I personally bought a Celestial Toystore 11th myself, and good God, it is some of the most fun I've have with a Sonic replica! The clack it gives off, the weight of it all, and the extra emitter-head. Good God! It's such fun! It's my designated winner of this, but that's my opinion.
For all those watching this video 4 years later , please note the following. Nick has greatly improved his work , his emitters, cores and general construction is far superior now. I can attest from speaking to many RR owners that nick has greatly improved his work on strength , gap issues and flick. Nick has also included the original CO sound chip (4 sounds) AS STANDARD in his sonics and offers a repair service for his sonic on any defects on his sonic. To compare to the CT , none have any swirl (CT have a pearlescent shine in their cores which is not what was promised originally) , remember CT is around 250 in its run if 500 (reduced down from 1000). CT also have bubbles in their emitters, a flaw in the Curing of the emitters, RR's do not ! You can play with the CT but in my own experience I've had issues with claw springs breaking , led issues and general bad construction in the rivets. Where as Nicks is utter perfection in dimension , weight and durability! CT has also been having issues in construction too . In addition to the sonic from RR's you get a beautiful display when your not playing with your sonic , something you do not with the CT . Overall my conclusion is to be weary of CT, be assured you get a fantastic sonic with RR's . I am an owner of a CT and its an amazing piece but it has been modified with its cores and claw spring hinge to look nicer and more screen accurate. Please take note of this before purchase , spend your money wisely and enjoy your new sonic !
Yeah I get what your saying but CT SONIC has only had one attempt to make there sonic where as nicks had like 4 releases for him to improve every time if CT released that many versions I’m sure there’s would be out of this world!
@@ryanbarker4129 yeah well with CT being gone , there's no "what if's" he's just gone so Rubbertoe is your only option now or else second hand CT which is meh
If you don't have anything to say about my comment regarding "Milky swirl" don't respond. Just one more comment Votesaxon07 has to get responded about.
It's funny how he works up the CT one(the best one in my opinion) but he chooses he likes both of them! And yes I know he says he likes CT more but still he said it!!
Crazy how someone I used to love to watch suddenly becomes this sinister monster. Thanks for ruining Natalie's chance to make something of this world, thank you for not giving a chance to Dean who hadn't even gotten a chance to live, and thanks for ruining my childhood.
god damn I'd buy both of them just so i could have the best of both, the case for the rubertoe, and showing off display, and the other one for the actual awesome looking sonic.
my ct came in yesterday and i am absolutely in love, drained the first battery in a day because of how i never wanted to put it down, i appriciate this review for helping me chose which one i wanted and while i love rubbertoes work on the 10th doctor sonic i got from them, i know for a fact i would break their 11th due to my desire to play with it. CT is my winner here just for the ability to have fun with it
I wonder what/how CT is gonna do now that nick released a second version. It’s accurate to the first 4 Sonics, WAYYY better swirl than both previous versions, it’s actually screw threaded (thank god), red button at the bottom with magnetic clamp (I absolutely hate the red button, although I think the toy version just left a sour taste with its shitty clamp and button), top sections don’t rotate, and the marks on the claws are gone. From what I’ve seen, I personally think nick’s second version beats both of them by a long shot.
The Wand Company blows both of these out of the water in my opinion. It might not be absolutely 100% screen accurate, but it's extremely close, only a real sonic screwdriver fan would spot the inaccuracies. It has a plethora of different sounds, a bright LED (when shut, it dims drastically when opened) and to top it off, you can actually use it as a universal remote.
Alex Everett-last here's my opinion, the 11th with the clear window is a innacurate and it is the thing that takes the cake and it's collar/battery compartment doesn't go to the body, it's same with the 12th with the innacurate claws being hallo just like the character options ty and the dark green emmiter
I feel like the names of the manufacturers are a bit of a give away. Rubbertoe REPLICAS is far more fragile and more meant to be looked at. The Celestial TOYstore is far sturdier and better for play. It all makes sense.
