Well thats their opinion and we Filipinos respect that. But no matter what other people say bad things to SB19 this boy group will never fail us to do more fantastic and expectacular performance❤.
@@myung1214 just like how kpop copied jpop b4 and american pop, right?....ur putting too much emphasis on how kpop is being copied like as if koreans own pop music...sheesh!
@@myung1214 kpop or pop wasn't accepted back in the days in their country like now. They're fans of BSB and the pioneers of kpop studied how european pop and american pop became popular all over the world and adopted that to their own and improved it. No one is copying who, cause pop music is just there people just tend to discover it late. The City pop of Japan was already a popular way back in the 80's. Currently the most popular were kpop songs.. But from the 90's to early 00s American pop was a world wide phenomenon and after a decade it had shifted to Asia and that's the rise of kpop. Then new things will be on trend too in the future it's just a cycle.
Im a kpop fan,but when i heard theyre voice singing live and its a love song.thats when i started to be addicted to them.dont judge them,hear them first.all of their song.theyre so talented.🥰🥰🥰
the last reminder is the best.. others not see sb19 as a good artist. but you will know if u can see and hear them live.. bcoz sb19 is live vocal monster.... u will never be disappointed on their live performance bcoz it so enjoyable and u will know u will into them like magnet.
PPOP, The most genuine and authentic group ever, Specially SB19 They write their own music, they choreograph their own, Check facts first, before saying it, Sorry to people like them, nobody copied by SB19, their works are all original. The 5 members are talented enough, and more to offer in the world. Thanks and God bless
What i think is that the moment they heard Ken and referred to Stray Kids having a low voice. Everything else was all assumptions and bias. Heck! having someone with a low voice had been a thing for a singing group, eversince. It's as normal as a choir having someone to sing as Bass. And just because of Straykids having someone with a low voice is special? as if they own it. That's dumb! In the Philippines all singing group had that kind of composition. In PH is normal and in Korea it's special? But why would we listen to a group here who all use autotune and haven't proven anything in the music industry like SB19 did.
That's Ken's real singing voice , he's not copying anyone. Well , these guys are Ppop Kings! They are all talented , can sing , rap and dance well! Well you can try to drag SB19 down , but we'll support our Mahalima forever! We stan REAL TALENT , WE STAN KINGS!😍
11:40 What really ticked me off at this part (push aside the technicalities, and how people lip-sync in music videos) was how the blonde guy basically just said their pronunciations were "off" or "inauthentic" WITHOUT knowing the different types of Filipino accents. First of all, I myself TALK like that. I make sure most of the words that come out of my mouth are properly enunciated. Pablo also has this kind of accent, and also Josh. I know both or either of them worked at a call center before and I've also been in that industry. Most of Filipinos who live in the Southern part of the Philippines, especially in Manila talk like that. Not all Filipinos have your typical Filipino accent where they pronounce "f" as a hard "p", and we also definitely do not have an American accent like they do. So, it was really unfair to me how they took SB19's way of pronouncing or enunciating words, dissected it, and made it seem like it was a bad thing. To me, it is already a part of our culture and just pointing at people and telling them how they should and should not enunciate words just gives me the ick. I made a comment in CasualChuck's video regarding Ken's deep voice and way of singing/rapping in his part. If you look at Filipino artists like Al James, you'll see that it's almost the same as Ken's flow or what Ken wanted to achieve on his part of the song. Whenever I hear Ken, his way of slow rapping and singing checks all the mark I see from LOCAL artists, and that in itself makes him the opposite of INAUTHENTIC. You can even find other artists outside S.Korea, outside of USA and outside of the Philippines who uses this style. Why? because Music is simply inspired. I could say the same thing to their music, which also sounds like any modern American pop. I wouldn't have this much of an issue with them if they could have just said SB19's songs are just not doing it. They should have just been honest. Their further explanation, adding in the way of pronouncing, the same vibes, etc., just made them seem worse in my eyes. I can respect if you don't like their music at all, but please do not further embarrass yourselves by adding unnecessary reasons why you don't like a certain thing. They as artists should know the lip syncs that go into music videos, the technicalities, how music is inspired, and they as decent people, should know how languages and accents differ. All the points they argued already have their own answers. It was as if they were giving excuses to why they don't like SB19 when it could just be as simple as not digging their music. That's what it seemed like they were doing. No hate to them, as Chuck said, just giving my opinion to their opinion.
Very well said, I honestly share the same sentiments....like they could just been blunt in saying that it's not their type of music or they simply don't like it. But to go further and almost making a mockery of our boys is not nice at all, especially when the blonde chick tries to go gasping for breath on reference to Ken on the MV of Go Up....as if she wouldn't if she had been dancing as f..K.!anyways as SB19 would say always choose to be kind....so end of rant.Peace❤️
These people are sick. As if they can sing especially the blond one. Well, to tell you the truth your favorite idols cannot even sing live. They cannot even distinguish the difference.
Close-minded people will judge you right away without even knowing well the person. But congrats SB19 because they are becoming bigger and bigger. More blessings to SB19. SB19 are extremely talented people. They can sing, rap and dance very well. And they are good people inside and out. They work hard to be successful just like other artists but they are not copying anybody. They were inspired by other artist just like anybody else.
