*Timestamps:* 00:00 - Introduction 00:25 - Background of Dr. Fatoohi 00:59 - Topic of the Discussion 03:51 - Story of Joseph pbuh: Qur'an vs Bible 06:08 - Joseph pbuh in the Qur'an 07:23 - Joseph pbuh in the Bible 08:10 - Overview of Joseph pbuh's story 09:27 - Isaac pbuh on his Deathbed 14:59 - Prophethood in the Qur'an 23:31 - Jacob pbuh on his Deathbed 26:14 - The Dream of Joseph pbuh 31:30 - Jacob's reaction to Joseph's dream 37:48 - The Conspiracy 43:28 - Jacob's reaction to Joseph's disappearance 49:13 - The False Accusation 53:20 - Joseph: The Dreams Interpreter 57:58 - Preaching to the Prison Companions 1:01:21 - Prisoners' dreams episode verses 1:03:42 - Joseph's Shirts 1:05:28 - Joseph's Missing Shirt 1:07:06 - Joseph's Missing Miracle 1:11:07 - The Best Stories of the Unseen 1:16:14 - The Documentary Hypothesis 1:21:51 - Inconsistencies & composition of the Bible 1:23:16 - Muhammad ﷺ qouting Joseph pbuh 1:25:01 - Muhammad ﷺ being the Final Prophet 1:26:46 - Studying Comparative Religion 1:32:25 - Pharaoh vs King in the Qur'an 1:33:27 - Miraculous nature of the Qur'an 1:35:12 - Purpose of the Discussion 1:37:26 - Refuting the claim of Qur'an copying from other Jewish & Christian sources 1:43:25 - Closing Remarks MashaAllah ❤️🤍💖 Fantastic Discussion 👍🏻👌🏻 _May Allah ﷻ bless you both and reward you for your efforts._ 🤲🏻
@@BloggingTheology I maybe wrong but you looked tiered in this video I hope your health is good by Allah will. don't overwork your body remember to take care of yourself.
Being born a non-Arabic speaking Muslim, this channel is helping me understand our sacred book Quran. My faith is increasing listening to these lectures. May Allah bless you guys in this world and hereafter. Thank you
Paul , you are a significant person to us. May allah bless you. And all the Muslim fellow who will see my comment, please pray for me. I have been facing severe depression since 10 years.
Paul , plz eat healthy and live a long life , while we are praying ALLAH for ur long life . Your content Are reliable because u have a scholar class , book in ur background, ur knowledge, ur popularity that scholar and professor from different reputed institution come . U ARE BRINGING REVOLUTION. SIR.
For those who want to dive deeper into the topic, Dr Louay wrote wonderful book abook about the topic, thank you Dr louay for showing us what those differences in between the Bible and the quran indicates too ,may Allah bless you and your bloved one, and thank you brothers Paul for wonderful content that enhance our knowledge as usual may Allah reward you for your good work in this life and the life after.
Thank you, brother, for your kind words. Exactly as you say, the story of Yusuf is full of amazing explicit and subtle wonders. I could only cover so much in my book. The book was first published in 2005 yet I still find myself learning new things about this completely captivating account. I will die and I am still a student of the story of Yusuf, trying to learn from it and about it.
@@louay.fatoohi Barak allah feek Dr louay ,to me personally this story spirituality touch deep my soul ,but when I first read your book I recognized how far superior the story in the Quran is.اسال الله العظيم ان يزيدك علما يعود بالنفع علي امه الإسلام امين
Alhamdulillah you brought Dr. Fatoohi back on, the last ones were very marvelous, learned so much about the Exodus, Allah Bless you for all your effort to enlighten us Paul, and bringing such wonderful guest. Waiting for Professor Ali Ataie again .
@@TheWatchmanWebsite You already know that "God will condemn you to HELL for IDOLATRY." But, instead of worship God, you choose to do idolatry, you worship a human. Even the worst thing is you celebrating his death by drinking his blood and eating his flesh. May Allah take you away from the hands of Satan, and lead you to the truth.
"We tell you [Prophet] the best of stories in revealing this Quran to you. Before this you were one of those who knew nothing about them." Quran: Yusuf: verse 3. Indeed, Allah tells the best of stories, full of wisdom, flawless flow of events with enough details yet concise.
Salam, brother Paul. As a revert, your content benefits me so much. I wanted to ask when the episode with Dr. Ataie refuting the alleged borrowing theories is going to be released? May Allah bless you 🤲🏻🥰
I found you on TH-cam at the gym working out as a western Muslim I have learned so much through your theology guests may Allah bless you and keeping me up-to-date in my dean I have learned more from you than my Muslim family who has no knowledge of all this it’s a shame but that’s what happens to Wanda grows up in a western world and not exposed to Islamic rules and religion knowledge so thank you so much I love you my Allah bless you and all your guests thank you
Fascinating material and engaging presentation. The good Dr. Fatoohi, like Ms. Marpel, surly has a keen eye for revelatory details the average reader would skip blithely over without notice or care. He also must have good patience for this type of research.
Masya Allah this is a remarkable and inspiring talk. It is a great reminder for me how Allah SWT has deviced in a plan. The prophet PBUH has passed away, like other human being, long ago but the miraculous book stays with us, enduring the time in an amazing way, as a devine guidance for believers and for those who seek the thruthful way. Thank you.
A very good point about the words the stars, the sun and moon being arranged in a different from the other verses. I read the verse many times and listened to its recitation even more but I never noticed it. Truly the Quran is like a mathematical text. Every word and I mean every word is in its right place. No one can pay that much attention to details like that when one writes a book. Thank you doctor Fatoohi for the insight. If there is anyone interested to know more about the Quran and the accuracy of expressions should watch Dr Fadhel Saleh As-Samarrai for more Quran gems. His videos are only in Arabic though.
