i thought it would be funny to include the clip of minnie whistling at the beginning so i hope you guys like that! ignore the lil text i forgot to take it out when i rendered the video 😂
I know her voice is gorgeous, but you didn't listen to all the kpop songs, did you? Many other kpop artists have this kind of voice I hope many international fans stop thinking that they know all aspect of kpop, not just listening to some kpop idol songs Cause as a Korean, sometimes I feel international fans underestimate other Korean artists and genre except kpop idols
for people who said that she sounds more powerful and has more control when she sings in english and sounds forced in korean, its because of the technique of each language when they’re being spoken, english tends to have more open mouthed words while korean tends to have more pout mouthed words. people who sounds good singing in korean would def sounds better in english, thats my opinion tho
At the start of LION and Oh MY GOD, she also used Korean words and her voice was still deep .She can sing either in high pitched or low pitched tone, it just depends on the song ,concept or verse, she has to sing . Most of the songs she is singing in korean in this video are songs with higher notes .She could also sing with higher tone in English songs, which she does some times and some times not, as you can see in the video ,how I said , it just depents on the concept or song. There are Korean songs, where her voice sounds much deeper, so I don't think that she sounds high pitched in korean, as some others may think .My honest opinion .
no, not because k songs are higher but because thats their style, nasally cutesy voice. most idols cant sing outside their styles, let alone sing their own songs live
God her voice is just so unique I could listen her all day long. Also I miss her without bangs I love her with bangs but without you can see more of her face and she's so pretty
I always whistle songs either to the end or some parts it's actually a habit- I sometimes whistle too loud to the point I'm scared someone who heard it will scold me XP
Minnie's vocal is perfect Minnie's rap is perfect Minnie's dance is perfect Minnie's look is perfect Minnie is perfect in every way (along with the other members of course) and I only started being stan of (g) i-dle because of Minnie 💕 ♥ ️ that's why she is my bias. ❤
She and Rosé have the most unique voices, I really love Minnie's voice it sounds heavenly but also powerful and badass! She can hit those high notes like a QUEEN. Especially when singing in English
Let's just accept the fact that we all want to have a voice like Minnie..... It's so soft.... Dreamy.... Creamy..wai- nvm. Not creamy. I mean just listen to that voice.... Once she sings a powerful song damn. Her voice is strong!👏👏 We stan A QUEEN like her!
First things first, Minnie and Yuqi need to release the full cover of Scared to be Lonely. Then Minnie needs a big collab with either Troye Sivan or Zedd or David Guetta. Then I can die happy.
@@yourfavmorena Her fluency and comfort with English, I believe, is more of a personal achievement than a success of the Thai education system. This is partly due to the teaching methods that focuses heavily on grammar rather than usage, broken sentences and poor accent (especially taught by teachers in public schools), and very little opportunity to use English in daily life. Quite a lot of Thais really struggle with English despite learning English from an early age. In fact, Thais on average score very low on English standard tests like Toefl, toeic and IELTS. Thailand is one of the lowest scoring nation in Southeast Asia and Asia at large. As a Thai, I am really disappointed with the country, because it always fail to set up a proper support system for any field of expertise to help people with talent to showcase, develop and nurture their talent into fruition. Talented people here needs to find a way for themselves, so many missed opportunities because they have talent but lack finance to help them getting their talents developed.
I think it has a lot to do with the common sounds in Korean. They require a different type of mouth shape and pronunciation than English words and in singing, pronunciation can have a huge impact on overall sound.
I hate how she's always brought down just because she has more lines than Miyeon. And how everyone say that she shouldn't be a main vocalist and Miyeon is better🤦 It makes me so mad. She is an amazing singer with emotional, unique voice who can sing highnotes perfectly live - what else do you want from main vocal???? She's so underrated. I love how interesting and emotional her songs sound. I'm waiting for her solo debiut!
