Only Murders In The Building Season 3 Episode 9: The Real Killer!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.พ. 2025
- After being right about too many different theories, I am presenting my final theories about who the murderer could be on Only Murders In The Building Season 3! Enjoy!
Did you like Only Murders In The Building Season 3 Episode 9? What are your theories? Tell me below!
#onlymurdersinthebuilding #hulu #omitb
I think you are closing in, and see your theory as plausible. When Charles sang "What if none of the pickwick triplets did it? Who'd a had a menacing motive and hid it?" My mind immediately went to Tobert, who I plain don't trust and seems to be in hiding. Also, can I just say that I am relieved Mabel didn't get married as a way to escape "not having her life together". Whew! And that dream of birthing triplets! I can't unsee that! lol!
I agree that marriage would be soo disappointing 😂
?? Okay let’s say Tobert did it for his documentary. But that’s still not strong motive. Eh we’ll find out tomorrow’s episode anyway.🗿
I saw someone else mention this Tobert theory and I can see this. I believe that elephant story is a clue in the case that shows he saw and recorded what happened. At first I was thinking he saw the murder and was blackmailing the murderer but this makes sense as well
We'll see in a few days!!!!
Howard is comic relief and will always be a main stay character. Tobert looks more likely but I’m sure the reveal will have an indepth background story of the motive. And of course if it’s someone else entirely Bravo to the writers that fooled us all!!! 😊👍
If it turns out to be someone we never saw in the season or saw only briefly, that would be really disappointing for me
@@HometownSkeptic2613 me too
Good theories! I can see Tobert being a fly-on-the-wall just recording everything. However, this would make him a liar to Mabel (again) and also make her very sad if this was true.
I think the reason why Ben showed up at the party wasn't just to reunite & apologize to his co-workers, but to find out who tried to kill him. Also, I believe the phone call he received at the party was from the doctors with the toxicology results confirming that it was indeed the cookies that poisoned him. This leads him to confront Cliff & Donna, outside the elevators where a struggle ensues. Cliff, trying to protect his mom shoves Ben who stumbles backwards, & slips on a death rattle hankie, falling to his death.
The twist in the final episode, is that we may find out that Dickie isn't Loretta's child after all, because the bus ticket date of 1976, the year she gave up her child, is at least 4 years after Dickie was born. It's possible there's a scenario similar to the premise of "The Comedy of Errors" involving 2 sets of twins, and mistaken identities, and Loretta's son Richard could be Dickie's younger cousin. The clues can be found on the envelope and letter from Michael & Eloise Glenroy, the couple who adopted Loretta's child.
I actually saw the theory about Dickie not being Loretta's actual son and you explained it pretty well. But if it's true, it's so unnecessary, in my opinion. What would it have anything to do with the murder itself?
@@HometownSkeptic2613 It doesn't really change the motive or how the murder was carried out, but it allows for the possibility that Ben has a twin, and that the Ben that was poisoned might not be the same Ben that fell.
Oh, that's possible because there were a lot signs for triplets this season. So, maybe there is a third brother
Re: The call- I think it's possible the call may have been from one of Ben's five sewing buddies. He tried to call them before the show, so it would makes sense that he would be eager to hear from them. But then how would they know he was alive, because they saw him die on-stage? And then what would the point of that call be anyway? Did they see something? Are they involved somehow?? Whatever it is, that call is the key.
Hmmmm, I haven't thought about the call really
I am starting to wonder if there are two important papers. It is convenient that the review is curled in such a way that you cannot see the part that we saw before with the date, and until and composer. I wonder if there is an insurance contract that got shredded as well.
I cannot keep up with all these theories lol
In the opening scene of episode 2, we see the neck of the person Ben took the hankie from as well as their hands, and that person looks VERY similar to Cliff. I think he’s the one who did it ngl
I don't exactly remember it, but wasn't that a re-imagination and there were different persons with hankies that pushed Ben?
@@HometownSkeptic2613 Yeah your probably right. I just think they might have done that for a reason...
Only two days...
I think it's Kimber. Remember what she says in VO during the Nanny's lullaby? About putting out a light brighter than her own? She was talking about Ben, not Loretta.
That would be interesting because we haven't really seen her since the early episodes.
Very good content! Subbed
Thanks for the support!
Who killed Ben Glenroy? THE ARCONIA!!! Donna poisoned the cookie, but what about the elevator incident? My co-worker raised an interesting theory: Ben's death was an accident! If that's true, then the killer is...THE ARCONIA!!! What if Ben was arguing - or just talking - with someone, they moved to the elevator, he presses the button and the elevator door opens but all that''s there is an open elevator shaft. Ben realizes it, turns to grab onto something/someone, but still falls down the elevator shaft. (In the process, Ben grabs the handkerchief.) The person who witnessed this - still not sure who it is - was too freaked out to say anything. Look at the clues: After the first opening night's events, the trio goes back to the Arconia and an elevator is on the blink. The residents of the Arconia are frustrated and keep talking about how some of the elevators act janky. Also, Ben may not have known about this because he just moved into the building into Amy Schumer's old apartment. He wasn't as aware of the clunkiness of the elevators. I think the killer is the Arconia. The building is responsible because the elevators are a hazard.
