so many new kpop stans dont know how much of a popular and huge group AOA was, so many of them missed the golden sexy era of KPOP, this will forever remain iconic.
Gotta admit no-one's ever gonna beat ChoA to this song. Stunning grace, I've been dancing for 3-4 years and I can't replicate it. Not saying I'm highly professional or anything hahaa, still a very amature dancer.
ChoA is so gorgeous.... i'm not into Kpop that much but there are some groups i like, but Choa is the one i most like... i j fund out recently she is not in the industry anymore ...
I'VE GOT IT! I don't watch/listen/know much about Kpop but I got it! The blonde girl, she's been the one hypnotizing me LOL. She really mastered the dance and character!
+iBelieveAkinFly yes she's bae..... The other members call her choahjumma because she's the oldest and she doesn't know common slang (she's 25 btw). She's also one of the best Kpop vocalists imo ..
+arvin bhattacharya really ? I am sorry then . In Nepal we have sur name like " bhattacharya" and also your name arvin is really popular name here so I thought you were Nepali , sorry again
Considering choA has *alot of fans* and most famous member in AOA it is shocking that she was the first one to leave the group, i literally see no hate comments about her, maybe it was jimin all along.
I’m in love with how choa moves! I’m trying to learn the dance so I’ve been using the 0.5 playing speed and I’m enamored with her every movement and expression. Her gracefulness and sexiness is even more emphasized. I think she captured how the cat moves the most and it’s seriously fascinating to watch!
Seolhyun makes it seem effortless, plus she does it in style. Hard to explain, she just makes the moves look "easy" and "good" or "better" even. I think she's always had a dancing background. For example, like how most people do one move and it seems sloppy/lazy or awkward, but she can make it work, kinda like that yanno? Every group has at least one of these "talents". I know cuz I dance, and dance videos/dance covers make up 60% of what I watch. Now to answer you're question, the moves aren't very complicated here, so all in all they all did well like you said. Have them do more hiphoppy stuff, I think Seolhyun would outshine them a little.
From a dancer's perspective, it's pretty obvious the overall best dancer is Chanmi, she's well balanced in terms of energy/cleanliness/character. However, for certain songs and certain parts of some dances other members pull it off better than her. For example, Choa pulls off the cat gesture the best because she literally moves like a cat licking it's paws whereas everyone else focuses more on the hip movement. Seolhyun has her moments where her energy outshines Chanmi's occasionally (Good Luck, Short Hair though not for the whole dance), and Hyejeong is known to pull off sexy concepts better than everyone else (shows here whenever it's her line).
The real bullies here is mina and those who defended her and sent hates to jimin. They ruined someone’s life, her career, her hardwork for the past 10 years.
Yeah. People who thought jimin was the bully have clearly never suffered bullying because there were many red flags about mina. I saw it straight away.
Choa, I love you so much Thanks for all the times you make me laugh. I'm sorry, I really hate to say this, but when you left aoa, I started crying TnT Goodbye Choa.
I got this from reddit, but i shared it here because this sums up everything so well: I have been saying this opinion for a long time, but while Mina may have experienced hurt at some point from Jimin, she has LONG stopped being a victim and instead turned herself into a perpetrator. Not only to the AOA members, but to multiple innocent people. None of what this Dispatch report reveals is surprising information, it just comfirms a pattern of horrific, abusive, manipulative, gaslighting, and narcisstic behaviour from Mina. Recall that she power tripped and got a nurse fired in the times of the pandamic all because she didn’t like the nurse’s “tone,” when she herself was being rude and demanding to the nurse. Recall that she proudly went to social media to brag about what she did to that nurse and then backpedalled when people criticized her. Recall that she knowingly went after someone else’s boyfriend, broadcasted their relationship in public without any shame, gaslighted the girlfriend into thinking she was the problem and was delusional for thinking that her boyfriend had cheated on her and that they had already broken up (they had not), straight up lied that the girlfriend’s father had sent her death threats and slandered him as being part of a mafia, and then threatened the boyfriend (who was not innocent as a cheater, but even he somehow got sick of her threats) with suicide if he didn’t respond to her texts. Recall that she has sl*t shamed Jimin MULTIPLE TIMES, going on her live as if exposing a huge secret to say “there is a member who really likes sex. It’s Shin Jimin.” And the one time she mentioned that Jimin brought a “man over for sex,” it actually turned out that they were playing boardgames, had invited Mina to join them, and she declined. Recall that she claimed Jimin was responsible for giving her cervical cancer which is transmitted through sexual intercourse. Hilarious double standards. Recall that she changed her story multiples times on whether the other members were innocent or not. At one point someone asked her what exactly wrong had Seolhyun done to her, and the worst thing Mina could think of was that Seolhyun’s dog had pooped in Seolhyun’s own dorm. Recall that the initial claim she had of FNC and Jimin not letting her meet her father at his deathbed turned out to be false and Mina herself just didn’t want to go. Now look at what has been revealed today: that even kind, patient Choa had given up on Mina listening to