As someone from northeast India, I can feel the pain of the Chinese Indians who had to face all the adversities and racism after the Indo China war. And I want them to know that a lot of Indians care about them and consider them as our own cause they are Indians too! Let peace and love prevail everywhere ❤
@@kamakshikaul its still the same Every norteast tribes who work study or visit mainland gets name calling and racism Bitter truth hurts Bhakts like u are blind to this issues And also SAVE MANIPUR
We in Malaysia are very lucky to be able to maintain Chinese education because the tolerance between the races here is very good.. we hope the harmony of the diversity of races in Malaysia will last forever..
That boy in the end gave me tears. His sentiments of being indian as well as chinese makes me feel that adults lose their sense of belongingness no matter what race.
Damn this is a touching story. As an Indian i feel guilty for the people how the government treated them. We are NE Indian and feel the same as Chinese here in the other states as well. Thank you for providing the fact.
Life is always difficult, and the life of an ordinary person always appears weak under the influence of world situations and politics. You don't need to feel guilty about this because you are a kind person. The world would be a better place if we were kind to others. thank you for your sympathy
@@Boro스네하 infact indians, assamese (except northeastern people) don't look Asian. Rather they look like someone who gets thoroughly checked at every international airport
That's common sense... For reference, why don't Chinese people love Japanese culture and them(Japanese) investing into China...? Hope u got my point...
I’m Singaporean and I never knew there’s a Chinese community in India! I find it very fascinating seeing ethnically Chinese individuals speaking English with a Tamil accent. It’s really sad that the heritage is disappearing by the day, but I can also understand why people are leaving for a better future. Thank you for the insights!
Well when I was in JB just returned from Singapore for work and I’ve met this one indian lady from Indonesia and yeah she’s a legit Indonesian citizen. I had no idea about their diaspora that spread elsewhere other than Malaysia and Singapore and perhaps Brunei.
@@nomadblueprintThere's a small Indian community in Indonesia. They are usually in the textile business. In Medan, there's a place called "Kampung Madras", a vibrant Indian Indonesian community.
@@nomadblueprint Yup, There are Indian Indonesia in Indonesia. Most of them spread in Sumatra Province, concentrate in Kampung Madras or Kampung Keling, Medan - North Sumatra. Also in Pasar Baru, Jakarta and small community in Jogyakarta, Central Java Province. Most of their livelihood are selling textille, Indian spices or sport supplier. And in Sumatra, some of them sell food, called "mie rebus / Boiled Noodle" or mie keling, an authentic noodle with thick sauce. No offence, in the past we usually called them "Keling" refer to their dark skin tone color.
malaysian chinese are despicabIe and look down on Iocals......chinese in thailand and indonesia are 100x better and have assimilated into the IocaI cuIture
My Teacher was a Chinese Indian from Kolkata he passed away few years ago. I can say he was also from Kolkata. And I’m really grateful I got to witness this. My teacher was best he was my mentor my. He changed my life. I really wish all the Chinese Indians can still preserve their culture. ❤❤❤ and even I am from Singapore. I was studying in India for few years. I met him in india dehradun really miss him.
are you from Tamil Indian community in singapore or from other parts Hinduism is followed by 10%of singaporeans and 12-14% of Singaporeans are of Indian origins and diaspora and 10-11% Mostly Tamilian only
Tai Ahoms are not chinese.Chinese is a nationality.There was no country called china in those days.whereas tai tribes originated from thailand.And tais are sino tibetan.
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
As an Indian: Thank you for contributing to the story of India. I understand that everyone strives for a better life, whether in their home country or abroad. I wish you the best, and I also wish for you to know that if you still want to call India one of your home countries then you are more than welcome to do so. Personally, I will always consider you as much Indian as myself. Outside of politics (which I don’t want to talk about), Indians and Chinese get along wherever they live. I have cousins who are married to Chinese women living in America, Canada and Australia. I also know that Indians have been living peacefully in Hong Kong for many generations and are very happy with their Chinese (Cantonese) neighbours. Personally, I studied in Australia and 2 of my closest friends were from China. They were among the best people I have met abroad: always wanting to pay for our dinners and drinks, and being the best hosts whenever I went for dinner with them, and also some of the most genuine and fun guys to get drunk with. Again, without getting into politics, I hope the people of India and China can continue to get along. We share many things in common despite our differences.
No, China and India never get along well you don't need to wish. The same goes for Vietnam and Philippine for the same reason that is China just wants everything belongs to them! Very greedy country. That attitude certailny causes suspicion amonsgt non-chinese communities in those countries. Chinese still worships their former homeland resisting assimilation, setting up their Chinese schools etc after 300 years just pack up and go back to China, no need to worry about everything thatcis not chinese. Your homeland should wellcome you as the sons and daughters have lost, shouldn't they as China is now very rich , 2nd after US, and powerful!
Better life usually means more money, where ever they get significantly more money people want to go there, USA and some western countries knew this, so they attract workers, thats all there to it.
@@gshrdy5415 Opportunity not decline here in kolkata but it gets better. This Indian Chinese can't afford that. This Indian Chinese run leathers business in the center of kolkata which is very harm full to environment. Creat lot's of emissions problem. Not good for health life. So government creat a whole new leather complex in out skirt of kolkata . Which is called bantala leather complex. But problem is this Indian Chinese can't afford the factories their may be . So you can't blame government. They tried their best to protect enviroment. And also market of leathers became More big. Infact biggest leather factories located here in bantala leather complex.
I’m Indian and my wife is Chinese American! We have a lot of shared values like family values and the way we think about money and parents and education.
As an Indian I am curious to know how does their mandarin sounds to Chinese people? Does that have an Indian accent too? 作为一个印度人，我很好奇他们的普通话对中国人来说听起来怎么样？这也有印度口音吗？
My suspicion is most that left China are the educated and community minded that's why they are willing to build school and continue to donate to all community events. My grandparents left China but I think they always wanted to go back when it "reopens" but it took so many decades and the kids ended up settled already. My granddad was uni educated in HK and his dad was a Judge with generations of wealth and education. My mum's side are also educated and in business. They all are one of the founders in Chinese schools and Chinese social projects in Malaysia. The community funding continues in my dad's generation and I am now also donating money to local causes. My family was believed in helping others, building a good community and we have a good family name / reputation in our town. We were not the super rich but willingly contributed a big portion of our income. But recently I met some Chinese who are not educated or even thinking education is important, just like to party and live day by day then borrow money from anyone they can.... that is a different kind of Chinese that I've never met in my life. 🤦♂️ I have always been a proud Chinese... didn't know stupid Chinese existed.
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
Friend sent me this video. Interesting to see this. I’m a Canadian born Hakka Chinese. My parents were born in kolkata. Like the interviewees described my grand father owned a restaurant and leather tannery. He was taken to a concentration camp during the sino Indian boarder war where he died. That’s when my dad’s side left. Definitely sad to see some of these ppl feeling trapped.
Oh my goodness! That's crazy. My parents migrated to Australia and my grandparents where in Malaysia before. I didn't know Indians took Chinese there for what? For being Chinese? These barbarians always say China have no human rights? That's why to me, they all say "most Chinese left" but didn't want to say much. Must be something very terrible that they can't even say? Everyone knows Malaysian government don't treat Chinese well as we are discriminate. But people are not afraid to say that.... Anyway to be honest, India is a ST country, I'm glad your family left. I've know many Indians, most I know are what my grandparents use to call them "snakes", very deceiving and always slithering around. Be careful they are always plotting. For example, when Indians moved their business a few doors away, my parents joked that their business will somehow catch fire and claim insurance. I always thought it was a joke. But, after 3 yrs, it happened! And they claimed huge insurance. The fire spread to our business and half burned our stock and even lots of family photos, clothing etc, all gone. Also many other incidences... makes me think they really are what my grandparents says they are.
Oh no. sorry to hear that! My mom was born in Calcutta too! Grandparents used to work there. May be my mom knows your parents :) ! My grandma used to teach at local Chinese School. See my post on the top sharing their story. My grandpa's best friend was the principal of the Chinese school, he was taken by the police in the middle of the night and sent to China/India boarder remote area and left to die, was later saved.. He died few years later at Chinese labor camp during Cultural revolution. crazy time.
@@nancyn1106 , wow indeed crazy time. You're Chinese, Indians want you to died, you're Chinese also taken by new government 😓. Both sides of My grandparents were in Malaysia I think since around 1930s, 40s, no issues. No one taking them to any camps. Both side family I believe wealthy in China. My dad's side, my great grandad was a Judge and family has lots of land. Mum's side her grandma has those lotus feet never said they're rich but judging by their mind set and skills having built up lots of businesses and estates in Malaysian makes me think that is what they've always done back in China. But they all went to Malaysia with very little. Built businesses like grocery shops and rubber plantation, houses etc from ground up. Dad's side I thought it's all just all talk they were rich saying granddad went to uni in HK and that's why he spoke English. But turned out the China government asked my dads siblings who ever want some family land can have a small parcel back. Some uncles went back to China was given some land back but not all the family land. Just some. They all know which areas used to be ours as my grandad took everyone back to see his hometown. We're all settled in Australia now.
@@steph4922 Thank you for sharing! It's amazing how our older generations faced so many challenges, unfair treatments and struggles at these difficult times yet able to come out strong, build successful businesses and set up better lives for the next generation. I can't imagine immigrating to a new country with no money and probably not even speaking the language, while having a whole family to support. It's amazing that your grandparents did so well. We need to tell these brave family stories to the next generation, so they will be inspired when they face difficult times. Our lives today are way too comfortable and we are becoming less resilient. My grandma used tell her WWII and Culture Revolution stories, and said to me that no matter how hard life it is, it will pass. Just stay alive, you can live with more and live with little. She also told me to travel a lot and put my needs first. She sure saw the world, her last international trip was at age 93.
Chinese are the greatest businessmen irrespective where they are. Wherever they are, they brought prosperity to the country. Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippine, Cambodia, Loas still need the Chinese to run its economy. Why India did not grow as fast because the Indian Government ill treated the Chinese and many left India. Otherwise India will have many middle class, similar to other Asian Countries. It is a pity that India miss the opportunity otherwise India would develop at a more faster pace.
why our chinese over sea so chicken , we have been chasing killing by local people even we born on the same land why not stand together to fight back and ask for help around chinese community to buy weapons to self defence instead running away and finally got killed , i hope 1 day our chinese can stand for ourself and fight back from racist
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger
Hey Buddy do you still live in India how many chinese still Live in Tangra kolakata in your region and your stemates of Chinese Chindians living in whole India and west Bengal?
