PLAYER POWER RANKINGS | 1. LOOSE-HEAD PROP
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2024
- Position by position, ranking the best players on Earth. Tracking how the list changes over time. Based on current form, historic form and a healthy dose of gut feeling too. Starting with Loose-head Prop.
This should be called top of the props
Props to you for coming up with that one
WISH I'd thought of that. Bravo!
Bravo
Please keep doing this series like every 6 months or so, it’s great to see how things are changing over time
I definitely agree
Porters engine is insane. He seems to have played a ridiculous amount of Ireland games for the full running time which is just crazy. He single-handedly deflects attention from the fact we are actually quite vulnerable at loosehead.
I also recommend watching his episode on 6n full contact, was a brilliant and humane insight to what its like to be a pro rugby player
He played 90 minutes in the chsmpion cup final - absolute freak
97K subs!
100K by the end of the week!
Whoop - Whoop!
Congratulations Tim!!
I like the criteria and I agree, basics first. Doesn't matter how good your game is, have to be dominant at scrumtime. Never any doubt about Ox. I agree with Porter at 2nd as well.
Great program. Would like to suggest you can somehow incorporate each players vital statistics somewhere on the page?? I’m talking about age, weight etc.
Cheers Mike
I loved that Ox Nche, a prop, got man of the match against Ireland, even thought SA lost.
Ox 🔥
🐂
@@mphomothle5430 he is insanely talented at loosehead. Perfect height as well.
Aaahh.. Love these player rankings.
Nice to see you're updating your Playlist aswell, interesting to compare now and then, 10 month ago.
De Groot for for me ,just doesn't bend ,true power
Your content is so genuine. Please don't change when you eventually get those big boy sponsors.
Shout out from Kenya
What an amazing series idea❤
Love your power rankings. Entertaining and educational 😂
Great concept Tim. I’ll look forward to listening every morning down here in oz.
Love these videos thanks Tim
What a time to be alive, there are so many world class props that a top 10 couldn't include them all. I thought Genge was superb against Ireland in the six nations, and just for that performance he deserved a spot in
Good list. Kitshoff is more than a great scrummager. His work at the breakdown is part of his appeal. I would rate porter above nche because of his play out of the scrums. Nche is, however, developing soft hands, so it's a toss-up for me. The margins are small except when you get to the scrum...then there is only one guy. Ox is boss
I just love your work.
Ox...Our boy💚💛🇿🇦
3 SAFFERS, good choices Tim
Good morning out of Durbs Tim, I'm looking forward to this power ranking series 🤙🤙🔥
Pretty hard to argue think I'd have de groot and Bell a little higher as an Irish fan I'm a bit worried (even though its impressive) about all the 70+ minutes porter is putting in I see him emulating furlongs injury ravaged later career for the same reasons you can only sustain that for so long before your body pays the price
Question for you Tim??
The recent test series in South Africa vs Ireland, number 1 vs 2 in the world it was always going to be hard fought, thus the drawn series 1-1, pity there was no third game. South Africa came out and played some entertaining running rugby, but against top teams games are hard and not flowing. So one week later we hand out free springbok caps against Portugal to check depth. I get it loads of rugby, rest players, look at what you have for rugby 2027, but really would this not be the ideal time to try the new game plan with lower level team and gets things close to perfect as you can? I am a huge rugby fan and enjoy the camaraderie in the rugby world. Also your podcast is great keep up the great work. Enjoy your next trip back to South Africa.
Yours in rugby Darren
First person who came to mind before looking at your list, for number 1 - is Ox Nche.
No one is as destructive in Scrums and he is very good in general play
Mind you the no 3 for the u20 boks is huge and highly mobile from the one try I saw him score. 👀
Love your channel! So unbiased and neautral! Keep goin!
Your pure class Tim, pure class
Ix
Am an avid fan of your podcast. Love your analysis and insight. Looking forward to your return to South Africa!
Good job mate. Keep it going!
De Groot should be further up there. This Rugby Championship will show what a good prop he is.
He’s better than Schoeman and Baille for sure.
He is definitely a better scrummer and is solid in defence. Schoeman is a decent ball carrier.
Interesting how they seem to have South African names...
I’m South African and that’s a Dutch name.
@@myshepspud1 Interestingly, both De Groot and Lomax (AB THP) were born in Australia.
3 Saffa's in the top 5
Woaahhh I’ve been waiting for this series again 🔊🔊
Rly glad these are back! Been watching since you did these after the 2023 6N (feels a million years ago now).. Would you consider looking back on those pics by position and having a stab at which ones you feel best and worst about judging with all the rugby played since?
Andrew Porter
Pierre Schoeman
Ellis Genge for the lions.
2 test series in South Africa in couple of months will be the biggest scrum battle in years
Spot on Sir Timothy
Can't put Ox Nche any higher than 4. Baille, Kitshoff and Porter all scrum well and do more around the park, Nche is up there cos he's the best scrummager. That's like picking a fly half purely for goal kicking. Porter is my current number one. Does everything and can do it well for 80 minutes.
