How does Thay calm down someone in rage? |Thich Nhat Hanh answers questions
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Thich Nhat Hanh answers questions during a retreat in Plum Village (May, 2014).
Question: Have you ever been able to calm down a person who is completely in rage?
-------
Help us caption & translate this video!
amara.org/v/FUS3/
#ThichNhatHanh #mindfulness #PlumVillage
This had me in tears. Hearing of their persecution and how the responded. It takes immense, real strength to respond to this kind of violence with dignity compassion.
Andrew Brady took the words right out my mouth sir!!
Every one of his talks brings me to tears! So glad im not the only one 😶
@@flanigan_a-go-go I would think that the original question pertained to rages on a personal basis - domestic violence, road rage, fight between neighbors, etc. - where the law of the land is on everyone's side. For road rage, yes, it might work to stay quiet and let the flow of traffic move things along. For domestic violence, silence and love have limits.
There are laws. There are social helps. There are friends and family. Be realistic and reach out.
Thay's response pertained to experiences in a rather politically-charged time on a national and even international level. Yes, the teaching called for silence and love, and the reality was that he and the followers had no choice other than to stay silent and be disassembled. The same went for the rest of the country. There was no law. There was only suppression.
I admire him for that. Namo Buddhay.
His unshakable faith and belief on compassion is just out of this world. He's a true bodhisattva, and I'm so thankful for the youtube and internet to make it possible for millions of people like us to be touched by his words and love. Thank you Plumvillageonline for uploading these videos for us!
Such a difficult thing to do. To find those seeds in oneself that would respond in like to violence and transform them into acts of love. Thay is a model of being to reach for.
This is a brilliant question of a teenager! I remember when I was an 18 year old, my private teacher whom I had crush on stepped outside of the room for couple of mins arguing with a parent; he came back raged with agony and was walking heavily with anger. I was paralyzed to talk to him. I didn’t know what to say or do. I just watched him talk, and walk. Still paralyzed and nodding. Couple of mins he was calm down. He sat and we start the session. It was 8 years ago, but I recall it to this day. That was a unique experience to see a stranger be calm down by me just being silent!
-
It was a memory, but after watching this video it became a LESSON ❤
Very educative. I love his videos. I do research on how Buddhism disappeared in Bihar. I realized it never disappeared from Bihar. Buddhists simply failed to research Indian Buddhism. They looked at Buddhism through the sphere of their own cultures searching for only the Buddha. Buddha had a myriad of names in different villages according to his teachings there. Example. His favorite teaching was 'Lust and desire causes pain. Remove lust and desire, and pain is removed'. Translated into Bihari (where the Buddha story took place) it is DHUKH HARAN meaning to remove dukha. Three dozen villages pray to DUKH HARAN Baba. Its clear that DUKH HARAN Baba is none other than the Buddha. Problem is Buddhists are searching only for the Buddha. In the real Vaishali the Buddha begged for alms. The locals there pray to 'BHIKHAINI' Baba (Beggar Baba). Bhikhaini was mispronounced by Buddhists as Bhikshu. Who is BHIKHAINI Baba. The Buddha no doubt. But people are searching for a man called Buddha. In the real Vaishali, in Beluha the Buddha suffered a sickness and felt he had grown old. The locals pray to 'BURHA' Baba (Old Baba). Who is BURHA Baba. The Buddha no doubt. In the real Vaishali the Lichavies pressurized Buddha not to die. They trailed him to Bandagawan pressurizing him not to die. To put pressure in Hindi is DABESHWAR. Three dozen villages around the stupa where Buddha gave the Lichavies his patra, the villagers pray to Baba 'DABESHWAR NATH' meaning the man who won the pressurizing game. It was the the Buddha no doubt as he gave the Lichavies his patra and succeded in sending them back. But Buddhists are searching for the Buddha. Forgive me for commenting out of the topic. I just wanted to impart this information to you.
