1,000$ Daily Salary But After 6 Days Ordinary People Become Devils
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- The real story of an experiment where a group of men are taken to a fake prison and are assigned the roles of guards and prisoners to test how their minds will work under these new labels.
Subscribe to our friends channel: tinyurl.com/Mo...
The funny thing is you don’t even need a prison experiment study to see how people act with power. Just work in customer service.
I WANT MY DAMN FRYS!
ikr
It’s not just the customers either, just look at the amount of petty managers who abuse their power
I've heard of 911 operators hanging up on people because they were being "rude" or "non-compliant" for freaking out while having an emergency and not payting attention like a robot to the phone operator.
I don't know who those people think they are but they should know that they're just a fleshy automated phone operator, their jobs are as impressive as a automated computerized voice phone operator....
@@leocervidae to be fair someone who can barely drop fries without fucking up thinks they are more important than they are.
fine shut down all fast food. you know what happens? your still at another minimum wage job because you have no skills and the us loses a few pounds from less fat food.
The experiment didn't even look that hard, but everyone had to let things get to thier heards
I mean I don't condone what they did , but their message was semi-justifiable . NOW , the DELIVERY was ALL THE WAY WRONG .
They just wanted to teach that even though they can't physically abuse them due to the rules , they have no qualms about breaking them down mentally . But unfortunately , when placed into a position of power you start to think you have everything figured out , and that you can get away with anything you want .
Not to mention , where was the professor during all this ? AND WHY WASN'T MICHAEL TRIALED FOR BENJI's DEATH !? even though they signed an agreement , I'm pretty sure it's nulled if you violate the rules of the agreement ! SO HE'S RESPONSIBLE FOR MURDER IN THE 3RD degree !
It was an experiment done in the 70s. No one was killed, but it was caned after like 8 days.
Without that asshole chase it would have been ok
@@tracexcze5408 Correction , I quite literally understood the film as it was based on an ACTUAL experiment which I had to do a report on . Also , IT'S CLEARLY IMPLIED that the red light was SPECIFIED to be manually turned on by the professor if he and his witnesses saw something wrong that occurred during the experiment that violated the previously stated rules . One of the rules is that ( PHYSICAL CONTACT , OR INTENT TO HARM THE PRISONERS PHYSICALLY ) isn't justified by any means and will result in the end of the experiment and no one getting paid .
What confuses me is that although the film shows scenes of them entering rooms without cameras to commit these atrocities , there are also scenes WHERE THERE ARE CLEARLY CAMERAS , AND THE GUARDS ACKNOWLEDGE SUCH ! IT'S A MASSIVE HOLE IN THE PLOT , WHY DID THE LIGHT NOT TURN RED !?
Not to mention the reason the guards think it was justified is because they excuse themselves with the excuses that ( " If we did something wrong the researches obviously saw it , which means we're not breaking the rules . And , if anyone was in our situation they'd do the same " )
Not to mention , MIKE MOST DEFINITELY DESERVED JAIL TIME . HE VIOLATED THE AGREEMENT RESULTING IN ITS ANULLMENT ! THEREFORE HE'S RESPONSIBLE AND ABLE TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR MURDER IN THE 3RD DEGREE !!!
@@thatonestreamergod8137 You know what a lie is, right?
if the guys blood sugar was low, insulin would only lower it further. He needed candy or some form of sugar/carbs.
That’s true, maybe the narrator messed up that part (about his blood sugar being too low)
Maybe in the movie, his blood sugar are really high. Tho the symptoms shows low blood sugar lol
@@MythicRealTrap possibly, but he had all his candy and stuff taken off of him. And I doubt there was much carbs in the gloop he was served
@@bmcc1231 But the main character gave him bread
@@pureone8350 there's no way he'd go hyperglycaemic from one piece of bread
Yeah movies never seen to get diabetes right
Important! This movie is based on the 'Stanford Prison Experiment' as many people have pointed out. However it's important to note that the Stanford Prison Experiment is an un-scientific experiment and has done a lot of damage to the field of psychology! The outcomes and the entire procedure of the experiment were manipulated in order to get the results that professor Philip Zimbardo wanted to. Multiple of the guards refused to hurt their prisoner counterparts until Zimbardo explicitly told them to do it multiple times.
If you wish to learn about an actual scientific study about obedience to authority and power relations look up Stanley Milgram's 'Obedience to Authority' study.
