I would have enjoyed the movie more if they found a way to basically extended the Monopoly scene to the rest of the film, just have the entire thing be Hugh Grant talking around in charming theological circles while being creepy and not even getting too action oriented. Make it a one room location, entirely dialogue oriented. Once the movie progressed passed those 2 ominous doors, I felt the writing seemed to lose it's way a little. I found myself disappointed in the outlandish reveals, as I felt Grant's character had been written too cleverly up until that point to warrant such a ridiculous motive/plan. I enjoyed the movie as a whole but adored the first half and found the second half just decent.
I was drawn in by their conversation. It is compelling to see how myths and religious origins are related and derived from each other. But Grant was not only discussing religion to challenge his guests, but to have them doubt their beliefs and feel lost. Then when they were in despair, he directed them face first into his trap. Then he will use them in future traps with new guests, and so on….
We got plenty of horror movies filled with gore, blood, and chases. It's so refreshing to see more psychologically mentally challenging horror that A24 usually nails. Need more! Sister Paxton was my favorite & stole the show for me. She was genuinely bubbly & fun!🙏🥰🌟 Mr. Reed: "With great power, comes great responsibility." Sister Paxton: "Spider-Man!"😂
Great video. I loved this movie. Particularly as a former mormon that went through a process to get out, this movie hit so many points of my personal journey.
As much as the thought of a dialog driven horror movie would instinctually turn some hardcore horror fans off, it works so well in this one. This was a film that I was really looking forward to, and I wasn't disappointed. It grabbed me early on and never let go. I agree that I could not picture anyone, but Hugh Grant in that role. I wasn't familiar with Sophie Thatcher or Chloe East going into this, but they were both amazing. Great review, as always.
I was waiting for you to review this one, Marianna. You have to give credit to Scott Beck and Bryan Woods as they wrote an amazing screenplay here and Hugh Grant, along with Sophie Thatcher and Chole East did an excellent job with their performances. Religion horror films are killing it this year with this one along with The First Omen and Immaculate.
I was blown away by Heretic. I wasn’t a huge fan of Beck and Woods previous films (apart from Haunt) but they did a great job, it has an awards worthy performance by Hugh Grant and the movie reminds me of The Wicker Man (the original) which I also love
Really looking forward to seeing this. I'm always fascinated by any atheist vs. theist dialogue. BTW, for a great religious horror thriller which kind of flew under the radar a few years ago, I highly recommend St. Maud. Well worth seeking out.
Great review. You captured the essence of the film without giving anything away. I have a theory about the ending that I want to discuss with someone! But none of my friends have seen it!!! Gah.
I literally just saw it! The dialogue with the discussion of religion was incredibly interesting and there are unsettling moments at times. The 3 leads were great. I first saw Sophie Thatcher in the incredibly underrated sci-fi movie from 2018, Prospect. She was so good in that movie with Pedro Pascal who is in a supporting role. I don’t think they needed Topher Grace for the role in this movie, but it was so small it didn’t matter.
I really liked the first part of Heretic but it did seem to become more conventional toward the end. The change in personality of Sister Paxton was a nice twist.
I said the same exact thing about John Kramer, aka Jigsaw! I love a philosophical villain! lol! I could actually see Tobin Bell a few years ago playing this part, but Hugh Grant was phenomenal. I haven't been scared watching any horror movie in decades! I loved this so much! So suspenseful.
Oh no worries I hope you're okay now! Take care ❤ I'm so excited to see it bit unfortunately it hasn't come out in my country yet and looks like they've cancelled it idk why 💔 @@ImpressionBlend
Unrelated comment, but I have heterochromia and my left eye is almost exactly the same as yours! Split down the middle with brown on one side and blue on the other. On a more related note…I just got home from seeing this film and absolutely loved it! Definitely worth a second watch
This movie looks so freaking good- thank you for not spoiling any of it! Even with all the trailer footage in your video it's still really hard to figure out what's going on.
By the way, i bought Oddity and Exhuma as you spoke about them and i was not disappointed. There was a sense of dread and fear in both and i thoroughly enjoyed both. Thank you.
Great review thanks Marianna. I really liked this movie but my girlfriend liked it more than me. Our opinions split mostly about the ending where she (like you) enjoyed the twist while I thought it seemed like a reach for something interesting.
