Same, I have the autocaptions on and the volume turned down SO low. I thought about just reading the transcript but I wanted to see how he said things, not just what he said.
4:20:04 Lawyer deliberately called the injured person a paraplegic and Alex took the bait correcting him by stating he was actually a quadriplegic. Just shows how evil he was stealing from someone like that.
No, I don't think it was a set-up by the prosecutor. It was an honest mistake, but bc Alex is trying to come across as being an "honest" man, he corrected him! In the end it held no water with the Jury....
@carolyn yanik Alex didn't need to correct the prosecutor in order for the nastiness of his schemes to be apparent. It's more likely to be a simple mistake but none of us have any way of knowing, especially with confidence.
This is a cold hearted dude. You can’t make me believe that Alex was the only lawyer stealing.Alex learned this from his family.The federal government is should look into all the cases that firm ever had.
@@rnarzu he certainly sounds like a person one would naturally lean towards and admire. Seems to have an ‘awe shucks’ mannerism that just makes him likeable. But he found his charm could deceive and fill his desire to line his pockets that he would do ANYTHING to protect that image. Paul became a thorn in his foot and with charges against Paul coming to a head within days, he had to go…Nothing would get in his way. So sad.
I don’t believe he took as many pills as he said he did. Maybe 460 milligrams a day. I doubt anyone has a tolerance of 460 pills and not die. Just the amount of Tylenol in that many perks alone would destroy a liver quickly.
One of the things that gets me and I think everyone agrees is, the lack of anger towards the 'real killer' and the lack of motivation on his part, or any Murdaugh's part, to find who allegedly did these henious murders. That alone speaks volumes as to his guilt.
@@mfeteira The psychotrauma of finding loved ones shot to death (after you just did it, plus scoops of HillBilly Heroin) tends to erase from the memory any small niggling details which would later be detrimental to one's defence.
@@mfeteira i don’t understand how that would be such a difficult thing to make up. he could just say they were talking about how the dogs were doing or how his mother is, or a baseball game or show they were watching. literally anything
It’s so clear in watching this how tactical it was for him to call Paul “Paw Paw”. He starts the first two times calling him Paul and immediately corrects himself to Paw Paw, like oh yeah I’m supposed to be calling him the nickname for my theatrical story!
This was the biggest L in legal history, how the hell are you a lawyer and you get up there with your pawpaw and mags and all that mess? He would have been so much better off had he not testified. I laughed my ass off when I saw this because I knew after he said he was there that his ass was fried.
Who else could have killed Maggie and Paul between 8:50 pm and 9:00 pm at the kennel location while Alex was supposedly napping on his couch in the house, without him hearing 7 rifle and shotgun shots?????????? His story is UTTERLY preposterous. WHY ARE THE FAMILY'S TWO SUSPECT GUNS MISSING? WHY are his shirt and shoes missing? That has never been explained. Am I the only one who keeps watching this learning something new each time I watch?? I'm somehow hooked on this, fascinated and APPALLED by THIS true life crime.
I think an audit of payouts vs what clients actually received across the entire US would net an astronomical amount of attorneys guilty of these same exact crimes. I believe this to be a industry standard and an unwritten taught scam of the lawyer community.
...And far too many of these scumbags are running the federal (and local) government. So many people just do not understand that you do not need to be an attorney to be voted into offices.
This is likely true .I bet many lawyers take a bigger cut if they can get more , And every single person in this world tells lies but he lied about stealing , not everyone is a thief. And he has guilty written all over him for murder . That sets him apart from most humans. No empathy present to kill son and wife with no remorse
@@kingayy9267 It seems you are right. I’m early 70s & had not heard of a “narcissist” (I suppose I’m fortunate). I’m in the U.K. so much is different yet the same, maybe it’s our language? This trial has had me gripped, the saddest for Paul & his dear Mama. Alex is the like of which I have ever known. The jury found him guilty of their murders, I have heard he has sought an appeal. He played everyone
I must say. Through none of his police interviews does he call his son Paul, “Paul-Paul” he REALLY tried it! 😂 trying to make himself have affection for that boy. Shame!
I just can’t believe he thought the bobbing of his head and smacking before talking would fool these jurors. He’s a lawyer and I guess he thought the jurors were gullible
As an attorney, he knows how to chew a bowl of word salad. More words, more confusion for the jurors to try to sort out. What's pertinent, what's word salad? The man is just pure evil. IMO
I feel horrible for his family for their untimely deaths being murdered but my heart breaks for the people that trusted him and even those that resulted in death.My God.What evil is this?
If I was in on the stand being accused of a family murder I didn’t do, I would be so frustrated and angry and saying in every other sentence “you are wasting time! I did not do this! PLEASE reevaluate and GO FIND WHO DID THIS TO MY FAMILY!!!” We are watching a song and dance!
You cannot evaluate someone else's behavior based on what you would do. This is how the police get it wrong, end up with tunnel vision and end up arresting the wrong person who goes on trial and ends up in jail for life or worse. We don't know if he's actually guilty, he probably is, but he is a liar, and if you lie too much when you do tell the truth, no one will believe you.
@@Jessa-RM No, you can’t evaluate on what we’d do but don’t you think if anyone were accused of this and didn’t do it that they’d be very upset and yell and scream their innocence and be so mad and throw a fit about the fact that they’re being accused of it? I’d never just sit there and talk about straps on a damn tree. I’d sit there and go off for hours about how wrong they are and how stupid they are. I’d be kicked out of court! I’d fight for my life and fight for them to find the killers the entire time I’m in court!
@BJW f yes man. He's simply speaking way too much about nonsense. An innocent person does not talk this much about everything and anything. Well he is. Classic sign of guilt. And people can think what they want. If your wife and son were murdered and your being prosecuted you would be fn frustrated about what's being done with who actually killed his MF family. Period.
I think he thought the world of his wife and son too....up until he HAD to do something. It needed to be done. Probably how he felt about those clients. They're nice people but IT needs to be done. Selfish to the core
I watched this again. It is absolutely amazing to me that this case was solved by the victim. The person who spent the weekend with him was intuitive enough to document everything. What he wore, where he was, the exact time he died. The guns he used. The shot gun with buck shot and duck shot . He documented they went to duck pond. The blackout and the casings. Just in real. Heart breaking
What’s amazing is that even Alex referred to Paul as very intuitive and that was before he realized Paul had posted these videos of him the day he died
Even a non guilty person would get a tissue or ask for a tissue but he wanted people to see him “crying” because that was the most important thing to him even if it meant having snot all over him which a “typical” person wouldn’t do but someone that’s trying desperately to get you to believe their lie would.