Ikr..all who said that just dumb solo stan(miyeon stn of coz) Minnie voice is versatile.. Like she can go deeper, high, smooth, dreamy etc... Meanwhile miyeon.. U know her voice not versitle yet wonderful... bcoz minnie suit all genre ..who can be blamed right
Minnie gets more highs notes than Miyeon (Edit) Im not saying who is worse, I only saying that Minnie gets more highs notes than Miyeon, both are so Good singing, its only my opinion.
@Jimin’s Beans Obviously she is not. Don't be ...oh come on that maybe just a white fact just like this guy is taller than that guy. You don't need to go for highest tone ever in the world to be the best singer. The most successful singers have difference high note their voice can reach or even they don't want that high note in their songs.
Whistling in tune is a hard thing to do, because the tune of the whistle does not depend on your vocal chords but how you move your tongue. She has got a hard skill done right!
Yes same. But maybe Hwasa feels awkward to just turn down (the pushy) Kei. She literally went beyond by giving Hwasa food and proving herself that she really wanted to be in Hwas's team. If I were Hwasa too, I'll be torn between the two. But because Minnie already gave her up, Hwasa then decided to just stick to Kei.
Show this video to everyone who thinks Minnie is only sweet and dreamy. OUR QUEEN BELTS WHEN SHE NEEDS TOO. She sounds spectacular singing in every language. One of the most unique vocals in K-Pop. I hope she continues to get more and more love.
I really want her to have more collabs or at least officially released covers so she can show more of her range. We just don’t get to hear enough of it and I need more 🥺
idle is the first girl group i officially stan in my entire 6 years with kpop and minnie is my first ever girl ultimate bias. her voice makes me happy, gives me chills, she is exteremely beautiful in my eyes and even so she is so talented, like she can talk or sing 24/7 and i will just listen her while crying about how precious she is. IS THIS LOVE wHaT ARE YOU DOIn TO ME
Her voice is pure gold, super stable and dreamy, one of the best vocalist in Kpop for me. She can rap too! G-Idle is a very very talented group, all the members are good at singing, that includes Soyeon. Cube ent., pls let her sing a good kdrama ost and I know that she'd blow up for sure.
Woww..... just wow.... Minnie is the best vocal... Her voice is so full of individuality (the very rare and beautiful voice) and makes me get immersed into her singing.. 8 mins went so quick and omg i want to see the full version of every single video you combined.. Just wow, she is so good
Her voice quality tho! Omg it’s outstanding it’s like you know those official studio version recording compared to like actual live voice, her live voice sounds EXACTLY like the official studio version 😍😭 her voice is so heavenly
Agreed. Her senorita era for me was by far the best, it shows how elegant and sassy she is, but minnie with bangs gives out different vibe, its a mix of powerful and cute. I love her both ways
Minnie’s voice sounds better in English it is because she sings her genre. She gets the diversity in Kpop which shows her range of vocal. Shows how versatile she is 👌🏻
![ตรงที่เดิม - ฝน พรสุดา [ต้นฉบับ :เบส ขวางหวัน]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/c5YnbGEztI8/mqdefault.jpg)
Minnie’s voice suits English songs more than Korean songs.
MENGFEI QIN especially in gravity!
So true 👍👍👍👍🍃👍
MENGFEI QIN I’m korean, but I agree.
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's cover . Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
True
Her high notes on lion is lit
Leonardo Quarviando FACT
That’s just adlibs
positive vibe they weren’t adlibs though, she sang her PART not adlibbing over another member’s part. Her adlib is only in Light My Fire
@@praveenw.4393 i suggest you to find out what "adlibs" means first
I don't know why that wasn't in this
Title: minnie's amazing vocals
First seconds of the vid: minnie whistling
Lmao
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's covers . Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
dear kook OK going now
LOL
Scared my cat
Not only is she extremely talented but she’s extremely gorgeous!!!
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's covers. Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
@@dearkook7466 haven't found anything tho
@@mnmalabanan8839 th-cam.com/video/sTisipxea7U/w-d-xo.html
@@mnmalabanan8839
Spring day
th-cam.com/video/i4uGR-us0H4/w-d-xo.html
BS&T
th-cam.com/video/ymvmirIHq_s/w-d-xo.html
Abd you'll find more❤
Hope you'll like it
no one sounds like her in kpop or even korea. she's so unique
Yep, her voice is so unique
Wait srsly? How do you know? I mean I think her looks are quite fitting to the korean standards? Small face and all?