I only new SB19 because of sister recommended it to me saying "you have to watched this group they looked promising and talented and you'll liked them." and she mentioned it a couple more times before I started watching them. Because I was so hesitant cause Filipinos love kpop, alot of people imitate it and then plus most of the pop song that was created before SB19 are not that really good and singers here mostly sang ballads and ppop before is mostly cringe so I didn't believed her at first, when the time of pandemic I was convinced by her to watched them, and I regreted I didn't do it the first time she told me😂😂 I watched their go up video and was amaze how syncronized they move, they're great dancers that's what hooked me to them. So I started to looked for their other songs to see if they can really sing so my sister recommended tila luha and hanggang sa huli and I was already sold. They're good dancers, good voices and they can sing and I knew they had potential and just need to keep improving more and push their limits. When they released "What" I was already amazed and happy that they can produced that kind of song and mv that never seen in Ph music scene. Plus I saw Justin is also a creative director of their MV it's really amazing and it made me expect from them more. From then I knew that if they're just given a chance more sponsor and more fan support they could soar high... they're so talented and every song of them has different vibes. It's rare to have a group that can do everything independently, in a world where autotune is normal, SB19 is a breath of fresh air. Their songs were alive, you can relate to it that's what sets them apart from kpop.
Ok, TAEYANG and Jimin came up their VIBES music, and listen to sb19 look at you ,look at you … there is similarities right?, but GOOD THING , Bazinga came a year before !
I'm pretty sure these reactors also get inspiration from other artists. Just wondering how would they feel if ever someone would tell them the same thing as their comment particularly the "not authentic".
That’s why I don’t support Kpop that much anymore..I only Stan one or two that’s about it..I been a kpop fans since big and era,wonder girls over 10 years now..when I tell you some of these kpop fan bases are close minded..like I said I been kpop fans for a long time now.. When I first discover SB19 I didn’t compare them with anyone else. I listened to their songs and learned more about them. It happened for me to like them more than kpop musics..We understand some people don’t like a certain type of musics,but when you give constructive criticism try to not compare them with your favorite artist..cause that’s just wrong..For example: if someone want me to listen to Adele for the first time and I’m a Metallica fan..I wouldn’t compare them because it’s a totally different genre or style..I would listened more to Adele to understand what her musics all about than comparing them…Great reaction as always
I like you Neu the way you react and make your own opinion about it, ya bro i see you😊 really appreciate a reactor like you. Kudos and keep grinding we're at your back and we will support you all the way.
What makes me "CRINGE" is an immensely successful group who sold many records being judged by a group who doesn't even have a title to their name. But you know what they say, you can't please everybody. So if that is their opinion, respect that. If you're still mad, double check if you are subscribed to their channel and just unsubscribe. No point in watching their reaction videos if you will just be pissed in the end.
No. They're pretty good Reactors. Everybody won't like SB19'S music. It's just ignorance. They don't really understand the history of the kpop industry and the genre of pop. So they compare everything to kpop.
Well I guess the good news in all of this negativity is that their subscribers and viewers got to check out SB19 and form their own opinions. Some of the viewers in the comment section liked the vid. ☺️
Ds s a very good reaction video it explains what authenticity is! If they only watch their interviews and their recent wyat concert tour where they sing live im sure they will learn fr sb 19 ,they have to research before giving their own opinions!
Ito grupo nato iwan kulang kung mag ka concert sa pinas baka langawin lng siguro to para sa akin lang hindi na opinyo yung kanila panlalait na yan at inumpisanhan man nila ito lang masabi ko sa grupo nato na mga dambuhalang balyena na ipit sa bato puno ng tae hehe pati kanta nila may mga halos kapariha din ah kaya sa akin din para sa kanila Big NO for me sa hitsura palang kung dito yan sa pinas bro mga kutoon na marites yan dilikado yan maging kapit bahay...wla din naman to grupo nila kanta na sikat ngayon kulang to na kita mga bakunawa nato heheh
Sinabi Mo pa, Sa totoo Lang naiirita Ako Sa kanila pag nagsasabi cla Ng "that's cute” para Lang may masabi...nakakabwisit! Nood na Lang ulit Ako Ng SB19 para makalma ulit.🙂
@@mira14344 hahaha chill lng wla yan hitsura palang nang mangayan iwan kahit na siguro pina ka sikat na kanta nila kng mayron man if mag concert sila nang live kahit libre pa di ko talaga feel ahaha yang grupo na yan parang mga tsismosa lng ang dating hindi artist hehe subukan kaya nila punta sa pinas iwan kulang kng may manood bah sana mabasa nila to
the song bazinga is for doubters like them. have them watch sb19's live performance of ballad songs. sb19 doesnt use autotune and all members can sing....like they can sing and harmonize....not like some other kpop/jpop/ groups which members use autotune and has "rap line" or "singers". All members of SB19 can sing, rap and dance. 😏
Tnx sir cuz u have a wide understanding a new song that the sb19 give to the audience it’s different now cuz it’s a millennial than that reactor’s cuz there olds already peace ✌️ but that’s the F truth 😂 And u know what they have plenty Filipino subscriber’s including me but now i will unsubscribe them hoping all Filipino as well will unsubscribe them cuz where mad angry 😡 at them please be kind but there bad opinions so be it 😡 But anyway sir starting now I’m ure subscriber cuz u have a good heart ❤️ thank u 🙏 very much 🙏 We us Filipino supporters feels bad ar them feels there a bashers haiiisssttt 😡 cuz they don’t know sb19 background humble beginnings b4 they get big ❤ but i believe a saying that those who put them down will up Amen 🙏 and u never put a good group down 😂❤❤❤ Go SB19 where here for u Filipinos will always supported u Amen 🙏 love ❤️ u always ❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭✌️✌️✌️
I think they should've did their research on SB19 bc according to their opinions their mind is locked into the kpop industry and the korean version of pop genre. I also respect their opinions but to be fair they shouldn't compare an industry to another just bc one is a lot more famous in the world. For all we know PPOP could be the reigning industry in the future. PP💫P R🧨SE! 💪🥂🎺🎷 Thanks for the Reaction.🤩🙏
If these guys react like this to SB19 for not fitting enough the mold of Kpop groups, I wonder how they will react to Alamat. Those guys definitely break the mold. 😄
@@ThisIsNotAhnJieRen they probably won't see any difference just like when I first heard Go Up. Although, I already told myself to take note of SB19 future songs because they were singing live in the Wish Bus.