Thank you for the information. Will check out both studies.
eeeh... while you may think its " a compromise of the study" the reason the dr "forced them" to do act against the prisoner is to remove theyr social structure . you realy need to make them do it once , then they are capable of repeating the action with no real problem.
i don't particolary think the study was done in the right way or not, but the " force them to do shit" is part of the study . most soldier \ guards \cults etc... are pushed by theyr superior to do shit the first time , because thats how you get ""good ppl"" to do bad shit.
@@unknow11712 forcing them doesn't make it happen natural so he still ruined the experiment
@@salmaabdullahgb he was taking the place of the "senior" that should have forced them in a " natural" enviroment.
Captain Disappointing
Yours is the best comment in the comment section so far.
The Milgram Experiment - which was repeated world wide with the same results - really shows how much people are capable of doing to other people when told by a so called authority in an objective, scientific way.
You don’t take insulin for low blood sugar I wish movies portrayed diabetes correctly especially type 1! It could save someone’s life one day! Giving insulin to a diabetic person with low blood sugar would kill them.
yeah....but if your body is dependent on insulin then when you go without it that can kill you as well......derp derp.
@@beefnacos6258 insulin is taken for high blood sugar levels (hyper) not low blood sugars (hypo) this film depicted it wrong, every single human being is dependent on insulin it’s just that with diabetics especially type 1 diabetics their pancreas no longer creates insulin so they have to take it artificially
So in the end, they all chilled in the bus and had “it was just a prank bro” moment🤣😂
😂😂😂💯❤️
Right and ain't no way Forrest Whittaker is breathing after that tragedy if I had something to say about it.
@@jasonallen3678 exactly he was responsible for the diabetic guy' death. Makes no sense he get away with that
Not to mention the rape!
@@hachitachi was Chase not strangled to death? If not, he also should be trialed for that ofcourse
The way to beat this experiment is to agree to just live as equals even with different positions. Sadly a lot of people are corrupted by power and aren't capable of that.
another way is to also question authority or the people who have the REAL power, which would have been the ones running the experiment.
Thank you. This is ridiculous and sad how people act.
Those desperate for money will do as they are told in order to get the money. Your solution would not fall within the rules of the study.
No because the whole concept was to act their roles
@@matttt123451 i could play their role in a more peaceful way
Carson held up to his word and held his dignity in never changing throughout the whole experience. I was rooting for him the whole time.
'Carson'?
i am sure most of the people work in some kind of office and/ or factory scenario. who has noticed that once some one amongst you was promoted over you and had power over you suddenly changed their behavior?
probably because you're a shit employee and they can finally do something about it 😂
Or in the Military
@@Lancelot0311 can’t feel bad for anyone in the military. You agreed to let the government owe you and follow every order you’re given no matter what. Of course it was going to be an awful and terrible experience. I would never ever join an organization that demands I drop all my morales and do anything I’m told no questions asked, but people do it every day and then get shook when they realize they don’t control their own lives anymore
@@goodmanntalks3127 you’re a real clown Pal. I’m in the infantry doing a humanitarian mission. Learn about the military before you speak about the subject.
That's because people don't respect someone who is in a position of power but act powerless.
This really happened. I believe it was Stanford University that did this experiment. It got so real and so violent that it had to be cut short.
This was the 2nd movie based off of this
@@horseheaddad3427 what's the first movie?
Fallible experiment and the conclusions cannot be used as valid. Too much influence from the psychologist and too many uncontrolled factors. Invalid study.
@@hereticsshallbecleansed7245 I believe it was Das Experiment ( or however it is written into german )
@@hereticsshallbecleansed7245 Stanford experiment
“We can do something about it”... The power of choice makes us human. The freewill to choose what's right.
The Experiment was/is based off the Stanford Prison Experiment... this movie adaptation is heartbreaking because Adrian Brody delivers such a compelling performance.
This is just like the Stanford experiment in 1971 which was scheduled for 2 weeks, but lasted for 6 days. Things got very out-of-hand.
Chase wanted some Oscar BAD 😂
'What dat mouf do?'
The professor couldn't even abide by the rules so how could you expect the test subjects.
I really like the background music of your videos and have gotten used to it. This is the reason I like this channel out of all the other movie recap channels.
It’s sad how true this is.
It always starts iff with almost everyone sweet and nice. But nobody remains like that.
Reminded me of the Belko experiment
@@auctifer0 hmmm interesting.
Should I check it out? Do u recommend?
@@emant8396 It was okay, worth watching once. I enjoyed it although for some reason I had expected it to be even more compelling.
@@beno1129 i see. Thanks for the opinion.