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
I live in Calcutta / Kolkata and I am almost 60 years old. Chinese community in Kolkata lived in 1 single address - 47, South Tangra Road. It was and still now a Chinese Fort with 6 entrances or gates only and they used to get opened and closed by the community everyday where non-Chinese were forbidden to enter except the labourers who used to work in the tanneries. The tannery process practiced by the Chinese was extremely toxic as a result Govt. made Kolkata Leather Complex some 20 years back under Court order due to tremendous pollution level. The pollution was so high that no one used to buy 2nd hand cars owned by the Chinese since the whole cars used to get corroded in no time. It was so high that the labels on Coca Cola Bottles used to get blackened out with three days sitting on the rack. But the Chinese having very large factories and making tremendous money from Leather product exports never wanted to invest from their earnings to take up a much better and modern facility in the leather complex and hence migrated. The food joints had always been there, they used to be know as Chinese Eateries with excellent taste and fresh food used to be cooked and served in the same place. These places started to become popular when they started to sell Liquor but without any liquor license. Hence the liquor was sold cheap and anyone can also take bottle of his choice and have it there by paying a bottle fee. But all these changed since the Govt. was loosing Excise duty and asked them to take proper Liquor license. That also they felt that the Govt. was against them. There was mismatch with the Chinese sought after lifestyle for big money, flashy cars, costly watches, etc. etc. but their surrounding population was different and only labours used to get very less salaries for doing a hazardous job and they used to get sick after prolonged use of chemicals constantly. Calcuttan's were always very friendly to them and they enjoyed their food and still now they do. I had many school and college batch mates from the community who have otherwise done extremely well since they integrated into Indian community. Problem was with the people who wanted to remain Chinese only. With only education in Chinese schools never learnt the local language and made a Fortress for themselves and remained cocooned in it. Mr. Jimmy the blogger here never ventured out the other part of Kolkata. The Bowbazar and Central Calcutta Chinese population who were in Carpentry and wood works, there were famous Chinese Dentists. The Sunday Morning Chinese Breakfast on Phears Lane, Lalbazar is so famous a lot of people from other parts of India come to visit it. The Chinese school - Ling Liang High School opened in 1949 is still now running well with a lot of students (www.linglianghighschool.com/). Chinese came to India and specifically West Bengal in 1800's as Salt Factory Workers and many stayed back. Mr. Jimmy Your research was very poor or I must say you wanted to say what you said for reasons best known to you.
Exactly Chinese community came here Just to earn money 🤑 I don't know why these people remained very isolated in the city like Kolkata may be they think of them as a superior creature or something. 🤣 Intentionally the didn't tried to indianise themselves and still they are complaining.
exactly if you decide not to gel with country's culture then you cannot grow its not just india its in every part of world . the research by Jimmy is extremely poor and misleading , that was something i was not expecting from him , a small suggestion to jimmy please visit China and document how exactly Indian's are living there you'll be surprised.
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
If you want to live in atriocatic Chinese government ! You can ! Mao zedon killed 20 million Chinese lol ! Started war against india ! Whereas india praised them as brothers given veto power and permanent sit in UNSC ! Lol ! Snakes
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
मैं भारतीय नागरिक हू। मुझे आपके वीडियो देखकर मालूम हुआ की कोलकाता शहर में चीनी समुदाय के लोग पिछले कई वर्षो से निवास में है। यह जानकर दुख हुआ की उन चीनी भाईयो को भेदभाव झेलना पड़ रहा है। उनके फैक्ट्री व्यापार स्कूल बंद हो गए। लोग पलायन कर गए। बड़े दुख की बात है। उम्मीद है बाकी के बचे लोग खुशहाली से जीवन व्यतीत करेंगे।
@@chengloong889Being an Indian, I want to tell you that we agree with all your points but except one thing. That is that India has occupied China. And brother, I have seen your media spreading hatred towards India, why so? China always claims to indian territory and renaming the part of aruranchal pradesh .
@@chengloong889 चीन प्राचीन काल से लेकर चेन काई शेक सत्ता तक चीन भारत का घनिष्ट मित्र था लेकिन जबसे सत्ता में माओ त्से तुंग आने के वजह चीनी विचारधारा कम्युनिस्ट हो गई। जिन चीनियों ने कम्युनिस्ट पार्टी का विरोध किया उनको कम्युनिस्ट पार्टी के अधिकारियों पुलिस/आर्मी ने मार दिया याफीर उनकी आवाज को दबा दिया जो चीनी अमीर थे वह ताइवान में जाकर बस गए । आगे जाकर कम्युनिस्ट माओ त्से तुंग के नेतृत्व में तिब्बत और भारत के कैलाश मानसरोवर और अरुणाचल , लद्दाख को पर हमला किया। तब हमारे देश के अंग्रेजो के मानसिकता/गुलामी की मानसिकता और अंग्रजो के चाटुकारा नेता पंडित जवाहरलाल नेहरु था । सत्ताओं के बदल जाने से विचारधारा भी बदल जाती है यह नेहरू को समझ नहीं आया ।
I so love the response from the little kid. This is the kind of world I also wish for all young people in today's fractured earth, so broken up into this group or that group, this/that religion, ethnicity, background, skin colour, etc. This boy is blessed to think and talk like that!
As an Indian we love our Chinese community. I had a junior Chinese girl in my college. I never felt like I was talking to a foreigner. Please try to stay in India if you can. ❤❤❤❤
I love the last young boy statement about how he feels in India. This is called an education makes anybody wise. And god bless all Indians living in India.
Indian myself thanks for making this didn't know we had a chinese community of hakka people, i can see the pain in their eyes, thank you for documenting this
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
Yeah, for you not for him, you don't know Indian's true colours, I'm a Indian too from northeast state but we looks different compare to other state Indian's people
I wish India can progress super fast and the remaining Chinese population in India don't go extinct. They are peace loving people like us Indians. The Indian and Chinese cultures have co-existed over 1000s of years without any problem.
I am a South Indian, in my village many people migrated to USA for better life style. Same way Chinese are doing from theirs hime land . There is no discrimination, only for High standard living life style
Yes Chinese people migrated to India for a better life❤ India is the best country in the world❤ India colonized the whole world 😢that’s why the whole world speak Hindi and Tamil
Bro as Indian im learning lot about communities who are living in India recently got to know Africans were living in India and now suddenly after watching your video got to know Chinese brothers are also living in India Never expected and thank you for making this video dont know why but I felt sad watching video.
Another fun fact, there is a small Chinese community in Assam, in the northeast of India. They mainly came due to the tea industry. Now, they too have mostly vanished, few remain but they number in the 50s...
I see many Indians in China, most are teachers and they are so highly respected there. In fact, Chinese people actually treat Indians better than their own, a stark contrast to the discrimination and hate crimes experienced by Chinese in India. Indians in China will never have to worry about safety or hate crimes.
ikr, my uncle teaches yoga there and he tells us about it but please give India a chance as India is still largely uneducated and uncivil society due to a major part of it being historically cut from society i.e. the ones that were outcasts. however bad it sounds to an Indian but is a truth
@@कार्तिकेय-ढ8मI think one of the main reasons for the difference is the news media in India constantly pushes anti-China news that stir up resentment but on the other hand, Chinese media don't like to push hate on any group of people
Generalization is a very bad thing, my friend. Just because you heard some Chinese people being discriminated in India doesn't mean every Chinese is being discriminated against in India. And please, just please stop being on a moral high ground as if there are no vices of ill-treatment against other races in China. There have been a lot of footage of African community being discriminated against in Guangzhou in China. Also Chinese call us Indians using a very vile, racist word called 阿三. That doesn't mean everyone is a bad apple. So that is why please don't generalize people especially considering yourself from a moral high ground.
@@ArghyadeepPal I never heard of the word 阿三. There is no such word or saying in Chinese and I just confirmed with a few Chinese people. I'm not sure what kind of propaganda media you read that from. Also the Africans being mistreated videos were completely taken out of context or cherry picked. Many of those videos of Chinese mistreating Africans in China were actually debunked including by French fact check website that despite it being anti-China bias outlet. For example, a video that happened years ago in Malaysia where a Black person robbing a store were beaten up by Malaysians were propagated on Western media as an African student getting beaten up by a group of Chinese. Another video showed Chinese restaurant owners fighting against black diners, which was actually under self defense and happened in New York, not in China. Bro, understand what you see in the media is gov funded propaganda. Talk to "real" people who actually been there with "real" experiences.
@@ArghyadeepPal You can learn about the origin of this nickname. Of course, most Chinese people later knew that “阿三” came from the comedy movie "Westward Journey"（大话西游）
I don’t know why as Malaysian Chinese I feel like crying watching this and I m just so grateful for what our ancestors (regardless Chinese, Malay or Indian) have done for Malaysia 🇲🇾 and we still get to learn our own language and history and culture super thankful esp after knowing what most Chineses experienced in this region 🙏🏻
I am an indian chinese. From tangra. Kolkata, India. And i identify myself as an indian. A proud Indian. Many from my community left for abroad. Its their choice. Its a trend generally seen in India. To move abroad due to high population and competition. Statistically its the same in China. Its bullshit and Has nothing to do with India not doing well or not supporting our community. Its not everyone else’s fault if the community does not open up. It likes to be within itself. Shying away. Always.
In ancient time Chinese used to visit in indian universities for studying we had strong bond and connection but now this bond is detached ,today tibbet people they love india china forcefully occupied our land ,and they also targeting noth eastern Indian states ,some people failed to adopt the Indian culture failed to adopt the lifestyle of India so what should we do ,they want better lifestyle that's why they leaving india ,,,
I’m sorry for what you guys have gone through. In India, people between states don’t get well together and are being called “outsiders” in our own country.
This young Chinese boy (son of the owner at this Chinese restaurant) gave a very intelligent politically correct answer when he was asked if he was Chinese or Indian. Smart boy!
The answer that the boy gave at the end is actually very similar to the pledge that indian school students learn everyday, Most people including many indians dont know indian is not an ethnicity it is a nationality anyone with indian citizenship is indian reagrdless of ethinicity we are all equal infront of the law but unfornutely past governments have been unfair to many communities including this one . Sad to see this community decline.
Bro past govts have been unfair. Past govts are the reasons so many communities are still living together. The current govt only speaks for one community. Thats too its fake.
The same is true of Christians in India. They are trying to flee India especially after Modi and the BJP RSS.. They don't feel safe in India anymore! The Parsis have left, the Jews have left. Always talk about a religious State with the majority religion and nonsense talk like that from Bharkts. No one is happy any more. Modi has destroyed the feeling of the country with his BJP RSS!
Thank you for making this video. I was there in 2007 visiting someone who grew up in Kolkata, she took me to the top of the school during the Chinese New Year festival. A lot of fond memories of the people and its local cuisine. I still can't find anywhere that makes fish balls the way they did over in Tangra.
In fact, Chinese migration to India's southern parts is even older than their migration to Singapore. I believe the official timeframe is in the 18th century but it may have been even earlier, during the Ming Dynasty when trade between China and Calcutta flourished
Many of indians ? Really not 😂 even 0.1 % ppl of india migrated ! Haha ! Ppl who migrate now they just want more money ! If you want to live in atriocatic Chinese government ! You can ! Mao zedon killed 20 million Chinese lol ! Started war against india ! Whereas india praised them as brothers given veto power and permanent sit in UNSC ! Lol ! Snakes
Who is ignorant and don't respect them?? Didn't you saw whole video the problem there was poor lifestyle in India not disrespect. Indians don't hate chinese and respect them same as other Indians.
Oh, so sorry to hear. Yes I agree I don't know why Chinese are always so hard working, so successful and so many countries are bad to us. I'm aussie Chinese, more and more Chinese come here. The good thing is the government are not directly against us. If someone tries to directly discriminate our kids, they will surely hear from me. I will not let anyone be rude to my kid, white or brown. I'm a well educated rich Chinese (my grandad went to Malaysia and my dads siblings studied in UK and Canada. Most families settled in Aus), my kids are just as good as any other Aussies. We need to stand up. No more running away from country to country.
As a Filipino-Chinese-Japanese-East Indian-Spanish-Canadian I would recommend for Chinese Indians to Immigrate Malaysia , Singapore , The Philippines ( Where I was born ) , Canada ( Where I live ) , USA since there are many diverse ethnicities. in those countries
Actually India is not a bad place. My friends enjoy their tours there. I imagine the elderly ppl finding it a great place to retire. My grandpa came from China too. Now we are settled happily in Singapore. To me, home is where the heart is. ❤️
i'm pretty sure they would much rather be with their kids in canada or wherever they've immigrated to, but the reality is they're old and they will only be an extra mouth to feed. whereas if they stay behind in India their kids can send a little bit of CAD home and it'd be considered enough for a months worth of expenses in india.
