1:29 : Ashley 3:40 : Clementine 6:39 : Graveyard 8:03 : You should be sad 9:35 : Forever...( is a long time) 11:23: Dominic's Interlude 12:46: I hate everybody 14:42 : 3am 16:45: Without me 18:36: Finally//beautiful stranger 19:33: Alanis' Interlude 20:18: Killing boys 21:44: SUGA's Interlude 22:53: More 25:03: Still learning 26:07: 929
this is actually super insightful! on forever is a long time she talked about how it started out as a happy relationship but as the song progressed she let her own insecurities & anxiety get the best of her & tried to express that sonically & lyrically. that’s what the “tell your man he’s got bad news coming” like comes from. also for dominic’s interlude she said it was like a continuation of that & a brotherly voice encouraging her to break up with that same guy. your interpretation on pretty much all of her lyrics though is pretty on the nail with what she was sharing so for barely known her you kinda were a beast lmaoo
Big ups for you for looking up the translations, you are the first non also BTS fan reactor I have seen doing that.👏👏👏. Where were some who even purposefully skipped it🙄
This was honestly one is the best reactions I’ve seen and how fast u caught unto everything. I’ve been following Halsey since debut (Room 93), I would recommend u react to her HFK album. 😁😁
I love the way you analyze and really dig into the music. It reminds me why I love music and find it to be such a personal aspect of myself. It’s art and you treat it as so. As someone with Bipolar, I fell in love with this album the second I heard it. Each track really feels like a different aspect of mania or depression, which are the two emotions you experience as bipolar. I felt extremely heard and less alone. Songs like Clementine, I hate Everybody, 3am (especially this song), Killing Boys, and Still Learning are clear examples of the struggles and emotions Bipolar individuals experience.
About "More".. she have had 3 miscarriages due to endometriosis.. she even shared about it on an interview that she was touring and had a miscarriage on stage while performing when she didn't knew she was pregnant! Also in Ashley she referred the line "I'll leave you the dust my love" to her fans.. In "Dominic's interlude" the song is produced beautifully.. but just where her voice fades while saying "just right.. just right" she's kinda talking to herself and contemplating about her past.. and as the music becomes even more theatrical and sort of builds in the background with the piano and the rain it signifies a tendency of overthinking stuff and being skeptical about a person's self image..I loved how you've put efforts and listened carefully and comprehensively.. you've got new subscriber!!! 🤗
Loved your analysis' and reaction to the album. Definitely even helped me, a seasoned Halsey fan, realize a little deeper meaning behind some of these lyrics.
"Am I getting yeehaw from this?" I love it so much. I feel like watching your reaction reminds me of when I was making analysis essays back when I was an undergrad student. Definitely looking forward for more in-depth analysis from you!
Her first two albums were great too, you should def give them a listen. Badlands is sort of a seminal work that set me on a different course in life than I had been following, and I’m glad it did.
If you hadn't pointed out the Cry Me A River interpolation, I swear I would have never figured out why it felt so familiar. WOW! I loved your reaction and analysis btw!
I see exactly what you’re saying about 929 undoing what she fought so hard for in still learning, but I think she did it purposefully because being bipolar means you’re going to cycle. So you’re finally getting it together and then cycle back to the same destructive behavior partly Because you feel invincible and partly because you don’t feel like you deserve. It’s part of being manic but you still have to find out how to grow and love yourself even when you know you’re gonna cycle back down that depressive road. It’s really profound that she chose to do it that way. It’s a very tangible way to express to others that the mania is coming down. They’re both equally and simultaneously her truth
I just found you and this was an incredible reaction and breakdown! Love it. You got so much that most people didn’t get. Respect for listening to the lyrics and not just blurring past them ❤️
Loved this reaction! And that was John Mayer on the ending of 3 am btw :) and the “mirror” is about her previous albums where she made the Halsey persona but now on manic she is more open as Ashley not the others way around. It’s Halsey’s third album but Ashley’s first. When someone questioned why she flexing her hit song Without Me she said “Anti-popstar is more about a mentality I think. It’s more about denying the notion that female pop artists should succumb to the social expectations of the genre.”
![[LIVE] นาทีนี้ต้องพี่ทนาย | ทนายแก้ว vs ทนายไพศาล | #คุยให้เด็กมันฟัง EP.47 (02/11/67)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HmquaO-PL_M/mqdefault.jpg)
If you like story-based albums, with great songwriting, then you'd have a field day with her previous album "Hopeless Fountain Kingdom"
1:29 : Ashley
3:40 : Clementine
6:39 : Graveyard
8:03 : You should be sad
9:35 : Forever...( is a long time)
11:23: Dominic's Interlude
12:46: I hate everybody
14:42 : 3am
16:45: Without me
18:36: Finally//beautiful stranger
19:33: Alanis' Interlude
20:18: Killing boys
21:44: SUGA's Interlude
22:53: More
25:03: Still learning
26:07: 929
This is so good omg it's crazy how you picked up on everything when you don't even really know about Halsey!!
I need you to do Room 93, Badlands and hfk!!