He was more distraught and frustrated with PawPaw being accused of the boat wreck and hopeful of overturning the law, than finding the ‘killer’ of his own son and wife! He never once showed that same passion and determination for the murders, as he did for the boat wreck! But the boat wreck was opening up a whole new kind of can of worms for Alex! His financial troubles, thefts, and mismanagement of clients claims were fixing to be unleashed!!!!
The way his head has a slight nodding effect. When givin any questions about murdering Maggie and Paul or hiding guns. Is fascinating. His body betrays him
It's all the "addiction" causing everything. His mouth smacking classic when he is forced to pretend to tell the truth. Disgusting too. His paranoia would not come and go like he's describing.He got off ripping ppl. off & enjoying how he is fooling everyone. Just disgusting.
@@lolodee3528 that’s what I was thinking too- my dad has worked in the prison system for nearly 40 years and he said some of the inmates are on more drugs IN prison than when they’re OUT! To me it doesn’t seem fair, you should have to live with your anxiety and depression but sadly that’s not what happens.
Key words.... from his ENTIRE testimony..... "I would never INTENTIONALLY hurt my wife Maggie or my son, Paul Paul." He did himself ZERO favors by taking the stand.
Not that I’m defending him but, that’s the best we ALL can say about anyone that we love. We most definitely can hurt them physically and emotionally UNINTENTIONALLY, but to hurt them intentionally is where evil lurks. So he did chose that word correctly.
I just realized this, when Alex is talking about those chickens being “Guard birds “ and making a lot of racket when anything unusual is going on or someone is around, those birds would have been making noise if a vigilante was lurking in the shadows and he would have heard that. Also those dogs would have been barking like crazy! They are hunting dogs! I’m surprised he didn’t shoot the dogs too. He gives me nightmares! Prosecution time was absolutely brilliant! Murdaugh you will meet the devil!
I can tell you a prison recording he called buster told him to go back to the house Buster asked him why he said so he could go deer hunting ..thus is before he was convicted ..According to Alex he is innocent he wasn't the killer so if that was true would there still be a murderer out there not caught ...Why would you ask your so to go bck deer hunting if the murderer wasn't caught
I heard that. Why in God's name would your surviving son want to SHOOT anything on the same property his mother and brother were gunned down on?? It's crazy.
Mr Murdaugh what time did you get home? Well you see this watch is a Swiss watch and the mechanics are very delicate. There’s a historical factory that goes back hundreds of years that employs watchmakers. There was a young man who used to work there that one day was walking in the garden and got stung by a bee……
Notice that when talking about his wife, he never said how much he loved her or how he fell in love with her. She was just a goodun who could fit in with his crowd and the poor people. She didn’t take to childbirth like it was a choice. She never questioned the finances and just signed what she wanted her to. Second class, there to serve his needs.
He even ripped off longtime Nanny who raised his boys! Said there would be big insurance then pocketed it for himself! Maggie was going to divorce him then Paul's lawsuit would cost him $10M!! have no doubt he blew his own family away becuz they were liabilities to him!!
How wealthy are they though? I saw the Netflix doc and knowing how much he would do to protect his son it’s tough to believe he would kill him. I’m not saying I believe him, I’m just trying to figure out the motive.
@@IAmEmberhe has a criminal history he has lied to the law before and u can tell he fears he has to lie because no one will believe him if he tells the truth and if he lies they still wont
I have a certain sympathy for his lawyers who must have known they were defending a lying evil murderer and that they were going to get their asses handed to them. I’m sure they tried to get him to plead guilty for a lesser sentence and probably advised him strongly not to take the stand. But this narcissist truly believed he could talk his way out of this. He’s never been held accountable for anything in his entire life, no doubt he thought that would continue. But everyone gets their comeuppance and he got two life sentences worth. The judge gave it to him with both barrels making those sentences run consecutively.
I think his lawyers were sick of him. He made them look like fools by lieing about his alibi. Then the jury says the thing that convicted him was his testimony and going to moselle. I’m not sure they wanted him to testify. Which he did thinking I’m a better lawyer than waters. That was problem he acted like a lawyer not a real person. Which is what the jury wanted to see.
He gives more detailed information than he needs to. He's trying to establish a rapport with the jury..."make them like me" "they will see that I'm just a normal guy" He gets an A+ for lying constantly and putting on a show. True Narcissist at work here. They got your number...how about Stephen Smith's life? What happened there Alex/Buster? I'm thrilled that case is being opened back up.
Thats funny when if were being honest what about him is likable?? He gets a fair unbiased jury with me so i guess we got 5 hours worth of day 1 to watch let the man have a fair shake the whole way through ! I know trials over but everybody instantly has an opinion you have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt which it sounds like based off 7 mins in he was fcked instantly
Unfortunately any false rapport he succeeds in showing is completely self serving. He does nothing without an ulterior motive for HIMSELF in my opinion. One of the worst pathological liars and narcissists I’ve ever seen on trial. Unfortunately people like him have very few (IF ANY) redeeming features. He loves himself far too much to ever do an “Epstein’. Anyone that can murder people the professed to love is totally and completely incapable of rehabilitation, the Judge obviously recognised that with his sentence.
He's comfortable running his mouth in the courtroom. "NO I DID NOT"Pure ignorance. No emotion in denying shooting his "loved ones" but when it comes to affecting his future and his alone the emotion shows.
Yes, I noticed it too, its like because he's saying "intentionally " that he's not lying because it was in a rage, I believe Paul took his pills while he slept, he woke and went down there to try and get them back and it sent him into a rage. Maggie's car was still running and I can't figure out why.
@@amandagoodrum9708 I've wondered if they were attempting a mini intervention or something, and the car was running because the plan was to take him to a rehab facility but he freaked out first.
