@Raxxanterax, another way to speed up finding the Black Mushroom is to know that the room with the mushroom does not spawn, when the exit to Cathedral Level 2 has a spiral staircase. So if you find the exit to Cathedral Level 2 and it has the spiral staircase you can immediately leave, and you don't need to search any further on that level. Your first two tries show very well, what I mean. In both cases there was that exit tile, I mean. On your third try there was that »normal« straight exit tile.
+1 to Jared For me, the sign is 'closed square map layout' The room must have two enters and can only be located in the "closed square" map layout. I couldn't find a layout with more than 1 closed square, and it's only it's south corner (bottom). So whatever you start at, you go "down".
I have to thank you for your help. I'm 74 and have played this game since it came out. I play solo because I don't know if I'm fast enough to play with others. I always watch your videos so thanks for that.
Things that triggered while searching for the Gibbering Gemstone, in the Cavern of Frost: - goblin field - goblin pylon - whymsydale - cow level - vault Things that didn't trigger: Gibbering Gemstone dropped. The search continues...
@@Matzi2001 What a dumb luck. Wasted like ~5 hours straight farming it on T13 and no luck then changed it to Normal after reading your comment and 1st try got a drop.
If you are on console you only need to get the Plan, Black Mushroom, Wirt's Bell, and the Gibbering Gemstone. You don't need to get either Leoric's Shinbone or the Liquid Rainbow. Not sure why that is, but it does make crafting the Staff of Herding a bit easier on console
thanks so much for saying so. i farmed mysterious chests for rainbow for over an hour and after finding several mysterious chests with zero rainbows i was starting to question my sanity.
also on console, when the host leaves a game, the remaining players are dropped into a new game, so the multi-game farming trick Rax describes for the Gemstone won't work.
Found Cosmic Wings in a Rainbow goblin while trying to get Gibbering Gemstone. This guides a great refresher for the Staff of Herding, its been so long since the first time crafting one.
I feel like you're talking to me as if I'm a 1st grader at times and I mean that in the best kind of way. I am like, clinically stupid. Your explicit clarity is excellent and helpful my friend. Thank you for the wonderful guide.
I farmed that stupid gem for hours until someone told me the secret. I ran through story mode to get to the cave. It took me about an hour and a half, but the gem was there the third time I went into the cave.
@@kungfuutah I did the story mode trick as well - icefall caves still spawned occasionally which was a bit annoying and it took me another two or three hours after that to get the gem to drop. All in all I believe I wasted seven hours just trying to get this one stupid little gem.
@@kungfuutah so you want to say, that if you play till the bridge of khorsik in story-mode and redo the game a few times, the dropchances are much higher?
The Mrs and I are casual Diablo players and we rely on content creators to really get a grip of things when an update or new season happens etc (things are moving far, far faster than they used to in the first two Diablo games).I just want to say that I honestly believe that your channel is the best for all things Diablo is concerned. You're always on point, explain anything that needs attention in detail and avoid spending time on things that do not. Presenting your content in a friendly manner is always a big bonus too. I hope you keep your channel at this high level, don't give in into things that other TH-camrs unfortunately have. Thank you for your content and help. Edit: I'm sorry you lost your HC DH the way you did, you certainly took that far differently than how I would have, haha
Raxx, you're truly the best man! All your guides, creating communities, grouping with your fanbase, that's what makes a great content creator and makes those who support you want to stay and support you more and you deserve it. You work hard not only for yourself but for all of us! Much love!
Great guide: Also here is an extra tip: when leaving a game, it's faster to port to town then leave game (5 to 6 sec), rather than leave game from a map (10 sec). This adds up over time.
Great guide Raxx. Just to add unless I missed it....there is a rare portrait frame (rainbow) that you get for killing Prince William if you use the staff of herding to open Whimsyshire...if you don't have it you may want to farm for it before using the staff at the altar
@@Nyctophilia36 It's a rare chance. i literally searched 100+ games and finally caught sir william with his pants down out in the open. and making the staff was super hard last season but i made it in a few hours this season.
@@meditationandhealthyliving9602 man i misread the original comment, i used the staff to sacrifice it in the altar, i thought the staff would get consumed when you use it for the Whimsyshire :/
You know, there was literally 1-2 brain cells telling me there was something to do with the staff before using it for the alter - Fffffffffff Well, thank you for putting that info here for others - rather hitting myself now, grrr
I was literally just typing up a comment that Chiltara is 100% confirmed NOT to carry the Gibbering Gemstone on Xbox when my girlfriend finally got one to drop. 273 Chiltaras killed for a single GGemstone on Xbox. That's way more effort than we plan to invest in any future challenges in the game if they become even more difficult. We love a challenge, but pure RNG like this is simply uninteresting, a waste of time and honestly was a big turn off just now as to whether or not we even want to keep playing a game that has such mechanics. We have been playing for about a month now and your guides have helped a ton so cheers for that.
For those still farming the gibbering Gemstone. I spent most of my Diablo time for 5 days trying to get this rare item. I killed Chiltara at least 100 times. But I finally got it to drop this morning. For those who haven't found it yet, take heart!!
got it from Chiltara my first time meeting meeting her - which was my third try at that map :) got the liquid rainbow crazy fast too... have to love rng
Dude much respect Raxx youve done so much for the community over the years and I cant wait for D4 i came back to D3 for this final season before D4 just finished farming the stuff for the staff started at 4:32 so about 4 hours got the plans in 4 tries, the black mushroom one try, the rainbow bottle took 23 tries, Gibbering 47 tries and got it on the 23rd cav now I just wait for monday for the cache
For starters, let me say that your videos, Raxx, are the only ones I watch if I decide to play Diablo 3. You do the best guides and this is no exception. I am an occasional D3 player, usually log in at the beginning of a season, get the Guardian achi and that's me done. I just decided to try season 28 a few days ago and have long way to go before I unlock the whole Altar. Nevertheless, stumbled across your vid and decided to do the hard part - get the Staff of Herding. Bought the Wirt's Bell, next decided to go for Leoric's Shinbone - boom, first try it was there! Thought to myself, this is easy. Tried for the pattern on T16 around 10 times, no luck. Saw in the vid that other parts can be done on normal, started grinding. Act 1, 2, 3..rince and repeat. Must have done around 15 resets before Liquid Rainbow dropped. Many more tries later I finally stumbled across the "special" room in the cathedral (started to think it doesn`t exist). There was the mushroom. Gibbering Gemstone took me another 15 tries after that (around 40 in total). Feels like Ice Falls and Caverns of Frost ratio was 70:30, at least for me. Never mind, I finally got the right Chiltara that dropped the Gemstone. All the ingredients present, just the pattern now. Back to T16 I go and let the grind resume. Not sure how many tries it took me, but around 1.5h in total. No pattern. It was at this point that I was getting quite annoyed and before I gave up for the night, a bright shiny thought struck my mind - let me check if I don`t already have the pattern! I did - it was sitting right there with my blacksmith and laughing at me...So for all the other noobs out there, like myself, if you`ve played the game for a while and done some bounties, before you go for the Staff of Herding, check your BS first.
