Most of these sound exactly the same as the undubbed version (except the dubbed sounds crisper). In fact , other than 1992, 2006, and 2001, the rest of these didn't even have significant change done to them, or none at all, and 1992 was the only one that actually needed dubbing.
Most off the time these so called undubbed are not even dubbed. Its just the quailty is different from being recorded on different devices. Some were recorded on a phone, old video recorder or voice recorder so obviously the sound quailty will be distorted and others are profesional hence the quailty difference. But people like to make false claims to discredit Mariah. I am not saying her performances were never dubbed but a lot of the ones they claim are dubbed arent hence why both the dubbed and undubbed sound the same
Except in that mtv unplugged dubbing and indeed a lot (nearly all) of the dubbing they corrected the pitch several times, she had gone either sharp or flat and it was corrected it to be on pitch. If this is simply to clean up the sound for audio production then why correct her pitch?
I prefer the rawness of her undubbed vocals & performances however I understand why artists often dub their live performances & a lot of times it has to do with being able to hear instrumentation, background vocals, the type of mic used & /or final mixing
@@chaelan6014 There was no rasp present there, it was a growl. The note was perfect. I would've sounded better with the full studio attempt too, so idk why she decided to change it. Maybe your right about the build up thing, but still.
@@ie2428 i feel like she failed to recover from the growl, the word "feet" was growled, but if you compare to growled "ground" 's from later performances, she didn't growl there. It kinda sounded like a belt from later on in her career at least to me
She has defo been overdoing the dubbing over the years... Which is probably why people cut her so little slack as well. Shame really, she has nothing to prove ❤️
You should’ve included the MTV Unplugged performance (and not just I’ll be there) - that is when I felt devastated and cheated as a fan… She had the same problem since forever and I dont mean the nodules, but the ego and the perfectionism… she was terrific and sooooo f*cking good (enough) without the dubbing… and I didnt read anything about the dubbing in her book. Did Mottola also impose the fraud?
Reading these comments and listening to the undubbed IBT... am I missing something? Because she sounds equally impressive in both dubbed and undubbed. Also, dubbing is pretty common practice (Usher, Beyonce, xtina...etc) all dub and tweak performances for an official release. They all sing very demanding songs back to back and the voice is bound to crack here or there. I think Mariah sounds brilliant in both btw. Also, Whitney said during the WYB interview that Mariah was a hell of a vocalist. I trust Nippy's judgment ❤😊
Charmbracelet is not as good as me, vocally, but much better than you, you are so tired, you can’t even support F5 hahah😂 (I’m obviously joking, I love you😘❤️)
@@joanquintero4670 Wooow listen to my “Emotions” performance in Frankfurt. If you think my whistles are trash you must soo-oo-oo-ooo HIIIIIIIIIIIIGH - real lambs will get that joke - 😂❤️😂
I wish she hadn't dubbed so much in the early days because it created an unrealistic expectation for her live vocals. People compare her current concerts to the 90s dubbed performances and technically she never sounded like that live. Besides, I prefer her raw vocals.
I somewhat agree. Apart from her prime 1993- 1996 . She sounded exactly the same even better in the daydream tour and msg. Same tone, better runs and ressonance. Its not the fact that she didnt sound like that live, i just think she was pushed to her limit and after a while it took a toll on her voice
The parts that were fixed here were minor mistakes or sound problems. The only one that was heavily edited and fixed was the MTV unplugged. I don't think it created unrealistic expectations. Her voice WAS out of this world. She aged, she toured a lot, she has her health problems. All of this affected her voice. Even if the "mistakes" were released, the public and the fans still would compare the old and the new voice.
I’m confused by some of these comments. The undubbed version would sound different if you’re in the audience recording. A phone doesn’t compare to professional recording equipment. She still sounds great to me. It’s little small differences but not liked she croaked or lost her pitch. And to hit the whistle register live is impressive
So do you know how they make this "dubbing" thing ? I'm really curious ? Do they add it later ? Is is basically like they "photoshop" the vocal ? Is she later adding a re-recorded version over the original show ? The craziest part is that for 100% of them I prefer the natural/undubbed version. A true Queen !! Thank you so much for this !