I noticed he won’t look the prosecutor in the eye when speaking to him “No I did not” What’s with all the smacking today? He lied because he was covering up. Why else would he lie. He’s guilty
@@renaybrown4313 Maybe this is completely naive of me, but he's been in jail for awhile now. If he stopped opiates when he went to jail, his withdrawal would be long over. Is it possible that he'd still be taking opiates in jail? I doubt his family would help pay for it after what he's put them through. It does look like addict behavior but it could also just be cotton mouth from anxiety over how huge the stakes are here.
Notice how the prosecutor asks him a question and Alex repeats the prosecutors question before answering? Hes trying to buy himself time before answering. Liars use that delaying tactic....
@Lisa Krug - In regards to repeating the question. I shouldve been more clearer. They repeat the question, to buy themselves time to think of an answer. Liars use it as a delaying tactic. Id say beauty contestants arent necessarily liars but they are buying themselves time to come up with an answer. Its not always used by liars I guess lol 👍
“I didnt shoot my wife or my Son anytime ever” Why even say the words “anytime” or “ever”? It’s like there was a possibility or a desire to in the past when he could’ve but he didn’t ever shoot them before. Even though he did. It just makes no sense. I don’t know. I can’t explain it. Just seems like those definitely aren’t the words you use to answer THAT question.
if he didn’t do it, he definitely knows who did & just don’t want that person to get caught. regardless, he knows exactly what happen to his son & wife
So he would fall on a sacrificial sword? No…people who do things like this? The hatred builds up in them slowly (this is my opinion)..this is a man who needs to “control” everything around him. His life started spiraling out of control as soon as the firm’s accountant told him they knew about his stealing the money from the clients. And then he convinced himself it wasn’t his fault but Maggie’s ….nagging about his pill taking….and Paul’s boat fiasco that became his problem after Mallory Beach’s death and he was sued personally because Paul was under age…it isn’t a stretch because he murdered them that day! And I am sure opioids and alcohol had a lot to do with it! Very sad…but if Paul didn’t video that last meeting at the kennel …he probably would have gotten away with it!
Love how he thinks he can condense that timeline to fit the story once the video was discovered. Without the video his story works: with the phone in the house, getting up from a nap and txting his wife. The amount of steps he took in the time after the murder could have been explained by saying he woke up a bit late, had to rush around etc. Soon as the video was found none of it made sense.
Sooo curious about Alex’s upbringing and his siblings true nature. Something about John Marvin and cleaning up the scene seems off? Maybe not. I’d kill to know more about Alex’s dad and how he supposedly threatened his wife Libby by putting her obituary in the paper when she threatened divorce…I wonder if there’s truth to that, I heard it in the Netflix doc. If true - how sinister and disturbingly frightening!!!
“I would never…intentionally…do anything to hurt Maggie and Paw Paw…” Says it all right there. But I think it’s served up with a huge side of minimizing because by manipulating and setting Maggie up to be there, using TWO different weapons….it was fully intentional.
BY NOW, WE CAN PICK UP ON A CERTAIN RHYTHM AND "SWING" TO HIS CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR. ALSO, WE CAN NOW DETECT HIS STYLE OF SNOT PRODUCTION AND HOW HE IS MATCHING WITS WITH MR. WATERS ( A GAME HE IS PLAYING INSTEAD OF ANY TRUE CARE ABOUT PEOPLE THAT HE HAS HURT)
I think the constant shaking of the head is his way of agreeing with the prosecution that he’s guilty - he’s a pathetic individual, I can only imagine the pure horror both Maggie and Paul must have experienced as he murdered them in cold blood
I wish they had asked him how he could possibly see that his son was still alive and then fire a shotgun at close range, knowing what it would do. It sounds like Paul saw him and knew it was his dad that was killing him 😢
@@maryfrances1307 He's got no manners whatsoever, chomping & chewing w/crap in his mouth every time you look at him, not to mention, he can't even grab a tissue, he just lets his snot stream down into his lap on the stand. Really disgusting.
That pitiful “ I’m really struggling with this, the nightmare is real, I’ve got to deal with this, I’m really devastated “little fast nod....OH my goodness that was so annoying- it just really grieved my SOUL. It’s amazing how liars, even if they’re perfected in their craft, don’t realize how cartoonishly obvious they look in their performance.... yet they think they’re real pulling it off 😳😳😳 It just really goes to show that deception is a strong thing when you settle to come into an agreement with a lie within yourself.
@@karenorozco8917 Not even close! A sociopath,liar,thief who enjoys doing this does not regret anything, except getting caught! His performance is rehearsed. He knows how to act,how to manipulate ppl as that's exactly what he does or did for a living. He has prosecuted cases,chose juries,gave openings,closings,questioning witnesses etc. He does not regret it one bit. He his wife supplied alcohol to underage kids all the time. None of Paul's "friends"spoke up about how wonderful he was. He wasn't. He & his dad had hunted and killed animals & birds for his entire life. Paul killed the housekeeper of 25 yrs. watch the docu. on Utube. What happened when he killed Mallory Beach...Buster killed his lover to make sure no one knew he was with a guy. His friends had begun to question him & taunt him. So he had to go. The power the lack of emotions for the entire family through out decades is well known. He knows exactly how to act! ACT!
What! This cross was terrible! After watching this entire trial, I am convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Alex Murdaugh is guilty of both murders in this case. That said, the prosecution was only allowed to bring in evidence of his financial crimes to establish a motive. They were not allowed to use evidence from these crimes to establish Alex’s character. It’s obvious that’s what is happening during the majority of cross. That lawyer handed the defence grounds for appeal on a silver platter by fixating so much on every client he stole from. Alex’s lawyers are likely holding back their objections to such clear character defamation precisely so they can use it to appeal the verdict. I understand this is not a good man on trial. But I’m annoyed the prosecution actively chose to break the rules laid out in this case. They had more than enough evidence of the actual murders to have won without making this into a inquiry into dozens of financial crimes he’s not even denying.
@@katewilson9183 not saying the overall strategy was executed well, I am a trial lawyer and think the cross was good. If you do it too you know how hard it is.
@@ChristieColeman-uc5dd I can definitely appreciate how hard it is. Not to mention the added pressure of such a high profile case. I think overall the prosecution did a decent job. It was just this specific cross that grated me. I think he even realized that he got carried away with the “look in the eyes and lie to” line, considering he apologized to the jury the next day for how long he went on with that line of questioning.