11:49 “…Sister Chan Khong, “Learning True Love” then a reference to They’s novel, “The Novice” follows.
victims of wrong perception which has given rise to fear
they respond with compassion
Books recommended are :
Learning to Love
and
The Novice
Siempre amorosamente a sus pies,bien amado maestro Thay.¡¡¡
He calms people down by talking really really slow and pausing a lot.
crazieeez correct. By slowing down, your mind is also invited to slow down, and to watch and notice your thoughts as you speak. Many unconscious people in "the world" speak at machine-gun pace, hardly ever taking a breath and not letting others speak. When the mind has been purified, everything begins to slow because time is no longer relevant or necessary. The slow speech of the Master has a certain vibration to it. Within that slow speech is also thoughts that are being watched and observed and allowed to reveal themselves. Thought and speech are connected. This doesn't mean he is a slow-thinker. But rather the opposite.
@@lapislazuli7876 you know who is extremely fast and doesnt need to take a breath, Eminem.. and hes sick. Then again Dr Jordan B Peterson speaks at machine gun speed and and hes brilliant. This man talks too slow for me to pay attention but, thats my problem and maybe I should try to slow down.
Gypsy American try watching on 2x or 1.5 x
@@gypsyamerican6242 Jordan is great. His teaching is straight forward, like a quick remedy to your problem but somewhat makes me feel pressured and not as long-lasting, deep and enlightening as Thich Nhat Hanh's. Just a personal thought
Yes - speaking softly is respectful to the listener
Speeakly slowly allows for breath & provides space for presence ...🌱
Thank You for that!
Your Faith and Love!❤❤🎉
"…enraged
Thich Naht Hanh has survived the Khmer Rouge... what is it do you imagine makes him a wisdom teacher with a message that is timely for this world?
While this is an obvious question in need of direct address for some, it is equally concerning that educated intelligence does not always equate skills in being observant, mature, experienced. Worth discerning...
I don't believe so...Vietnam is close to Cambodia but I have not read this about his history. Khmer Rouge was Cambodia
"In 1969, Nhat Hanh was the delegate for the Buddhist Peace Delegation at the Paris Peace talks. When the Paris Peace Accords were signed in 1973, Thich Nhat Hanh was denied permission to return to Vietnam and he went into exile in France. "
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Th%C3%ADch_Nhất_Hạnh
"During the five years of the Khmer Rouge rebellion from 1970 to 1975, the support of North Vietnam, in conjunction with China, was essential to its eventual triumph.[19] However, even before the Vietnam War ended, the relationship between the Khmer Rouge-which was in the process of seizing power from a US-backed regime headed by Lon Nol-and Vietnam was strained."
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian-Vietnamese_War
Yes- that's my point. I don't mean to insult- it's just ironic because I was going to give you the same link. If you read his history here or elsewhere, nowhere is there mention that he fought the Khmer Rouge and survived them. He was in Vietnam not Cambodia. The section you posted is referring to politics with Cambodia and North Korea so I'm not sure your point. Again, there's not a section you can copy and paste from his history that indicates he survived the KR.
True Bodhisatva
Thank you for this video and for the English subtitles, I have a question, who is Thay? Thanks
Melissa Jenkins right thank you😊
Angela sfdsfd thay actually means teacher in Vietnamese, that's why thich refers to himself as thay
Hi Thay.
behavioralism in a buddist monk
Who is the author of the book he suggested? I can't seem to find it, there are many books named Learning to love.
Sister Chan Khong, Learning True Love.
What is that thumping sound??
RIP🕊🕊🖤🖤
LOVE
u can't tell a lie from the truth. God spent the entire o.t. getting rid of pagans, idolatry and false religions & here u sit before a 3 foot idol believing a man that is a pagan. u can't tell the difference between a lie and the truth and haven't even researched what GOD said.> Rev 21:8 "But the cowardly, the unbelieving, the vile, the murderers, the sexually immoral, those who practice magic arts, the idolaters and all liars-they will be consigned to the fiery lake of burning sulfur. This is the second death".