Yes, they fix those audio before it aired or released on DVD. re-recorded new vocal, or using her vocal from other date (for DVD tour). Or just fix bad quality audio.
It can be done in many different ways. Sometimes they even have several takes to pick up parts from, so the final performance that we watxh is none of the ones Mariah originally sang. If they have the the raw vocals and a note is flat surely they can pitch it up a little bit and fix it. And of course the vocal can be filtered to sound smoother, like the usually do in the studio.
This was very interesting AND for me, it explains a lot. A lot of people, including myself have been thinking that her voice drastically changed. No, Look at the vanishing performance, Mariah was cracking and off on certain parts and that was the beginning of her career. But back then, things were still covered up....in today's world, things are exposed more. Ti be perfectly honest, Mariah is still obviously talented, but her voice was never as perfect as some of us thought. No shade...just truth. She is able to do certain things with her voice and in the studio, she can go over it as many times as needed until it's perfect. When a singing live, if you screw up, you just gotta keep moving. Mariah's song writing blows me away more than her singing. Songs like Vision of love, I am Free, Fly like a bird...and there's no dubbing on those song writing skills.
The way you put things isn’t right. It wasn’t covered up, all singers have their live versions dubbed that is normal in the industry. I have seen Vanishing rehearsal and live performance and I think both were amazing performances. The challenge for Mariah is that she made her songs very hard to be replicated on live performances. Most of theses examples her voice is just more horsey in undubbed versions and in Emotions if I remember the 2nd take was "perfect” the whistle here is not the same like the undubbed version I have seen in which she sounded better.
It’s literally part of the music industry just like fixing everything after a movie is made to make it cohesive. There are dubbed performances of every singer alive, but people only focus on Mariah. It’s disappointing when soo called ‘Mariah support’ channels post shit like this making her look bad just for views. Unsubscribing
she really only does it for live tv performances. she usually just increases the sound when she pulls back from her mic and cover up rasp or slightly flat notes thats all
@@TheLegendofMariah so much for LIVE tv… but I also dont get how it works, sometimes it is normalizing volume (vocals vs instruments) but there are a zillion vocal corrections (like off keys, not hitting certain key and some other strained disasters). So the vocal fixes needed to be re recorded. Say MTV Unplugged, the leaks showed that even with the audience there they re recorded more than 2-3 times… then they re engineered and mixed everything the same
@@TheLegendofMariah this. But also, she's not the only one who does it. It looks like it was some kind of protocol in TV shows. I don't think she herself was actually doing it, specially in the Mottola era.
The reason why I hate DVD/VHS tapes. I was watching one of Queen's concerts yesterday, and the live record was so much different. I always prefer TV performances to VHS tapes, because they are telecasted as they are...without any sort of editing.
I can see why she dubbed those parts in Vanishing and VOL, but otherwise the undubbed all sounded great to me. Some pitchy moments but that's normal - nothing was THAT off.
DUBBING FOR HER IS LIKE A LIFE SAVING SOME TIMES. ON THE LIVE WITH PAVAROTTI CONCERT THE DUBBED VERSION HAVE BEEN SOOOO FIXED THAT IN MANY CASES THEY ADDED NOTES SHE DIDNT EVEN SING....LIKE IN THE WHISTLING NOTES OF MY ALL AT THE BEGINNING
I feel bad for her. I want to give her a hug because she's been way too harsh on herself! MARIAH, YOU SOUND BEAUTIFUL IN THE UNDUBBED VOCAL CLIPS! So a little rasp here and there. We love that raspiness in your voice because it's part of who you are. I thought the squeaky, rough whistle registers here sounded so cute! It reminds me of when you told that story of how you'd wake up every morning as a kid and would say something in that same voice to your mom while all groggy. That's been a part of you forever. I wish you'd embrace it and not try to hide it! You're voice is just beautiful no matter what.