Some of us do. You just have to have the will to and a lot of those men didn't. Realize when you're overstepping rationality and reel yourself back in
This whole movie was based off a real events known as The Stanford Experiment. It was a psychology experiment done at Stanford University back in the 70s, instead of $1000/day the subjects were offered $15/day. It was supposed to be 2 weeks long but ended up being terminated after 5 days when the brutality had escalated past what was considered ethical.
@Aliver87 Ok and?…you do realize that the experiment predates the German film right?
@Aliver87 I’m not in any way saying this was a remake of any other film. What I said was the movie is based on a real life event that took place at Stanford University during the 1970s
that experiment isnt considered even remotely scientific. it was basically paid actors and people need to stop hyping it up.
I loved this movie when I was younger. When Nix took off his shirt and revealed his giant neo nazi tattoo, it blew me away. And that slow motion scene of all of them running down the hall stayed in my memory. Good movie
The thing is, I feel like Nix was always the elephant in the room. But because he knows he has the guts and the knowledge to get "the job done". He lays low because he knows what he's capable of.
Me to I thought he was Mexican lol
Yes, this can happen. Always try to surround yourself with different people in your life. It helps with independent thinking and rational perspectives.
“Women, pot, and smiles” good life motto Chase, good life motto.
Why pot? is he a home appliances salesman? I don't get this part
@@yujisamadesu pot is marijuana my guy
I love every role that Adrian Brody portrays, such an awesome actor
Based on a real story when a university turned into a prison and stripped people and abused them
There's no other actor that can act as despicable in some movies and as joyful and loving in others as FOREST Whittaker. Did he ever get an Oscar? Because he certainly does on my opinion deserves one.
The cast did such an amazing job here. Fisher Stevens is such an underrated legend.
“Classic horrible prison lunch” that’s light years ahead of what I ate in prison. Aramark is absolutely disgusting, if you know you know. Maggots in the summer, snow falling through the windows onto your tray in the winter
While this is a great look at the mentality of prisoners/guards, its also something ive seen in various work places over the years. So many times I've seen so many people that just accept others behaviors even when they are in no form of authority over them. So many times ive heard someone say "man so and so sucks, but theyve been here X years, or they are good friends with so and so, or sometimes its as simple as theyre pretty smart so they get to act how they want."
Outside of actual supervisoral roles, much of the "hierarchy" between team mebers of the same rank is as organized as picking team captain for kickball during recess when in elementary school.
I learned about a similar study in my AP psychology class. It was a lesson on will your morals change if you are directed by a person of authority.
The study also had guards, prisoners, and a warden. The guards and warden seemed to like the power and went on power trips against the prisoners cause they wanted to, or because they were told to.
The whole point of the experiment in this movie was to see how far the guards would go with their power if they got “permission” (the red light not flashing)
6:06 this violates the rules of ethics in experimental research. If someone has a medical emergency, they are required to get proper help, or permission to leave the experiment.
Many posters have pointed out correctly that this is based on a real life Stanford experiment. However no one has pointed out the important fact that many of the elements of that study is in use today and called Reality TV.
Power corrupts any man, no matter how pure he is or how he was raised, the presence of others hastens this process
Maybe it corrupts some men but I believe crown mentality plays a large part, I feel most of the guards wouldn’t have acted so if no one took advantage of their role.
Power does not corrupt it only shows who we truly are a truly good man without power will do no harm
This is really similar to the Stanford Experiment
Amazing
It's not really amazing at all... It's clearly a poorly written copy of it.
It seems interesting. We learned this in Psychology.
This is where Saw Gerrera became an extremist
Had to watch it in college when i took psychology class. I remember watching it 2nd and 3rd time coz i was fascinated with how humans' brains work. But thinking of it now.. lol 😂 there's a lot more movies about psychology.
The Bible outlines the physcology of humans pretty well.
@@op8995 i don't even understand bible.. i tried to read it.. none of it makes sense.
There is also a german movie, which includes the same events, as this movie does. However the ending is far more darker than this one, as not only a few people die, but also the scientist gets shot by a guard.
Yeah, this is basically a 1:1 remake of the original german movie
How does Forest Whitaker not age?
At the the 7:00 min mark we clearly see 5 pale guards however we know that there are 2 copper colored guards as well(David Banner & forest Whitaker) so the dilemma with the production is, they said that there was 6 Guards and the Rest were prisoners however, we see 7 different guards for some reason... So that's a slip up on the producer and director...
Just check out original 2001 german "Das Experiment" not this cheap remake.
excuse me… copperd colored?