This comment is very late, but it came up in my suggested videos as I subscribe and watch Cashual Chuck's content. I really enjoy your retrospection and valuable input in this video. You are real, respectful, informative, and I enjoy how you present information matter of factly without bias. Just subscribed, and I look forward to your value-add commentary to other reaction vids, etc.! :)
Yes, they are entitled to their own opinion but they could have done better to deliver it. I understand that they don't like SB19 but some parts of their opinion are quite disrespectful not only to SB19 but to the Filipinos and our music industry. .. especially when they react to "What". I don't care if they like SB19 or not, but they should do it with respect.
When Dizz say's "show me" in their "live" performance his mouth did not align with the mike coz he turned his head but there was no break in the vocals 🤔 it's from 26:41 - 26:43
No other words to say but thank you so much... Thank you for loving Philippines... Pls do more filipino videos... Promise we will support you in return. God bless...❤💯🇵🇭
My question is, should pop be different in every country? What I thought is when you say pop music, there's always similarities regardless of the nationality of the singers. SB19 writes and composes their songs base on their stories, experiences, journey that is also relatable to people. They don't create music by copying Kpop or Jpop.
in my opinion those who have composed or written music were just inspired by music they grew up with. Music is universal and things might be kind of similar or give a nostalgia vibes.
7:45 same reaction dude. Feeling inauthentic doesn't mean you have to be an expert or become one from a certain race. But if he rewrites the script. "Does she know the authenticity of sb19?" "Does she even come across a single member of the group" "Is she their close friend or a friend of a friend?" "Because it takes vast knowledge and so much background information to distinguish inauthenticity. Its like to be able know inauthenticity, first you have to know their authenticity or else that's accusation" That is the take I'm hoping for not being the fact of becoming an expert or becoming a filipino. For even some Ppop experts or other filipinos doesn't know the authentic sb19 in the first place.
That's our ppop what ever opinion or bad things your talking against them we don't care mind your own business all we know that's SB19 is smart to make their own songs, dancing and real voice, are u? That's why there trending and popular now guys
To compare these two groups, l would choose the all boy group for simple reason - the boys are more natural singers than the other one who used auto tunes to their music rather than their natural individual voices, tsk! Perhaps these reactors are blinded by their jealousy or insecurities against the boy group, lol. Tsk!
CasualChuck is one of the best reactors that ever catered for SB19. His videos are informative. But as I mentioned before especially the fans on the comment that don’t understand American/Canadian English shouldn’t comment. Sometimes we speak playfully but they would assume it was an offensive comment. Everyone use “cute” all the time and that’s no way an insult. But fans stop attacking Chuck for his opinion and all the die hard fans need to stop attacking those who dislike certain things about SB19. You guys don’t own them. Just because someone makes a bad comment or constructive criticism doesn’t mean they’re not a fan. Mga ignorante kasi Minsan mga tao. Don’t react to American reactors because sometimes how we perceive things is different from other cultures.
SB 19 studies dance, music technic creations and technically they studies all in Korea . Their manager is from Korea yes they are manage by a Korean person. When they all ready they go back to Philippines to launched their first song.
You know ill be Straight, i don't like SB19 at First and i hate their Faces, But now i Change my Mind Hahah, When you heard their Deep Voices Vocalozation, their Very Talented, Their Dancing Singing Live at Concert they Effortless and Give Energy in every Performance!
A lot of people were offended about their statement specially the fans bcs we saw and we know their struggles to reach where they are now, their gifts and skills, and I think she was pertaining to Ken's part when she said inauthentic based on the video where they compared it to straykids, and I was kinda hurt for SB19 and for Ken because he mentioned it before in one of their videos that he actually hated his deep voice,and Pablo helped him, motivated and assured him that he's good, his voice is amazing and that he has his own style, everyone of them does that's why Pablo said that in writing their songs, he also have to take into account each their styles and skills to show their absolute best. Ken is now embracing what he has so saying that it was inauthentic and that they have to be themselves or be who they really are was kinda off and somewhat stupid imo. I mean, this is them. The real SB19 and they're not just writing and making songs for the sake of trends or smthng, all of their videos were so deep if you dig or dive into what each the lines or lyrics meant. I most especially love their lyricism, it's just on a whole different level. Not everyone can like SB19 and that's understanble but ppl should also really mind the words they'll use or atleast give more context to properly explain their point.