Vanishing - Dubbed Vision Of Love - Undubbed Make It Happen - Undubbed Hero - Undubbed Make it Happen - Undubbed My All - Undubbed Hero - Undubbed Emotions - Dubbed Can't Let Go - Dubbed All I Want For Christmas Is You - Dubbed Hero - Undubbed
How on earth did you find the first take undubbed performance of Unplugged?! 😍 It’s so cute hearing how shy she was before she came into full voice for the final recording! 🙌🏽
will ""lambs"" ever stop caring so much if a performance is lipped or not? it's not informative or interesting and just makes mariah look bad. every single time you search "dubbed" or "undubbed" on youtube there are only videos from lambs about mariah, while singers like beyonce (who uses prerecords vocals a lot) are nowhere to be seen. it's so annoying and just makes more people doubt every live performance of hers. it's such an obsession at this point, get a job.
Half of the undubbed ones weren't even that bad. Perfection is overrated. I rather have something flawed but real, in the moment than a perfect studio vocal.
@x123 many artists do a live recording with the band and play that version either in its entirety or bits and pieces during the concert, so it sounds "live". especially when they do world tours
@@Joshua-cu1uz I think it’s both the TV and Mariah, you can tell she’s extremely insecure, even now, I was looking at her interview recently with the chubby British guy and she looks super super uncomfortable with her dress. You can tell she can barely breath, I think she really needs to work on that and accept her flaws, cause otherwise she will always have to keep on dubbing her performances
This makes me realize how ALL her live performances have been tweaked and are not truly live. But for her a singer born with nodules it doesn't really surprise me. Still stan her ❤
You’re not a fan, this is just a lame passive aggressive comment, every single professional performance from every single artist you see have been tweaked, its not just MC
She shouldn’t have done this dubbing thing, many of the performances she dubbed were actually not bad. It’s dishonest to dub and say it’s live. Whitney would never
Videos like this are just Uber falsified! Many of these “dubbed “ moments are SIMPLY better audio quality. But using the word dubbed makes it sound like she lip synchs or goes back and “changes” the vocal which just isn’t true. Maybe in a few cases this has happened but it certainly isn’t all the time or for every performance as this video tries to depict.
How they dubbed all this performance??? Ive got curios and confuse 🙁 ? Is she sang tha song before performing live and when she fails, is the tech engineer will corrects it ??
I can't speak for all of these but divas live wasn't dubbed. you just chose fan vs microphone feedback, if it was dubbed the make it happen rasp would be gone.
Why did she dub so many times in her prime?? Is it just her, or does everyone dub their live performances too?? Idk if I should be dissapointed or what.
@@The_Truth- whitney did dubb some of her performances. All tv performances and live concerts have to be dubbed if they are being sold on VHS or DVD to silence out the audience noise and balance out the sound. People need to understand that dubbing is not always having the singer re sing all the vocals or playing the studio version over a live performance. A lot if the time with live performances the vocals from the mic feed from the performance are used and the sound engineer can increase the volume of what was picked up on the mic and balance the sound and or if needed correct pitch. Also Whitney often lowered the key to her songs. Way more than Mariah did. That doesnt make the song bad tho. And its not always up to the singer whether its dubbed or not its depends on where the performance is and record labels.
@@daintybowlegs1 Whitney didn’t lower her keys in her prime, she rearranged her songs which was smart on Whitney’s part because of this extensive tour dates. Mariah lowered her keys in her prime and still strained and struggled. Hence, mtv unplugged undubbed Mariah is pitchy, hitting flat notes, straining and struggling live. If they did a Whitney unplugged you would find an undubbed version the way you find Mariah’s. All tv performances are not dubbed . Example Whitney at the AMAs singing how will I know had technical issues nothing about that performance was dubbed.
yeah literally, i was like okay for some of them but when they got to make it happen for divas live the only difference was how it was recorded. It was live otherwise the so called dubbed version would be way better. some people need better ears.
People, please. These videos are fake. These videos are being made to discredit Mariah Carey, and if you are foolish to believe them, I'm sorry that there's no ending in this bs.
Part 2?
Up
YES QUEEN
Yes please!💖
Please
Up
the undubbed of the hero duet with pavarotti really shows how powerful her voice is
I love her undubbed imperfections 😍. They are beautiful
Most of these sound exactly the same as the undubbed version (except the dubbed sounds crisper). In fact , other than 1992, 2006, and 2001, the rest of these didn't even have significant change done to them, or none at all, and 1992 was the only one that actually needed dubbing.