I beg to differ. With a hostile government, it is difficult to stay. The place is becoming decadent and the local council make no effort to repair them. You don’t see any future. There is minimal development. Unlike you the lucky one, to find a job here is very tough.
@@cfyong1838, are you Chinese in India? Try to leave asap. Go anywhere, try Malaysia; Taiwan; China if you don't have enough to go US Canada Aus. My personal experience is Indians are very cunning... we are like cows and horse work hard to earn money. My grandparents call them snakes, plotting looking for free food, taking more than what they work for. I would be worry to live in a snake and worm hole when we are cows and horses. 🥺🥺 get out of there. By the way; what is the government doing to Chinese there?
There is no conflict, there is freedom of voice, if the country is communist and prohibit any negative news about it's country than it can control the population. The population is big and so much of freedom for people
If you want to live in atriocatic Chinese government ! You can ! Mao zedon killed 20 million Chinese lol ! Started war against india ! Whereas india praised them as brothers given veto power and permanent sit in UNSC ! Lol ! Snakes
It's always the people who face the hardships due to country's relationship with other countries. I hope that we and our future generations together could build an environment that's enriching for not only our community but for people from other communities and countries. Thank you for making this video and spreading awareness about the chineses in india.
It is very sad that hakka Chinese community suffered alots difficulty but if we see the context of west Bengal state also suffered lots of riot and govt conflicts lot of things .. which is indescribable but now slowly slowly things are changing..maybe everything will be good one day. And i also hope indian chinese community condition will be improved and best wishes for them whom settle in abroad i wish aap hamesha khush rhe😊😊
Thank you very much for covering this :) While some of us in India are aware of ethnic minorities like the Chinese community in West Bengal, we rarely, if ever, heard their stories. The realities this community faces is real and rampant. Its a shame to see this decline of the community...
In Canada, it’s not easy to prosper as well. Cost of living is high. Many Hakka Chinese open restaurants to promote the Hakka food, but that is a difficult business too.
Good video and well edited. Thanks for sharing with all of us former or current Hakka Chinese who used to live in Calcutta. As a former Chinese who lived here 50 years ago ( and all guests in the video were my Peimay schools mates too) I would say who stayed back are also the lucky ones too they enjoy easy life in India as opposed to most of us that left India, we have a hard time to adjust the new country and blend in with the local population just like our previous ancestors who settled down here 100 years ago. Basically one has to work hard and will be rewarded, its my advice,no hard feeling. I am so amazed you have a solid guts like a rhino to visit India. And last but not least the little boy at the end of video is the great grandson of Mr. Chen who was a great supporter of KMT Taiwanese government, also a well respected local Chinese citizen, thank you.
I am reseaching on the history of the overseas Hakka people and had been to your place of birth, Calcutta, twice. I would very much appreciate it if your goodselves could advise me as to the credibility of the book "the deoli wallahs" (the true story of the 1962 Chinese-Indian internment) written by Joy Ma and Dilip D'Souza, publiced in February 2020. When I was in Calcutta, I tried to my best to get first hand information from those who still live there, but, perhaps due to the "circumstances", I was only able to obtain "some" information, nothing much though. Your assustance would be greatly appreciated. For your info, I travelled to Singkawang, Indonesia (great Overseas Hakka city), Sabah (where even the natives speak Hakka language) and Sarawak (closely knitted) , Malaysia, Thailand (some settlements with majority Hakka decentants), Burma (Myanmar) where there are still a great number of Hakka decentants living there, Tahiti and obviously, Mauritius, Reunion and Madagascar. Appreciate your assistance in this matter, if you could and with continuing best wishes, all the best.
For Gods sake stop stereotyping India, Calcutta is the poorest part of India apart from Delhi, Varanasi Overall India as a country is very diverse with a lot of nice places, if the Chinese setlled in Southern India instead of Calcutta their lives would have been far better India is an asian powerhouse economy where poverty is rapidly decreasing and is at 18% in 2022 according to United Nations data India is a G20 member good bye!said India does not have indoor plumbing? Stop dreaming and living in a paradise, as a Jewish Persian I would it was you barbaric brits who destroyed India along with Muslims, ancient India was admired by Greeks I am a Zoroastrian Parsi living in India whose ancestors had migrated to India 1500 years back for taking shelter when the Muslims invaded Persian Empire and defeated the Sasannians who were the last of our great ancestors that had made Persia as one of the most prosperous empires and ancient civilizations. We Parsis have always been grateful to India for the kindness they showed us and we cannot tolerate anyone blindly insulting our country because we Parsis have also become Indians. Not only us but even Persian nationalists in Iran who hate the barbaric Islamic regime have admiration for India because we and Indians both belong to ancient civilizations. While it is true that India has many problems but that does not mean whatever you say is true. Infact your ideas about India are not only rubbish and filled with fantastic but you are a racist. Yes you are completely a cruel racist who is displaying absolute racism towards India. Listen, people like you are no more different than those white supremacist groups or the far right zionists infact you are 100000 times worse than them. You are basically blindly brainwashed by Chinese communist propaganda and therefore you cannot accept the fact that India is progressing, you believe in fake conspiracy theories and the fact that Russia is a great superpower where in reality the villages in the interior parts of Russia have huge problems with indoor plumbing, defecation outdoors is far common
@@wyliamulayye7534There were Hakka communities in the Caribbean, also. I was born & raised in Jamaica, but now live in the US. Most of the Jamaican Hakkas moved to Toronto or to Florida.
Back in the early 80's we lived in Calcutta and frequented Tangra alot. Very sad to see, my parents had a few Chinese friends and we spent alot ot time with them. Lots of reasons to leave, economics, racism, lack of opportunity. good video.
14:13 I am Singaporean Chinese. I encourage this young man to come to Singapore to live and work. It is very easy for Indian nationals to get work permit in Singapore due to the CECA Agreement with India. We have a population of 75% Chinese and 10% Indian. You will adapt easily in Singapore. English is the lingua franca here. And Tamil (southern India language) is an official language. Ancestors of Chinese in Singapore came from Southern Chinese provinces. So we have Hakka Chinese too, from Fujian and Guangdong provinces. They settled here 100 years ago. Also the little boy at the tail end of the video, come Singapore to study. 😊 i went to New Delhi, Agra, Jaipur and Mumbai in 2011, free and easy. I was never harmed. It was fun. Egg Biryani and jai, the tea, was delicious. Love India, and will be back next time, to the South.
Hi ! I'm from Northeast India and i have met many Chinese Friends also when I was in North India while doing my graduation. They are really nice and we have many things in common yes it's true. I have many friends from all around the world. Met some friends through online have met some in different states of India some are from my university Japan, China, Philippine, Thailand, Ukraine, Usa ..Other countries. WE HAVE One thing in common HUMANITY. We want to stay peacefully No matter in which country which state which place we are.
@@台灣省省長蔡包子 stop lying , it's the opposite . It's illegal immigrants from Bangladesh and neighbouring countries that have encroached India , not the other way around . India is in a difficult spot and has to stay neutral for Russia becuz they were never against us , unlike US they are the two faced monsters who we should be careful of . As for the Indian Chinese people it's sad they had to leave , I consider all of them as my family and my ancestors were Chinese as well . But it's really the Indian people who are at fault and Govt for supporting them . And trust me it's American and western people who look down on india , not the other way around .
As a person who grew up in that locality, I feel happy that there has finally been some coverage provided on the situation of the Chinese living there. Although I would disagree with some of the views expressed in the video, it is a fact that majority of the people there think like that.
I m nepali indian and I from a very small town named kalimpong there were many many Chinese they had leather shoe shops and I had many class mates but they slowly migrated to Australia 🇦🇺 Canada 🇨🇦... I think now there are 2 family lest that too I m not sure all my Chinese friends were fluent in nepali but Chinese guys from tengra Calcutta were good in hindi.
@@zhipeichen It's just indoctrination from school and society. There's no critical thinking if you haven't lived long enough to think and to experience the world.
As someone from northeast India, I can feel the pain of the Chinese Indians who had to face all the adversities and racism after the Indo China war. And I want them to know that a lot of Indians care about them and consider them as our own cause they are Indians too! Let peace and love prevail everywhere ❤
India are racist even to thier own people the caste system, hindu hate Christian try to destroy church
Northeast tribes face the same as well racism discrimination and name calling
@@Rav01508things have changed now no need to biker
@@kamakshikaul its still the same
Every norteast tribes who work study or visit mainland gets name calling and racism
Bitter truth hurts
Bhakts like u are blind to this issues
And also SAVE MANIPUR
@@Rav01508 how can we save manipur when those animals dont want to save themselves. Hooligans and junglees killing each other
我是马来西亚第4代华人。身为马来西亚华人，我们为我国的华文教育感到敬佩及光荣。感恩先辈努力地把华文教育传递至今。看了你的影片才知道印度的某个地方还有华人, thanks for the insights. Interesting video.
We in Malaysia are very lucky to be able to maintain Chinese education because the tolerance between the races here is very good.. we hope the harmony of the diversity of races in Malaysia will last forever..
What is 4th generation Chinese?
@@Enryu_CZX our ancestors are from China who immigrate to Malaysia. So i’m the forth generation Chinese in Malaysia.
兄弟姐妹们 会中文 我感到自豪 未来某一刻 中文一定会超过英语使用率
@@cytang4904 ooh that means your great grand father. do you know malay?
That boy in the end gave me tears. His sentiments of being indian as well as chinese makes me feel that adults lose their sense of belongingness no matter what race.
I dont think many adults could have articulated such a beautiful reply. Hats off to him! We need more like him today in this world!
@urdailygamr9229成年之前可以申请中国国籍
@urdailygamr9229你是印度华人吗
@@uhhhhhh7681 living under communist government? i dont think they want that. they must be considering taiwan or usa.
@@uhhhhhh7681 父母不是中国籍，他不可能申请到。
Damn this is a touching story.
As an Indian i feel guilty for the people how the government treated them.
We are NE Indian and feel the same as Chinese here in the other states as well.
Thank you for providing the fact.
Life is always difficult, and the life of an ordinary person always appears weak under the influence of world situations and politics. You don't need to feel guilty about this because you are a kind person. The world would be a better place if we were kind to others. thank you for your sympathy
True man. Being born in assam. These freaking assamese discriminated me. Just because I don't look indian??
Damm
@@Boro스네하 we consider you as Indians❤😊
India is not India without North East
@@Boro스네하 infact indians, assamese (except northeastern people) don't look Asian. Rather they look like someone who gets thoroughly checked at every international airport
That's common sense...
For reference, why don't Chinese people love Japanese culture and them(Japanese) investing into China...?
Hope u got my point...
I’m Singaporean and I never knew there’s a Chinese community in India! I find it very fascinating seeing ethnically Chinese individuals speaking English with a Tamil accent. It’s really sad that the heritage is disappearing by the day, but I can also understand why people are leaving for a better future. Thank you for the insights!
There’s a Chines saying. Where there’s sunshine. There’s a Chinese. 😊
Well when I was in JB just returned from Singapore for work and I’ve met this one indian lady from Indonesia and yeah she’s a legit Indonesian citizen. I had no idea about their diaspora that spread elsewhere other than Malaysia and Singapore and perhaps Brunei.
@@nomadblueprintThere's a small Indian community in Indonesia. They are usually in the textile business. In Medan, there's a place called "Kampung Madras", a vibrant Indian Indonesian community.
You can find Chinese in almost every part of the world and they all call the highly concentrated place as Chinatown
@@nomadblueprint Yup, There are Indian Indonesia in Indonesia. Most of them spread in Sumatra Province, concentrate in Kampung Madras or Kampung Keling, Medan - North Sumatra. Also in Pasar Baru, Jakarta and small community in Jogyakarta, Central Java Province. Most of their livelihood are selling textille, Indian spices or sport supplier. And in Sumatra, some of them sell food, called "mie rebus / Boiled Noodle" or mie keling, an authentic noodle with thick sauce.
