This Fucker's name is Vitaliy Milonov. He is abnormal dude with stupid ideas and crazy personality.... If she did that every Russian would had a relief cuz he is such burden to society u cannot imagine
@@aidankelder2004 does that mean parents also have the right to abuse children, as government has no right to intervene? What type of logic is this? May be you support pedophiles as well because "government has no right to interfere in the house"
@@sammatthew2841 on a general basis no the government has no place in the home whatsoever. when abuse is involved when it gets to a particular degree then the government should step in. In terms of physical violence. a little bit should be tolerated
I'm Russian, and this law has been met with criticism even in my homeland. There is a history of violence towards women in my family: psychological, financial, physical, sexual. Many women experience abuse here, but decide not to tell for several reasons: First of all (but not the most important), we have a saying -- не выноси сор из избы. "Do not air dirty linen in public" would have the same meaning in English. When there are problems at home, you don't discuss it with people outside family. Then, women might not divorce abusive husband (or even report abuse) because "my son needs to have a father in order to grow up a real man", "at least my husband is not an alcoholic/unfaithful", "I want my kids to have a full family", "I don't have a job to feed my children" or "well, he said he was sorry, and I still love him, so I forgive". So consider that the statistics gathered from the women who talked about abuse might be the tip of an iceberg. The politician in the glasses is known for his orthodox views, and he often speaks in favour of the Russian church and traditional family views, and he is very vocal against homosexuality (or any sexuality besides being straight) or something that "poses threat to Russian spirituality". He gets fun made of him on the internet because of his radical propositions (make childfree a psychological abnormality and public declaration of it -- extremism, sell sex toys only if doctor prescribes them, block dating websites, create "day of fighting against abortions", create a patriotic order and make it mandatory for children to join it [and make them wear patriotic scarves on the neck], and many more). I didn't mention him personally going to LGBT events and trying to ruin and close them down, because meh that's not even a surprise.
Well, my dear, you can criticize him all you want but he represents the ruling ideology, somehow he can openly speak this kind of vile stuff on camera but I doubt you or anyone else would dare to oppose Putin on camera with your face and name. So enjoy your dictatorship, you created it and now the world hates you. Ukraine hates your government, Baltics hates your government, Poland hates your government. I'm just glad we are no longer part of that shithow and can live in a much more free and fair society. Russia is lost forever.
I'm sure a someone called Pedro can provide a much more accurate and valuable insight into women's rights and domestic abuse in Russia, than an actual Russian woman.
"my son needs to have a father in order to grow up a real man" I'm from the America where women have the father removed by the courts so they can simply "Trade up" and collect a check each month from the government while they do so. The boys who grow up without a father either grow up to be extremely violent robbers,rapers,killers (20x more likely to go to prison) or cuckolds who like watching foreigners take their women.
You missed the guys point entirely..He saying in the simplest cases the punishment does not fit the crime and made things worse for the family. .The family didn't it want the laws the way they were..The media takes the worse case scenario an uses as an example of common domestic fights.
@Kiki Melendez No DV Is not built the same. You can't paint a broad brush. That's where the problem lies. There's a uge difference between a red mark and a broken arm, leg, ruptured spleen etc. That's why the the law has a tier system. The DV laws are their own enemy.
@Kiki Melendez There isn't a point speaking with people like you, people like you paint with a broad brush, that's the problem and you end up devaluing the laws..People like you are your own worst enemy.. There isn't a doubt in my mind that you have been a victim of domestic violence which leaves your opinion bias and suspicious..All DV is not the same, YOU'RE WRONG.. Get off your high horse.
@@cogen651 a man beat his wife to point where she was covered in bruises and begging him to stop he even recorded it and put on the internet for his friends to see and he never went to jail
I once met a Russian Woman while I was on vacation. She walked up to me and asked me for a drink. I ordered a tequila from the bartender for her as she was having trouble speaking english. I believed she thanked me and proceeded to enjoy her drink. She was just in the middle of asking me something else when an angry Russian Man walked up behind her and Slapped her full in the face. I got up to separate them as he proceeded to slap her again across the face. The sound of his hand striking her face was like thunder. It echoed throughout the resort. My friends and I were able to separate them and call security but she walked off to him. He grabbed her by the hair and dragged her back into their hotel. We last saw them being chased by security into the night. 100% true story This is why Feminism needs to exist. Every Modernized country has gone through this situation and made laws to protect women once women are allowed the opportunity to organize themselves. Seeing what Russia's idea of Family Values is truly chilling when witnessed first hand. If you had a Daughter who married a Russian Man and decided to move there to be with him, would you not want there to be a Feminist Movement right about now?
No, because Feminism is not about equal human treatment, but rather has a far deeper agenda. When the Feminist movement started here, I recognized certain disparities and unfair treatment, and believe that those were wrong and opposed them. As things progressed, and I read feminist founders literature, and learned about the underlying philosophy, I rejected it as well. Whenever people in the 1980's asked if I was a feminist, I answered, "No, I am an Equalist."
Zizu and East west, this about white Christian man not about black, brown or Muslims so you racist islamophobics need to shut up and stop bringing Muslims, Blacks and browns in every topic that has nothing to do with them. You angry because this guy has stated that a white sexist guy beat a poor woman.
@Zizu Zai If he was to have done something, that male individual might have taken it out on her for making a "scene" or "getting him in trouble" or he could've killed her. Situations like that aren't black and white. It's a complicated thing.
Keith Roy - I don’t know about other feminists. But why I personally still claim myself to be a feminist rather than what you’ve claimed is because I think women need to be more uplifted before sex based egalitarianism can be more appropriately pushed for. It’s hard to say I’m an ‘equalist’ or an ‘egalitarian’ (sex based for this discussion) when the problem I see is rooted around the notion of females. Men are popularly considered as less for being or even potentially being like women. For being “feminine”. Being feminine is meant to equate the quality’s that make up a woman, or generals of women in general. Yet it’s often associated poorly, being feminine by men is popularly perceived as weak. That notion is twisted. That’s a problem. And it’s from what I perceive to be notions like that, towards issues like male/female treatment, that I struggle to yet call my self an egalitarian. But I get your stance, but I can’t unfortunately yet complete agree.