To the Prosecutor....When Alex Murdaugh is saying he doesn't believe the person was even there is because they were incapacitated in some form from their Injuries, therefore they were not able to come info the office or lacked the mental capacity. That made it easier for him to carry out the criminal offenses as often as he did. This is why he can give the same response over and over..I almost forgot to mention Certified Mail was a way to do things back in the day.
Early signs of bipolar manic black outs , scitzo by drug use (can also be caused by alcohol) , alzimhers , mpd, borderline personality disorder, a million things I don’t think he is guilty , I think drugs have damaged his brain by abuse of prescription medication that wasn’t ment for him . Just not enough pointing to him
He had no distrust in SLED when he flashed his “badge” at the hospital with the boat case. Actually he had a ton of trust in sled. Funny defense wants to use that narrative.
This is his lawyers giving him timelines about what to say when asked. He’s tying himself in a mess……yeah give them all the unnecessary information. It’s called distracting the jurors with fillers.
What did he do with all that money? It wasn’t all for drugs. There is some other situation going on when they’re stealing 10’s of millions and can’t pay it back. It’s not like his entire family and friends were buying pills also. This reeks of hidden money for Buster somewhere else.
he definitely has anger, there are many times where you can see his jaw get tight because he’s angry or frustrated, but he isn’t mad because they are dead, he’s mad that his whole world is being revealed, there is a video of him where is face is blood red and the look of pure evil when he is sitting with his lawyers and that look is so horrific it scared me and made me cry.
His consistent lies and contradictions, the obvious use of cute nicknames to make him more relatable, the abuse or over extension of his position of power and the fact that he admits to being there at 8:44 and not having a positive alibi until getting to his mothers. The fact that the guns used were missing his gun was loaded the exact same way the hose was touched it, the GSR, the blood spatter, the fact that he was about to lose everything for fraud it really is an open and shut case. There being no specific person that threatened Paul to point the blame at. It’s unreasonable to think he isn’t to blame. Open and shut case in my opinion the prosecution did a beautiful job presenting this case.
You will notice that everytime he lies, he sniffs. Nearly everytime. When you begin to compare it with evidence we know contradicts, it is scary how telling that is.
I think that is a tremor related to his opioid addiction….there are great many side effects from “detox” and I have read about nose running…lots of sniffing and tremors. So he rocks back and forth as well.
I don’t understand how you could just walk off from your deceased family and speak normally in this manner on the phone to answer questions and walk to the house etc. The whole 911 call is very “off” for someone that just found their loved ones deceased. That’s just my personal opinion and observations. This is so unbelievably sad.
That says nothing to me. There's many many innocent people out there whose calls are just as off, weird, odd, and calm and or distracted. Many. That call I don't take much out of-only the evidence.
How shocking to see you're dad holding the gun.did paul say anything to dad.what are your feelings for this. And Maggie. Betrayal to the max.she saw some one she thought she knew.no chance for either one.so sad, this whole saga of deceit and murder.
I definitely think he killed Paul quickly cause he could maybe fight back so he blew his head off but when it came to Maggie he had a little talk with her then blew her away. That Dr G TH-cam channel talks about it in his video on the third interrogation.
I always felt he was shocked paw paw didn't go down with the first shot. And had to get him again. I think with the wife he shot her but when he was going for the kill...I think he said a lot to her. He overkills Paw paw out of shock but Maggie's overkill, 2 shoots to the head....seem out of a passionate anger.
He seems so prepared for answering specific questions, but what we don’t see is that authenticity of a grieving, father and husband there’s no reflections on how he felt and how he feels now with his world crashing down all around him I don’t know it’s just very robotic
![⭐ฮิตในTikTok!! ( หมูเด้ง MooDeng ) Ver. แดนซ์โจ๊ะๆ ReMix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3krsyfWUeHU/mqdefault.jpg)
Can someone please give that man some damn water ! My misophonia cannot deal with those sounds coming from his mouth the ENTIRE time !!!!
Same, I have the autocaptions on and the volume turned down SO low. I thought about just reading the transcript but I wanted to see how he said things, not just what he said.
That’s a habit of drug addicts
I thought he was chomping on something!
Ughhh. Yesss. I think he does it on purpose thinking it’s coming off as him struggling emotionally
I thought he was chewing on something. So annoying.
His lip smacking is insufferable 😭
Like Barty Crouch....
This is eventually going to make one hell of a movie. So much material
Want a movie about everything why don't we make a movie about yourself too?
Mini series, please!!!!!!
@@kwnwrestler16 😂 dude, you have horrible grammar.
Why watch a movie when you got the trial?
@@kwnwrestler16should make a movie about your boring life. None will watch. A Murdaugh movie would KILL!
4:20:04 Lawyer deliberately called the injured person a paraplegic and Alex took the bait correcting him by stating he was actually a quadriplegic. Just shows how evil he was stealing from someone like that.
No, I don't think it was a set-up by the prosecutor. It was an honest mistake, but bc Alex is trying to come across as being an "honest" man, he corrected him! In the end it held no water with the Jury....
You are right and was not the only time. Waters out lawyers AM.
@carolyn yanik
Alex didn't need to correct the prosecutor in order for the nastiness of his schemes to be apparent.
It's more likely to be a simple mistake but none of us have any way of knowing, especially with confidence.
I agree here. The prosecutor knows this case thoroughly and knows in fact the person was a quadriplegic. Smoooth move!👍
Lawyer lying...
It's nice coming back and watching this knowing he's been found guilty
❤
@@susangphotos Yeah like a terrible version of a Columbo episode, he's guilty, we know he did it - so lets get to the mechanics of it
Right? 😂 I am doing it also. He's talking different as the trial goes on. Instead of 𝗧𝗛𝗔𝗧 𝗵𝗲'𝘀 𝘀𝗮𝘆𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗗𝗔𝗧
I think so too. One intimate moment between his mom & dad and we end up with this creature.
@@Deborah4Antiques Lol never thought about it like that, but hey that could be said about every creature on earth.
I know this sounds odd, given the circumstances, but listening to Murdaugh testify I can see how people were charmed by him and trusted him.
He seems very likeable to me...
I agree.
It’s the southern gentleman accent.