I want to correct you. Every letter is precisely placed with a purpose. Some words are missing a letter or a vowel and others have extra vowel or letter, written or pronounced or both. And they have very subtle addition to meaning and consistency in the Quran.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
May Allah shower His blessings upon Brother Paul and his esteemed guests for their unwavering commitment to assisting individuals in their quest for the true religion. I must express my utmost admiration for the captivating presentation delivered by the distinguished Dr. Fatoohi.
MashaAllah, another wonderful lecture! I'm a huge admirer of Dr. Fatoohi, have enjoyed his lectures, purchased his books. I can't help but feel I've enrolled in a wonderful class (or classes), led/orchestrated by our wonderful Professor Paul Williams. More of this kind of content, please!
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
My favorite Surah in the Quran subhanAllah! The Surah is a beautiful example of Ring Composition structure and theme which is prevalent throughout the Quran but specifically this Surah. JazakAllah Khair to Bro. Paul and Dr. Fatoohi.
Very interesting topic brother Paul as usual, still watching this video, I watched the video you did with Dr Louay about the indeed controversial topic of abrogation. I wanted to ask if you can host a person on the other side of the argument of abrogation, perhaps a presentation just as academic as the one Dr Louay did. I wanted to make an informed decision on the subject and to be honest your channel has become my number one place to get academic perspectives on matters like this. It would be nice to get a traditional perspective on this issue as well. I'll also look through the channel and see if you made any other videos on the subject. Thank you for every thing you're doing for the community. I pray that god rewards you for everything good that you do and forgive you for everything bad that you do.
Surat Yusuf was and will always be my favorite surah of the Holy Quran,Love the story itself,the way it was told,the lessons learned thanks to it,the people involved in it,And just love the way it always surprise me with something new I didn't pay attention to before,it just seems like each time you read it, reflect on it you ended up discovering something new which is totally understandable ND expected from the words of our Creator
Hi Khadija, If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
Dear Brother. I am really excited to see a Muslim who is specialized in cosmology. I have been longing to understand cosmology and the quranic understanding. Would you be kind enough to start a series on cosmology in Islam view with this particular guest of yours. thank you in advance.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
At the end of everything, i can't accept nor imagine that the very almighty God that created the this whole universe and can vanish it in less than a second would be humiliated or beaten. Never ever.
MashaAllah, have no words left, this is the first time i am seeing Dr. Fatoohi , Alhamdulillah he's doing a fantastic job. And your channel as well, your video of king Charles 3 about Islam randomly came 2-3 days ago to me. Thank you Subscribed you
Congratulations once again for brilliant content and discussion. These discussions are so valuable and you learn a tremendous amount. Shukran to both of you. May Allah grant you health to present many more of these wonderful interviews
May Allah bless you brother Paul snd Louay. This discussion was an iman booster. I would have loved to hear more from you brother Paul about your reflections on the Quranic description of the disciples that you mentioned almost at the end.
Another small, but might be significant, is what brothers of Yousef used to come and carry the Goods on in Quran is Camels … while in the Biblical story it was Donkeys.. the significance is the distances they were travelling and the needs to carry big amounts of Goods which only camels can !
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
Hi Paul.I am glad your keeping well. God will use whom , he will. You Paul is that person who is representing God. You are a chosen one. May God guide you and strengthen you. ❤️🥰👍✌🏽
“Jacob lost his sight but not his faith “ Nice comment ( reminder) by Dr. L Thanks to both brothers . Just my thought : Br. Paul from west and Dr. L from East . Meet on this channel East and West belong to Allah and His light illuminates East and west. Inshallah one day peace shall prevail .
Yes, so interesting. It is so fascinating after some deep study of the Bible and the Quran and then see a qualified person compare the two. It is fascinating how the Quran constantly subverts the biblical message (in a good way) like how Jacob's death scene becomes about God and not about tribes.
The story of Yusuf (es) is not only beautiful in its content but style. Ibn tayyimiah thought when Quran talks surah Yusuf (es) to be the best of قصص which could be interpreted by best in style or rhetoric that can be said of course for every ayah in any case. It’s unique virtue as masterpiece in everything, whether , content, style rhetoric etc. The story is precise and beautifully related with many lessons that can be extracted from each and every verse. There were two Saudi brothers Who extracted 1000 lessons from the story of Yusuf (es) MashaAllah. Asma. Haq. Yusuf.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
@exhale inhale Haney is not reliable and comes up with fringe interpretations. The man claims he has been revealed a secret way to interpret the quran, and those before him did not do it correctly and his way is the correct way. Don't promote that man. Farid responds has exposed him already
The Pharaoh at the time of Joseph is called a king in the book of _Jubilees_ , dated to c. 200 BCE; after the _Torah_ had been composed and 900 years before the composition of the Qur'an. _Jubilees_ was a well known text already, and is clearly a source used to compose both the Qur'an and biography of Muhammad. Qur'an Chapter 12 is demonstrably a written account of an oral text, a retelling of the Joseph story found in Genesis, Chapters 37-50 (but also from other sources, as mentioned above). As the guest speaker explains, the Genesis story of Joseph is more detailed than the Qur'an (i e. provides details, such as names, locations, etc, which are mostly absent in _Sura_ 12). This should be expected in a retelling, where literary texture is typically lost due to forgetfulness and other (often intentional) changes to the narrative text: oftentimes, names and numbers are forgotten during retellings, as only the gist is conveyed. By way of example, the Qur'an doesn't identify the traders who bought Joseph; does not mention the names of Joseph's brothers; does not tell of Joseph's age or how much he was sold for; and so on. The emphases of the story are changed too: the trauma of Jacob's grief at losing his favourite son is lost in the Qur'an, which adds theological elements to the text (as noted in the presentation). No doubt, many textual variations in the Joseph story occurred during its transmission and performance, such that the Qur'an version itself may have been adapted for its audience multiple times before being canonised; such as the story of Jacob having his sight returned to him by having his head covered by a piece of Joseph's clothing. After all, the biblical story repeatedly tells us that Jacob could see (e.g. Gen. 42:35; 45:27; 46:30).