Omar TheOwner - I’m a “feminist” and I don’t want domestic violence against men. What your perceiving are a number of popular news blown women who hate men verbally and actively hate men. And who then perceive to claim that this declaration of disdain brings women equality. That’s horrid, not true* and just not sensical. But then again your comments about the perceived general sensibility of women seems rather sexist. So I’m unsure as to how much sense (you as a person, not as a thing with a defined sex) have.
Well.I'm Russian and I can't bear this shit Milonov said. How can such people be a part of modern power system? My country associates with Medieval times because of it. I don't want you to think that normal citizens admit authoritarian biopolitics. And what is the funniest thing? "The government shouln't control family life". It sounds good without any context. But this guy wants to ban abortion all over the country. What nonsense...
the guy is obviously a orthodox Christian fundamentalist. we have them also here in serbia, unfortunately. sometimes l long back for communism just because commies sure did place those backward clergy people where they belong.
Ксения Дербуш Queen Queenly American women abuse there husbands far worst and all ya got do is beat your husband controlled his every move cheat on him and call the cops and send him to jail
Maybe he needs for first make abortion for money. If you want do it but pay for it. I don't understand why all taxpayers should pay for someone's abortion
Russia is poor, it’s surprising to say but it’s very poor, Putin does nothing. I don’t know why people admire him but he sucks, an old man of the last century still fighting to stay in command instead of bringing someone Young and New to share their better ideas or at least “An idea” for the Russian Economy.
If you look at professional fighters they have at least enlarged brow ridge flattened noses sunken eyes damaged nerves puffy cheeks. And Fights are years apart and have refories. But not just her face how she walks stands is in better health. If melt plates were placed before aging bone size reduction they should be showing. And joint erosion
As a human being i feel bad for them. Now ive never hit a woman in my life. Im a single father who works everday and takes care of his 2 children. When i come accross some russian or middle eastern women they give me a look like i want to rob them or something lol. They should be more afraid of there own husbands than me lol. This world is crazy is all i can say.
It's Western propoganda. They've been taught to fear brown men, despite their own men posing far more danger to them. Once internet access is available to all people, stereotypes like this will subside.
As a Russian I just want to remind some people in the comments that Russian citizens and Russian government are two different things. There are a lot of us here who are against Putin's politics. We're just always left out in the media coverage.
after he gets off from work, he goes to youtube, downvotes every Vice video, makes fun of vegans, condemns LGBT, then calls liberals retards. if there is any evidence against him, he call it fake news. geez, this is familiar.
I had to watch my mother almost get beaten to death, a fine or 2 years will never fix that burden on my mind, what is so difficult about protecting your countries women
You do realise women are always the first to start hitting? Men only hit back when they finally have enough and snap. When the women get in their place, domestic violence will fade.
My beautiful beloved Alina (who stands 5'5") is routinely abused by her husband Daniel (who stands 6'4"). And people tell me I have no right to try and help her!!!
@@categories5066i. Fact women have always been patient .u have a historian on ur profile pic but u dont know shit bout history and how men were beating us the whole time domestic abuse will stop if only men knew their place (and women )but u saying women hit first in domestic marriages makes even feel more bad for u
My son's father attacked me and my 3 year old son. Caused bruising. Cops took pictures, arrested him. He was in jail for 12 days, and 3 years informal probation. In Oregon, USA, in 2015.
So you're telling me that this woman's ex-husband hit her with an ax and beat his mom...and the police still didn't believe her?! That's fucked up, this law has no regards to human rights. This is why I'm not *ever* going to Russia.
Kinda true in a way. Doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be punished, but a society that fucked in the head is probably doomed no matter what the powers that be may try to do
He's right. When wives absorb feminist influences and think they are equals to the husband instead of subservient, the husband has to enforce the God ordained hierarchy. Just like how increased acts of defending against burglary should occur when burglary increases.
FREE MONEY CLICK NOW hmm let's see he called women Pig 🐷 dog 🐶 slobs, disgusting animal, insulted Muslim women, let's not forget "I can grab them by the pu-- remark". 😂but you are right no convictions
No this is only a portion of Russians with extremist ideology with super orthodox views. They mainly come from deprived regions from broken families. Majority of them don't even have money to travel to nearest Belarus, Ukraine or baltic nations. Your ideology is like judging English people by those working class football hooligans who stormed Wembley
There is no excuse for domestic violence anywhere to anyone. As a Russian kid growing up in a Russian family it hurts everyone and helps no one, when I got hit it scarred me for life and made my parents feel bad. My mother being hit by my father is making me scarred and her traumatized and hurt. It doesn't help anyone. Russian families are all like this, I can confirm that 100% every family has experienced violence. The father of the family is always the biggest and most powerful in the family and their wives are suffering from it. It's just not a way to live like that, with pain in silence. But it's hard to change that, nearly impossible, when a whole country works that way and even supports it.
He says people don’t want the government controlling what happens in their home. Last I heard it’s illegal to be gay/ lesbian in Russia. Make that make sense!!!
Alonzo Aldaba Russian news make him look like the best President/man the world has ever seen. People tend to believe in the made up image of him, they like to believe in a "fairy tale"
he made this country great and powerfull, threw out corrupt oligarchs has a deep love for the russian family conservative views, made it legal to go to church without getting records at FSB this whole video is propaganda, if person complains to police that there husband is hitting them the police will go there there house and put him to prison, majority goes to jail as the person telling the police has the most power. majority of people who goes to police gets justice.
Committing assault or murder should be illegal with the same penalties whether one's offence is against a stranger or a family member. To have it any other way only benefits the individual committing the violence.
The people who approved the bill should be made aware that violence is never a tradition or value of any decent family. I feel for the lady whose abusive husband will be out in 6 years. I hope she can get herself some skills or education that will allow her to make some money and move to a place far away from where she is now where she can start a new life with her daughter.
Violence may not be a tradition or value of a decent family, but the God ordained hierarchy in families is. Ideally, the husband should never have to enforce the ordained hierarchy but the reality is that sometimes he has to. Russia has made it that this enforcement isn't illegal.