Thank you so much! :)
I love your reaction! None of the other ones I’ve watched so far have picked up on the fact that “more” was about her miscarriage and future baby
Thank you so much! :)
Wow, this is your first listen and you have more knowledge than some of "halsey stans" out there 👏🏻
this is actually super insightful! on forever is a long time she talked about how it started out as a happy relationship but as the song progressed she let her own insecurities & anxiety get the best of her & tried to express that sonically & lyrically. that’s what the “tell your man he’s got bad news coming” like comes from. also for dominic’s interlude she said it was like a continuation of that & a brotherly voice encouraging her to break up with that same guy. your interpretation on pretty much all of her lyrics though is pretty on the nail with what she was sharing so for barely known her you kinda were a beast lmaoo
Thank you so much! That’s really interesting. :)
Big ups for you for looking up the translations, you are the first non also BTS fan reactor I have seen doing that.👏👏👏. Where were some who even purposefully skipped it🙄
This video should be titled: Psych major analyzes Manic by Halsey. But I'm not mad about it!
Did u say "I'm Not Mad" 😱💕
you need to listen to badlands and hopeless fountain kingdom. youre kinda amazing at this! new sub! The voicemail is John Mayer.
Thank you so much! What a cool detail!
This was honestly one is the best reactions I’ve seen and how fast u caught unto everything. I’ve been following Halsey since debut (Room 93), I would recommend u react to her HFK album. 😁😁
Thank you so much! :)
Yeah this is by far one of the most comprehensive reviews of the album that I’ve watched. You did a great freaking job!!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Thank you so much! :)
I love the way you analyze and really dig into the music. It reminds me why I love music and find it to be such a personal aspect of myself. It’s art and you treat it as so. As someone with Bipolar, I fell in love with this album the second I heard it. Each track really feels like a different aspect of mania or depression, which are the two emotions you experience as bipolar. I felt extremely heard and less alone. Songs like Clementine, I hate Everybody, 3am (especially this song), Killing Boys, and Still Learning are clear examples of the struggles and emotions Bipolar individuals experience.
Thank you so much! :)
YOU ARE ACTUALLY SO SMART AND GOOD AT THIS OMFG 😭
Thank you so much! :)
This is definitely one of the best Manic reaction videos out there. You had a lot of great explanations and interpretations.
Thank you so much! :)
About "More".. she have had 3 miscarriages due to endometriosis.. she even shared about it on an interview that she was touring and had a miscarriage on stage while performing when she didn't knew she was pregnant!
Also in Ashley she referred the line "I'll leave you the dust my love" to her fans..
In "Dominic's interlude" the song is produced beautifully.. but just where her voice fades while saying "just right.. just right" she's kinda talking to herself and contemplating about her past.. and as the music becomes even more theatrical and sort of builds in the background with the piano and the rain it signifies a tendency of overthinking stuff and being skeptical about a person's self image..I loved how you've put efforts and listened carefully and comprehensively.. you've got new subscriber!!! 🤗
Thank you! :)
Loved your analysis' and reaction to the album. Definitely even helped me, a seasoned Halsey fan, realize a little deeper meaning behind some of these lyrics.
Thank you so much! :)
"Am I getting yeehaw from this?" I love it so much. I feel like watching your reaction reminds me of when I was making analysis essays back when I was an undergrad student. Definitely looking forward for more in-depth analysis from you!
Thank you so much! :)
Her first two albums were great too, you should def give them a listen. Badlands is sort of a seminal work that set me on a different course in life than I had been following, and I’m glad it did.
If you hadn't pointed out the Cry Me A River interpolation, I swear I would have never figured out why it felt so familiar. WOW! I loved your reaction and analysis btw!
Thank you so much! :)
I see exactly what you’re saying about 929 undoing what she fought so hard for in still learning, but I think she did it purposefully because being bipolar means you’re going to cycle. So you’re finally getting it together and then cycle back to the same destructive behavior partly Because you feel invincible and partly because you don’t feel like you deserve. It’s part of being manic but you still have to find out how to grow and love yourself even when you know you’re gonna cycle back down that depressive road. It’s really profound that she chose to do it that way. It’s a very tangible way to express to others that the mania is coming down. They’re both equally and simultaneously her truth
Great analysis!
Thank you! :)
This is a beautiful ablum 🌟🌟✨
I just found you and this was an incredible reaction and breakdown! Love it. You got so much that most people didn’t get. Respect for listening to the lyrics and not just blurring past them ❤️
WOW! You are a genius i'm so glad u gave this album justice
Thank you so much! :)
love your work and comments you are the bestt
Thank you so much! :)
I love listening to your thoughts and reactions 😍
Loved your reaction 😁 You need to react to Room 93 next, it's her first ep, and Is There Somewhere is honestly a career highlight 😫
Thank you! :)
Love your insight man, definitely one of the best reviews I've seen. I'd love to watch a Badlands and Room 93 analysis from you!
Thank you so much! :)
periodt king
Loved this reaction! And that was John Mayer on the ending of 3 am btw :) and the “mirror” is about her previous albums where she made the Halsey persona but now on manic she is more open as Ashley not the others way around. It’s Halsey’s third album but Ashley’s first. When someone questioned why she flexing her hit song Without Me she said “Anti-popstar is more about a mentality I think. It’s more about denying the notion that female pop artists should succumb to the social expectations of the genre.”
Thank you so much! :)
react to nightmare by her or hfk album
Love the reaction
Thank you! :)
the guy at the end of 3am is john mayer
Hi: are you a student of psycologie??? I am very impressed of your analysis👍
Thank you so much! I'm not actually. I studied English literature in undergrad. :)
Respect👍
she had 3 miscarriages