Most off the time these so called undubbed are not even dubbed. Its just the quailty is different from being recorded on different devices. Some were recorded on a phone, old video recorder or voice recorder so obviously the sound quailty will be distorted and others are profesional hence the quailty difference. But people like to make false claims to discredit Mariah. I am not saying her performances were never dubbed but a lot of the ones they claim are dubbed arent hence why both the dubbed and undubbed sound the same
@@daintybowlegs1 thank you I noticed that too
It’s unbelievable that doesn’t matter the way. Her voice is unique !!!!
Some people do realize it that sometime dubbing is only use to clean up the sound for digital release like the mtv unplugged
Exactly
Except in that mtv unplugged dubbing and indeed a lot (nearly all) of the dubbing they corrected the pitch several times, she had gone either sharp or flat and it was corrected it to be on pitch. If this is simply to clean up the sound for audio production then why correct her pitch?
@@blecho9890 she mostly just resing the sont until its perfect
@@blecho9890 Please do not tell me that when you're there dubbing it, you won't correct the notes because that is just LAZY.
I prefer the rawness of her undubbed vocals & performances however I understand why artists often dub their live performances & a lot of times it has to do with being able to hear instrumentation, background vocals, the type of mic used & /or final mixing
2:51 Mariah almost knocking off the choir member lmao
Like she said "out of my way"
0:14 ok but this F#5 is so clean
I wonder why they changed the E5 at 3:44 to a lower note on the dubbed version. It was perfect.
Exactly i never understood that
She distorted and she didn't usually rasp there and they probs didn't like it, then probably to make it a buildup for the next note
@@chaelan6014 There was no rasp present there, it was a growl. The note was perfect. I would've sounded better with the full studio attempt too, so idk why she decided to change it. Maybe your right about the build up thing, but still.
@@ie2428 i feel like she failed to recover from the growl, the word "feet" was growled, but if you compare to growled "ground" 's from later performances, she didn't growl there. It kinda sounded like a belt from later on in her career at least to me
@@ie2428 that's not a growl
She still sounds good either way. The dubbing just refines her gift!
Make it happen from Divas Live soounds 10000% better in the undubbed
She has defo been overdoing the dubbing over the years... Which is probably why people cut her so little slack as well. Shame really, she has nothing to prove ❤️
Who? A lot of singers think she’s great and I have seen some of them trying to sing her songs and their versions weren’t better than hers for sure.
These so-called undubbed videos are fake.
Many undubbed were actually great ❣️
Even the adventures of mimi lol
2:40 LMAO I WAS EATING-
@@mariahcareyunited mariah almost ran over that woman of the choir lmao
you were nice for not exposing mtv unplugged’s i’ll be there performance 😭
lol
@@TheLegendofMariah part 2? 🥰
You should’ve included the MTV Unplugged performance (and not just I’ll be there) - that is when I felt devastated and cheated as a fan… She had the same problem since forever and I dont mean the nodules, but the ego and the perfectionism… she was terrific and sooooo f*cking good (enough) without the dubbing… and I didnt read anything about the dubbing in her book. Did Mottola also impose the fraud?
@@McFred1065 well they wanted someone to March Whitney’s talent and the only way to do that is dubb
@@tisanbako lol or because it's televised they wanted to make sure it was perfect
Reading these comments and listening to the undubbed IBT... am I missing something? Because she sounds equally impressive in both dubbed and undubbed. Also, dubbing is pretty common practice (Usher, Beyonce, xtina...etc) all dub and tweak performances for an official release. They all sing very demanding songs back to back and the voice is bound to crack here or there. I think Mariah sounds brilliant in both btw. Also, Whitney said during the WYB interview that Mariah was a hell of a vocalist. I trust Nippy's judgment ❤😊
Her imperfections make her voice more perfect than dubbed one version her undubbed version are superior …I love her voice to death
Dubbed or undubbed, yo vocal still the best Mariah ....We love you
See when the audience is loud you have to dub sometimes, but nobody is clapping for Charmbracelet which is why she isn’t in this video
Charmbracelet is not as good as me, vocally, but much better than you, you are so tired, you can’t even support F5 hahah😂
(I’m obviously joking, I love you😘❤️)
@@mariahcareydaydreamera2526 u sure? Ur whistles are kinda trash sis 💅✨
@@joanquintero4670 Daydreams whistles are good and way better than Unstablebracelet
@@joanquintero4670 Wooow listen to my “Emotions” performance in Frankfurt. If you think my whistles are trash you must soo-oo-oo-ooo HIIIIIIIIIIIIGH
- real lambs will get that joke -
😂❤️😂
OML TEOM-
I wish she hadn't dubbed so much in the early days because it created an unrealistic expectation for her live vocals. People compare her current concerts to the 90s dubbed performances and technically she never sounded like that live. Besides, I prefer her raw vocals.