her. Some people say that if Choa was the leader, AOA would be safe. But that’s not true. Choa was done with her too and only Jimin, as the leader, had the persistence to try and make Mina listen for the sake of the team. In 10 years, Mina only took vocal lessons 3 times. She caused a comeback to be delayed because she went and had her hair done and refused to come to practice. Any leader would not be able to tolerate a member bringing the whole team down. Any person who works and has an actual job that involves coworkers knows this. It looks like Jimin was strict and tried to get her to play as a team player and Mina took that as an attack. If it was Choa as the leader, she would have just replaced Jimin as the target of Mina’s resentment. People talk about mental illness and sympathize with Mina to ridiculous degrees, but don’t seem to be able to spare an ounce of sympathy for the other members who ALSO are struggling with mental illness. (On that note, Mina has even belittled and made fun of Chanmi’s depression before). “Hurt people hurt people.” That’s not an excuse, that’s an explanation at best. Being mentally ill does not give ANYONE the right to deprive people of their livelihoods (like with the nurse and AOA), ruin relationships and slander others (like with the girlfriend and her father), sl*tshame them (she straight up calls Jimin a wh**e in the texts to her), or hold them hostage with threats of suicide. I have stopped feeling sympathy for Mina, she has just hurt too many people and is set out to destroy lives. She won’t be satisfied until Jimin kills herself. I would say she’s a psychopath but it’s more likely that she is a narcissist who lives in her own world where she is perpetually the victim. If anyone has dealt with a narcissist in their lives before they would know how they completely destroy you from the inside out and make you question your own reality and sanity. I feel sorry for AOA, Jimin, the nurse, the ex girlfriend, and anyone else Mina has harmed. I hope they heal and get their justice one day from the emotional and mental abuse they’ve faced from Mina.
you know i think Mina suffered way too much and the pain she's been through keep her caged into a negative state of mind that is negative for her first,she's unhappy,she suffers you guys don't imagine how it must feel like to have the whole universe against you,harrassing you.We must try to understand her,to show compassion.She's the biggest and first victim in the story,should we blame her for complaining,expressing her sufferance, it's so wrong poor her that would even more victimise her.this comment would only reinforce the feeling she has not to be understood nor believed.we love you Mina!
@@redrose999INVU No, the victims in the bullying story is aoa, because they got harassed and bullied for a year over false allegations. Mental health can’t be excuse for what she did, it’s not a excuse for ruining someones life. AOA’s mental health matters too and they were so wronged in this whole situation and you still have guts to defend Mina? Srs fuck off
I know People only pay attention to Choa as if she was a solo artist. Sucks though, now she's gone. The only good thing about her leaving as that everyone else will get noticed now but now there will always be a missing spot
i think on her statement on IG, this was the day that she was getting her hairline done and Jimin flipped over and got mad so she didnt went and participate in this dance practice.
It's 2019 and im still here. Idk i really like AOA this much, its so pleasant seeing them dancing in some serious heels, even until now there is no girlgroup that have similar vibes with them. Their dance isnt really full energy and make them sweat all over but thats what make them special
It's crazy watching this again now that i know this was the time Jimin locked Mina in a closet for "ruining her mood" when Mina's father was ill. Goes to show we never know what happens behind the scenes
chubbae jinyoung wanna one I don’t know about the rest, but chanmi was definitely not a bystander because she suffered severe depression and was bullied in the group according to her mother in an interview... she even ran away (went missing) once and her mother had to take a train to seoul daily for 2 months to ensure she doesn’t do anything silly... ))): a person who was bullied is definitely not a bystander I believe
@@joshskywalker614 well nothing is sure yet.. but we are guessing that maybe jimin bullied other members who withdrawed from AOA(YuKyoung, Choa and Mina) and also eunbi from ladyscord who has deceased already. Also Koream fans are guessing that SeulHyun is bystander or accomplice because she was very close to jimin and also said that Mina was annoying in ine TV program(well we don't know if she was just joking or being serious)... I'll let you know if somethjng else gets official!!
There's one of them that has extremely good dance skills o.o The one with brown hair, shoulder-lenght hair and the black t-shirt without the sleeves. It is just, I can't stop looking at her o.o
For one second i thought u was referring to Yuna. In my opinion, yuna's dancing was the best in this video cause she is the closest in imitating movements of a cat
MiuNya if it makes you feel better, they don't have ass, spend months dancing like cats and probably always feel cold even in summer because they're thin. They look really good dancing this on stage, but i think anyone can pull it off. tbh i think it would suit shorter people like you because cats= petite.
Forever Devillish I'm trying to make people feel better about themselves. Everyone has an ass i know that (it'd be abnormal to not have one) and obviously clothes protect us from the weather but so does natural body insulation, which i'm just pointing out, AOA would have less of compared to the many girls with other body shapes.