The screen used one isn't as robust as we would all hope. From something I heard once, Matt became proficient at breaking the sonic on a regular basis. No matter how strong it was made Matt, like David before him, required a small collection of sonics so that in the event of him breaking one we'd never know the difference. Yet I agree, the Celestial Toystore wins with it attention to durability
Well regardless really the rubbertoe is the ultimate one because they are the people that made the One using the show so it's not even a replica it is the Real Deal
@@BriZ3l21 NNnope, because i'm not earning any money because of this virus, i can't simply afford it, in time i may get one or perhaps make one of my own like SanHolo80
Fun fact although the red button was scrapped you will notice now and then on doctor who that the sonic that had the red button will appear the red button wouldn't be used but you will see the hinge that allows the red button cover to open. For example deep breath the scene when Clara and the doctor are strapped to the restaurant chair, when the doctor says don't let it roll away, if you pause it right, when only the bottom half of the sonic is showing out of his pocket you will notice the hinge on the end cap. 😁👍😊
Jonluc Mombrun that’s because they was using the CO toy. Pause it right when it drops and hits the floor. It’s the little plastic toy. The toy actually pops up quite a bit in the show.
Really it doesn't look like the toy and I have looked over that scene quite a lot and didn't realise it was the toy besides why use the toy did they not have prop to use.
Call-Eno most possibly because Matt smith always broke the screwdriver as it wasn't meant for aggressive flicking the cage section was supposed to be pushed up by your thumb.
I actually learned how to write in gallifreyan. Oml it is so complicated. It literally is circles packed in circle groups and each circle can be a letter or a sentence depending on where the circle is in the group. Also each letter has to be orientated to make another letter and... Jesus christ.
all we want is a sonic exactly like the one Matt Smith uses so the prop maker from doctor who made some to sell so there is nothing wrong with the rubertoe
Though the Rubber Toe replica has a beautiful design, it is way too fragile. The CT is by far the winner as it is now only beautiful, but it is also more secure and better for roleplay which many fans want. Whether for display or to play, CT wins for me.
CT, is a clear winner in my opinion, I'm kinda disappointed that an actually prop design from the show would make something that is quiet flimsy and not meant for cosplayers and fans who love to dressup as the 11th and 12th doctor
Ich have CT's Sonic Number 193. Best Monday ever. I also have basically no swirl, wich I don't mind, because we never really saw the swirl in the show.
Both sonics are pricy af. But I really wish Nick made them the same way as he did with 11's actual screwdriver. If the flickability was just like his original 11 sonics, I think it would be more durable and could stand up to the CT a hell of a lot better than what was displayed today. And perhaps if he added sound as standard would be a nice gimmick, but theres only so much a viewer can moan about before he or she has to buy one to further criticise these replicas.
Trust me, everything you just hoped about for Nick's Sonics has happened. sound comes as standard now, and it's flick is on par if not better than CT's. either way both are cool.
@@Spaijit Yeah, as I said. I am moaning about an older sonic, video is old and all. But considering the Rubbertoe one is cheaper and if thats the case in terms of quality... I know what the easter bunny is getting me for christalmightymas
![[Full] 4 ต่อ 4 Celebrity EP.920 | 3 พ.ย. 67 | one31](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KwiW2M_kAg4/mqdefault.jpg)
I think the CT screwdriver is the clear winner
Me 2
Same idea
same
irishhips definitely
but the rubbertoe isn't bad either.
*Watches video*
Oh cool! I want to buy a CT screw driver!
*goes to website*
*sees price tag*
oh...
500 fucking pounds
Emails ct: can I please have one for £30
Getting mine soon !
And here in the US, It adds up to $1000 FRICKIN DOLLARS! You have to be RICH to afford it!
@@e_Dave NANI,
HOWWWWWWWWW
*looks at top pocket*
"this is where I would put my ct 11th doctor's sonic screwdriver...IF I HAD ONE!"
relatable
Same here
get the tennant versuib
to spensive m8
get the remote my guy it’s for poor people like us
The CT sonic is just as good of a display piece as the Rubbertoe, and it can be played with. So I think CT is the clear winner
I own a CT and can say , it's not. The standard cores are just ... we don't talk about that . There never is any swirl on it to be honest.