Jn 5:26 " “Do not be amazed at this, for a time is coming when all who are in their graves will hear his voice and come out - those who have done what is good will rise to live, and those who have done what is evil will rise to be condemned".
Job 7:9 "As a cloud vanishes and is gone, so one who goes down to the grave does not return.
Job 8:12 "While still growing and uncut, they wither more quickly than grass. Such is the destiny of all who forget God; so perishes the hope of the godless".
Job 14:10 "But a man dies & is laid low; he breathes his last & is no more. As the water of a lake dries up,.. so he lies down & does not rise; till the heavens are no more, people will not awake or be roused from their sleep".
Job 16:22 “Only a few years will pass before I take the path of no return"
Lk 23:43 "Jesus answered him, “Truly I tell you, today you will be with me in paradise.”.
Dan 12:2 "Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake: some to everlasting life, others to shame and everlasting contempt.
Heb 9:27 "Just as people are destined to die ONCE, and after that to face judgment,
Ps 78:39 "He remembered that they were but flesh, a passing breeze that does not return".
Jn 9:39 "Jesus said,“For judgment I have come into this world, so that the blind will see and those who see will become blind.”
Lk 16:26 "And besides all this, between us & you [the living & the dead] a great chasm has been set in place, so that those who want to go from here to you cannot, [the living cannot reach the dead] nor can anyone cross over from there to us.[the dead cannot reach the living]" that means all the lies from the rcc about mary 'appearing' on earth are lies from satans own mouth. those who refuse the teachings of God are sent a curse of a reprobaate mind - one in which he no longer can understand the things of heaven. repent! because you're in trouble of being able to enter heaven.
Jesus no offense but is somebody having sex right behind the camera? Whats with that constant slapping noise? I kept getting distracted from his message because of it!
As a Vietnamese, I know there was such resistance towards Thay and other Viet who fled the country during war time. This happened with the old government, which are much more welcoming now. Really hope there would be a plum village in Vietnam soon, in Thay's hometown.
We had communism in Romania too. Half of the history of the country was spent under a communist regime. I think there fact that is banned worldwide is saying words. I hope Vietnam will experience a change of regime and have democracy (not perfect, though better than an illegal regime like communism). 👍🏻
You when wronged: "We do not hate those that have [insert injustice done unto you]. For we know they are victims of wrong perceptions that have given rise to fear and suspicion. We hope they will look and understand us better. Our intention is not to harm them, only to help..."
Once in a while, I come back to take refuge and courage in this marvelous testimony.
Compassion is the only sensible response to rage. To meet rage with rage is foolish. As my beloved uncle taught me, there is no future in anger.
Thank you Thich Nhat Hanh and all of the young monks he talks about, also others living in Plum Villages all over the world for the example, way of life and inspiration to practise mindfulness, and compassion in the face of severe abuse, and violence. This talk touched my heart and soul deeply, and will continue to serve as inspiration and challenge as to how to live my life. Thank you. Thank you.
I wish someone could edit out that distracting noise in the background. Was it a bored kid? A fan? Why did someone present not intervene and stop that? The irony for me is that he's talking about peacefully and effectively dealing with anger and violence, but my reaction to that sound is anger and violent impulses.
You're right, it could have been edited out, and for some reason it wasn't. Yet in time you'll find your watching this same video again and notice the sound without getting upset. You're on the right path, much love
Lol thank you!!! 😂 I couldn’t focus on anything else!
well at least now you know better how to deal with those impulses lol
such a beautiful man, teacher, and bodhisattva
This is so powerful
I have struggled with rage and I realize that it was just wrong perceptions and confusion. What I really was feeling is fear and knowing that makes me want to run and figure out the truth, stick with the facts and avoid my judgements. Also, once you start saying no to abuse, you'll learn who is really on the path. I think understanding is key and avoiding that kind of toxicity is key to a firm enlightened state.
