Why call recordings are very difficult to prove in court?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- I am a Delhi based lawyer.
You can send me your stories at amish.aggarwala@gmail.com
wa.me/+9199581...
I post regularly on:
TH-cam: / @amishlegal
Instagram: / bettercallamish
LinkedIn: / amish-aggarwala-45978246
7 THINGS MEN SHOULD KNOW BEFORE GETTING MARRIED: STORIES OF FALSE CASES AND LEGAL BATTLES IN INDIA:
www.amazon.in/...
#lawyer #law #court #lawstudent
Lekin Amish bhai C.I.D. me Dr. Saluke to turant sab bata dete hain 😂
Wo phone chaat ke bata dega
Because He is GOAT. 😂
Bcoz he got paid😂😂
😂
He is from the Andromeda galaxy!!
In short bol do direct india ka justice system ghatiya hai😂
Hn aur call recording krne ki teri akal bahut tezz h😂
@@indiathatis2987 ??
Bhai ye bolne wali baat nhi hai, ye to sabko pata hai
Naa, ham indian ho jaayenge esa bolne pe
This is followed all around the world.
This brother unlocks new fear every time
if you are in fear better call amish
What he is saying is true.
Audio recordings are difficult to prove and they are often seen as a doubt while clear videos are more definite and trustworthy when aligning in order.
Even photos show more.
Audios just give info but they are not definite, they are dubious.
Chats are fine but can be distorted.
About videos, it's better to meet or say what u want to say not what others' want to hear
@@potbot887 😆😆
Even videos will be doubtful in few yearsx after AI takes over @@dklf697
So the voice can't be recognised but someone chatting can be confirmed that he was the one chatting? Wow
Yes because you can show mobile number and that can be linked with the person easily.
Yes and can be verified ?
@@ParthMaru11photoshop has entered the chat
@@mizanzerotoo6941 it can be detected easily
@@mizanzerotoo6941 you can actually see the data of the chats as well, and confirm it if that chat ever occured
Voices can be easily faked now
Ok if you do sex record video.........ok
If she do fake rape case
Who ever has power to win in this world that will become justice
Judiciary is one of the biggest industry capitalizing on fear and insecurity of public.
Infact Industrialization thrives on fears! Let's pray for well being of everyone
That's great; now I can call the person, & speak my mind, without worrying about anything 😅😂
My friend always records every single call he gets dont know why 😂
He is sick!
Because he have MI phone, like me... call records like butter and remains with you for years.
The only good you can achieve with it is to keep people in check by proclaiming you have their call recorded
@@TheCycloneTrooper... also if you decide on the price to sell or buy something, they cannot change the price later..
My Samsung phone always does auto call recording
Thanks... Your channel is actually helping out common people to know about the real law and justice system of India and I hope people of India would stop being careless idiots after watching your videos since justice system is rigged against them or to put in more polite words, justice is not always what they have thought of in their mind.
Plus you need to get a certificate from forensic lab for the recording device as well that it was not tempered or is malfunctioning.
Simple solution is to stay single and avoid marrying risks....
Imagine a peaceful life with parents, pets, good single friends and passion career.
Yeh Bhai akela Mard Jaat ko Bacha raha hai! The hero we need!
Why can't i get it done personally from a reputed forensic lab instead of waiting for court to legitimize it.
U can actually
@@dbtta Shouldn't he be telling about this also then. Seems like an important info has been left out.
@@forkrust9296 umm ig he is saying the truth, I didnt take as in court cases but for fun.
@@dbtta why would anyone check authenticity for a video just for fun. Its obviously for court proceedings. Smh. There are many countries that allow citizens to get authenticity of the video or recording from independent parties. So its important to know if its allowed in India.
@@forkrust9296 we made an AI model of our voice and our og voice and got it forensically checked for fun, lmao
Aapki court laws tho bahut mahaan hai sir... Aam admi ko is desh me rehna hi nahi chahiye.... I thought laws are made to help people.. But here people are used for law business to run.
