I know this piece and learned how to play it. This performance is breathtaking. The control, pace and phrasing are marvelous. The ear shattering ovation at the end was well deserved. I applauded too!! Bravissimo!!
i think i should stop complaining that i have small hands (at least a can reach an solid octave). this lady can barely reach an octave but still play this piece really well. i really want to see her shine in the future.
A wonderful performance, very Chopin tone, also catching the Polish sentiments. It was challenging for her to play it without slips. But she demonstrated that she actually mastered the piece!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This is a very insightful and beautiful performance of what may be Chopin's most interpretively and technically challenging solo work. Wishing every succeaas for this budding, talented young artist.
BRAVO! I loved it. Wonderful playing. If anything the faster parts are bit faster than the music properly demands, but aside from a couple of very minor flubs towards the end this is phenomenally good playing. It is NOT, however, on the same level as Kate Liu's superlative rendition, which I believe is the best I have ever heard in more than sixty years of piano study, performance and itintense listening to all the greats -- and to hundreds of highly gifted students as well.
I really like this. It's played with a lot of feeling, but none of the ridiculous simulated ecstasy that make so many pianists unwatchable. (Guess where that comes from!) This performance is all about the music. Also, it's rather encouraging to see a pianist with relatively small hands make such a fine job of this ballade. :)
Totally agree. Kate Liu or Eric Lu are the perfect example of "weird faces" in order to simulate "how they feel the piece". Music is sound and feelings. If you want to transmite feelings to your audience with your facial expressions maybe theatre is better suited for you. If I had to say something negative about Miss Nakagawa's rendition is that maybe she rushed tempo too much in some passages, but nothing too disturbing. Beautiful performance.
I totally agree, and it is indeed very inspiring, even educational for me, since I have small hands too. I learn a lot just by watching the way she uses her hands and arms. A very healthy and natural technique that produces a rounded, golden sound.
Yeah, while some of the pianists are being pretentious, I think for a lot of others, they are simply 'feeling the notes'. If I had to give one criticism of this particular performance, it would be that I think she hit a few wrong keys along the way. I thought the tempo was fine though. Other then those tiny imperfections, I'd say it was a good performance.
I can understand why pianist jump around and stuff (lang lang) when they have their own show/concert. It makes the concert atmosphere a lot more “fun” idk. However in a competitive competition when judges judge you on only your playing it’s in a way “unnecessary”
Say that again after you attended and watched a recital and make sure to describe what YOU saw from their faces while being seated. You can only say this because YOU ARE WATCHING from TH-cam. If you are too concerned about their faces, PROBABLY you want to watch a play instead, not LISTEN to a recital?
You could see she was disappointed. But I agree, it's my favorite of interpretations. People tend to take dynamics and "rubato" to the extreme, but she told a more coherent story; it felt easier on the mind to connect the piece together.
When a pianist makes mistakes or uses strange phrasing ... sometimes it's Wonderful, Fantastic... Listen to Genius Hoffmann th-cam.com/video/fqPN4gXy834/w-d-xo.html (miracle begins from about 3,00 mn ... To the end)
Spoken like a true youtube expert... I’d take a good musical interpretation with a few mistakes over a dull so-called perfect playing, that’s actually wayyy more frustrating. Mistakes are what makes us human, nothing wrong with that.
I know this piece and learned how to play it. This performance is breathtaking. The control, pace and phrasing are marvelous. The ear shattering ovation at the end was well deserved. I applauded too!! Bravissimo!!
I always admire and watch this particular interpretation of Chopin's Ballad's in F minor
i think i should stop complaining that i have small hands (at least a can reach an solid octave). this lady can barely reach an octave but still play this piece really well. i really want to see her shine in the future.
Piękno muzyki Fryderyka Chopina to fenomen graniczący z cudem ❤️
A wonderful performance, very Chopin tone, also catching the Polish sentiments. It was challenging for her to play it without slips. But she demonstrated that she actually mastered the piece!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
She's so damn beautiful, a lovely talent coupled with true beauty.
Great performance. And holy shit, her hands are tiny. Despite that (it's a deterrence), what a wonderful rendition of Chopin's masterpiece.
これまで聴いたショパンのバラード4番の中でアシュケナージさんとあなたの演奏が僕の中でベストです
本当に素晴らしい！生で聴きたいです！
This is a very insightful and beautiful performance of what may be Chopin's most interpretively and technically challenging solo work. Wishing every succeaas for this budding, talented young artist.
Completely agree. She maintained the lyrical flow throughout the piece, combining pathos with power when needed. Just wonderful.
It is a perfect performance. You care about a tempo, and you play a piano calmly and elegantly. It is my favorite performance.(from Osaka, Japan)
9:10 is pure mistakes which is sad.
