_Love_ how you didn't just throw MAMD down to the bottom of the list like most people do! It has its flaws for sure, but it's a very sweet, funny, and charming show that I believe doesn't get the credit it deserves
FINALLY someone who recognises how good starship is !!!!!!! i feel like its so underrated which isnt fair because its easily one of starkid’s best shows
My favorites are the hatchet field series. Starting with Nerdy Prudes Must Die then followed by The Guy Who Didn't like Musicals, then Black Friday, but then my list follows a similar course to yours.
My ranking of all the ones I’ve watched are: 1.Starship 2.Twisted 3.Nerdy prudes must die 4.The guy who didn’t like musicals 5.Black Friday 6.The trail to Oregon 7.Holy musical b@man 8.Firebringer
SO glad you put NPMD at #2! People don’t realize how phenomenal that show is (I’ve watched it three times help). I have to say I’m surprised that Starship is your #1 pick, even though I love it as well. I think it’s plagued by mostly mediocre songs - save for Kick it Up a Notch - and being too long.
Honestly I could never rank them in order, I’ve tried but I felt guilty putting things at the bottom. I rated them out of 10 and nothing went below 8. I genuinely loved every show even Ani
My ratings even though nobody asked 1. avpm 8/10 2. Me and my dick 9/10 3. Avps 10/10 4. Starship 10/10 5. Holy musical b@man 10/10 6. Avpsy 8/10 7. Twisted 9/10 8. Ani 9/10 9. Trail to Oregon 10/10 10. Firebringer 10/10 11. The guy who didn’t like musicals 12/10 12. Black Friday 8/10 13. VHS Christmas Carol 10/10 14. Nerdy prudes must die 10/10
Starship isn’t my top favorite anymore, but it was when I was a kid and it does my heart good to see it ranked so high, it gets so overlooked! I can’t say I would have ranked it differently, really, but I wanna say that I think Ani is really funny, especially as a former extended universe buff, and Nick Lang is so unbelievably good as Obi-Wan. My hottest take is that Firebringer is the most forgettable to me, which hurts to say. I wanted to like it so bad, but it didn’t really leave much of an impression, other than “Fuck no, Zazz” and thinking that Zazz/Keeri were more endearing as a ship than Zazz/Jemilla
I agree with most of this. I would have just put TGWDLM before Black Friday. It might just be because I listened to it soooo much that I’m broad with it now. But I love your top four.
I feel like I agree with this entire ranking, but for me, nerdy prudes is at the bottom of the hatchet trilogy :( not sure why I can't get into it. But Jagerman was AMAZING
I never expected to see Starship this high, but I personally agree with HMB & Ani, I don’t get a lot of the jokes and the storyline doesn’t interest me that much, because I’m not into the superheroes and Star Wars
14: Me and My Dick 13: Firebringer 12: A Very Potter Senior Year 11: A VHS Christmas Carol 10: Black Friday 9: Ani: A Parody 8: Nerdy Prudes Must Die 7: A Very Potter Sequel 6: A Very Potter Musical 5: Starship 4: Holy Musical B@man 3: Trail to Oregon 2: The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals 1: Twisted
Meanwhile my lowest two are little white lie (from 2007, it's a series and it is shit....anyway go watch my video essay about it) and Starship (I never really got into it but the music slaps)
![[Re:all TREASURE] EP.6 in 방콕ㅣ🚩 쩡캠의 방콕 투어 빵 마이 와이 👍](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uyFw-nItA_s/mqdefault.jpg)
_Love_ how you didn't just throw MAMD down to the bottom of the list like most people do! It has its flaws for sure, but it's a very sweet, funny, and charming show that I believe doesn't get the credit it deserves
IT CRACKS ME UP. Might not be the best but seriously still is very funny.
Me after hearing number one: You Gotta KICK IT UP A NOTCH!
so good
SO GOOD
It’s funny how Trail to Oregon has become the Lion King to Ani’s Pocahontas.
FINALLY someone who recognises how good starship is !!!!!!! i feel like its so underrated which isnt fair because its easily one of starkid’s best shows
rip vhs christmas carol
Didnt watch ANI, placing HMB second to last should be illegal.
I don't know a lot of star wars so Ani is't for me, but I listen to that cast album all the time. would recomend at least listening to the songs
Vhs Christmas Carol erasure is crazy
Thank goodness I wasn’t the only one who relized
mad respect for mamd being higher up than i thought it would be its such an underrated song
omg i didnt even finish watching, hahaha. But holy musical batman and twisted being so low is killing me, haha
Twisted and Starship >>> (though obviously AVPM is a favorite too)
Yes, Starship is so great!!! Also yeah I've been listening to NPMD on repeat every day too lol
Too 3 for me:
1: Twisted (best musical they’ve ever made imo)
2: Trail to Oregon
3: GWDLM
Personally, I think npmd is #1 lol BUT I LOVE STARKID TOO
NPMD and the guy who didn’t like musicals are the only starkid musicals I’ve seen so far, but yeah NPMD is in my top 5 fave musicals ever
My favorites are the hatchet field series. Starting with Nerdy Prudes Must Die then followed by The Guy Who Didn't like Musicals, then Black Friday, but then my list follows a similar course to yours.