@@peachyonomatopoieaAgree like this Comment, i Stan Kpop Too, at First i don't like SB19 but when you heard Their i mean i heatd their Live Vocal, Wow They're Talented!
THEY ARE BULLY. Defenitely stepping on other artists especially with new ones in industry. Meh. Even knowing that SB19 are new in industry and still learning and improving gradually, they still say whatever they wanna say even it will hurt to other artists. They're rude. 😑 They thought they're higher than the other amateur artists out their. NOPE! Becuase humbleness and kindness first come before fame! 🤷🙅 CANCEEEL!
Who are these reactors? Singers?...they're not even in wiki and never heard of their music...hmmm the way they react it seems like they're mocking the boys. They need to know SB19 before saying words they might eat later. 😤
A’tin are appreciative of constructive criticisms, especially if coming from people who have knowledge in music and dance. However, i think the problem is in the way they conveyed those comments. Their unnecessary giggles can be read as mockery (personally, i’m a little sensitive to that 😅), while their other comments can be interpreted as them being misinformed.
What?! The part of the song "Di na bala, para iangat ang bandera. Bala na sa puso niyo na ang tatama." IS NOT A WORD? Watta idiot are they? That's a damn two sentences.😆 Talking unnecessary word without even knowing the meaning of that lyric part. It's meaningful! Try search it. Well, I think they don't even bother to read the captions/subtitle. 🙄😆
These four people reacting to the video are what I would refer to as “group thinkers” led by the first person who made the initial comment of “not authentic” . The way she used authentic was based out of context without any antecedent knowledge of what they are talking about i.e. SB19. It is obvious that her version of authenticity is so limited if you will.
Learned a lot from this reaction bro. Thank you so much! That's how content creation is. We learn as we go. Your wisdom is greatly appreciated! 🔥🔥
You're welcome man! I appreciate it, thank you! 🙏🏽
❤️❤️❤️
1
Are they in the US coz I never heard about them 😅
@mariateresaamador7 yes they performed in LA in a small stage which they said they almost fall last year of August 19, 2022.
Well thats their opinion and we Filipinos respect that. But no matter what other people say bad things to SB19 this boy group will never fail us to do more fantastic and expectacular performance❤.
Korek Dont Care For that Girl..Lol..
as if the kpop is authentic, kpop came from JPOP (fashion style and mixing english with their language) + American Pop. Pop music is evolving.
💯
they didn't know jpop already exist before kpop lmao. japan did most of it already 😊
@@bakedmac4723 J-pop then and K-pop now are very different. And now J-pop is copying K-pop
@@myung1214 just like how kpop copied jpop b4 and american pop, right?....ur putting too much emphasis on how kpop is being copied like as if koreans own pop music...sheesh!
@@myung1214 kpop or pop wasn't accepted back in the days in their country like now. They're fans of BSB and the pioneers of kpop studied how european pop and american pop became popular all over the world and adopted that to their own and improved it. No one is copying who, cause pop music is just there people just tend to discover it late. The City pop of Japan was already a popular way back in the 80's. Currently the most popular were kpop songs.. But from the 90's to early 00s American pop was a world wide phenomenon and after a decade it had shifted to Asia and that's the rise of kpop. Then new things will be on trend too in the future it's just a cycle.
Yes. I love jpop and performance wise, i vote for them. I'm a fan of KAT-TUN and V6 😊
Im a kpop fan,but when i heard theyre voice singing live and its a love song.thats when i started to be addicted to them.dont judge them,hear them first.all of their song.theyre so talented.🥰🥰🥰
❤❤❤SB19 because they are extremely talented.
Versatile.
Good people inside and out.
the last reminder is the best.. others not see sb19 as a good artist. but you will know if u can see and hear them live.. bcoz sb19 is live vocal monster....
u will never be disappointed on their live performance bcoz it so enjoyable and u will know u will into them like magnet.
Im dissapoinred when I saw them live too much trash so stop being delusional 😂
@@superpanda3857 WHAT THE FUCK. YOU ARE LYING.
STOP SLANDERING THEM.
THEY ARE TOO GOOD. LOL
@@superpanda3857really???
PPOP, The most genuine and authentic group ever, Specially SB19 They write their own music, they choreograph their own, Check facts first, before saying it, Sorry to people like them, nobody copied by SB19, their works are all original. The 5 members are talented enough, and more to offer in the world.
Thanks and God bless
What i think is that the moment they heard Ken and referred to Stray Kids having a low voice. Everything else was all assumptions and bias. Heck! having someone with a low voice had been a thing for a singing group, eversince. It's as normal as a choir having someone to sing as Bass. And just because of Straykids having someone with a low voice is special? as if they own it. That's dumb! In the Philippines all singing group had that kind of composition. In PH is normal and in Korea it's special? But why would we listen to a group here who all use autotune and haven't proven anything in the music industry like SB19 did.