Couldn't agree more. Sinister is definitely the keyword here. Watched it yesterday. Loved the twist and turns trying to predict where it was heading (; P.S. Glad you got over the bug and Lol about your end comment, ngl may be less at ease at scented candle and book lover domiciles from now on 😅
Grant was masterful (he should be in the Oscar race IMO, but genre bias will probably kill any chance he has), and his costars were also very impressive. Enjoyed the first half more, but overall I thought it was satisfying.
Just viewed the film. Still processing ⏳But couldn’t agree more with your review. I’d add that the set designer really did amazing work with this film!
Was anyone else a bit lost about what year it was until Hugh said something about 2017? I don’t know with the ending I felt that this one was just ok. Great dialogue tho!
The very first scene made me think that the subtext of the whole movie was about sexual gratification. Barnes knows something to be true, then Paxton is "converted" because Barnes saved her with her actions and words. "Does size matter" is substituted for belief vs disbelief and the truth hurts. I thought of a title of a prince song came to me in the cage scene. Antagonist's bringing up polygamy then the multiple victims that are present begs the question of size equals control. Primates are not monogamous, the position of alpha is presented as the center of the horror, yet the protagonists seek a spiritual alpha.
Felt attacked as a big fan of books? That's unexpected, but I haven't seen it yet, still not in my country, but really wanna see it and now I'll be on the lookout of what could be an "attack" to book lovers hehe...
I just saw this today! and I really liked it. I found it to feel alot like Speak No Evil, while being a completely different story, and in my opinion a better movie. I would still put Kinds of Kindness as my favorite movie I've seen this year, and Heretic and the Substance neck and neck for 2nd. Then I'd have a battle between Blink Twice and Speak No Evil after that, but I dont see every movie just the ones that look interesting to me.
Without having seen it yet, the Hugh Grant character to me seems like one Alfred Hitchcock would have had in one of his movies. An individual who to the outside world seems well mannered and ingratiating, but there within lurks the darkness of his soul.
I've watched this movie a few times now and I can't see Hugh\ Mr Reeds hair any wetter to get the bike lock at any time from when he greeted them at the door to the first room where he was talking about polygamy to the 2 rooms of belief and disbelief so that's a lie or wasn't shown on camera very well as his clothes didn't even seem damp show me his damp clothes and his wet hair>??? Also without the door interruption that was outside his control who would he have been able to perform his magic trick in the basement???? Nobody mentions this at all!!!!
He also wasn’t gone from the missionaries long enough to have performed the tasks claimed, nor could that floor trap door trick work in the silence of the room without the gals being aware.
@@SumDumGy also what's the significance of the robes or grim reaper behind the girls when they look behind them before Grant puts on the projector show about Christ???
Liked this movie! I had been anticipating it for a while. I liked the conversation on religion. It was unlike the other religious horror movies for sure.
I saw this Thursday and really enjoyed it. Imagine building a home with the sole purpose of entrapping and manipulating missionaries in mind. One thing did bother me early on is I felt the missionaries were experiencing a level of discomfort too early over things Mr. Reed was saying to them in their initial conversations. I don’t feel that discomfort was warranted yet. He seemed to me to be saying things that were innocent and appropriate for the discussion.
Like I said, I was only bringing up "Saw" because of Mr. Reed, not because it's a similar movie. If we're talking what it reminded me off - "Martyrs", "Barbarian", and "Speak No Evil"
Hahaha🤫🤔🙊Question.....Everything!? Alright. ▪︎Eamon's mom, is changing batteries to something in Sing street.....What is it? A flashlight? ▪︎Just as, left field of a question as, why two sisters are talking about condoms, at the beginning. ▪︎Just as, left field as why sister paxton is watching porn in the first place. ▪︎Guess, everything's fair game, right? ▪︎All in all, can't wait to see Mr.Grant in this. His role as fletcher, helped him prepare for playing this dodgy character🎬🎭lol.
To keep it real the first half was intriguing but it all fell apart towards the end no spoilers but it’s cliche ending I’ve seen so many times in so many movies that part doesn’t fit inside of a A24 movie movie had potential
I found the intellectual banter grow tedious very quickly and it never grabbed me after the initial start of the horror. I don't think the movie commits to its own ideas and the script reflects a certain insecurity. Personally, I found Don't Breathe to be much more thrilling.
It is one of the stupidest films I've ever seen it was as stupid as the turning and it made no sense and it did not explain anything and you just left me confused
![ละลาย (LALALYE) - DAOU PITTAYA ต้าห์อู๋ พิทยา [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wo6r9TgausI/mqdefault.jpg)
I could have watched a whole movie with the focus being just the subject matter & dialogue minus the horror elements. Saw it today & it was that good.