It's worth noting that the Qur'ān seemingly uses 'Pharaoh/فرعون' as a proper name rather than a mere title (like al-malik ~ the king), since the word lacks the definite article and is indeclinable (ghayr munṣarif) because it doesn't receive tanwīn (nunation) - Firʻawnᵘ as opposed to Firʻawnᵘⁿ, as is the case with other foreign proper names in the Qur'ān (Ibrāhīmᵘ, Ismāʻīlᵘ, Hārūnᵘ etc.)
@@noahrue470 Thank you, Noah, for your valued response. I hope you don't mind that I have added your comment to my Qur'an notes. Of course Hebrew grammar does not contain the definite article, but simply refers to 'Pharaoh' (פרעה). Perhaps this could be one reason why the Qur'an uses the name, فرءون, as a proper name rather than a title?
@Gavin James It wouldn‘t explain why the Qur'ān uses Firʻawn as a proper name only for the Pharaoh of Exodus, since the Hebrew Bible applies the given term without a definite article for several rulers, and not simply for the former. After all, numerous Qur'ānic commentators _do_ assert that he had a distinct proper name (often given as al-Walīd bin Muṣʻab). Of course, despite these grammatical concerns, I don‘t fully rule out that it could be a mere title transformed into a quasi-proper name in the Qur'ān, similar to how Arabic Islamic sources use the general term Qayṣar (Caesar) as a sort of proper name for Emperor Heraclius.
@@noahrue470 I actually checked _Genesis_ 41:1 (JPS _Tanakh_ , Hebrew-English), because I'm interested in the Joseph story, here. But I think you are correct concerning the grammar. Thank you.
SubhanAllah Wal hamdulillah Wa la ilaha illallahu Wallahu Akhbar...!!! You all, our beloved brothers sisters, who do dawah voluntarily on the streets and everywhere on earth, with sincerity, your own efforts and willingness, are the best among the Ummah. We love you all. We therefore seek mercy and help from Allah SWT to grant our brothers and sisters with the strength, courage, bravery and good health, to bring the messages of our Rasulullah Mohammed PBUH to all mankind and grant you all, our brothers and sisters, with a place in Jannah. Aamiin Yarobbil Aalamiin 🕌 🌙 🤲🤲🤲 💖 🌹
1:43:00 this theory of Prophet Muhammad (sas) compiling all these known and unknown sources in order to produce the Qur'an becomes even more ridiculous when you consider the mere time it would consume of a person. How on earth should the Prophet be able to have done it during his migration to Medina, all the battles, being a husband, father, friend, imam and so on. We would have to hear : oh on this occasion he was unavailable because he was compiling/putting together the Qur'an 🙈 but nobody ever claimed this about the prophet. And on top of it, imagine, all of this in the oral form 🤯 so at the end this orientalist arrive at a theory which in itself would require a miracle in order to be true 😅 In any case: barakallahu fik brother Paul for the excellent kind of content you provide.
Brother Paul, a kind suggestion: it would be great if you show the guest and your image a little bit bigger, you have a room .. it is nice to see you guys while you are speaking plus the text does not need to be so huge.. 2 third of the screen for the text and 1 third (your images). thanks may Allah protect you give you light, increase your knoweldge and give you success in both world and your loved ones and all of us amin.
Watch Nouman Ali Khan's "Surah Yusuf" series to really appriciate the amazing story. It's long but worth it. Bayinnah also has about 3 episodes (that I could find) for Bible/Qur'an comparison on Joseph (pbuh).
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
Pretty incredible. Just had a talk with a christian friend and we talk about the issue of the name Pharaoh not being in use during Joseph’s time. He wanted proofs, well Allah is the best of planners.
Scholarly discussion bordered on realistic evidences, comparative resources and prevailing misconceptions. The story of Prophet Joseph (aws) as narrated in the Holy Qur'an, shed lights to some inconsistencies contained in the bible and added more realistic true happenings... Allah Wakbar!
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel) {Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes... Check out the story of dhulqarnayn too
Salaam Paul. In the Quran the high priest of pharaoh is mentioned by name (haman) and commanded to build a high tower. Is there any mention of this name in other scriptures or archiolgical finds? Jzk
there are multiple Jewish Torahs such as the Samaritan, Babylonian Septuagint, the masoretic( current version) as well as the alexanderian text so how can it be considered one text
I expected the King-Pharaoh naming difference to be a much lengthy subject in this discussion. It was only a few minutes. But also learned many more subtle differences.