It's funny, because the damage that Shin Jimin did to Mina should never be forgotten, it is something that no person should forget, if we forget more things of this style will probably happen in the future and perhaps the consequences will be worse, please do not comment so empty and meaningless things 11 years of mistreatment and abuse should not be forgotten or forgiven
초아가 진짜 찰떡이네,,목소리도그렇고 고양이그자체네
애옹....애옹....애옹
근데 민아는 왜 없음? 나중에 들어왔나
초아가 에오에 고양이 이미지 다 만들어놨는데 나간게 아쉬움..
난 ㅠㅠ 유나도 좋은뎀 유나 음색 마음에 듦 초아가 졸라게 뛰어나서 그렇징
생긴것동 .....!!!!!!!!!
초아 누나는 진짜 전설이다..
ㅇㅈ 진짜 AOA 고양이 이미지는 초하가 다 한 듯...
@@Golden_ying_yeo_king 초아에요!
진짜 고양이,, 샴고양이 같아요
@@들개-n3i 결혼 안했어요ㅜ
Could some one translate this please
초아가 진짜 끼가 많은듯
뭔가 되게 앙큼해보이고 여우같음 계속 쳐다보게 됌
그리고 멤버들중에서 고양이에 대한 이해도나 표현력이 제일 높은거같음
진짜 여왕고양이 같애
냥아치를 안 키워 보셨구나... 이해도는 지민이 더 높은거 같은데........
@@조류즈-h8j 냥아치가 쓰레기는 아님ㅇㅇ
@@조류즈-h8j 지민은 도둑고양이 같은 느낌이고요ㅋㅋ 저는 여왕고양이 말한건데요?;
도둑 고양이는 저를 가소롭다는 듯이 처다보지는 않던데....
@@YHJ2070 도둑고양이는 알겠는데 여왕고양이... ㅋㅋㅋ 표현 오글거리는데 납득이 간다
안무 볼때마다 진짜 신기했던게, 노래 첫부분 나같은애 첨봣대 여기부분이랑 하이라이트...
안무가 동작은 단순해 보이지만 느낌을 잘 살리기가 진짜 개 어려워 보이는데..
저렇게 매혹적이게 자연스럽게 나오는게 신기. 자기껄로 만들려고 다들 얼마나 노력했을까..
이렇게 또 초아를 그리워하며 댓글을 남겨봅니다
당신은 선견지명이 있군요
하ㅜㅜ초아언니보고싶죠ㅜㅜ
촤...넘보고싶어요. 독보적 음색... 아끼지마..
돌아왔더랬죠
초아컴백
can't deny this will go down as one of the most iconic kpop songs
Oh hi JB XD
zynbw why was that?
zynbw that's a stupid logic
yeah & in future rookie groups gonna cover it
Still my jan
이 노래는 진짜 초아가 고양이같아서 잘 어울렸음 혜정은 개인적으로 짧은치마 오피스룩 찰떡이었고 민아나 설현은 청순하게 생겨서 심쿵해 개찰떡
지민이는 그냥 떡 ^^
민아 심쿵해 진짜 심쿵해ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
혜리 쿵떡 ^^
김희주 혹시 설현도 사건연루된 거 아시나요?
솔방울 3주전에 쓴거니까 지적하실거면 그냥 지나가주세요~ 팬 아닙니다~
지금 들어도 좋네ㅠㅠㅠ
이제는 참 아쉬운 걸그룹이 됐다.
안무도 참 독창적이면서 허스키한 초아보컬이 참 브레이브사운드와 찰떡이었는데..
두명 나가고 퀸덤으로 오르다 지민 사건 터져서 끝장난거 딴 맴버들이 오히려 불쌍🤢
@@cuddly-im5tr
방관자일수도...
난 민아가 넘 불쌍.. 더 활동하고 싶은데 계속하면 진짜 죽고싶을 만큼 괴롭히는 애하고 있어야 해서
탈퇴했는데..
ᄒ옵치 다른 멤버들도 알면서 그냥 방관한거니까.. 불쌍하다고 말하긴 애매한 듯
전부다 외계인 같이 생긴 신지민 그년 때문임 ㅡ.ㅡ
so many new kpop stans dont know how much of a popular and huge group AOA was, so many of them missed the golden sexy era of KPOP, this will forever remain iconic.
AOA IS A CLASSIC
Gotta admit no-one's ever gonna beat ChoA to this song. Stunning grace, I've been dancing for 3-4 years and I can't replicate it. Not saying I'm highly professional or anything hahaa, still a very amature dancer.
She looks like a cat too
Choa in Miniskirt - Like A Cat is undefeated. Hyejong came close
This one and the little walking dance thingy they do in excuse me! She does it sooo effortlessly it’s satisfying to watch
@@mj-kd9uz The one with blond hair
@L wait who's hyejong?? Sorry new fan here!!
1:00 진짜 이 파트는 초아 아니면 안됨...