I am so pleased to see him so healthy after his recent illness. Such wisdom and calm. We are so lucky to have his example to follow.
This video was recorded several months ago. Here is the most recent update on his health: plumvillage.org/news/an-update-on-thays-health-3rd-january/
From the description of the video: "Questions and Answers with Thich Nhat Hanh on 12 July 2011"
He is doing well, but not yet back to where he was before his illness.
Thank you for sharing this. Tears of understanding and love.
Incredible this person👌💖🌱💯👌
I adore him , he brought so much peace to humanity 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏⚘⚘⚘
GREAT HONOUR 💖🌱💖 😘
Yes be calm an that will calm them. Don't argue with them, show compassion for them an listen to them. Letting someone vent an just supporting them can mean Alot!
Breathe, be in awareness of awareness....aaaaaahhhhh, just be-ing present.....
Beautiful pure compassion. Inspiration to follow
I think important thing is not to get involved with some one who is in rage. The most important thing is to learn calm your self down first. Some times our buttons get pushed so hard that we cannot avoid rage, the best thing to do at that time is to walk away in a room and scream out loud to ur self rather than having a go at some one else.
Toxic.
It wouldn't be a Plum Village video without some coughing
Lol 😂
Oh my heart ❤
Your teaching has touched my very soul ♥
Thank you for helping
Every one 🌈🙏🌺
Hôm nay chúng con mới được tỏ tường về vụ Bát Nhã. Nhưng đó chỉ là phần phụ thôi, cốt yếu là con được lĩnh ngộ lời dạy của Thầy để áp dụng cho gia đình con. Thú thật, vợ chồng con hay có những mâu thuẫn thường ngày, bất đồng và cãi vã. Từ khi biết vận dụng lời Thầy để cứu vãn hạnh phúc gia đình thì nó có hiệu lực. Nhân đây, con gửi lời cảm ơn (không biết tên cụ thể) bạn nào đã làm cái phụ đề tiếng Việt cho video này. Cảm ơn luôn bạn đã đặt câu hỏi rất hay. Thường thì người phương Tây đặt câu hỏi hay lắm
It is clear to me that dear Thich Nhat Hanh is truly an enlightened being. Nibbana is close for him. I am light years away from it but that is A-okay. I am on a journey. I am whole and great just as I am. I need to always be in the present; I need to be mindful; and I need to be filled with love and compassion. And may I see the emptiness of all phenomena. I sincerely wish love, peace and enlightenment to all.
Good for you knowing this! Yes you don't need fixed because your just as your supposed to be. Nothing wrong with you an you make adjustments when you see the need to.
Thanks for the English subtitle.
At 2:40 Thay says "he did not try to justify himself" .... yup "But Jesus remained silent and gave no answer. " Mark 14:61
Exactly! Outside of Chistian belief, there's the belief that Jesus was heavily influenced by Buddhism. Some Muslim sholars defend this, and there's some archaeological evidence of this in India too.
beautiful isnt it summer sky?
@@surgeeo1406 Sources? I got interested.
@@surgeeo1406 the people who wrote the Bible stories surely was influence by Buddhist thought. Jesus is a made up persona
This is so very wonderful, thank you, dear Thay. Thank you, dear Plum Village Community! 🙏💛
His immense wisdom and humility goes far beyond words. Thanks Thay! Bless you. 🙏🌟🕯🕯🌿
(A pity for that tapping noise, during the lecture, maybe a sound engineer could erase it?).
Yes tapping noise is very distracting!
@@lesleymcmillan1893
Yes!
Perhaps the act of “waging peace” is much harder than “waging war” but, if the culture of peace takes hold; at least we will remove the suffering we create ourselves and be able to turn our attention to mitigating the suffering we already experience without wars.
Pure wisdom. Thank you
Merci Vénérable Thich Nhat Hanh
Longue vie à vous,
P.S. La vidéo est sous-titrée en Français
Sachez que Thay parle parfaitement notre langue.