I know her voice is gorgeous, but you didn't listen to all the kpop songs, did you? Many other kpop artists have this kind of voice I hope many international fans stop thinking that they know all aspect of kpop, not just listening to some kpop idol songs Cause as a Korean, sometimes I feel international fans underestimate other Korean artists and genre except kpop idols
No one sounds like each other
...? What does it mean? It sounds so rude ㅋㅋ
for people who said that she sounds more powerful and has more control when she sings in english and sounds forced in korean, its because of the technique of each language when they’re being spoken, english tends to have more open mouthed words while korean tends to have more pout mouthed words. people who sounds good singing in korean would def sounds better in english, thats my opinion tho
Very true! Thanks for pointing it out :D 🖤
Exactly
Natashya Putri yess I always fail when try to sing in Korean its so hard for me
yeah it's basically the same with Jungkook.
At the start of LION and Oh MY GOD, she also used Korean words and her voice was still deep .She can sing either in high pitched or low pitched tone, it just depends on the song ,concept or verse, she has to sing . Most of the songs she is singing in korean in this video are songs with higher notes .She could also sing with higher tone in English songs, which she does some times and some times not, as you can see in the video ,how I said , it just depents on the concept or song. There are Korean songs, where her voice sounds much deeper, so I don't think that she sounds high pitched in korean, as some others may think .My honest opinion .
Is it just me or is her voice deeper when singing in english and more high pitched when singing in korean?
Korean songs tends to be higher that's why
yes, like rosé
Yeah, that's the case for most idols
@@nnalivia okay but can not bring other idols in here? This video abt minnie tho:(
no, not because k songs are higher but because thats their style, nasally cutesy voice. most idols cant sing outside their styles, let alone sing their own songs live
Minnie true voice range is being utilised well when she’s singing in English
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's covers . Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
God her voice is just so unique I could listen her all day long. Also I miss her without bangs I love her with bangs but without you can see more of her face and she's so pretty
True, but she also looks so cute and fierce at the same time with bangs 😍
I thought she was the visual when she debut with latata
@@strawberrymochi3420 but during Lata ta she has that weird short bang (ʘᴗʘ✿)
Z G they weren’t real bangs though. I think she said they were fake or like similar to extentions? Correct me if I’m wrong though
@@ayazu515 yes that was fake you're right :D
The day Minnie and Yuqi's cover of Scared to be Lonely comes out I will actually die.
TheMooseLord we need it to happen soon 😭
@@dariontive isnt it already out-
@@chlovtbl they probably mean as in studio version ? Idk
People: Minnie's voice is better in English
Me: *how tf can she whistle a whole song*
Edit: Not trying to be that person but, Thanks for the likes~
Lol fr
I always whistle songs either to the end or some parts it's actually a habit-
I sometimes whistle too loud to the point I'm scared someone who heard it will scold me XP
True lmao
Yasssss
She also whistle Oh My God song
how she is the least popular being this talented and pretty is beyond me...
She is pretty popular especially after queendom.
In korea maybe she is coz she’s foreign but internationally she’s up there with Soyeon and Soojin
Wdym she always trends
Minnie ain’t least popular
aren’t least popular Shuhua and Miyeon?
shes sounds so much more powerful when she sings in english
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's covers . Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
Agree
wow... her face completely changes with the hair change! It was so hard for me to recognize her without the black hair and bangs!
IKR
Ikrr she like from cute to like BOMB
@@miggymosqueda4392 Indeed
funny bc i’ve stanned since before debut so to me my brain naturally sees minnie with orange-ish hair, not black
She really stands out with bangs and black hair i think..
She is good for both language..and the fact that she is Thai..she is slaying all the way..really like minnie and yuqi voice..rare vocal..