Same here! The conversation was fascinating
Same! So tightly written
I agree. A dialogue-heavy movie like "My Dinner With Andre".
--
I would have enjoyed the movie more if they found a way to basically extended the Monopoly scene to the rest of the film, just have the entire thing be Hugh Grant talking around in charming theological circles while being creepy and not even getting too action oriented. Make it a one room location, entirely dialogue oriented. Once the movie progressed passed those 2 ominous doors, I felt the writing seemed to lose it's way a little. I found myself disappointed in the outlandish reveals, as I felt Grant's character had been written too cleverly up until that point to warrant such a ridiculous motive/plan. I enjoyed the movie as a whole but adored the first half and found the second half just decent.
I was drawn in by their conversation. It is compelling to see how myths and religious origins are related and derived from each other. But Grant was not only discussing religion to challenge his guests, but to have them doubt their beliefs and feel lost. Then when they were in despair, he directed them face first into his trap. Then he will use them in future traps with new guests, and so on….
We got plenty of horror movies filled with gore, blood, and chases. It's so refreshing to see more psychologically mentally challenging horror that A24 usually nails. Need more!
Sister Paxton was my favorite & stole the show for me. She was genuinely bubbly & fun!🙏🥰🌟
Mr. Reed:
"With great power, comes great responsibility."
Sister Paxton: "Spider-Man!"😂
Great video. I loved this movie. Particularly as a former mormon that went through a process to get out, this movie hit so many points of my personal journey.
Couldn't agree more! might get some blueberry candles as xmas gifts :)
I wonder how the scented candle industry is doing after this ))
As much as the thought of a dialog driven horror movie would instinctually turn some hardcore horror fans off, it works so well in this one. This was a film that I was really looking forward to, and I wasn't disappointed. It grabbed me early on and never let go. I agree that I could not picture anyone, but Hugh Grant in that role. I wasn't familiar with Sophie Thatcher or Chloe East going into this, but they were both amazing. Great review, as always.
I particularly enjoyed the end credit song choice - its call-backs to the dialogue, in a couple ways, made me smile.
I was waiting for you to review this one, Marianna. You have to give credit to Scott Beck and Bryan Woods as they wrote an amazing screenplay here and Hugh Grant, along with Sophie Thatcher and Chole East did an excellent job with their performances. Religion horror films are killing it this year with this one along with The First Omen and Immaculate.
Personally, I didn't love "Immaculate", but "The First Omen" was great!
I was very put off by “The First Omen” and found “Immaculate” incredibly bland.
I was blown away by Heretic. I wasn’t a huge fan of Beck and Woods previous films (apart from Haunt) but they did a great job, it has an awards worthy performance by Hugh Grant and the movie reminds me of The Wicker Man (the original) which I also love
Really looking forward to seeing this. I'm always fascinated by any atheist vs. theist dialogue. BTW, for a great religious horror thriller which kind of flew under the radar a few years ago, I highly recommend St. Maud. Well worth seeking out.
I've been aware of this film for awhile, but didn't know what to think before the reviews came out/ Have to see it soon.
Great review. You captured the essence of the film without giving anything away. I have a theory about the ending that I want to discuss with someone! But none of my friends have seen it!!! Gah.
I literally just saw it! The dialogue with the discussion of religion was incredibly interesting and there are unsettling moments at times. The 3 leads were great. I first saw Sophie Thatcher in the incredibly underrated sci-fi movie from 2018, Prospect. She was so good in that movie with Pedro Pascal who is in a supporting role. I don’t think they needed Topher Grace for the role in this movie, but it was so small it didn’t matter.
Sophie Thatcher is awesome in Yellowjackets, cannot wait to see her in this!!
I really liked the first part of Heretic but it did seem to become more conventional toward the end. The change in personality of Sister Paxton was a nice twist.
I said the same exact thing about John Kramer, aka Jigsaw!
I love a philosophical villain! lol!
I could actually see Tobin Bell a few years ago playing this part, but Hugh Grant was phenomenal. I haven't been scared watching any horror movie in decades! I loved this so much! So suspenseful.
FINALLY!! I've been waiting for your review on it since it came out as I know you're a huge horror fan!
Sorry, I got sick and lost my voice, couldn’t talk lol
Oh no worries I hope you're okay now! Take care ❤
I'm so excited to see it bit unfortunately it hasn't come out in my country yet and looks like they've cancelled it idk why 💔
@@ImpressionBlend
Excellent review Marianna. So glad to hear that you really enjoyed this film. It’s definitely on my watchlist for sure.👍
Unrelated comment, but I have heterochromia and my left eye is almost exactly the same as yours! Split down the middle with brown on one side and blue on the other.