@@louiebrown5515 What if the man had a bad day at work and want to beat someone to relieve the tension? He could beat his boss, but he's aware that he will be fired if he does it. So " the perfect punching bag" is his wife, even though she has nothing to do with it. Or he likes to drink alcohol too much and he becomes violent when he's drunk and start assaulting his wife. Or what if his wife gets sick or disabled and can't be anymore as "submissive" as his husband likes? Then what? Would he leave her for a woman that is healthy enough to sastify all his needs and desires?
3:34 So you're against intruding into the bedroom? Then surely you believe that the rights of LGBT people need to be respected. Right? Right? Hey where did ya go buddy? Come back here.
4:01 "By...Anti-fascists...not by normal people" I don't know where you come from but here in America normal people are anti fascists and I would expect you are too being once on the the biggest communist countries in the world lol.
@Rick Quicker I'm a Ukrainian German, sit down. Contrary to your dumpster fire of a country Germany knows how to learn from its history and teaches the future generations.
I feel like I should be surprised......but then I remember this is Russia we are talking about, there is very little European in that country. Soviet times have not ended there
Thank you God I don't live in Russia. Domestic abuse should be judged independently case by case. The guy talks scrap. That poor woman look at her abuse.
one thing about abuse it that once you have someone abusing you, you know that if you 'let him go' -as if its thats easy to get a psycho to go away from what he feels is his prey,once they are gone you are 100% sure youve just released a monster on an unsuspecting woman whose life he will ruin next and you feel guilty or as if you need to follow him around warning his future partners for the rest of your life. These types of men should be caged and not left for women to deal with alone, manyof the abusers will choose a woman who has no where else to go and make sure they impregnate their girlfriend to force her to try to work it out which it will never ever do, he will never change.
@MissDroplette 1.An administrative penalty is established by Article 73 of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Administrative Offenses" in the form of a warning or administrative arrest for a period of three to ten days, if repeated within a year after the imposition of an administrative penalty, it entails an administrative arrest for up to ten days or a fine of five monthly calculation indicators. 2.Administrative detention consists in the imprisonment of a person who has committed domestic violence, with compulsory detention in a special room. Police just close their eyes on domestic abuse, they usually say "Come back later when it will get worse" and corruption. If abuser worked in police or has connection with them, they don't do nothing or abuser just give them bride.
Actually this problem is not about penalty for domestic violence. Main problem is very low level of life in Russia (real averege montly income beyond Moscow is about 200-300 dollars) and no chances to any personal developement. All these problems lead to alchogolism and crimes.
Hello, guys. I'm from Russia. I'm living in town from this video. This is not a fake, it's cruel truth. Sorry for my bad english language, but I want to say: Milonov a piece of shit, laws of our country very abusive, very awful. My father is abuser, my mom lived in terror before divorce. I hated this situation, our government makes our life is terribble. It's scared. Really scared. I want to believe: one day we are make new world, we are living new life, without homophobia, domestic violence, stupid law-system and other bad things.
In Australia they say 1 woman dies every week whilst in Russia, 1 every 40 minutes. These are disgusting statistics. i'm hoping they're over exaggerated.
No wonder Putin is single, his ex wife dumped him and she did it right, he's inhuman and that reflects in his actions and also in the politics of it's country! So sorry for Russian women have to go through this, you are all beautiful!!
If look at professional fighters they at least have enlarged brow ridge flattened noses sunken eyes damaged nerves puffy cheeks . and Fights are year's apart and have refories. .yet woman in this documentary . some how not just her face she walks and standing better health . For taking lot worse less restricted damage more frequently. She has metle plates replacing her Joints. But that has nothing joint aroson. It from what she discribed would be in a week shear and plats should be showing sense were in planted before aging bone size
We rather read and comment ignorant reply's, than read a book which is hard to understand. Capitalism with Asian values will win, because our democratic model can't compete.
Implying one cannot comment and read a book. I use my computer to read books *as well*, thank you sir. And everyone should catch up on their history books.
I wonder what happens when a woman beats a man up. I bet they put them in jail. and what if you koll one of the fuckers saving your life. This absolutely sickens me.
Seriously?? He finally got put into prison after he finally killed someone. If they have put him into prison wayyy before, the neighbor's life would be saved. These politicians are shit. You can see how ignorant Milonov is when he cuts off the interviewer
"Condemned by whom? Not by the normal people. Normal people, normal families, they said "No". You can't take our rights to beat our wives, daughters, sisters and mothers!".
I know this is not propper to say but maybe someone should show that Milonov, with his Stone Age mindset, what it's like so he won't consider it some "normal" occurrence. Sickening. Any man or woman who beats their s.o. severely deserves the death penalty.
Yes true, but the problem is you are a feminist in a supposedly gender equal society. we need feminists in these countries where women are oppressed. Western Europe may not be perfect for women, but its not perfect for men either because nothing is perfect! Think about it - would you take a wage about 10 pounds lower than men or live in a poverty stricken country? The point is issues about wage gap are too small in a desperate world.
30 years in the US men got a warning for the first offense. Seen a woman bashed with a butcher knife and the man get a warning. The kids witnessed it and got no help. Yall should do a video for domestic violence in america.
I had a relative take anger out on me when I was younger. If this person had a bad day at work, my life would be Hell. This person had some unstable partners who made the other person even madder. This person's current partner has changed this person into a human again. I've learned quite a bunch about bringing out the good in people by watching this partner. Reminds me of 1001 Arabian Nights. I try not to feed other people my sickness and take a more active role into thinking about consequences.
I use to think highly of Putin now I lost all respect for him No respect for Putin and how he keep that Country quiet on how awful it must be to live there
Im Far Right but come on I think that's one thing we all can agree on that domestic violence is a no good at all simple it can and will destroy family's, Now I do believe in 1 for 1 meaning you give me 1 I'll give you 1
I remember how a father whose family was at risk of destroying itself. His son had been indoctrinated into mutilating himself and his wife was supportive. At his wits end, he did what had to be done and what God demands to protect his home. He used his God-given strength to enforce his God ordained authority in his home. Since he was in the west, he was punished for protecting his family and while in prison, his son mutilated himself. The story would go the exact opposite way in Russia.
Shows that women there are remorseful when their disobedience gets punished and will hide that their husband was forced to enforce God's ordained hierarchy in the home.
