We don't want WCTH to go into "Soap Opera" territory. This show is far to good to let that happen. WCTH has set the standard other shows need to aspire to.
It's not going to go to soap opera territory. Because they know if they ever brought Jack back from the dead, they would lose the majority of the true fans because we all know how stupid that would be.
@@Michelle-wn8zv I'm with you Michelle, the writers and producers are smart enough to know, this is a once in a career show and they don't want to mess that up.
Yes. They are destroying Lucas now. How terrible. Chris is a great actor and his character should not be ruined by terrible writing. Elizabeth Stewart seems to really show a toxic aspect of writing. Every time she writes about Lucas she is ruining him. His character is not bad like the way they are showing him. It is the bad writing. This first episode is awful and I don't expect them to write good stories since they don't respect Lucas. Janette Oke's version of the saloon owner is nothing like this now. I also don't appreciate that they are changing Nathan to make him seem better than he is. Sorry, these people don't know how to keep the character's true to who they are. They basically changed Elizabeth, Rosemary, N, and now Lucas too. Very terrible writing. This sounds like they are very jealous.
En France, après la saison 1sortie en français chez Amazon, plus rien 😢!! Alors que beaucoup de personnes achètera ient volontiers les autres saisons. Pourquoi n'avons nous pas la suite ?
Série linda parabéns , AMEI a história , desde o começo , ela tinha que ser o Nathan , Elizabeth por fim fez ótima escolha lindo ver Elizabeth e Nathan juntos fantástico
Was over Elizabeth & her wishy-washy ways after she told Nathan she wasn't IN love with him, got engaged to Lucas, then dumped him last-minute at train station, only to start swooning over Nathan. What a callous player. She should have ended up ALONE! Can't stand her. Still like Nathan, even if he is a sap, & Lucas, who didn't deserve Elizabeth. Good riddance. Love Lee & Rosie, fave couple, & everyone in Hope Valley BUT Elizabeth & her stupid little basket.
I hope they do bring Jack back. They could have made a mistake in identifying who it was. I don't care if it is a training exercise. It is a soap opera already. Give me a break after 12 seasons, you don't think this show is a soap opera? Why do people keep watching week after week. Because it's a story, and it changes. It is nothing like the books anymore at all. Back in these days, bodies were identified, mistakenly, guy shows up alive. Daniel Lissing coming back could be a great thing. Stop complaining about it, none of this is real, it a great show, and I love watching it.
Acredito QUE Jack foi um bom ator fez um bom papel , mas agora chega Jack tá morto e precisa continuar assim, Nathan e maravilhoso excelente ATOR também , e Nathan é Elizabeth precisam ficar juntos e simplesmente fantástico maravilhoso
I think the writers should have Jack come back, then Elizabeth choose Jack over Nathan!! Maybe the Nathan fans will really understand, feel the pain, hurt, disgust and total misleading of Lucas & Elizabeth's courtship and engagement ( how many seasons of Lucas and Elizabeth's GREAT LOVE for each other, POOF.... GONE)!? How the rug was pulled out from under us by the writer's!!?😱 Maybe get a little taste of how the Lucas fans really felt about the break up!! 💔💔💔Still very disappointed about the end turn of Season 10!!! After all, did they switch to Nathan because Lucas was becoming as popular a character as Elizabeth with their most beautiful, well written, acted out by both Erin & Chris, "one of a kind" love story??? Clearly the love connection and chemistry between Nathan and Elizabeth DOES NOT EVEN COME CLOSE to what the writer's had with Lucas and Elizabeth's "love story"!! No matter how hard the writers try to make Nathan and Elizabeth "appear" to be in love now and have chemistry together!! Very very disheartening for this "Heartie" still!!😢
This show is not a 1980s days of our lives show. They are not going to bring Jack back from the dead. and if they did, I would no longer wash it because that would be completely stupid.
After the sudden and ridiculous breakup between Elizabeth and Lucas, I was done. They had a beautiful story line and it was silly to end it! I'm so tired of Elizabeth's conflicted love life story line!