I somewhat agree. Apart from her prime 1993- 1996 . She sounded exactly the same even better in the daydream tour and msg. Same tone, better runs and ressonance. Its not the fact that she didnt sound like that live, i just think she was pushed to her limit and after a while it took a toll on her voice
The parts that were fixed here were minor mistakes or sound problems. The only one that was heavily edited and fixed was the MTV unplugged. I don't think it created unrealistic expectations. Her voice WAS out of this world. She aged, she toured a lot, she has her health problems. All of this affected her voice. Even if the "mistakes" were released, the public and the fans still would compare the old and the new voice.
This solidifies the fact that there is no perfect real-time vocalist ever. All dem legends are humans also.
Regine velasquez
@@sannybunny614 who? btw, no
@@batch9518 search engine is free
@@sannybunny614 I'm actually from Philippines, so I know her. By "WHO", I mean that I don't see regine anywhere close to Mariah the Queen
@@batch9518 is okay only true Lambs knew what you meant
I’m confused by some of these comments. The undubbed version would sound different if you’re in the audience recording. A phone doesn’t compare to professional recording equipment. She still sounds great to me. It’s little small differences but not liked she croaked or lost her pitch. And to hit the whistle register live is impressive
So do you know how they make this "dubbing" thing ?
I'm really curious ? Do they add it later ?
Is is basically like they "photoshop" the vocal ? Is she later adding a re-recorded version over the original show ? The craziest part is that for 100% of them I prefer the natural/undubbed version. A true Queen !! Thank you so much for this !
Yes, they fix those audio before it aired or released on DVD.
re-recorded new vocal, or using her vocal from other date (for DVD tour). Or just fix bad quality audio.
It can be done in many different ways. Sometimes they even have several takes to pick up parts from, so the final performance that we watxh is none of the ones Mariah originally sang. If they have the the raw vocals and a note is flat surely they can pitch it up a little bit and fix it. And of course the vocal can be filtered to sound smoother, like the usually do in the studio.
personally i like the undubbed ver. its just show shes human
the dubbed parts in tatou club is very noticable Xd since the quality changes
most of the undubbed in divas live wasnt really that far different from the dubbed version since she slayed that night XD
Many of these are better undubbed. As a perfectionist I get it though 😵💫
Plus the multi-take days must’ve been hard on her voice.
She still sound the same lol...The Audio Quality and Video Quality are just fixed.
Thank you! Videos like this are pathetic
4:41 😮😮😮😮 the Impossible Run turned out to be a impossible after all
True i loved that run…. She really set people to expect more of her on live performances…
It's not impossible. It's really easy tho. She probably forgot to do that
She did it in some of her rainbow tours
She did it live during the rainbow tour, a few times
This was very interesting AND for me, it explains a lot. A lot of people, including myself have been thinking that her voice drastically changed. No, Look at the vanishing performance, Mariah was cracking and off on certain parts and that was the beginning of her career. But back then, things were still covered up....in today's world, things are exposed more. Ti be perfectly honest, Mariah is still obviously talented, but her voice was never as perfect as some of us thought. No shade...just truth. She is able to do certain things with her voice and in the studio, she can go over it as many times as needed until it's perfect. When a singing live, if you screw up, you just gotta keep moving. Mariah's song writing blows me away more than her singing. Songs like Vision of love, I am Free, Fly like a bird...and there's no dubbing on those song writing skills.