No offence, in the past we usually called them "Keling" refer to their dark skin tone color.
马来西亚的华人，真的真的，很努力，一直保住自己的文化，自己捐钱建学校，政府不合作就变成私立中学，为了后代，为了母语，一直传承下去
malaysian chinese are despicabIe and look down on Iocals......chinese in thailand and indonesia are 100x better and have assimilated into the IocaI cuIture
前人种树，后人乘凉
Ungrateful people..
我超佩服馬來西亞華人的﹐馬來西亞華人識多國語言﹐中文教得很好﹐而且那裡的很
多建築物比中國還中國
@@chloelovely3782 no
My Teacher was a Chinese Indian from Kolkata he passed away few years ago. I can say he was also from Kolkata. And I’m really grateful I got to witness this. My teacher was best he was my mentor my. He changed my life. I really wish all the Chinese Indians can still preserve their culture. ❤❤❤ and even I am from Singapore. I was studying in India for few years. I met him in india dehradun really miss him.
are you from Tamil Indian community in singapore or from other parts Hinduism is followed by 10%of singaporeans and 12-14% of Singaporeans are of Indian origins and diaspora and 10-11% Mostly Tamilian only
Not chinese... They are tibbati
@@anikumar4713 na they are Chinese Living in India since Centuries Brought up By Britishers and Dai Chinese Tai Chinese During Ahom Empire
Tai Ahoms are not chinese.Chinese is a nationality.There was no country called china in those days.whereas tai tribes originated from thailand.And tais are sino tibetan.
@@Sylotizeecontact Dai Chinese and Tai Chinese exists Bro
I am indian ,I also worked in Chinese restaurant in kolkata ,Indian Chinese are very nice people
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
As an Indian: Thank you for contributing to the story of India. I understand that everyone strives for a better life, whether in their home country or abroad. I wish you the best, and I also wish for you to know that if you still want to call India one of your home countries then you are more than welcome to do so. Personally, I will always consider you as much Indian as myself.
Outside of politics (which I don’t want to talk about), Indians and Chinese get along wherever they live. I have cousins who are married to Chinese women living in America, Canada and Australia. I also know that Indians have been living peacefully in Hong Kong for many generations and are very happy with their Chinese (Cantonese) neighbours.
Personally, I studied in Australia and 2 of my closest friends were from China. They were among the best people I have met abroad: always wanting to pay for our dinners and drinks, and being the best hosts whenever I went for dinner with them, and also some of the most genuine and fun guys to get drunk with. Again, without getting into politics, I hope the people of India and China can continue to get along. We share many things in common despite our differences.
No, China and India never get along well you don't need to wish. The same goes for Vietnam and Philippine for the same reason that is China just wants everything belongs to them! Very greedy country. That attitude certailny causes suspicion amonsgt non-chinese communities in those countries. Chinese still worships their former homeland resisting assimilation, setting up their Chinese schools etc after 300 years just pack up and go back to China, no need to worry about everything thatcis not chinese. Your homeland should wellcome you as the sons and daughters have lost, shouldn't they as China is now very rich , 2nd after US, and powerful!
Better life usually means more money, where ever they get significantly more money people want to go there, USA and some western countries knew this, so they attract workers, thats all there to it.
@@gshrdy5415
Opportunity not decline here in kolkata but it gets better.
This Indian Chinese can't afford that.
This Indian Chinese run leathers business in the center of kolkata which is very harm full to environment. Creat lot's of emissions problem. Not good for health life.
So government creat a whole new leather complex in out skirt of kolkata . Which is called bantala leather complex.
But problem is this Indian Chinese can't afford the factories their may be .
So you can't blame government.
They tried their best to protect enviroment.
And also market of leathers became More big.
Infact biggest leather factories located here in bantala leather complex.
I’m Indian and my wife is Chinese American! We have a lot of shared values like family values and the way we think about money and parents and education.
@@wearemariners1889are you comedy many factories in india producing toxic gas control them
我在加拿大30了，我有个同事是老师，她就是从这个地方移民来的客家人，她的爷爷曾经是这间学校的校长，她在印度出生，她会说带口音的广东话，我问她为什么中文这么好，她说在印度读的是中文学校，校长是她爷爷，原来这就是她生长的地方，谢谢分享。
人差不多走完了，还是留下了印记。比如印度称炒面为hakka noodle. 还有包子momos.
人的缘分真的很奇妙 世界也真的是一个圈
@@bryceliang8279momos本意应该是奶子的意思？🤣
Cheese India border fighting ,the government of India treat chinese very bad.that the reason chinese
她爷爷应该是个很了不起的人。在那里做校长传承保持华人的文化。比起印度来加拿大真的各个少数族群的天堂了。
梅培中學，題字的是嚴家淦先生，僑胞們在外地最後的精神依託，不論哪裡的華人，都很努力的生活，致上最高的敬意
培梅中学不是梅培中学。
大师当永存，他也是曾经的中华民国总统。有幸遇到过很多移居海外华人，数代以来坚持对文化血脉的传承，令人钦佩。
佩服
蔡元培，梅贻琦
He's from Suzhou.
"So everyone here we consider ourselves equal, as brother and sister", wonderfully put.
偶然刷到这个，很感恩马来西亚的中华文华可以保留得那么好，每一代都还有机会学母语，谢谢祖祖辈辈的坚持♥
中华民族会自强不息
@@wshggg
@@wshggg你的引战真是低级😅
what about if I speak in English? Does that mean I am American or British? Brainwashed one. @@wshggg
只有那种低级的老古董，还抱守着繁琐的繁体字，跟几百年的老僵尸一样，笑死，你怎么不用甲骨文呢@@wshggg
真有趣看著華人面孔但是一口印度英文，連說話的姿勢也是印度人特有的，真的很特別
入鄉隨俗，沒有什麼特別
我也想说有点好笑，但是他讲的内容又有点伤感，所以会有一种复杂的感觉。
在地化啊 , 一定會的啦
As an Indian I am curious to know how does their mandarin sounds to Chinese people? Does that have an Indian accent too?
作为一个印度人，我很好奇他们的普通话对中国人来说听起来怎么样？这也有印度口音吗？
@@MRchud24 Very standard
海外移民的老人們很強，都是自己花錢建學校明白學習的重要。 馬來西亞的中文教育也是因為他們的堅持才保留得那麼完善至今。
My suspicion is most that left China are the educated and community minded that's why they are willing to build school and continue to donate to all community events. My grandparents left China but I think they always wanted to go back when it "reopens" but it took so many decades and the kids ended up settled already. My granddad was uni educated in HK and his dad was a Judge with generations of wealth and education. My mum's side are also educated and in business. They all are one of the founders in Chinese schools and Chinese social projects in Malaysia. The community funding continues in my dad's generation and I am now also donating money to local causes. My family was believed in helping others, building a good community and we have a good family name / reputation in our town. We were not the super rich but willingly contributed a big portion of our income.
But recently I met some Chinese who are not educated or even thinking education is important, just like to party and live day by day then borrow money from anyone they can.... that is a different kind of Chinese that I've never met in my life. 🤦♂️ I have always been a proud Chinese... didn't know stupid Chinese existed.
學校題字的是嚴家淦 估計是民國政府出資的中華學校
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
看到海外中華同胞一樣打拼，感恩馬來西亞先賢的努力，把中華文化保留到這麽好。我是馬來西亞華人，海外華人加油。
Friend sent me this video. Interesting to see this. I’m a Canadian born Hakka Chinese. My parents were born in kolkata. Like the interviewees described my grand father owned a restaurant and leather tannery. He was taken to a concentration camp during the sino Indian boarder war where he died. That’s when my dad’s side left. Definitely sad to see some of these ppl feeling trapped.
Oh my goodness! That's crazy. My parents migrated to Australia and my grandparents where in Malaysia before. I didn't know Indians took Chinese there for what? For being Chinese? These barbarians always say China have no human rights? That's why to me, they all say "most Chinese left" but didn't want to say much. Must be something very terrible that they can't even say? Everyone knows Malaysian government don't treat Chinese well as we are discriminate. But people are not afraid to say that....
Anyway to be honest, India is a ST country, I'm glad your family left. I've know many Indians, most I know are what my grandparents use to call them "snakes", very deceiving and always slithering around. Be careful they are always plotting.
For example, when Indians moved their business a few doors away, my parents joked that their business will somehow catch fire and claim insurance. I always thought it was a joke. But, after 3 yrs, it happened! And they claimed huge insurance. The fire spread to our business and half burned our stock and even lots of family photos, clothing etc, all gone.
Also many other incidences... makes me think they really are what my grandparents says they are.
Oh no. sorry to hear that! My mom was born in Calcutta too! Grandparents used to work there. May be my mom knows your parents :) ! My grandma used to teach at local Chinese School. See my post on the top sharing their story. My grandpa's best friend was the principal of the Chinese school, he was taken by the police in the middle of the night and sent to China/India boarder remote area and left to die, was later saved.. He died few years later at Chinese labor camp during Cultural revolution. crazy time.
@@nancyn1106 , wow indeed crazy time. You're Chinese, Indians want you to died, you're Chinese also taken by new government 😓. Both sides of My grandparents were in Malaysia I think since around 1930s, 40s, no issues. No one taking them to any camps. Both side family I believe wealthy in China. My dad's side, my great grandad was a Judge and family has lots of land. Mum's side her grandma has those lotus feet never said they're rich but judging by their mind set and skills having built up lots of businesses and estates in Malaysian makes me think that is what they've always done back in China. But they all went to Malaysia with very little. Built businesses like grocery shops and rubber plantation, houses etc from ground up. Dad's side I thought it's all just all talk they were rich saying granddad went to uni in HK and that's why he spoke English. But turned out the China government asked my dads siblings who ever want some family land can have a small parcel back. Some uncles went back to China was given some land back but not all the family land. Just some. They all know which areas used to be ours as my grandad took everyone back to see his hometown. We're all settled in Australia now.
@@steph4922 Thank you for sharing! It's amazing how our older generations faced so many challenges, unfair treatments and struggles at these difficult times yet able to come out strong, build successful businesses and set up better lives for the next generation. I can't imagine immigrating to a new country with no money and probably not even speaking the language, while having a whole family to support. It's amazing that your grandparents did so well.
We need to tell these brave family stories to the next generation, so they will be inspired when they face difficult times. Our lives today are way too comfortable and we are becoming less resilient. My grandma used tell her WWII and Culture Revolution stories, and said to me that no matter how hard life it is, it will pass. Just stay alive, you can live with more and live with little. She also told me to travel a lot and put my needs first. She sure saw the world, her last international trip was at age 93.
Chinese are the greatest businessmen irrespective where they are. Wherever they are, they brought prosperity to the country. Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippine, Cambodia, Loas still need the Chinese to run its economy. Why India did not grow as fast because the Indian Government ill treated the Chinese and many left India. Otherwise India will have many middle class, similar to other Asian Countries. It is a pity that India miss the opportunity otherwise India would develop at a more faster pace.