to Bro Paul AsSlamunAlaykum, I would appreciate it if you could relay this information to Dr. Ali Ataie. And if you can't then at least I tried to inform him. At least he will get the chance to evaluate it. This is a symbol that is YHWH. First it is not a name and it is not a spoken word. It is an adjective that is attributive and descriptive. Also it is some form of an acronym. Also it is not a word that is pronounceable but it can be acted out. Also it is Arabic in origin. Until Moses/Musa AS went to Median the Israelites were not given this "Name" of Allah AwJ. Moses/Musa AS received it after he met His Father in-law Jethro/Shoayb AS, in Median. Jethro/Shoayb AS was an Arab. Before then the Israelites did not know God by that "Name". Exo 6:3 And I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto Jacob, by the name of God Almighty, but by my name JEHOVAH was I not known to them. So This "NAME" was revealed to Him through Jethro/Shoayb AS who was a Prophet. And since Jethro was an Arab He spoke Arabic. And YHWH was not pronounced because it cannot be pronounced. It is an acronym because each letter signifies something. However it is acted out in a sense. In the Quran there is Stand alone letters like ALM or TH or YS or KHYAS, that is evidence that Arabs used this type of communication for those that could understand the intricacies of the Arabic Language. And most IMPORTANTLY it was a SIGN for the Jews as well as for the Arabs, that they would be able to confirm that What The Prophet REVEALED was from Allah AwJ. Since YHWH is in the Arabic style of Communication, one would have to decipher it's meaning using the Arabic Language. Let me elaborate. "YHWH" : The "Y" or YA is, as is in Arabic a vocative or beseeching. Like saying - "OH" my Father or "OH" my Mother. Like wise it signifies "OH" my God. this is where you have many Jews and Christians that will say the Name of God is YAH. The first "H" stands for breathing in or out. So if you stand really quite and take a BREATH you will notice a slight H sounding voice emitted. The "W" WA as is in Arabic means "and". The second "H" also signifies to a BREATHING, in or out. One breath always follows the other. So if you accept that God gave the Breath of Life then it becomes apparent that this action is being done by people as long as they are alive. Everyone is alive by expressing this "NAME" of God. The only difference between people is that Believers do this invoking God and being Grateful/Hamd and disbelievers are doing it in ignorance, but doing it none the less. So when you are doing the action "Ya(H)Hu" by breathing in and out while invoking the vocative "Ya", you can appreciate the meaning. In essence it stands for beseeching God/Allah AwJ by saying "OH the one who has given me the ability to BREATH IN AND BREATH OUT". In other words "LIFE" / EXISTANCE. As Muslims say " ya hay ياحي " Let me add that this is similar to the "HURÛF-ı MUKATTAAT الحروف المقطّعة" These are the stand alone letters that are in the Beginning of some of the Surats/Chapters in the Quran. The Stand Alone Letters which are original in the Quran and are in the Arabic Language. So it is ONE of the Reasons that The Jews should be able to RECOGNIZE that the Quran is a Revelation from God because of this anomaly. The "HURÛF-ı MUKATTAAT in the Quran must also have had this correlation with the Scripture that Moses had BROUGHT from God. Allahu AA'lam . Salam.
Subhanallaah wa Tabaraqallaahh. Its because of their so very extreme nationalism, as a result they dont even have a name for the Creator of all existence, except HaShem or HaShim in Arabic.
![🎤 ไปกันต่อออ! จับฉลากร้องเพลง x P’ #XXSIVK [EP.2] (1/2) เพลงของใครจึ้งสุดน้าา 💓🎤 #MXFRUIT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mLI_K0sAS4o/mqdefault.jpg)
*Timestamps:*
00:00 - Introduction
00:25 - Background of Dr. Fatoohi
00:59 - Topic of the Discussion
03:51 - Story of Joseph pbuh: Qur'an vs Bible
06:08 - Joseph pbuh in the Qur'an
07:23 - Joseph pbuh in the Bible
08:10 - Overview of Joseph pbuh's story
09:27 - Isaac pbuh on his Deathbed
14:59 - Prophethood in the Qur'an
23:31 - Jacob pbuh on his Deathbed
26:14 - The Dream of Joseph pbuh
31:30 - Jacob's reaction to Joseph's dream
37:48 - The Conspiracy
43:28 - Jacob's reaction to Joseph's disappearance
49:13 - The False Accusation
53:20 - Joseph: The Dreams Interpreter
57:58 - Preaching to the Prison Companions
1:01:21 - Prisoners' dreams episode verses
1:03:42 - Joseph's Shirts
1:05:28 - Joseph's Missing Shirt
1:07:06 - Joseph's Missing Miracle
1:11:07 - The Best Stories of the Unseen
1:16:14 - The Documentary Hypothesis
1:21:51 - Inconsistencies & composition of the Bible
1:23:16 - Muhammad ﷺ qouting Joseph pbuh
1:25:01 - Muhammad ﷺ being the Final Prophet
1:26:46 - Studying Comparative Religion
1:32:25 - Pharaoh vs King in the Qur'an
1:33:27 - Miraculous nature of the Qur'an
1:35:12 - Purpose of the Discussion
1:37:26 - Refuting the claim of Qur'an copying from other Jewish & Christian sources
1:43:25 - Closing Remarks
MashaAllah ❤️🤍💖
Fantastic Discussion 👍🏻👌🏻
_May Allah ﷻ bless you both and reward you for your efforts._ 🤲🏻
Many thanks Asadullah SAAiD!
@@BloggingTheology I maybe wrong but you looked tiered in this video I hope your health is good by Allah will.
don't overwork your body remember to take care of yourself.
Thank you, brother, for creating this helpful timeline.
خمووحخخخخخخوخوخوخ
What a Marvelous Quran channel!
I was reverted ..This channel worth millions of views and followers ..May Allah protect and bless you brother ..☪️☪️
Pray for Palestine
؟ @@cartoonsinhindi1023
Salam and salutations.. May Allah cc your taqwa and keep you and us in the path.
Being born a non-Arabic speaking Muslim, this channel is helping me understand our sacred book Quran. My faith is increasing listening to these lectures. May Allah bless you guys in this world and hereafter. Thank you
Paul , you are a significant person to us. May allah bless you. And all the Muslim fellow who will see my comment, please pray for me. I have been facing severe depression since 10 years.
Paul , plz eat healthy and live a long life , while we are praying ALLAH for ur long life . Your content
Are reliable because u have a scholar class , book in ur background, ur knowledge, ur popularity that scholar and professor from different reputed institution come . U ARE BRINGING REVOLUTION. SIR.
For those who want to dive deeper into the topic, Dr Louay wrote wonderful book abook about the topic, thank you Dr louay for showing us what those differences in between the Bible and the quran indicates too ,may Allah bless you and your bloved one, and thank you brothers Paul for wonderful content that enhance our knowledge as usual may Allah reward you for your good work in this life and the life after.
Alhamdulillah
Thank you, brother, for your kind words.