The honestly and bitter truth Lambs don’t want to accept. Plus she adds some effects on her vocals
Agreed 💯
th-cam.com/video/CGryDDXQN8E/w-d-xo.html
As a lamb i agree with this. Mariah greatest strenght has always been her songwritting
The way you put things isn’t right. It wasn’t covered up, all singers have their live versions dubbed that is normal in the industry. I have seen Vanishing rehearsal and live performance and I think both were amazing performances. The challenge for Mariah is that she made her songs very hard to be replicated on live performances. Most of theses examples her voice is just more horsey in undubbed versions and in Emotions if I remember the 2nd take was "perfect” the whistle here is not the same like the undubbed version I have seen in which she sounded better.
Okay damn I didn’t know that it was this often during her prime too
Think it’s cause she did so many TV promotional performances, and TV love to dub
Some notes are like completely changed on the dubbed versions! However, I prefer the ones that are undubbed!
BTW I'm certain dubbing wasn't just done to MC's performances
It’s literally part of the music industry just like fixing everything after a movie is made to make it cohesive. There are dubbed performances of every singer alive, but people only focus on Mariah. It’s disappointing when soo called ‘Mariah support’ channels post shit like this making her look bad just for views. Unsubscribing
Does she dub her vocals immediately after leaving the place where she sings or idk the day after? How does it work? Never got it lmao
she really only does it for live tv performances. she usually just increases the sound when she pulls back from her mic and cover up rasp or slightly flat notes thats all
@@TheLegendofMariah so much for LIVE tv… but I also dont get how it works, sometimes it is normalizing volume (vocals vs instruments) but there are a zillion vocal corrections (like off keys, not hitting certain key and some other strained disasters). So the vocal fixes needed to be re recorded. Say MTV Unplugged, the leaks showed that even with the audience there they re recorded more than 2-3 times… then they re engineered and mixed everything the same
It’s dishonest. She shouldn’t have done it
@@TheLegendofMariah this. But also, she's not the only one who does it. It looks like it was some kind of protocol in TV shows. I don't think she herself was actually doing it, specially in the Mottola era.
I get the sense that she at least waits multiple hours so her voice isn’t as hoarse or whatever condition it was as in the performance before dubbing.
The reason why I hate DVD/VHS tapes. I was watching one of Queen's concerts yesterday, and the live record was so much different. I always prefer TV performances to VHS tapes, because they are telecasted as they are...without any sort of editing.
I think that some of this clips, the undubedd version is greater than dubbed! 😮 Her rasp gave emotion to the performs.
I can see why she dubbed those parts in Vanishing and VOL, but otherwise the undubbed all sounded great to me. Some pitchy moments but that's normal - nothing was THAT off.
Whatever!! Alll i know her voice is very unique No one in this entire world can dupliicate/immitate her voice.
In undubbed vision of love whistle was clearer
DUBBING FOR HER IS LIKE A LIFE SAVING SOME TIMES.
ON THE LIVE WITH PAVAROTTI CONCERT THE DUBBED VERSION HAVE BEEN SOOOO FIXED THAT IN MANY CASES THEY ADDED NOTES SHE DIDNT EVEN SING....LIKE IN THE WHISTLING NOTES OF MY ALL AT THE BEGINNING
Shes still sounds good
I feel bad for her. I want to give her a hug because she's been way too harsh on herself! MARIAH, YOU SOUND BEAUTIFUL IN THE UNDUBBED VOCAL CLIPS! So a little rasp here and there. We love that raspiness in your voice because it's part of who you are. I thought the squeaky, rough whistle registers here sounded so cute! It reminds me of when you told that story of how you'd wake up every morning as a kid and would say something in that same voice to your mom while all groggy. That's been a part of you forever. I wish you'd embrace it and not try to hide it! You're voice is just beautiful no matter what.
Vanishing - Dubbed
Vision Of Love - Undubbed
Make It Happen - Undubbed
Hero - Undubbed
Make it Happen - Undubbed
My All - Undubbed
Hero - Undubbed
Emotions - Dubbed
Can't Let Go - Dubbed
All I Want For Christmas Is You - Dubbed
Hero - Undubbed
3:43 perfect Mariah don't need dub this part 🥺🇧🇷
Make it happen dubbed was a CRIME !!!!
