With Corelli you just want to sing along even though you know you can't and you fall on your knees with admiration. With Del Monaco you are just pressed into your seat and can't move
@@joerngrossblotekamp What you say may be true, but in fact this video is doing exactly that. But, it is not asking which is the best, but who you prefer, as judging singers is a very subjective matter. Personally, I prefer Corelli.
@@leslieepstein4700 Yes, of course it‘s very subjective. I answered to the comment saying one „is the best“. It didn’t say „I prefer…“. I would never discuss a personal preference.
Two absolute Titans of the greatest tenors in history.During this period when Del Monaco, Corelli and Di Stefano were at the top of their game, it was a golden era of riches for Italy, and apart from Pavarotti, has not been seen or heard since, and probably never will unfortunately...
TWO THE GREATEST TENORS, AND VOICE OF ALL TIME, TWO LEGENDS. MARIO, FRANKO, FRANKO MARIO, THE GREATEST EVER LIVED. I AM A TENOR FOR MY SELF. BUT WHEN I LISTEN CORELLI ,AND DEL MONACO, I CAN'T SING ONE WEEK.
....If I could hear them both together, I would. What glorious times! Today only mediocrity reigns. A chorus of all current tenors couldn’t compete with those two giants. FC spoke at MDM funerali.
I prefer Del Monaco! (But i love also Corelli). Both great, but in this video Mario Del Monaco sounds like a bariton, his voice is so deep and marvellous.
@@ladivinacallas2507 non è proprio così. Hanno entrambi delle voci di timbro baritonale, e Del monaco non canta sempre come un baritono. Canta da stupendo tenore lirico spinto,i suoi acuti sono lame. Anche Corelli è un lirico spinto, con una voce un poco meno estesa, ma più duttile che gli rende di più in qualche passaggio. Io amo di più Del Monaco, per tanti motivi, di conoscenza, di estensione, di tecnica e di emotività. Questo non vuol dire che un altro non debba preferire Corelli per i motivi suoi.
@@Василиса-р5л @Василиса хм. Не слышал я тряски, может слух ещё не так развит. Зато я слышал, какие у него верхние ноты свободные и мощные. А у Дель Монако как-то очень сплюснуто звучит.
@@Василиса-р5л Спасибо) Возможно, частое, может, я привык и поэтому не обращаю внимания. Писали, что у него в начале карьеры была проблема с этим, а потом, вроде, он это исправил. А почему у меня ощущение, что у Дель Монако верхняя нота сплюснутая? И не только у него, а у многих, особенно, на звуке "э"? Где-то писали, что в этой песне это из-за произношения итальянского "te" как "тэй", а Корелли поёт просто "тэ" и поэтому так и было правильно, как в первом варианте. Я думал, что это связано с техникой.
Two fabulous tenors, surely among the greatest of recorded history. Don't seem to be any of similar vocal and emotional quality these days...at least not to my knowledge. Would love to discover any????
One thing is for certain we will never hear voices like these again. The voices of the current opera singers can't even be remotely compared to these legendary Italian tenors. Their power,their piercing resonance and timbre just give me chills. Greazie mille for sharing this.
It is very difficult to compare this way, there are so many factors involved: Mike placement, theater size and acoustics, quality of recording equipment, etc. Needless to say it would be GREAT!! to have these two performing today. So we agree?
No voice to me is as thrilling as Del Monaco's mountain rocketing voice, god it's epic, earth shattering, dramatic, passionate. I get many praise Corelli more and hail him as the greatest, his color and technique, but for me he doesn't shake my core as Mario, I can't imagine what it must've been like to be at the same venue as him
Due pilastri della Lirica, introvabili al giorno d'oggi e, se continua così, sarà sempre più difficile trovarne due così che, lì somiglino, almeno un po'. Poi, tra F. C. e MDM, ormai, da sempre, il mio preferito è, in assoluto Franco Corelli. Tutti e due dovevano gestire e domare un'enormità di voce e, Franco, con lo studio e la tecnica ci è riuscito come nessun altro tra i tenori. Sembrava non sforzasse per niente, neppure negli acuti pieni, impressionanti e sempre sicuri e senza incertezze. Comunque, tutti e due da rimpiangere. GRANDI
I would say both have impressive vocal techniques; Corelli clearly can make a bigger sound to make all the drama Del Monaco it's making but Corelli probably knew more drama was not necessary for this song of love, he sings with love and passion Del Monaco sings this and everything else to show what he could do with his voice.
