About the magnets, you're correct that the force is equally strong before and after. But force acts as an acceleration, meaning it's depending on time. And since the rocket's velocity is higher after than before, the time spent is lower. In other terms, the magnetic force is lowering quicker than it increased, thus the deceleration is smaller than the acceleration. Of course you can cut the magnetic field for better performance, but that's not a requirement. That's how a Gauss cannon works.
doesn't the fact that the rocket's repulsion magnetic field match the repulsion of the ring as soon as he crosses the center and it would accelerate more by magnetic repulsion? Not sure If I worded this right, but the magnet attracts toward the ring, and repels on the other side? Wouldn't that be a double acceleration factor rather than just being pulled back after he enters the ring?
@@camerontredway5294 See the magnetic field of the rocket in the animation before it passes through. It is not just one pole, the rocket acts as a two poles magnet, in the same direction as the ring magnet. So after passing through the ring and the rocket still attracts themselves, each with the opposite pole than before.
@@Slgjgnz@camerontredway5294 just asking because i dont know, but wouldn't/doesn't the fact of it being a coil play a factor also??? Im a car guy so I was thinkng like the internal coils in an alternator or a starter selonoid.
Gauss cannon uses electromagnets which turn off right when a projectile reaches the center of the coil to prevent the projectile from slowing down after it passes the coil. Time does not affect anything in this case. These have to be electromagnets on the video.
"how is that hat creating thrust with no atmosphere" i like how thats what he decides to nitpick and not "how is he getting that close to a star and not getting absolutely disintegrated"
Also, I think the major difference is that stickman was originally pointing the rocket up, which doesn't actually extend your fall into an orbit but instead just delays your impact. After he realized, he turned the rocket so that it burned prograde on the horizon, which DOES turn your fall into an orbit. Also, while this normally wouldn't be enough to go against the gravity of an entire star, the rocket does behave like a bull or horse because funny cartoon, so his kicks might've given it motivation or something?
@@link_team3855 When i was a kid, we had an old TV that sometimes got a red screen and my dad told me to hit it on top, then the screen came back. Then we got a brand new TV, the latest shit on the market (still was way before flat screens) and the TV channel my parents were watching had a red transition between commercials. So i saw the red and swung my arm and while swinging to hit it my parents screamed dramatically "NOOO DON'T DO IIIIIT!"
I choose to believe that the stickman is playing by animation rules, and simply trying to understand the rules of physics. He sees a physical force, looks at the way it works in a vacuum, and then uses it from that point on only when it befits him. Like, when he’s falling into the black hole; he doesn’t get ripped apart, because he doesn’t have any pieces; he is one entity, and that is all he is. But you know what *can’t* get ripped apart? A Plank Length sized animation, that’s what. So he gets smaller- it’s not like he *needs* to be any given size, anyways.
Um actually, for the Lorentz factor, velocity is the abscissa... The factor is close to 1 for anything below 50% of c, but tends to infinity at extremely high speed approaching c. Meaning space and time are approximately normal for us, but near c time is extremely dilated: the faster you move through space the slower you move through time.
Animation vs Physics is the sequel to Amination vs Mathmatics. When TSC transports at the end of AvM, he appears in space to start his adventures in AvP...e sent him there.
Technically a star does have an atmosphere; the corona. Our sun’s corona is somehow hotter than the surface, but in this animation universe that stick figure is literally named “The Second Coming” so if anyone could make a cowboy hat be the difference between falling into a star and going around it; it’s them.
The previous vid from Alan's channel was Animation vs. Physics. Would be dope if he dives into every type of science like geography, chemistry, or computer science.