Please....everyone on whatever silly team they were on had or had to deal with the changes. E was always meant to be with a mountie. That's is how the story went. Bringing Jack back would be the dumbest thing they could ever do. This is historical fiction. It's not Dallas or Days of our Lives. Please can we just move on and be grownups about this? How long are people going to hemhaw about this? Most women who have lost a spouse have a hard time moving on. They sometimes may hurt someone unintentionally because they made a wrong decision. It's natural and it even happens in real life too. So if people are sooooo unhappy with the direction the story took. Just don't watch it. Quit acting like something sooo terrible has been done to a fictional character and to you. It is still a TV show at the end of the day .not life or death.
It is like a Days of Our Lives, in that they toyed with some Hearties into believing Lucas and Elizabeth were a couple for a few seasons and then were engaged!!! Then Elizabeth dropped Lucas in less than 3 minutes end of Season 10. No other couples on WCTH led anyone else on in a relationship for several episodes and then dropped them because they were in love with someone else!!! Just was saying bringing Jack back because Nathan fans would not want to have been lead on for so many seasons and then Elizabeth drop Nathan all of the sudden!!
I think the writers need to have Nathan break up with Elizabeth...it's about time we see Elizabeth deal with heartbreak. She's been a terrible flirt all along, hurting way too many men. Lucas and Nathan aren't the only ones. She hurt Jack and Charles too.
Hopefully he left her enough to build the house he wanted for her ..not fair to put Elizabeth in this predicament.she truly loved jack .but he wanted to move on . don't bring him back..as far as lucas and Elizabeth the passionate kisses they shared the way he pushed her to do something with her books so many good things very sexy man..but she left the fast life to be in a small country town..theres Nathan and Elizabeth are they made for one another theres alot of positive reasons to be together.. just choose someone so it doesn't make her look bad being a school teacher..at least they just hold hands and kiss nothing else..
I'm all for Jack coming back. It started off with Jack that would be amazing. A lot of you love those stupid Soaps so why not. It would just be a great love story.
I have to agree. I feel that Elizabeth was much better suited to Lucas, and frankly I'm rather tired of this soap opera. Jack has been gone since season 5, so we have had 6 seasons of Elizabeth waffling between Nathan and lucas. Enough already. I think if the producers had polled the Hearties they might not have made this mistake. I felt it was very out of character for Elizabeth to ditch Lucas in the way that she did.
I've missed an entire season, and not because I wasn't looking, whatever was on the TV was just the beginning of Lucas and Elizabeth's relationship! Jeez Now her and Nathan might marry. Why is this show so far behind in Canada
I still think that Lucas and Elizabeth are end game that Elizabeth should be with Lucas or they bring should bring Jack back her heart belongs to Jack who is the love of Elizabeth life and then Lucas is her other love of her friends.
If Jack is taken out, I will quit watching . Jack and Elizabeth had a lot of trials to go through to get to their marriage. THEN Jack dies ?? No that's not a good ending.
Are you not caught up? Daniel left the show 6 years ago. Jack has been gone since. Daniel wanted to leave the show and he did....6 years ago. We are on season 12 starting this coming Sunday.
@@alyce831 That's what Rosemary put in her head. She wanted Lucas because he seemed secure and comfortable. Go back and check. When Lucas had to run for governor, he was no longer secure and comfortable....so she ran to Nathan who is secure and comfortable: "You feel like home to me"; "Its your heart that makes me feel brave". There is so much irony in this story, it is hard to follow.
We don't want WCTH to go into "Soap Opera" territory. This show is far to good to let that happen. WCTH has set the standard other shows need to aspire to.
It's not going to go to soap opera territory. Because they know if they ever brought Jack back from the dead, they would lose the majority of the true fans because we all know how stupid that would be.
@@Michelle-wn8zv I'm with you Michelle, the writers and producers are smart enough to know, this is a once in a career show and they don't want to mess that up.
Too late for that. It's already in soap opera territory.
@ not to the point where they're bringing dead people back alive! That was the point of my statement
I think along with a few other fans, this is the makings of a soap opera. Okay by me, but it’s definetly getting there.
Yes. They are destroying Lucas now. How terrible. Chris is a great actor and his character should not be ruined by terrible writing. Elizabeth Stewart seems to really show a toxic aspect of writing. Every time she writes about Lucas she is ruining him. His character is not bad like the way they are showing him. It is the bad writing. This first episode is awful and I don't expect them to write good stories since they don't respect Lucas. Janette Oke's version of the saloon owner is nothing like this now. I also don't appreciate that they are changing Nathan to make him seem better than he is. Sorry, these people don't know how to keep the character's true to who they are. They basically changed Elizabeth, Rosemary, N, and now Lucas too. Very terrible writing. This sounds like they are very jealous.