....glad to have had them both on earth. Different voices, both perfect in it´s way. Distinguishable, I would never prefer one alone. Mi piace moltissimo
Don't make me choose,per favore.Both are among the greatest Italian tenors of all time. Che bellissima. Grazie mille for sharing these two marvellous voices with us.
In this comparison, it's hard to decide. Corelli, however, seems to hit the high notes with less effort than Del Monaco. But I could listen to either of them all day.....
@@alessandromoccia471..... Io non scelgo nessuno.... perché difronte a questi semidei la scelta è ardua ed imbarazzante. Amo ed adoro Franco Corelli per la sua eleganza ed il suo modo di cantare..... poi mi giro dall'altra parte e trovo Mario Del Monaco che amo ed è un portento stravolgente ed un trascinatore da brivido... a chi dare il cuore???
Both are fantastic. But hearing them side by side like this, I was surprised that in my opinion, I actually preferred Del Monaco. His voice seemed a bit more consistent throughout his range, whereas Correlli's high seemed a bit more pushed.
Hm. I hear Corelli's top note here more freely than Monaco's. Del Monaco's sounds more flattened. And there's a few comments here where people heard the same.
Love this type of video, so thank you! With two opera singers at this level of skill you can go into an analysis of what each does better than the other etc. but it really comes down to one's individual preference, doesn't it? What do we each value in a particular song or passage and who gives us that value? How one responds viscerally to the sound is also individual. The huge, rich sound of Del Monaco does it for me, if it comes down to sound alone. But Corelli may have been the one who showed the greatest vocal versatility.
Ho avuto la fortuna di ascoltarli entrambi dal vivo, due voci eccezionali che davano emozioni profondissime, impossibile per me esprimere, nello specifico, una preferenza. Se posso allargare il discorso, dico però che l'interpretazione di questa aria che mi emoziona maggiormente è quella di Caruso.
It's like when Corelli goes into his high notes his throat goes into a more neutral position and more open and then the notes flow so much smoother when Delmonico goes up it's almost like something's being clenched or squeezed in his vowel becomes more of an e and Corelli is more of an ah and it flows very freely. Corelli also seems to have a very calm unstruggled facial expression anytime he sings.
I agree. MDM uses a dipthong vowel sound to push the voice forward in the face, whereas Corelli's voice is perfectly placed and completely open, with such a wholesome rounded sound. Franco Corelli's technique is wonderful and there is nothing like the pushing going on that there is in MDM's performance; it is a Neapolitan Folk song, not Otello's Act 1 Esultate! However, I do not wish to denigrate MDM, he posses an extraordinary instrument the like of which we would love to hear again today.
Del Monaco used a lot of physical strength when he sang, but did not squeeze. MDM's voice was actually larger than Corelli's, but both voices could fill any opera house.
@@aaron.anchored.in.christ well maybe-up to B flat-his B was hit or miss-and there was no C. Corelli's upper extension is unparalleled for a voice of that size
@@labienus9968 Del Monaco had a solid C. Arguably less free than Corelli’s, but he had a great one. th-cam.com/video/SFL-HhPXMZM/w-d-xo.html Go to 3 minutes 28 seconds
Preferisco Corelli, ha una voce più calda, più piena. Monaco per me è troppo acuta. CORELLI LO ASCOLTATO QUANDO IL BABBO METTEVA I SUOI DISCHI, ANCHE DI DEL Monaco, ma già da bembina mi piaceva più lui. Questi sono due grandissimi tenori, che hanno fatto onore all'italiana. Perché eravamo emigranti in Colombia. 👍👏👏💕🎶🎶👍🌹
Si uno toma al arte como competencia olimpica, es porque no lo siente, no lo disfruta. Demos gracias a la vida por Del Mónaco y por Corelli y por todos los que como ellos vivirán por siempre y para siempre.
@@jarto10 They weren't really friends until much later. MDM mocked FC's early vibrato but soon feared Corelli-who wouldn't?-and never came back to the Met after FC's debut. MDM was the real Melocchi student, Corelli took a few lesson with him they say, but he adapted the lowered larynx realizing the danger of inflexibility, and inability to sing softy that became MDM's fate
@@labienus9968 MDM could sing softly and there are countless examples to prove it. He did what he chose to do. The argument that he couldn’t sing softly is tired old shtick.