진짜 고양이 같음
비쥬얼+노래+춤 다 되는 사기캐였음ㅠ
그건 아니고
ChoA is so gorgeous.... i'm not into Kpop that much but there are some groups i like, but Choa is the one i most like... i j fund out recently she is not in the industry anymore ...
Yeah we all miss her she was one of the best vocalists in my opinion
She is the best
I'm glad this didn't age well
(in the not being part of the industry anymore)
She back
Maria daza
Choa is back in a big way...a lot of the support staff are with her at Great M as she is now a soloist
근데 진짜 볼때마다 안무 잘만든듯...👍 노래랑도 어울리고 사뿐사뿐이라는 가사랑 찰떡. 그리고 고양이 세수하는부분은 진짜 고양이같고 초아 눈 확끌고 ... 안무가분 열일하셨네
초아 진짜 요염한 고양이 같다 초아밖에 안보여......
지금봐도 춤선이나 느낌이나 분위기 너무 초아님 ㅠㅜㅜㅜ 세젤예ㅠㅠㅠ 다시 보고싶어 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
이우리 나도ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Choa was the most eye catching... a real gem it's a shame she isnt singing anymore
Shame???
@@stanwjsn try reading it again but slowly so you can process it
Which one is she?
@@dr.c196 She's the blonde one
Thank you :) shes cute
I'VE GOT IT! I don't watch/listen/know much about Kpop but I got it! The blonde girl, she's been the one hypnotizing me LOL. She really mastered the dance and character!
Choa!!! She the main vocalist/guitarist (Aoa black) and oldest
+Pasemaca Tukana she knows her stuff!
+iBelieveAkinFly yes she's bae..... The other members call her choahjumma because she's the oldest and she doesn't know common slang (she's 25 btw). She's also one of the best Kpop vocalists imo ..
+Pasemaca Tukana haha. 25 is just right anyway!
+iBelieveAkinFly She ALSO mastered dancing in high heels. I'm surprised no one twisted an ankle o -o
Due to Recent News
Everyone's talking about Jimin and Mina
ME:
I am here just for CHOA
Same hahahahaha
Same
*yas me too*
Same
It is better not to comment on hateful things.
지금 보니까 보컬들도 진짜 탄탄하네... 노래 너무 좋다
와 초아씨 춤선 너무 예쁨,,,,,,
Something about Choa just keeps my attention on her
+ChiisaiJack like what
ChiisaiJack shes elegant...
김 종대 Ada wong Hairstyle
김 종대 Her hair because it's blond and short
고 신원 (9percent 加油) sameee
초아는 동작 하나하나 그냥 야옹이네요. .
다시 연예인으로 복귀하길. . .
아이돌 그룹들은 보다보면 뭐라고 설명하기 애매한데 딱 느낌이 오는 멤버가 있다. 난 AOA 이 때 처음 알았는데 초아 보고나서 "아! 비주얼로도 실력으로도 이 팀에서는 얘가 제일이구나:"라고 딱 느낌이 왔다. 나머지 애들은 애초부터 보이지도 않았음.
난 초아는 보컬, 민아는 비주얼....
민아는 그냥 눈에 안 띄는 느낌이던데 착하고 귀여움+소심하게 끼부리는 게 잘 어울리는 애 ㅇㅇ 아무리 민아가 피해자고 신지민이 썅년이지만 민아가 에오에 비주얼 담당은 아녔음 그랬음 설현이 잘 나갈 일도 없었겠지
초아는 그냥 전설 얼굴 몸매 실력 다 되는 ㄹㅇ 초아 원픽이었는데 역시 초아 리즈는 사뿐사뿐...
예쁘다 잘 버텨줬다 하는 건 좋은데 너무 올려치기는 하지 맙시다 아닌 건 아닌 거예요 🤗
Z .__. 사람들 취향마다 다른 건데 뭘 그걸 또 아닌 건 아니라고 딱 자르고 있냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
guys choa is so elegant like having her as the centre for the chorus part is perfect because the way she moves her hands is so elegant!!!
국내댓글 처음본 당신 축하합니다
장희재 ㄱㅅ
푸하하 !!
@@올라이트-d8d ewomm9 , t9yu9. .
하지만 지민이
웅 아니얌!!
does anyone else have the biggest crush on choa lmao
arvin bhattacharya I have my favourite 2 yes for all them I do.
Finally I found a fellow Nepali who loves choa !!!! My favourite is choa too ❤️
Kalpana Grg well if you mean that im nepali well sorry im korean/filipino
yes fml
+arvin bhattacharya really ? I am sorry then . In Nepal we have sur name like " bhattacharya" and also your name arvin is really popular name here so I thought you were Nepali , sorry again
AOA will forever be an iconic group! Their charisma is on another level.