@@aniahaniah2282 LMFAO
Copper. Cringe asf
@@aniahaniah2282 No excuse for you
Theres a german Version of this FIlm called "Das Experiment" , it goes down the same line and was pretty good.
does anyone know who the narrator is? i absolutely love this narration voice. i can’t watch any other movie recap video unless it’s this specific voice. ah!! so so good! thank you to whomever you are! ❤️
The robot from Lost In Space
@@Lil_ThickOh my god! Really? Thank you for letting me know! ❤️
I’m surprised only one guy died, I expected everyone dead with one lone survivor. Guess humanity is more morale than I thought.
Without chase the experiment would have been normal 😂😂
This is based on a real event and that fact should terrify all of us.
"As she kisses his soft knuckles" took me out 😂
This movie is based on a real experiment! The guards let the power go to their heads.
The director of this move clearly watched the Stanford prison experiment. I’m not mad though. People should be mad about the prison industrial complex and the prison system/experience as a whole.
the sed part is, this movie is bsed on true story!
this experiment was seceret and the experiment didn't concluded any proper outcome
Forrest Whittaker character was right. Everything that went wrong with the experiment can be traced back to Travis (Adrien's character).
the fact that the dr running it got kidnapped and held prisoner by the gang in always sunny is deeply satisfying
That prison lunch ironically is a decent meal
😂 travis got soft knuckles 🤣
this is why i always refuse to be a leader in projects or divisions. i have no idea if I'm doing good or bad, if I'm harming or helping
“When the chips are down, these “civilized” people, they’ll eat each other.”
Prison lunch looks better than school food 💀
Power is absolute , and corrupts , there is always a price to pay mentally emotionally physically , and so on ,
The experiment proved it , the real one , that’s why there are limitations on what can go on in prisons , , but the film is good it shows humanity at its worse , good one ,
You've completely missed the point of both the movie and the real experiment. Absolute power comes in many forms such as a mother taking care of her baby. Power doesn't corrupt absolutely. For every corrupt cop, soldier or guard, there are more who sacrifice their lives to save innocent people ie. Cops and Firefighters rushing into the 9-11 towers to save lives.
The point of the experiment is that people have a tendency to realign their personal moral compass to comply with authority. In the movie, the guards stopped questioning right and wrong and allowed a red light to become their moral compass. In the real 1971 experiment, volunteers electrocuted (or thought they did) a person crying and begging to be released - all because the professor in charge told them to continue.
People, generally speaking, rarely stand up against authority when it comes to right vs. wrong.
Funfact - This film is a remake of the german "Das Experiment" from 2001. But in the german version, the prisoners and the guards are swapping after a brief time.
The real life doctor (Zimbardo) started the experiment to try to prove his hypothesis that the acts of the Nazi soldiers in WWII were carried out because those individuals were different from normal people in some way, meaning they were more willing to do horrific things to people (because others contested that this wasn't true and that the soldiers were under extreme social influence).
A cross-section of normal people were taken to the facility and randomly assigned either guard or prisoner.
Similar to the movie, it ended badly and the experiment had to be shut down after only a short amount of time because of the brutality. In fact, the effect of the environment was seemingly so strong that Zimbardo himself got caught up in it and started abusing his power as the researcher too.
So he ended up contradicting his own original hypothesis.
The experiment was a sham, since the guards didn't want to be violent. Zimbardo had to press them to give him the results he wanted. He is widely discredited, and regarded as a joke
Adriren Brody looks like John Lennon sometimes.
SUCH a good movie. Highly recommend to high schoolers to teach them the reality of power hoarding
Boy said soft knuckles
Lmao 🤣
@@bizcut i knew i wasnt the only one who caught that 😂😂
Stanford Prison Experiment: The Movie.
Except there was also a Stanford Prison Experiment movie lol
@Miles Thompson This movie was actually made before the second one(2010 and 2015 respectfully)..
This video was released 6 days ago
These ppl folded hella easy 🤣 if I was doing this I’d simply just not act insane.
We all think we would but it's not until we are in that situation that we truly know who we are.
@@beautyhunter2286 But the shit is not real why act stupid and ridiculous for nothing. Everybody about to get paid just to sit there and shut up. I don't understand people.
That chair kick at 7:28 looks like real head trauma. Ouch!
I am in not way an authoritarian but the prisoners seemed to loose their shit immediately.
Like you know that if you wont get punished for that basketball thing you are risking not getting paid? So maybe even if its a bit unfair that you hit a dude with a basketball its possible to read that situation that way, and doing 10 pushups is nothing. Pride might not be a thing to even think about then and there.