Franco Corelli consistently delivers amazing performances, but in this particular song, Mario Del Monaco conveyed a heightened sense of passion and emotion.
Согласен, оба великолепны и у каждого были свои арии, в которых они были лучшими. Но конечно сила голоса Mario del Monaco поражает, странно как в оперных театрах окна не разлетались от энергии его голоса.
Не будем отрицать , что Галина Вишневская одна из величайших оперных певиц современности. Она пела с Дель Монако и Корелли в Ла Скала. В интервью она сказала : "Я никогда и нигде больше не слышала такого потрясающего голоса , как у Франко Корелли".
Оба потрясающие тенора. Один лирический другой глубокий драматический. Ничего лучшего в мире нет чем прекрасные голоса итальянцев и их бель канто. Кому-то повезло больше и он прожил длинную жизнь и творческую карьеру, а некотопые покинули этот мир , успев навсегда остаться молодыми и прекрасными.
😂🤣😂 Автор ролика, явно, фанат Марио дель Монако. Наложил на его голос эффект, чтоб казался мощнее, а голос Корелли, наоборот, заглушил. Браво 😂🤣😂👋👋 современной музыкальной аппаратуре! А если серьёзно, то для того, чтобы сравнить голос двух певцов, нужно использовать запись с одной студии и одного года. Ещё, желательно, точно убедиться, что записывали на одну и ту же аппаратуру. Поэтому данный ролик не даёт точного представления о мощности голосов этих вокалистов. Это, простите, мухлёж.
The ecoustics are different. Corelli is singing in a television studio, Del Monaco in a theater. Both were incredible, but my heart belongs to Corelli.
La differenza degli acuti tra Corelli e Del Monaco:il primo è più pungente perchè negli acuti la sua voce è più fine,con meno armonici...il secondo ha gli acuti pieni di armonici,quindi risulta più grande,ma ha meno punta...salve
The differences in the recording is not fair to Corelli, so Del Monaco sounds much better. But if they both were recorded with the same equipment and acoustic then it would be fair. However I still believe this aria suits Del Monaco better, and Corelli in other arias.
![[ TEASER ] เงาะป่า - วงL.กฮ. | TMG RECORD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M4ObdFfcPww/mqdefault.jpg)
This is like asking “do you prefer a Ferrari or Lamborghini?“
Fiat Punto. :D
Yes, MDM he is like Lamborghini, tractor 🚜 😂
More like do you prefer an Alfa Romeo or an Abrams tank. Different types of vehicle.
Corelli is Ferrari and del Monaco lamborghini ? Your righ they are great voices and different qualities each other !
Or the C8 Corvette
deux très grands mais je préfère Corelli
Corelli's voice has charm and sublme tibre
One is a great spinto tenor and the other is a great dramatic tenor. Both of them are amazing in their own way ❤️💯🔥👑
With Corelli you just want to sing along even though you know you can't and you fall on your knees with admiration.
With Del Monaco you are just pressed into your seat and can't move
That is the most honest truth!!
Прекрасно сказано!
Wow! You just described what i felt! :)
Mario 100 / 10 e lode
Corelli"s voice is far more beautiful!
Corelli,s voice s sublime❤
Corelli....perché è più 'innamorato'. Del Monaco sembra più un condottiero in guerra. Comunque grandissimi entrambi.wowwww
Franco Corelli is by far the best. But both of them are excellent
A spinto tenor can hardly be compared to a heroic one in the meaning of who is better.
@@joerngrossblotekamp What you say may be true, but in fact this video is doing exactly that. But, it is not asking which is the best, but who you prefer, as judging singers is a very subjective matter. Personally, I prefer Corelli.
@@leslieepstein4700 Yes, of course it‘s very subjective. I answered to the comment saying one „is the best“. It didn’t say „I prefer…“. I would never discuss a personal preference.
High c Corelli all the way, Corelli is just effortless
Corelli
Impossibile scegliere, i Dei bisogna soltanto ascoltarli ,ammirarli,e ringraziarli delle meravigliose emozioni che ci hanno regalato.