Bro I just wanna say.... I farmed the pattern for THREE HOURS. Beyond annoyed. About to yeet my PC out the window. I had the pattern the entire time. Thank you for pointing out my own stupidity. Jesus christ I'm so mad lol.
I'll be honest it's kind of cool that they figured out a way to work in this item into a season. I know finding the parts can be a little grindy because they don't always spawn but being the last big season before the release of Diablo 4 it's cool to see the staff of herding have a purpose again.
There’s really nothing “cool” about how they made this item work with the season. You just craft it, then delete it. Nothing about the staff’s identity is utilized in any way after sacrificing it. I’d go as far as saying it’s a LAZY way to work this item into the season.
@@classxs yeah but just the fact that there are probably hundreds if not thousands of people that don't even know what this item is and this will be an introduction for them.
@@ASQDGAMING I dunno, man. "hey newbie, here's this really cool, really difficult and time consuming item to craft that does this really cool thing. Oh? You crafted it? Nice. Now delete it" doesn't sound like a good introduction to me.
Thanks for this! All done on T16, pattern on #7, mushroom on #5, shinbone on #1, rainbow on #3. Gemstone on Chilltara #13, from my 16th CoF, skipping over 37 Icefalls!
Thanks Raxx, really useful to have this refresher. It's changed a quite a bit since the last time I farmed up the SoH. I just did some practice runs. Black Mushroom on 3rd attempt, Gibbering Gemstone on my FIRST, on a "Clear CoF 2nd Level" quest. So now I've condemned myself to hours of grinding in S28 when it really matters. Aaagh. Also picked up my 7th primal of the season and hit P900 with my Karlei/Strafe DH. I'm a very casual and intermittent player but I'm stoked for S28.
If you're farming for the gibbering gemstone on wizard, I highly recommend getting the aether walker, cosmic strand, pride's fall and a little bit of everything that reduces resource cost on you. Being able to spam teleport all the way will make the process so much more painless and quick.
For everyone reading this as a guide for the staff in Season 30 then everything about it is still relevant. The only difference is they have increased the drop chance on the gibbering gemstone to something like 20% now, rather than the ridiculous low rate it spawned previously. I got mine in 4 runs. In Season 28 I did over 200 - I know, I kept track. Great guide as well - thanks for doing this.
Couple notes here for folks: 1) The IMO the Shinbone and mushroom are great to check for after doing bounties. You will be there anyway. just drop by. 2) If you are looking for the plan, try throwing on a nagel ring. 39% added magic find and the plans are legendary (this worked for my RNG after running 15 times on T6 with no ring on). 3) invite the group if you get the shinbone or mushroom. it's just nice. 4) THe gemstone was the worst. I just did that solo.
Thanks for your help! Because i feel compelled to open every chest I see, I Just found Liquid Rainbow on 1st level in a resplendent chest. Also, while in Cathedral Level I, I found the special room with the 2 doors like you said and there was nothing. But since I had just started exploring the area, I continued and found yet another special looking room and this time I found it. Just thought I would pass that along. Been playing Diablo since the 90's and have been watching you now for years. Thanks for all you do!
For the gemstone, just look up the cave locations on the map, easy to find on the fandom wiki. It also shares spawns with other points of interest, like the catapults, shrines and sometimes just holes in the ground. You can see on the edge of the screen if that area is not a cave entrance type rocky part, move to the next.
Thanks Raxx and his community as a whole. We helped collaboratively succeed and even more people are using the communities! Looking forward to the future of D4 with Raxx and his community! Edit: words are hard
Thanks a lot, Raxx! This guide was gold. Got the plan and 4 mat so quick i was like Wow! Then started the pain. 45 runs and no Gibberish Gemstone... next day got tired and asked BF to farm a little for me... I explained just like you and he got on the 5 run! Was missing that for Wings of Terror weeeeee. Thanks again.
staff of herding is for opening whimsyshire, not the cow level😁 & this is for the console players: for console players it‘s actually not that hard cause we apart from the plan itself, we only have 3 items to collect: - Plan itself (Act 4 - Izual) - Black mushroom (Act 1 - Cathedral 1) - Wirts Bell (Act 2 - Squirt the Peddler) - Gibbering Gemstone (Act 3 - Fields of Slaughter - Caverns of Frost) I‘ve done it in 2 hours while besides searching for the parts searching for the Falcon Wings and watching a netflix series, so not that big of a deal :)
I don't mind the grind, but I hate the activities that forces you to leave the game and create a new one. Such a waste of time, why blizzard don't understand that waiting for a countdown is not fun. Thanks for the guide by the way, best diablo content!!
@@puru721 or better yet, let me ask you this. When you finish a run with Baal and wanna continue to farm Baal, what do you do? Towards the end of the day, it’s the same thing. You quit and start over the new game and continue to farm Baal. Sure, you’re farming Baal for a different reason. But you’re still quitting and start over to grind and farm. That was my point. I wasn’t making fun or poking at d2. Am a fan of d2 more than d3 and I do believe that d3 isn’t a diablo game. But I like both for different reasons. Don’t be triggered.
@@peterretep1010 there no 10 second timer no such thing in d2 come on man.. u can leave and quickly making new game 🤷🏻♂️..not trigger at all mate just don't spread wrong information xD
@@puru721 I was talking about restarting the game and play the new one. Never did I mentioned any timer. Wtf are you saying? What misinformation was I saying?
To anyone who thinks this will take way too long (I did, and almost wanted to quit it) I still wanted to atleast try it, and see how far I could go before giving up. This is not a flex but more a reinsurance that is can be done fast. Blizz might have upped the chance for these items to drop. These are the tries I did for the items. The plan: 20 tries. The Mushroom: 10 tries. The Shinebone: 16 tries. I somehow already had the liquid rainbow, so I was ahead before I even knew it. The Gibbering Gemstone: 7 tries! I know some might not believe my luck but I would bet that after 4 months Blizz might have increased the droprate for these items. So if you haven't done this, do try it. You might get lucky as me or find out that blizz increase the droprate. And thanks Raxx. This guide was superb. I didn't have a group, but this was still super easy to follow.