Exactly as you say, the story of Yusuf is full of amazing explicit and subtle wonders. I could only cover so much in my book. The book was first published in 2005 yet I still find myself learning new things about this completely captivating account. I will die and I am still a student of the story of Yusuf, trying to learn from it and about it.
@@louay.fatoohi Barak allah feek Dr louay ,to me personally this story spirituality touch deep my soul ,but when I first read your book I recognized how far superior the story in the Quran is.اسال الله العظيم ان يزيدك علما يعود بالنفع علي امه الإسلام امين
@@Moussa430 Wa baraka feeka, brother.
@@RobinoftheHod The title is "The Prophet Joseph in the Qur'an, the Bible, and History", and it is available on Amazon.
Alhamdulillah you brought Dr. Fatoohi back on, the last ones were very marvelous, learned so much about the Exodus, Allah Bless you for all your effort to enlighten us Paul, and bringing such wonderful guest. Waiting for Professor Ali Ataie again .
@@TheWatchmanWebsite You already know that "God will condemn you to HELL for IDOLATRY." But, instead of worship God, you choose to do idolatry, you worship a human. Even the worst thing is you celebrating his death by drinking his blood and eating his flesh. May Allah take you away from the hands of Satan, and lead you to the truth.
"We tell you [Prophet] the best of stories in revealing this Quran to you. Before this you were one of those who knew nothing about them." Quran: Yusuf: verse 3.
Indeed, Allah tells the best of stories, full of wisdom, flawless flow of events with enough details yet concise.
Your vlogs are helping in understanding Islam and making the message of the Quran so much clearer. Thank you
Salamun Alaikum
Take your knowledge to the next level by listening to The Marvelous Quran by Dr. Hany
Salam, brother Paul. As a revert, your content benefits me so much. I wanted to ask when the episode with Dr. Ataie refuting the alleged borrowing theories is going to be released? May Allah bless you 🤲🏻🥰
At a later date to be confirmed
Dr Fatoohi is one of my favourite guests, always covering crucial topics with depth & nuisance. May Allah always keep you both steadfast 🤲🏾
Ok
Nuance, not nuisance.
I found you on TH-cam at the gym working out as a western Muslim I have learned so much through your theology guests may Allah bless you and keeping me up-to-date in my dean I have learned more from you than my Muslim family who has no knowledge of all this it’s a shame but that’s what happens to Wanda grows up in a western world and not exposed to Islamic rules and religion knowledge so thank you so much I love you my Allah bless you and all your guests thank you
Fascinating material and engaging presentation. The good Dr. Fatoohi, like Ms. Marpel, surly has a keen eye for revelatory details the average reader would skip blithely over without notice or care. He also must have good patience for this type of research.
Mashallah. My favorite channel on TH-cam and all social media.
Edit: this, like your other works, will be something i visit many times over.
More brilliant content of the very highest order. Thank you. God bless you both. And may God guide all seekers of knowledge
Wow, thank you!
Masya Allah this is a remarkable and inspiring talk. It is a great reminder for me how Allah SWT has deviced in a plan. The prophet PBUH has passed away, like other human being, long ago but the miraculous book stays with us, enduring the time in an amazing way, as a devine guidance for believers and for those who seek the thruthful way. Thank you.
A very good point about the words the stars, the sun and moon being arranged in a different from the other verses. I read the verse many times and listened to its recitation even more but I never noticed it. Truly the Quran is like a mathematical text. Every word and I mean every word is in its right place. No one can pay that much attention to details like that when one writes a book. Thank you doctor Fatoohi for the insight.
If there is anyone interested to know more about the Quran and the accuracy of expressions should watch Dr Fadhel Saleh As-Samarrai for more Quran gems. His videos are only in Arabic though.
I want to correct you. Every letter is precisely placed with a purpose. Some words are missing a letter or a vowel and others have extra vowel or letter, written or pronounced or both. And they have very subtle addition to meaning and consistency in the Quran.
Assalam bro, I recommend u also watch Dr Rashad Khalifa.
What a learned individual Dr Fatoohi is .Agree that Sheik Paul's interjections add alot of value jazakumullah Kheir for both of yours.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
Really enjoyed this - concise clear and engaging. Thank you to both . Allah swt grant you both health and success ameen
This is terrible cocktail- devoid of truth …. Just feeble , mythology, Quran is huda … haq
This is terrible cocktail- devoid of truth …. Just feeble , mythology, Quran is huda … haq
@@obaidulhaque7687 This is scholarship and real history.
Always enjoy Br. Paul’s work and the guests he brings on for discussions. May Allah reward and preserve you. Ameen.
Thank you so much Dr. Fatoohi (and Paul) for this very enlightening discussion; the subtleties presented were overwhelming.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
May Allah shower His blessings upon Brother Paul and his esteemed guests for their unwavering commitment to assisting individuals in their quest for the true religion. I must express my utmost admiration for the captivating presentation delivered by the distinguished Dr. Fatoohi.
MashaAllah, another wonderful lecture! I'm a huge admirer of Dr. Fatoohi, have enjoyed his lectures, purchased his books. I can't help but feel I've enrolled in a wonderful class (or classes), led/orchestrated by our wonderful Professor Paul Williams. More of this kind of content, please!
This was an amazingly informative video and gave me newfound appreciation of the story of Joseph. May you both live long fulfilling lives insha'Allah
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
I like dr Louay Fatoohi noticing these profound details maa shaa Allah! Very interesting video Alhamdoulillah!
May Allah SWT bless and reward u both
Thanks! For the extremely valuable knowledge
Glad it was helpful. Many thanks Wesam!
49.99 dollar 😶😶😶😶
Assalamualaikum dear brothers,
MasaAllah great program.
May Allah swt bless you both always.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
Masha Allah Awesome presentation.