#action #réaction - Sujet : Colère, jalousie...
Acceptez de se faire insulter ; violenter ou autre en disant oui et Amen n'est pas toujours facile surtout quand cela nous a profondément blessé(e) atteint, détruit #action #réaction !!!!!!! (la réaction annule l'action, celui ou celle qui fait l'insulte par jalousie, par la haine (=> action) doit peut s'attendre à une réaction.... ) - Et si la réaction annule l'action que reste-t-il l'équilibre !!!! Et moi j'aime bien l'équilibre :) - Tout a des limites jusqu'à 1 certain point où il faut agir avec plus de ''personnalité'' cela ne veut pas dire forcément dans la même colère, violence mais avec une certaine fermeté, l'exemple cité par Thay (1 an et demi) prouve pour moi que les '''méchants'''' ont gagnés puisque moines et nonnes devaient fuir ??!!!!
@@L_ange_Indomptable
Oui, c'est en effet ça. De mon expérience, j'ai dû apprendre à me défendre, avec justesse et fermement. Avec des mots que la partie adverse comprends. Depuis l'enfance, j'avais toujours été dans la compassion, la pleine conscience et ayant une patience d'ange, celà m'a deservie plus d'une fois. Hélas. Et, ça m'avais même nuit. Des décenies de vie très dure et de maltraitences non recherchés, m'ont laissé des traces, car je n'ai pas mis le frein de suite, aux autres. Ni suis-je partie, très vite. (Ce n'était pas possible).
Donc, je dirais, que si l'on est déjà une personne bienveillante, aimante et gentille, faites attention de ne pas vous faire épuiser votre patience et votre compassion. Car, hélas, quand vous aurez trop subit, il n y aura plus beaucoup de patience ni de compassion. 🙏🕊
He’s so beyond that he talks of himself as another person. I’d like to get there one day.
very clear an challenging ..... thanks :-)
There are many good ways we can deal with anyone who is in rage either in public or private situation effectively. Mindfulness practice daily in our lives automatically guiding us how to handle all sort of conflicts kindly and successfully🙏
Remember to breathe deeply before applying the five steps of conflict-solution strategies as such: acknowledge it/accept it/embrace it/transform it/letting it go🙏
Using our inner-powers learning through Buddha’s teachings and other experiences to bring peace
to ourselves and other beings🙏
Harmony and Happiness
Are In Our Hands🙏
DAILY PEACE 🙇🏼♂️🇦🇺🙇🏼♂️
Thank you Th
Chúng ta có thể thực hành lời Thầy dạy vào chính những mối quan hệ trong gia đình của chúng ta. Mô Bụt.
I wish the recording was of higher quality, there’s some sort of thumping effect happening. Does anyone have a link to a better recording
Please fix the audio issues! 🙏🏽
J'ai toujours bcp de respect et d'admiration peur ceux qui ont vraiment du faire face à la violence et l'ont affrontée avec la non-violence dans le coeur...de ces personnes-là on peut vraiment accepter un enseignement...c'est, à mon sens, une des choses les plus difficiles.
Tears of gratitude....In deep gassho. Om to the one who leaps beyond all fear.
so much to learn for me... thanks for that humble and lovely lesson.
This changed my life. Thank you
Your beautiful Soul Thay…thank you for your gifts of wisdom and love…
DEEP - do NOT defense - do NOT engage - do NOT explain - do NOT personalize 🙏
Not to respond so easy to say but at times extremely hard to do. Be silent . Have compassion 🙏
Thank you beloved Thay for the sharing of your living experience and great wisdom 🙏🌧️🙏
All the "victims" of today's culture should pay attention to the correct way to be a hard core victim: Forgive your attacker. Respond in silence with compassion. Bide your time and survive. And then later on... respond LOUDLY with compassion. And this coming from a person who really was a victim, and who organized against, real - fucking terrifying - multi-state sponsored military violence. Literally.. he fought the law... and the law lost.
