Earlier, I uploaded this exact video. However, there were so many issues I with it. I ended up taking it down. Thanks to those who pointed it out. I plan on doing mech next. However, I may end up uploading something else outside this series just so there's more diversity among my channel. Hope you all enjoy this one, though!
These videos make me realize just how important it is for each song that the monsters are released in a good order. I would’ve absolutely hated workshop if the monsters released in this order I think the main thing about it is that it has to be a listenable song when it releases. Workshop already felt like a full song when it released with the original 5, but this doesn’t feel like it could be a full song until the latter half of the video. Doesn’t necessarily mean that you can’t start off with an empty sounded verse, like Sporerow on mythical island when that first released. Pretty helpful stuff to know for making fanmade islands that also release in waves
Yeah, I agree. Workshop just _worked_ from the start. It really _felt_ complete, even though obviously we knew more monsters would come. I think another good point is on sometimes leaving out verses if they’re too empty. While Meebkin and Gaddzooks play in the Whail verse as is, even to the point where Workshop today will play that verse if you only have the wave 1 monsters, it’d just be too empty without Flasque and Whail. So they left it out until wave 2 showed up, and it was a great decision.
That’s what I am saying! The main five set up a distinct vibe to the ethereal workshop where if you had to remove any monster from the island these five would have to be the last to be removed, even if some monsters are better because it just wouldn’t be ethereal workshop without Meebkin or Yooreek Like there is a difference between being from the start and being the foundation of the song and being added later and just changing it.
Yep, and everyone was always annoyed when the later monsters came out, like piplash, Nitebear, and X’rt, where they “just didn’t add as much” as the original five. Like, yeah, of course they don’t.
@@tenebroise6633 Yeah. While such monsters naturally land low on my list, that doesn’t mean they’re bad or I don’t appreciate what they bring. There’s just not meant to be the foundation of the song and thus contribute less than others, which is okay. They still have their place.
I realized that in the first wave every monsters plays atleast in one Auglur verse for example: Teeter-tauter plays in the last second of the first auglur verse. Piplash plays in the first auglur verse. Nitebear plays in the last auglur verse and gadzooks plays as the drummer in the first auglur verse and auglur plays in its own verse
I always thought that simply if Oogiddy and Whaill swapped releases sound wise that would be a much better way to end off the island, because Whaill only plays twice but it’s such a massive change
I feel like even with the same monsters at the end, ethereal workshop would just have such a different vibe because of the lack of three of the main 5 monsters to begin with. Like Yooreek and Meebkin were key components of setting up a vibe for workshop that it feels entirely different without them from the start.
since teeter tauter is yooreek in this universe, all the other monsters in wave 1 would of been teased by creators, which would be interesting to think about
Wave 1 and 2 are better than what we actually got lol Wave 3 is meh Wave 4 is the most impactful Meebkin is not a reveal worthy of last triple imo. Whail adds a lot and gets both verses on release so more impact there... Saving Pentumbra for last is immaculate.
@@VvIiVvZzIiOo32Flasque, and for the record no they didn’t all appear in the same wave they originally did. Gadzooks and Auglur were both in wave 1 Flasque was a wave 2 monster
Earlier, I uploaded this exact video. However, there were so many issues I with it. I ended up taking it down. Thanks to those who pointed it out. I plan on doing mech next. However, I may end up uploading something else outside this series just so there's more diversity among my channel. Hope you all enjoy this one, though!
Hi
Hello
Hi
Cool!
Hi
Nitebear wouldve been a LOT less hated if this was the way it released
Nitebear is one of if not THE MOST OVERHATED monster. Idk why people hate on him he is a good monster
Nitebear is hated?
Why are people hating Freddy Fazbear
Bad design + horrible sound
@@Kguy-r6ethat’s not true for nitebear but true for piplash’s sound not design
The fact that Oogiddy came with X'rt honestly makes sense.
Duo of disgusting perfection
Avatar of Wrath lol
"Green farts"
Delicious
I said the same exact thing 2 days before you did.
so no one is gonna even mention the fact that his workshop is absolutely jam packed with decorations?
Yup I saw this
Idk
the x'rt hiding in the top right like we wouldnt notice lmao
There is 2 of them
I can see pentumbra
ITS MEEEEEEE
These videos make me realize just how important it is for each song that the monsters are released in a good order. I would’ve absolutely hated workshop if the monsters released in this order
I think the main thing about it is that it has to be a listenable song when it releases. Workshop already felt like a full song when it released with the original 5, but this doesn’t feel like it could be a full song until the latter half of the video. Doesn’t necessarily mean that you can’t start off with an empty sounded verse, like Sporerow on mythical island when that first released. Pretty helpful stuff to know for making fanmade islands that also release in waves
Yeah, I agree. Workshop just _worked_ from the start. It really _felt_ complete, even though obviously we knew more monsters would come.