@@ilovemycatrussell9298 Yeah that was sad, she must've gotten tired or nervous by the end.
Pleeeeeeeeease remove the ad or commercial break in such a beautiful ballade.
So lovely !
BRAVO! I loved it. Wonderful playing. If anything the faster parts are bit faster than the music properly demands, but aside from a couple of very minor flubs towards the end this is phenomenally good playing. It is NOT, however, on the same level as Kate Liu's superlative rendition, which I believe is the best I have ever heard in more than sixty years of piano study, performance and itintense listening to all the greats -- and to hundreds of highly gifted students as well.
今この曲ひかせてもらってるんですが、こんなに上手になれるまで頑張りたいです！
Lovely!
I really like this. It's played with a lot of feeling, but none of the ridiculous simulated ecstasy that make so many pianists unwatchable. (Guess where that comes from!) This performance is all about the music. Also, it's rather encouraging to see a pianist with relatively small hands make such a fine job of this ballade. :)
Totally agree. Kate Liu or Eric Lu are the perfect example of "weird faces" in order to simulate "how they feel the piece". Music is sound and feelings. If you want to transmite feelings to your audience with your facial expressions maybe theatre is better suited for you.
If I had to say something negative about Miss Nakagawa's rendition is that maybe she rushed tempo too much in some passages, but nothing too disturbing.
Beautiful performance.
I totally agree, and it is indeed very inspiring, even educational for me, since I have small hands too. I learn a lot just by watching the way she uses her hands and arms. A very healthy and natural technique that produces a rounded, golden sound.
Yeah, while some of the pianists are being pretentious, I think for a lot of others, they are simply 'feeling the notes'. If I had to give one criticism of this particular performance, it would be that I think she hit a few wrong keys along the way. I thought the tempo was fine though. Other then those tiny imperfections, I'd say it was a good performance.
I can understand why pianist jump around and stuff (lang lang) when they have their own show/concert. It makes the concert atmosphere a lot more “fun” idk. However in a competitive competition when judges judge you on only your playing it’s in a way “unnecessary”
Say that again after you attended and watched a recital and make sure to describe what YOU saw from their faces while being seated. You can only say this because YOU ARE WATCHING from TH-cam. If you are too concerned about their faces, PROBABLY you want to watch a play instead, not LISTEN to a recital?
頑張ってください。応援しています。
she leads me on a journey and I follow with my eyes closed
LOVE IT!
このレベルでも次に進めないなんてピアノは本当に難しいんだね。
Really nice job. Absolutely inspiring.
world class
女性用に鍵盤の幅が狭いピアノがあってもいい。
小さな手でよく弾けるなと感心します。
子供用も欲しいなと思います。ヴァイオリンは幼児用があるのに、ピアノは幼児でもいきなり大人と同じ楽器
今のところ、日本人の演奏では中川さんのこの時のバラ４が最も好み。
本当に素晴らしい♪
何回も聴いています♬
いつかバラ4弾けるようになりたい(^O^)／
it's magic
ほんとけど、中川さんてお嬢様度世界一だと思う。
이뿌당
優美で上手い ！
Magnificent!
中川さんのピアノ品があって好きです。
she plays very cute and passionated.
うますぎだろ…
While a really great interpretation, no doubt she did not pass this round due to the inaccuracies. A real shame considering the intent was there
You could see she was disappointed. But I agree, it's my favorite of interpretations. People tend to take dynamics and "rubato" to the extreme, but she told a more coherent story; it felt easier on the mind to connect the piece together.
ein Traum wird wahr
Fantastic ! Better than K.Liu. Bravo pour la coda !
When a pianist makes mistakes or uses strange phrasing ... sometimes it's Wonderful, Fantastic... Listen to Genius Hoffmann
th-cam.com/video/fqPN4gXy834/w-d-xo.html
(miracle begins from about 3,00 mn ... To the end)
good
ピティナ特級もよかったよ！
本当に素晴らしい！！でもただそれだけの演奏だ。
9:10 is it me or is the piano out of tune by quite a lot?
The piano sounds fine, but she made a lot of mistakes in that section.
@@ilovemycatrussell9298 haha OK. But that was the most important part of the song haha it's a pity.
non è ancora capace di "entrare" nel testo : suona le note con un po' di buon gusto e nulla di più .
Engen Bereich.
아구힘이 엄청나네
😂
if you play fast, make sure you can get the notes... nothing is more frustrating
Spoken like a true youtube expert...
I’d take a good musical interpretation with a few mistakes over a dull so-called perfect playing, that’s actually wayyy more frustrating.
Mistakes are what makes us human, nothing wrong with that.
I loved her style but this was a COMPETITION after all
😂
😂