Oh and he's so clear, doesn't talk slow or constantly repeat himself.. I've never once been confused by his descriptions either - what a god send his content is!
Great guide, was kinda unlucky with most spawns and drops and then the Gibbering gemstone dropped on first Cavern of frost. Took about 2 hours to do everything. Thanksss
I did the Staff of Herding years ago, and I very much remember that grind; it was so awful. When reading about S28, and the altar, I was super excited until I saw Herding on the sacrifice list and a swore out loud. This season is proof that the Devs either don't play D3 or are sadists.
Interesting. I remember the liquid rainbow giving me the most trouble. Though, that was back when there were nightmarish/hellish/infernal staff of heardings as well.
I came back for the final season after playing D4 Beta and needing my ARPG fix. It's been 4 years since I've played D3. Fantastic final season before D4 release. Unlocking the seals has been rewarding and it hasn't been fast. The two cock blockers have been the Ancient Puzzle Ring and this stupid Gemstone. After 6 hours of farming over 2 days, the gemstone finally dropped. For those that are still trying to get it, have faith, it will drop eventually. @Raxxanterax: Great content! Found you via Asmon. Over the past few weeks I probably watched 8 hours of your content and it helped me refamiliarize my way back into D3. What is Augmentation? Answered. Echoing Nightmares? Done. Thank you!
Excellent guide, virtually every aspect covered, still doesn't make this any less annoying but the guide is super helpful, maybe the devs make some of these drop rates more reasonable.
I think they buffed the drop rate. I remember doing this twice on two separate regions and it took days and days of farming. I did this during this season twice on two different regions. First one I did it in about 30 min to get all the materials. Second time around it took about an hour. I remember the Cavern of Frost being the hardest drop but both times I got it on the first try.
Hey Rex, just a quick question. I noticed you said change to Normal mode before you go Kill Chiltara in the COF. Is it better to do it on normal? Is there a better drop rate compared to T1 or Higher? Just curious. I have ran it several dozen times and I have not gotten lucky yet. I did not know if the level difficulty made her drop the Gibbering Gemstone. Well, thank you very much for all the work you do on all these videos. Be well :)
With Gibbering Gemstone, I've always found it far easier to just reload until the bounty for Chiltara shows up. By having four people soloing you get 4x the reloads, which makes it a lot faster to get the her to spawn because there's less loading and no timeouts (check in town). When one of you get that bounty, they invite everyone else.
@@meditationandhealthyliving9602 Correct. But you aren't looking at this correctly. 4 people hunting, there are 4 different conditions 2 out of the 4 are reset instantly the other 2 are invite conditions. With just 3 people hunting like this we had cavern or chiltara every single reset. Made this a breeze.
Really appreciate the video, very informative and helpful, not to mention I was able to get some clan mates their mushrooms, shin bone and liquid rainbow. Still farming gibbering gemstone at the time of commenting but found the rest in under 10 minutes.
i believe for the liquid rainbow there is a faster search for it when you look on campaign mode since you start right beside the alcove and that 1st alcove you were going to did you ever have it spawn as mysterious cave because i thought that second alcove was a different cave
I made the staff about 10 seasons ago. Yeah, Chitara was a royal PITA. I used all of these tricks, but did it all solo. I also spent an entire off season using it to get Portrait, which I never did! Ha. Yeah tho, that Gibbering Gemstone...phew. Good thing is isn't required at the Altar until very late in the season for casuals like me. So I can wait and do it later. YMMV, good luck.
Thanks for the vid. After watching this I just casually did these tasks while progressing through the season and by the time I got to the staff requirement on the altar all I was needing was the gemstone and did caverns of frost and got it! Didn't feel like a grind at all.
Thanks so much for your video. I just got the gem on my third run, it was a breeze. Really lucky. Farmed the staff in 30 minutes. I guess I spent all my luck on this one.
For faster farming Gibberish Gemstone: Farming in campaign mode lets Cilltara always spawn in Forst Caves, so one random factor less, since Icefall could spawn. And the Gemstone still is no save drop from Cilltara. Also there is redit rumor about better dropchance in adventure T7.
Thanks a bunch! Took me about an hour to get the first 4. I'll just hunt Chiltara whenever I start a new game till I actually need the gemstone. Top man!
Thanks for the guide! I think I was extremely lucky. I got the Gibbering and rainbow on first try(!) I actually had the most difficulty getting the mushroom. Which was still only 15-ish games.
After watching this video, it only took me 1 hour and 10 minutes to find *all* the parts. Solo. T6. First try on the plan and the mushroom. Gibbering took the longest, about 20 runs. Still, this guide made it a breeze for me. Thanks!
Was following the guide here and I actually got the liquid rainbow out of a resplendent chest on the first floor of the mysterious cave. It was the only item that dropped from it, but make sure that you’re opening every resplendent chest as well
Thit fkn gemstone by far is the third hardest to find object in the game after cosmic wings and rainbow portrait of course (i was not able to get them so far after all the years spent in the game)... Last time with Staff of herding i spent two months farming that gibbering bastard and Chaltara haunted me in nightmares 😁 that was a total pain in the ass 🔥 Adding it to the season will definitely be a curse to someone ...( P.s. 300+ opened boxes and still no signs of wings ...(
I'd been trying to get the dang mushroom for 2 hours, pulled up your video to make sure I was doing it right and as I'm getting to the black mushroom spot of the video I find it😂. Thanks for the good luck
Thanks man! Im so happy to have nice and easy guide for it ^^ I watched 3 episodes of show (45min each) while checking Izual, shin and mushroom at the same time. Got only mushroom :x They drop rates are terrible...
thanks, got to see its 1 of the few game tutorials i actualy watched to the end :)))))) with pen in hand and writing on paper all the stuff .... Jesus this stuff is hard
Lol, solo'd this in under an hour...(thank you Raxx!!!) (saved me all sorts of time with finding black mushroom (doc.)) but liquid rainbow was super quick - just kept restarting game over and over and ONLY did bounties "Mysterious Cave" runs (no idea why you didn't recommend doing that - saved sooo much time) 2nd Mysterious Cave game got the Rainbow. Gibbering Gemstone literally was the fastest one... every one of my "Fields of Slaughter" had the Caverns of Frost and on my third Caverns of Frost I found Chiltara for the first time - and she gave me the Gibbering to me the first go, f- glorious : ) And again, if there is a bounty specific for Chiltara why not recommend people restarting over and over and just doing the maps with that specific bounty - That and with the Bounties obviously there is a yellow arrow pointing the player to exactly what area the needed location spawned - thankfully I got it so quickly solo! Absolutely fantastic video as always Rexx - massive massive thanks for all you do!