If’s you have power for your satisfaction justifying with mount of suffering on your destroying, how can I help for your poor attitude and desires ?
You have never seen any suffering because you are illusion of luxury and only ordering justifying, how much more your justifying destiny , how’s you taking money for yours if’s there’s no place no power that money justifying yourself.
Dear Man thank you
お坊さんへ：ほんまに感謝しますと尊敬します。
🙏🔥❤
🙏
❤
How could anyone give this a thumbs down? What a pity.
Some humans are not ready for awakening. Compassion for them will help in there process and humanity's.
Accidentally perhaps?
hello! I translated this video to Spanish sometime ago. Could anybody approve the translation so that it can be available? thanks!
Thank you very much, dear friend! We published your translation.
Dear friends:
I'm so happy you published the subtitles in Spanish!
I translated 2 more very touching of your videos to Spanish so that more people can see them.
Thanks a lot!
th-cam.com/video/szX7XbgLMGc/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/QY99Ekk3URc/w-d-xo.html
One bright side to conflicts like that was being able to spread messages like this around the world.
Your seeing the good in everything. Good job!
🥰🙏😁 love and compassion is victory for both sides of any frontier ☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️🌿🌼🌿🌼🌈🌈🌈
Great!
Es tan placentero escucharlo una mil veces, es un bálsamo de paz y sabiduria para, la mente el cuerpo y el alma.
I think it is more than people having the wrong perception. I think it is mainly people who were abused as children and now have personality disorders such as narcissism.💔
11:49 “the book by ______(?)______ , “Learning to Love”
Anyone figure out the author’s name?
Que amor !!👩🏻🏫
I want to yell at him to talk louder.
Thankyou for sharing
Ca fait fondre de tristesse!!! Mais quelle chance d avoir été accueillis par la France!!!
No dudo que sea verdad lo que dice... pero por que viendo que no son violentos por que les hici3ron
Todo eso !!!
🙏🏼❤️
NAMO AMITABHA
Beautiful!
The title sucks
You should not. You simply hold onto the rage for another day.
Calm is not the answer to every problem. Whoever said that is wisdom is a fool.
They mean someone else’s rage not your own.
🕊️
Thank you Thay
I hope someone can edit the sound blips ...
Thanks for sharing! Amazing!!! :0)
I want justice and over all my enemy's that have wronged me and I am asking you to help me
You have to forgive so you can live clean. Its so hard but thats why Jesus came to help us.
But does Thay ever pepper himself up to liveliness and spontaneity?
yes
Thank you, Thay. Thank you so much.
He inhales
What’s thay?
It means teacher in Vietnamese
@@mathcuratorzanachan3574 thanks
I wish he would stop talking about hinself in the third person
bboyy 1871 spiritual teachers often refer to themself in the third person, or another kind of nomenclature (eg; "the parable of X - with X being their name - or "teacher says" or "in the story of X" and so on. This is because they are making a distinction between the Body-mind self or ego self (which has identity with a name and a past and a Story) to their true Self (capital S): the spirit that never left Reality or God. It is not "behaviouralism" as is suggested by a post below. It is a mindful way of assisting the listener or student to begin to unravel the false or wrong-minded self or ego by pointing to the working of the split mind. All advanced non-duality teachers tend to speak in this manner as a teaching / learning communication tool. It takes a great deal of parablising, allegory, examples and narrative for teachers to show students how tricky the ego mind is, and creating that distance between themself as master and themself as body-mind is paramount to good instruction.
He is Vietnamese and that is the custom- someone Vietnamese commented on that later than your post.
Compassion beings do not watching while someone is raging, but coming when ones is not longer raging if live, peace and compassion ones is....
Raged because someone is not near to love, peace and compassion....
i get even madder when people are silent and i’m angry
Sometimes people's anger shock the receiver into silence, especially someone who is not used to angry outbursts.
I cannot find the book he speaks about.