Her voice sound thin and dreamy in Korean but sound thick, dreamy and powerful in English
Minnie = Talent
Minnie's vocal is perfect
Minnie's rap is perfect
Minnie's dance is perfect
Minnie's look is perfect
Minnie is perfect in every way (along with the other members of course)
and I only started being stan of (g) i-dle because of Minnie 💕 ♥ ️
that's why she is my bias. ❤
Same💕
True
Same😁
Minnie’s vocal range is so wide from low to high. She’s really amazing!
I love when Yuqi and Minnie Unnie singing scared to be lonely
My bias in (G)I-dle! Not only has an amazing voice, but also a bubbly personality and various talents!
Let's face it. Minnie is a bird. She also whistles like one❤💜
She is the human ver. Of a bird
can I just say Minnie with bangs looks so different to me than Minnie without it's so weird but cool
DekuIsAble i feel like she looks better without bangs but i mean she’s pretty either way haha.
For real, I get shocked too
I really like when she sings in english
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's covers. Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
Her voice is so dreamy. The type of indie pop song that famous in Korea like bol4
She's so pretty with long brown hair but so gorgeous in black hair with bangs
her voice reminds me of bol4 when she does less stronger songs
So true!! 🤯🤯🤯
I was really agree with that
Minnie, I love you 😍
รักเลยพี่มินนี่
Love you so much Minnie
She and Rosé have the most unique voices, I really love Minnie's voice it sounds heavenly but also powerful and badass! She can hit those high notes like a QUEEN. Especially when singing in English
5:52 Minnie singing birdy is just perfect
think the same!
Birdy by who if you dnt mind me asking
@@Yesimlexx it’s shelter by birdy I believe cmiiw
Let's just accept the fact that we all want to have a voice like Minnie..... It's so soft.... Dreamy.... Creamy..wai- nvm. Not creamy. I mean just listen to that voice.... Once she sings a powerful song damn. Her voice is strong!👏👏 We stan A QUEEN like her!
CREAMY LMAOOOO
Ice Nice 😂 😂 😂 CREAMY, just how did you think of that????????
It's smoooth and buttery lol
First things first, Minnie and Yuqi need to release the full cover of Scared to be Lonely. Then Minnie needs a big collab with either Troye Sivan or Zedd or David Guetta. Then I can die happy.
When she sings in english it seems like her natural voice but when she sings in korean it sounds a little forced
@tea yes ik they learn english so she must feel a lot more comfortable singing in english than korean bc she has more experience with english
In my youtube channel you'll find a lot of minnie's covers . Please go check them ❤❤ I love you
@@yourfavmorena Her fluency and comfort with English, I believe, is more of a personal achievement than a success of the Thai education system. This is partly due to the teaching methods that focuses heavily on grammar rather than usage, broken sentences and poor accent (especially taught by teachers in public schools), and very little opportunity to use English in daily life. Quite a lot of Thais really struggle with English despite learning English from an early age. In fact, Thais on average score very low on English standard tests like Toefl, toeic and IELTS. Thailand is one of the lowest scoring nation in Southeast Asia and Asia at large. As a Thai, I am really disappointed with the country, because it always fail to set up a proper support system for any field of expertise to help people with talent to showcase, develop and nurture their talent into fruition. Talented people here needs to find a way for themselves, so many missed opportunities because they have talent but lack finance to help them getting their talents developed.
I think it has a lot to do with the common sounds in Korean. They require a different type of mouth shape and pronunciation than English words and in singing, pronunciation can have a huge impact on overall sound.
Dont forget that minnie is frok thailand
She eats CDs for breakfast,lunch and dinner. Proved.
I hate how she's always brought down just because she has more lines than Miyeon. And how everyone say that she shouldn't be a main vocalist and Miyeon is better🤦 It makes me so mad. She is an amazing singer with emotional, unique voice who can sing highnotes perfectly live - what else do you want from main vocal???? She's so underrated. I love how interesting and emotional her songs sound. I'm waiting for her solo debiut!