Unfortunately if Video doesn't have to be authenticated by FSL then the AI can also fool human eyes with Videos quite sharply
It cannot be directly treated as evidence but in some cases call recordings have been used to prove another piece of evidence or substantiate some other evidence.
This might be true ish but you can get meta data from phone companies that can backup the clam
That's what Howard said to Chuck
In one of your previous video, you mentioned that recoding is important and one of your friends got advantage of recodingns....and that the reason you didn't buy iphone bcoz it doesn't allow recording.
Link of video: th-cam.com/video/_PWAFk5CEvE/w-d-xo.html
Yeah I know he's giving a very stupid advice right now , don't listen to him in everytime, call recordings does have important value in legal proceedings my friend won the case with call recording evidence, a complete CDR of the victim's no. obtained by police to prove it, it's so simple but this amateur making it complex.
@@indigobrain7450it won't work every time if the accused says it's not his and do a research court will have to do it so it's not better than video or photot
😅
Can you please make a video on this topic?
What are my rights as a male if a female assaults (slap or otherwise) me in public out of no fault of my own? What would be the legal consequences if I retaliate back in the same manner with the same force the same under the right of private defence?
I've been searching the internet for this ans and I've found nothing.
Short answer, if you can then hit and then run
Because even if you file a case then a simple sorry is enough for her
Whereas you will have to spend 2-5 years in jail
There must be some legal precedent and law that would clearly state what could be done... I want a full video on it and I definitely would not like to run...
The moment you "retaliate", it's no more self defence because you're on offensive. Private or Self Defence ends the moment the aggression ends.
One slap - file case for simple hurt. Continuous slapping - you get the right to defend yourself and in the exercise of that self defence, you can push, slap back without being excessively cruel (as in you can't break someone's hand for slapping you). The moment continuous slapping stops, your private defence also ends. You have this right regardless of your or assailant's gender.
@@Escapist... Are you a law student or something?
I've posted the same comment asking the same thing for quite some time now and this is the 1st reasonable reply I've got...
Thank you for the information 👍👍
The audio file itself has enough metadata to prove authenticity
Chutiya Judges don't know anything about metadata. They are as much far away from technology as Dogs from Calculus.
Nahi ab to law ne bhi add ho gaye h 😂😂😂
Through Forensic. I work in that dept.
bacha liya bhai mai to aese hi khush rehta tha call auto recording setting laga ke
Its better to have something than nothing
With advance of AI voices.. this just makes audio recordings even more impractical in courts
well he is no more now i guess
Indian law system everyone in the world they know how they work by the time a person get judgement he or she will be in hell or heaven 😅😅😅
After watching all these videos I can sum our justice system:
1)Whether or not you get justice solely depends if you can buy the judge or not.
2)Common man. Yes "man". will basically never get justice.
Super information bro
Thankyou sir for valuable information
That is why your legal system is a $hit. Justice should not always rely on indisputable evidence (ironically which is not the case either in India), but on sensible observation of facts and the situation. Unfortunately judges in India consider themselves super human, omniscient and above law and hence arrogantly trample even the basic human rights of the litigants. Further, do not forget the rampant corruption and deep down rot in the legal system which squeezes every bit out of your savings.
Just the thought of this system makes me puke 🤮🤮
With AI it is even more difficult to tell real from fake
My siblings has those same recordings of his partner but court called it inadmissible on grounds of breach of privacy....now we have moved to Supreme Court 😢😢
Even chats does not mean its the other party texted what if it was someone else like friends or spouse who knows our password
Indian Law By Mike. ❤
I have a doubt.
If in the call recording the people on both end say their name would that be trusted? Or do we have to concern that the people on one end could be forced to say their name under threat?
Heard of telco using Lawful Interception? That's admissible in court.
It is best that someone has video recordings or audio recordings. Every evidence needs time to prove.