Stop putting lies out about Jack coming back because he isn’t. Daniel is completely done with the show.
En France, après la saison 1sortie en français chez Amazon, plus rien 😢!! Alors que beaucoup de personnes achètera ient volontiers les autres saisons. Pourquoi n'avons nous pas la suite ?
Série linda parabéns , AMEI a história , desde o começo , ela tinha que ser o Nathan , Elizabeth por fim fez ótima escolha lindo ver Elizabeth e Nathan juntos fantástico
The show runner refuses to listen to how the fans feel about how they ruin the characters.
That would be so stupid to bring Jack back
@marymoran6343 they are not bringing Jack back. His character is dead and Daniel is 100% done with the show.
I haven’t watched this stupid show ever since she went with Nathan. Once Jack was gone, Elizabeth is so annoying.
I love Nathan and Elizabeth together again!
Again????
If jack came back she's still married she can't marry Nathan
Was over Elizabeth & her wishy-washy ways after she told Nathan she wasn't IN love with him, got engaged to Lucas, then dumped him last-minute at train station, only to start swooning over Nathan. What a callous player. She should have ended up ALONE! Can't stand her. Still like Nathan, even if he is a sap, & Lucas, who didn't deserve Elizabeth. Good riddance. Love Lee & Rosie, fave couple, & everyone in Hope Valley BUT Elizabeth & her stupid little basket.
Lucas is actually a lot like Jack aside from a few aspects. I don't like Nathan.
I'm almost fed up with the bs storylines with Elizabeth. If she marries Nathan, I'm done!!
I'm with you. I love her with Lucas
Me too! Lucas all the way!
I agree.. Elizabeth should have stayed with Lucas!
I really hope Nathan and Elizabeth gets Married in Season 12 ❤❤❤
I hope they do bring Jack back. They could have made a mistake in identifying who it was. I don't care if it is a training exercise. It is a soap opera already. Give me a break after 12 seasons, you don't think this show is a soap opera? Why do people keep watching week after week. Because it's a story, and it changes. It is nothing like the books anymore at all. Back in these days, bodies were identified, mistakenly, guy shows up alive. Daniel Lissing coming back could be a great thing. Stop complaining about it, none of this is real, it a great show, and I love watching it.
Acredito QUE Jack foi um bom ator fez um bom papel , mas agora chega Jack tá morto e precisa continuar assim, Nathan e maravilhoso excelente ATOR também , e Nathan é Elizabeth precisam ficar juntos e simplesmente fantástico maravilhoso
I think the writers should have Jack come back, then Elizabeth choose Jack over Nathan!! Maybe the Nathan fans will really understand, feel the pain, hurt, disgust and total misleading of Lucas & Elizabeth's courtship and engagement ( how many seasons of Lucas and Elizabeth's GREAT LOVE for each other, POOF.... GONE)!? How the rug was pulled out from under us by the writer's!!?😱 Maybe get a little taste of how the Lucas fans really felt about the break up!! 💔💔💔Still very disappointed about the end turn of Season 10!!! After all, did they switch to Nathan because Lucas was becoming as popular a character as Elizabeth with their most beautiful, well written, acted out by both Erin & Chris, "one of a kind" love story??? Clearly the love connection and chemistry between Nathan and Elizabeth DOES NOT EVEN COME CLOSE to what the writer's had with Lucas and Elizabeth's "love story"!! No matter how hard the writers try to make Nathan and Elizabeth "appear" to be in love now and have chemistry together!! Very very disheartening for this "Heartie" still!!😢
This show is not a 1980s days of our lives show. They are not going to bring Jack back from the dead. and if they did, I would no longer wash it because that would be completely stupid.
After the sudden and ridiculous breakup between Elizabeth and Lucas, I was done. They had a beautiful story line and it was silly to end it! I'm so tired of Elizabeth's conflicted love life story line!