BTS has v ...big bang has top as low voice members ...there is nothing new
Who use all autotune lol ur opinion is pathethic 😂
That's Ken's real singing voice , he's not copying anyone. Well , these guys are Ppop Kings! They are all talented , can sing , rap and dance well! Well you can try to drag SB19 down , but we'll support our Mahalima forever! We stan REAL TALENT , WE STAN KINGS!😍
11:40 What really ticked me off at this part (push aside the technicalities, and how people lip-sync in music videos) was how the blonde guy basically just said their pronunciations were "off" or "inauthentic" WITHOUT knowing the different types of Filipino accents. First of all, I myself TALK like that. I make sure most of the words that come out of my mouth are properly enunciated. Pablo also has this kind of accent, and also Josh. I know both or either of them worked at a call center before and I've also been in that industry. Most of Filipinos who live in the Southern part of the Philippines, especially in Manila talk like that. Not all Filipinos have your typical Filipino accent where they pronounce "f" as a hard "p", and we also definitely do not have an American accent like they do. So, it was really unfair to me how they took SB19's way of pronouncing or enunciating words, dissected it, and made it seem like it was a bad thing. To me, it is already a part of our culture and just pointing at people and telling them how they should and should not enunciate words just gives me the ick.
I made a comment in CasualChuck's video regarding Ken's deep voice and way of singing/rapping in his part. If you look at Filipino artists like Al James, you'll see that it's almost the same as Ken's flow or what Ken wanted to achieve on his part of the song. Whenever I hear Ken, his way of slow rapping and singing checks all the mark I see from LOCAL artists, and that in itself makes him the opposite of INAUTHENTIC. You can even find other artists outside S.Korea, outside of USA and outside of the Philippines who uses this style. Why? because Music is simply inspired. I could say the same thing to their music, which also sounds like any modern American pop.
I wouldn't have this much of an issue with them if they could have just said SB19's songs are just not doing it. They should have just been honest. Their further explanation, adding in the way of pronouncing, the same vibes, etc., just made them seem worse in my eyes. I can respect if you don't like their music at all, but please do not further embarrass yourselves by adding unnecessary reasons why you don't like a certain thing. They as artists should know the lip syncs that go into music videos, the technicalities, how music is inspired, and they as decent people, should know how languages and accents differ. All the points they argued already have their own answers. It was as if they were giving excuses to why they don't like SB19 when it could just be as simple as not digging their music. That's what it seemed like they were doing. No hate to them, as Chuck said, just giving my opinion to their opinion.
Very well said, I honestly share the same sentiments....like they could just been blunt in saying that it's not their type of music or they simply don't like it. But to go further and almost making a mockery of our boys is not nice at all, especially when the blonde chick tries to go gasping for breath on reference to Ken on the MV of Go Up....as if she wouldn't if she had been dancing as f..K.!anyways as SB19 would say always choose to be kind....so end of rant.Peace❤️
Agree.
They are racist. Period.
These people are sick. As if they can sing especially the blond one. Well, to tell you the truth your favorite idols cannot even sing live. They cannot even distinguish the difference.
Yeah Sb19 cannot please everyone but LoL SB19 is way better than stray kids. They're versatile and highly AUTHENTIC ❣️😉
Close-minded people will judge you right away without even knowing well the person.
But congrats SB19 because they are becoming bigger and bigger. More blessings to SB19.
SB19 are extremely talented people. They can sing, rap and dance very well.
And they are good people inside and out.
They work hard to be successful just like other artists but they are not copying anybody. They were inspired by other artist just like anybody else.
They should make a show down to SB19 let's see what they Got
😆😆😆
Hahaha yeah damn right I DARE THEM😡
No need they’re so below the high standard of SB19.
Yes we need showdown hinamon nyo ang sb19 na live vocals without auto tune ok go we need showdown
Let kpop perform the ballads of SB19 and say again they are like kpop.. haha..
Thank you for this, love from the 🇵🇭 the way she said unauthentic is so her 🤭😅SB19 is SB19 period.
They are the real Bazinga lol
The biggest twist was that the song they reacted to is actually for people like them.
exactly haha
😂😂 bobo Kasi haha nka sub pnmn Ako Dyan mka pag unsubscribe nga
Ha baboy Monroe
😂
Pig Monroe hahahaPIG
This Bazinga MV screams swag and hotness then they call it cute??? HAHAHAHAHA they don't have way better to say! 😅😅😅😅
I only new SB19 because of sister recommended it to me saying "you have to watched this group they looked promising and talented and you'll liked them." and she mentioned it a couple more times before I started watching them. Because I was so hesitant cause Filipinos love kpop, alot of people imitate it and then plus most of the pop song that was created before SB19 are not that really good and singers here mostly sang ballads and ppop before is mostly cringe so I didn't believed her at first, when the time of pandemic I was convinced by her to watched them, and I regreted I didn't do it the first time she told me😂😂 I watched their go up video and was amaze how syncronized they move, they're great dancers that's what hooked me to them. So I started to looked for their other songs to see if they can really sing so my sister recommended tila luha and hanggang sa huli and I was already sold. They're good dancers, good voices and they can sing and I knew they had potential and just need to keep improving more and push their limits. When they released "What" I was already amazed and happy that they can produced that kind of song and mv that never seen in Ph music scene. Plus I saw Justin is also a creative director of their MV it's really amazing and it made me expect from them more. From then I knew that if they're just given a chance more sponsor and more fan support they could soar high... they're so talented and every song of them has different vibes. It's rare to have a group that can do everything independently, in a world where autotune is normal, SB19 is a breath of fresh air. Their songs were alive, you can relate to it that's what sets them apart from kpop.