I personally bought a Celestial Toystore 11th myself, and good God, it is some of the most fun I've have with a Sonic replica! The clack it gives off, the weight of it all, and the extra emitter-head. Good God! It's such fun! It's my designated winner of this, but that's my opinion.
+BronyinDisguise its too expivence for me how did you get more than a normal 1000 its soo hard
+BronyinDisguise Where might I buy one?
I bought one a while ago. I don't remember where or when.
+CrystalGamer Minecraft videos and more! Just get the Wand Company's 12th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Universal Remote, it's around 120 US Dollars.
wow i dont have that many
Loved watching this video in the past. Crazy with what has happened
What about now, he murdered his girlfriend of 4 months who was pregnant, dude made my childhood and does that shit
agreed he is a psychopath unfortunately
Me: *3 years ago* £750 I can't afford that!
Me: *now* £500 I still can't afford that!
It's like "mate, anything above $100 is too much of a struggle"
@@peterwilson3629 even £50
If it ever drops to £250 I'm buying
For all those watching this video 4 years later , please note the following.
Nick has greatly improved his work , his emitters, cores and general construction is far superior now. I can attest from speaking to many RR owners that nick has greatly improved his work on strength , gap issues and flick. Nick has also included the original CO sound chip (4 sounds) AS STANDARD in his sonics and offers a repair service for his sonic on any defects on his sonic. To compare to the CT , none have any swirl (CT have a pearlescent shine in their cores which is not what was promised originally) , remember CT is around 250 in its run if 500 (reduced down from 1000). CT also have bubbles in their emitters, a flaw in the Curing of the emitters, RR's do not !
You can play with the CT but in my own experience I've had issues with claw springs breaking , led issues and general bad construction in the rivets. Where as Nicks is utter perfection in dimension , weight and durability! CT has also been having issues in construction too . In addition to the sonic from RR's you get a beautiful display when your not playing with your sonic , something you do not with the CT .
Overall my conclusion is to be weary of CT, be assured you get a fantastic sonic with RR's . I am an owner of a CT and its an amazing piece but it has been modified with its cores and claw spring hinge to look nicer and more screen accurate.
Please take note of this before purchase , spend your money wisely and enjoy your new sonic !
is RR sonic cost 750?
@@h3dzer yes it does. But it's been internally structured much better !
@@olancorcoran true, i think ill go with Rubbertoe, it just beautiful
Yeah I get what your saying but CT SONIC has only had one attempt to make there sonic where as nicks had like 4 releases for him to improve every time if CT released that many versions I’m sure there’s would be out of this world!
@@ryanbarker4129 yeah well with CT being gone , there's no "what if's" he's just gone so Rubbertoe is your only option now or else second hand CT which is meh
CT won in MY opinion the spare batteries and extra emitter really got me into wanting one.
And the awesome flicking feature
+Marcus Tsang yeah
Well start saving up its £750 which is probably $1000
The most popular word in all of his sonic screwdriver videos. "Milky swirl".
That's two words.
Phrase*
If you don't have anything to say about my comment regarding "Milky swirl" don't respond. Just one more comment Votesaxon07 has to get responded about.
+Jake Arama Even then I still think the more common phrase is legal guff.
Yeah xD
I personally feel that I like the rubbertoe sonic the most because it is very detailed with swirl FX. My personal feeling.
CT bonus item: Cool T-shirt
RB bonus item: sock.
It's funny how he works up the CT one(the best one in my opinion) but he chooses he likes both of them! And yes I know he says he likes CT more but still he said it!!
If you don't want to spend an arm and a leg, the wand company has a really nice version.
Crazy how someone I used to love to watch suddenly becomes this sinister monster. Thanks for ruining Natalie's chance to make something of this world, thank you for not giving a chance to Dean who hadn't even gotten a chance to live, and thanks for ruining my childhood.