Sir you forgot call list and location of phone with the person calling. Hope those are not inconclusive? Call list and location of phone now days does not takes time and courts worldwide are accepting it as a strong evidence. So call recordings with location of phone to track if it actually belongs to the person speaking plus call list from telecom company. So if you are threatening me then I will be presenting call recording with location of phone with your location plus your call list. That is solid evidence to prove you are guilty.
What about SSR case there were multiple chats of rhea and AU and Mahesh Bhatt but nothing has been done by CID or SIT yet.
Same thing happening in Owaisi's "15 minute" statement...
#AI can mimic voices.
So in future Videos and Voices both evidences will be useless
But new reforms introduced by Anit shah has changed this. Yes, it's to be passed. But now these are valid docs.
Chats can be edited, it's hard to edit call recordings or voices, even using best of ai
But *chats* bhi ab fake bnai jaa skti hai
Le AI : - r u comedy me
But, once he only said two years back in one of his videos that, why he prefers Android over ios. Just because Android have inbuilt anonymous call recording option available 🤔
As per evidence act is the voice sample obtained furtively without consent of other party even admissible in court?
very true
Please tell me which issue does court solve in one or two weeks...they take sevral years some times decades to solve the local issue
In 2023 no one harras by someone but they know very well they will harass by working methodology of indian courts nd judges.
system ghriya nae h it needs upgrade . filmo me sbko justice turant mil jata h usi ne aadt khrab kr di h sbki ki ha yar justice b jaldi milna chahiye . esa nae hota h most cases are grey than white or black
They are very much useful to negotiate 😅
It seems you're hatching a conspiracy to trap someone. 😀
didnt you told me once not to buy iPhone or else u wont have call recordings?
So true
Agar ye bhi hm krenge toh court kya order krenge
Best is emails
I'll be watching you closely, just filed for divorce. Need all the advice i can get.
Not sure if voice evidence will hold good in a court of law in this age of AI.
Classic example is nithari khand, where court rejected all electronic evidences
Request you to throw insight for animal lovers, to fight against society residents, member or committee, for harrassing community animals (cats, dogs birds).. Thankyou... irrespective of you being an animal lover or not, pls do
What if the call is from a particular phone number which could be traced and proved that it is infact of the person who is speaking ? Can phone numbers be tempered too ? Can I call to a person from a different phone number that is not mine ?
Ai entered the chat
Call chat screen shot also I can make fake as real... No one can tell the difference... So it also bad peace of evidence..
Without permission call recording is also crime then how
This man is on mission to save Married Man!
Video recordings don’t prove readily either. they too need to be examined . Doctoring them is easy
WAIT. My phone shows the call recording ka source phone number as well. So what extra they need to play with??
There are AI tools which can produce exact voice like yours..100% accurate. I know 2-3 AI software
Justice system in india is ghe worst...cases taking more than 10 years ...
means call pr gaali de sakte hai
But without consent or court order can they record voice ??
But the opposition will say that the audio is fabricated no?
Now digital proof are valid so does it make any difference?
Aur wo voice sample dene se mana bhi kar sakte hain
Indian justice & supreme court of India is living in British Empire 1856 😂😂😂😂
भाई भारत में रहते हो तो हिंदी हीं बोली। जय हिन्द ❤
Now you can generate AI Voice & AI Videos 😂😂😂
Nightmare 😢
Can be traced if they are fake easily
Ai videos are very easy to distinguish, plus how can the ai replicate your spouse properly 😅.
Dude.. We can take the call lists from phone. And you can see the number there too and also the time we called too....
It takes years ... No point in paying all these taxes here.
Experienced real life that police or court only care once someone is dead etc., if there is no death involved they wont interfere.
Certainly brother.
Sorry but the system is too insensitive & shameless. No one is concerned even if you die unless you are a vip or rich & powerful.
As an cybersecurity expect, yes this is true, digital forensics can take a long period of time. there are many thing that happen when investing samples like this.
can u elaborate on yr point?