Concordo pienamente qua non si tratta di scegliere ma di ammirarli tutti e due
Two absolute Titans of the greatest tenors in history.During this period when Del Monaco, Corelli and Di Stefano were at the top of their game, it was a golden era of riches for Italy, and apart from Pavarotti, has not been seen or heard since, and probably never will unfortunately...
Mai dire mai... i talenti arriveranno! Saluti
Come dimenticare Tenori con la "t" maiuscola come Bonisolli, Cecchele, e Giacomini?
Corelli❤
BOTH OF THEM ARE GREAT WITH GREAT SOUND AND GREAT VOCAL TECHNIQUE AND TONE OF VOICE!!!! NO COMPARISON!!! BOTH OF THEM ARE LEGENDS FOR LIFE!!!
Corelli for me.
Mario Del Monaco. The KING of Tenors.
Franco Corelli 😘
Ma ci rendiamo conto a che livelli sono arrivati questi due fenomeni. Impressionanti.
I like both of them ❤️
You cannot compare greatness Amen and gloria hallelujah!!!
Different Tenors, different voices. Del Monaco y Corelli, wonderful tenors.
And different acoustic conditions .
Impossibile scegliere la voce piu‘ bella, perche’ entrambe bellissime. Ma se lo fosse, sceglierei Del Monaco.
Corelli had better high notes, and better legato. He could sing high B flat pianissimo without changing voice to falsetto.
I agree with you ! One should enjoy them, each in his own right, and not keep comparing.
Mario .n*.UNO
TWO THE GREATEST TENORS, AND VOICE OF ALL TIME, TWO LEGENDS. MARIO, FRANKO, FRANKO MARIO, THE GREATEST EVER LIVED. I AM A TENOR FOR MY SELF. BUT WHEN I LISTEN CORELLI ,AND DEL MONACO, I CAN'T SING ONE WEEK.
Корелли!!!
Los dos Grandes entre los grandes. Difícil comparar por tanto talento junto. Yo me quedo con Franco Corelli.
Corelli is effortless
My God!!!!!!! I was born in the wrong decades! Corelli makes you marvel and Del Monaco makes you weep.
Both of course. It's like asking "do you prefer magnificence or greatness"
both simply marvelous!!
as performers they are both perfect. But I believed more in Franco's love story this time
Due inarrivabili. Quanto ci mancano.
....If I could hear them both together, I would. What glorious times! Today only mediocrity reigns. A chorus of all current tenors couldn’t compete with those two giants. FC spoke at MDM funerali.
Corelli! Simply Corelli
Bravissimi 👍anche se differenti
I prefer Del Monaco! (But i love also Corelli). Both great, but in this video Mario Del Monaco sounds like a bariton, his voice is so deep and marvellous.
Los dos son muy chingones .
Valter Berardi Mario del Monaco often sounds like bariton, not only in this video.
@@ladivinacallas2507 non è proprio così. Hanno entrambi delle voci di timbro baritonale, e Del monaco non canta sempre come un baritono. Canta da stupendo tenore lirico spinto,i suoi acuti
sono lame.
Anche Corelli è un lirico spinto, con una voce un poco meno estesa, ma più duttile che gli rende di più in qualche passaggio.
Io amo di più Del Monaco, per tanti motivi, di conoscenza, di estensione, di tecnica e di emotività.
Questo non vuol dire che un altro non debba preferire Corelli per i motivi suoi.
Del Monico was a big lyric and Corelli was a spinto,/dramatico....
@@jimbuxton2187 What?
Очень сложно кого-то из них выделить. У обоих высочайший уровень. Дух захватывает!
Согласен! ТУт нет лучшего, как между Джильи и Скипой например, но есть только предпочтения
у Корелли голос трясется. Жидковат он против дель Монако
@@Василиса-р5л @Василиса хм. Не слышал я тряски, может слух ещё не так развит. Зато я слышал, какие у него верхние ноты свободные и мощные. А у Дель Монако как-то очень сплюснуто звучит.
@@75bg90 я не люблю такое частое вибрато, как у Корелли. Все у вас со слухом нормально
@@Василиса-р5л Спасибо) Возможно, частое, может, я привык и поэтому не обращаю внимания. Писали, что у него в начале карьеры была проблема с этим, а потом, вроде, он это исправил.