That dance is classical i lv it so much
umm did anyone notice they're actually wearing heels with differing heights so they'll all look the same height?... dannggg
Omg I didn't notice that good observation
+Vik.Y.S. All korean groups do that. Check Lovelyz videos, they do it too, and SNSD as well ;)
+Eléonore Noblot SNSD too? Damn they must put hyoyeon and taeyeon in some pretty high heels then
+Janelle Rudolph what about sunny? o.o
IamnotJHope Sadly XD yes because shes about half a foot shorter than sooyoung
just cant keep my eyes off choa
me too!! haha
She is dam hot
+gatsby79 the hottest in the group imo! she looks like an anime character!
short and blond hair that is choa
yyyyyyes!!
이걸 알고리즘이 날 이끌었다
I was watching MEOVV - Meow and it reminded me of this song. I miss you AOA!
초아는 진짜 고양이네
I just now noticed that they have tape around their feet so that their heels wouldn't fall off! :P
Majority of K-pop girl group do it~
park bom probably would've benefited from this.
aegyoqueen160 My whole is a lie now
omg haha i did not see that
Lmao I though that was part of the shoe
와...2014년엔 유툽이 지금처럼 활성화 되지 않아서 그런가...
사뿐사뿐 안무가 이렇게 완벽한줄 몰랐네~
공중파 카메라웍이 고양이 춤할때 줌땡기거나 뱅글뱅글 회전시켜서 제대로 못봐서 그런지...
암튼 역대급 안무영상이다!!
초아는 진짜.. 비율진짜 너무 좋고 몸매 너무 이쁨 ㅠ 춤도 젤이쁘게 잘춤..노래도 잘하그 솔로로 대뷔하자 어차피 이굽노래할때 초아만 봤다
I can't take my eyes off Choa. Girl has so much stage presence it's crazy.
Choa's moves are so graceful, she's so perfect in this choreography
퀸덤땜에 노래 다 돌려듣는중 사뿐사뿐 도입부분 개좋아
Considering choA has *alot of fans* and most famous member in AOA it is shocking that she was the first one to leave the group, i literally see no hate comments about her, maybe it was jimin all along.
I used to stan aoa because of her .. she is the only girl I stan on kpop .. she need to comeback
@@reaction3268 What? Where? When?
@@darkp7774 she sang an OST
Seolhyun was deemed the most popular, but Hyejeong, Choa, and Jimin were top members too.
Choa was the motherly one, probably she got out because of little satan as well
choa does everything so feminine even when she dances she looks so elegant like the fucking queen she is
와.. 초아 진짜 춤잘춘다 손끝까지 느낌이 살아있음 노래도 잘하고 춤도 잘추고👍🏻
음색도 좋고 얼굴도 매력있고 몸매도 좋고 솔로로 나와도 진짜 잘할듯! 좋은 소속사 찾아서 솔로로 나와주세요~
히포쟈너 헝 한국인 ㅠㅠ
Seolhyun is so tall and gorgeous 😍
I think so
+KJ JH ㄴㅅㄴㅎㄴㅇㅅᆞㄴㅅㄹㅈㅅㄹᆞㄴᆞㅂ58594/^♡♡♡---/;;;;/님 ㅣㅣㅣㅣ. . ㅣ 합니당, .ㄱㄴㅂㄴㄷㅊㅅㄷ길ᆢㅈㄹㅅㄷㅅㄴㅌㄹ낀ㄴㅈㄷㅅㄴㅈㄷㅅㄹㄴᆞㄴㅅㄴㅎㄴㅅㅊㄴ 이 대통령은 ㅜ
Maybe her legs are longer than other members.It makes her height is taller.
+김경남 ?
초아 금발단발 진짜 ㄹㅈㄷ... 메보라 노래도 겁나 잘 부르는데 무대도 되게 잘함
oh .. my .. God .. Choa.. so beautiful .. crying T.T
cat dance is the best.
Cash Shew her voice😍😍😍😍
Cash Shew hnnng ikr??
I knowwww!
WHO IS CHOA PLEASE TELL ME
힐 신었는데.. 대단..
CHOA is so cute and beautiful
الو
JPOPが10年経っても追いつけない境地やな。まったく錆びてなくてすごい。
I like how AOA's dances are simple yet effective. Not many groups seem to be able to do that.
I’m in love with how choa moves! I’m trying to learn the dance so I’ve been using the 0.5 playing speed and I’m enamored with her every movement and expression. Her gracefulness and sexiness is even more emphasized. I think she captured how the cat moves the most and it’s seriously fascinating to watch!
"seriously fascinating" is so appropriate a description for Choa.
I could willingly spend a lifetime in a quest to know her better.
The brunette with bangs I like.
노래 자체가 명곡이네
ㄹㅇ 춤도 지림
déjà 9ans mais toujours aussi bon
Idk I feel like Choa is the best at doing the little cat thing thing at 1:03 but then again she's my bias 😍
Emily Nguyen she always does it beautifully
노래 춤 진짜 다 좋네...