On a more related note…I just got home from seeing this film and absolutely loved it! Definitely worth a second watch
This movie looks so freaking good- thank you for not spoiling any of it! Even with all the trailer footage in your video it's still really hard to figure out what's going on.
By the way, i bought Oddity and Exhuma as you spoke about them and i was not disappointed. There was a sense of dread and fear in both and i thoroughly enjoyed both. Thank you.
You're very welcome!
I can’t wait to watch this! And one location setting are my favorite to watch!
I saw it today and couldn't agree with your review more. You nailed it.
Great review thanks Marianna. I really liked this movie but my girlfriend liked it more than me. Our opinions split mostly about the ending where she (like you) enjoyed the twist while I thought it seemed like a reach for something interesting.
Can't wait to check this one out!
Couldn't agree more. Sinister is definitely the keyword here. Watched it yesterday. Loved the twist and turns trying to predict where it was heading (;
P.S. Glad you got over the bug and Lol about your end comment, ngl may be less at ease at scented candle and book lover domiciles from now on 😅
Definitely going to see this one now. Will try to catch both this and Anora in the near future
Finally some good writing and convincing dialogue. I’ll watch it.
Great review. Was thinking about if it’s worth a try. Sounds promising 👍
Thank you! Definitely worth a try
@ 👍
Grant was masterful (he should be in the Oscar race IMO, but genre bias will probably kill any chance he has), and his costars were also very impressive. Enjoyed the first half more, but overall I thought it was satisfying.
Hugh Grant + Horror = Splendid Scares! Had a fun time with Heretic, great review!
Just viewed the film. Still processing ⏳But couldn’t agree more with your review.
I’d add that the set designer really did amazing work with this film!
Totally agree, about set design!
Was anyone else a bit lost about what year it was until Hugh said something about 2017?
I don’t know with the ending I felt that this one was just ok. Great dialogue tho!
I wish Heretic worked for me the way it did for you and others but it just turned out fine for me. I wanted more from the basement scenes
Oddly, I could have done no basement all dialogue and mind games with this one
I will admit, the dialogue was on point
Great review as always. I agree with you on all aspects, even though I thought the ending got a bit tropey but the ride is worth it
Thank you!
I love the film except for most of the last ½ hr.
Also, I classify it as a psychological thriller rather than horror.
Loved this. Loved all three leads.
Hugh Grant is so Charming how could you resist. He was the perfect villain.
Not sure if it's coming to my local, but it's definitly on my radar.
Just seen this...and my brain hurts. They should've played "Losing my Religion" by R.E.M. to make it close to perfect!
The very first scene made me think that the subtext of the whole movie was about sexual gratification. Barnes knows something to be true, then Paxton is "converted" because Barnes saved her with her actions and words.
"Does size matter" is substituted for belief vs disbelief and the truth hurts. I thought of a title of a prince song came to me in the cage scene.
Antagonist's bringing up polygamy then the multiple victims that are present begs the question of size equals control. Primates are not monogamous, the position of alpha is presented as the center of the horror, yet the protagonists seek a spiritual alpha.
Can't wait to see this new entry into the horror genre!
Felt attacked as a big fan of books? That's unexpected, but I haven't seen it yet, still not in my country, but really wanna see it and now I'll be on the lookout of what could be an "attack" to book lovers hehe...
Thanks for the recommendation!
The first third of the movie was actually quite compelling and original. Then, it went downhill. Especially at the end...
I just saw this today! and I really liked it. I found it to feel alot like Speak No Evil, while being a completely different story, and in my opinion a better movie. I would still put Kinds of Kindness as my favorite movie I've seen this year, and Heretic and the Substance neck and neck for 2nd. Then I'd have a battle between Blink Twice and Speak No Evil after that, but I dont see every movie just the ones that look interesting to me.
Oh yea, a better remake of “Speak No Evil” than the actual remake of “Speak No Evil” plus a bit of “Martyrs” and a bit of “Barbarian”.
@@ImpressionBlend did you like "Kinds of Kindness?"
A grippingly good movie, didn't notice time passing! 5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Without having seen it yet, the Hugh Grant character to me seems like one Alfred Hitchcock would have had in one of his movies. An individual who to the outside world seems well mannered and ingratiating, but there within lurks the darkness of his soul.