А почему у меня ощущение, что у Дель Монако верхняя нота сплюснутая? И не только у него, а у многих, особенно, на звуке "э"? Где-то писали, что в этой песне это из-за произношения итальянского "te" как "тэй", а Корелли поёт просто "тэ" и поэтому так и было правильно, как в первом варианте. Я думал, что это связано с техникой.
I "prefer" not to have to choose. Glorious, both of these icons.
Of course Mario Del Monaco!
Two fabulous tenors, surely among the greatest of recorded history. Don't seem to be any of similar vocal and emotional quality these days...at least not to my knowledge. Would love to discover any????
@everyday tenor Search for Jonas Kaufmann
Try Alessandro Moccia, he sounds like MDM if he was having a bad day.
Tutti e due grandi ed unici.
One thing is for certain we will never hear voices like these again. The voices of the current opera singers can't even be remotely compared to these legendary Italian tenors. Their power,their piercing resonance and timbre just give me chills. Greazie mille for sharing this.
Impossibile esprimere una preferenza di fronte a due giganti del canto lirico drammatico.
Just one word: Corelli
It is very difficult to compare this way, there are so many factors involved: Mike placement, theater size and acoustics, quality of recording equipment, etc. Needless to say it would be GREAT!! to have these two performing today. So we agree?
agree!
No voice to me is as thrilling as Del Monaco's mountain rocketing voice, god it's epic, earth shattering, dramatic, passionate. I get many praise Corelli more and hail him as the greatest, his color and technique, but for me he doesn't shake my core as Mario, I can't imagine what it must've been like to be at the same venue as him
Sconvolgente drammatico appassionato condivido
M. Del Mónaco = Fierce
Corelli = Melancholy
Very fine descriptions! I can’t agree more.
Per definire questi due tenori non ci sono aggettivi disponibili. Qui MDM era al suo massimo. Corelli sempre impressionante.
Due pilastri della Lirica, introvabili al giorno d'oggi e, se continua così, sarà sempre più difficile trovarne due così che, lì somiglino, almeno un po'. Poi, tra F. C. e MDM, ormai, da sempre, il mio preferito è, in assoluto Franco Corelli. Tutti e due dovevano gestire e domare un'enormità di voce e, Franco, con lo studio e la tecnica ci è riuscito come nessun altro tra i tenori. Sembrava non sforzasse per niente, neppure negli acuti pieni, impressionanti e sempre sicuri e senza incertezze. Comunque, tutti e due da rimpiangere. GRANDI
Corelli chiamava Mario x la tecnica di cosa vogliamo parlare
Nessun dubbio Corelli Franco sempre!!!!!
I would say both have impressive vocal techniques; Corelli clearly can make a bigger sound to make all the drama Del Monaco it's making but Corelli probably knew more drama was not necessary for this song of love, he sings with love and passion Del Monaco sings this and everything else to show what he could do with his voice.
I think you are soooooo correct !!!
Unfair comparison because of the audio quality difference. I'll take Corelli!
corelli
What an era!
Me quedo con los 2!!! Quien se atreve a menospreciar a uno de ellos? Los dos monstruos vocales mas grandes!!
Corelli!
....glad to have had them both on earth. Different voices, both perfect in it´s way. Distinguishable, I would never prefer one alone. Mi piace moltissimo
Franco Corelli aveva una vocalità unica uno squillo straordinario
Don't make me choose,per favore.Both are among the greatest Italian tenors of all time. Che bellissima. Grazie mille for sharing these two marvellous voices with us.
In this comparison, it's hard to decide. Corelli, however, seems to hit the high notes with less effort than Del Monaco. But I could listen to either of them all day.....
Scelgo tutti E Due due Mostri Sacri.
Sono pienamente d'accordo amico mio caro.
@@alessandromoccia471..... Io non scelgo nessuno.... perché difronte a questi semidei la scelta è ardua ed imbarazzante. Amo ed adoro Franco Corelli per la sua eleganza ed il suo modo di cantare..... poi mi giro dall'altra parte e trovo Mario Del Monaco che amo ed è un portento stravolgente ed un trascinatore da brivido... a chi dare il cuore???
@@elsaasta5164 Anch'io non scelgo. Assolutamente..
È impossibile.
Li abbiamo avuti entrambi, scegliere sarebbe ingiusto. Ringraziamo Dio per averceli donati! 😍
Obviously, we're talking about two different voices with different admirable characteristics.