Mr. Putin, how could you allow this? You do not seem to me to be a man whom could have any respect for a coward who beats women. As I have always had a deep love and respect for Rus folk, I find it hard to "believe" the President or his advisors would be alright with such violence towards wives and mothers. Yes I would agree with the man in this video that Society going down morality wise is a huge problem not just for Rossiya but the entire world.
According to Russian law, beatings are the infliction of physical pain without causing harm to health and are an administrative offense. If these actions caused harm to health, then this is the intentional infliction of harm to health, which is a criminal offense.
How do Russian politicians keep people safe when they safe domestic violence is ok? Battered people who wouldn't hurt others live in fear. I am sad and scared for anyone abusive situation. "Normal" disagreements are verbal, NOT physical.
This and the war on Ukraine is the reason I say down on Russia and down on Putin. Hopefully Russia falls and gets colonized one day by sensible people.
That poor lady, Mrs. Orlova, lives in Ufa. My beautiful beloved Alina left Ufa to escape a brutal father--only to marry an American man who abuses her every chance he gets!!!
VICE News went to meet those behind the changes, as well as the people most affected.
WATCH more Isobel Yeung on VICE News Tonight - bit.ly/2yp3Rk2
Alex Miletic How much does Kremlin lay you to write this?
Do you have an update on Gulnara Orlova??? Her husband would be out of prison now. I watched this episode when it originally aired.
Do you have an update on Gulnara Orlova??? Her husband would be out of prison now. I watched this episode when it originally aired.
Normal people don't beat their spouses.
Yea obviously they hack them with axes instead.
Common Russian proverb - "If He Beats You, It Means He Loves You" "Если бьет, значит любит" Explains all about the society there.
lib cucks
+K J-U north koreans cant afford salami
Benedikt Huebner There is no such thing as normal people.
you can tell that the interviewer really wanted to punch him in the face
Yeah, physical abuse is a right only women are given towards men.
the guy had a good point though, the government has no place in the house or bedroom.
the the husband and wife figure things out between them
This Fucker's name is Vitaliy Milonov. He is abnormal dude with stupid ideas and crazy personality.... If she did that every Russian would had a relief cuz he is such burden to society u cannot imagine
@@aidankelder2004 does that mean parents also have the right to abuse children, as government has no right to intervene? What type of logic is this? May be you support pedophiles as well because "government has no right to interfere in the house"
@@sammatthew2841 on a general basis no the government has no place in the home whatsoever.
when abuse is involved when it gets to a particular degree then the government should step in. In terms of physical violence.
a little bit should be tolerated
I'm Russian, and this law has been met with criticism even in my homeland. There is a history of violence towards women in my family: psychological, financial, physical, sexual. Many women experience abuse here, but decide not to tell for several reasons:
First of all (but not the most important), we have a saying -- не выноси сор из избы. "Do not air dirty linen in public" would have the same meaning in English. When there are problems at home, you don't discuss it with people outside family. Then, women might not divorce abusive husband (or even report abuse) because "my son needs to have a father in order to grow up a real man", "at least my husband is not an alcoholic/unfaithful", "I want my kids to have a full family", "I don't have a job to feed my children" or "well, he said he was sorry, and I still love him, so I forgive". So consider that the statistics gathered from the women who talked about abuse might be the tip of an iceberg.
The politician in the glasses is known for his orthodox views, and he often speaks in favour of the Russian church and traditional family views, and he is very vocal against homosexuality (or any sexuality besides being straight) or something that "poses threat to Russian spirituality". He gets fun made of him on the internet because of his radical propositions (make childfree a psychological abnormality and public declaration of it -- extremism, sell sex toys only if doctor prescribes them, block dating websites, create "day of fighting against abortions", create a patriotic order and make it mandatory for children to join it [and make them wear patriotic scarves on the neck], and many more). I didn't mention him personally going to LGBT events and trying to ruin and close them down, because meh that's not even a surprise.
alexa saperstein dont be lazy, come up with new stuff instead of copy pasting your shit everywhere
Well, my dear, you can criticize him all you want but he represents the ruling ideology, somehow he can openly speak this kind of vile stuff on camera but I doubt you or anyone else would dare to oppose Putin on camera with your face and name. So enjoy your dictatorship, you created it and now the world hates you. Ukraine hates your government, Baltics hates your government, Poland hates your government. I'm just glad we are no longer part of that shithow and can live in a much more free and fair society. Russia is lost forever.
I'm sure a someone called Pedro can provide a much more accurate and valuable insight into women's rights and domestic abuse in Russia, than an actual Russian woman.
Stop it bot of kremlin, dont ctrl+c ctrl+v your bullshit comment.
"my son needs to have a father in order to grow up a real man" I'm from the America where women have the father removed by the courts so they can simply "Trade up" and collect a check each month from the government while they do so. The boys who grow up without a father either grow up to be extremely violent robbers,rapers,killers (20x more likely to go to prison) or cuckolds who like watching foreigners take their women.
Domestic violence is never ok period
You missed the guys point entirely..He saying in the simplest cases the punishment does not fit the crime and made things worse for the family. .The family didn't it want the laws the way they were..The media takes the worse case scenario an uses as an example of common domestic fights.
@Kiki Melendez No DV Is not built the same. You can't paint a broad brush.
That's where the problem lies. There's a uge difference between a red mark and a broken arm, leg, ruptured spleen etc. That's why the the law has a tier
system. The DV laws are their own enemy.
@Kiki Melendez There isn't a point speaking with people like you, people like you paint with a broad brush, that's the problem and you end up devaluing the laws..People like you are your own worst enemy..
There isn't a doubt in my mind that you have been a victim of domestic violence which leaves your opinion bias and suspicious..All DV is not the same, YOU'RE WRONG..
Get off your high horse.
@carlos blanco I guess you beat your spouse on a monthly basis or you will in future. Ok.
@@cogen651 a man beat his wife to point where she was covered in bruises and begging him to stop he even recorded it and put on the internet for his friends to see and he never went to jail
I had no idea treating a woman with respect is a liberal policy!
That explains a lot.
I just thought it's was human decency.
It really isn't something that should be politicized.
@@CanadianBullFrog that, and combatting climate change
I once met a Russian Woman while I was on vacation. She walked up to me and asked me for a drink. I ordered a tequila from the bartender for her as she was having trouble speaking english. I believed she thanked me and proceeded to enjoy her drink. She was just in the middle of asking me something else when an angry Russian Man walked up behind her and Slapped her full in the face.