Many many thanks
Masha Allah 🥰❣️☝️may both blessed reward knowledge to learn more
My favorite Surah in the Quran subhanAllah! The Surah is a beautiful example of Ring Composition structure and theme which is prevalent throughout the Quran but specifically this Surah. JazakAllah Khair to Bro. Paul and Dr. Fatoohi.
What kind of high class of mindes these two have ? Bless you Paul , bless you Fattohi
Very interesting topic brother Paul as usual, still watching this video, I watched the video you did with Dr Louay about the indeed controversial topic of abrogation.
I wanted to ask if you can host a person on the other side of the argument of abrogation, perhaps a presentation just as academic as the one Dr Louay did.
I wanted to make an informed decision on the subject and to be honest your channel has become my number one place to get academic perspectives on matters like this.
It would be nice to get a traditional perspective on this issue as well.
I'll also look through the channel and see if you made any other videos on the subject.
Thank you for every thing you're doing for the community.
I pray that god rewards you for everything good that you do and forgive you for everything bad that you do.
Thank you so much for your great efforts to inform us. May Allah bless you 🤲🌺🌺🌺🌺
Surat Yusuf was and will always be my favorite surah of the Holy Quran,Love the story itself,the way it was told,the lessons learned thanks to it,the people involved in it,And just love the way it always surprise me with something new I didn't pay attention to before,it just seems like each time you read it, reflect on it you ended up discovering something new which is totally understandable ND expected from the words of our Creator
Hi Khadija,
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
Again a great video. Your channel is marvelous brother Paul. Thanks for inviting experts in the field to discuss important issue related to Islam.
Fanta, really! Loved it! Allah bless both of you
Thank you for another fantastic video Paul
Another fascinating episode
Very insightful!
Very inspiring and informative discussion
Extraordinary, beautifully presented topic to its forensic analysis , bearing lofty message by both has no predecessor .
Dear Brother.
I am really excited to see a Muslim who is specialized in cosmology. I have been longing to understand cosmology and the quranic understanding. Would you be kind enough to start a series on cosmology in Islam view with this particular guest of yours. thank you in advance.
I love the last point very much … very brilliant point بارك الله بكم
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
At the end of everything, i can't accept nor imagine that the very almighty God
that created the this whole universe and can vanish it in less than a second
would be humiliated or beaten. Never ever.
MashaAllah, have no words left, this is the first time i am seeing Dr. Fatoohi , Alhamdulillah he's doing a fantastic job.
And your channel as well, your video of king Charles 3 about Islam randomly came 2-3 days ago to me.
Thank you
Subscribed you
Congratulations once again for brilliant content and discussion. These discussions are so valuable and you learn a tremendous amount. Shukran to both of you. May Allah grant you health to present many more of these wonderful interviews
May Allah reward you both for that pertinent, brilliant analysis. Jazakoum Allah kheir
Enjoyed your university class.
May Allah bless you brother Paul snd Louay. This discussion was an iman booster. I would have loved to hear more from you brother Paul about your reflections on the Quranic description of the disciples that you mentioned almost at the end.
Love the simple explanation with PowerPoint presentation 🌹 no confusion, very clear
May Allah reward you
Best comparative narrative out there, great content and useful
I am a descendent of bani Joseph tribe according to my pashtun side of family
Get a DNA test.
@@letmetalk2240 no need....we can trace back to Abraham
My brother.
Another small, but might be significant, is what brothers of Yousef used to come and carry the Goods on in Quran is Camels … while in the Biblical story it was Donkeys.. the significance is the distances they were travelling and the needs to carry big amounts of Goods which only camels can !
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
Thank you both
This vid was fantastic thanks Paul and dr
You guys give brothers vibe 😭❤️
Hi Paul.I am glad your keeping well. God will use whom , he will. You Paul is that person who is representing God. You are a chosen one. May God guide you and strengthen you. ❤️🥰👍✌🏽
I feel enriched with the insights given by you, Dr.Fatoohi.
Thank you for hosting him in BT.
May Allah bless you both.
Alhamdulillah
Great, great & great. Thank you both.
May Alloh SWT blessed you both in Jannah,the good explaination about the two books...🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿
Surah number 12 & joseph was number 12 in the family
“Jacob lost his sight but not his faith “
Nice comment ( reminder) by Dr. L
Thanks to both brothers .
Just my thought :
Br. Paul from west and Dr. L from East . Meet on this channel
East and West belong to Allah and His light illuminates East and west. Inshallah one day peace shall prevail .
I highly recommend the book that Dr. Louay wrote about this subject
Biggest ignorance in human life is human ability to follow forefathers rather than searching truth
MashAllah, this is unbelievably in depth and intriguing. JazakAllah brothers
Amazing discussion
Great analysis, Dr. Fatoohi is a really balanced and insightful scholar.
Yes, so interesting. It is so fascinating after some deep study of the Bible and the Quran and then see a qualified person compare the two. It is fascinating how the Quran constantly subverts the biblical message (in a good way) like how Jacob's death scene becomes about God and not about tribes.
I wish this page removes these scam like ads but besides that great discussion.
May Alloh SWT,bless both,...Aamiinyarobalamin...🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿
Woww! What a wonderful analysis! Thanks #Paul for inviting this scholar.
A merger of bookshelves!!
The story of Yusuf (es) is not only beautiful in its content but style. Ibn tayyimiah thought when Quran talks surah Yusuf (es) to be the best of قصص which could be interpreted by best in style or rhetoric that can be said of course for every ayah in any case. It’s unique virtue as masterpiece in everything, whether , content, style rhetoric etc. The story is precise and beautifully related with many lessons that can be extracted from each and every verse.
There were two Saudi brothers Who extracted 1000 lessons from the story of Yusuf (es)
MashaAllah.
Asma. Haq. Yusuf.