Notice how charmbraceletriah isn't here😌
How on earth did you find the first take undubbed performance of Unplugged?! 😍 It’s so cute hearing how shy she was before she came into full voice for the final recording! 🙌🏽
2:45 I always think of this as her cowardly lion hair 😩
Ermmm I love the undubbed versions! Sounded amazing!
Okay but the first one sounds exactly the same
The way the dubbed was better in 1990-1998 (minus Tatou Club - she was nervy or something that day)
I mean, sounds like the undubbed is more powerful. Seems like they just cleaned up the sound to not have it sound like a recording.
I love her face before she caught the mic singing My All (Pavarotti)
Need thanksgiving concert 1993 undubbed version🥺🤣☠️（？）
Hope one day we could get that
will ""lambs"" ever stop caring so much if a performance is lipped or not? it's not informative or interesting and just makes mariah look bad. every single time you search "dubbed" or "undubbed" on youtube there are only videos from lambs about mariah, while singers like beyonce (who uses prerecords vocals a lot) are nowhere to be seen. it's so annoying and just makes more people doubt every live performance of hers. it's such an obsession at this point, get a job.
She set the standard so high and it’s also interesting for fans to see if they can ID what’s live and not live
Thank you I am soo with you and not supporting any channels that do this bs
Me when I saw/heard she reached that note in make it happen 🤩🤯
Queen either way
Undubbed version still amazing to hear..legend!!!
Where do you get the undubbed versions of these performances?
There all on youtube😁
@@TheLegendofMariah What?? That's so cool, I didn't even know😭😭
@@TheLegendofMariah It's "They're all on TH-cam."
@@kallasmarker3319 lol.
@@kallasmarker3319 this aint english class let it slide babes
This is a normal practice . As long as she really can SING and a true SINGER and ARTISTE. Unlike some ….. 🤭
Different voices 😮😮😮
Half of the undubbed ones weren't even that bad. Perfection is overrated. I rather have something flawed but real, in the moment than a perfect studio vocal.
It was a great idea to dub the vocals is the 90's but in the current days it won't work anymore
Obviously because its the same voice why she doing it again? 😂
@@AlithAnar i am saying it won't work anymore because of the internet
0:36 even though that was strained I still like it
Mariah’s my love 😍 my baby💖 and my queen 👸👑 ~ SLAY MIMI! ~ 💖♥️💖♥️💖♥️ ILYSM MIMI!!!!💖💖
Why are so many of her performances dubbed? Wow. This is eye-opening.
Live TV industry
@@Joshua-cu1uz Mariah
@x123 many artists do a live recording with the band and play that version either in its entirety or bits and pieces during the concert, so it sounds "live". especially when they do world tours
@x123 yeah they don't dub as much as Mariah, they just use autotune to skip the dubbing process
@@Joshua-cu1uz I think it’s both the TV and Mariah, you can tell she’s extremely insecure, even now, I was looking at her interview recently with the chubby British guy and she looks super super uncomfortable with her dress. You can tell she can barely breath, I think she really needs to work on that and accept her flaws, cause otherwise she will always have to keep on dubbing her performances
Yes Tru some had been DUBBED!!! but at times MC still sounds 👍OR 😇😇ANGELIC☺☺🤗
4:29 so divine
6:25 😭😭
Mariah is not reallllll!!!
Shes a freak of nature
We love you queennnn ✨✨✨
RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YES YOU DID!!!!
Plot twist.
What if the dubbed is undubbed and the undubbed is editing.
Allover the years plenty of live GOOD VOCALS of MC STILL!!!!
Also,Look at using📱📱recordings ones are Real....TV shows udually or dvds were DUBBED!!