Ok, TAEYANG and Jimin came up their VIBES music, and listen to sb19 look at you ,look at you … there is similarities right?, but GOOD THING , Bazinga came a year before !
Ken and Josh started in the streets - philippine streets. You wont survive if you are soft..
Thank you for your reaction.
I'm pretty sure these reactors also get inspiration from other artists. Just wondering how would they feel if ever someone would tell them the same thing as their comment particularly the "not authentic".
I'm pretty sure they get inspired from them as well haha.
Thanks for supporting ATIN ♥️
Sb19 songs is way better than thiers with substance
That’s why I don’t support Kpop that much anymore..I only Stan one or two that’s about it..I been a kpop fans since big and era,wonder girls over 10 years now..when I tell you some of these kpop fan bases are close minded..like I said I been kpop fans for a long time now.. When I first discover SB19 I didn’t compare them with anyone else. I listened to their songs and learned more about them. It happened for me to like them more than kpop musics..We understand some people don’t like a certain type of musics,but when you give constructive criticism try to not compare them with your favorite artist..cause that’s just wrong..For example: if someone want me to listen to Adele for the first time and I’m a Metallica fan..I wouldn’t compare them because it’s a totally different genre or style..I would listened more to Adele to understand what her musics all about than comparing them…Great reaction as always
Thanks for your honest opinion...
what you said is true , if you want to know an artist in a deeper sense, u've got to watch them more and not just based on 1 video or music.
I like you Neu the way you react and make your own opinion about it, ya bro i see you😊 really appreciate a reactor like you. Kudos and keep grinding we're at your back and we will support you all the way.
Appreciate it, thank you! 🙏🏽💙
Thank you so much.
What makes me "CRINGE" is an immensely successful group who sold many records being judged by a group who doesn't even have a title to their name. But you know what they say, you can't please everybody. So if that is their opinion, respect that. If you're still mad, double check if you are subscribed to their channel and just unsubscribe. No point in watching their reaction videos if you will just be pissed in the end.
Correct 😅😅😅
I've been looking for this original reaction video .. what's the name of this group?
They are not even authentic themselves. The audacity. They just want views cuz nobody knows them FR!
Ahhh..ok..THEY ARE..HATERS and BASHERS..
No. They're pretty good Reactors. Everybody won't like SB19'S music. It's just ignorance. They don't really understand the history of the kpop industry and the genre of pop. So they compare everything to kpop.
Well I guess the good news in all of this negativity is that their subscribers and viewers got to check out SB19 and form their own opinions. Some of the viewers in the comment section liked the vid. ☺️
Ds s a very good reaction video it explains what authenticity is! If they only watch their interviews and their recent wyat concert tour where they sing live im sure they will learn fr sb 19 ,they have to research before giving their own opinions!
Ito grupo nato iwan kulang kung mag ka concert sa pinas baka langawin lng siguro to para sa akin lang hindi na opinyo yung kanila panlalait na yan at inumpisanhan man nila ito lang masabi ko sa grupo nato na mga dambuhalang balyena na ipit sa bato puno ng tae hehe pati kanta nila may mga halos kapariha din ah kaya sa akin din para sa kanila Big NO for me sa hitsura palang kung dito yan sa pinas bro mga kutoon na marites yan dilikado yan maging kapit bahay...wla din naman to grupo nila kanta na sikat ngayon kulang to na kita mga bakunawa nato heheh
Sinabi Mo pa, Sa totoo Lang naiirita Ako Sa kanila pag nagsasabi cla Ng "that's cute” para Lang may masabi...nakakabwisit! Nood na Lang ulit Ako Ng SB19 para makalma ulit.🙂
@@mira14344 hahaha chill lng wla yan hitsura palang nang mangayan iwan kahit na siguro pina ka sikat na kanta nila kng mayron man if mag concert sila nang live kahit libre pa di ko talaga feel ahaha yang grupo na yan parang mga tsismosa lng ang dating hindi artist hehe subukan kaya nila punta sa pinas iwan kulang kng may manood bah sana mabasa nila to
😂😂 natawa ako sa dambuhalang balyena.
the song bazinga is for doubters like them. have them watch sb19's live performance of ballad songs. sb19 doesnt use autotune and all members can sing....like they can sing and harmonize....not like some other kpop/jpop/ groups which members use autotune and has "rap line" or "singers". All members of SB19 can sing, rap and dance. 😏
Just subscribed😊 bcoz of the ff. Reasons:
1. i admire ur honesty and straightforward opinion😊
2. I am a proud SB19 fan😊
Thank you!
Sb19 fan here ❤❤❤
Tnx sir cuz u have a wide understanding a new song that the sb19 give to the audience it’s different now cuz it’s a millennial than that reactor’s cuz there olds already peace ✌️ but that’s the F truth 😂
And u know what they have plenty Filipino subscriber’s including me but now i will unsubscribe them hoping all Filipino as well will unsubscribe them cuz where mad angry 😡 at them please be kind but there bad opinions so be it 😡
But anyway sir starting now I’m ure subscriber cuz u have a good heart ❤️ thank u 🙏 very much 🙏
We us Filipino supporters feels bad ar them feels there a bashers haiiisssttt 😡 cuz they don’t know sb19 background humble beginnings b4 they get big ❤ but i believe a saying that those who put them down will up Amen 🙏 and u never put a good group down 😂❤❤❤
Go SB19 where here for u Filipinos will always supported u Amen 🙏 love ❤️ u always ❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭✌️✌️✌️
Thank you for your reaction🥰 have a nice day..