This is a cold hearted dude. You can’t make me believe that Alex was the only lawyer stealing.Alex learned this from his family.The federal government is should look into all the cases that firm ever had.
Also the police department who cover up all Murdock's wrong doing.
What was his motive to kill his wife and son though? Dear god
The outrage that should be displayed from a man whose wife and son were murdered just isnt there. Actions tell it all.
What scares me is that he doesn't look like a murderer😢😮 This evil murder his own son and wife. How own son😢EVIL
It’s so obvious too that he has NO CURIOSITY about who killed them 😂 it’s almost like he already knows who did it… *cough*
@@rnarzu he certainly sounds like a person one would naturally lean towards and admire. Seems to have an ‘awe shucks’ mannerism that just makes him likeable.
But he found his charm could deceive and fill his desire to line his pockets that he would do ANYTHING to protect that image.
Paul became a thorn in his foot and with charges against Paul coming to a head within days, he had to go…Nothing would get in his way. So sad.
Fear and having a criminal past won’t matter if u lie or not they won’t believe u
there wouldnt be a calm moment if i was being chrged with my families murder and i was innocent
Every time the lawyer asks if he shot his family members he replies “no I did not” while frantically nodding his head yes.
Yup. Just saw that. He's a liar
God the things this guy can blame on opiate drug addiction just defies belief. Millions of dollars stolen because he took pills?? Gimme a break.
He stole almost nine million. That takes some real entitlement.
I know it's crazy
I don’t believe he took as many pills as he said he did. Maybe 460 milligrams a day. I doubt anyone has a tolerance of 460 pills and not die. Just the amount of Tylenol in that many perks alone would destroy a liver quickly.
@@Derricktaco I agree that he's exaggerating but he never said Percocet. He was addicted to Oxy
Did anybody in the Murdough family call Paul by his given name?
One of the things that gets me and I think everyone agrees is, the lack of anger towards the 'real killer' and the lack of motivation on his part, or any Murdaugh's part, to find who allegedly did these henious murders. That alone speaks volumes as to his guilt.
Just like OJ
Bingo! And not remembering the last conversation with Maggie and Paul in the Kennels
@@mfeteira The psychotrauma of finding loved ones shot to death (after you just did it, plus scoops of HillBilly Heroin) tends to erase from the memory any small niggling details which would later be detrimental to one's defence.
Everyone was diligently trying to find out who killed his family except him.
@@mfeteira i don’t understand how that would be such a difficult thing to make up. he could just say they were talking about how the dogs were doing or how his mother is, or a baseball game or show they were watching. literally anything
It’s so clear in watching this how tactical it was for him to call Paul “Paw Paw”. He starts the first two times calling him Paul and immediately corrects himself to Paw Paw, like oh yeah I’m supposed to be calling him the nickname for my theatrical story!
Exactly!! And he was working my last nerve with that too.. we all know you killed paw paw and his mother .. you money hungry murder
Bingo. I caught on to that load of crap as well. Like calling him Paw Paw would make him look like a grieving killer.
All this slobbering bullshidder wished was that “PauPau” never had a boat party.
It was so ridiculous the whole “paw paw” bit. He would drop it and pick it back up when he forgot.
Paw Paw 😭😭
Paul took that video and I'm so glad he did. Puts his dad right there.
Little detective 💔
How ironic was that? He did the video and didn’t have a clue about what was going to happen….
Paw Paw screwed him, again
This was the biggest L in legal history, how the hell are you a lawyer and you get up there with your pawpaw and mags and all that mess? He would have been so much better off had he not testified. I laughed my ass off when I saw this because I knew after he said he was there that his ass was fried.
Dude it was suicide for him to get up there.
Who else could have killed Maggie and Paul between 8:50 pm and 9:00 pm at the kennel location while Alex was supposedly napping on his couch in the house, without him hearing 7 rifle and shotgun shots?????????? His story is UTTERLY preposterous. WHY ARE THE FAMILY'S TWO SUSPECT GUNS MISSING? WHY are his shirt and shoes missing? That has never been explained. Am I the only one who keeps watching this learning something new each time I watch?? I'm somehow hooked on this, fascinated and APPALLED by THIS true life crime.
I think an audit of payouts vs what clients actually received across the entire US would net an astronomical amount of attorneys guilty of these same exact crimes. I believe this to be a industry standard and an unwritten taught scam of the lawyer community.
I agree 💯
...And far too many of these scumbags are running the federal (and local) government.
So many people just do not understand that you do not need to be an attorney to be voted into offices.
This is likely true .I bet many lawyers take a bigger cut if they can get more , And every single person in this world tells lies but he lied about stealing , not everyone is a thief. And he has guilty written all over him for murder . That sets him apart from most humans. No empathy present to kill son and wife with no remorse
That,'s scary, so some of them must be murderers too
Definitely is
This man is BEYOND a narcassist. He's absolutely diabolical.
Why is "narcissist" the current go-to TH-cam commenter insult?
@King Ayy I agree. I rarely use it, but when it fits...
@@kingayy9267 It seems you are right. I’m early 70s & had not heard of a “narcissist” (I suppose I’m fortunate). I’m in the U.K. so much is different yet the same, maybe it’s our language? This trial has had me gripped, the saddest for Paul & his dear Mama. Alex is the like of which I have ever known. The jury found him guilty of their murders, I have heard he has sought an appeal. He played everyone
I must say. Through none of his police interviews does he call his son Paul, “Paul-Paul” he REALLY tried it! 😂 trying to make himself have affection for that boy. Shame!
Him saying paw paw is killing me
Because you hear the deception in it. You pick up the evil in it.
Yes, he’s using their nicknames on purpose to seem like he *loved* them
I just can’t believe he thought the bobbing of his head and smacking before talking would fool these jurors. He’s a lawyer and I guess he thought the jurors were gullible
No they see he is an addict and has a criminal history himself
Plus the occasional eye contact
Opiods cause dry mouth. I don't think he is clean.
He had it all. A wife, sons and money, and that wasn't enough for him. He is beyond sickening and evil. And now he has NOTHING!!!
As an attorney, he knows how to chew a bowl of word salad. More words, more confusion for the jurors to try to sort out. What's pertinent, what's word salad? The man is just pure evil. IMO
Word salad?