Emotions and mtv unplugged as a whole was weak vocally undubbed imo I think the dubbing saved certain moments especially emotions F6
For unplugged its not very unplugged
This makes me realize how ALL her live performances have been tweaked and are not truly live. But for her a singer born with nodules it doesn't really surprise me. Still stan her ❤
You’re not a fan, this is just a lame passive aggressive comment, every single professional performance from every single artist you see have been tweaked, its not just MC
Make me love her more than before.. 😍😍😍
She shouldn’t have done this dubbing thing, many of the performances she dubbed were actually not bad. It’s dishonest to dub and say it’s live. Whitney would never
Actually she would and she did
@@_iconriah no hate but out of interest what did Whitney Dubb
@@_iconriahno Whitney didn’t
Where do you find these undubbed official footages
I wonder where do they get those undubbed vocals
Can u do a part 2 with her home performances
I love dubbed ver
This is such a dumb ideia, the only thing that change in 90% of the clips is the audio quality.
1:51
The Best 👑
Videos like this are just Uber falsified! Many of these “dubbed “ moments are SIMPLY better audio quality. But using the word dubbed makes it sound like she lip synchs or goes back and “changes” the vocal which just isn’t true. Maybe in a few cases this has happened but it certainly isn’t all the time or for every performance as this video tries to depict.
Wait, she didn’t singing g5 in Vision of love???
Is there an undubbed version of the Shining Through the Rain concert?
How they dubbed all this performance??? Ive got curios and confuse 🙁 ? Is she sang tha song before performing live and when she fails, is the tech engineer will corrects it ??
yes they fix it after the performance
They make different takes and sometimes she record the vocals in the studio if they are not perfect
5:49 is an example, she haven’t actually performed that riff at the end, she added that after the concert was done.
where did u find the dubbed version for hero in italy 1999 with the opera singer? I can only see the undubbed on youtube. link?
th-cam.com/video/rjvTzFlHVRs/w-d-xo.html
He is the great Luciano Pavarotti, one of the greatest opera singers in history... he's not "the opera singer." So many uneducated people on TH-cam.
how does she do dub? I can't even hear the transitions
She dub on the studio? Right ?
@@katyapervaya yes
I can't speak for all of these but divas live wasn't dubbed. you just chose fan vs microphone feedback, if it was dubbed the make it happen rasp would be gone.
Why did she dub so many times in her prime?? Is it just her, or does everyone dub their live performances too?? Idk if I should be dissapointed or what.
Whitney didn’t. Mariah in her prime was pitchy and flat many times and she strained a lot too. She lowered her keys on unplugged and still struggled.
@@The_Truth- whitney did dubb some of her performances. All tv performances and live concerts have to be dubbed if they are being sold on VHS or DVD to silence out the audience noise and balance out the sound. People need to understand that dubbing is not always having the singer re sing all the vocals or playing the studio version over a live performance. A lot if the time with live performances the vocals from the mic feed from the performance are used and the sound engineer can increase the volume of what was picked up on the mic and balance the sound and or if needed correct pitch. Also Whitney often lowered the key to her songs. Way more than Mariah did. That doesnt make the song bad tho. And its not always up to the singer whether its dubbed or not its depends on where the performance is and record labels.
@@daintybowlegs1 Whitney didn’t lower her keys in her prime, she rearranged her songs which was smart on Whitney’s part because of this extensive tour dates. Mariah lowered her keys in her prime and still strained and struggled. Hence, mtv unplugged undubbed Mariah is pitchy, hitting flat notes, straining and struggling live. If they did a Whitney unplugged you would find an undubbed version the way you find Mariah’s. All tv performances are not dubbed . Example Whitney at the AMAs singing how will I know had technical issues nothing about that performance was dubbed.
Most singers dub their performances. It's a thing in music business.
@@bayduvegrolode4531 Celion Dion!
Mariah Carey no Divas 1998 já apresentava desgaste vocal
4:29 SO.THIS.IS.DUBBED??? 😳
More like just a difference in audio quality than being dubbed..
@LambilyXDaydream actually, that's pretty much what it is. Except for a few times when she did actually go flat or sharp.
yeah literally, i was like okay for some of them but when they got to make it happen for divas live the only difference was how it was recorded. It was live otherwise the so called dubbed version would be way better. some people need better ears.
People, please. These videos are fake. These videos are being made to discredit Mariah Carey, and if you are foolish to believe them, I'm sorry that there's no ending in this bs.
How did you get the undubbed footage ?
How to dub? ReSing in the studio?
Something like that
I don’t understand why everything is dubbed. Is there a reason this always happened?
Because she can’t match those studio vocals