In March, astronomers watched for the first time as the jets launched from the active heart of a galaxy powered by a feeding supermassive black hole switched direction and pointed straight at Earth. The galaxy, PBC J2333.9-2343, located around 656 million light-years from Earth, had been seen emitting jets but had appeared to fall quiet until firing up again and realigning its jet by 90 degrees to point at Earth. The team behind the observation described this as "a very exceptional case of jet reorientation." Something to think about ??????? Keep looking up 🤠
There is a team, but only the animators (as well as the composer and sound designers and a few others). All of the story for this as well as Animation VS Math (which you sadly failed to get to thus far BTW) is done by a nerdy lead animator called Terkoiz. And there are a few mistakes in the video but the non-theoretical phenomena seem mostly accurate
I think it was 10^95-10^110 years for the last supermassive blackholes to die off. An exact number is hard, because of varying sizes and the possibility of collisions to extend the timer. So it's within a range of only 15 orders of magnitude
Thanks for this your reaction video on animation vs physics. I also suggest you the prequel of this video - animation vs math. It's as great as this video. And thanks again fir what you fid in this video. That was very interesting and gave a lot of knowledge.👍👍👍
Next is vs. math, and then vs. geometry for now. I'm waiting for the biology video. Everyone only ever remembers shit about the mitochondria. I agree whole heartedly with how awesome and bright our future could be as not only a species, but for the whole planet. Not to mention forming bridges to other planets. Another aspect I hope is covered in the biology video, mass extinction events. Which for the certain coming calamity, i hope we'll be ready for.
No can do, MrLBoyd! Pluto is a dwarf planet by definition, as is Ceres, which is the largest object in the asteroid belt. Eris, Makemake, and Haumea are the remaining dwarf planets in our solar system. And, yes, all hail Carl Sagan, truly one of the most beautiful beings made of star stuff to ever inhabit this pale blue dot!
"Magnetic energy is much stronger than gravity" Oh for sure, electromagnetism is far stronger than gravity, even on celestial scales, its just that until you reach the scale of a supermassive black hole, something that is so packed with energy that radiates out as charged particles and loses energy by generating absolutely gigantic electromagnetic fields, it doesn't quite hold up to simple attraction between massive objects. Its electromagnetic force that binds spiral galaxies together, that's why the EM storms the Sun generates cause so many major effects down on Earth, like its 150-odd year cycle of activity where it blasts charged particles at the Earth and overloads the geomagnetic field and ends up frying fragile electrical conductors, like HV wires and the grid's massive power transformers and low-nanometer non-radiation-hardened non-EMP-hardened microprocessors. Frankly, the effects of electromagnetism are both incredible to witness and frightening to behold the power of, to the point that gravity is almost certainly the celestial-scale analog of the weak nuclear force compared to EM being the celestial-scale analog of the strong nuclear force. That part is very interesting to theorize about in my opinion, we known the WNF and SNF are related, and are two of the four fundamental forces, so why wouldn't gravity and electromagnetism be related also, only being macro-scale compared to the nuclear forces micro-scale effect? I don't know, it makes sense to me.
16:20 my guess is that by the time stick man reaches the other side of the magnet he already gained momentum and the poles are switched as he exits the magnet so he’s also being propelled by that as well. Not sure though someone please fact check me
if i recall correctly solar sails are a thing... you literally use the heat a surface area to create movement... now, given a hat is probably not enough to be able to escape a suns gravity, but it is a technical method of production of thrust regardless of atmosphere... even if in reality it would be miniscule as all hell...
4:15 demographic lol. probably ppl that at some point saw stick figure fights. and so alan made a stick figure... fight the animator. (thats where it started anyway, then minecraft happened.) EX: one of the actual shorts is others playing with a slimball trying to make basket ball... Cobweb was the first choice for a 'hoop' but it kinda sucked. Orange walks over, and the next thing he knows his head is the hoop.
Chemical feul can only go up to a maximum speed. Gauss on the other hand doesn't really have a maximum speed. The limiting factor of Gauss or essentially a railgun is the amount of electrical power you can dump into the system. Unless man can find a Chemical feul source that can exponentially increase the speed of a ship, Gauss or Railgun technology will be the best path forward.