I got up to separate them as he proceeded to slap her again across the face. The sound of his hand striking her face was like thunder. It echoed throughout the resort. My friends and I were able to separate them and call security but she walked off to him. He grabbed her by the hair and dragged her back into their hotel. We last saw them being chased by security into the night.
100% true story
This is why Feminism needs to exist. Every Modernized country has gone through this situation and made laws to protect women once women are allowed the opportunity to organize themselves. Seeing what Russia's idea of Family Values is truly chilling when witnessed first hand. If you had a Daughter who married a Russian Man and decided to move there to be with him, would you not want there to be a Feminist Movement right about now?
No, because Feminism is not about equal human treatment, but rather has a far deeper agenda.
When the Feminist movement started here, I recognized certain disparities and unfair treatment, and believe that those were wrong and opposed them. As things progressed, and I read feminist founders literature, and learned about the underlying philosophy, I rejected it as well.
Whenever people in the 1980's asked if I was a feminist, I answered, "No, I am an Equalist."
Zizu and East west, this about white Christian man not about black, brown or Muslims so you racist islamophobics need to shut up and stop bringing Muslims, Blacks and browns in every topic that has nothing to do with them. You angry because this guy has stated that a white sexist guy beat a poor woman.
@Zizu Zai If he was to have done something, that male individual might have taken it out on her for making a "scene" or "getting him in trouble" or he could've killed her. Situations like that aren't black and white. It's a complicated thing.
Keith Roy - I don’t know about other feminists.
But why I personally still claim myself to be a feminist rather than what you’ve claimed is because I think women need to be more uplifted before sex based egalitarianism can be more appropriately pushed for.
It’s hard to say I’m an ‘equalist’ or an ‘egalitarian’ (sex based for this discussion) when the problem I see is rooted around the notion of females.
Men are popularly considered as less for being or even potentially being like women. For being “feminine”.
Being feminine is meant to equate the quality’s that make up a woman, or generals of women in general. Yet it’s often associated poorly, being feminine by men is popularly perceived as weak.
That notion is twisted. That’s a problem. And it’s from what I perceive to be notions like that, towards issues like male/female treatment, that I struggle to yet call my self an egalitarian.
But I get your stance, but I can’t unfortunately yet complete agree.
Omar TheOwner - I’m a “feminist” and I don’t want domestic violence against men.
What your perceiving are a number of popular news blown women who hate men verbally and actively hate men. And who then perceive to claim that this declaration of disdain brings women equality. That’s horrid, not true* and just not sensical.
But then again your comments about the perceived general sensibility of women seems rather sexist. So I’m unsure as to how much sense (you as a person, not as a thing with a defined sex) have.
Well.I'm Russian and I can't bear this shit Milonov said. How can such people be a part of modern power system? My country associates with Medieval times because of it. I don't want you to think that normal citizens admit authoritarian biopolitics.
And what is the funniest thing? "The government shouln't control family life". It sounds good without any context. But this guy wants to ban abortion all over the country. What nonsense...
the guy is obviously a orthodox Christian fundamentalist. we have them also here in serbia, unfortunately. sometimes l long back for communism just because commies sure did place those backward clergy people where they belong.
If you are having more than 3 abortions per year, you should cut down a little. Thanks tRUMP.
Ксения Дербуш Queen Queenly American women abuse there husbands far worst and all ya got do is beat your husband controlled his every move cheat on him and call the cops and send him to jail
Maybe he needs for first make abortion for money. If you want do it but pay for it. I don't understand why all taxpayers should pay for someone's abortion
Как же я с тобой солидарен...
Russia is poor, it’s surprising to say but it’s very poor, Putin does nothing. I don’t know why people admire him but he sucks, an old man of the last century still fighting to stay in command instead of bringing someone Young and New to share their better ideas or at least “An idea” for the Russian Economy.
If you look at professional fighters they have at least enlarged brow ridge flattened noses sunken eyes damaged nerves puffy cheeks. And Fights are years apart and have refories. But not just her face how she walks stands is in better health. If melt plates were placed before aging bone size reduction they should be showing. And joint erosion
In 1990s before Putin came to power Russia was even poorer.
@@wisdom9091 wtf are u talking about
Well done, Russia, instead of battling domestic abuse you just decided to legalize it. Genius move!
...which is why I would never trust Russia with the life of my beautiful beloved Alina, even though she was born and raised there.
Reverse psychology 😂🤣
@@ilttpvvm too bad she got adopted by some degenerate Westerner
@@leviacker1260 hes talking about his wife....or significant other. Not his daughter. At leaat thats what it sounds like.
@@leviacker1260
Someone: Doesn’t want his Wife or Daughter being beaten to death.
A Retard on the Internet: dEgEnErAtE WeStEnEr.
This makes me sick to my stomach.
As a human being i feel bad for them. Now ive never hit a woman in my life. Im a single father who works everday and takes care of his 2 children. When i come accross some russian or middle eastern women they give me a look like i want to rob them or something lol. They should be more afraid of there own husbands than me lol. This world is crazy is all i can say.
marcus cook God Bless You
Kairi Musall thank you!
James Russells lmao
James Russells my best friend was white too! He passed in 2010 from overdose. Crazy huh lmao?
It's Western propoganda. They've been taught to fear brown men, despite their own men posing far more danger to them. Once internet access is available to all people, stereotypes like this will subside.
As a Russian I just want to remind some people in the comments that Russian citizens and Russian government are two different things. There are a lot of us here who are against Putin's politics. We're just always left out in the media coverage.
People have the government they deserve.
America can certainly have a Putin right now, unlike Biden.
Define "NORMAL"! .?
That word normal life makes me cringe.
That's because that guy in russia is famous for his abnormal love for "normal" and abnormal hatred for all that arent what he thinks normal...
THAT is the most spot-on explanation of this mannerism I've seen yet!
Must be a distant cousin of Vernon Dursley.
You seriously don't know what normal means? You can't be normal...
total obedience to Chthulhu
By whom? - By vegans? :D
Nanovirus96
'96
That dude is a fucking moron lol. He's the equivalent of an american conservatist
Nanovirus96 No, by stoopid liberal hillbillies. :D
after he gets off from work, he goes to youtube, downvotes every Vice video, makes fun of vegans, condemns LGBT, then calls liberals retards. if there is any evidence against him, he call it fake news. geez, this is familiar.