I think another good point is on sometimes leaving out verses if they’re too empty. While Meebkin and Gaddzooks play in the Whail verse as is, even to the point where Workshop today will play that verse if you only have the wave 1 monsters, it’d just be too empty without Flasque and Whail. So they left it out until wave 2 showed up, and it was a great decision.
That’s what I am saying!
The main five set up a distinct vibe to the ethereal workshop where if you had to remove any monster from the island these five would have to be the last to be removed, even if some monsters are better because it just wouldn’t be ethereal workshop without Meebkin or Yooreek
Like there is a difference between being from the start and being the foundation of the song and being added later and just changing it.
Yep, and everyone was always annoyed when the later monsters came out, like piplash, Nitebear, and X’rt, where they “just didn’t add as much” as the original five. Like, yeah, of course they don’t.
@@tenebroise6633 Yeah. While such monsters naturally land low on my list, that doesn’t mean they’re bad or I don’t appreciate what they bring. There’s just not meant to be the foundation of the song and thus contribute less than others, which is okay. They still have their place.
Wave 3 being Oogiddy and X'rt makes alot of sense if you really think about it.
The poison element is the main element for them
3:50 OOGIDDY WHY DID YOU CRUSH THE FOUNTAIN WE PAID A LOT OF MONEY FOR THAT
he vomit on it too ):
@@rodrigosaenz2778 no he pissed on it
@@thegoof2763EW IS PEE GREEN
@@SamuelMarin-b3v yes
@@SamuelMarin-b3v yes you uncultured imbecile
I realized that in the first wave every monsters plays atleast in one Auglur verse for example: Teeter-tauter plays in the last second of the first auglur verse. Piplash plays in the first auglur verse. Nitebear plays in the last auglur verse and gadzooks plays as the drummer in the first auglur verse and auglur plays in its own verse
Wave 2 hey X'rt youre not hiding from me in the top right corner
Wave 1 is basically gadzooks and teeter-tauter core
Ethereal workshop but everyone is teeter-tauter
Hop hap hop WAAAEEEEEEEE hop hip hoops hap
Hæ hœ hœp hæ hœ hœp
Hohphihoohphihphphohihohphohoh
_WAAAEEEEEEEEEE_
Heaven.
Now crystal needs to be unstable
So, basically, if air island was first and cold island was last
Yep. Weird to think about.
I mean it would work, you'd have the happy upbeat island first and the depressing sad island last
Remember: early waves didn’t have as many spoiler waves. (The cool ones) so shadow wave 1 would be a little shorter but not noticeably so
I see u black axolotal 😈😈 5:57
Ur not the only one 😉
Yep, not the only one 💀
What the im the unstable!?
@@Vee_44 wtf is sus about the comment?
@@Vee_44 is it perhaps about the v#####?
I always thought that simply if Oogiddy and Whaill swapped releases sound wise that would be a much better way to end off the island, because Whaill only plays twice but it’s such a massive change
I like that my favorite element is the most stable
Plasma
THWOK59 is that real it’s you!
Mech*
i like that my favourite element is the least stable 😊
Yo whats good Thwok59
Here is my idea for element swap crystal mech poison plasma shadow
I feel like even with the same monsters at the end, ethereal workshop would just have such a different vibe because of the lack of three of the main 5 monsters to begin with.
Like Yooreek and Meebkin were key components of setting up a vibe for workshop that it feels entirely different without them from the start.
Does anybody else get what I mean or am I just stupid 😭
No I get what you mean entirely. It just would feel wrong without them.
This would make Teeter Tauter a more loved character by a lot
Wave 5 is how ethereal workshop should sound.
Having that green thing in Yooreek without Bemeebeth playing feels so wrong
Can’t wait till if poison was the least stable!!
First thing different 0:09 plasma have moved!
I love how Flasque is introduced in the same wave as ingame lol
I wonder how the MSM community would react if this was the way it was released instead
In every timeline wave 2 adds a new verse
Very cool idea this would make a lot of hate change to monsters like X'rt and Blarret
Gotta love how the monster that represents the meebs would be last
That's what I was saying to myself, lol
Last triple?
Uhhh, yeah.
@@Swagpion lollllll
yoo congrats on 2k!
At the 4th one you can literally see pentumbra
SLEEPING HAHAHAHAHA
@@Casparpar well that's why you can't hear him
since teeter tauter is yooreek in this universe, all the other monsters in wave 1 would of been teased by creators, which would be interesting to think about
Tater tot*
@@shadowgaming-en4lkTATER TOT?