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
@exhale inhale Haney is not reliable and comes up with fringe interpretations. The man claims he has been revealed a secret way to interpret the quran, and those before him did not do it correctly and his way is the correct way. Don't promote that man. Farid responds has exposed him already
Salam to both of you, thank you so much, what a great discussion
Am always looking out for more from Dr louay fatoohi. Thank you brother Paul. May Allah reward you.
tqvm doc n bro paul for discussing this topic..very interesting 👍❤😁
The Pharaoh at the time of Joseph is called a king in the book of _Jubilees_ , dated to c. 200 BCE; after the _Torah_ had been composed and 900 years before the composition of the Qur'an. _Jubilees_ was a well known text already, and is clearly a source used to compose both the Qur'an and biography of Muhammad.
Qur'an Chapter 12 is demonstrably a written account of an oral text, a retelling of the Joseph story found in Genesis, Chapters 37-50 (but also from other sources, as mentioned above). As the guest speaker explains, the Genesis story of Joseph is more detailed than the Qur'an (i e. provides details, such as names, locations, etc, which are mostly absent in _Sura_ 12). This should be expected in a retelling, where literary texture is typically lost due to forgetfulness and other (often intentional) changes to the narrative text: oftentimes, names and numbers are forgotten during retellings, as only the gist is conveyed. By way of example, the Qur'an doesn't identify the traders who bought Joseph; does not mention the names of Joseph's brothers; does not tell of Joseph's age or how much he was sold for; and so on.
The emphases of the story are changed too: the trauma of Jacob's grief at losing his favourite son is lost in the Qur'an, which adds theological elements to the text (as noted in the presentation).
No doubt, many textual variations in the Joseph story occurred during its transmission and performance, such that the Qur'an version itself may have been adapted for its audience multiple times before being canonised; such as the story of Jacob having his sight returned to him by having his head covered by a piece of Joseph's clothing. After all, the biblical story repeatedly tells us that Jacob could see (e.g. Gen. 42:35; 45:27; 46:30).
It's worth noting that the Qur'ān seemingly uses 'Pharaoh/فرعون' as a proper name rather than a mere title (like al-malik ~ the king), since the word lacks the definite article and is indeclinable (ghayr munṣarif) because it doesn't receive tanwīn (nunation) - Firʻawnᵘ as opposed to Firʻawnᵘⁿ, as is the case with other foreign proper names in the Qur'ān (Ibrāhīmᵘ, Ismāʻīlᵘ, Hārūnᵘ etc.)
@@noahrue470 Thank you, Noah, for your valued response. I hope you don't mind that I have added your comment to my Qur'an notes.
Of course Hebrew grammar does not contain the definite article, but simply refers to 'Pharaoh' (פרעה). Perhaps this could be one reason why the Qur'an uses the name, فرءون, as a proper name rather than a title?
@Gavin James It wouldn‘t explain why the Qur'ān uses Firʻawn as a proper name only for the Pharaoh of Exodus, since the Hebrew Bible applies the given term without a definite article for several rulers, and not simply for the former. After all, numerous Qur'ānic commentators _do_ assert that he had a distinct proper name (often given as al-Walīd bin Muṣʻab). Of course, despite these grammatical concerns, I don‘t fully rule out that it could be a mere title transformed into a quasi-proper name in the Qur'ān, similar to how Arabic Islamic sources use the general term Qayṣar (Caesar) as a sort of proper name for Emperor Heraclius.
@@noahrue470 I actually checked _Genesis_ 41:1 (JPS _Tanakh_ , Hebrew-English), because I'm interested in the Joseph story, here. But I think you are correct concerning the grammar.
Thank you.
SubhanAllah Wal hamdulillah Wa la ilaha illallahu Wallahu Akhbar...!!!
You all, our beloved brothers sisters, who do dawah voluntarily on the streets and everywhere on earth, with sincerity, your own efforts and willingness, are the best among the Ummah. We love you all. We therefore seek mercy and help from Allah SWT to grant our brothers and sisters with the strength, courage, bravery and good health, to bring the messages of our Rasulullah Mohammed PBUH to all mankind and grant you all, our brothers and sisters, with a place in Jannah. Aamiin Yarobbil Aalamiin 🕌 🌙 🤲🤲🤲 💖 🌹
1:43:00 this theory of Prophet Muhammad (sas) compiling all these known and unknown sources in order to produce the Qur'an becomes even more ridiculous when you consider the mere time it would consume of a person. How on earth should the Prophet be able to have done it during his migration to Medina, all the battles, being a husband, father, friend, imam and so on. We would have to hear : oh on this occasion he was unavailable because he was compiling/putting together the Qur'an 🙈 but nobody ever claimed this about the prophet. And on top of it, imagine, all of this in the oral form 🤯 so at the end this orientalist arrive at a theory which in itself would require a miracle in order to be true 😅
In any case: barakallahu fik brother Paul for the excellent kind of content you provide.
i loved this episode so much ❤️❤️ so rich in informations thank you
Glad you enjoyed it!
Brother Paul, a kind suggestion: it would be great if you show the guest and your image a little bit bigger, you have a room .. it is nice to see you guys while you are speaking plus the text does not need to be so huge.. 2 third of the screen for the text and 1 third (your images). thanks may Allah protect you give you light, increase your knoweldge and give you success in both world and your loved ones and all of us amin.
It might be bound to the program they used for the conference
@@Markussiemens658 thanks brother, I thought with all the advancement in programming such option would be basic. Thanks though for answering.
@Blogging Theology Would it be possible for you to invite Karen Armstrong?
Oh wow!!! Yes . I asked many months ago too. She is a bit new age now but her knowledge on Islam is one of the best
That would be amazing-in addition to Dr. F. -to invite Karen Armstrong on your awesome Blogging Theology would be wonderful:))) In’sha’Allah
Make multi languages captions for the videos please
this is high level of analysis , i think this should be like postdoc lectures in religion comparing departments .