Why are you commenting this on a 7 year old video?
@foxfour3683 this used to be a video I'd watch in my younger years. Finding out the man behind the white backdrop is a murderer has led me back here
@@ziggywatene5633 yeah.. it is quite sad as i also used to watch him when i was younger. i hope he's innocent but it dosent look good :(
@@foxfour3683 He ain't innocent bud
god damn I'd buy both of them just so i could have the best of both, the case for the rubertoe, and showing off display, and the other one for the actual awesome looking sonic.
I was thinking the same if I had the money.... wishful thinking..ha
Welp, time to customize the Rubbertoe and add your own sound chip.
you could buy it with sounds
+Novogue but thats almost $200 or £150 added
Movoux for hundreds more pounds ! No
my ct came in yesterday and i am absolutely in love, drained the first battery in a day because of how i never wanted to put it down, i appriciate this review for helping me chose which one i wanted and while i love rubbertoes work on the 10th doctor sonic i got from them, i know for a fact i would break their 11th due to my desire to play with it. CT is my winner here just for the ability to have fun with it
I'm saving up every single penny for this thing
did you get it
You'd think that the prop maker would make a better replica than a fan. CT wins this one
weirdly enough I'm pretty sure he made the original prop for the show as well
I wonder what/how CT is gonna do now that nick released a second version. It’s accurate to the first 4 Sonics, WAYYY better swirl than both previous versions, it’s actually screw threaded (thank god), red button at the bottom with magnetic clamp (I absolutely hate the red button, although I think the toy version just left a sour taste with its shitty clamp and button), top sections don’t rotate, and the marks on the claws are gone. From what I’ve seen, I personally think nick’s second version beats both of them by a long shot.
CT is finished with doctor who , He's finishing off his final wave of sonics atm . He's now in the 200's and will be finished once 500 are sold
Btw did you all know that The toy ( 12th Doctor touch control sonic screwdriver ) can't take hard flicks? :D
i should know given I flicked it too hard and now the sound doesn't work
The Wand Company blows both of these out of the water in my opinion. It might not be absolutely 100% screen accurate, but it's extremely close, only a real sonic screwdriver fan would spot the inaccuracies. It has a plethora of different sounds, a bright LED (when shut, it dims drastically when opened) and to top it off, you can actually use it as a universal remote.
Alex Everett-last I agree.
Alex Everett-last here's my opinion, the 11th with the clear window is a innacurate and it is the thing that takes the cake and it's collar/battery compartment doesn't go to the body, it's same with the 12th with the innacurate claws being hallo just like the character options ty and the dark green emmiter
So basically you are using a real sonic screwdriver exept it cant open locks or do turkey
If you dont get the do Turkey bit watch time of the doctor
Whovian Productions I get the turkey bit, they cooked it in the tardis
Ct is a genius. I miss my friendship with this guy.
I just recently got my CT and I love it so much!
How long did yours take to arrive
@@RG-dc5il well it took roughly a few weeks give or take :)
This is an awesome Review and Comparison. Thank you for the great video
11:11 I thought my phone was broken lol
Same
I feel like the names of the manufacturers are a bit of a give away. Rubbertoe REPLICAS is far more fragile and more meant to be looked at. The Celestial TOYstore is far sturdier and better for play. It all makes sense.
You should review the new Rubbertoe 2nd Edition 11th Doctor screwdriver. It's SOOO much better and comes with sound by default I think.
Just get a character options single button sonic, pretend you are flicking it. Boom! A winner!
Blurringma haha, that's what I do.
forever low funded...
TheDoctorWhoGuy 04 lol ikr
Binny I got so used to flicking and pressing a button :P
That’s what I do too
Joe Regent can we custom paint them?