Can't argue with those formidable brutes
You might want to think of adding the players bio when you profile them 🤔
Second this
1 2 & 3 spot on 👍
Genge never gets the credit he deserves. Easily in top 10 looseheads in the world. Scrummed excellently throughout the 6N’s especially up against Antonio in the French game. He’s had Furlong on toast on numerous occasions. He was fantastic in the Oz series that England won completely outperforming Bell etc, etc.
He was badly missed by England in the recent NZ series.
I think he gets lumped in with Sinckler scrum-wise as they’ve been on together when it’s gone wrong. But I agree, he’s not a weakness there
Always love your breakfast list videos Tim 👍
Willliams didn't get much game time in super rugby. Injuries then cruz missed quarterfinals. He'll likely be nz no2 soon. Baxter has great potential. Standout in that HC match v UBB, then his performance in NZ. Huge future.
De Groot 6th seems low. He's been in form all season and the only scrummager to counter and nullify Newell so far this season. RC scrums will be the true test tho
I'm still unsure why Porter is so high on these lists. Good player but i wouldn't rank him in the top 5 at all. Maybe I'm missing something? 🤔
He has a decent engine but gets away with dark arts at scrumtime.
Fantastic work Tim! I love these! Can't wait to see all the other lists🔥🔥🔥🔥
Great idea love the content ☘️❤️
Nice job Tim!
Spot on Timothy
Tu'ungafasi is severly under rated. Had a superb Super Rugby season and was the anchor of the Blues forward pack
would be interested in top 10 lists for solely england eligible players - perhaps released to tie in with the squad announcement this autumn
As a Blues fan I do like Tuʻungafasi, I'd still have a hard time arguing for his inclusion in this list, a fine bunch to be sure. I suspect he's still the ABs side because of his knowledge and implementation of the dark arts of the front row. ;^)
Bell has spent so much of the past two years injured but isn't too far away from getting back on the park. He isn't top tier at scrum time ... yet. He and Tamaiti Williams are both 23, turning 24 this year, and both are good ball players, not just set piece performers. Mind you, Bell can run a lot faster. He's easily the fastest runner of those listed here (subject to how his injuries have healed up).
One to watch out for in the TRC is Isaac Kailea, another youngster, who made his debut for Australia against Wales a few weeks ago - 190cm and 129kg and immediately looked right at home in test rugby.
I do wonder if South Africa could supply the top 4 if you included their A team . Just a conveyor belt of props and we have been lucky enough to snaffle Schumen !!!!!
Good list and good list order
Great selection of the top 10, can’t argue against any.
I feel Porter gets too much leeway by refs, he does some obvious illegal tactics and somehow they let him get away with it too often, except in that RWC QF, there he got called out and had nowhere to go.
Other than that, the 3 best total front rows Sa, NZ, Fra and followed by Ire. Ireland and SA will need replacing by the next World Cup so NZ and Fra are looking menacing come 2027.
Watch out for Gerhard Steenekamp coming through, great ball carrier and seem to be getting dominant in scrums
7:28 so nice he did it twice!
Great list, but for me I’d go:
1 Ox
2 Porter
3 Kitshoff
4 de Groot
5 Baille
6 Schoeman
7 Marler
8 Williams
9 Bell
10 Steenekamp
You didn't watch Kitshoff play a single minute this past season did you?
@@jeramy576 I watched almost every URC game.
@@jameswyatt4443 rewatch them.
LMFAO Ethan Degroot has owned all these guys other than maybe the french guy. He's the most consistent go forward prop in the world right now.
A loosehead cannot "own" another loosehead.
De groot is number 1 for me. He rolled all the props ahead of him
Porter is debatable for me.. If it’s not penalties, cynical play, he is pulling down the opposition props in scrums. . Agree, One credit is that he plays full 80 comfortably.
I agree
That's more to do with the fact you're South African and he's Irish. If he was any other nationality ye wouldn't care or mention him.
@@stiofain88 , and you know this for a fact?
Look at his penalty count in scrums, how many times did he get penalized in the 6 nations , definitely more than the other starting prop for Ireland.
Check stats before making lame assumptions.
@@vuyaniman9440 Look at your passport.
@@stiofain88 , I repeat .look at stats and then argue. If not keep your assumptions to yourself. …
Interesting that you mentioned Ox's performance in the world cup against France, Ireland and England but didn't mention his performance against NZ in the final? Why not? I'd like to hear your opinion on that.
He won game defining penalties in the quarter and semi. I didn't mention Scotland game or Ireland pool game either...those 2 scrums were SO consequential.
@@EggchasersRugby Ok, thanks for that.
Number 1 for Ireland that bloke has stones the size of watermelons
Danilo Fischetti has to be in for me, although I perhaps underrated Pierre Schoeman in my list as I’ve left him out entirely.
Realistically De Groot, Tamati, Porter and 7 South Africans.
Don’t forget the All Ireland football final is on now BBC2 Northern Ireland
Tyrol Lomax.. beast!
Degrroot already should be top 3
Good choice
Neels Smit
Steenkamp must be close...was great vs leinster and ireland(got that penalty try)
Spot on
Great job, Tim! For me, Porter concedes too many penalties, like in the RWC 1/4 final...