身为马来西亚华人觉得自己很幸福。虽然在经济和教育领域范围不断受到国家政策上的排挤但是几十年来我们华人还是能在这里保持自己的习俗，语言和文化的同时也可以和友族和睦相处。除了政客令人厌烦之外我觉马来西亚华人都很爱这里。马来西亚不累不累
是在多元文化社会生存不容易！必须多举办慈善义工帮助别的种族，增进感情相互了解，促进合作。
马来西亚华人与台湾香港大陆都很亲近❤
感谢马来西亚华人一直传承守护闽粤潮客文化
马来西亚 还有客家话 电台 播报新闻哦~
why our chinese over sea so chicken , we have been chasing killing by local people even we born on the same land why not stand together to fight back and ask for help around chinese community to buy weapons to self defence instead running away and finally got killed , i hope 1 day our chinese can stand for ourself and fight back from racist
看后真的很感恩林连玉和以前＆现在所有在马来西亚捍卫＆保护华文教育的英雄。谢谢。
说实话我们马来西亚华人算是非常幸运了。虽然没有一个国家是十全十美，但我们已经是非常幸运了。也感谢我们的祖先下南洋时选择了大马，假如选错地方，我们不会有今天。
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
以前讀書有看過加爾各答印度唐人街的紀錄，但這麼真實的紀錄真的太棒了！謝謝分享！
I am from kolkata (Calcutta) ...here is a place which is called china mandir
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
在世界任何地方，华裔永远都是重视教育。这股精神是非常值得敬佩。
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger
大家好！我最终是兄弟，我感谢大家的评论，我彻夜不眠地看着和阅读它们！非常感谢。来自印度的厚爱！❤️❤️❤️
Ur so cute 🥰
Your thoughts are pure brother. You have a long way to go. Study wisely and always respect your roots.
just love your comment, have a good day brother
Hey Buddy do you still live in India how many chinese still Live in Tangra kolakata in your region and your stemates of Chinese Chindians living in whole India and west Bengal?
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
I live in Calcutta / Kolkata and I am almost 60 years old. Chinese community in Kolkata lived in 1 single address - 47, South Tangra Road. It was and still now a Chinese Fort with 6 entrances or gates only and they used to get opened and closed by the community everyday where non-Chinese were forbidden to enter except the labourers who used to work in the tanneries.
The tannery process practiced by the Chinese was extremely toxic as a result Govt. made Kolkata Leather Complex some 20 years back under Court order due to tremendous pollution level. The pollution was so high that no one used to buy 2nd hand cars owned by the Chinese since the whole cars used to get corroded in no time. It was so high that the labels on Coca Cola Bottles used to get blackened out with three days sitting on the rack.
But the Chinese having very large factories and making tremendous money from Leather product exports never wanted to invest from their earnings to take up a much better and modern facility in the leather complex and hence migrated.
The food joints had always been there, they used to be know as Chinese Eateries with excellent taste and fresh food used to be cooked and served in the same place. These places started to become popular when they started to sell Liquor but without any liquor license. Hence the liquor was sold cheap and anyone can also take bottle of his choice and have it there by paying a bottle fee.
But all these changed since the Govt. was loosing Excise duty and asked them to take proper Liquor license. That also they felt that the Govt. was against them.
There was mismatch with the Chinese sought after lifestyle for big money, flashy cars, costly watches, etc. etc. but their surrounding population was different and only labours used to get very less salaries for doing a hazardous job and they used to get sick after prolonged use of chemicals constantly.
Calcuttan's were always very friendly to them and they enjoyed their food and still now they do. I had many school and college batch mates from the community who have otherwise done extremely well since they integrated into Indian community. Problem was with the people who wanted to remain Chinese only. With only education in Chinese schools never learnt the local language and made a Fortress for themselves and remained cocooned in it.
Mr. Jimmy the blogger here never ventured out the other part of Kolkata. The Bowbazar and Central Calcutta Chinese population who were in Carpentry and wood works, there were famous Chinese Dentists. The Sunday Morning Chinese Breakfast on Phears Lane, Lalbazar is so famous a lot of people from other parts of India come to visit it.
The Chinese school - Ling Liang High School opened in 1949 is still now running well with a lot of students (www.linglianghighschool.com/).
Chinese came to India and specifically West Bengal in 1800's as Salt Factory Workers and many stayed back.
Mr. Jimmy Your research was very poor or I must say you wanted to say what you said for reasons best known to you.
Thanks for sharing your experience. Really widens the view I had earlier.
Savage reply sir your language and knowledge shows ur age and experience
I second that. My beauty therapist in Mumbai is 4th generation Chinese and has very well integrated into India. Well educated, modern day urban woman
Exactly Chinese community came here Just to earn money 🤑 I don't know why these people remained very isolated in the city like Kolkata may be they think of them as a superior creature or something. 🤣 Intentionally the didn't tried to indianise themselves and still they are complaining.
exactly if you decide not to gel with country's culture then you cannot grow its not just india its in every part of world . the research by Jimmy is extremely poor and misleading , that was something i was not expecting from him , a small suggestion to jimmy please visit China and document how exactly Indian's are living there you'll be surprised.
如此努力的同胞 看了让人很感动 希望全球华人都能团结起来
China is a great nation
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
最後那位小弟弟 好厲害 口齒清晰說出很大人的話
谢谢你！其实我到底是弟弟😊
小弟很會說漂亮話，長大之後才發現很多事並不是當初所想，不然為何許多人要離開印度？
从小对多元化种族社会有这么好的认知，这个小弟弟很厉害。我二十多岁的时候都未必有他看得清楚。
@@noname74626
政治正确罢了。
不然你会死翘翘。美国也一样。
这只是一种理想，并非现实。就算在多元文化国家的澳洲都达不到这种状态。@@noname74626
客家人不管到哪裡，即使窮，但決不會窮教育。。
或者你會發覺，客家話會很接近中文，所以客家人都一般能夠做到說中文！
客家先輩對教育的高瞻遠矚，令人敬佩。
這似乎是客家人骨子裏的基因
客家话就是中文
客家话是中文方言啊😂
你想说的是华语（普通话/国语）吧。
除了客家话很接近国语之外其他蛮赞同的，跟国语区别还是很大，到大陆北方客家口音的国语大多都听不懂或有点懵懂。
敬佩客家先輩對教育的重視！感謝，jimmy 製作了這一輯節目，讓我們更了解客家人在印度的發展和生活
If you want to live in atriocatic Chinese government ! You can !
Mao zedon killed 20 million Chinese lol ! Started war against india ! Whereas india praised them as brothers given veto power and permanent sit in UNSC ! Lol ! Snakes
School is abandoned.. Chinese youth there not learning their language And culture. it has become more indian.
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
13:14 這位大哥眼裡的無奈，還是苦笑著敘述，看得好心酸😔
很佩服移民海外還能堅持讓子女學中文的華僑, 你們辛苦了! 加油!!!
馬來西亞，華文教育發展的十分完善，從小學到中學甚至大專。
或許應該說除了大陸，香港，台灣，全世界唯獨馬來西亞中文教育有這麼系統的！
甚至於可以讀寫簡體，簡體字。
環境使然也同時兼備懂得英文，馬來文。
@@chankenny6772缅甸华人汉族也是说普通话 云南话缅北都是华人区 缅甸中部慢德勒 仰光 都是华人华侨汉族很多 我的城市腊戌华校就有20几所 高中4所 初中13所 小学也特别多 缅北和云南差不多 缅甸南部仰光那边是客家人多
@@杨杨浩然
弘揚中文是炎黃子孫，不斷延續。
馬來西亞華文小學有一千多所，華人獨立中學有61間。
私立大學，有拉曼大學，新紀元，南方等等！
中文學校在馬來西亞一直都是華社出錢出力吃力不討好去發揚光大，甚至得到其他種族青睞他們辦學態度，和有目共睹的成績！
min ga lar par kha myar!
~曼德勒。
辛苦? 國際學校內白人小朋友說的國語比香港及澳門華人清楚呀! 要學國語? 入讀國際學校就行。
मैं भारतीय नागरिक हू। मुझे आपके वीडियो देखकर मालूम हुआ की कोलकाता शहर में चीनी समुदाय के लोग पिछले कई वर्षो से निवास में है। यह जानकर दुख हुआ की उन चीनी भाईयो को भेदभाव झेलना पड़ रहा है। उनके फैक्ट्री व्यापार स्कूल बंद हो गए। लोग पलायन कर गए। बड़े दुख की बात है। उम्मीद है बाकी के बचे लोग खुशहाली से जीवन व्यतीत करेंगे।
没办法，印度政府为了转移国内的矛盾，一直去侵占中国，造成中国和印度的敌视，这样做，印度政府还可以获得欧美的支持。
@@chengloong889Being an Indian, I want to tell you that we agree with all your points but except one thing. That is that India has occupied China. And brother, I have seen your media spreading hatred towards India, why so? China always claims to indian territory and renaming the part of aruranchal pradesh .
@@chengloong889 चीन प्राचीन काल से लेकर चेन काई शेक सत्ता तक चीन भारत का घनिष्ट मित्र था लेकिन जबसे
सत्ता में माओ त्से तुंग आने के वजह चीनी विचारधारा कम्युनिस्ट हो गई।
जिन चीनियों ने कम्युनिस्ट पार्टी का विरोध किया उनको कम्युनिस्ट पार्टी के अधिकारियों पुलिस/आर्मी ने मार दिया याफीर उनकी आवाज को दबा दिया जो चीनी अमीर थे वह ताइवान में जाकर बस गए ।
आगे जाकर कम्युनिस्ट माओ त्से तुंग के नेतृत्व में तिब्बत और भारत के कैलाश मानसरोवर और अरुणाचल , लद्दाख को पर हमला किया।
तब हमारे देश के अंग्रेजो के मानसिकता/गुलामी की मानसिकता और अंग्रजो के चाटुकारा नेता पंडित जवाहरलाल नेहरु था ।
सत्ताओं के बदल जाने से विचारधारा भी बदल जाती है यह नेहरू को समझ नहीं आया ।
@@chengloong889Your Chinese president actually renamed our Indian state with Chinese name... It's your president's fault
@@Harry_2003 怎么可能，中国从不干涉其他国家内政
I so love the response from the little kid. This is the kind of world I also wish for all young people in today's fractured earth, so broken up into this group or that group, this/that religion, ethnicity, background, skin colour, etc. This boy is blessed to think and talk like that!
现在世界都是极右派当道，长大不改变再说吧。
看了这影片， 身为马来西亚华人的我， 深深感到庆幸和骄傲 ， 我的祖父母为了传承我们的华人文化做了非常非常多的事… 同时也为在印度的长辈们祈祷，祝福 … 你们为了后代， 真的做了许多感人和伟大的事。
As an Indian we love our Chinese community. I had a junior Chinese girl in my college. I never felt like I was talking to a foreigner. Please try to stay in India if you can. ❤❤❤❤
ha ha, do not pretend. even india people hate china very much .
Support them,if people like you exist than their is hope for them too ❤.
@@AchiJamir-vu3jhu naga??
@@hiji5512 na bhai Indian hu
@@AchiJamir-vu3jh ha ha Indian to h but ....tu nagaland se h na
I love the last young boy statement about how he feels in India. This is called an education makes anybody wise. And god bless all Indians living in India.
客家人真的很厉害很能吃苦也很擅长经商。我认识的大陆的客家人也是如此，感觉生活再难也无法击垮，show my respect
stay together fight back i will support 1000%
im hakka too but my parents so chicken
The little boy in the end touched my heart! He’s taking the best of both worlds, a fine young man in the making. 🥲🫰🏻
Indian myself thanks for making this didn't know we had a chinese community of hakka people, i can see the pain in their eyes, thank you for documenting this
想起幾年前在上海的印度餐館遇到一家印度華僑。餐館老闆是印度人。印度華僑到了上海也會懷念印度菜。人啊！很複雜。
India has always betrayed all the neighboring countries and India can never be a friend of China because India is a friend on the face but is a deadly poison in the heart so India can never be a friend to anyone. China, Pakistan and Bangladesh are absolute friends and absolute brothers and always come forward in each other's danger.