That's literally what I said in the video :) although I said it was an accident, I didn't say a building was the killer :):)
my question is why was the elevator door open? I have seen plenty broken elevators in NYC, but none of them had the door open, each floor has its own door, so the door should have been closed. I mean, yes, great for a dramatic death in a TV show, but not very realistic...
TV shows have different logics, I guess 😂
Also, the episode clearly said red herring when talking about the dip.
🤔🤔
Yup i knew Tobert did it when he had dinner with Mabel
go watch episode 10 :(
The cookie theory was made up by the trio's interpretation. In reality I think Dicky is playing the victim to Ben. I do believe that person who died in the elevator I think it was a dummy of Ben. Just like in the play they have a dummy for a Mom. Ben is being Cobro in real time. He's trapping his brother who wanted to kill Ben. Ben is in hiding until Dicky and others are put away. Dicky has been taking Ben's money and identity. Loretta and the whole cast are in on solving the crime against Ben. Ben still alive and well.
Well that's a theory I heard for the very first time 😂
@@HometownSkeptic2613 They haven't shown us anything or talked about the elevator situation. No para medics on scene. No nothing until we see Uma taking the hanky but still after that all went silent. Ben on the floor looked like a stage dummy to me
that seems far-fetched to me but if it turns out to be correct, you have my respect lol
@@HometownSkeptic2613 I know it's odd to think that was a dummy doll in the elevator. With nobody covering the elevator scene and just focusing on the day of opening night leads me to believe Ben is still alive.
Love the show. I still do not know who is the killer. DONNA MIGHT BE IT
Dickie, Tobert and Cliff ( he’s not that stupid as presented) - 3 killers
I'm thinking maybe Tobert just watched but did nothing, instead of murdering Ben
I'm pretty sure Ben didn't give Tobert a hankie. So based on the hankie, he can't be the killer.
I think he just watched as Ben died and didn't do anything
With the comments at the party after his first death the womans made a comment, something like "even stage hands gets a hankie?" He would get one and I wouldnt be surprised
@@HeirOfGlee but Ben brought the hankies on opening day and then kicked Tobert out.
@@HeirOfGlee I think it could be KT. A lot of focus seemed to be on her hankie in the first episode. Perhaps Tobert was a witness, though. I'm not sure what would motivate KT to kill Ben or why Tobert would protect her, but it's just a theory.
I thought tobert too, but didnt know the why?? Dont think its Howard,
Probably to shoot a Ben documentary. It would worth more money and fame if Ben were dead
It’s probably either Tobert or Donna’s son
Part of me doesn't think Dickie did it. I can't explain why. It's just I feel like he doesn't have a murderer face.
I don’t think there is a murder this season. I think Ben’s first death was an allergic reaction to the cookie. Then he accidentally fell down the elevator shaft.
I never thought about the first one, but the second one I really agree with.
Of course, you're going to be eventually right when you blame everyone 😂
Did you expect me to have one theory and one suspect from the beginning and stick to that for 9 episodes? I just like discussing different possibilities and some of them end up being true. That makes me happy
I cant recall, are you aware of the "spoiler" that was released last week or are you aware, but choosing to ignore it?
Ive unfortunately seen it (I wont say what the spoiler is) and here is my prediction and attempt to tie it together. In the patter song, the triplets are Penelope, Patrick and Paco. Donna is Penelope and poisons Ben to harm the show in the spirit of The Producers and protect her son....Cliff is Patrick, after Ben returns to the party and then leaves, Cliff ends up talking to Ben in front of the open elevator, explains to him how stressed he was over all the drama, does his stress dance, which startles Ben, and Ben accidentally falls down the shaft. Tobert is Paco. Tobert is on the 10th floor with his GoPro and is recording and captures Cliffs stress dance causing Ben to go into the shaft. Donna/Cliff then do something to convince Tobert to help them/hide it/cover it up. The reason I think this theory for Tobert, is to answer the question "how is Bens death going to be proven"? There is no hotel security footage for the obvious reason. It wont be someone simply confessing. So there has to be a recording of it, and it wont be from the building security cameras. So it has to be from Tobert/his equipment.
I really hope am wrong on this. Because the answer to the "who did it?" question will just end up being "The Producers", which many like you in the community connected very early on (granted without any details of how or why) based on the Broderick and Brooks having cameos and a play that was going down the drain. And I dont like that and feel is lazy and weak compared to the previous two seasons.
I'm not aware of any spoilers, I just watch the episodes. Your theory makes sense and it's not far off from what I said. As for this season being weak compared to other seasons, I don't know if you followed theories when Season 1 was airing, but everyone knew the killer was Jan very early on. That's why I think in Season 2 they made the killer someone like Poppy and no one really had guessed it. I don't know what they will do with this season. I kind of enjoy the fact that my guesses turn out to be true but not everyone may like that and I understand.
Hi! Can you tell me the spoilers?
@@ango8466 i wont say exactly what it is here...but you can look it up if you like...just search for OMITB Season 3 soundtrack and note what one of the songs is titled.
🎉
Thanks!
This is the worst season! So boring! I would not watch it if it wasn't for Meryl!
I disagree...