I doubt that loser has work.
So sad for these women all over the world. Stand up and fight back.
Its not about abusing women here in Russia, its about a very very bad government built on corruption
@@herus1 yeah putin is a puppet of the oligarchs.
I live in the UK and I felt the effects of this even all the way across the world
I had to watch my mother almost get beaten to death, a fine or 2 years will never fix that burden on my mind, what is so difficult about protecting your countries women
@Life With Honor troll or a slave owner?
e there was for sure a reason.
@Life With Honor You're pretty good example why russia needs feminism, youre a real simpleton.
Russia doesn't need feminism. Wish other countries would follow Russia.
@@rammos9171 Ew hell no
I hate men who do this 😑. Pick on someone your own size
You do realise women are always the first to start hitting? Men only hit back when they finally have enough and snap. When the women get in their place, domestic violence will fade.
I hate men who support misandric feminism
My beautiful beloved Alina (who stands 5'5") is routinely abused by her husband Daniel (who stands 6'4").
And people tell me I have no right to try and help her!!!
@@categories5066i. Fact women have always been patient .u have a historian on ur profile pic but u dont know shit bout history and how men were beating us the whole time domestic abuse will stop if only men knew their place (and women )but u saying women hit first in domestic marriages makes even feel more bad for u
@@ilttpvvm they are right
My son's father attacked me and my 3 year old son. Caused bruising. Cops took pictures, arrested him.
He was in jail for 12 days, and 3 years informal probation.
In Oregon, USA, in 2015.
Its russia law not u.s law?? Youre not even russian so shut up mind youre own country..
So you're telling me that this woman's ex-husband hit her with an ax and beat his mom...and the police still didn't believe her?! That's fucked up, this law has no regards to human rights. This is why I'm not *ever* going to Russia.
same
Then dont?. Mind your own law and country!!
So many weak men, cowards who are afraid to confront somebody their own size.
The russians are confront all the world against them.
"INCREASE OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IS A SIGN OF IMPROPER SPIRITUAL ATMOSPHERE IN THE SOCIETY"....
WHAT AN amazing STATEMENT !!!
That is true... that is why the gov needs to punish mofoes, so they get back on the right spiritual path.
Duan Chuan, and even better is MGTOW. Avoid all this hussle.
He's a known loon there.
Kinda true in a way. Doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be punished, but a society that fucked in the head is probably doomed no matter what the powers that be may try to do
He's right. When wives absorb feminist influences and think they are equals to the husband instead of subservient, the husband has to enforce the God ordained hierarchy. Just like how increased acts of defending against burglary should occur when burglary increases.
No wonder Trump likes Putin
Does Trump have any domestic violence convictions?
FREE MONEY CLICK NOW hmm let's see he called women Pig 🐷 dog 🐶 slobs, disgusting animal, insulted Muslim women, let's not forget "I can grab them by the pu-- remark". 😂but you are right no convictions
He didn't call all women that. Only the ones that actually were.
saratoga6427 sorry I don't speak Russian 😂
One day you will come home from working at Home Depot and immigration will be waiting to give you a free ride back to Mexico.
I'm in favor of adding Russia to the travel ban
well, travel yes, but make it easier for ok young folk to emigrate out of Russia.
No this is only a portion of Russians with extremist ideology with super orthodox views. They mainly come from deprived regions from broken families. Majority of them don't even have money to travel to nearest Belarus, Ukraine or baltic nations. Your ideology is like judging English people by those working class football hooligans who stormed Wembley
this comment ages very well kkkkkkkk
This is utterly appalling.
There is no excuse for domestic violence anywhere to anyone. As a Russian kid growing up in a Russian family it hurts everyone and helps no one, when I got hit it scarred me for life and made my parents feel bad. My mother being hit by my father is making me scarred and her traumatized and hurt. It doesn't help anyone. Russian families are all like this, I can confirm that 100% every family has experienced violence. The father of the family is always the biggest and most powerful in the family and their wives are suffering from it. It's just not a way to live like that, with pain in silence. But it's hard to change that, nearly impossible, when a whole country works that way and even supports it.
3:38 "rudely involved government into your own bedroom"... How is it rudely involving them if the person went to the police station and reported it???
And the irony is that they do involve themselves in peoples bedroom by making anti lbgtq laws
@@dreamofspringsexactly 😂
He says people don’t want the government controlling what happens in their home. Last I heard it’s illegal to be gay/ lesbian in Russia. Make that make sense!!!
What the heck? Why do people like Putin? Can someone tell me the good things he's done to Russia?
Alonzo Aldaba Russian news make him look like the best President/man the world has ever seen. People tend to believe in the made up image of him, they like to believe in a "fairy tale"
Alonzo Aldaba He brought back Russia from the brink of collapse after the fall of the Soviet union.
he made this country great and powerfull, threw out corrupt oligarchs has a deep love for the russian family conservative views, made it legal to go to church without getting records at FSB
this whole video is propaganda, if person complains to police that there husband is hitting them the police will go there there house and put him to prison, majority goes to jail as the person telling the police has the most power. majority of people who goes to police gets justice.
Николай Казаков you are totally brain washed lul
Николай Казаков 1:41
It is very cowardly to beat women. Someone has to protect them.
All that trauma inherited from wars. And a culture that washes the trauma away with vodka.
Committing assault or murder should be illegal with the same penalties whether one's offence is against a stranger or a family member. To have it any other way only benefits the individual committing the violence.
So reading the comments you American conservative men condone domestic violence? Thanks for showing your true colors. This is why Biden won.
Biden will loose badly soon.
Beating of elderly, women, and children should be banned everywhere
The people who approved the bill should be made aware that violence is never a tradition or value of any decent family. I feel for the lady whose abusive husband will be out in 6 years. I hope she can get herself some skills or education that will allow her to make some money and move to a place far away from where she is now where she can start a new life with her daughter.
Violence may not be a tradition or value of a decent family, but the God ordained hierarchy in families is. Ideally, the husband should never have to enforce the ordained hierarchy but the reality is that sometimes he has to. Russia has made it that this enforcement isn't illegal.