Rugby void? Rassie and Co will drop the team nice and early for us next week to discuss. When you’re an Saffa, there’s no rugby void. Rugby is life.
Where’s all your videos from your trip to SA
Looks like you might break 100k by the time you get to fullback, Tim!
Until 9th August (not February)?
Heyy Tim. I just want to help you with Pierre Schoeman's correct pronunciation:
The "a" in Schoeman is pronounced as the "u" in Sun, Fun, Bun, Stun.
Pierre Schoeman 👍
Ntuthuku Mchunu, 1 for the future
For the past 4 years. So nice to get many chances.......
I am going out on a limb here and I think most of us could call the No9 (scrum half that is) already 🙂
De Groot should perhaps be higher. Arguably, Kitshoff should perhaps not even be in the top 10 at the moment. Has looked tired since the World Cup and notndone much.
A few other saffers could also be knocking in the door.
While the amount of minutes and work Porter gets through is remarkable, he gets away with illegal scrumming. He is so blatant sometimes I'm reluctant to call it the dark arts of prop scrumming.
I would put De Groot 2nd and Schoeman 3rd. They are powerhouses and can play around the park as well.
I cannot agree with Porter. He is big and he is strong, but his technique in pulling with his arm, is going to cause more and more issues as referees catch this. It is also dangerous as lesser props will not be able to correct his pulling, as Frans Malherbe did. He is stong enough to keep his bind and push straight and monster the tight head that way, so why resort to putting the scrum in a compromising position. Some of these collapses are going to cause serious injuries. He also gives away too many penalties at rucks. He is better than that.
In general I agree however schoeman should be 3rd kits isn’t playing and Cyril isn’t on form, also if Porter doesn’t have someone to hold his arm up in a scrum how can he classed as a prop
Good choices
Re Andrew Porter, very good player, but if you go back and look at the 2nd tesr Ireland v Springboks Porters bind was illegal-the laws state props must bind on their opponents BACKS.Porter was binding on the side with his elbow toward the ground and thereby pulling his opponent down and destabilising him. No response from any of the officials( all Northern Hemisphere) who were overall pretty poor.
That is why you always play to the whistle.
OX!!!!
Thought id see Fletcher Newell in there
He's a tighthead
Ox Nche
Ox pox
@@twitflash7618Ox Rocks
Porter is good in the scrum can last the full game but he is not imo number 2, he has way too many brain farts and is almost certain to give away stupid penalties every game with some of these been the difference in a final result ! He badly needs to become a lot less hot headed then he can be the best possibly
Fair
Ox has trouble with Infrastructure if he gets lost, because the man is incapable of taking a backwards step😂
3 South Africans in your top 10🇿🇦🎉
If Wilco Louw is recalled would be top 3 in no time
If we're looking at scrummaging as our most important criteria, I can't agree with Porter so high, he gives away so many scrum penalties.
Pierre Schoeman is also a favorite Prop for me, for his commitment and general play impact - but he is not as dominant as others in Scrums
Ox
love the channel. Keep the good work!
Loosehead this week not tighthead prop
@@Dinkybear622 omg you are right, soryy what a stupid statement ahaha
De Groot at 6? Yeah right mate
Gerhard Steenekamp should be very close , to me he was beter than ox the entire season post the rwc
Rugby"void" 7's?????
man I think Tamaiti Williams
Fletcher Newel ,Cody Taylor and De Groot if the locks do their job will shock s Africa
Agreed Those Bokkie fans don't realize quite how far this ABs front row has developed and developed into something that could wreck the bok scrum and maul
I think the South Africans rate the ABs front row a lot.
The interesting thing is that SA has props coming out of its ears at the moment, and it isn't necessarily even the best scrummagers that get to play.
Front row isn't a problem for AB's right now, but the locks ...
@Hiltok yep. Except we do have enough tall big timber playing super rugby,but young.I reckon pick them and back the coaching to integrate them..Still not sure why they haven't investing Parkinson from highlanders ,2m plus and 140kg.
@@Hiltok Agree. But I think in a season or so the AB's will be fine. Dary will come on, and Holland becomes available
Three South Africans in top ten.
not an awful list, but I think Marler is way overrated, and Schoeman could be a lot higher.
Sleeping on Gerhard Steenkamp
Its fine, he is still young. I believe he will make the next list.
Porter ? Tim ain’t no way
Penalty merchant
Yeah, except there's a more relevant statistic regarding Andrew Porter. He has played for Ireland against the Springboks 4 times. Ireland have won 3 of those matches. Nuff said.
@@fawltyoldboybasil.2178 enough side? That doesn’t mean he’s a good prop. He can’t scrum . The man’s hips are forever facing the touch line AND he’s always dropping his elbow . POM is ALWAYS helping him keep it up
He is definitely the best there is Ireland in that position but the guy wouldn’t make a Currie Cup side in SA
If this came from a Kiwi, Aussie, Brit or Frenchman it might be worth listening to. But it came from a South African. Enough said.
@@reabetswekhiba7551 In todays game, props have to contribute a good deal more than just scrummaging.