After about 25 tries got the gibbering gemstone, liquid rainbow, leoric's shinbone in 1 game, then 4-5 games later the mushroom as well finally. Before sacrificing the Staff on the altar it may be worth visiting the Staff - Whimsyshire if you have a fast character and Broken Crown on the follower, then each run will grant about 25-45 imperial gems, as at least two sets of clouds on the map drops a load of gems similar to the Goblin Whimydale. If you found the two sets of clouds you can freely exit and do another run, I haven't found a 3rd drop yet. (I know it's not much, but if you are as unlucky as I am finding gem / rainbow goblins, it could help with the first augments)
Thanks was awesome. the plan took me on the 3rd try, mushroom 1st try, shinbone 2nd try, rainbow took a while but got it. the last one gibbering is annoying i'll try again tomorrow
Ive actually farmed the staff in most seasons, twice, one in SC one in HC. I normally did it when I was listening to an ebook or something or as a break from the grind of main gameplay. My main aim was getting the spectre rainbow sword transmog with it. My off season has heaps of the staffs carried over. Yes I am insane. Anyway, I would say that I averaged 4 hours SSF, fastest was one hour, slowest was 2 days, both times the timeloss was chiltara not dropping or mysterious cave not appearing. My tip is, any new game, check the bounties quickly, even if you are not farming it, just incase you see the key bounties appear. Next would be just look if you are going by in bounties, often ill get the shin bone because I noticed it from the balcony when doing a bounty in leorics manor, or the mushroom just coincidentally while going past that area. But the key for me, as SSF at least, is wait until you have a good speed build. The walk to get chiltara, find the mysterious cave, get to Izual, fin the mushroom room all add up as time spent just moving and it totally isn't worth it unless you are doing that fast. awesome video as always.
gibbering gem stone first try - took me 45 mins start to finish guess i got very lucky - ty for the guide - i havnt farmed the staff since it first came out lol
Thx for your work mate! farmed for everything but the gemstone yesterday within 1.5 hours. today within 45 minutes the gemstone. started in t16 5 chiltaras, on normal another 3 chiltaras and then changed to t7 and first chiltara drops it. perhaps coincidence, perhaps the reddit rumor is true
@Raxxanterax best way to get gibbering gemstone is to do speed campaign to machines of war in chapter 3. CoF spawns 3-4 times in a row and chiltara has a 100% spawn rate each time u do CoF in campaign. i completed alter day 1 of s28 doing this.
I don't know if this helps anyone for Gibbering Gemstone. But I just did Caverns of Frost and Chilltara wasn't there. I had nemesis bracers on and hit the shrine and she popped out of it. So pretty cool.
Back in the day you had to make the staff AND upgrade it for each difficulty mode you wanted to use it in. I still have the Infernal Staff of Herding, which was required to access whimsyshire in the brutal inferno mode, while it was still in game. You can no longer make this thing. I'm never deleting it.
@Raxxanterax, another way to speed up finding the Black Mushroom is to know that the room with the mushroom does not spawn, when the exit to Cathedral Level 2 has a spiral staircase. So if you find the exit to Cathedral Level 2 and it has the spiral staircase you can immediately leave, and you don't need to search any further on that level. Your first two tries show very well, what I mean. In both cases there was that exit tile, I mean. On your third try there was that »normal« straight exit tile.
Ty I will remember that
turbohud shows it too^^
hope the bannwaves the next season will change a bit but man if i see the leaderbords...
Faster, always in the lower left corner.
+1 to Jared
For me, the sign is 'closed square map layout'
The room must have two enters and can only be located in the "closed square" map layout.
I couldn't find a layout with more than 1 closed square, and it's only it's south corner (bottom).
So whatever you start at, you go "down".
@@ChrisGuldan which one? i use chineese lightning, and it dont show anything like that, only show black mushroom in ~30meters
I have to thank you for your help. I'm 74 and have played this game since it came out. I play solo because I don't know if I'm fast enough to play with others. I always watch your videos so thanks for that.
Richard, get involved online, you will find plenty of groups who can help, and clans to make the whole thing more interactive. Will you play d4?
If anybody xbox here I would love to have a partner I haven't played in a long time but I started again fresh start recently
Wtf bro
Thanks for all your hard work, Raxx. Everything you do is high quality and so so helpful.
My pleasure! Thank you so much!
Things that triggered while searching for the Gibbering Gemstone, in the Cavern of Frost:
- goblin field
- goblin pylon
- whymsydale
- cow level
- vault
Things that didn't trigger: Gibbering Gemstone dropped.
The search continues...
I farmed 10hours for it and got it then a friend said it will drop easier on normal and i got 2 in one hour
@Matzi 2001 let's hope I get lucky with this. 15 hours of farming and no luck 😢
I got the cow level but no damn gibbering stone yet lol, it's been 3 days
@@Matzi2001 What a dumb luck. Wasted like ~5 hours straight farming it on T13 and no luck then changed it to Normal after reading your comment and 1st try got a drop.
I have been farming the gibbering gemstone on my xbox since 2017 and still haven't gotten it. Hopefully my journey on PC will be more lenient...
If you are on console you only need to get the Plan, Black Mushroom, Wirt's Bell, and the Gibbering Gemstone. You don't need to get either Leoric's Shinbone or the Liquid Rainbow. Not sure why that is, but it does make crafting the Staff of Herding a bit easier on console
what do you mean you dont need to get either shinbone or rainbow? how does the recipe look to reflect that?
@@XGazudin The recipe on console is just the Mushroom, the Bell, and the Gemstone.
@@xJackieBx haha thank you, makes a lot more sense than whatever my weird brain was trying to come up with
thanks so much for saying so. i farmed mysterious chests for rainbow for over an hour and after finding several mysterious chests with zero rainbows i was starting to question my sanity.
also on console, when the host leaves a game, the remaining players are dropped into a new game, so the multi-game farming trick Rax describes for the Gemstone won't work.
