rabbi, replied honestly. May Allah guide us all.
indeed B"H
He's been exposed on his real views about Muslims go listen he's a snake
Someone finally asked my question. I found other reasons a Jew might call us b'nai Noah, but only an orthodox rabbi is really qualified to say.
+Gunther Khan Yeah, thanks brother! Jazak Allah
Joel no the Rabbi Lied through his teeth , he didn't even answer the Question.
The Rabbi should of said no I'm sorry you will not be Allowed to Worship Allah , if you do we will cut of your head.
You are only allowed to Worship the Beast , the Anti- Christ.
He is no Rabbi , he is an Ashkenazi Jew from Western Russia , can't you tell by his East European Accent lol
Really look into the Noahide Laws , you will shit Yourself my Friend.
Think of this you have Jesus , Allah , Budda and God knows how many more , but what they are telling us is we can no longer Worship those Gods , we can only Worship one God , Seriously.
But who is that God , that is the Question you need to ask , because all of a Sudden those Gods Don't Exist , how Crazy is that ???
Satanic One World Order
@@paulfensome1404 anti semitic + islamophobia
The Rabbi did not answer the question "Can a Muslim be a Ben Noah?". So here is the answer : to be a ben Noah one must take upon himor herself to practice at least 7 commandments (identified as the seven commandements of the children of Noah) and to do so because you recognize that every single letter of the Torah written by Moses is the divine truth. This undertaking has to be performed in the presence of a rabbinical court of 3 judges. Given that as a Muslim, you are to believe that the Jews falsified some verses regarding Isaac and Ismael, then it follows that one can NOT be a Muslim and a Ben Noah at the same time.
@@RaphaelKaufmann ... unless a muslim doesn't believe what you've assumed.
very interesting teaching on a question that I have often wondered about. thank you :)
Todah Rabah and shukran and god bless you and the Jews of the world from your Muslim brother here!🙌🏻😊❤️
It's true when the Rabbi says: when the Christians accused Muslims worshipping the moon God and stuff. That's just so funny. I can't even response to them because that's soooo misleading and stupid accusation..😅
Just respond by saying they worship a cross God 😂
Rom A no man we should not make fun of anyone.
Pivos Pivepic those were the pagan Ishmaelites Muhammad brought the ishmaelites back the worship of the God of Abraham
@Pivos Pivepic what does crescent have anything to do with islam? Islam doesn't have a symbol Quran clearly says do not worship the sun or moon
''Among His signs are the night and the day, and the sun and the moon. Do not prostrate yourselves to the sun, or to the moon. But prostrate yourselves to Allah who has created them, if it is Him whom you worship.'' (41:37)
So whats your point? the name ''Allah'' didnt come from mecca, christians and Jews in Arabia were using the name ''Allah'' before even Mecca had idols in it, the moon symbol has nothing to do with islam, do you see a moon on the Kabah?
La ilaha il Allah. There is no God but One God.
Thank you for being honest about our religion.
There is No god but God.
@@adambrownhussein6525 or to be more precise ''there is no god but Allah''
@@harixav If the word Allah was a name like Ali, Bob or John, then this version would be correct but it isn't. Allah is an Arabic/Semitic word that means God. So we just replace the word Allah with God and it becomes No god but God. Some people still use No God but God when the Shahada doesn't say La Allah ila Allah. The Shahada says La ilaha ila Allah. There is no god but Allah makes sense but mixing two languages is confusing to some people and there is no need if our goal is to properly explain Islam. Allah means God. Btw, Anti-Islamic plagiarist Reza Aslan and Random House(now Penguin Random House) plagiarized "their" book of the same title "No god but God" from a submitted manuscript.
@@adambrownhussein6525Well, Allah would be more accurately translated as “The God” as opposed to “ilah” which means “a god/deity”. “God” in English can mean anything that is worshipped, like “ilah” in Arabic, but Allah, meaning “THE God”, means only one thing which is “the only true God, the Creator”.