@zakaris7259 as long as it isn't another super massive black hole, not much. If it is a super massive black hole, then the time it takes will go up. 10^105 years is a good estimate for an especially large black hole.
Although I understand your point of positive to negative and negative to positive being attracted in each direction but the pull in one direction multiplied by the repel in the opposite direction but the polarity would have to flip as the ship passes through the magnetic field
probably way out of my depth here but I would assume since the charges on the ship were set opposite to the rings the front of the ring would pull you in and the back of the ring would push away and with greater frorce due to the momentum gained from the initial pull force but I can't be certain I'm terrible at math so I can't do tge necessary calculations
I'm not saying Pluto is the cause of all of our problems; I'm just saying it might not have been the wisest idea to enrage the God of War by denouncing the planet named after him...
On the part with the frictionless floor when he was using the momentum to get to the lther side, if the friction was 0, wouldnt he get to the other side with just one throw? Since he woundnt slow down?
You're missing a couple of things that equal, roughly, the same result. Oversights and cartoon logic. There seems to be some intentional glossing over, as well. I believe the change of trajectory, towards the sun, was just wrong. There is a definite disconnect between the visuals representations, aside from the actual equations, and the physics.
I think your thinking way to much into the hat. Maybe the hat just controls the rocket and doesn’t actually have any effect on the space or ‘atmosphere’ around it.
I don't know much about this, but my best guess is the polarity of the Magnets... When he was going through the rings, His magnet and the rings are set Blue to the left (forward) red to the Right (Behind) so as he approaches a ring, His Blue gets Pulled by the Rings red, then as he passes through the center, his Red hits the rings Blue and pushes him away with the same force it was originally pulling him in with. When he is coming to a new Ring, it's Red pulls his Blue, and when he is leaving g a ring, It's Blue pushes his Red.
17:00 - in. Maybe you are not wrong, it is animation. Like the 'big bang theory' it is all in your belief system. I just like picking on you evolutionists, science always changes.
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
Many!
Many, ..
Many years later...
Many
Many!
die daaglikse nuus
Nou kan jy beelde vertaal!
About the magnets, you're correct that the force is equally strong before and after. But force acts as an acceleration, meaning it's depending on time. And since the rocket's velocity is higher after than before, the time spent is lower. In other terms, the magnetic force is lowering quicker than it increased, thus the deceleration is smaller than the acceleration.
Of course you can cut the magnetic field for better performance, but that's not a requirement.
That's how a Gauss cannon works.
doesn't the fact that the rocket's repulsion magnetic field match the repulsion of the ring as soon as he crosses the center and it would accelerate more by magnetic repulsion? Not sure If I worded this right, but the magnet attracts toward the ring, and repels on the other side? Wouldn't that be a double acceleration factor rather than just being pulled back after he enters the ring?
@@camerontredway5294 See the magnetic field of the rocket in the animation before it passes through. It is not just one pole, the rocket acts as a two poles magnet, in the same direction as the ring magnet. So after passing through the ring and the rocket still attracts themselves, each with the opposite pole than before.
@@Slgjgnz@camerontredway5294 just asking because i dont know, but wouldn't/doesn't the fact of it being a coil play a factor also??? Im a car guy so I was thinkng like the internal coils in an alternator or a starter selonoid.
@@AJ-nh8ik The selonoid is what makes the whole rocket polarized when the magnet is applied on it, making the cannon possible.
Gauss cannon uses electromagnets which turn off right when a projectile reaches the center of the coil to prevent the projectile from slowing down after it passes the coil. Time does not affect anything in this case. These have to be electromagnets on the video.
The hat isn’t meant to create thrust, it’s meant to create dramatic flare.
Its meant to show you the direction TSC is looking at as its in 3D
@@itzg.i.g.1256 Oh. Yes, I suppose that is also true, but I was clarifying about the scene with the star, as that does confuse alot of people.