CT has a better sonic, but RubberToe has a better casing IMO
I love the rubbertoe one!
they both look evenly best
You are telling me you have to pay more for sonic in a sonic screwdriver
The screen used one isn't as robust as we would all hope. From something I heard once, Matt became proficient at breaking the sonic on a regular basis. No matter how strong it was made Matt, like David before him, required a small collection of sonics so that in the event of him breaking one we'd never know the difference. Yet I agree, the Celestial Toystore wins with it attention to durability
I've read somewhere that peter capaldi rarely flicked his open due to the likelyness of it breaking and him not wanting to put up with that.
Me: CT Sonic is the best, going for it!!
Prize: £500
Also me: Well, back to Character Options...
Which is nerdier? Buying one of these or watching a youtube video about these or buying both of these?
I want that sonic screwdrivers now. I love it ever.
Well regardless really the rubbertoe is the ultimate one because they are the people that made the One using the show so it's not even a replica it is the Real Deal
I'm pretty sure it sounded better in his head then in life.
CT vs Rubbertoe vs The Wand Company
Make it happen
I just ordered the CT 11th/12th Screwdriver, wondering how long it takes to ship because I'm hyped!
When I get enough money, I'm getting the Celestial toystore model
You got it ?
@@BriZ3l21 NNnope, because i'm not earning any money because of this virus, i can't simply afford it, in time i may get one or perhaps make one of my own like SanHolo80
I keep looking over the internet but I can find these anywhere
Fun fact although the red button was scrapped you will notice now and then on doctor who that the sonic that had the red button will appear the red button wouldn't be used but you will see the hinge that allows the red button cover to open. For example deep breath the scene when Clara and the doctor are strapped to the restaurant chair, when the doctor says don't let it roll away, if you pause it right, when only the bottom half of the sonic is showing out of his pocket you will notice the hinge on the end cap. 😁👍😊
Jonluc Mombrun that’s because they was using the CO toy. Pause it right when it drops and hits the floor. It’s the little plastic toy. The toy actually pops up quite a bit in the show.
Really it doesn't look like the toy and I have looked over that scene quite a lot and didn't realise it was the toy besides why use the toy did they not have prop to use.
Jonluc Mombrun not sure. I’ve always spotted it because there’s really huge screws on the silver struts on the toy and it’s used sometimes.
Call-Eno most possibly because Matt smith always broke the screwdriver as it wasn't meant for aggressive flicking the cage section was supposed to be pushed up by your thumb.
also here's another idea. The Wand Company vs CT and the sonic will be 10's. That would be cool
I'm definitely getting a CT sonic! Maybe next year when I've saved up a bit more
And I’m over here with my character options toy... 🤦🏻♂️
What i like about earlier rubbertoes is that they are as broken and flimsy as the original props
Just from the name of "Rubbertoe" vs. "Celestial Toys", I can already tell who won.
great work man i really wish i had one
the 11th doctor s sonic screwdriver toy had a red botton
So does this
With a flimsy cap.
I felt like Stephen was the best with words when it comes to negativaty.But im not saying he has negativity its just that he choose his word carefully
For $975 it’s not getting into my collection until I’m rich.
Ct lowered the price to £500
I actually learned how to write in gallifreyan. Oml it is so complicated. It literally is circles packed in circle groups and each circle can be a letter or a sentence depending on where the circle is in the group. Also each letter has to be orientated to make another letter and... Jesus christ.
Latrell Aquino no you didn't, sry but no
You cant learn gallifrayen its both a made up language and impossible to read and write kind of like latin minus the made up part
Someone made a gallifreyan alphabet actually. It's not official or anything but I think that's they mean
Whovian Productions bethesda made an entire language for dragons for skyrim so its possible
@@sonicfire65 film theory time, can Gallifreyan exist?
I prefer rubbertoe because he made the prop for the show.
Bricks and Crafts Yes. But it's shite. Like, Really Shite.
Bricks and Crafts So what?
D.I.Y Point i get your point (no pun intended) but personally i would love to own the celestial toystore although if it had money i would get both .
OMFG the celestial toy store for it cost 750!!! I don't have that kind of money!! So lucky!! XD I need it XD
I think the CT sonic is a winner it has more features and is just better
Could we get separate reviews of these ?
