Putting a limit on the length of a contract is restraint of trade. The objective of freeing up free agency would also go against the AFL's equalisation policy because the clubs at the pointy end would keep on topping up at the expense of clubs at the other end of the ladder. Kane would have a different opinion on this if it was Port getting bled dry by the big clubs.
Clubs at the pointy end already keep topping up at the expense of clubs down the bottom and have been doing so for years. Exactly what difference does it make.
@@taliamason7986 It would only get worse with shorter contracts. Free agency was pushed by the AFLPA, not by the AFL. The AFL knows it detracts from their equalisation objectives.
@Geelongcats9090Harry Sheazel won the Rising Star, something JHF didn't do. Sheazel is an adequate replacement for JHF and North got Wardlaw as well, so North did really well out of it. You're just salty because Port has a Victorian coach who you South Australians hate, and you can't sack him. Your club's small mindedness of only wanting SA born coaches will keep you flag less for many years.
How about a cap at 5yr contracts for players with triggers of 1-3yrs providing a player hits a certain criteria. It does away with these long term contract risks and issues and it specifically puts the working nouse back onto the player. If they want that long term contract to stick then they have to perform
People like Cornes want shorter term contracts for players so that they can speculate more about who they will go to when their contract runs out. Whenever the media suggest something, it is solely to give them things to talk about.
@@dhenderson1810 probably right. IMO I think shorter contracts sounds like the most logical spin on protecting clubs from players literally dropping the ball/standards on form. And that's why I think if ever there was to be any contract past 5yrs, then having the nessacary criteria to trigger the extension is the way to go. It not only rewards players form with their long term contract and security, but it also protects clubs. Granted the only real side effect is that injuries could make alot of grey area on this but maybe that's tough love and luck of the draw.
For someone presenting as an intellectual even a footy one you should know the difference between laconic (using few words) and lackadaisical (lazy of action).
Cornes gets Phil in to justify all the crap he brings up on the show , Cornes nearly has an orgasim when Phil says Carlton can't win the flag without Weitering .
@@dhenderson1810maybe so, but the suns will still not play finals. They will not jump from 15th to inside the top 8 without 3 changes and there just won’t be that many.
Just with West Coast From what i’ve seen players like Hough, Ginbey, Watermen, H edwards etc have comeback in very good nick West coast have had a couple injuries so far but everyone does Kane Cornes has never had anything positive to say about west coast even when they were good Port can’t do no wrong, can you imagine how much shit west coast would get if they stuffed up a concussion protocol Yet he went of on something that wasn’t anyone’s fault and was taken care of and handled well
I rate u phill but what are u on about with the eagles? Are just waffling or stating player/s have actually come back unfit. Kane is always waffling about eagles but shocked me about phill
@@azzajames7661 He was actually saying he expects a bump in player availability because the players got to work in that Sept-Nov period in 2023 and have been in good nick. Worth listening to the entire press conference
@@Snappernose West Coast might be struggling at the moment, but it’s all swings and roundabouts there no point sitting in the middle of the ladder forever if you never win a grand final. Some people look at winning spoons as negative when realistically it’s a big positive, you can land. Yourself a high quality draft picks or have good trading power. West Coast are now currently the 2nd youngest side in the comp doesn’t take long to turn things around fast. What will be more concerning to other clubs is most of West Coast Eagles older players have moved on opening up their celery cup. And with some fantastic free agents out of contract in 2024 it will be exciting times.
highly rate Phil Davis joining AFL media teams
This was a great segment
Perfect Yin-Yang balance, love seeing these two on together, Phil was so good through the trade period too.
Phil is a great addition and hopefully brings some balance to Kane’s unshakable bias
Great insight from Phil Davis, reckon he needs a guy like Cornes to bounce off of to bring out his best
Cornes is better as a questioner than an opinion giver as well.
Great segment lads, very informative
God we need to clone Phil Davis, speaks so well
Putting a limit on the length of a contract is restraint of trade. The objective of freeing up free agency would also go against the AFL's equalisation policy because the clubs at the pointy end would keep on topping up at the expense of clubs at the other end of the ladder. Kane would have a different opinion on this if it was Port getting bled dry by the big clubs.
Clubs at the pointy end already keep topping up at the expense of clubs down the bottom and have been doing so for years. Exactly what difference does it make.
@@taliamason7986 It would only get worse with shorter contracts. Free agency was pushed by the AFLPA, not by the AFL. The AFL knows it detracts from their equalisation objectives.