Word salad is defined as “a jumble of extremely incoherent speech".
@@princessclaude6615 ok thanks
Does Alex really think that the jury believes his stupid lies??
that is why he took the stand. Cross examination he is another character, his arrogance convicted him. Glad he did.
I feel horrible for his family for their untimely deaths being murdered but my heart breaks for the people that trusted him and even those that resulted in death.My God.What evil is this?
83prettyblack - I wouldn't waste my sympathy if I was you. They're not one of them worth it.
If I was in on the stand being accused of a family murder I didn’t do, I would be so frustrated and angry and saying in every other sentence “you are wasting time! I did not do this! PLEASE reevaluate and GO FIND WHO DID THIS TO MY FAMILY!!!” We are watching a song and dance!
And your attorney would advise you not to do that. Truth is, we don’t know if he’s lying. But likely, he is.
You cannot evaluate someone else's behavior based on what you would do. This is how the police get it wrong, end up with tunnel vision and end up arresting the wrong person who goes on trial and ends up in jail for life or worse. We don't know if he's actually guilty, he probably is, but he is a liar, and if you lie too much when you do tell the truth, no one will believe you.
That's the way you would act. That doesn't mean that is the way he should act or it means he is guilty. Does your conscience bother you?
@@Jessa-RM No, you can’t evaluate on what we’d do but don’t you think if anyone were accused of this and didn’t do it that they’d be very upset and yell and scream their innocence and be so mad and throw a fit about the fact that they’re being accused of it? I’d never just sit there and talk about straps on a damn tree. I’d sit there and go off for hours about how wrong they are and how stupid they are. I’d be kicked out of court! I’d fight for my life and fight for them to find the killers the entire time I’m in court!
@BJW f yes man. He's simply speaking way too much about nonsense. An innocent person does not talk this much about everything and anything. Well he is. Classic sign of guilt. And people can think what they want. If your wife and son were murdered and your being prosecuted you would be fn frustrated about what's being done with who actually killed his MF family. Period.
He keeps saying he thinks the world of the people he stole from and I find it stunning how he can separate this.
That's how sick in the head he is.
It's despicable to be honest. The audacity of Alex to say he cares when he stole millions from those clients
I think he thought the world of his wife and son too....up until he HAD to do something. It needed to be done. Probably how he felt about those clients. They're nice people but IT needs to be done. Selfish to the core
I watched this again. It is absolutely amazing to me that this case was solved by the victim. The person who spent the weekend with him was intuitive enough to document everything. What he wore, where he was, the exact time he died. The guns he used. The shot gun with buck shot and duck shot . He documented they went to duck pond. The blackout and the casings. Just in real. Heart breaking
What’s amazing is that even Alex referred to Paul as very intuitive and that was before he realized Paul had posted these videos of him the day he died
Even a non guilty person would get a tissue or ask for a tissue but he wanted people to see him “crying” because that was the most important thing to him even if it meant having snot all over him which a “typical” person wouldn’t do but someone that’s trying desperately to get you to believe their lie would.
He was purposely doing it. Listen for his nasal sounds, he blows it out
He was more distraught and frustrated with PawPaw being accused of the boat wreck and hopeful of overturning the law, than finding the ‘killer’ of his own son and wife! He never once showed that same passion and determination for the murders, as he did for the boat wreck! But the boat wreck was opening up a whole new kind of can of worms for Alex! His financial troubles, thefts, and mismanagement of clients claims were fixing to be unleashed!!!!
The way his head has a slight nodding effect. When givin any questions about murdering Maggie and Paul or hiding guns. Is fascinating. His body betrays him
No reason to lie when it comes to your wife and son murder I would be honest about everything to catch the killers..HE DID IT 💯
It's all the "addiction" causing everything. His mouth smacking classic when he is forced to pretend to tell the truth. Disgusting too. His paranoia would not come and go like he's describing.He got off ripping ppl. off & enjoying how he is fooling everyone. Just disgusting.
interesting that you noticed mouth smacking as a sign
How he was smacking the lips, you'd think he had a damn Jolly Rancher in his mouth.
Looks to me like he’s on some kinda antidepressant stuff. Almost all of them cause cottonmouth. It sounds benign, but it’s grotesque.
@@maureenhammack9826 😂😂😂
@@lolodee3528 that’s what I was thinking too- my dad has worked in the prison system for nearly 40 years and he said some of the inmates are on more drugs IN prison than when they’re OUT! To me it doesn’t seem fair, you should have to live with your anxiety and depression but sadly that’s not what happens.
Key words.... from his ENTIRE testimony..... "I would never INTENTIONALLY hurt my wife Maggie or my son, Paul Paul." He did himself ZERO favors by taking the stand.
Not that I’m defending him but, that’s the best we ALL can say about anyone that we love. We most definitely can hurt them physically and emotionally UNINTENTIONALLY, but to hurt them intentionally is where evil lurks. So he did chose that word correctly.
I would have to disagree.. he killed them... so CLEARLY he WOULD 'intentionally' hurt them. @@sanjuan651
His defense team couldn't talk him out of testifying. He believed he could convince the jury if his innocence.
Delusional monster.
Not once have I seen anyone ask where he got the pills as I am not sure he even had an opiate addiction.
I just realized this, when Alex is talking about those chickens being “Guard birds “ and making a lot of racket when anything unusual is going on or someone is around, those birds would have been making noise if a vigilante was lurking in the shadows and he would have heard that. Also those dogs would have been barking like crazy! They are hunting dogs! I’m surprised he didn’t shoot the dogs too. He gives me nightmares!
Prosecution time was absolutely brilliant! Murdaugh you will meet the devil!
Next question STEVEN SMITH?????
He is the (DEVIl)
Imagine the information that we didn't get to hear because it didn't make it into trial. I bet there's more and it points to him.
There are allegations by a prostitute also. It’s on TH-cam.
I can tell you a prison recording he called buster told him to go back to the house Buster asked him why he said so he could go deer hunting ..thus is before he was convicted ..According to Alex he is innocent he wasn't the killer so if that was true would there still be a murderer out there not caught ...Why would you ask your so to go bck deer hunting if the murderer wasn't caught
I heard that. Why in God's name would your surviving son want to SHOOT anything on the same property his mother and brother were gunned down on?? It's crazy.