계속 듣게 됨
What's the dance ranking in AOA? Because they all seem extremely good
I think Chanmi and Seolhyun are the main dancers? Im not sure
Chanmi
Chanmi > Seolhyun and Hyejeong > everyone else
Seolhyun makes it seem effortless, plus she does it in style. Hard to explain, she just makes the moves look "easy" and "good" or "better" even. I think she's always had a dancing background. For example, like how most people do one move and it seems sloppy/lazy or awkward, but she can make it work, kinda like that yanno? Every group has at least one of these "talents". I know cuz I dance, and dance videos/dance covers make up 60% of what I watch.
Now to answer you're question, the moves aren't very complicated here, so all in all they all did well like you said. Have them do more hiphoppy stuff, I think Seolhyun would outshine them a little.
From a dancer's perspective, it's pretty obvious the overall best dancer is Chanmi, she's well balanced in terms of energy/cleanliness/character. However, for certain songs and certain parts of some dances other members pull it off better than her. For example, Choa pulls off the cat gesture the best because she literally moves like a cat licking it's paws whereas everyone else focuses more on the hip movement. Seolhyun has her moments where her energy outshines Chanmi's occasionally (Good Luck, Short Hair though not for the whole dance), and Hyejeong is known to pull off sexy concepts better than everyone else (shows here whenever it's her line).
the way none of you are apologizing to jimin now but you were quick to harass her and defend someone without a single proof
The real bullies here is mina and those who defended her and sent hates to jimin. They ruined someone’s life, her career, her hardwork for the past 10 years.
For real
Yeah. People who thought jimin was the bully have clearly never suffered bullying because there were many red flags about mina. I saw it straight away.
Choa looks like Talking Angela, She's cute 😂
Which is the reason why kpop is cancer
@@jup1ter_f1ve why are you here if it's so cancerous
@@jup1ter_f1ve so is your mom
Y̶e̶a̶h̶ 😂😂😂
🤣
이 영상은 몇번을 봐도 진짜 초아밖에 안보임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 춤선 자체가 달라
Choa, I love you so much Thanks for all the times you make me laugh. I'm sorry, I really hate to say this, but when you left aoa, I started crying TnT
Goodbye Choa.
ChimChim y el Galleto sad :(
초아 이 노래 완전 찰떡
i just noticed the heel difference between Choa and Jimin and all the others.... :P
their heels are all different heights so when they're on stage there's not much height difference~😂
I think if Mina join this dance practice, she will be use the same heels with Choa and Jimin :)
Kartika Wibowo true!
최애곡이라 듣기만 했었는데 이때 하이힐신고 추셧구나 누나들
다리 엄청 아프셧겟다
지민 제외
걘 아파도 싸죠
@@japduck7SS7 엥 그건 아닌듯, 인성으로만 욕해용
나만 초아를 그리워한게 아니였어..
i miss them
I got this from reddit, but i shared it here because this sums up everything so well:
I have been saying this opinion for a long time, but while Mina may have experienced hurt at some point from Jimin, she has LONG stopped being a victim and instead turned herself into a perpetrator. Not only to the AOA members, but to multiple innocent people. None of what this Dispatch report reveals is surprising information, it just comfirms a pattern of horrific, abusive, manipulative, gaslighting, and narcisstic behaviour from Mina.
Recall that she power tripped and got a nurse fired in the times of the pandamic all because she didn’t like the nurse’s “tone,” when she herself was being rude and demanding to the nurse. Recall that she proudly went to social media to brag about what she did to that nurse and then backpedalled when people criticized her.
Recall that she knowingly went after someone else’s boyfriend, broadcasted their relationship in public without any shame, gaslighted the girlfriend into thinking she was the problem and was delusional for thinking that her boyfriend had cheated on her and that they had already broken up (they had not), straight up lied that the girlfriend’s father had sent her death threats and slandered him as being part of a mafia, and then threatened the boyfriend (who was not innocent as a cheater, but even he somehow got sick of her threats) with suicide if he didn’t respond to her texts.
Recall that she has sl*t shamed Jimin MULTIPLE TIMES, going on her live as if exposing a huge secret to say “there is a member who really likes sex. It’s Shin Jimin.” And the one time she mentioned that Jimin brought a “man over for sex,” it actually turned out that they were playing boardgames, had invited Mina to join them, and she declined. Recall that she claimed Jimin was responsible for giving her cervical cancer which is transmitted through sexual intercourse. Hilarious double standards.
Recall that she changed her story multiples times on whether the other members were innocent or not. At one point someone asked her what exactly wrong had Seolhyun done to her, and the worst thing Mina could think of was that Seolhyun’s dog had pooped in Seolhyun’s own dorm.
Recall that the initial claim she had of FNC and Jimin not letting her meet her father at his deathbed turned out to be false and Mina herself just didn’t want to go.