Both are fantastic. But hearing them side by side like this, I was surprised that in my opinion, I actually preferred Del Monaco. His voice seemed a bit more consistent throughout his range, whereas Correlli's high seemed a bit more pushed.
Hm. I hear Corelli's top note here more freely than Monaco's. Del Monaco's sounds more flattened. And there's a few comments here where people heard the same.
@@75bg90 its the other way around,Monaco is stringing,Corelli is not even half thrust yet ha ha ha!!!
Caruso, Galliano, Del Monaco, Corelli, Di Stefano, un altro livello, niente più da dire.
WOW ! vs WOW!
Love this type of video, so thank you! With two opera singers at this level of skill you can go into an analysis of what each does better than the other etc. but it really comes down to one's individual preference, doesn't it? What do we each value in a particular song or passage and who gives us that value? How one responds viscerally to the sound is also individual. The huge, rich sound of Del Monaco does it for me, if it comes down to sound alone. But Corelli may have been the one who showed the greatest vocal versatility.
Mare o Montagna? Ma tutte due, senza dubbio!
Molto dificele... PER ME CORELLI.. PUI CANTABILE.. E MATICE DEL CUORE.!! E SUO AGUDO.. PERFECTO COLOR...
Both Corelli and Del Monaco.
They're both equally beautiful, talented men. Can't decide.
❤Sono entrambi Dei per sempre!!!❤
You could build a battleship with the amount of metal in del Monaco's voice. Truly astonishing.
Такие голоса,с ума сойти,как они прекрасны. Здесь уже дело вкуса. Я больше люблю Дель Монако.
Ho avuto la fortuna di ascoltarli entrambi dal vivo, due voci eccezionali che davano emozioni profondissime, impossibile per me esprimere, nello specifico, una preferenza. Se posso allargare il discorso, dico però che l'interpretazione di questa aria che mi emoziona maggiormente è quella di Caruso.
It's like when Corelli goes into his high notes his throat goes into a more neutral position and more open and then the notes flow so much smoother when Delmonico goes up it's almost like something's being clenched or squeezed in his vowel becomes more of an e and Corelli is more of an ah and it flows very freely. Corelli also seems to have a very calm unstruggled facial expression anytime he sings.
I agree. MDM uses a dipthong vowel sound to push the voice forward in the face, whereas Corelli's voice is perfectly placed and completely open, with such a wholesome rounded sound. Franco Corelli's technique is wonderful and there is nothing like the pushing going on that there is in MDM's performance; it is a Neapolitan Folk song, not Otello's Act 1 Esultate! However, I do not wish to denigrate MDM, he posses an extraordinary instrument the like of which we would love to hear again today.
However, Del Monaco had a bigger top than Corelli 😂
Del Monaco used a lot of physical strength when he sang, but did not squeeze. MDM's voice was actually larger than Corelli's, but both voices could fill any opera house.
@@aaron.anchored.in.christ well maybe-up to B flat-his B was hit or miss-and there was no C. Corelli's upper extension is unparalleled for a voice of that size
@@labienus9968 Del Monaco had a solid C. Arguably less free than Corelli’s, but he had a great one.
th-cam.com/video/SFL-HhPXMZM/w-d-xo.html
Go to 3 minutes 28 seconds
Corelli because of the smoothness of his voice, wonderful legato, and more thrilling high notes...
Preferisco Corelli, ha una voce più calda, più piena. Monaco per me è troppo acuta. CORELLI LO ASCOLTATO QUANDO IL BABBO METTEVA I SUOI DISCHI, ANCHE DI DEL Monaco, ma già da bembina mi piaceva più lui. Questi sono due grandissimi tenori, che hanno fatto onore all'italiana. Perché eravamo emigranti in Colombia. 👍👏👏💕🎶🎶👍🌹
CORELLI É UM FENÔMENO DA NATUREZA.
Si uno toma al arte como competencia olimpica, es porque no lo siente, no lo disfruta. Demos gracias a la vida por Del Mónaco y por Corelli y por todos los que como ellos vivirán por siempre y para siempre.
They’re too good, both of them.
I prefer more the lyrical tenors...but if i have to make a choice...Corelli
They were friends, also shared the technique. That's why they are the only two tenors with metal voices.