Can u elaborate
can u elaborate
As an engineer I can confirm that you just eat and scroll internet and pretend to be someone who you what to be
As a voice sample itself, I approve of this .
Then one forensic lab gives positive report other party Sample examiner gives negative report ... In the end You loose your case .
This is not only true in Voice recording but also in "Handwriting" test case ...
My Judge said handwritting Examination is not a fool proof method and cannot be admitted as evidence ... 😂😂😂 ....
Finally I lost my faith on Judiciary and lost property worth of crore ... 😂😂
Wtf dude
Hire the biggest goon of your area, give him some ransom in Lakhs, he will probably do the job for you.
@@crazyshorts4278 you know what you are saying and where
My dada lost 25 years of his life due to judiciary. 😢😢 he even agreed to give away the property but his uncle wanted to ruin his life. He said I will make you run to courts every now and then. I lost my childhood, my dad would never be at home for dinner, earning his extra money, he would always be angry and curse me that I got bad luck. I don’t feel like human, thanks to judiciary harassing him.
@@crazyshorts4278not everyone stays in UP and Bihar. 😢 and what if perpetrator has good political connection.
What I've learned from his channel that judiciary isn't able to impart justice and humans should take matters in their own hands
Edit:- I no longer believe in such views shared above,I am not deleting so as to let people know that I accept my mistake
Failure of Great Indian Constitution. In short
Absolutely, if you really think Indian Judiciary system will give you justice then it's the biggest joke and scam , strong and powerful will always win no matter what and our Judiciary prove it very often, so be powerful and be strong.
Yeah worst
Jokes on people whose innocent lives gets destroyed due false rape case.Many End up in jail for several years.
Judiciary is a joke is all i can comprehend.
A shady institution which claims justice is just Stooge for doing illegal things legally.
We don't get to say anything against coury but mighty justice court can interfere even in the matters of bedroom.
Married Man is not owner of wife’s sexuality: Justice Chandrachud
Yep !! That's how al queda was established 😂
Sadly in our so called modern world asuras ko vadh nahi kiya jata. Agar aap vadh karoge to bolenge murder. Inlogo ko murder aur vadh ke difference nahi pata.
So I can buy an iPhone now 😁
How is IPhone helpful ?
@@sureshvadgama2838 Amish has another video where he says he prefers Android over Iphone because Android has call recording feature available. I think the video is titled something like "why I will never buy an iphone".
My comment above is just a reference to that (in a joking way).
@@sureshvadgama2838iphone don't have call recordings so if there is no use of call recording no need to prefer android for call recording
But it does contain the date of call etc... if the voice is not identified by the court... Then what other evidence can be weighed.....
Me getting ready for my eventual divorce by watching these videos even before getting married 😂
chats are more credible? a husband wife can use each others' phones or the person can simply deny they didn't have their phones with them. Courts need urgent reforms!
Same query
They will match the call timing of both end received and the the duration.
So for safety never text anything incriminating then just talk about crime on the phone since it will be harder to prove😂
It directly means that Indian Judicial system is far behind in terms of giving justice if you have money justice will be served if not you are done.
What you actually have to do is
Show it to your opponent and make him think that its a huge evidence
Thats all
Uska bhi to lawyer hoga jo usko ye bata dega
I like how the ineffective operation of the justice system is normalised.
That means. If someone files a case against u then just accept it or just go missing.
In these times of deep fakes, even images and video evidence would be different to judge
So justice is broken and thus, we should just take it in our own hands.
Always record in public like a park or mall food court.
No way it will be argued that other person had reasonable expectation of privacy
Bottom line is Income tax money I am paying is total waste.. Judicial system in India needs a serious upgrade or kick in its bottom
We need Artificial Intelligence to speed up the Judiciary by a revolutionary amount!
Finally some one who knows the solution
I also thought in childhood cid officer are talent and solve case within days but after knowing some offiers are corrupt taking bribe and work for politicians and never solve complicated case they just try to close the case 😢