Tamdhu 18 & Alternatives for Macallan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Tamdhu 18 Year Old (2022) Scotch Whisky Review and alternatives for Macallan 18 Sherry Oak. Has Tamdhu made a bolder version of Macallan 18? What are other good options for 18 year old sherry matured whiskies?
SUPPORT THE SHOW: / sipperssocialclub
#tamdhu #macallan #scotchreview
Scores:
After my initial score I add or subtract points relative on how I perceive value (based on what I paid for the bottle). A zero value means I think the price is justified.
0-69.5 - Don’t bother trying, life is too short for bad spirit.
70-79.5 - Worth trying, but you’re not missing out if you don’t.
80-84.5 - I recommend trying.
85-87.5 - Definitely try this!
88-91.5 - I recommend buying a bottle blind!
92-95.5 - Stuff you reserve for special pours!
96+ - The meaning of life.
![[Re:all TREASURE] EP.6 in 방콕ㅣ🚩 쩡캠의 방콕 투어 빵 마이 와이 👍](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uyFw-nItA_s/mqdefault.jpg)
Sounded really good. I love Tamdhu, though I have not had this 18 year. I actually prefer a little more bold influence. Thanks for sharing!
I just found this at my local big box liquor store for $200 before tax. I may give it a go now. Thanks for the honest and informative review. Super helpful.
Enjoy :)
I just tried tamdhu 12 and 15 and then drank my Macallan 12 and 15 double cask at the same sitting. Holy cow they are replicas! But the Tamdhu is a little bit more flavorful and has more enhanced notes. I totally agree It’s better and is a Macallan killer. And I’m saying this after being introduced to scotch by Macallan and being a loyal Macallan fanboy. Can’t wait to try the Tamdhu 18!
I enjoy their 15 yo as well, but to be honest, prices are simply too high for many of us. Thanks Jeremy for a very fine and detailed review. Kindest regards, S.
Very high praise ... i feel a "whisky of the year" coming on. I'll need to see about finding one.
Great reviewJeremy. Keep them coming. Do you think the Tamdhu 18 is worth the price difference vs the Tamdhu 15? Thanks
Couldn’t agree more. Great score, great scotch.
Have tried the Tamdhu 12 and 15 and think they too are better than the Macallan equivalents. I have a bottle of the 18 too, but am yet to open it.
Love the Glenallachie 18. Even if they were priced the exact same, I’d take it over the MacAllan 18 any day.
Same
Tamdhu IS the sherry future with GlenAllachie as it’s loyal and improving wingman!
Getting a bit tired of Glenallachie. Too many wood finishes to mask so so spirit. Billy Walker is putting out a lot of mediocre liquid.
@@pharmacistsdoitoverthecoun5012 I completely agree with you on that. Billy is having to work through much of his older stuff while his new stuff gets better and better. We still have time, but Tamdhu is where it’s at now for great sherry.
I also agree, hard to keep up with the hundred wood finishes that are coming out. I'm expecting good things when all new spirit comes to age
That Tamdhu 18 is $267 here in NC, a control state. Looks nice but I'm still too much of a novice to pursue that. I'd likely go for a Glenallachie 12 before a Tamdhu.
267 usd? Yeah that's quite expensive. Glenallachie 12 is always solid.
@@SippersSocialClub Indeed true Jeremy. Special order too.
Just as a somewhat related FYI, I special-ordered an Isle Of Arran 10 last Nov 1 (year ago), still haven't gotten it. Spoke with my ABC agent of my county here, and it doesn't seem to be their fault; apparently Arran or its distributor cancelled my order twice without letting my ABC agent know, so we both were in the dark this whole time. She found out that the reason it was cancelled was because I ordered a 750ml bottle and they're moving to only 700ml bottles. She said she'd follow up on it, but I've seen Arran 10 700ml bottles being more expensive than their 750ml counterparts. So everyone's getting expensive, including Arran apparently.
My concern is American whiskies will be going the way of 700ml bottles soon. Jack Daniel's already is doing that with some of their bottlings, and it's rather cynical IMO.
@@whompbiscuits8930 500 mls are more and more common as well
Tamdhu is where its at. The 15yo and this 18yo are beautiful!
I'll see if I can pickup a 15 :)
I feel like it is difficult to find really good 18yr stuff, it seems to be at a weird point in which it’s expensive but without providing the expected quality. Will certainly keep an eye out for Tamdhu 18 following your recommendation. Though it’s age statement doesn’t match I think Michael Couvreur Overaged Malt or Auld Blossoming Malt offer really exceptional Sherry cask whisky, certainly worth trying if you haven’t yet.
I agree, all the 18 year stuff is what they were charging for 21's a few years ago
Absolutely. Michael Couvreur Auld Blossoming Malt is the ultimate Macallan killer, hands down!
@@jizast I'll have to check em out!
@@SippersSocialClubexactly, it’s like there’s been a coordinated strategy within the industry to raise prices across the age stated categories. As is stands there are far less age stated whiskys, particularly older ones, that justify their price. Not surprising new distillery’s are flourishing in the current market.
Great Review Jeremy. I have been saying this is the Macallan alternative for a long time... I also liked the Glenturret for that role, but honestly Glenturret has got too expensive...
I agree, even though Glenturret drinks older, it's still quite a lot. Do they have a 18? Or it just bumps to 25?
@@SippersSocialClub i think just bumps to 25 🤦🏻
Arran 18, Bunna 18, Glendro 18, amd Glenallachie 18 are decent in their own right but they are different profile than Macallan. Tamdhu 18 is really the same profile as Macallan.
Got my first one of these as a Christmas present for myself. First couple of drams were having me think of a Independent Glenturret 17 sherry puncheon I got the year before. Now that it's down a bit it's really coming into it's own. Never had Macallan 18 but at todays prices I never will. Very nice bottle. Cheers Jeremy
Nice. That glenturret sounds interesting, who bottled it?
@@SippersSocialClub Think it was an Old Particular that K&L Wine got
As a Macallan Fan boy I don't believe you. 😛 Thanks for the review
Lol, I'll guess you'll have to try and find out :)
Preach it!!! Yes!!!
Love Tamdhu. I have the 15 YO and the batch strength. I can buy the Distillers Art 2007 14 YO release but don’t know anything about it. It’s $160 so need some intel before buying. Have you had it?
Haven't tried it. I've had some CS single casks that have been amazing
How much different is this from the old Billy Walker Glendronach 18 or the Tamdhu 15?
Noice! Gotta try this juice.