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia were they Melocchi method students? because they show quite a striking similarity to MdM
@@jarto10 They weren't really friends until much later. MDM mocked FC's early vibrato but soon feared Corelli-who wouldn't?-and never came back to the Met after FC's debut.
MDM was the real Melocchi student, Corelli took a few lesson with him they say, but he adapted the lowered larynx realizing the danger of inflexibility, and inability to sing softy that became MDM's fate
@@labienus9968 MDM could sing softly and there are countless examples to prove it. He did what he chose to do. The argument that he couldn’t sing softly is tired old shtick.
@:D Love them both but Caruso didn’t have squillo?
@@rdargenio Tired, but true-I don't know about the schtick part, however. Everyone knows that, he even says it himself to Olivero.
Due giganti ma Franco FRANCO!!!!!!
Franco Corelli consistently delivers amazing performances, but in this particular song, Mario Del Monaco conveyed a heightened sense of passion and emotion.
Нужно слушать вживую. Качество записи разное. И кроме того ,в одной арии лучше один, в другой- другой.
В данном случае оба прекрасны.
Согласен, оба великолепны и у каждого были свои арии, в которых они были лучшими. Но конечно сила голоса Mario del Monaco поражает, странно как в оперных театрах окна не разлетались от энергии его голоса.
У Корелли гораздо более правильная атака верхних нот, манера звукоизвлечения и более естественная мимика, чем у Дель Монако. Но оба прекрасны!
Не будем отрицать , что Галина Вишневская одна из величайших оперных певиц современности. Она пела с Дель Монако и Корелли в Ла Скала. В интервью она сказала : "Я никогда и нигде больше не слышала такого потрясающего голоса , как у Франко Корелли".
Вишневская никогда не пела с Марио!
@@ОлегКовтуненко-о9с ммм... Возможно Марио пел с ней приватно) но это не точно. .
We can't compare GREATNESS my friend. Arnold
Bravo bravo los dos ,no sabría cual coger ,es como si te dicen a quien quieres más a papá o s mamá
Due grandissimi interpreti c'e' da esserne orgogliosi
Il grande maestro Franco Corelli , unico e eccezionale.Grazie.
Оба потрясающие тенора. Один лирический другой глубокий драматический. Ничего лучшего в мире нет чем прекрасные голоса итальянцев и их бель канто. Кому-то повезло больше и он прожил длинную жизнь и творческую карьеру, а некотопые покинули этот мир , успев навсегда остаться молодыми и прекрасными.
😆😆😆
Del Monaco for that particular aria, but Corelli is also divine
BOTH! Now stop comparing. Opera is an art form, not a competition.
I prefer both. Amazing singing
I prefer MDM, because he is more expretion in his voice and singing... but of course I adore FC too! Both Gifts from Heaven!❤❤❤
😂🤣😂
Автор ролика, явно, фанат Марио дель Монако. Наложил на его голос эффект, чтоб казался мощнее, а голос Корелли, наоборот, заглушил.
Браво 😂🤣😂👋👋 современной музыкальной аппаратуре!
А если серьёзно, то для того, чтобы сравнить голос двух певцов, нужно использовать запись с одной студии и одного года. Ещё, желательно, точно убедиться, что записывали на одну и ту же аппаратуру.
Поэтому данный ролик не даёт точного представления о мощности голосов этих вокалистов. Это, простите, мухлёж.
The ecoustics are different. Corelli is singing in a television studio, Del Monaco in a theater. Both were incredible, but my heart belongs to Corelli.
I like Corelli for his very beautiful high notes.
La Divina Callas Corelli has a voice that was sweeter than MDM. MDM is very brassy! Both are amazing!
La differenza degli acuti tra Corelli e Del Monaco:il primo è più pungente perchè negli acuti la sua voce è più fine,con meno armonici...il secondo ha gli acuti pieni di armonici,quindi risulta più grande,ma ha meno punta...salve
The differences in the recording is not fair to Corelli, so Del Monaco sounds much better. But if they both were recorded with the same equipment and acoustic then it would be fair. However I still believe this aria suits Del Monaco better, and Corelli in other arias.
Both 😊
Bartosz Zamojski Si!
Del Monaco is such a great tenor, just can't stop listening to him. Corelli is amazing too, but Del Monaco takes the cake for me.
Both