I think that their hashtag is a campaign against sb19 because that song of them was on number 1 for days.
Sb19❤️
Jealousy is written on their empty faces.
I think they should've did their research on SB19 bc according to their opinions their mind is locked into the kpop industry and the korean version of pop genre. I also respect their opinions but to be fair they shouldn't compare an industry to another just bc one is a lot more famous in the world. For all we know PPOP could be the reigning industry in the future. PP💫P
R🧨SE! 💪🥂🎺🎷
Thanks for the Reaction.🤩🙏
If these guys react like this to SB19 for not fitting enough the mold of Kpop groups, I wonder how they will react to Alamat. Those guys definitely break the mold. 😄
@@ThisIsNotAhnJieRen they probably won't see any difference just like when I first heard Go Up. Although, I already told myself to take note of SB19 future songs because they were singing live in the Wish Bus.
This comment is very late, but it came up in my suggested videos as I subscribe and watch Cashual Chuck's content. I really enjoy your retrospection and valuable input in this video. You are real, respectful, informative, and I enjoy how you present information matter of factly without bias. Just subscribed, and I look forward to your value-add commentary to other reaction vids, etc.! :)
They are just jealous because they discovered that SB19 are all talented men after watching their music videos.
Thank you so much bro. For following kur boys we A'tin loves you a lot.
Yes, they are entitled to their own opinion but they could have done better to deliver it. I understand that they don't like SB19 but some parts of their opinion are quite disrespectful not only to SB19 but to the Filipinos and our music industry. .. especially when they react to "What". I don't care if they like SB19 or not, but they should do it with respect.
Hey lady, I respect your opinion. Make sure you don't make a 360-degree turn in the future.🤔😁😂 Regret is inevitable, your loss.😢
Thanks bro😊
When Dizz say's "show me" in their "live" performance his mouth did not align with the mike coz he turned his head but there was no break in the vocals 🤔 it's from 26:41 - 26:43
I think they’re saying that because their brain and taste is Kpop programmed 😂😂😂
No other words to say but thank you so much... Thank you for loving Philippines... Pls do more filipino videos... Promise we will support you in return. God bless...❤💯🇵🇭
New subscriber here from philippines love ur reaction sir🥰
Appreciate you!
Lol , a lot of A’tin unsubscribe to their channel including me. 😂
I was never subbed. I would just watch certain Reactions of theirs like Morrisette. Lol
Yaa!me too
me too😂😂
Me too I immediately unsubscribe and made sure that I clicked on You Tube to not suggest videos from them .....
My question is, should pop be different in every country? What I thought is when you say pop music, there's always similarities regardless of the nationality of the singers. SB19 writes and composes their songs base on their stories, experiences, journey that is also relatable to people. They don't create music by copying Kpop or Jpop.
in my opinion those who have composed or written music were just inspired by music they grew up with. Music is universal and things might be kind of similar or give a nostalgia vibes.
precisely! pop is pop. pop also originated in America, so, are they saying Kpop is also inauthentic? hmmm
@@chinllanos6392and pop group is originally in japan j pop so basically kpop is inauthentic too
I like how you respect everyone even though they say some shit
Haha, gotta give respect always.
7:45 same reaction dude. Feeling inauthentic doesn't mean you have to be an expert or become one from a certain race. But if he rewrites the script. "Does she know the authenticity of sb19?" "Does she even come across a single member of the group" "Is she their close friend or a friend of a friend?" "Because it takes vast knowledge and so much background information to distinguish inauthenticity. Its like to be able know inauthenticity, first you have to know their authenticity or else that's accusation"
That is the take I'm hoping for not being the fact of becoming an expert or becoming a filipino.
For even some Ppop experts or other filipinos doesn't know the authentic sb19 in the first place.
Casual Chuck's "yeah" meant they're not even good. 😄
🤣😭
Their opinion is keber for me wa pakels...ilove SB19
😂😂😂😂😂😂 that's the way they want..offfff....bastos moves..haha
Sb19 full package
BIG ELEPHANT IS TALKING WHILE MONKEY IS WATCHING. THEY ARE SINGER GROUP ALSO.
They should've watched their live performances. Sheesh!
We need showdown from sb19 live vocals and these 4 piggy evil bashers we need rightnow!! Kskainin lng ksyo ng buhay ni stell
When somebody says, "you are cute," it could mean, good or bad. In their case, they are mocking SB19.
That's our ppop what ever opinion or bad things your talking against them we don't care mind your own business all we know that's SB19 is smart to make their own songs, dancing and real voice, are u? That's why there trending and popular now guys
'Feels inauthenric..' OH HERE WE GOOOOOOO! 😂😂😂
To compare these two groups, l would choose the all boy group for simple reason - the boys are more natural singers than the other one who used auto tunes to their music rather than their natural individual voices, tsk! Perhaps these reactors are blinded by their jealousy or insecurities against the boy group, lol. Tsk!
That's my opinion too. Base on how they reacted, they're jealous.
Do you think they can dance like sb19? They think they are better than sb19
they know how to twerk..
Thanks KING NEU
You're welcome Judith!