Seeing very mixed reviews about this but now way more interested.
Really? Most of the reviews I've seen were very positive
Not a Hugh Grant fan, but he did pretty good in the movie
I would have liked to learn more of Mr reeds backstory
I've watched this movie a few times now and I can't see Hugh\ Mr Reeds hair any wetter to get the bike lock at any time from when he greeted them at the door to the first room where he was talking about polygamy to the 2 rooms of belief and disbelief so that's a lie or wasn't shown on camera very well as his clothes didn't even seem damp show me his damp clothes and his wet hair>??? Also without the door interruption that was outside his control who would he have been able to perform his magic trick in the basement???? Nobody mentions this at all!!!!
He also wasn’t gone from the missionaries long enough to have performed the tasks claimed, nor could that floor trap door trick work in the silence of the room without the gals being aware.
@@SumDumGy also what's the significance of the robes or grim reaper behind the girls when they look behind them before Grant puts on the projector show about Christ???
@ Good question. The curtain that shrouded them is lifted to see the statues underneath but what the significance is I do not know.
let us know what you think of the new silo season 2 eps and The Day of The Jackal
Liked this movie! I had been anticipating it for a while. I liked the conversation on religion. It was unlike the other religious horror movies for sure.
First movie I have seen where the protagonist is from the place I live.
I thought it was pretty good. I didn't hate it but kind of loved it. The dialogue was very good and I agree Hugh Grant was very good.
I saw this Thursday and really enjoyed it. Imagine building a home with the sole purpose of entrapping and manipulating missionaries in mind.
One thing did bother me early on is I felt the missionaries were experiencing a level of discomfort too early over things Mr. Reed was saying to them in their initial conversations. I don’t feel that discomfort was warranted yet. He seemed to me to be saying things that were innocent and appropriate for the discussion.
To go from 65 to this... the range on Beck and Woods needs to be studied.
We’re just going to pretend they had nothing to do with “65”, and forget that movie exists
I would lump it under Catholiwood, along with Dogma, Stigmata and The DaVinci Code.
Remind me of the movie Barbarian more than it did Saw.
Like I said, I was only bringing up "Saw" because of Mr. Reed, not because it's a similar movie. If we're talking what it reminded me off - "Martyrs", "Barbarian", and "Speak No Evil"
Hahaha🤫🤔🙊Question.....Everything!? Alright.
▪︎Eamon's mom, is changing batteries to something in Sing street.....What is it? A flashlight?
▪︎Just as, left field of a question as, why two sisters are talking about condoms, at the beginning.
▪︎Just as, left field as why sister paxton is watching porn in the first place.
▪︎Guess, everything's fair game, right?
▪︎All in all, can't wait to see Mr.Grant in this. His role as fletcher, helped him prepare for playing this dodgy character🎬🎭lol.
To keep it real the first half was intriguing but it all fell apart towards the end no spoilers but it’s cliche ending I’ve seen so many times in so many movies that part doesn’t fit inside of a A24 movie movie had potential
Blueberry pie
It looks great.
Immaculate is also Preety good for a religious horror.
It looks awesome and very interesting, specially dealing with a subject that is so criticized by people unwilling to have their beliefs challenged
No one minds having it challenged, what we mind is having it misrepresented.
hugh grant really takes some fun roles and he doesn't get enough credit for that
If Oscars didn't hate horror he wold be in the Best Actor conversation this year
For the algorithm
I wouldn’t consider this a horror movie.
Pls see Tha Day of the Jackal. Awesome
Will check it out, thank you for the recommendation!
Not really a horror film to me, though some of the scenes are horrifying.
as a gamer since the 90s, wut?
Haha, not THAT Heretic )) I see you
@@ImpressionBlend haha, love the recognition
I walked out of the theater. Tedious and boring.
I found the intellectual banter grow tedious very quickly and it never grabbed me after the initial start of the horror. I don't think the movie commits to its own ideas and the script reflects a certain insecurity. Personally, I found Don't Breathe to be much more thrilling.
I LIKED THUA FUKN THE EBDUBG Wasgood byt hg reasoningas a vukkan was excekkebt duakiguegave him away earkt as thesecond girl figured him oit
It is one of the stupidest films I've ever seen it was as stupid as the turning and it made no sense and it did not explain anything and you just left me confused
We need to talk about you being so damn cute
No, we need to talk about Kevin
We don't talk about Kevin... or Bruno
Relax.....She, be married.
Not a Hugh Grant fan, but he did pretty good in the movie