SAME STARSHIP IS THE BEST AND YOU CAN NOT TELL ME OTHERWISE!!
i just got into started and i now need to watch all of these!! so thank you because i really didn’t know how many plays there were!
My school did The Trail to Oregon two years ago now, and I was Son. I was the only 8th grader among Juniors, lol, but those guys are like my family 🫶
Starship is great. VHS Christmas Carol is my favorite though.
Honestly, Trail to Oregon is my favorite, but I acknowledge it is not their best. Glad it made it to your top 5 tho!!
Yes! I love Starship!
Fire bringer is at the bottom of my list to dw
I cannot tell you how much I love starship, I literally watched it again yesterday
I saw the apolcalyptour and it was amazing.
seeing starship ranked as number 1 instantly earns my respect!!
Starship is my top one too
WHERES MY BABY VHS CHRISTMAS CAROL
My ranking of all the ones I’ve watched are:
1.Starship
2.Twisted
3.Nerdy prudes must die
4.The guy who didn’t like musicals
5.Black Friday
6.The trail to Oregon
7.Holy musical b@man
8.Firebringer
SO glad you put NPMD at #2! People don’t realize how phenomenal that show is (I’ve watched it three times help). I have to say I’m surprised that Starship is your #1 pick, even though I love it as well. I think it’s plagued by mostly mediocre songs - save for Kick it Up a Notch - and being too long.
Honestly I could never rank them in order, I’ve tried but I felt guilty putting things at the bottom. I rated them out of 10 and nothing went below 8. I genuinely loved every show even Ani
My ratings even though nobody asked
1. avpm 8/10
2. Me and my dick 9/10
3. Avps 10/10
4. Starship 10/10
5. Holy musical b@man 10/10
6. Avpsy 8/10
7. Twisted 9/10
8. Ani 9/10
9. Trail to Oregon 10/10
10. Firebringer 10/10
11. The guy who didn’t like musicals 12/10
12. Black Friday 8/10
13. VHS Christmas Carol 10/10
14. Nerdy prudes must die 10/10
HMB being 2 is criminal.
Yoo starship love!!
SO AGREE WITH NERDY PRUDES. I listen to it every day 😂❤
Starship isn’t my top favorite anymore, but it was when I was a kid and it does my heart good to see it ranked so high, it gets so overlooked!
I can’t say I would have ranked it differently, really, but I wanna say that I think Ani is really funny, especially as a former extended universe buff, and Nick Lang is so unbelievably good as Obi-Wan.
My hottest take is that Firebringer is the most forgettable to me, which hurts to say. I wanted to like it so bad, but it didn’t really leave much of an impression, other than “Fuck no, Zazz” and thinking that Zazz/Keeri were more endearing as a ship than Zazz/Jemilla
putting twisted at 7
I was disappointed seeing Ani and hmbm so low but you made it up to me by putting npmd and starship at the top
I agree with most of this. I would have just put TGWDLM before Black Friday. It might just be because I listened to it soooo much that I’m broad with it now. But I love your top four.
VIVA LA STARSHIP
I feel like I agree with this entire ranking, but for me, nerdy prudes is at the bottom of the hatchet trilogy :( not sure why I can't get into it. But Jagerman was AMAZING
I never expected to see Starship this high, but I personally agree with HMB & Ani, I don’t get a lot of the jokes and the storyline doesn’t interest me that much, because I’m not into the superheroes and Star Wars
14: Me and My Dick
13: Firebringer
12: A Very Potter Senior Year
11: A VHS Christmas Carol
10: Black Friday
9: Ani: A Parody
8: Nerdy Prudes Must Die
7: A Very Potter Sequel
6: A Very Potter Musical
5: Starship
4: Holy Musical B@man
3: Trail to Oregon
2: The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals
1: Twisted
TWISTED AT NUMBER SEVEN ?!!??????1?1?
Meanwhile my lowest two are little white lie (from 2007, it's a series and it is shit....anyway go watch my video essay about it) and Starship (I never really got into it but the music slaps)
Man guess the other shows better KICK IT UP A NOTCH…
Yeah I’ll go-
Where is vhs Christmas Carol or vhs Christmas carols
My unpopular opinion is that firebringer is my least favourite... I never listen to those songs, don't know why