@@louiebrown5515 What if the man had a bad day at work and want to beat someone to relieve the tension? He could beat his boss, but he's aware that he will be fired if he does it. So " the perfect punching bag" is his wife, even though she has nothing to do with it. Or he likes to drink alcohol too much and he becomes violent when he's drunk and start assaulting his wife.
Or what if his wife gets sick or disabled and can't be anymore as "submissive" as his husband likes? Then what? Would he leave her for a woman that is healthy enough to sastify all his needs and desires?
'Fake News' - That reminds me of someone else
Devya Dixit gee I wonder who... 🤔
Vice is fake news
Topics domestic abuse being legal isn’t fake news. 14,000 women being murdered a year from domestic abuse isn’t fake news either.
in mother Russia not beating wife is domestic abuse
Unlike u.s women beat men like you!! Weak male beta soyboy!!
3:34 So you're against intruding into the bedroom? Then surely you believe that the rights of LGBT people need to be respected. Right? Right? Hey where did ya go buddy? Come back here.
The difference is: consent.
I’m soooo shock by this. I can’t believe this actually happens... how can the police be so ignorant. I’m loosing all faith in humanity....
4:01 "By...Anti-fascists...not by normal people"
I don't know where you come from but here in America normal people are anti fascists and I would expect you are too being once on the the biggest communist countries in the world lol.
Texas Man I’d rather a divorce than being beat to death.
This aged poorly, Antifa is now seen as a terror organization by trumpsters 😂
@@miiuneko They're scared of antifa, because they think of them as rivals now.
@@eevve9894 ya I know. They are fascist and fear and loathe everyone that's non-conforming. 🤷🏻♀️
@Rick Quicker I'm a Ukrainian German, sit down. Contrary to your dumpster fire of a country Germany knows how to learn from its history and teaches the future generations.
Wow. This is incredibly messed up.
I feel like I should be surprised......but then I remember this is Russia we are talking about, there is very little European in that country. Soviet times have not ended there
Thank you God I don't live in Russia. Domestic abuse should be judged independently case by case. The guy talks scrap. That poor woman look at her abuse.
This scares me not only for the Russians citizens but also how similar US politicians are starting to sound to the politician with the glasses.
What should be decriminalized is the killing of violent abusers in self defense.
one thing about abuse it that once you have someone abusing you, you know that if you 'let him go' -as if its thats easy to get a psycho to go away from what he feels is his prey,once they are gone you are 100% sure youve just released a monster on an unsuspecting woman whose life he will ruin next and you feel guilty or as if you need to follow him around warning his future partners for the rest of your life. These types of men should be caged and not left for women to deal with alone, manyof the abusers will choose a woman who has no where else to go and make sure they impregnate their girlfriend to force her to try to work it out which it will never ever do, he will never change.
Now domestic abuse is also legal in Kazakhstan(post Soviet Union country, near Russia )
@MissDroplette
1.An administrative penalty is established by Article 73 of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Administrative Offenses" in the form of a warning or administrative arrest for a period of three to ten days, if repeated within a year after the imposition of an administrative penalty, it entails an administrative arrest for up to ten days or a fine of five monthly calculation indicators.
2.Administrative detention consists in the imprisonment of a person who has committed domestic violence, with compulsory detention in a special room.
Police just close their eyes on domestic abuse, they usually say "Come back later when it will get worse" and corruption. If abuser worked in police or has connection with them, they don't do nothing or abuser just give them bride.
Actually this problem is not about penalty for domestic violence. Main problem is very low level of life in Russia (real averege montly income beyond Moscow is about 200-300 dollars) and no chances to any personal developement. All these problems lead to alchogolism and crimes.
Don't marry.
Another reason why I love western men. They treat women the best.
Lol!! 🤣🤣🤣 u.s women beat white weak beta male like you.. what a soyboy!
Hello, guys. I'm from Russia. I'm living in town from this video. This is not a fake, it's cruel truth. Sorry for my bad english language, but I want to say: Milonov a piece of shit, laws of our country very abusive, very awful. My father is abuser, my mom lived in terror before divorce. I hated this situation, our government makes our life is terribble. It's scared. Really scared. I want to believe: one day we are make new world, we are living new life, without homophobia, domestic violence, stupid law-system and other bad things.
Dame Russia, you crazy.
"This is fake news"....where have we heard those words over and over. Take notes America....this soon be u.
U be rally doomb
In Australia they say 1 woman dies every week whilst in Russia, 1 every 40 minutes. These are disgusting statistics. i'm hoping they're over exaggerated.
ALP7A. The liberal media always blow things out of proportion. Fake news
Russian troll factory successfully dislikijg the videos here
keep believing that...drink more koolaid
More like a bunch of alt right Putin/trump lovers
Егор Селиванов Maybe you don't but obviously those in power in Russia do.
That doesn't really explain 90% of vice videos being downvoted when they have nothing to do with russia
Maybe a dislike means they don't actually agree with or like the content.
No wonder Putin is single, his ex wife dumped him and she did it right, he's inhuman and that reflects in his actions and also in the politics of it's country! So sorry for Russian women have to go through this, you are all beautiful!!
He talked just like Donald Trump.. just more refined.
If look at professional fighters they at least have enlarged brow ridge flattened noses sunken eyes damaged nerves puffy cheeks . and Fights are year's apart and have refories. .yet woman in this documentary . some how not just her face she walks and standing better health . For taking lot worse less restricted damage more frequently. She has metle plates replacing her Joints. But that has nothing joint aroson. It from what she discribed would be in a week shear and plats should be showing sense were in planted before aging bone size
the ignorance in the comments section, if a reflection of the general education-level, means we are so fucked...
utofbu Yeah, look at the younger generation full of stoopid liberal idiots who think they know everything. Fools!
No. Russians are. Americans are under or on par. Read your history.
We rather read and comment ignorant reply's, than read a book which is hard to understand.
Capitalism with Asian values will win, because our democratic model can't compete.
Implying one cannot comment and read a book.
I use my computer to read books *as well*, thank you sir.
And everyone should catch up on their history books.
Look at all those Russian bots
That's just messed up...