Now look at what has been revealed today: that even kind, patient Choa had given up on Mina listening to her. Some people say that if Choa was the leader, AOA would be safe. But that’s not true. Choa was done with her too and only Jimin, as the leader, had the persistence to try and make Mina listen for the sake of the team. In 10 years, Mina only took vocal lessons 3 times. She caused a comeback to be delayed because she went and had her hair done and refused to come to practice. Any leader would not be able to tolerate a member bringing the whole team down. Any person who works and has an actual job that involves coworkers knows this. It looks like Jimin was strict and tried to get her to play as a team player and Mina took that as an attack. If it was Choa as the leader, she would have just replaced Jimin as the target of Mina’s resentment.
People talk about mental illness and sympathize with Mina to ridiculous degrees, but don’t seem to be able to spare an ounce of sympathy for the other members who ALSO are struggling with mental illness. (On that note, Mina has even belittled and made fun of Chanmi’s depression before).
“Hurt people hurt people.” That’s not an excuse, that’s an explanation at best. Being mentally ill does not give ANYONE the right to deprive people of their livelihoods (like with the nurse and AOA), ruin relationships and slander others (like with the girlfriend and her father), sl*tshame them (she straight up calls Jimin a wh**e in the texts to her), or hold them hostage with threats of suicide.
I have stopped feeling sympathy for Mina, she has just hurt too many people and is set out to destroy lives. She won’t be satisfied until Jimin kills herself. I would say she’s a psychopath but it’s more likely that she is a narcissist who lives in her own world where she is perpetually the victim. If anyone has dealt with a narcissist in their lives before they would know how they completely destroy you from the inside out and make you question your own reality and sanity.
I feel sorry for AOA, Jimin, the nurse, the ex girlfriend, and anyone else Mina has harmed. I hope they heal and get their justice one day from the emotional and mental abuse they’ve faced from Mina.
True
holy shit. go off.
Do you remember what reddit thread you got it from?
you know i think Mina suffered way too much and the pain she's been through keep her caged into a negative state of mind that is negative for her first,she's unhappy,she suffers you guys don't imagine how it must feel like to have the whole universe against you,harrassing you.We must try to understand her,to show compassion.She's the biggest and first victim in the story,should we blame her for complaining,expressing her sufferance, it's so wrong poor her that would even more victimise her.this comment would only reinforce the feeling she has not to be understood nor believed.we love you Mina!
@@redrose999INVU No, the victims in the bullying story is aoa, because they got harassed and bullied for a year over false allegations. Mental health can’t be excuse for what she did, it’s not a excuse for ruining someones life. AOA’s mental health matters too and they were so wronged in this whole situation and you still have guts to defend Mina? Srs fuck off
I legitimately love this song, and the amazing dancing is a bonus.
agree'd🤛
I miss my Choa....ㅠㅠ
이쁘고 사랑해 초아
ㅇㄴ근데 도입부랑 중간중간 들리는 지민 목소리…엄청 팍 꽂히는 게 있긴 하다… 딴 건 몰라도 목소리 개성 하나만큼은 진짜 인정
no one ever mentions hyejeong or chanmi or mina so i'll say it here! i love my underrated talented girlies! (i love em all though!)
sunny d IKR , I actually love them the most
sunny d
Chanmi is my ultimate bias in all of kpop so I'm in like every video screaming praise for her 😂
sunny d i never thought aoa was underrated or overrated but they were just popular and known
*****
Mina was missing from this video! During this era she was filming a drama and her father passed away 😔
I know People only pay attention to Choa as if she was a solo artist. Sucks though, now she's gone. The only good thing about her leaving as that everyone else will get noticed now but now there will always be a missing spot
곡 분위기에 딱 들어맞는 보컬에
수준이 다른 디테일이 들어간 춤선에
고양이 그 자체였던 초아.. 3분 39초짜리 고양이 뮤지컬을 보여준다
I like listening to music by AOA they sing amazing ❤ 👏 😊
사복버전으로도 올려주지...ㅠ 안무영상이 무대의상과 하이힐 말이 됩니까
Now I understand why Mina is not on this video. She might have had a breakdown on that day and Jimin as a leader..... I still can't believe it.
i think on her statement on IG, this was the day that she was getting her hairline done and Jimin flipped over and got mad so she didnt went and participate in this dance practice.
Ok i dont understand this part.. Why mina is not in this?
I thought that Mina wasn't there because of her father's funeral.
yeah i was wondering why Mina is not there
Jimin hates mina
Tallest girl in them
Issss......
Hyejeong. 😍✨
That suppose to be a good thing? The shortest look the sexiest.