Question, will you ever get one of the 2nd edition Rubbertoes?
I bought the CT and LOVED IT
How long did it take to ship, just ordered mine :D
God...those sonics are sooo...😍😍
all we want is a sonic exactly like the one Matt Smith uses so the prop maker from doctor who made some to sell so there is nothing wrong with the rubertoe
everyone knows how fragile the CT and how it has not aged well. Im constantly sending mine in for repaies
You can probably find a clear emitter for modding.
Though the Rubber Toe replica has a beautiful design, it is way too fragile. The CT is by far the winner as it is now only beautiful, but it is also more secure and better for roleplay which many fans want. Whether for display or to play, CT wins for me.
I was actually wondering weather CT would be willing to give the option of a bright green led as seen on his early prototypes
He doesn't , but you can get it modified
+Votesaxon07 Just to let u know that rubbertoe is releasing the 12th doctors new sonic, check rubbertoe's official channel to see it
He knows, we all know lol
Amazing vídeo
If i could i would get both, and keep the rubbertoe for display and the ct for flicking around.... To bad i have no money lmao
People are commenting “Oh, I only like the rubber toe cos it’s the actual sonic in da showww
the hashtag is real
So after watching this video, I went onto the CT website to purchase the screwdriver. They must know they are the best because it cost 750 pounds!
Lowered it to 500 tho
What happened to your C T prototype
It’s clear the Morrison’s sonic is the winner
for me its the CT
Plot Twist. CT is secretly Nick Robato
CT, is a clear winner in my opinion, I'm kinda disappointed that an actually prop design from the show would make something that is quiet flimsy and not meant for cosplayers and fans who love to dressup as the 11th and 12th doctor
C E L E S T I A L!!!
Me: watching this with my CO Sonic Screwdriver
Ich have CT's Sonic Number 193. Best Monday ever. I also have basically no swirl, wich I don't mind, because we never really saw the swirl in the show.
I still think the best prop for its price is the universal remote all though I regretfully sold my tenth but still got my 11/12
I'd buy one. Y'know, if I had a thousand damn dollars to blow.
Both sonics are pricy af. But I really wish Nick made them the same way as he did with 11's actual screwdriver. If the flickability was just like his original 11 sonics, I think it would be more durable and could stand up to the CT a hell of a lot better than what was displayed today. And perhaps if he added sound as standard would be a nice gimmick, but theres only so much a viewer can moan about before he or she has to buy one to further criticise these replicas.
Trust me, everything you just hoped about for Nick's Sonics has happened. sound comes as standard now, and it's flick is on par if not better than CT's. either way both are cool.
@@Spaijit Yeah, as I said. I am moaning about an older sonic, video is old and all. But considering the Rubbertoe one is cheaper and if thats the case in terms of quality... I know what the easter bunny is getting me for christalmightymas
I counted up all his complements to the sonics and here are the points: Rubbertoe:7 CT:19 guess which one is better 😂
I’m thinking maybe I should upgrade the sonic I have right now
Surprised the ct is better and is cheaper
Just wish it had all the sound effects instead of one.
If I had to buy a sonic screwdriver I would choose CT all the way
If you have the CT 11th sonic and The Wand Co. 10th doctor sonic,boy...!!!You are the ultimate cosplayer
I feel the claws going farther on the CT doesn’t look as good but ct is better
The one in the briefcase is my faverat
Minepro2587 it's the ct
Minepro2587CT
the ct is the best sonic screwdriver for fans
Oooh red sonic
was the red button ever shown on the show?
I'm getting a CT screwdriver of my mom
a year later and this comment keeps me up at night. what does it mean?
@@addymassa i understand now.
He is getting a screwdriver that looks like his mum.
Im so clever
No
I wish that I could have this...
The CT screwdriver is the best
CT is secretly the brother of Nick Robatto😂
dose anyone else wish that he did one on the tv remote tenth doctor and the ct prop
Oo! What other weapons are you obsessed with?