I guess those guys sing in a bar. Who are they to say that SB19 is unauthentic? Have they proven anything yet like SB19?
CasualChuck is one of the best reactors that ever catered for SB19. His videos are informative. But as I mentioned before especially the fans on the comment that don’t understand American/Canadian English shouldn’t comment. Sometimes we speak playfully but they would assume it was an offensive comment. Everyone use “cute” all the time and that’s no way an insult. But fans stop attacking Chuck for his opinion and all the die hard fans need to stop attacking those who dislike certain things about SB19. You guys don’t own them. Just because someone makes a bad comment or constructive criticism doesn’t mean they’re not a fan. Mga ignorante kasi Minsan mga tao. Don’t react to American reactors because sometimes how we perceive things is different from other cultures.
SB 19 studies dance, music technic creations and technically they studies all in Korea . Their manager is from Korea yes they are manage by a Korean person. When they all ready they go back to Philippines to launched their first song.
I agree with your statements than those reactors
You know ill be Straight, i don't like SB19 at First and i hate their Faces, But now i Change my Mind Hahah, When you heard their Deep Voices Vocalozation, their Very Talented, Their Dancing Singing Live at Concert they Effortless and Give Energy in every Performance!
A lot of people were offended about their statement specially the fans bcs we saw and we know their struggles to reach where they are now, their gifts and skills, and I think she was pertaining to Ken's part when she said inauthentic based on the video where they compared it to straykids, and I was kinda hurt for SB19 and for Ken because he mentioned it before in one of their videos that he actually hated his deep voice,and Pablo helped him, motivated and assured him that he's good, his voice is amazing and that he has his own style, everyone of them does that's why Pablo said that in writing their songs, he also have to take into account each their styles and skills to show their absolute best. Ken is now embracing what he has so saying that it was inauthentic and that they have to be themselves or be who they really are was kinda off and somewhat stupid imo. I mean, this is them. The real SB19 and they're not just writing and making songs for the sake of trends or smthng, all of their videos were so deep if you dig or dive into what each the lines or lyrics meant. I most especially love their lyricism, it's just on a whole different level. Not everyone can like SB19 and that's understanble but ppl should also really mind the words they'll use or atleast give more context to properly explain their point.
#A”Tin go SB19 2023
Lesson learned haters will we be haters no matter how good you are they will never it in you because they're HATERS 😂😂😂
Bcz they r stan kpop ... thats why, they r not openminded..
??? I highly stan KPOP, but I also stan PPOP on an equal level, so not everyone is as close-minded as them.
@@peachyonomatopoieaAgree like this Comment, i Stan Kpop Too, at First i don't like SB19 but when you heard Their i mean i heatd their Live Vocal, Wow They're Talented!
NICE VIDEO MAN! ALL FACT 🔥👏
As I expected from reverse ahahahahah they even bash morisette in singing and they said she's trying to be a Mariah
They don’t even realised that Pablo and Stell’s voice is higher than this guys 😂😂😂
well im just glad that you're not one of them. you even watched their vlogs and interviews, wow! thanks for doing that! 😊
Well that's their opinion however SB19 created their own songs and perform it so well specially on live performance damn so good❤❤❤
They are racist! They think they are good nah No way Jose! Haters and bashers because SB19 goes up!celebration 🎉
I don't think race has anything to do with their statement. 💀
THEY ARE BULLY. Defenitely stepping on other artists especially with new ones in industry. Meh. Even knowing that SB19 are new in industry and still learning and improving gradually, they still say whatever they wanna say even it will hurt to other artists. They're rude. 😑 They thought they're higher than the other amateur artists out their. NOPE! Becuase humbleness and kindness first come before fame! 🤷🙅 CANCEEEL!
chuck's "overprotectiveness" 🙄 ☁️🏃♂️
Who are these reactors? Singers?...they're not even in wiki and never heard of their music...hmmm the way they react it seems like they're mocking the boys. They need to know SB19 before saying words they might eat later. 😤
They're out in ds world when they comment 🤣
I love your reaction
Appreciate you!
Thanks for the rv
A’tin are appreciative of constructive criticisms, especially if coming from people who have knowledge in music and dance.
However, i think the problem is in the way they conveyed those comments. Their unnecessary giggles can be read as mockery (personally, i’m a little sensitive to that 😅), while their other comments can be interpreted as them being misinformed.
Oh wait, these riverse got to billboard???😅
My answer is big NO
🤣
Uhmm...Riverse who?!!!?who the f...K are they??
A gift for you , ppop manila 2023
💙💙💙💙
They're really NOT...They're basing their craft on Kpop-stuff.
Let the success talk,haters or insecure people are there as always😊😊👍👍✌✌✌
What?! The part of the song "Di na bala, para iangat ang bandera. Bala na sa puso niyo na ang tatama." IS NOT A WORD? Watta idiot are they? That's a damn two sentences.😆 Talking unnecessary word without even knowing the meaning of that lyric part. It's meaningful! Try search it. Well, I think they don't even bother to read the captions/subtitle. 🙄😆
These four people reacting to the video are what I would refer to as “group thinkers” led by the first person who made the initial comment of “not authentic” . The way she used authentic was based out of context without any antecedent knowledge of what they are talking about i.e. SB19. It is obvious that her version of authenticity is so limited if you will.