Watch Nouman Ali Khan's "Surah Yusuf" series to really appriciate the amazing story. It's long but worth it. Bayinnah also has about 3 episodes (that I could find) for Bible/Qur'an comparison on Joseph (pbuh).
Nouman Ali Khan is not someone you should be taking from. He’s a jaahil.
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
@@samboy90 Why did you say this about Mr.Nouman?!
Pretty incredible. Just had a talk with a christian friend and we talk about the issue of the name Pharaoh not being in use during Joseph’s time. He wanted proofs, well Allah is the best of planners.
I'd love this for every prophet
Great job, brother Paul. Now we need another episode that covers the differences between them on the story of Moses!
The story of Musa as is already covered on this channel. Very interesting.
always wanted to know more about prophet joseph peace be upon him, allah humma barak uncle paul, salaam
Amazing!, Highly appreciated
Glad you liked it!
The Quran has no errors. Only thing that wasn’t emphasized when he was giving examples at the end of this wonderful discussion.
Scholarly discussion bordered on realistic evidences, comparative resources and prevailing misconceptions. The story of Prophet Joseph (aws) as narrated in the Holy Qur'an, shed lights to some inconsistencies contained in the bible and added more realistic true happenings...
Allah Wakbar!
Can you please bring him to compare the story of Dhulqarnain and the legends of Alexander
Most channels remove comments that contain a link. You can reach the video by placing the following title in the TH-cam search box and Inshaa’Allah you will find it (by Al Mudarabah Channel)
{Why was the Quran not revealed to him all at once?} - Is there a Repetition in the Holy Quran?
If you want to learn the true story of Yusuf, go check the marvelous Quran channel on TH-cam for the Truth derived from within the Quran. I'll give you a spoiler... There were no sex scenes...
Check out the story of dhulqarnayn too
Salaam Paul. In the Quran the high priest of pharaoh is mentioned by name (haman) and commanded to build a high tower. Is there any mention of this name in other scriptures or archiolgical finds? Jzk
there are multiple Jewish Torahs such as the Samaritan, Babylonian Septuagint, the masoretic( current version) as well as the alexanderian text so how can it be considered one text
Great insights
I expected the King-Pharaoh naming difference to be a much lengthy subject in this discussion.
It was only a few minutes. But also learned many more subtle differences.
to Bro Paul
AsSlamunAlaykum, I would appreciate it if you could relay this information to Dr. Ali Ataie. And if you can't then at least I tried to inform him. At least he will get the chance to evaluate it.
This is a symbol that is YHWH. First it is not a name and it is not a spoken word. It is an adjective that is attributive and descriptive. Also it is some form of an acronym. Also it is not a word that is pronounceable but it can be acted out. Also it is Arabic in origin. Until Moses/Musa AS went to Median the Israelites were not given this "Name" of Allah AwJ. Moses/Musa AS received it after he met His Father in-law Jethro/Shoayb AS, in Median. Jethro/Shoayb AS was an Arab. Before then the Israelites did not know God by that "Name".
Exo 6:3 And I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto Jacob, by the name of God Almighty, but by my name JEHOVAH was I not known to them.
So This "NAME" was revealed to Him through Jethro/Shoayb AS who was a Prophet. And since Jethro was an Arab He spoke Arabic. And YHWH was not pronounced because it cannot be pronounced. It is an acronym because each letter signifies something. However it is acted out in a sense. In the Quran there is Stand alone letters like ALM or TH or YS or KHYAS, that is evidence that Arabs used this type of communication for those that could understand the intricacies of the Arabic Language. And most IMPORTANTLY it was a SIGN for the Jews as well as for the Arabs, that they would be able to confirm that What The Prophet REVEALED was from Allah AwJ. Since YHWH is in the Arabic style of Communication, one would have to decipher it's meaning using the Arabic Language.
Let me elaborate. "YHWH" : The "Y" or YA is, as is in Arabic a vocative or beseeching. Like saying - "OH" my Father or "OH" my Mother. Like wise it signifies "OH" my God. this is where you have many Jews and Christians that will say the Name of God is YAH.
The first "H" stands for breathing in or out. So if you stand really quite and take a BREATH you will notice a slight H sounding voice emitted. The "W" WA as is in Arabic means "and". The second "H" also signifies to a BREATHING, in or out. One breath always follows the other. So if you accept that God gave the Breath of Life then it becomes apparent that this action is being done by people as long as they are alive. Everyone is alive by expressing this "NAME" of God. The only difference between people is that Believers do this invoking God and being Grateful/Hamd and disbelievers are doing it in ignorance, but doing it none the less. So when you are doing the action "Ya(H)Hu" by breathing in and out while invoking the vocative "Ya", you can appreciate the meaning. In essence it stands for beseeching God/Allah AwJ by saying "OH the one who has given me the ability to BREATH IN AND BREATH OUT". In other words "LIFE" / EXISTANCE. As Muslims say " ya hay ياحي "
Let me add that this is similar to the "HURÛF-ı MUKATTAAT
الحروف المقطّعة"
These are the stand alone letters that are in the Beginning of some of the Surats/Chapters in the Quran. The Stand Alone Letters which are original in the Quran and are in the Arabic Language. So it is ONE of the Reasons that The Jews should be able to RECOGNIZE that the Quran is a Revelation from God because of this anomaly.
The "HURÛF-ı MUKATTAAT in the Quran must also have had this correlation with the Scripture that Moses had BROUGHT from God.
Allahu AA'lam . Salam.
Subhanallaah wa Tabaraqallaahh. Its because of their so very extreme nationalism, as a result they dont even have a name for the Creator of all existence, except HaShem or HaShim in Arabic.
I'm sure Sam Gerrans theory can be combined with this to form something really synergetic. Well done and thank you, very enlightening.
Stealing "Allah's Blessing" form a Prophet (a.s) how can People believe men can steal Prophethood form the Lord of all word's!