Ikr..all who said that just dumb solo stan(miyeon stn of coz) Minnie voice is versatile.. Like she can go deeper, high, smooth, dreamy etc... Meanwhile miyeon.. U know her voice not versitle yet wonderful... bcoz minnie suit all genre ..who can be blamed right
Minnie gets more highs notes than Miyeon
(Edit) Im not saying who is worse, I only saying that Minnie gets more highs notes than Miyeon, both are so Good singing, its only my opinion.
SpRinKles PaRtY they are both main vocals and (G)I-DLE hasn’t been active that long. I bet Miyeon will get more high parts in the next comebacks
No no please no need comparing
Well both of them are main vocalists and they choose who suit the part the most....
@Jimin’s Beans Obviously she is not. Don't be ...oh come on that maybe just a white fact just like this guy is taller than that guy. You don't need to go for highest tone ever in the world to be the best singer. The most successful singers have difference high note their voice can reach or even they don't want that high note in their songs.
And I guess Minnie high notes is better than Miyeon’s.
I'm crying 😭. Her voice is so beautiful.
Whistling in tune is a hard thing to do, because the tune of the whistle does not depend on your vocal chords but how you move your tongue. She has got a hard skill done right!
and then there is me who cant even whistle
best vocalist of 4th gen, periodt.
I wish she had sung with Hwasa "I wish you were gay". :'v I think it would sounded better.
Ayala Liz Honestly same
BUT key is perfect
Yes same. But maybe Hwasa feels awkward to just turn down (the pushy) Kei. She literally went beyond by giving Hwasa food and proving herself that she really wanted to be in Hwas's team. If I were Hwasa too, I'll be torn between the two. But because Minnie already gave her up, Hwasa then decided to just stick to Kei.
Ayala Liz IKR!😔
I think key did really well but if it was Minnie it will be better for the pronunciation
she has such a pretty voice I’m seriously in love and I suddenly want a solo album
Her vocals in All That Jazz HOLY-
cant even whistle damn this girl is national treasure
Show this video to everyone who thinks Minnie is only sweet and dreamy. OUR QUEEN BELTS WHEN SHE NEEDS TOO. She sounds spectacular singing in every language. One of the most unique vocals in K-Pop. I hope she continues to get more and more love.
I really want her to have more collabs or at least officially released covers so she can show more of her range. We just don’t get to hear enough of it and I need more 🥺
idle is the first girl group i officially stan in my entire 6 years with kpop and minnie is my first ever girl ultimate bias. her voice makes me happy, gives me chills, she is exteremely beautiful in my eyes and even so she is so talented, like she can talk or sing 24/7 and i will just listen her while crying about how precious she is. IS THIS LOVE wHaT ARE YOU DOIn TO ME
Yeah
She could be easily the main vocal 😍
Sthefany She is, along with Miyeon.
@@christinafucci396 She's the leader vocal and Miyeon the main vocal
Sthefany They’re both main vocals.
She is main vocalist with Miyeon
@@sthefany955 she is a main vocalist along with Miyeon since debut lol
I need a full studio version of idontwannabeyouanymore
Damn that was a lot to type😂
The best Main Vocal❤️
her voice is so stable and unique omg I think I am her fan
I love her voice
(G)I-DLE is so lucky to have 6 girls with their own style in every way
Every member of Gidle has a very distinct voice. ❤️
Minnie climbing a position for being one of the great lead vocalist and the way she harmonize was so great 😘😘
She's a main vocalist along with miyeon you dumb fuck
She is a main vocalist along with Miyeon... Since debut lol
GamerKC Plays rude much
GamerKC Plays woah chill
@@gamerkcplays774 that's kinda rude..
5:46 Soojin kissed Minnie 🤭🤭
Lmao she can kiss Minnie but not Shuhua 😂😂 poor shushu if she saw that xD
Hyunieee :3 th-cam.com/video/gNp-GkXUd1Q/w-d-xo.html check this out 😂
oh my god
Minnie out here serving us the best vocals 😍
Im in love Minnie's voice
I wish Yuqi's voice have the same attention as Minnie's ♥️
but it has, she is the most popular in the group
Yuqi is already the most popular in the group??? Why can't Minnie get some attention for once?