@@nosmokejazwinski6297 Yes, I explained this long time back. But you can't say "The God Created Heaven and Earth". You say God Created Heaven and Earth". In English, the article "The" is dropped. "God in English can mean anything". No, God means Allah. It's god that can mean anything worshipped other than God(Allah). Hence No god but God or La ilaha ila Allah.
I love it when you tell the truth....thank you and much respect...peace from a Muslim
rabbi you should get in contact with dr shabir ally and try to bring muslims and jews closer together and clear the misconceptions.. would love to see you both on stage at the same time would so good for both faiths.. Salam my brother
MR Zaman !
This Rabbi is Better Then Shabir Ally.
Shabir Ally is NOT FOLLOWING Quran.He is Following other Books & Imams.
ONLY----Quran.
Quran 45-18 >>Then I put you, on an ordained way concerning the matter.
So follow it.
And do not follow the inclinations of those who do not know.
Quran 6-155 >.And this is a Book I have revealed blessed, so follow it and fear Allah that you may receive mercy.
Quran 18-01 >>Praise is to Allah , who has sent down upon His Servant the Book and has not made therein any deviance.
Quran 41-06 >>Say "I am only a man like you to whom it has been revealed that your god is but one God; so take a straight course to Him and seek His forgiveness." And woe to those who associate others with Allah
Quran 07-03 >>Follow, what has been revealed to you from your Lord and do not follow other than Him any allies. Little do you remember.
+Khan Afghan get your salafi self out of here.. shabir ally has done so much for islam defending it against the slander of the Christians.. how anyone can say a bad word about him I would never know
Mr Zaman !
I AM Just Saying That !
Shabir Ally is not Following The Book of one God.
Quran .
I Am NOT A SALFI OR SOMETHING OTHER !
I Am on The Way of My Grandfather PR Abraham.
Quran 4-125 >>And who is better in religion than one who submits himself to Allah while being a doer of good and follows the religion of Abraham, inclining toward truth ?
And Allah took Abraham as an intimate friend.
+Khan Afghan only a salafi would say something negative about another muslim and you sound very salafi to me.. in future don't post your negativity
Mr Zaman !
I Know You DONT Have Any ANSWER . EVEN Shabir Ally Too.
Because i Am Standing on Truth.
Gooooodbye !
I really like this guy
Love you rabbi . May allah (one god) bless you from asean, borneo muslim .
Love all nabi (prophet) .
ADAM / ADAM
2 . IDRIS / ENOCH
3 . NUH / NOAH
4 . HUUD / HEBER
5 . SHALEH / SHELAH
6 . IBRAHIM / ABRAHAM
7 . LUTH / LOT
8 . ISMAIL / ISHMAEL
9 . ISHAQ / ISAAC
10. YAKUB / JACOB
11. YUSUF / JOSEPH
12. AYUB in / JOB
13. ZULKIFLI / EZEKIEL
14. SU'AIB / JETHRO
15. YUNUS / JONAH
16. MUSA / MOSES
17. HARUN / AARON
18. ILYAS / ELIJAH
19. ILYASIN / ELISHA
20. DAUD / DAVID
21. SULAIMAN / SOLOMON
22. ZAKARIA / ZECHARIAH
23. YAHYA / JOHN
24. ISA / YESUS
25.MUHAMMAD
Peace
Love u
this explaination makes my faith in Islam even stronger
Excellent show al humdulillaah
Thank you Rabbi, I'm muslim and I respect you
Islam is universal judaism
The fact that they claim Joshka is born of a virgen birth invalidates their claim of him being messiah, because then how is his paternal lineage linked to David ha Melech?
Lots of respects to a very learned person..sholom rabbi!
Stay blessed, Rabbi Tovia Singer, may Allah bless you in abundance ❤️
As a Muslim much respect from me💞🙏
Excellent!