SOLAR FLARE!!!! 🎉
"how is that hat creating thrust with no atmosphere" i like how thats what he decides to nitpick and not "how is he getting that close to a star and not getting absolutely disintegrated"
12:40 stars also have atmospheres. It's called the corona and it's a lot denser than earth's atmosphere
Also, I think the major difference is that stickman was originally pointing the rocket up, which doesn't actually extend your fall into an orbit but instead just delays your impact. After he realized, he turned the rocket so that it burned prograde on the horizon, which DOES turn your fall into an orbit.
Also, while this normally wouldn't be enough to go against the gravity of an entire star, the rocket does behave like a bull or horse because funny cartoon, so his kicks might've given it motivation or something?
@@hunnyjar8937 it's the same with electric devices, if it's not working or too slow just hit it
@@doragonsureia7288 percussive maintenance ALWAYS works
(except when it doesnt, i guess...)
@@link_team3855 When i was a kid, we had an old TV that sometimes got a red screen and my dad told me to hit it on top, then the screen came back.
Then we got a brand new TV, the latest shit on the market (still was way before flat screens)
and the TV channel my parents were watching had a red transition between commercials. So i saw the red and swung my arm and while swinging to hit it my parents screamed dramatically "NOOO DON'T DO IIIIIT!"
I choose to believe that the stickman is playing by animation rules, and simply trying to understand the rules of physics. He sees a physical force, looks at the way it works in a vacuum, and then uses it from that point on only when it befits him.
Like, when he’s falling into the black hole; he doesn’t get ripped apart, because he doesn’t have any pieces; he is one entity, and that is all he is. But you know what *can’t* get ripped apart? A Plank Length sized animation, that’s what. So he gets smaller- it’s not like he *needs* to be any given size, anyways.
The solar winds are bouncing off the hat, so propulsion lol
Please do "Animation vs Math" Its so good aswell. Loved the reaction, as always.
You're forgetting that he's a stickman. He doesn't have the same mass as a human.
3:20 The Chosen One is 50 kg, i believe..
Why do you believe that?@@alphawolf8437
Also the rocket has mass
@@alphawolf8437 that's not the chosen one btw.
Um actually, for the Lorentz factor, velocity is the abscissa...
The factor is close to 1 for anything below 50% of c, but tends to infinity at extremely high speed approaching c. Meaning space and time are approximately normal for us, but near c time is extremely dilated: the faster you move through space the slower you move through time.
This is a great video, but Animation vs. Math is better. A solid masterpiece. Check that one out, if you could.
I think he did, but I could be misremembering
Nah I prefer this one
Due to the text and dotted significations of the physics concepts, this video is a slightly greater production in my opinion.
@@phanquan9470 same, i just love everything space related so that's that
Animation vs Physics is the sequel to Amination vs Mathmatics. When TSC transports at the end of AvM, he appears in space to start his adventures in AvP...e sent him there.
Rocket riding cowboy is a reference to "Dr. Strangelove".....(I think) old movie about the A bomb
And the apple is because newton
Yes!
Technically a star does have an atmosphere; the corona. Our sun’s corona is somehow hotter than the surface, but in this animation universe that stick figure is literally named “The Second Coming” so if anyone could make a cowboy hat be the difference between falling into a star and going around it; it’s them.
That was equal parts brilliant and dangerous.....
I'm off to rabbit hole. I may be some time.
Technically a magnetasphere can be a type of atmosphere
Also the magnetic thrust is based on rail guns
17:01 I was thinking like the magnets flipped
From nasa’s website: “photosphere, chromosphere, and corona are all part of the Sun's atmosphere”
"What's the demographic for this?"
EVERYONE
Animation vs Math next!!