Wow, this child spoke the right way in a well manner without any discrimination. Hope he will do well in his future 'what a smart kid'.
好感動 好有意義的影片 海外華人都不容易 希望叔叔一切安好
Yeah, for you not for him, you don't know Indian's true colours, I'm a Indian too from northeast state but we looks different compare to other state Indian's people
I wish India can progress super fast and the remaining Chinese population in India don't go extinct. They are peace loving people like us Indians. The Indian and Chinese cultures have co-existed over 1000s of years without any problem.
Without any problem?😁
Peace loving Indian people? Lmao
@@major2707 there are no problem before british come. The history is way longer than 1962. and 1962 is infact cause by thee west.
@@ChuanMing19sadly they don't know, full black Indian's people true colour
@@Rencapricornwe don't care
Hakka spread all over the world. I am very proud of being Hakka
! Huge support from Hong Kong.
I am hakka from indonesia 🇮🇩
I am a hakka from Mauritius. If think they come from the same region Meizhou than us .
Hakka from UK
Hakka from Shenzhen here, I've got loads of relatives living in Hong Kong, sadly many of them don't speak Hakka dialect anymore.
@@Jonathan-js9co
What is hakka? is it different from Chinese?
想不到印度還有這樣的地方，一個華人社區的興起與沒落，對離開或留下的華人來說，也是一個時代的悲傷吧😢。
又是一個很棒的企劃，拍攝紀錄這些人的生活，短短18分鐘多的影片，看得有些意猶未盡🤩。
實在是不想說不好聽的話，印度真的是我這輩子去過最誇張的國家
@@apt62夸张在哪里呢？本人没去过 但是感觉那边很混乱😂
机场门口可以看到印度人在路边拉屎算吗@@tingtinglim3792
你的感觉是对的，很乱，很脏，
性侵 不尊重女人 一直都沒改變@@tingtinglim3792
印度人真的是地球上生存基因最強的人種，全世界大多國家都有中國城，但只有印度是中國人沒辦法成功紮地生根的地方，太驚人了。
俄罗斯是其中一个
India🇮🇳 Budda Sanatani culture, 10000 years ago🔺
The Chinese picked the worst Indian state to start a community in.
Should’ve made their way to Mumbai, Gujurat or the other North Eastern states.
生活在台灣的我，對華人區的刻板印象，就是繁華熱鬧，沒想到印度華人區已經變得如此荒涼，真的是長見識了🎉
那已经不是华人区了，是印度区住了几个老一代华人。
那么勤快的华人在印度都生存不下去！神仙都救不了印度😂
@@中华神龙因为当年边境战争华人被迫害纷纷逃离而已
@@mantraveling4755 那印尼沒有邊境問題為什麼華人又被同化了？那泰國也沒有邊境問題為什麼也被同化了？？越南中國還沒幹它時也開始驅趕華人，搶華人的財產了這也是中國問題？？到了今天還沒看清黑皮膚，白皮膚，黃皮膚的區別嗎？華人刻苦耐勞應該也是罪。。我們華人歷代都是勤奮賺錢，任勞任怨，最後得到一個罵名就是搶完他們的錢，再搞場政治show就可以侵吞華人的財產了
@@ken76224 所以说你无知嘛，印尼华人被同化是被强迫的，必须说印尼语改印尼姓，我都遇到过这样的印尼华人，当然也很多跑路的。泰国属于自然融入。印度这些年发展很快，不要什么华人呆不住就没希望。同样的还有韩国、越南和朝鲜，都是传统华人社区被摧毁，赶走，各自原因不同都没希望？你心情我可以理解，但不要太自以为是看得起自己了
这真的很有趣。 我是印度人（使用谷歌翻译写普通话），中文对印度人的影响是巨大的。 最通俗的可以看出印度人对中餐的喜爱（虽然不是正宗的中餐，但为了迎合我们，混合了印度风味）。 然而，我应该让中国人知道的一件事是--印度人和中国人的文化有很大不同。 我们并不是孤立地生活，也从来没有这样做过。 在你看来，印度人可能贫穷、肮脏或粗鲁，但我们绝对不喜欢那些喜欢生活在“飞地”或试图通过保守自己来“保护自己的文化”的人。 印度人在这方面是外向的，总是相信混合。 因此，每个说“无论走到哪里，我们都应该保留中国价值观”的人，抱歉，这在印度行不通，因为你必须将中国价值观与流行的印度价值观结合起来。 否则，印度不是中国人适合来的地方。 你不能像生活在马来西亚或新加坡那样生活在这里，华人和马来人是两个截然不同的东西。 如果你住在印度的任何地方，你的语言、你的食物、你的着装和你的文化都必然会受到印度的影响--简单明了。
我向所有中国人致以最深切的敬意。 但到了印度，一定要和当地人交谈，融入其中，欣赏一切，如果你不喜欢什么，用礼貌的语气表达你的意见，而不是炫耀中国沙文主义。 将中国文化尊重地给予我们，并收回印度文化以融合成新的东西。 印度对你来说永远不会是中国，但印度可以是一个给你一个新的世界观的地方，而不是你习惯的世界观，而且它可以非常好（尽管这个国家有贫穷或非同质的民族性质，相信 我对此）。 合十礼。
@@user-jf9mj9ey9p 每個國家，包括中國，都有自豪感。 它應該對自己作為一個國家和文明單位的實力感到自豪。
不用擔心印度。 自從印度河流域文明誕生以來，我們的社會已經非常不同，實際上與中國完全相反。 印度河流域文明時期，有三大種族：非洲原住民（現今僅存在於安達曼群島）、伊朗西部的德拉威人（今印度南部）和百越人（今印度東北部）印度以及印度東部）。 與一直是單一民族社會的中國不同，印度自古以來就是多元文化的。 這使得我們的發展道路比中國更複雜，但不用擔心。 我們將書寫自己的命運，閃耀自己的時代。 作為舊世界最後一個倖存的連續文明，沒有被伊斯蘭化或受到資本主義或共產主義等西方政治意識形態的污染（印度都不是），我們知道我們的前進方向，我們有希望。 南無阿彌陀佛。 祝你有美好的一天。
印度鼓吹大印度教主义😮
印度人基本上还是排外的。
@@李大人-m7p 不。 印度不提倡一種宗教。 然而，印度確實主張將本土信仰和身分置於外國信仰和身分之上。 印度的認同在過去曾多次被試圖阻礙，這使得他們極度保護自己的本土文明製度，包括印度教、印度語言、印度文化習慣和印度生活方式
@@tommylee6161 他們是保護性的，而不是仇外的。 在過去的 1000 年裡，他們一直受到阿富汗部落、突厥蒙古人和歐洲人的入侵。 另外，印度的國家分裂比中國和台灣之間的分裂嚴重得多。 對他們公平一點。 還有，當年日本侵略中國的時候，你們也產生了反日情緒，這種情緒在今年的亞運會上還可以看到。 所以這不只是印度的事情，你們中國人也是這樣。 但你更擅長說謊，並向別人隱藏你的感受，而我們印度人則不然。 我們會說實話。 我們的國徽還寫著：「真理永遠獲勝」。
I am a South Indian, in my village many people migrated to USA for better life style. Same way Chinese are doing from theirs hime land . There is no discrimination, only for High standard living life style
No discrimination, insultation and threatening? Are you sure?
Yes Chinese people migrated to India for a better life❤ India is the best country in the world❤ India colonized the whole world 😢that’s why the whole world speak Hindi and Tamil
Bro as Indian im learning lot about communities who are living in India recently got to know Africans were living in India and now suddenly after watching your video got to know Chinese brothers are also living in India Never expected and thank you for making this video dont know why but I felt sad watching video.
很高兴看到这样的视频,我老婆也是客家人,而且住在客家最大积聚地:广东梅州,和她结婚才知道原来华人还有客家人这个群体,然后在全世界还分布这么广,每个国家都可以看到客家人的身影,而且都取得了非常大的成就,像李光耀,英拉兄妹,真是大开眼界,希望看到更多华人群体在国外的视频
客家人也分布在中国大陆各地，感觉每个省都有客家人的存在，真是血里带风的族群，飘摇不定，又落地生根。
在外国的客家人基本都是这里出去的
Another fun fact, there is a small Chinese community in Assam, in the northeast of India. They mainly came due to the tea industry. Now, they too have mostly vanished, few remain but they number in the 50s...
It's sad 😢
Source for 50s they are even more then 300s in South India in Mumbai and in northeast also much more
they are thousands Assamese Chinese lives and they are Thousands more then in kolkata
我是印尼华侨第四代客家人，我祖父辈来到印尼也是先建华校可惜当时排华被烧毁，华社一直被当地势力打压，但随着文明社会的发展也有很多华人子孙崛起让我们有机会学中文留住华夏文化，我们第四代也有很大部分人一直移民往政治比较稳定的国家发展，偶然刷到这个视频真心为海外华人骄傲，辛苦了❤
sungguh perjuangan hidup yg menyedihkan...
华人去哪里都是先赚钱，然后建学校。非常佩服老一辈的海外华侨华人。
教育很重要
几千年的传统，文字不灭，文明永存。
重视教育，即使再穷，就算饿死 ，也要读书的说法。
最後孩子的回答很好，蒲公英的種子不管飛到何處，都要努力紮下根
谢谢，我其实是个小孩子，哈哈
谢谢，我其实是个小孩子，哈哈
@@azart2gaming380你是餐厅老板儿子吗？很棒，以后有机会的话来中国看看
@@nk5942 是的，我是餐馆老板的儿子！
@@azart2gaming380哇。你好棒。还会写中文？
I see many Indians in China, most are teachers and they are so highly respected there. In fact, Chinese people actually treat Indians better than their own, a stark contrast to the discrimination and hate crimes experienced by Chinese in India. Indians in China will never have to worry about safety or hate crimes.
ikr, my uncle teaches yoga there and he tells us about it but please give India a chance as India is still largely uneducated and uncivil society due to a major part of it being historically cut from society i.e. the ones that were outcasts. however bad it sounds to an Indian but is a truth
@@कार्तिकेय-ढ8मI think one of the main reasons for the difference is the news media in India constantly pushes anti-China news that stir up resentment but on the other hand, Chinese media don't like to push hate on any group of people
Generalization is a very bad thing, my friend. Just because you heard some Chinese people being discriminated in India doesn't mean every Chinese is being discriminated against in India. And please, just please stop being on a moral high ground as if there are no vices of ill-treatment against other races in China. There have been a lot of footage of African community being discriminated against in Guangzhou in China. Also Chinese call us Indians using a very vile, racist word called 阿三. That doesn't mean everyone is a bad apple. So that is why please don't generalize people especially considering yourself from a moral high ground.
@@ArghyadeepPal I never heard of the word 阿三. There is no such word or saying in Chinese and I just confirmed with a few Chinese people. I'm not sure what kind of propaganda media you read that from. Also the Africans being mistreated videos were completely taken out of context or cherry picked. Many of those videos of Chinese mistreating Africans in China were actually debunked including by French fact check website that despite it being anti-China bias outlet. For example, a video that happened years ago in Malaysia where a Black person robbing a store were beaten up by Malaysians were propagated on Western media as an African student getting beaten up by a group of Chinese. Another video showed Chinese restaurant owners fighting against black diners, which was actually under self defense and happened in New York, not in China. Bro, understand what you see in the media is gov funded propaganda. Talk to "real" people who actually been there with "real" experiences.
@@ArghyadeepPal You can learn about the origin of this nickname. Of course, most Chinese people later knew that “阿三” came from the comedy movie "Westward Journey"（大话西游）
I don’t know why as Malaysian Chinese I feel like crying watching this and I m just so grateful for what our ancestors (regardless Chinese, Malay or Indian) have done for Malaysia 🇲🇾 and we still get to learn our own language and history and culture super thankful esp after knowing what most Chineses experienced in this region 🙏🏻
I love the kid at the end. Everyone born in India is Indian. Full stop. I have had Indian Chinese classmates and they are as Indian as I am.