@Geelongcats9090Harry Sheazel won the Rising Star, something JHF didn't do.
Sheazel is an adequate replacement for JHF and North got Wardlaw as well, so North did really well out of it.
You're just salty because Port has a Victorian coach who you South Australians hate, and you can't sack him.
Your club's small mindedness of only wanting SA born coaches will keep you flag less for many years.
I hope Kane keeps the beard. Adds about 5 kg to his frame.
How about a cap at 5yr contracts for players with triggers of 1-3yrs providing a player hits a certain criteria.
It does away with these long term contract risks and issues and it specifically puts the working nouse back onto the player. If they want that long term contract to stick then they have to perform
People like Cornes want shorter term contracts for players so that they can speculate more about who they will go to when their contract runs out.
Whenever the media suggest something, it is solely to give them things to talk about.
@@dhenderson1810 probably right. IMO I think shorter contracts sounds like the most logical spin on protecting clubs from players literally dropping the ball/standards on form. And that's why I think if ever there was to be any contract past 5yrs, then having the nessacary criteria to trigger the extension is the way to go. It not only rewards players form with their long term contract and security, but it also protects clubs. Granted the only real side effect is that injuries could make alot of grey area on this but maybe that's tough love and luck of the draw.
Players and clubs should be able to negotiate any length contract they want but it should be paid in pull if either party re-nig.
For someone presenting as an intellectual even a footy one you should know the difference between laconic (using few words) and lackadaisical (lazy of action).
Cornes gets Phil in to justify all the crap he brings up on the show , Cornes nearly has an orgasim when Phil says Carlton can't win the flag without Weitering .
Not sure if Phil Davis or dom dolla
For the suns to play finals there’d need to be 3 changes to the 8. Coz the suns aren’t jumping Adelaide or the bulldogs so who comes out?
The Bulldogs are going downhill.
They hit their peak and are on the way down.
Not having Bailey Smith all season will hurt them as well.
@@dhenderson1810maybe so, but the suns will still not play finals. They will not jump from 15th to inside the top 8 without 3 changes and there just won’t be that many.
Crows to make prelims
Riveting discussions by two titans of afl media
kanes good get this other flog off
i watch sen to here about saint kilda and i never hear anything about them
Just with West Coast
From what i’ve seen players like Hough, Ginbey, Watermen, H edwards etc have comeback in very good nick
West coast have had a couple injuries so far but everyone does
Kane Cornes has never had anything positive to say about west coast even when they were good
Port can’t do no wrong, can you imagine how much shit west coast would get if they stuffed up a concussion protocol
Yet he went of on something that wasn’t anyone’s fault and was taken care of and handled well
I rate u phill but what are u on about with the eagles? Are just waffling or stating player/s have actually come back unfit. Kane is always waffling about eagles but shocked me about phill
They are going off what Simpson said, west coasts very own coach. Some players have come back unfit😒
@@azzajames7661 He was actually saying he expects a bump in player availability because the players got to work in that Sept-Nov period in 2023 and have been in good nick. Worth listening to the entire press conference
@@azzajames7661yeah thats not what Simpson was saying at all, sorry.
Love SEN Never one think positive about a WA team especially West Coast.
What’s to be positive about? They’re rubbish
@@Snappernose Your response is as intelligent as listening to Kane Cornes and SEN podcast.
You’re listening to them so what’s your point champ?
Fact is WC are rubbish and will be for a while yet… is that too intellectual for you?
@@Snappernose
West Coast might be struggling at the moment, but it’s all swings and roundabouts there no point sitting in the middle of the ladder forever if you never win a grand final. Some people look at winning spoons as negative when realistically it’s a big positive, you can land. Yourself a high quality draft picks or have good trading power.
West Coast are now currently the 2nd youngest side in the comp doesn’t take long to turn things around fast.
What will be more concerning to other clubs is most of West Coast Eagles older players have moved on opening up their celery cup. And with some fantastic free agents out of contract in 2024 it will be exciting times.
@@FoLlOwThEwHiTeRaBbIt1Keep accepting mediocrity.
no football so out comes the dribble.
I hope ur saying these things from a script.. I seriously hope you are both not that naive in regards to drug use in AFL…
People that wear baseball caps inside are "half-back-flankers".
Two of the most boring and mundane journalists. Good on Phil for setting up his career after footy but I will not be listening to him
Test everyone (even coaches) zero tolerance. hefty bans and fines.
Great take on the Uncle Dougs Phil .. Throw in there you never did.. not much more to say .. had more to say about weight shaming 👎
Kano beardo