Oh the irony where woman used to have lots of liberties during soviet times now woman are getting beaten
I wonder what happens when a woman beats a man up. I bet they put them in jail. and what if you koll one of the fuckers saving your life. This absolutely sickens me.
Seriously?? He finally got put into prison after he finally killed someone. If they have put him into prison wayyy before, the neighbor's life would be saved.
These politicians are shit. You can see how ignorant Milonov is when he cuts off the interviewer
Lol, jezus, Russia, what's next, sharia law?
Soon brother, soon
Lul, man, there are regions in Russia where sharia prevails over ordinary law already - Chechnya for example
Russia should try to conquer all muslims countries and ban islam
whener Im on the russian side of you tube the misogyny just seeps out of every pore.
I am so surprised domestic abuse is legal in russia in the former soviet union. Stalin would have a heart attack by seeing this bullshit.
"Condemned by whom? Not by the normal people. Normal people, normal families, they said "No". You can't take our rights to beat our wives, daughters, sisters and mothers!".
Exactly, in Russia, the right to enforce God's ordained hierarchy in the home has not been taken from anyone.
"Fake news" thats where Dump got that from.
sometimes im scared to live in this country
Who would dislike this? Seriously.
I did because of the disingenuous title.
Putin fanboys that folows him religiously that has Jim Jones cult like loyalty.
I know this is not propper to say but maybe someone should show that Milonov, with his Stone Age mindset, what it's like so he won't consider it some "normal" occurrence. Sickening. Any man or woman who beats their s.o. severely deserves the death penalty.
*This* is the reason I am a radical feminist. *This* is why feminism is needed.
Yes true, but the problem is you are a feminist in a supposedly gender equal society. we need feminists in these countries where women are oppressed. Western Europe may not be perfect for women, but its not perfect for men either because nothing is perfect! Think about it - would you take a wage about 10 pounds lower than men or live in a poverty stricken country? The point is issues about wage gap are too small in a desperate world.
Stay in the kitchen,
Family values is evil
I dont think that is just beating, it seems more like attempt of murder... I mean hitting someone with axe in the head...
30 years in the US men got a warning for the first offense. Seen a woman bashed with a butcher knife and the man get a warning. The kids witnessed it and got no help. Yall should do a video for domestic violence in america.
Link?
I had a relative take anger out on me when I was younger. If this person had a bad day at work, my life would be Hell. This person had some unstable partners who made the other person even madder. This person's current partner has changed this person into a human again. I've learned quite a bunch about bringing out the good in people by watching this partner. Reminds me of 1001 Arabian Nights. I try not to feed other people my sickness and take a more active role into thinking about consequences.
1440 mins in a day
Woman dies every 40min
1440\40=36 women a day
36*365= 13,140 women a year
How do you get 12,000 women dying every year vice?
Haha
I agree with beating a women by a men to discipline her but not to death! That’s absolutely wrong
Kilalmyn who are violent against women or advocate for it.
The world needs to leave Russia alone in their own situations. If this what their government wants, the so be it🤷♂️
gross
@@VoyagerD not gross. this what their citizens want when they want Putin in power. So be it
I use to think highly of Putin now I lost all respect for him
No respect for Putin and how he keep that Country quiet on how awful it must be to live there
That guy is lying no woman would ask for that.
Obedient women who know their place in God's ordained hierarchy in the home would.
Im Far Right but come on I think that's one thing we all can agree on that domestic violence is a no good at all simple it can and will destroy family's, Now I do believe in 1 for 1 meaning you give me 1 I'll give you 1
I remember how a father whose family was at risk of destroying itself. His son had been indoctrinated into mutilating himself and his wife was supportive. At his wits end, he did what had to be done and what God demands to protect his home. He used his God-given strength to enforce his God ordained authority in his home. Since he was in the west, he was punished for protecting his family and while in prison, his son mutilated himself. The story would go the exact opposite way in Russia.
Orlova's ex husband is actually a very ill man not only did he beat her but also his mother
Why does that not surprise me?
This is why they win being this kind of bastard means power
Wow. The nerve that guy has.
There are day time TV shows in the middle east that show woman how to hide your bruises. Russia is not the only one.
but you won't see vice make a documentary there.
And so they are just as bad as each other
Shows that women there are remorseful when their disobedience gets punished and will hide that their husband was forced to enforce God's ordained hierarchy in the home.
i'm not a Christian but...ffs! JESUS!!!! Wtf is wrong with these people??!!
What the hell?!
its great isnt it
Oh, No!Putin, my opinion of you is now turning 180 grades!
Mr. Putin, how could you allow this? You do not seem to me to be a man whom could have any respect for a coward who beats women. As I have always had a deep love and respect for Rus folk, I find it hard to "believe" the President or his advisors would be alright with such violence towards wives and mothers. Yes I would agree with the man in this video that Society going down morality wise is a huge problem not just for Rossiya but the entire world.
He enjoys the support of the orthodox church far to much to care about women.
According to Russian law, beatings are the infliction of physical pain without causing harm to health and are an administrative offense. If these actions caused harm to health, then this is the intentional infliction of harm to health, which is a criminal offense.
Just when I thought Putin couldn't sink any lower...
Wonder what's going to happen when women start returning the favor?
@@funonline972 keep pimp hand strong don't let those feminsts destroy Russia
They will be punished or jail!
They'll then realize the difference in strength and realize one of the many reasons that God ordained that wives should be subservient to husbands.
How do Russian politicians keep people safe when they safe domestic violence is ok? Battered people who wouldn't hurt others live in fear. I am sad and scared for anyone abusive situation. "Normal" disagreements are verbal, NOT physical.
I demand they legalize drunk driving
I feel nothing but rage for that Russian mp.
It’s crazy that we make business and trade with such cultures. Oh well, who said you don’t need morals to get into business.
This and the war on Ukraine is the reason I say down on Russia and down on Putin. Hopefully Russia falls and gets colonized one day by sensible people.
Nazi much
Guns are legal in Us so Domestic violence in Russia
I don't like harming others
Leave innocent alone
:( dam those vegans
That poor lady, Mrs. Orlova, lives in Ufa.
My beautiful beloved Alina left Ufa to escape a brutal father--only to marry an American man who abuses her every chance he gets!!!
Are you a mother or something.
Oh my god. That first politician. Vomit. Vomit vomit vomit vomit!