Mr Murdaugh what time did you get home?
Well you see this watch is a Swiss watch and the mechanics are very delicate. There’s a historical factory that goes back hundreds of years that employs watchmakers. There was a young man who used to work there that one day was walking in the garden and got stung by a bee……
Notice that when talking about his wife, he never said how much he loved her or how he fell in love with her. She was just a goodun who could fit in with his crowd and the poor people. She didn’t take to childbirth like it was a choice. She never questioned the finances and just signed what she wanted her to. Second class, there to serve his needs.
This guy is the king of word salad avoidance.
Bill Clinton...definition of"is."
Southern shady lawyer
No no, I'm sure we needed to hear about the guinea fowl, that's the key to this whole case 😅
Such a wonderful family....his son doesn't even know when his dad's birthday is...
He even ripped off longtime Nanny who raised his boys! Said there would be big insurance then pocketed it for himself! Maggie was going to divorce him then Paul's lawsuit would cost him $10M!! have no doubt he blew his own family away becuz they were liabilities to him!!
is this narcissism? Is he a narcissistic person. It seems to me that he is. Arrogant? But why did he do it? I do not see a motive
The root to all evil 👿 money 💰
Çheryls explanation sounds right.
How wealthy are they though? I saw the Netflix doc and knowing how much he would do to protect his son it’s tough to believe he would kill him. I’m not saying I believe him, I’m just trying to figure out the motive.
Yup. Definitely the reason why. I thought this even just seeing the documentary.
He’s lied so much, how can we believe him now?
What has he lied about? I just started watching this
@@IAmEmber everything lol😂
Can't. Boy who cried wolf.
@@IAmEmber He lied over and over to police and SLED the night of the murders. Also, all of the thievery over the years. This guy has NO credibility.
@@IAmEmberhe has a criminal history he has lied to the law before and u can tell he fears he has to lie because no one will believe him if he tells the truth and if he lies they still wont
It would have driven me nuts him repeating the question and talking in circles. What the hell did he do with all the millions of dollars he stole?
Cars, trips, hunting parties, boats, guns, beach house, town house, hunting lodge….they lived lavish
They had an expensive lifestyle. All their houses. He stole to afford that lifestyle.
Gambling.
I have a certain sympathy for his lawyers who must have known they were defending a lying evil murderer and that they were going to get their asses handed to them. I’m sure they tried to get him to plead guilty for a lesser sentence and probably advised him strongly not to take the stand. But this narcissist truly believed he could talk his way out of this. He’s never been held accountable for anything in his entire life, no doubt he thought that would continue. But everyone gets their comeuppance and he got two life sentences worth. The judge gave it to him with both barrels making those sentences run consecutively.
They’ve filed an appeal already. I don’t feel sorry for them.
Do not feel sorry for either one….
I think his lawyers were sick of him. He made them look like fools by lieing about his alibi. Then the jury says the thing that convicted him was his testimony and going to moselle. I’m not sure they wanted him to testify. Which he did thinking I’m a better lawyer than waters. That was problem he acted like a lawyer not a real person. Which is what the jury wanted to see.
He gives more detailed information than he needs to. He's trying to establish a rapport with the jury..."make them like me" "they will see that I'm just a normal guy" He gets an A+ for lying constantly and putting on a show. True Narcissist at work here. They got your number...how about Stephen Smith's life? What happened there Alex/Buster? I'm thrilled that case is being opened back up.
A malignant Nac + Psychopath. He is really mentally disturbed.
*rapport
Thats funny when if were being honest what about him is likable?? He gets a fair unbiased jury with me so i guess we got 5 hours worth of day 1 to watch let the man have a fair shake the whole way through ! I know trials over but everybody instantly has an opinion you have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt which it sounds like based off 7 mins in he was fcked instantly
Unfortunately any false rapport he succeeds in showing is completely self serving. He does nothing without an ulterior motive for HIMSELF in my opinion. One of the worst pathological liars and narcissists I’ve ever seen on trial. Unfortunately people like him have very few (IF ANY) redeeming features. He loves himself far too much to ever do an “Epstein’. Anyone that can murder people the professed to love is totally and completely incapable of rehabilitation, the Judge obviously recognised that with his sentence.
With all the hurt he did to people that hired him he is wating time. I definitely dont see them liking him.
He's comfortable running his mouth in the courtroom. "NO I DID NOT"Pure ignorance. No emotion in denying shooting his "loved ones" but when it comes to affecting his future and his alone the emotion shows.
NO I DID not.
No I did not!!!!
@Lucia-hb5kp true narcissistic for sure!! Thank God he was convicted!!
Thinking one knows something they can't actually know. Pure arrogance.
When they don’t use contraction for “did not”, they’re very likely lying
No I did not shaking his head yes. That's body language right there.😒
My thoughts exactly!
If he took a Polygraph Test the machine would explode😂😂
😅🤣😂
How many time has he said “ I would never intentionally hurt or kill the” oh ok so it was accidental cos you were drugged up? He did it
Yes, I noticed it too, its like because he's saying "intentionally " that he's not lying because it was in a rage, I believe Paul took his pills while he slept, he woke and went down there to try and get them back and it sent him into a rage. Maggie's car was still running and I can't figure out why.
@@amandagoodrum9708 I've wondered if they were attempting a mini intervention or something, and the car was running because the plan was to take him to a rehab facility but he freaked out first.
I think he was saying it that way bc he knows he hurt them in many other ways… like with his drug addiction and all the lies and everything.
1 minute in and he’s nodding yes but saying no to if he killed his wife and son. 🤦🏼♀️
I noticed he won’t look the prosecutor in the eye when speaking to him “No I did not”
What’s with all the smacking today? He lied because he was covering up. Why else would he lie. He’s guilty
A lie is a lie 🤥 there is no justifiable reason for a lie.
Right! The smacking is getting on my nerves, it’s the drugs.
@@renaybrown4313 Maybe this is completely naive of me, but he's been in jail for awhile now. If he stopped opiates when he went to jail, his withdrawal would be long over. Is it possible that he'd still be taking opiates in jail? I doubt his family would help pay for it after what he's put them through. It does look like addict behavior but it could also just be cotton mouth from anxiety over how huge the stakes are here.