Beautiful response
Masha Allah. I really respect this man for his sincerity and righteousness. Ya Rabbi, may The Creator make us both winners in the hereafter.
A muslim needs approval only from Allah swt.
Interesting. I didn't expect that answer. I love that. ❤
Thank you sir☺
Thank you sir! Very intellectual and respectful answer. In islam we actually believe that traditional jews who follow the original testaments will go to heaven inshallah. This shows the amount of bonds and similarities between both religions
Ishmael brother of Isaac
Deuteronomy 18:18 A New Prophet
…17"The LORD said to me, 'They have spoken well. 18I will raise up a prophet from among their countrymen like you, and I will putMy words in his mouth, and he shall speak to them all that I command him. 19It shall come about that whoever will not listen to My words which he shall speak in My name, I Myself will require it of him.…
This chapter is about the Levites though. Ishmael is not mentioned here.
this is about Joshua. (Deuteronomy 34:9, Joshua 1:7/17-18)
i love this great rabbi I love you so much sir you are a true follower of one God may God bless you
Thank you, Rabi
When I see Muslims reacting, it is always with respect and love. When I see a Christian reacting, it is 90% hate and emotional.
Why is that? 🤔
This is in the Quran. Fact not emotion
Surah 3 85. Whoever seeks other than Islam as a religion, it will not be accepted from him, and in the Hereafter he will be among the losers.
@Jamal Ramadan If you're a Jew ir Christian, from a Muslim perspective they are losers. Does that show love and respect? That's my point
@Jamal Ramadan He's like a jealous kid when his friend get closer to the other kid, isnt he?
Remove Israel's allies and watch Muslim take over Israel. They would exterminate Israel if they had a chance.
Al-A'raf 7:159
وَمِن قَوْمِ مُوسَىٰٓ أُمَّةٌ يَهْدُونَ بِٱلْحَقِّ وَبِهِۦ يَعْدِلُونَ
And among the people of Moses is a community which guides by truth and by it establishes justice.
I have recently come across Rabbi Singer's videos. They are indeed eye-openers! I never knew that such antipathy to Christianity existed in some Jewish circles...almost to the point of hatred it seems. I shall continue to view his videos with great interest to better understand his point of view.
BTW: I would be most interested in hearing what Rabbi Singer has to say about surah 5, ayat 82.
When interfaith discussions are honest, frank and respectful, we all benefit no matter our convictions thereafter. The direct respectful approach of this Rabbi is not appreciated enough. Shalom from a devout muslim.
Allahu Akbar! Allahu Ahad! God isThe Greatest God is Echad!
Surah 3 85. Whoever seeks other than Islam as a religion, it will not be accepted from him, and in the Hereafter he will be among the losers.
Amen.
האם אתה מבין מה זה להיות בן נוח?
Not sure if you've spoken on it already but, I'd be very interested to hear your opinion/take on Samaritanism. You have such a wonderful knowledge of religion, it would be great to hear your thoughts. God bless.
May God bless you brother
How can we contact with this Rabbi ? What's the number and which Time is this program taken place?
tornado 1 Usually Sunday 10AM Eastern Standard Time/9AM Central Time in the USA.
Love love love the song in the end even though I don’t understand it a bit. Would someone suggest me some more Jewish music? Specially if it’s from the Torah. Thanks from a Muslim
A song about King David, in biblical Hebrew.
@@danielcohen5109 Thanks ..I too wanted answer to this.
Salute, Rabbi Singer.
Rabbi Singer: You certainly have an in-depth knowledge of Islam and Islamic beliefs.
What you said about Muslim beliefs in the above vlog is absolutely correct. Your knowledge and understanding and cordiality towards Islam and Muslims has won a high place of respect, admiration, and love for you in our hearts.