看到影片蠻感動的，13年到16年我在印度馬德拉斯讀書，那個時候我們班有一個第四代還是第幾代的印度華裔，他已經不怎麼會說中文了，他媽媽聽到他有中國同學就很高興請我們去家裡作客。我那個時候覺得他們是很孤獨的，馬德拉斯的華人少之又少，不像影片中有個華人社區。我認識的另外一家華人也是客家人，也是把孩子送去美國讀書了，這幾年斷了聯繫，不知道有沒有一家人都移民走
哇，你读书也去的好远
@@woshisuo 哈哈哈，很神奇的經歷
Wow how was madras ?
你是哪里人？怎么跑印度去读书呢？跑好远😂
@@ޓއއއ-ޑ7ބ 印度是英聯邦國家，它的畢業證在國外的認可率很高的，我當年是為了給去歐洲讀研究生做準備。
Love for that kid. Not just Chinese, this migration is happening in every community from kolkata.
Kolkata is becoming an old-age home.
it sounds like 90s of china
Very good propaganda.
Tons of pppl from bimaru states are coming here. 😂
Kolkata was good back then, don't know what happened
I am an indian chinese. From tangra. Kolkata, India.
And i identify myself as an indian. A proud Indian.
Many from my community left for abroad. Its their choice.
Its a trend generally seen in India. To move abroad due to high population and competition. Statistically its the same in China.
Its bullshit and Has nothing to do with India not doing well or not supporting our community.
Its not everyone else’s fault if the community does not open up. It likes to be within itself. Shying away. Always.
In ancient time Chinese used to visit in indian universities for studying we had strong bond and connection but now this bond is detached ,today tibbet people they love india china forcefully occupied our land ,and they also targeting noth eastern Indian states ,some people failed to adopt the Indian culture failed to adopt the lifestyle of India so what should we do ,they want better lifestyle that's why they leaving india ,,,
@@kmt55indan lifestyle sh1tting on streets, poverty, corruption, pollution, over population ofc they will leave for other countries.
Good actor. Deserve an Oscar
They simply don't care about c0w dung grape capital of the world.
Indian Chinese 😂😂😂
我哪有想到，除了我们印尼华人之外，世上还有其他海外华人正面对着跟我们几乎相似的困难。Life is not always that easy. Love from Indonesia.
我也是印尼华人，在这里的生活不错。但是我跟你同意，有时候对海外华人生活不容易。
Wah.... 你们这些印尼华人懂得写华语。是怎么学的？
我估计你们是比较年轻一辈的吧？
Love from Malaysia.
@@ableoswimmingpond 我们在非洲也是受到歧视待遇，但是随着这些年中国国力的增强，尤其是中美贸易战以来，得到了更多尊重。
@@s._3560 家大业大的都分裂。少数族群则必须抱团才能存活。这是必然的，不只是华人，这是人类的天性。
困难的就回中国，不困难的就待下去。想拿回中国国籍就去拿台湾籍然后等统一。😂
18:34 弟弟回答得好好，出乎意料之外。
我也是客家人，當年祖先選擇來南洋落腳，現在是馬來西亞第三代華人。馬來西亞是個好地方，只是種族議題讓政客有機可乘，攪爛一鍋好粥，政治議題成了這個國家最大得敗筆，可惜可惜。
Thank you! I’m the little brother in the end haha
大馬華人以前有很多人來台灣讀書,但這幾年來的比較少了,都去中國了
@@azart2gaming380 Halo little brother you really did a good job by answering the question well. Good mindset. Wish you the best.
@@junxianli6976 馬來西亞有很多親中的人，但有多少人去中國唸書這我不確定
@@Virgo_823 以前有和來台念書的人聊過,福利不錯,也知道一些大馬華人的處境,但台灣後來取消了很多優惠,加上中國搶人,很多人就轉往中國了,
唐人散布全世界，都有艱辛打拼的傳統，都有出色成功的表現。謝謝小編非常不錯的制作👍
I’m sorry for what you guys have gone through. In India, people between states don’t get well together and are being called “outsiders” in our own country.
Good
確實，客家人遍部全球，能吃苦耐勞生意頭腦很好！
This young Chinese boy (son of the owner at this Chinese restaurant) gave a very intelligent politically correct answer when he was asked if he was Chinese or Indian. Smart boy!
Look man a child's thoughts are pure. When he grows he won't have the same perspective because of experiences accumulated.
The answer that the boy gave at the end is actually very similar to the pledge that indian school students learn everyday, Most people including many indians dont know indian is not an ethnicity it is a nationality anyone with indian citizenship is indian reagrdless of ethinicity we are all equal infront of the law but unfornutely past governments have been unfair to many communities including this one . Sad to see this community decline.
Bro past govts have been unfair. Past govts are the reasons so many communities are still living together. The current govt only speaks for one community. Thats too its fake.
almost entire chinese assamese community was deported in 1962 war by indian occupation
tell that to the bhaiyyas that rule the country
The Christians are trying to flee India too as they don't feel safe in India especially after Modi.
The same is true of Christians in India. They are trying to flee India especially after Modi and the BJP RSS.. They don't feel safe in India anymore! The Parsis have left, the Jews have left. Always talk about a religious State with the majority religion and nonsense talk like that from Bharkts. No one is happy any more. Modi has destroyed the feeling of the country with his BJP RSS!
The fact that the last kid said, "We don't differentiate; we are all equal; we are all brothers and sisters," is the perfect teaching.
Thank you for making this video. I was there in 2007 visiting someone who grew up in Kolkata, she took me to the top of the school during the Chinese New Year festival. A lot of fond memories of the people and its local cuisine. I still can't find anywhere that makes fish balls the way they did over in Tangra.
In fact, Chinese migration to India's southern parts is even older than their migration to Singapore. I believe the official timeframe is in the 18th century but it may have been even earlier, during the Ming Dynasty when trade between China and Calcutta flourished
Nah it's during Chinese civil war ! Chinese ppl are still in my state i known many of them !
Many of indians ? Really not 😂 even 0.1 % ppl of india migrated ! Haha ! Ppl who migrate now they just want more money ! If you want to live in atriocatic Chinese government ! You can !
Mao zedon killed 20 million Chinese lol ! Started war against india ! Whereas india praised them as brothers given veto power and permanent sit in UNSC ! Lol ! Snakes
You are us. We are you. Please do not leave. This is your motherland. With love and respect - from Ṭaṅgra.
I loved the way the child spoke at the end about unity and love, about no one is different. ❤❤❤❤
This really made me emotional I hope main land Indians stop being ignorant and give some respect to them
(Prayers from a north-east Indian )
Btw there is also a Chinese settlement in a place called Makum in Tinsukia district of Assam. It also used to be a China Town.
@@o0...957 thats true.
Bruh, we are unity in diversity. We will ensure everyone gets respect. (Ignore the ignorants )
Who is ignorant and don't respect them?? Didn't you saw whole video the problem there was poor lifestyle in India not disrespect. Indians don't hate chinese and respect them same as other Indians.
@priyankakumarisingh4511 only the Indian media and trolls dont respect them
我是缅甸华人，这边的 很多 华人学校 学生也慢慢 变少，华人区里的都是 老人，年轻人 都出去了，真希望 对华人多一些公平，少一些歧视
Oh, so sorry to hear. Yes I agree I don't know why Chinese are always so hard working, so successful and so many countries are bad to us.
I'm aussie Chinese, more and more Chinese come here. The good thing is the government are not directly against us. If someone tries to directly discriminate our kids, they will surely hear from me. I will not let anyone be rude to my kid, white or brown. I'm a well educated rich Chinese (my grandad went to Malaysia and my dads siblings studied in UK and Canada. Most families settled in Aus), my kids are just as good as any other Aussies.
We need to stand up. No more running away from country to country.
能否移民回中國？
@@dordorfromhk-hj5vo很难的，中国移民基本上s级的了
@@dordorfromhk-hj5vo以前教员让他们自己选择的，他们选择了缅甸，抛弃了穷苦的大陆。那现在我们三四代人拼了命努力把国内生活变得这么好，他们想回来了，我们凭什么惯着？既然选择了缅甸，那就好好融入当地，好好建设他们自己选的地方。
As a Filipino-Chinese-Japanese-East Indian-Spanish-Canadian I would recommend for Chinese Indians to Immigrate Malaysia , Singapore , The Philippines ( Where I was born ) , Canada ( Where I live ) , USA since there are many diverse ethnicities. in those countries
Being a Tibetan I feel sad to see them vanished.
They r hardworking Chinese not CCP 😢
Actually India is not a bad place. My friends enjoy their tours there. I imagine the elderly ppl finding it a great place to retire. My grandpa came from China too. Now we are settled happily in Singapore. To me, home is where the heart is. ❤️
i'm pretty sure they would much rather be with their kids in canada or wherever they've immigrated to, but the reality is they're old and they will only be an extra mouth to feed. whereas if they stay behind in India their kids can send a little bit of CAD home and it'd be considered enough for a months worth of expenses in india.
I beg to differ. With a hostile government, it is difficult to stay. The place is becoming decadent and the local council make no effort to repair them. You don’t see any future. There is minimal development. Unlike you the lucky one, to find a job here is very tough.
@@cfyong1838, are you Chinese in India? Try to leave asap. Go anywhere, try Malaysia; Taiwan; China if you don't have enough to go US Canada Aus.
My personal experience is Indians are very cunning... we are like cows and horse work hard to earn money. My grandparents call them snakes, plotting looking for free food, taking more than what they work for.
I would be worry to live in a snake and worm hole when we are cows and horses. 🥺🥺 get out of there.
By the way; what is the government doing to Chinese there?
@@cfyong1838Indians are not hostile to Chinese and it's nationals and only the border problems other than trade and everything goes well
@@sriganesan8237 that’s good. Tq
很開心最後小朋友的觀點，今天他如果在印度，就應該認同那片土地，而不是被種族所綁架，正如他說的，他和其他族裔的印度人，就是兄弟姊妹的關係
也要其他族裔把他当兄弟姐妹才行。看看印度各种的宗教冲突，小朋友的想法只是个梦想
There is no conflict, there is freedom of voice, if the country is communist and prohibit any negative news about it's country than it can control the population. The population is big and so much of freedom for people
@@cocoyu5537, yes he treats others like bro and sis. Others treat him like a lamb to be consumed.
他是一厢情愿罢了
If you want to live in atriocatic Chinese government ! You can !
Mao zedon killed 20 million Chinese lol ! Started war against india ! Whereas india praised them as brothers given veto power and permanent sit in UNSC ! Lol ! Snakes
Salute those Chinese who live in India till today, I'm a Malaysian by birth and I will never choose India to emigrate
no one begging you to come
Please don't come here and increase our population even more!
Even Indian people don't choose India when they get rich or get the chance to move , they move abroad and live happily
@@adventuretime4451LoL 😂 believe like this
@@sriganesan8237 maybe you poor
It's always the people who face the hardships due to country's relationship with other countries. I hope that we and our future generations together could build an environment that's enriching for not only our community but for people from other communities and countries. Thank you for making this video and spreading awareness about the chineses in india.