Found Cosmic Wings in a Rainbow goblin while trying to get Gibbering Gemstone. This guides a great refresher for the Staff of Herding, its been so long since the first time crafting one.
Got a rainbow goblin too, but no wings 😢
I feel like you're talking to me as if I'm a 1st grader at times and I mean that in the best kind of way. I am like, clinically stupid. Your explicit clarity is excellent and helpful my friend. Thank you for the wonderful guide.
I've been farming Chiltara for five hours in a row now with no gibbering gemstone drop. Great stuff, I'm really enjoying season 28.
I farmed that stupid gem for hours until someone told me the secret. I ran through story mode to get to the cave. It took me about an hour and a half, but the gem was there the third time I went into the cave.
@@kungfuutah I did the story mode trick as well - icefall caves still spawned occasionally which was a bit annoying and it took me another two or three hours after that to get the gem to drop. All in all I believe I wasted seven hours just trying to get this one stupid little gem.
Gemstone clearly took longer than the rest of them combined for me too.
@@kungfuutah so you want to say, that if you play till the bridge of khorsik in story-mode and redo the game a few times, the dropchances are much higher?
@@hioh8716 yep
The Mrs and I are casual Diablo players and we rely on content creators to really get a grip of things when an update or new season happens etc (things are moving far, far faster than they used to in the first two Diablo games).I just want to say that I honestly believe that your channel is the best for all things Diablo is concerned. You're always on point, explain anything that needs attention in detail and avoid spending time on things that do not. Presenting your content in a friendly manner is always a big bonus too. I hope you keep your channel at this high level, don't give in into things that other TH-camrs unfortunately have. Thank you for your content and help.
Edit: I'm sorry you lost your HC DH the way you did, you certainly took that far differently than how I would have, haha
Raxx, you're truly the best man! All your guides, creating communities, grouping with your fanbase, that's what makes a great content creator and makes those who support you want to stay and support you more and you deserve it. You work hard not only for yourself but for all of us! Much love!
Great guide: Also here is an extra tip: when leaving a game, it's faster to port to town then leave game (5 to 6 sec), rather than leave game from a map (10 sec). This adds up over time.
Great guide Raxx. Just to add unless I missed it....there is a rare portrait frame (rainbow) that you get for killing Prince William if you use the staff of herding to open Whimsyshire...if you don't have it you may want to farm for it before using the staff at the altar
if you use the Staff of Herding to open Whimsyshire, is it guaranteed to get the rainbow frame? or is it a chance?
@@Nyctophilia36 It's a rare chance. i literally searched 100+ games and finally caught sir william with his pants down out in the open. and making the staff was super hard last season but i made it in a few hours this season.
@@meditationandhealthyliving9602 man i misread the original comment, i used the staff to sacrifice it in the altar, i thought the staff would get consumed when you use it for the Whimsyshire :/
@@Nyctophilia36 It's a very rare drop. Prepare to spend some time doing it
You know, there was literally 1-2 brain cells telling me there was something to do with the staff before using it for the alter - Fffffffffff Well, thank you for putting that info here for others - rather hitting myself now, grrr
Accurate, easy to understand, really great video. Whole process around an hour and a half completely solo T16 the whole time
I was literally just typing up a comment that Chiltara is 100% confirmed NOT to carry the Gibbering Gemstone on Xbox when my girlfriend finally got one to drop. 273 Chiltaras killed for a single GGemstone on Xbox. That's way more effort than we plan to invest in any future challenges in the game if they become even more difficult. We love a challenge, but pure RNG like this is simply uninteresting, a waste of time and honestly was a big turn off just now as to whether or not we even want to keep playing a game that has such mechanics. We have been playing for about a month now and your guides have helped a ton so cheers for that.
For those still farming the gibbering Gemstone. I spent most of my Diablo time for 5 days trying to get this rare item. I killed Chiltara at least 100 times. But I finally got it to drop this morning. For those who haven't found it yet, take heart!!
3 days, still nothing!!!!
got it from Chiltara my first time meeting meeting her - which was my third try at that map :) got the liquid rainbow crazy fast too... have to love rng
Dude much respect Raxx youve done so much for the community over the years and I cant wait for D4 i came back to D3 for this final season before D4 just finished farming the stuff for the staff started at 4:32 so about 4 hours got the plans in 4 tries, the black mushroom one try, the rainbow bottle took 23 tries, Gibbering 47 tries and got it on the 23rd cav now I just wait for monday for the cache
ive been following you for years and actually never commented on your videos so I want to say that youre doing gods work with your videos/guides.
For starters, let me say that your videos, Raxx, are the only ones I watch if I decide to play Diablo 3. You do the best guides and this is no exception. I am an occasional D3 player, usually log in at the beginning of a season, get the Guardian achi and that's me done. I just decided to try season 28 a few days ago and have long way to go before I unlock the whole Altar. Nevertheless, stumbled across your vid and decided to do the hard part - get the Staff of Herding. Bought the Wirt's Bell, next decided to go for Leoric's Shinbone - boom, first try it was there! Thought to myself, this is easy. Tried for the pattern on T16 around 10 times, no luck. Saw in the vid that other parts can be done on normal, started grinding. Act 1, 2, 3..rince and repeat. Must have done around 15 resets before Liquid Rainbow dropped. Many more tries later I finally stumbled across the "special" room in the cathedral (started to think it doesn`t exist). There was the mushroom. Gibbering Gemstone took me another 15 tries after that (around 40 in total). Feels like Ice Falls and Caverns of Frost ratio was 70:30, at least for me. Never mind, I finally got the right Chiltara that dropped the Gemstone. All the ingredients present, just the pattern now. Back to T16 I go and let the grind resume. Not sure how many tries it took me, but around 1.5h in total. No pattern. It was at this point that I was getting quite annoyed and before I gave up for the night, a bright shiny thought struck my mind - let me check if I don`t already have the pattern! I did - it was sitting right there with my blacksmith and laughing at me...So for all the other noobs out there, like myself, if you`ve played the game for a while and done some bounties, before you go for the Staff of Herding, check your BS first.
Bro I just wanna say.... I farmed the pattern for THREE HOURS. Beyond annoyed. About to yeet my PC out the window.
I had the pattern the entire time. Thank you for pointing out my own stupidity. Jesus christ I'm so mad lol.
Dude, what a great guide! Playing season 31 and got ALL of these in like an hour and a half, thank you so much!