As a Muslim who has studied the First Five Books of Moses, I find Judaism and Islam so close in the fundamentals of their faiths that I have no doubt that the two religions have a common source, i.e., the God Almighty. Furthermore , we Muslims have ALL the Jewish prophets in common with the Jews , from Abraham, Issac, Jacob, all the way to Moses ( may God's peace and blessings be upon them all). As a matter of fact the Quran is full of events from the life of Moses and the Children of Israel from the days of their Egyptian captivity to their freedom and Exodus .
I find both Judaism and Islam have more in common in the fundamental of their faiths than what differs them in details. I hope one day the force and love of our respective religious beliefs will bring us closer and unite us as one people. God willing. InshaAllah.
With best wishes and Salaam. Shalom.
great video.this Rabbi is correct in the points he makes.Juddism and Islam are more connected then any other faith. but our peoples are so dis United And some even hate each other just for being that religion.
Judaism and Islam are deeply and fundamentally connected in our core beliefs. However, the tragic and seemingly ubiquitous tensions in our generation has nothing to do with religion (din)
at all. Rather, it is the epic, noxious politics that sparked so much pain to our family. As I mentioned in a different video, Judaism and Islam are probably the least eclectic religions in the world. Despite this, and a tragic dark cloud of politics that seems to poison everything, there remains a steadfast, striking mutual respect between our faiths. Will we witness the final redemption quickly in our lifetime? I pray that this is the will of God.
God bless you Rebbe! Both Jews and Muslims fully submit to the Onness of G-D .... we NEVER associate partners with Allah/Hashem.
Awesome!
This guy, rabbi Tovia rocks!
This rabbi is gonna be welcomed in the Muslim world. Love you, rabbi tovia singer. May Allah/G-d/HaShem bless you eternally.
Christianity is closer to Hinduism
Basically folklore...
The Quran talks about righteous jews!!
Verily indeed Rabbi tovia is one of them
Thank you
Jews, Christians, Muslims and by extension all humanity should show respect to one another and not use offensive language. Our God is One(as in One in One) and His Message to us through the many prophets and messengers is One. Worship ONLY Me and shun the worship of idols, man, animals, terrestrial bodies etc. Although the Message is one, it has overtime been understood by some as different for each group. Divisions such as "Jews and Gentiles", "Noahides" etc were created. I'm not aware of Muslims classified as ",Noahides". God(Allah) appointed Noah(pbuh) as a messenger to his people. Those who believed were Muslims or Submittees ONLY to God(Allah) and those who rejected or doubted were disbelievers. This is repeated for all prophets and messengers from Abraham(pbuh), Ishmael(pbuh), Isaac(pbuh), Jacob(pbuh), Joseph(pbuh), Moses(pbuh), Jesus(pbuh) to the last and final messenger Mohamed(pbuh). This was the trend- believers and rejectors/doubters. The FIRST Muslims or Submittees ONLY to God(Allah) were Adam(pbuh) and Eve(Hawa-Gbph). The first rebel against God(Allah) was Lucifer. Believers follow the Path of Adam(pbuh) and Eve(Hawa-Gbph) and rejectors/doubters follow the path of Lucifer, Nimrod, Pharaoh, Atheists, Agnostics, Polytheists, Pantheists, Animists and Pagans.
Respect is meant to met by respect. I respect what the jewish rabbi said, Judaism is also a monotheistic Abrahimic religion and a good jew may be forgiven or rewarded as told Quranic verse provided he do not worship any other God nor set partners beside the Almighty. Allahu ala aalamu, God knows best.
Salam-Shalom
Thats very interesting! Makes it easier for me to find the right religion for me!
If islamic rituals or prayers would include more about the Chosen Nation it would make me feel better.
But your statement was very important for me. Thank you!
Islam doesn’t accept a notion that one nation can be chosen over the others. We don’t believe in any kind of supremacy based on blood and ancestry. In Islam, you can only become better than other through faith and piety, not through bloodline. Judaism is too ethnocentric, Islam is Universal and for everyone.
Love and respect for The Rabbi and good Jewish people from Pakistan.