The previous vid from Alan's channel was Animation vs. Physics. Would be dope if he dives into every type of science like geography, chemistry, or computer science.
its to my belief that the prequel to this is the animations vs mathematics
Please react to Animator vs Animation 1-4. It's kinda where this whole "Animation vs" thing began, and they're short enough to combine into one video
You said two things, 'Make Pluto a planet again and hail Carl Sagan' subed
It absolutely is a series. Animation vs Education
In March, astronomers watched for the first time as the jets launched from the active heart of a galaxy powered by a feeding supermassive black hole switched direction and pointed straight at Earth.
The galaxy, PBC J2333.9-2343, located around 656 million light-years from Earth, had been seen emitting jets but had appeared to fall quiet until firing up again and realigning its jet by 90 degrees to point at Earth. The team behind the observation described this as "a very exceptional case of jet reorientation."
Something to think about ??????? Keep looking up 🤠
There is a team, but only the animators (as well as the composer and sound designers and a few others). All of the story for this as well as Animation VS Math (which you sadly failed to get to thus far BTW) is done by a nerdy lead animator called Terkoiz. And there are a few mistakes in the video but the non-theoretical phenomena seem mostly accurate
many
33:46 I agree.
i love this
Did anyone else think the latter half of this video felt like Interstellar? The music was epic
Leonard Suskind... M Theory (as in membrane) not String Theory, Was postulated upon a few yrs later I believe
I think it was 10^95-10^110 years for the last supermassive blackholes to die off. An exact number is hard, because of varying sizes and the possibility of collisions to extend the timer. So it's within a range of only 15 orders of magnitude
You gotta react to Animation vs Math next xD
Thanks for this your reaction video on animation vs physics. I also suggest you the prequel of this video - animation vs math. It's as great as this video. And thanks again fir what you fid in this video. That was very interesting and gave a lot of knowledge.👍👍👍
Next is vs. math, and then vs. geometry for now. I'm waiting for the biology video. Everyone only ever remembers shit about the mitochondria. I agree whole heartedly with how awesome and bright our future could be as not only a species, but for the whole planet. Not to mention forming bridges to other planets. Another aspect I hope is covered in the biology video, mass extinction events. Which for the certain coming calamity, i hope we'll be ready for.
25:50
time travel has ALWAYS been a thing...
its just easier to go forwards
No can do, MrLBoyd! Pluto is a dwarf planet by definition, as is Ceres, which is the largest object in the asteroid belt. Eris, Makemake, and Haumea are the remaining dwarf planets in our solar system. And, yes, all hail Carl Sagan, truly one of the most beautiful beings made of star stuff to ever inhabit this pale blue dot!
"Magnetic energy is much stronger than gravity" Oh for sure, electromagnetism is far stronger than gravity, even on celestial scales, its just that until you reach the scale of a supermassive black hole, something that is so packed with energy that radiates out as charged particles and loses energy by generating absolutely gigantic electromagnetic fields, it doesn't quite hold up to simple attraction between massive objects. Its electromagnetic force that binds spiral galaxies together, that's why the EM storms the Sun generates cause so many major effects down on Earth, like its 150-odd year cycle of activity where it blasts charged particles at the Earth and overloads the geomagnetic field and ends up frying fragile electrical conductors, like HV wires and the grid's massive power transformers and low-nanometer non-radiation-hardened non-EMP-hardened microprocessors. Frankly, the effects of electromagnetism are both incredible to witness and frightening to behold the power of, to the point that gravity is almost certainly the celestial-scale analog of the weak nuclear force compared to EM being the celestial-scale analog of the strong nuclear force. That part is very interesting to theorize about in my opinion, we known the WNF and SNF are related, and are two of the four fundamental forces, so why wouldn't gravity and electromagnetism be related also, only being macro-scale compared to the nuclear forces micro-scale effect? I don't know, it makes sense to me.