It is very sad that hakka Chinese community suffered alots difficulty but if we see the context of west Bengal state also suffered lots of riot and govt conflicts lot of things .. which is indescribable but now slowly slowly things are changing..maybe everything will be good one day. And i also hope indian chinese community condition will be improved and best wishes for them whom settle in abroad i wish aap hamesha khush rhe😊😊
但凡有去過印度這國家都不可能覺得他們是會成為超級大國的。內部分裂太巨大，加上烙印在骨子裡的種姓制度，很難全民一起前進。
种姓制度的根源是印度教，遗憾的是，印度人不承认这一点。只要印度教存在一天，种姓制度无法根除，法律，只能管到表面上的东西。
越是自诩文明古国，等级观念会越严重，百姓们以文明古国为荣，他们没想到这正是他们思想上的枷锁。
比共產黨統治中國還要好。
你这话只对了一半，美国发展得快也是因为这一点，没有历史的包袱，但是看东亚的发展，说明文明还是有优劣之分的，儒家文化的国家重视教育，百姓道德感强、遵守纪律，勤俭节约，比较大的缺点是太过封闭，只要克服这个缺点就能发展得不错。儒家文化既培养伪君子，也培养了很多真君子，真君子会努力改善底层人民的生活水平，这也是印度所欠缺的，他们的聪明人只考虑自己。@@林林-i4u1n
语言都统一不了的国家确实难搞。。。。。
Thank you very much for covering this :)
While some of us in India are aware of ethnic minorities like the Chinese community in West Bengal, we rarely, if ever, heard their stories.
The realities this community faces is real and rampant.
Its a shame to see this decline of the community...
我是广东梅县的，影片里面的客家话听起来都像是梅县音 很亲切❤ 感谢Jimmy的视频 让我看到了客家华侨在印度的生活。 很喜欢的你的视频！
太棒了！看完视频后你有什么想法和感受？🙂
In Canada, it’s not easy to prosper as well. Cost of living is high. Many Hakka Chinese open restaurants to promote the Hakka food, but that is a difficult business too.
Good video and well edited. Thanks for sharing with all of us former or current Hakka Chinese who used to live in Calcutta. As a former Chinese who lived here 50 years ago ( and all guests in the video were my Peimay schools mates too) I would say who stayed back are also the lucky ones too they enjoy easy life in India as opposed to most of us that left India, we have a hard time to adjust the new country and blend in with the local population just like our previous ancestors who settled down here 100 years ago. Basically one has to work hard and will be rewarded, its my advice,no hard feeling. I am so amazed you have a solid guts like a rhino to visit India. And last but not least the little boy at the end of video is the great grandson of Mr. Chen who was a great supporter of KMT Taiwanese government, also a well respected local Chinese citizen, thank you.
Why don't the Chinese go home to Taiwan or mainland China or Hong Kong or Macau but instead to go godforsaken places like Canada or Australia?
I am reseaching on the history of the overseas Hakka people and had been to your place of birth, Calcutta, twice. I would very much appreciate it if your goodselves could advise me as to the credibility of the book "the deoli wallahs" (the true story of the 1962 Chinese-Indian internment) written by Joy Ma and Dilip D'Souza, publiced in February 2020.
When I was in Calcutta, I tried to my best to get first hand information from those who still live there, but, perhaps due to the "circumstances", I was only able to obtain "some" information, nothing much though. Your assustance would be greatly appreciated.
For your info, I travelled to Singkawang, Indonesia (great Overseas Hakka city), Sabah (where even the natives speak Hakka language) and Sarawak (closely knitted) , Malaysia, Thailand (some settlements with majority Hakka decentants), Burma (Myanmar) where there are still a great number of Hakka decentants living there, Tahiti and obviously, Mauritius, Reunion and Madagascar.
Appreciate your assistance in this matter, if you could and with continuing best wishes, all the best.
For Gods sake stop stereotyping India, Calcutta is the poorest part of India apart from Delhi, Varanasi
Overall India as a country is very diverse with a lot of nice places, if the Chinese setlled in Southern India instead of Calcutta their lives would have been far better
India is an asian powerhouse economy where poverty is rapidly decreasing and is at 18% in 2022 according to United Nations data
India is a G20 member good bye!said India does not have indoor plumbing? Stop dreaming and living in a paradise, as a Jewish Persian I would it was you barbaric brits who destroyed India along with Muslims, ancient India was admired by Greeks
I am a Zoroastrian Parsi living in India whose ancestors had migrated to India 1500 years back for taking shelter when the Muslims invaded Persian Empire and defeated the Sasannians who were the last of our great ancestors that had made Persia as one of the most prosperous empires and ancient civilizations. We Parsis have always been grateful to India for the kindness they showed us and we cannot tolerate anyone blindly insulting our country because we Parsis have also become Indians. Not only us but even Persian nationalists in Iran who hate the barbaric Islamic regime have admiration for India because we and Indians both belong to ancient civilizations. While it is true that India has many problems but that does not mean whatever you say is true. Infact your ideas about India are not only rubbish and filled with fantastic but you are a racist. Yes you are completely a cruel racist who is displaying absolute racism towards India. Listen, people like you are no more different than those white supremacist groups or the far right zionists infact you are 100000 times worse than them. You are basically blindly brainwashed by Chinese communist propaganda and therefore you cannot accept the fact that India is progressing, you believe in fake conspiracy theories and the fact that Russia is a great superpower where in reality the villages in the interior parts of Russia have huge problems with indoor plumbing, defecation outdoors is far common
I am Tibetan.
@@wyliamulayye7534There were Hakka communities in the Caribbean, also. I was born & raised in Jamaica, but now live in the US. Most of the Jamaican Hakkas moved to Toronto or to Florida.
Such a wise boy! His closing speech is wow. We are all humans and brothers and sisters regardless of where we are from, what colour our skin is.
Back in the early 80's we lived in Calcutta and frequented Tangra alot. Very sad to see, my parents had a few Chinese friends and we spent alot ot time with them. Lots of reasons to leave, economics, racism, lack of opportunity. good video.
14:13 I am Singaporean Chinese. I encourage this young man to come to Singapore to live and work. It is very easy for Indian nationals to get work permit in Singapore due to the CECA Agreement with India. We have a population of 75% Chinese and 10% Indian. You will adapt easily in Singapore. English is the lingua franca here. And Tamil (southern India language) is an official language. Ancestors of Chinese in Singapore came from Southern Chinese provinces. So we have Hakka Chinese too, from Fujian and Guangdong provinces. They settled here 100 years ago. Also the little boy at the tail end of the video, come Singapore to study. 😊 i went to New Delhi, Agra, Jaipur and Mumbai in 2011, free and easy. I was never harmed. It was fun. Egg Biryani and jai, the tea, was delicious. Love India, and will be back next time, to the South.
What attitude Singapore treats towards mainland Chinese? I am Chinese from mainland China. Southern anhui province. Kinda curious about it.
@@saisirvous7363 We treat mainland Chinese with respect. And we talk, play and eat with them everyday. We get along well.
You should also visit the Northeast next time you come to India.
@@o0...957 I always watch Bollywood. I intend to learn Hindi. Beautiful language. Yes, more places I want to visit in Bharat. Jai Hind!
@@saisirvous7363我高中宿舍上铺就博士移民新加坡了。他是说也就是社会管理严格一些，其他还是很好的。
主要是护照也好用，要去哪里玩也很容易。
他说最大的区别是：小孩读书太卷了，比国内还卷。😂😂
看了这个影片觉得我们在马来西亚的华侨很幸福
馬來西亞的是华裔,非华侨.
@@weifuanchoy7905 随便啦。在马拉西亚字词如:华侨，华裔，华人，唐人,等，都是指为有华侨祖籍的大马国民。会不会说中文是次要，重点是农历新年与红包有来往。
@@weifuanchoy7905 国籍是政治上的东西，虽然今天他们马来西亚华人没有中国国籍但可能明天政策一变动就有了，反正在我看来任何讲中文遵从中华文化的人都是自己人，无论他有没有中港台政府发的护照。
馬來西亞本來就是華僑，遲早要回中國落地生根，記得你們的祖，不要數典忘祖
好喜歡弟弟最後講的那些話。 很感動
Hi ! I'm from Northeast India and i have met many Chinese Friends also when I was in North India while doing my graduation. They are really nice and we have many things in common yes it's true. I have many friends from all around the world. Met some friends through online have met some in different states of India some are from my university Japan, China, Philippine, Thailand, Ukraine, Usa ..Other countries. WE HAVE One thing in common HUMANITY. We want to stay peacefully No matter in which country which state which place we are.
2014年我到過這加爾各答的China Town。還在那裏和一位客家老鄉一起吃雲吞麵。是中國人的印度徒弟開的。
這唐人街是我見過最破落的。印度政府對華人的迫害，可見一斑。
中印戰爭，關係惡化導致的，或許有其他原因
@@ZhiziKnowHow 迫害華人需要戰爭嗎？多用腦想想吧！世界各地都有華人，華人刻苦耐勞節儉存錢，到最後一句你們華人搶了他們的錢就開始打壓華人，侵吞華人財產！世界各國經常發生的事！
@@ZhiziKnowHow 别把印度想像的那么善良，印度只是实力不行，但是对于周边小国，印度一直都在蚕食他们。你可以把印度人理解为台湾的塔绿班，他们无知自大，就算是美国是印度的邻居，印度人也一样看不起美国人，也一样会和美国发生战争。军事排名在印度人的眼里顺序是俄罗斯第一，美国第二，印度第三....
@@台灣省省長蔡包子 stop lying , it's the opposite . It's illegal immigrants from Bangladesh and neighbouring countries that have encroached India , not the other way around . India is in a difficult spot and has to stay neutral for Russia becuz they were never against us , unlike US they are the two faced monsters who we should be careful of . As for the Indian Chinese people it's sad they had to leave , I consider all of them as my family and my ancestors were Chinese as well . But it's really the Indian people who are at fault and Govt for supporting them . And trust me it's American and western people who look down on india , not the other way around .
@@ZhiziKnowHow印度周边的小国都要被他吞完了，62年收拾它是忍无可忍。
之前去跟一群客家人在培梅中学里聊天，有一个奶奶跟着我们聊了一下午，到晚上很舍不得我们离开，跟着我们到大路上打车，希望她还好！
As a person who grew up in that locality, I feel happy that there has finally been some coverage provided on the situation of the Chinese living there. Although I would disagree with some of the views expressed in the video, it is a fact that majority of the people there think like that.
i'm a Chinese-Indonesian and thank you for actually sharing this.. i can't believe how relatable the situation is with us to some extend
I m nepali indian and I from a very small town named kalimpong there were many many Chinese they had leather shoe shops and I had many class mates but they slowly migrated to Australia 🇦🇺 Canada 🇨🇦... I think now there are 2 family lest that too I m not sure all my Chinese friends were fluent in nepali but Chinese guys from tengra Calcutta were good in hindi.
我認識一個從印度來台灣結婚定居的華人..他說他們以前在印度算有錢人！不過現在來台灣跟太太一起開餐廳很不錯！
影片最後餐館老闆的兒子說的那段話是理想面(烏托邦)，但是印度現實面並不是這樣子的~難怪老闆要趕快讓兒子們趕快去國外留學!!!!
那段话是"应该"这个样子，但显然并不是"现实就是这个样子"。尤其是莫迪上台后推动的印度民族主义，连本土印度少数族群都受歧视，遑论华人了。
这么熟练的背诵，不过脑的脱口而出，绝对是洗脑后的产物
还小嘛，所以理想主义一点也能理解
@@zebraimage plz tell your step dad xi zingpink 😂
@@zhipeichen It's just indoctrination from school and society. There's no critical thinking if you haven't lived long enough to think and to experience the world.
The boy gave a very nice answer. Good boy, and I wish him well.
当地华人的英语都带着印度腔，说话摇头的神态也相似。
最后的华人餐厅生意火红，还算是一个比较 light-hearted 的结尾。
यह सब गलतफैमी के कारण हो रहा है