+Mike K like who? XD
+Dana Maharan Choa and Jimin
+Mike K 😂😂
actualy the tallest is mina choa jimin hahahahaha mina is the shortest actually
i miss choa!~ 😢😢❤️❤️❤️
#choa
Choa 're great dance well you're the best , you and all the other
Chanmi, Choa and Jimin appeals to me the most but they are all so beautiful. 😍😍😍
It's 2019 and im still here. Idk i really like AOA this much, its so pleasant seeing them dancing in some serious heels, even until now there is no girlgroup that have similar vibes with them. Their dance isnt really full energy and make them sweat all over but thats what make them special
I Miss them :'(
It's crazy watching this again now that i know this was the time Jimin locked Mina in a closet for "ruining her mood" when Mina's father was ill. Goes to show we never know what happens behind the scenes
Wtf?! For real? 😐
@@karlinanr6325 Yup and there are way more things Jimin did to Mina. Mina posted thise things on her Instagram and now Jimin dropped out of AOA
Did the other members knew this?? And they shut their mouth all this time??
chubbae jinyoung wanna one I don’t know about the rest, but chanmi was definitely not a bystander because she suffered severe depression and was bullied in the group according to her mother in an interview... she even ran away (went missing) once and her mother had to take a train to seoul daily for 2 months to ensure she doesn’t do anything silly... ))): a person who was bullied is definitely not a bystander I believe
@@joshskywalker614 well nothing is sure yet.. but we are guessing that maybe jimin bullied other members who withdrawed from AOA(YuKyoung, Choa and Mina) and also eunbi from ladyscord who has deceased already.
Also Koream fans are guessing that SeulHyun is bystander or accomplice because she was very close to jimin and also said that Mina was annoying in ine TV program(well we don't know if she was just joking or being serious)...
I'll let you know if somethjng else gets official!!
HYEJEONGS LEGS ARE BRIGHTER AND HOTTER THAN THE SUN
they are brighten than my future!!!
EXACTLY!! xDDD
+Ozcár Choi I saw you like 100 times under aoa videos...XD
Samuel Shiau REALLLY HAHAH XDDD
+Samuel Shiau nrl
I'm a big SNSD fan, but I can say without a doubt, AOA has some of the best practice dance cams in Kpop.
Like SNSD barely has dance practice lol those damned people at SM
Good luck and happy new 2024 ka 🎉🎉
돌아와 초아야ㅜㅜ
초아가 이팀을 살렷지 있을때 잘하지
I cant take my eyes off Choa
너무 초아😍
There's one of them that has extremely good dance skills o.o The one with brown hair, shoulder-lenght hair and the black t-shirt without the sleeves. It is just, I can't stop looking at her o.o
That's jimin its their leader
No, I learned who they are now! she is Hyejeong! ♥♥
For one second i thought u was referring to Yuna. In my opinion, yuna's dancing was the best in this video cause she is the closest in imitating movements of a cat
Yuri Miura The blond one is good too
123exo456bts Jimin has the shortest hair. Choa is the blonde :). She's is a really good dancer.
I was playing smite and realized Bastet has this as her dance emote😭so Iconic
choa reminds me of talking angela
Lol
omfg I wasn't the only one who thought that 😆😆😆
+Anime Luver THANK YOU VERY MUCH
+Anime Luver hola
hola
改めて見るとAOAって全員のスタイルマジで異次元
If I had a body like a korean idol id also want to dance like this ;; ugh they look so good. Why did I have to be genetically short and stumpy.
MiuNya if it makes you feel better, they don't have ass, spend months dancing like cats and probably always feel cold even in summer because they're thin. They look really good dancing this on stage, but i think anyone can pull it off. tbh i think it would suit shorter people like you because cats= petite.
They don't have ass? You must be blind. And clothes exist for a reason.
Forever Devillish I'm trying to make people feel better about themselves.
Everyone has an ass i know that (it'd be abnormal to not have one) and obviously clothes protect us from the weather but so does natural body insulation, which i'm just pointing out, AOA would have less of compared to the many girls with other body shapes.
Ok I'm sorry but most people are stumpy because of the choices they make in life(diet, exercise regimens)
Forever Devillish that's quite true as well...
01:12 whenever I do that my face gets covered with hair -_-
Same
omg same
dirty waturr $l !! this v bh vv·
초아가 '사뿐사뿐 걸어가~~' 이 부분할 때 노란 치즈 고양이가 애교 부리는거 같당😁
Choa, only Choa ♥️♥️♥️
TH-cam is weird showing all AOA's content times like this I don't wanna get reminded of what Jimin did to Mina
then don't click it. The more you click the more the algorythm will show you some...and make it trend
Satan you mean ?
It's funny, because the damage that Shin Jimin did to Mina should never be forgotten, it is something that no person should forget, if we forget more things of this style will probably happen in the future and perhaps the consequences will be worse, please do not comment so empty and meaningless things
11 years of mistreatment and abuse should not be forgotten or forgiven
@@freedom43774 she tried to commit suicide and you want her to wait until they RETIRE go and re-think your words and be more educated
@@freedom43774 ........ continue
Can't stop lookin' at Seoulhyn...😍
S A M E
can i just express how much i adore aoa like they're really good, their songs are catchy they are also good looking god damn it i---
Choa best in both vocal and dance!!