I'll be honest it's kind of cool that they figured out a way to work in this item into a season. I know finding the parts can be a little grindy because they don't always spawn but being the last big season before the release of Diablo 4 it's cool to see the staff of herding have a purpose again.
well. the gibbering gemstones have always had this ability of breaking keyboards.
as long as they buff droprate
There’s really nothing “cool” about how they made this item work with the season. You just craft it, then delete it. Nothing about the staff’s identity is utilized in any way after sacrificing it. I’d go as far as saying it’s a LAZY way to work this item into the season.
@@classxs yeah but just the fact that there are probably hundreds if not thousands of people that don't even know what this item is and this will be an introduction for them.
@@ASQDGAMING I dunno, man. "hey newbie, here's this really cool, really difficult and time consuming item to craft that does this really cool thing. Oh? You crafted it? Nice. Now delete it" doesn't sound like a good introduction to me.
Thanks for this! All done on T16, pattern on #7, mushroom on #5, shinbone on #1, rainbow on #3. Gemstone on Chilltara #13, from my 16th CoF, skipping over 37 Icefalls!
Thanks Raxx, really useful to have this refresher. It's changed a quite a bit since the last time I farmed up the SoH.
I just did some practice runs. Black Mushroom on 3rd attempt, Gibbering Gemstone on my FIRST, on a "Clear CoF 2nd Level" quest. So now I've condemned myself to hours of grinding in S28 when it really matters. Aaagh.
Also picked up my 7th primal of the season and hit P900 with my Karlei/Strafe DH. I'm a very casual and intermittent player but I'm stoked for S28.
This was gold man. knocked it out. Never gotten that staff made before! Thank you so much!
If you're farming for the gibbering gemstone on wizard, I highly recommend getting the aether walker, cosmic strand, pride's fall and a little bit of everything that reduces resource cost on you. Being able to spam teleport all the way will make the process so much more painless and quick.
For everyone reading this as a guide for the staff in Season 30 then everything about it is still relevant. The only difference is they have increased the drop chance on the gibbering gemstone to something like 20% now, rather than the ridiculous low rate it spawned previously. I got mine in 4 runs. In Season 28 I did over 200 - I know, I kept track. Great guide as well - thanks for doing this.
Couple notes here for folks: 1) The IMO the Shinbone and mushroom are great to check for after doing bounties. You will be there anyway. just drop by. 2) If you are looking for the plan, try throwing on a nagel ring. 39% added magic find and the plans are legendary (this worked for my RNG after running 15 times on T6 with no ring on). 3) invite the group if you get the shinbone or mushroom. it's just nice. 4) THe gemstone was the worst. I just did that solo.
Thanks for your help! Because i feel compelled to open every chest I see, I Just found Liquid Rainbow on 1st level in a resplendent chest. Also, while in Cathedral Level I, I found the special room with the 2 doors like you said and there was nothing. But since I had just started exploring the area, I continued and found yet another special looking room and this time I found it. Just thought I would pass that along. Been playing Diablo since the 90's and have been watching you now for years. Thanks for all you do!
For the gemstone, just look up the cave locations on the map, easy to find on the fandom wiki. It also shares spawns with other points of interest, like the catapults, shrines and sometimes just holes in the ground. You can see on the edge of the screen if that area is not a cave entrance type rocky part, move to the next.
16:10 just watching rax going ham on that 'three leaf clover' :)
Thanks Raxx and his community as a whole. We helped collaboratively succeed and even more people are using the communities! Looking forward to the future of D4 with Raxx and his community! Edit: words are hard
Thanks a lot, Raxx! This guide was gold. Got the plan and 4 mat so quick i was like Wow! Then started the pain. 45 runs and no Gibberish Gemstone... next day got tired and asked BF to farm a little for me... I explained just like you and he got on the 5 run! Was missing that for Wings of Terror weeeeee. Thanks again.
staff of herding is for opening whimsyshire, not the cow level😁
& this is for the console players: for console players it‘s actually not that hard cause we apart from the plan itself, we only have 3 items to collect:
- Plan itself (Act 4 - Izual)
- Black mushroom (Act 1 - Cathedral 1)
- Wirts Bell (Act 2 - Squirt the Peddler)
- Gibbering Gemstone (Act 3 - Fields of Slaughter - Caverns of Frost)
I‘ve done it in 2 hours while besides searching for the parts searching for the Falcon Wings and watching a netflix series, so not that big of a deal :)
This guide was invaluable, I managed to farm it all solo in under an hour without ever doing it before.
u are invaluable man go toch some grass!
I don't mind the grind, but I hate the activities that forces you to leave the game and create a new one. Such a waste of time, why blizzard don't understand that waiting for a countdown is not fun. Thanks for the guide by the way, best diablo content!!
Meh, got used to it with d2.
@@peterretep1010 ??u can leave the game without timing??do you really play d2?or u mean you played d2 Minecraft version???😆😆
@@puru721 or better yet, let me ask you this. When you finish a run with Baal and wanna continue to farm Baal, what do you do? Towards the end of the day, it’s the same thing. You quit and start over the new game and continue to farm Baal. Sure, you’re farming Baal for a different reason. But you’re still quitting and start over to grind and farm. That was my point. I wasn’t making fun or poking at d2. Am a fan of d2 more than d3 and I do believe that d3 isn’t a diablo game. But I like both for different reasons. Don’t be triggered.
@@peterretep1010 there no 10 second timer no such thing in d2 come on man.. u can leave and quickly making new game 🤷🏻♂️..not trigger at all mate just don't spread wrong information xD
@@puru721 I was talking about restarting the game and play the new one. Never did I mentioned any timer. Wtf are you saying? What misinformation was I saying?
To anyone who thinks this will take way too long (I did, and almost wanted to quit it) I still wanted to atleast try it, and see how far I could go before giving up. This is not a flex but more a reinsurance that is can be done fast. Blizz might have upped the chance for these items to drop. These are the tries I did for the items.
The plan: 20 tries.
The Mushroom: 10 tries.
The Shinebone: 16 tries.
I somehow already had the liquid rainbow, so I was ahead before I even knew it.
The Gibbering Gemstone: 7 tries!
I know some might not believe my luck but I would bet that after 4 months Blizz might have increased the droprate for these items.
So if you haven't done this, do try it. You might get lucky as me or find out that blizz increase the droprate.
And thanks Raxx. This guide was superb. I didn't have a group, but this was still super easy to follow.
Colonel, you better have a look at this timestamp 16:18 . What is it, son? I don't know, sir, but it looks like a giant...