16:20 my guess is that by the time stick man reaches the other side of the magnet he already gained momentum and the poles are switched as he exits the magnet so he’s also being propelled by that as well. Not sure though someone please fact check me
Actually I think that is the case bc if you look at 14:26 it shows the solenoid has 2 poles
if i recall correctly solar sails are a thing... you literally use the heat a surface area to create movement... now, given a hat is probably not enough to be able to escape a suns gravity, but it is a technical method of production of thrust regardless of atmosphere... even if in reality it would be miniscule as all hell...
4:15
demographic lol.
probably ppl that at some point saw stick figure fights.
and so alan made a stick figure... fight the animator. (thats where it started anyway, then minecraft happened.)
EX: one of the actual shorts is others playing with a slimball trying to make basket ball... Cobweb was the first choice for a 'hoop' but it kinda sucked.
Orange walks over, and the next thing he knows his head is the hoop.
20:37 hilarious boyd
Chemical feul can only go up to a maximum speed. Gauss on the other hand doesn't really have a maximum speed.
The limiting factor of Gauss or essentially a railgun is the amount of electrical power you can dump into the system.
Unless man can find a Chemical feul source that can exponentially increase the speed of a ship, Gauss or Railgun technology will be the best path forward.
A super massive black hole can survive for a minimum of 10^100 years, according to current predictions.
what if it merges with another black hole before that
@zakaris7259 as long as it isn't another super massive black hole, not much. If it is a super massive black hole, then the time it takes will go up. 10^105 years is a good estimate for an especially large black hole.
I’m guessing with the magnets they are referring to the repelling force?
Although I understand your point of positive to negative and negative to positive being attracted in each direction but the pull in one direction multiplied by the repel in the opposite direction but the polarity would have to flip as the ship passes through the magnetic field
probably way out of my depth here but I would assume since the charges on the ship were set opposite to the rings the front of the ring would pull you in and the back of the ring would push away and with greater frorce due to the momentum gained from the initial pull force but I can't be certain I'm terrible at math so I can't do tge necessary calculations
I'm not saying Pluto is the cause of all of our problems; I'm just saying it might not have been the wisest idea to enrage the God of War by denouncing the planet named after him...
🤣🤣
You should watch the Animation vs math first , and the latest geometry
Do his video animation versus math
Bro in the thumbnail looks horrifyingly horrific.
So how does a railgun work if the magnets were supposed to catch him?
They turn on right as the bullet enters, and turn off right as it leaves the propulshioning force.
On the part with the frictionless floor when he was using the momentum to get to the lther side, if the friction was 0, wouldnt he get to the other side with just one throw? Since he woundnt slow down?
.. only quintillions?
hm. maybe i play idle games too much, i got used to 1e308 being a 'big' number
Just wait until this guy finds out about googology
His hat flew off when he entered the star's corona or whatever that field was.
You're missing a couple of things that equal, roughly, the same result. Oversights and cartoon logic. There seems to be some intentional glossing over, as well. I believe the change of trajectory, towards the sun, was just wrong. There is a definite disconnect between the visuals representations, aside from the actual equations, and the physics.
Haven't watched the full video yet😅 but I wanted to say I love the content! Keep up the great work ! FIRST
I think your thinking way to much into the hat. Maybe the hat just controls the rocket and doesn’t actually have any effect on the space or ‘atmosphere’ around it.
This comes after Math. 🎉
Many to the power of many manys more!
I don't know much about this, but my best guess is the polarity of the Magnets... When he was going through the rings, His magnet and the rings are set Blue to the left (forward) red to the Right (Behind) so as he approaches a ring, His Blue gets Pulled by the Rings red, then as he passes through the center, his Red hits the rings Blue and pushes him away with the same force it was originally pulling him in with.
When he is coming to a new Ring, it's Red pulls his Blue, and when he is leaving g a ring, It's Blue pushes his Red.
4th dimension
Magnets are magic, its as easy as that
17:00 - in. Maybe you are not wrong, it is animation. Like the 'big bang theory' it is all in your belief system. I just like picking on you evolutionists, science always changes.
F Pluto
MANY
Dude it is a stick figure chill.