Tung tung.. another bop song of her
Her voice is pure gold, super stable and dreamy, one of the best vocalist in Kpop for me. She can rap too! G-Idle is a very very talented group, all the members are good at singing, that includes Soyeon. Cube ent., pls let her sing a good kdrama ost and I know that she'd blow up for sure.
I dont care abt yall keep comparing her voices in different languages i love her voice either way
Minnie looks so different without BANGS
I really love her
Her voice is really amazing and unique. I can listen Minnie sing fir hours
Woww..... just wow....
Minnie is the best vocal...
Her voice is so full of individuality (the very rare and beautiful voice) and makes me get immersed into her singing..
8 mins went so quick and omg i want to see the full version of every single video you combined..
Just wow, she is so good
If she would have been an western singer i feel like she would be like an indie singer or something
Definitelly indie, she reminds me of birdie (not their voices but their way of singing)
Wendell Araujo yeah or AURORA
@@fade5889 DEFINITELLY
@@fade5889 her voice does remind me. of aurora especially at 6:30
Her voice quality tho! Omg it’s outstanding it’s like you know those official studio version recording compared to like actual live voice, her live voice sounds EXACTLY like the official studio version 😍😭 her voice is so heavenly
And here it is, ladies and gentlemen, the best female vocalist of the 4th generation. ;)
Of course yes Minnie one of the best main vocalist.
minnie always slayed it all~~
Minnie's voice is more opened and relaxed when she sings in english, that's it.
I am so in love with her voice😭
i want to see her singing "i love you 3000"
MINNIE IS A GEM!
why are Thailand idols so talented and beautiful? Like their always my bias lisa blackpink Bambam got7 sorn clc and Minnie ;-;
her voice is so angelic omg❤
Minnie is soooo pretty
This vid just made me realize that she looks way better without bangs.
Agreed. Her senorita era for me was by far the best, it shows how elegant and sassy she is, but minnie with bangs gives out different vibe, its a mix of powerful and cute. I love her both ways
@@emedquiz so true
I think the bangs helped her stand out
Agree
Minne my love
So perfect
She's so talented omfg
I have two female singers in k-pop culture which i won't get bored to hear them sing.
One is Ji Young from Bol4
The other one is Minnie from (G)i-dle
She honestly sounds like an angel
stan minnie. THAT'S IT.
Totally adorable
2:05 HOLYSHHHHTTTT SHE SANG MY FAVORITE SONG 'SWEATER WEATHER' BY THE NEIGHBOURHOOD! 💕🙊
Her high note in LION was the only high note that surprised me in my whole life and made me stan her.
Wow just Minnie can do it so amazing, her face her smile voice vocal aura gesture cheerful and her personality is so awesome ❤️😍😍
I love minnie's part in latata. She did it in sexy way🔥🔥🔥
One of my favorite voices in kpop
best voice/vocal in kpop industry.
Minnie💖
Minnie’s voice sounds better in English it is because she sings her genre. She gets the diversity in Kpop which shows her range of vocal. Shows how versatile she is 👌🏻
Minnie: *Secretly Stans Ikon,Bts*
Us: 😮😮😮 "where is the calibration button?"
You mean collaboration?
omfg she’d come solo or be in a group and still be a successful artist i bet
2:06 what an angel
title?
The fact that she’s thai and gained more fan base than her fellow band mate is a whole another of flex
Why? She deserves more fans than the rest of gidle or something?
Omg my Minnie have a soft sound and beautiful💖💖❤💙💙💛💚❤😭
Out of her voice is amazing but also her charming is attractive me so much
Her voice is so unique😍❤
She is my favourite main vocalist alongside with wendy
I actually prefer gidle vocal than any other gg
I freaking in love with her parts in Oh My God in all versions (eng, kor and japanese)
Can we take a moment to apreciate her whistle skills 😍
Minnie the best.