Johnson! Where is my report? Wait, do you see that over there? It's gotta be the size of my...
Thanks for the guide I made the staff a decade ago and couldn't remeber any of the steps other than the shin one since it's unique enough.
Glad I could help!
👌🏻 I swear Raxx makes every aspect of life in D3 so much easier. I truly don't know what I'd do without him & his hours of hard work 👏🏻🥰💕💕
Oh and he's so clear, doesn't talk slow or constantly repeat himself.. I've never once been confused by his descriptions either - what a god send his content is!
Great guide, was kinda unlucky with most spawns and drops and then the Gibbering gemstone dropped on first Cavern of frost. Took about 2 hours to do everything. Thanksss
I did the Staff of Herding years ago, and I very much remember that grind; it was so awful. When reading about S28, and the altar, I was super excited until I saw Herding on the sacrifice list and a swore out loud. This season is proof that the Devs either don't play D3 or are sadists.
It's a final "fuck you" to the players.
thx for this one. it's been years since I crafted the staff. was extremly lucky this season with the drops.
Interesting. I remember the liquid rainbow giving me the most trouble. Though, that was back when there were nightmarish/hellish/infernal staff of heardings as well.
yeah that was a pain in the ass to upgrade the staff.
Great guide, amazing editing, to the point, very useful. 10/10! Keep it up and pat yourself on the back, great job!
Can't wait for the season! So Hype! Love the videos Raxx!
I came back for the final season after playing D4 Beta and needing my ARPG fix. It's been 4 years since I've played D3. Fantastic final season before D4 release. Unlocking the seals has been rewarding and it hasn't been fast. The two cock blockers have been the Ancient Puzzle Ring and this stupid Gemstone. After 6 hours of farming over 2 days, the gemstone finally dropped. For those that are still trying to get it, have faith, it will drop eventually. @Raxxanterax: Great content! Found you via Asmon. Over the past few weeks I probably watched 8 hours of your content and it helped me refamiliarize my way back into D3. What is Augmentation? Answered. Echoing Nightmares? Done. Thank you!
Yeah, three leafs clover...
Still does looks like a three leaf clover to me ;-)
Anyway, awesome video like always.
Thanks Raxx. 3 levels of RNG on the gemstone make it for a miserable experience, but you made it as easy as it can be.
Excellent guide, virtually every aspect covered, still doesn't make this any less annoying but the guide is super helpful, maybe the devs make some of these drop rates more reasonable.
Hey! Great video! I followed the very clearly laid out steps and got my staff in about an hour. Very cool.
I think they buffed the drop rate. I remember doing this twice on two separate regions and it took days and days of farming. I did this during this season twice on two different regions. First one I did it in about 30 min to get all the materials. Second time around it took about an hour. I remember the Cavern of Frost being the hardest drop but both times I got it on the first try.
Good stuff. Thanks to all who contributed to the data.
Hey Rex, just a quick question. I noticed you said change to Normal mode before you go Kill Chiltara in the COF. Is it better to do it on normal? Is there a better drop rate compared to T1 or Higher?
Just curious. I have ran it several dozen times and I have not gotten lucky yet. I did not know if the level difficulty made her drop the Gibbering Gemstone.
Well, thank you very much for all the work you do on all these videos. Be well :)
farmed gibbering gemstone in 1 hour solo using the info in this vid. tyvm you are the god for efficient d3 strats
With Gibbering Gemstone, I've always found it far easier to just reload until the bounty for Chiltara shows up. By having four people soloing you get 4x the reloads, which makes it a lot faster to get the her to spawn because there's less loading and no timeouts (check in town). When one of you get that bounty, they invite everyone else.
u can literally spend an hour without that rare bounty showing up... in fact i found the gibbering gem this season without ONCE seeing that bounty.
@@meditationandhealthyliving9602 Correct. But you aren't looking at this correctly. 4 people hunting, there are 4 different conditions 2 out of the 4 are reset instantly the other 2 are invite conditions. With just 3 people hunting like this we had cavern or chiltara every single reset. Made this a breeze.
@@gopatriots1991 Oh yeah, if you're doing groups like that, anything is possible, lol.
Really appreciate the video, very informative and helpful, not to mention I was able to get some clan mates their mushrooms, shin bone and liquid rainbow. Still farming gibbering gemstone at the time of commenting but found the rest in under 10 minutes.
i believe for the liquid rainbow there is a faster search for it when you look on campaign mode since you start right beside the alcove and that 1st alcove you were going to did you ever have it spawn as mysterious cave because i thought that second alcove was a different cave
You have to get to that point in the campaign, that will taka a bit but yeah when you're there its faster.
I made the staff about 10 seasons ago. Yeah, Chitara was a royal PITA. I used all of these tricks, but did it all solo. I also spent an entire off season using it to get Portrait, which I never did! Ha. Yeah tho, that Gibbering Gemstone...phew. Good thing is isn't required at the Altar until very late in the season for casuals like me. So I can wait and do it later. YMMV, good luck.
My brother, that is not a three leaf clover.
😂
Thanks for the guide! Working solo, on T16, I managed to get all remaining pieces in 1 hour (I had already found the Liquid Rainbow)! :)
I ended up doing it solo, didn't take too long, something about your paint skills made it easier on me.
Thanks for the vid. After watching this I just casually did these tasks while progressing through the season and by the time I got to the staff requirement on the altar all I was needing was the gemstone and did caverns of frost and got it! Didn't feel like a grind at all.
Best d3 content maker so far. Its always like d3 for dummies and i understand everything you talking about!
Thanks so much for your video. I just got the gem on my third run, it was a breeze. Really lucky. Farmed the staff in 30 minutes. I guess I spent all my luck on this one.
For faster farming Gibberish Gemstone: Farming in campaign mode lets Cilltara always spawn in Forst Caves, so one random factor less, since Icefall could spawn. And the Gemstone still is no save drop from Cilltara. Also there is redit rumor about better dropchance in adventure T7.
Thanks a bunch! Took me about an hour to get the first 4. I'll just hunt Chiltara whenever I start a new game till I actually need the gemstone. Top man!
Thanks for the guide! I think I was extremely lucky. I got the Gibbering and rainbow on first try(!) I actually had the most difficulty getting the mushroom. Which was still only 15-ish games.
This helped a ton. Your instructions were clear and concise.
it only took me about 90 mins to do with this guide man, thanks
THANKS FOR GUIDE! got completed in 50 minutes whole loot :D
Thanks for your work. Got everything without an hour solo with the help of this video.