I feel like Teeter-Tauter (or however you spell it) would be so much more popular if they were released earlier
1:48 is me :)
yooreek... uh?
@@tibby4503wat
No shadow Sherlock it's you
In wave 4 of your idea i saw pentumbra on the corner 😂
where does the droplet noise come from at the start of the song?
It's the sound you get when you select a meeb in the attunement structure
This might have been the best timeline
PENATRUBA WHAT U DOING IN THE CORNER OVER THERE XD
They saved the best for last 🔥🔥
2:38 I can hear pentumbra
3:51 wow x'rt is in wave 3 whit ogiddy
Says Xr't
I see a pentumbru in da corner in the second to last part
5:56 pentumbra is like: I wanna join :(
If the universe orbits Pentumbra for still being in wave 4 even if reversed, then the Multiverse orbits Flasque for being in wave 2 still...
the title shouldve been
“What if: Shadow was the most unstable element”
Your title doesnt have "ethereal workshop". It must include. Plus, least stable and most unstable is the same thing
Tater-Tot somehow is always on the first wave...
i love pentumpbra 🤩
Equivalents:
Yooreek: Teeter-Tauter
Meebkin: Auglur
Blarret: Piplash
Gaddzooks: Gaddzooks
Auglur: Nitebear
Flasque: Yooreek
Nitebear: Flasque
Whaill: Rhysmuth
Piplash: X'rt
Vhenshun: Oogiddy
X'rt: Blarret
Pentumbra: Vhenshun
Teeter-Tauter: Meebkin
Rhysmuth: Whaill
Oogiddy: Pentumbra
never notice piplash would rhyme to the beat
now make it so the wave monsters are reversed (i.e, Oggidy would be wave one, Teeter-Tauter and Rhysmuth would be wave two, and so forth)
Do this with Mech, crystal and poison
Make spirits are the least unstable.
You mean plasma?
THAT IS LITERALLY JUST INVERTED STABILITY
So my element is now unstable now ig
Now teeter-tauter on wave 1?!
If ethereal workshop was good
Wdym it is the same song
Finally waill yes
You should do the next video where the element stability is based on the natruals breeding time
Poison > Crystal > Shadow > Plasma > Mech
Not my favorite monster coming last😭😭😭😭😭
you forgot to remove the whaill verse in wave 1
I don't determine if the verse is in there or not. If it plays in the wave, it stays in the wave. I'm not removing it
Wave 1 and 2 are better than what we actually got lol
Wave 3 is meh
Wave 4 is the most impactful
Meebkin is not a reveal worthy of last triple imo. Whail adds a lot and gets both verses on release so more impact there...
Saving Pentumbra for last is immaculate.
Wow i like this
Piplash would be a fan fav if it was realeases early although auglur would prob be less overrated
❤❤❤
Look in the top right corner 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
What is that noise 0:13
I placed that sound each time text pops up. It's the sound you get when you select a meeb in attunement structure
@@BoxMSM oh
@@BoxMSMbut I don’t like it
Plasma ir shadow should have been the least stable elements
I just noticed I'm less than an hour late
Have you noticed that there is 2 anglers in wave 4 to 5
Auglur
@@thegoof2763 oh thanks
@@Casparpar no problem!
I love blarret, she is a good girl
Don't wanna be annoying, but every single msm monster from Mammot to BeMeeBeth and every monster else actually don't have genders, they go by it
what is this song also
Ethereal Workshop
Auglur would replace meebkin then
Is Wong
Who's Wong? Sounds Chinese
Here and the likes are 666 and the same time i watched
Under a year woohoo
199th like (I’m not a bot)
Anyways cool idea!
Thank you!
@@BoxMSM your welcome :) I probably could never come up with this idea myself!
Wdym “unstable”?
What are you asking?
@@BoxMSM im asking what is your factual intensions for saying the word as we know as “unstable” in this cinamatic clip of your’s
hi
Hello
Please remove the castle now!
Kinda too late for that. 3 videos deep with only 1 left
666th like!
First
Everyone make him have the top comment for no reason🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
Maybe last
Finally meebkin at 8:00
It’s cool that gadzooks aglur and Falsky boi ⚗️ are all in the same wave that they were originally from
Who is falsky boy
@@VvIiVvZzIiOo32Flasque, and for the record no they didn’t all appear in the same wave they originally did. Gadzooks and Auglur were both in wave 1 Flasque was a wave 2 monster
why can't you spell 😭😭😭🙏🙏