Please....everyone on whatever silly team they were on had or had to deal with the changes. E was always meant to be with a mountie. That's is how the story went. Bringing Jack back would be the dumbest thing they could ever do. This is historical fiction. It's not Dallas or Days of our Lives. Please can we just move on and be grownups about this? How long are people going to hemhaw about this? Most women who have lost a spouse have a hard time moving on. They sometimes may hurt someone unintentionally because they made a wrong decision. It's natural and it even happens in real life too. So if people are sooooo unhappy with the direction the story took. Just don't watch it. Quit acting like something sooo terrible has been done to a fictional character and to you. It is still a TV show at the end of the day .not life or death.
It is like a Days of Our Lives, in that they toyed with some Hearties into believing Lucas and Elizabeth were a couple for a few seasons and then were engaged!!! Then Elizabeth dropped Lucas in less than 3 minutes end of Season 10. No other couples on WCTH led anyone else on in a relationship for several episodes and then dropped them because they were in love with someone else!!! Just was saying bringing Jack back because Nathan fans would not want to have been lead on for so many seasons and then Elizabeth drop Nathan all of the sudden!!
I think the writers need to have Nathan break up with Elizabeth...it's about time we see Elizabeth deal with heartbreak. She's been a terrible flirt all along, hurting way too many men. Lucas and Nathan aren't the only ones. She hurt Jack and Charles too.
No soap opera please
It is a soap opera and its gotten worse every season.
Hopefully he left her enough to build the house he wanted for her ..not fair to put Elizabeth in this predicament.she truly loved jack .but he wanted to move on . don't bring him back..as far as lucas and Elizabeth the passionate kisses they shared the way he pushed her to do something with her books so many good things very sexy man..but she left the fast life to be in a small country town..theres Nathan and Elizabeth are they made for one another theres alot of positive reasons to be together.. just choose someone so it doesn't make her look bad being a school teacher..at least they just hold hands and kiss nothing else..
I'm all for Jack coming back. It started off with Jack that would be amazing. A lot of you love those stupid Soaps so why not. It would just be a great love story.
I have to agree. I feel that Elizabeth was much better suited to Lucas, and frankly I'm rather tired of this soap opera. Jack has been gone since season 5, so we have had 6 seasons of Elizabeth waffling between Nathan and lucas. Enough already. I think if the producers had polled the Hearties they might not have made this mistake. I felt it was very out of character for Elizabeth to ditch Lucas in the way that she did.
I've missed an entire season, and not because I wasn't looking, whatever was on the TV was just the beginning of Lucas and Elizabeth's relationship! Jeez Now her and Nathan might marry. Why is this show so far behind in Canada
Agree let it be dont turn a Canadian story into a American one
Too late....the show foresaw that Trump would make Canada a state with a governor.
So looking forward to the blended Grant family. Hopefully a wedding earlier in the season.
Now if Jack came back, then I would watch it. Otherwise, no!
Absolutely not. Lucas isn’t even in the equation. Jack then Nathan are Elizabeth’s true loves.
Not Nathan.
I want Elizabeth with Lucas
With Lucas she has love in her eyes
Please no more Janette
I hope Jack comes back alive or it will be boring
would love to have Jack be back on the show
Nathan é Elizabeth juntos fantástico espero o casamento , casal magnífico lindo
I will not watch.
Jack is alive
I stopped watching this show as soon as they bed hopped Elizabeth with Nathan now. STUPID! What a disappointment 😞
They should bring Jack back
I still think that Lucas and Elizabeth are end game that Elizabeth should be with Lucas or they bring should bring Jack back her heart belongs to Jack who is the love of Elizabeth life and then Lucas is her other love of her friends.
Lucas is Elizabeth other love of her life.
Sorry but her and Lucas not endgame. She literally felt he was the only safe option due to his job.
If Jack is taken out, I will quit watching . Jack and Elizabeth had a lot of trials to go through to get to their marriage. THEN Jack dies ?? No that's not a good ending.
Are you not caught up? Daniel left the show 6 years ago. Jack has been gone since. Daniel wanted to leave the show and he did....6 years ago. We are on season 12 starting this coming Sunday.
@@alyce831 That's what Rosemary put in her head. She wanted Lucas because he seemed secure and comfortable. Go back and check. When Lucas had to run for governor, he was no longer secure and comfortable....so she ran to Nathan who is secure and comfortable: "You feel like home to me"; "Its your heart that makes me feel brave". There is so much irony in this story, it is hard to follow.
I never liked Lucas
I never liked Nathan
Sooo cheesy
No Jack we love her w Nathan