@@peruball2589 it's pretty obviously chae, and I kinda don't think the producers pitched it up, it seems like she actually recorded it one octave higher she wouldn't lip sync it live as if it was a normal vocal if it was meant to be a vocal effect and not a line
@@miam_k It's clearly chipmunked though, yeah it's chae and all but that's not her singing an octave higher, and why wouldn't she lip sync it? In better Mina and Momo sang adlibs during the pre choruses even when they were pitched down, so there's that example that pitching it up or down makes no difference if the members are lipping it or not, but that clearly is pitched up artificially, like no question of it it's her post chorus pitched up, it doesn't sound humanly at all
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh the better adlib are not pitched down, they have a muffling effect and you can hear that I just mean that the higher octave vocals don't sound like a chest voice pitched up, it sounds like she actually sang it that way
Guys...i just realised...the line distribution order is the exact same as the twice all songs line distribution...damn!
And the sizes of the time gaps are kinda similar too except for the gap between Chaeyoung and Tzuyu
MBS Music, Subscribed because your videos are so much fun!
Idk why they edited Chae voice 😅
basing it off the live, I don't think the vocals are edited
@@miam_k that part is chae or not? I see her lipsync that part bur idk
@@peruball2589 it's pretty obviously chae, and I kinda don't think the producers pitched it up, it seems like she actually recorded it one octave higher
she wouldn't lip sync it live as if it was a normal vocal if it was meant to be a vocal effect and not a line
@@miam_k It's clearly chipmunked though, yeah it's chae and all but that's not her singing an octave higher, and why wouldn't she lip sync it? In better Mina and Momo sang adlibs during the pre choruses even when they were pitched down, so there's that example that pitching it up or down makes no difference if the members are lipping it or not, but that clearly is pitched up artificially, like no question of it it's her post chorus pitched up, it doesn't sound humanly at all
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh the better adlib are not pitched down, they have a muffling effect and you can hear that
I just mean that the higher octave vocals don't sound like a chest voice pitched up, it sounds like she actually sang it that way
I leave my like 62 before this goes viral
1:11, 1:14, 1:15 in this part it's not dahyun??? she sings it live and it doesn't sound like jihyo 😅
That adlib doesn't sound like Mina(before the prech)
You can heard clearly in analysis video about this song, and that's really Mina.
@@snsdgivemetwice that voice is too full to be Mina tho
@@vaughnlekziThat's same as her part in "Crazy Stupid Love" intro "Hoo Hoo Hoo Hoo"
@@snsdgivemetwice The intro was Chae tho? Vocal analysis from Kom confirmed it
@@vaughnlekzi no, vocal analysis can never “prove” anything, mina literally sang it live which is proof
Which album does this song belong to?
it doesn't belong to any album yet but I think it will be part of dive
@@mbs_music ohh, ok
I think Dive, they did the same with Just Be Yourself
Well nayeon's lines were only 3 choruses, and she still got the most lines because she sang quite a lot of adlibs🙄
Nayeon deserves it