I mean later of course, but doing ten pushups for an accident or just eating the food seems like a passable test?
I am kinda getting your point.
To be honest movie caps ,me and my family can always make Popcorns just to watch your recaps ,thank you for being our netflix buddy♥♥♥♥
What the heck is this casting, wow it's full of A stars what the heck.
The guards all went on to become police officers and enjoyed qualified immunity for the rest of their careers.
How hedwig keep that eyeliner on😂😂😂
Power⚡ huh
Money can definitely ruin/corrupt any human being, especially those in need desperately...
There is a German version of the movie, which I can highly recommend. It's less dramaticised and allows for a glimpse into how the scientists justify the actions.
The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, that more or less can explain people's behavior
The light is the main problem. There should be clearly written rules, and the second they aren’t adhered to, the one who breaks the rules should be removed and penalized.
But the movie made the point that often times there is nothing to hold those with authority accountable, so they realize they can do what they want.
if the prisoners were more respectful as well then they wouldnt have been treated badly. in the movie it all started when the prisoners denied eating the food the guards gave them and started making fun of them and if i remember correctly they started thrwoing the food towards the guards
the funniest thing that happened to me in my work was when a customer came to me with one of those scratching tickets that cost her 5€ and she had won nothing she literally asked me to spawn a win on it saying that the store is scamming people because it just took 5€ from her :DDD
there's a spot at 2:43 where, if you look frame by frame, by pausing the video and tapping the , and . keys to go back and forth, the old man's face on the right glitches by jolting up from one frame to the next, then back down.
i don't like glitchy things.
The movie The Stanford Prison Experiment is WAY better! You see all the real footage and reactions mixed in with the movie. It feels much more real seeing the actual footage. One of the most insane experiments I’ve ever seen
Doesn't retract from the fact (In my opinion) that this was a great movie
Wow I learned of this in my psychology class! “Zimbardo prison experiment”
the lesson is: you shouldnt need a red light to pop up to know that what you're doing is wrong,
I remember watching the german adaption of this movie in german class in college, I the whole class was so disturbed after finishing it, we needed to go to the cafeteria to drink something to calm down
Power over others starts from birth, when a mother starts to take care of a newborn baby. That doesn't mean it will lead to abuse.
The point of the movie's experiment is that most people will blindly trust 'authority' and will align their personal moral compass to this higher 'authority'. Of course, back in the 1970s people had a lot more trust in authority.
David banner underrated af as a actor
Thank God people don't behave this way in real-life 🙄 that would be terrible
This is just the Stanford Prison Experiment
Choosing the tough looking guys as the guards misses the point of this incident entirely. It doesnt matter who you are or what you look like.
Checkout original german version "Das Experiment" from 2001.
Seems to be inspired by Stanford prison experiment
There is a quite similar german movie from 2001 called "Das Experiment" watched that in biology in school. Based on what I remember, they got sued for putting "based on a true story" at the end.
Not similar but simply original. This 2010 version is just cheap remake. 2001 "Das Experiment" was in cinemas in Europe and US... 2010 remake just direct-to-video, what is good information about quality of this production.
Good to know. Always thought of it as just another "small" movie, never knew it made it even into US cinemas.
As she kisses his soft knuckles 😂😂😂 excellent
“Kisses his knuckles and notices it is not soft anymore”
Yeah we all watched the same clip dude.
@@michaelcohen9363 What are you yappinf? the line just struck me.
@@bad8646 we all saw the same clip, there was no reason for you to repeat it like a parrot.
I knew this sht was going down hill when they said “deprived of civil rights”
Im sorry,but I would have stalked all the guards until I atleast killed most of them after that b.s experiment and Forrest Whittaker would be the first to go..
They missed the part where they turned into devils
Wow.. I have been looking for this movie. TH-cam algorithm and our minds is worth studying
Damn Aaron rodgers is a great actor
Its is really annoying you dont post the movie title in the description.
He said it
$1000 wage* salary is monthly pay, wages are daily/weekly ones.
Wage can be your compensation over any time period. There is no set period for wages. It is usually defined by a modifier. For example, "hourly wage" is a common term on job listings.
@@nuknukisdead ty for letting me know :)
I love that they put the 'piet Paulusma word aangereden' video in the movie, was a really big meme about a weatherman in Holland lol
these videos always make my day :))
After that experiment, those guards would be limping.
Not all humans are subject to absolute power corruption. Upbringing, intelligence and education can negate such behavior.
Whenever I see that one guy from Never Back Down, I know shit is about to get real.
This is basically how the police behave
"My crush became a man"