If Sean had guessed the type right, I think his bottle guess would count, but he essentially guessed Obtanium Light Whiskey for Obtainium Canadian Whiskey. It’d be like giving a point if he guessed EH Taylor and Bourbon but it was EH Taylor Rye.
Saying obtainium is like saying Nulu. If the bottle guess is a specific bottle rather than a brand then no points. Now had it been obtainium light whiskey rather than Canadian I would have said yes points because, in my opinion, by guessing light whiskey and then just writing obtainium you were guessing Obtainium LW.
If you would have counted Dan's "old Carter" then you should count Sean's "obtainium" because "old Carter" also has bourbon, rye, American under the label.
I’m on team smashers but they did not get a point for light whiskey because it is Canadian whiskey. Hence the bottle is obtainium Canadian whiskey and not light whiskey.
Isn't the type part of the bottle guess (obtanium light whiskey)? This shows how petty Vampire is when he's in a "competition". He's gonna get 5 or 10 points on the timer category like he does every year and he's arguing for a 1/2 point...
I'm Team Sean all day long, but nope, gotta agree with Dan, calling Obtanium on it's own would be like calling "Stagg". It's Obtanium Canadian, so clearly not Obtanium Light. I might give Sean half a point if it was clearly indicated "Obtanium Canadian (Light Whiskey)" on the bottle or similar, but it does not have it.
If Sean had guessed the type right, I think his bottle guess would count, but he essentially guessed Obtanium Light Whiskey for Obtainium Canadian Whiskey. It’d be like giving a point if he guessed EH Taylor and Bourbon but it was EH Taylor Rye.
By Sean's own logic he thought it was obtanium light whiskey, which it isn't so that's a no on the bottle guess
Dan wrote that it’s whiskey, 1/2 point as well.
I think for this year, non point, I think next year instead of bottle guess it should be distillery guess, plus 1 for bottle snipe
Sean you got the point for obtainium
Half point. Have a little Christmas spirit!
Try the new limited 70th bottle from Wild turkey
Had Sean said Canadian than maybe but I would say no to the bottle guess and the the type. The type is a wash so it doesn't really matter.
Can’t miss the whiskey type and get the bottle guess pt. He guessed obtanium light and it wasn’t that. No point.
The madness continues!
How is hazmat light whiskey
Half point for the bottle guess. Obtanium was correct but definitely differentiate between the Light and Canadian. I mean I probably couldn't...
No points Sean!
Light Whiskey is a category of American Whiskey. It's like what Canada calls base whiskey which is basically produced the same.
Saying that particular Canadian whiskey isn’t light whiskey is like saying Jack Daniels Tennessee whiskey isn’t bourbon
This is why we can't have Pour Guesses.
No on the bottle guess
Saying obtainium is like saying Nulu. If the bottle guess is a specific bottle rather than a brand then no points. Now had it been obtainium light whiskey rather than Canadian I would have said yes points because, in my opinion, by guessing light whiskey and then just writing obtainium you were guessing Obtainium LW.
Moose knuckle writes like a cop
Instead of half time, you should just double the time it takes to record the guesses.
1/2 a point button
No on the bottle guess. If someone’s bottle guess is too vague, they should be asked to clarify before the envelope is opened.
Here for day 9
The wheels have fallen off
1/2 pt
Obtainium line differentiates light whiskey from Canadian, no point.
points to the snowman, nothing for santa pouring his stuff out
If you would have counted Dan's "old Carter" then you should count Sean's "obtainium" because "old Carter" also has bourbon, rye, American under the label.
Give him the point, he probably needs the wedges more.
I’m on team smashers but they did not get a point for light whiskey because it is Canadian whiskey. Hence the bottle is obtainium Canadian whiskey and not light whiskey.
Kevin Wightman! FTW!
Isn't the type part of the bottle guess (obtanium light whiskey)? This shows how petty Vampire is when he's in a "competition". He's gonna get 5 or 10 points on the timer category like he does every year and he's arguing for a 1/2 point...
1/2 point for tie-breaker, which won't matter.
1/2 point
No points for the obtanium.
No Point
Sean gets the half point
No points for bottle. Maybe the guy that wrote the card is a draftsman or an engineer/ architect?
I'm Team Sean all day long, but nope, gotta agree with Dan, calling Obtanium on it's own would be like calling "Stagg". It's Obtanium Canadian, so clearly not Obtanium Light. I might give Sean half a point if it was clearly indicated "Obtanium Canadian (Light Whiskey)" on the bottle or similar, but it does not have it.
Ol left Jack
Sean not only should it be zero points cause it’s not light whiskey…let’s face it, Dan needs all the help he can get so far
Dan is a crybaby all the time
Give him the point.
and I'm #teamdan
No points
Dan is right....
Sean definitely shouldn’t get a point for that. He guessed the wrong bottle…pretty simple logic.
No point
Don’t know how you can get credit for bottle pick when you can’t get the type of whiskey right
No point for a bottle guess
où est le savant?
Sean should get half of a point
Kinda feels like both of you are just phoning this in. Maybe better next year.
Nah I'm with Sir Servant on this one no point!
#TEAMSEAN LETS GO!
I'd give it to him. Minus 5 for Dan every time he says he's "jacked"
Sean gets a point. #TeamSean
full point for team smashers button
No point
no point