After watching this video, it only took me 1 hour and 10 minutes to find *all* the parts. Solo. T6. First try on the plan and the mushroom. Gibbering took the longest, about 20 runs. Still, this guide made it a breeze for me. Thanks!
Was following the guide here and I actually got the liquid rainbow out of a resplendent chest on the first floor of the mysterious cave. It was the only item that dropped from it, but make sure that you’re opening every resplendent chest as well
Just got my liquid rainbow out of a resplendent chest as you described
Thit fkn gemstone by far is the third hardest to find object in the game after cosmic wings and rainbow portrait of course (i was not able to get them so far after all the years spent in the game)... Last time with Staff of herding i spent two months farming that gibbering bastard and Chaltara haunted me in nightmares 😁 that was a total pain in the ass 🔥 Adding it to the season will definitely be a curse to someone ...(
P.s. 300+ opened boxes and still no signs of wings ...(
I'd been trying to get the dang mushroom for 2 hours, pulled up your video to make sure I was doing it right and as I'm getting to the black mushroom spot of the video I find it😂. Thanks for the good luck
Got the mushroom and the gibbering gemstone in the same game. Thrilling 45 seconds! Thanks Raxx!!
Man, this takes me back to grinding for this staff in the early-D3 days.
Thanks man! Im so happy to have nice and easy guide for it ^^
I watched 3 episodes of show (45min each) while checking Izual, shin and mushroom at the same time. Got only mushroom :x They drop rates are terrible...
Got all the items! Thank you for the guide! Playing solo and Got the giber gemstone at the 3rd try!
TY for the guide sir, I did this in one non-season years ago. Found the mysterious cave and the rainbow first run. TY sir
Thanks for the guide, first try on mushroom, second try on gibbering gemstone
Nice. Worked like a charm. LOL, took less than an hour to get everything. Easy peasy lemon squeezie.
Great guide, going to follow you just for your user of paint, its basic and quick but it really does help a lot!
got the black mushroom first game, gibbering gemstone on my 3rd game. this liquid rainbow one is a paiiiiin and tysm for the guide
thanks, got to see its 1 of the few game tutorials i actualy watched to the end :)))))) with pen in hand and writing on paper all the stuff .... Jesus this stuff is hard
Lol, solo'd this in under an hour...(thank you Raxx!!!) (saved me all sorts of time with finding black mushroom (doc.)) but liquid rainbow was super quick - just kept restarting game over and over and ONLY did bounties "Mysterious Cave" runs (no idea why you didn't recommend doing that - saved sooo much time) 2nd Mysterious Cave game got the Rainbow. Gibbering Gemstone literally was the fastest one... every one of my "Fields of Slaughter" had the Caverns of Frost and on my third Caverns of Frost I found Chiltara for the first time - and she gave me the Gibbering to me the first go, f- glorious : ) And again, if there is a bounty specific for Chiltara why not recommend people restarting over and over and just doing the maps with that specific bounty - That and with the Bounties obviously there is a yellow arrow pointing the player to exactly what area the needed location spawned - thankfully I got it so quickly solo! Absolutely fantastic video as always Rexx - massive massive thanks for all you do!
Thanks!
Thank you, buddy!
After about 25 tries got the gibbering gemstone, liquid rainbow, leoric's shinbone in 1 game, then 4-5 games later the mushroom as well finally. Before sacrificing the Staff on the altar it may be worth visiting the Staff - Whimsyshire if you have a fast character and Broken Crown on the follower, then each run will grant about 25-45 imperial gems, as at least two sets of clouds on the map drops a load of gems similar to the Goblin Whimydale. If you found the two sets of clouds you can freely exit and do another run, I haven't found a 3rd drop yet. (I know it's not much, but if you are as unlucky as I am finding gem / rainbow goblins, it could help with the first augments)
Thank you, got it all in 20 minutes. Great guide!
Thanks was awesome. the plan took me on the 3rd try, mushroom 1st try, shinbone 2nd try, rainbow took a while but got it. the last one gibbering is annoying i'll try again tomorrow
Ive actually farmed the staff in most seasons, twice, one in SC one in HC. I normally did it when I was listening to an ebook or something or as a break from the grind of main gameplay. My main aim was getting the spectre rainbow sword transmog with it. My off season has heaps of the staffs carried over. Yes I am insane. Anyway, I would say that I averaged 4 hours SSF, fastest was one hour, slowest was 2 days, both times the timeloss was chiltara not dropping or mysterious cave not appearing.
My tip is, any new game, check the bounties quickly, even if you are not farming it, just incase you see the key bounties appear. Next would be just look if you are going by in bounties, often ill get the shin bone because I noticed it from the balcony when doing a bounty in leorics manor, or the mushroom just coincidentally while going past that area.
But the key for me, as SSF at least, is wait until you have a good speed build. The walk to get chiltara, find the mysterious cave, get to Izual, fin the mushroom room all add up as time spent just moving and it totally isn't worth it unless you are doing that fast.
awesome video as always.
Staff complete in 52 mimnutes. got gibbering on 6th try. thanks for the guide
gibbering gem stone first try - took me 45 mins start to finish guess i got very lucky - ty for the guide - i havnt farmed the staff since it first came out lol
it took me longer to watch this video than it did to find my staff, thanx Raxx
Awesome! Thank you making this so easy! I got everything I needed solo and within an hour :D
Thx for your work mate! farmed for everything but the gemstone yesterday within 1.5 hours. today within 45 minutes the gemstone. started in t16 5 chiltaras, on normal another 3 chiltaras and then changed to t7 and first chiltara drops it. perhaps coincidence, perhaps the reddit rumor is true
Honestly, some of your best work here, mate. Thank you.
@Raxxanterax best way to get gibbering gemstone is to do speed campaign to machines of war in chapter 3. CoF spawns 3-4 times in a row and chiltara has a 100% spawn rate each time u do CoF in campaign. i completed alter day 1 of s28 doing this.
I don't know if this helps anyone for Gibbering Gemstone. But I just did Caverns of Frost and Chilltara wasn't there. I had nemesis bracers on and hit the shrine and she popped out of it. So pretty cool.
Back in the day you had to make the staff AND upgrade it for each difficulty mode you wanted to use it in. I still have the Infernal Staff of Herding, which was required to access whimsyshire in the brutal inferno mode, while it was still in game. You can no longer make this thing. I'm never deleting it.
This no clover, this balls dude! 16:12