Did anybody notice that Alex said I WILL NEVER INTENTIONALLY DO ANYTHING TO HARM THEM.
Notice how the prosecutor asks him a question and Alex repeats the prosecutors question before answering? Hes trying to buy himself time before answering. Liars use that delaying tactic....
Good catch! I noticed that too
He's also a lawyer so he's trained adequately in the art of conditioning, confusing, legal-ease and pure and simple BS... That's part of it as well.
He’s also trying to make himself appear smaller another manipulation tactic.
Uhh ever noticed in beauty pageants when they’re asked that famous question, and they always repeat it before answering. So they’re always lying?
@Lisa Krug - In regards to repeating the question. I shouldve been more clearer. They repeat the question, to buy themselves time to think of an answer. Liars use it as a delaying tactic. Id say beauty contestants arent necessarily liars but they are buying themselves time to come up with an answer. Its not always used by liars I guess lol 👍
Pau!Pau!!! He’s playing emotional. Don’t believe him.
As a seasoned attorney, he knew what would swing a jury
Makes you wanna throw up little in the back of your throat, huh?
A grown man , a lawyer in court can’t even call him Paul. Get over that baby talk, you killer,,,
Apparently not. 😂
he's angrier towards the dude who killed the sunflowers...
Him testifying was a super terrible idea 😂 he seemed more guilty with every question An answer.
He's actually apologizing to everyone for killing them.
Well, this pillar of society has had his day in court. Amen.
Alex Alex Alex you deserve an Oscar for this performance 🎭
Ikr especially the snot that that on point
Rip Maggie and Paul
There should be charges regarding Badge 570 Badge 571 Impersonating LE as County Soliciter..Caught in a trap...
He actually thought he'd get on the stand and get off? He is the ultimate fool for a client, representing himself via the witness stand.
Interesting how he says he's embarrassed about stealing money from clients not ashamed. Just shows he still doesn't have remorse for stealing.
“I didnt shoot my wife or my Son anytime ever” Why even say the words “anytime” or “ever”? It’s like there was a possibility or a desire to in the past when he could’ve but he didn’t ever shoot them before. Even though he did. It just makes no sense. I don’t know. I can’t explain it. Just seems like those definitely aren’t the words you use to answer THAT question.
if he didn’t do it, he definitely knows who did & just don’t want that person to get caught. regardless, he knows exactly what happen to his son & wife
So he would fall on a sacrificial sword? No…people who do things like this? The hatred builds up in them slowly (this is my opinion)..this is a man who needs to “control” everything around him. His life started spiraling out of control as soon as the firm’s accountant told him they knew about his stealing the money from the clients. And then he convinced himself it wasn’t his fault but Maggie’s ….nagging about his pill taking….and Paul’s boat fiasco that became his problem after Mallory Beach’s death and he was sued personally because Paul was under age…it isn’t a stretch because he murdered them that day! And I am sure opioids and alcohol had a lot to do with it! Very sad…but if Paul didn’t video that last meeting at the kennel …he probably would have gotten away with it!
Agree
His own lawyer after he detailed his relationship with Maggie, had to point blank ask him if he loved her.
Love how he thinks he can condense that timeline to fit the story once the video was discovered. Without the video his story works: with the phone in the house, getting up from a nap and txting his wife. The amount of steps he took in the time after the murder could have been explained by saying he woke up a bit late, had to rush around etc. Soon as the video was found none of it made sense.
I had wondered what actual evidence they had on him. However , the lies he told and the 20 seconds did it for me.
Today's extremely accurate second-by-second phone records, steps taken, texts repeated etc., reveals facts. And nothing but the facts.
So they had cameras on the porch but no where else? That's odd to me
9:14 does anyone else find his statement curious? “When the sunflowers got killed, when we knew they were dead” we knew Paul was coming home.
Sooo curious about Alex’s upbringing and his siblings true nature. Something about John Marvin and cleaning up the scene seems off? Maybe not. I’d kill to know more about Alex’s dad and how he supposedly threatened his wife Libby by putting her obituary in the paper when she threatened divorce…I wonder if there’s truth to that, I heard it in the Netflix doc. If true - how sinister and disturbingly frightening!!!
“I would never…intentionally…do anything to hurt Maggie and Paw Paw…”
Says it all right there.
But I think it’s served up with a huge side of minimizing because by manipulating and setting Maggie up to be there, using TWO different weapons….it was fully intentional.
BY NOW, WE CAN PICK UP ON A CERTAIN RHYTHM AND "SWING" TO HIS CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR. ALSO, WE CAN NOW DETECT HIS STYLE OF SNOT PRODUCTION AND HOW HE IS MATCHING WITS WITH MR. WATERS ( A GAME HE IS PLAYING INSTEAD OF ANY TRUE CARE ABOUT PEOPLE THAT HE HAS HURT)
I think the constant shaking of the head is his way of agreeing with the prosecution that he’s guilty - he’s a pathetic individual, I can only imagine the pure horror both Maggie and Paul must have experienced as he murdered them in cold blood
I wish they had asked him how he could possibly see that his son was still alive and then fire a shotgun at close range, knowing what it would do. It sounds like Paul saw him and knew it was his dad that was killing him 😢
He did that almost the whole time during his testimony, but I noticed it a lot when he wasn't on the stand. It looked to me like a tick he had.
He appears to have tardive dyskinesia. It’s a neurological side effect of some medications, mainly psyche meds.
@@maryfrances1307 He's got no manners whatsoever, chomping & chewing w/crap in his mouth every time you look at him, not to mention, he can't even grab a tissue, he just lets his snot stream down into his lap on the stand. Really disgusting.
That pitiful “ I’m really struggling with this, the nightmare is real, I’ve got to deal with this, I’m really devastated “little fast nod....OH my goodness that was so annoying- it just really grieved my SOUL.
It’s amazing how liars, even if they’re perfected in their craft, don’t realize how cartoonishly obvious they look in their performance.... yet they think they’re real pulling it off 😳😳😳
It just really goes to show that deception is a strong thing when you settle to come into an agreement with a lie within yourself.
5:27 I feel like he's saying sorry for the murders.. and he's genuinely sorry, but doesn't want to admit to the murders.
Oh yes!
@@karenorozco8917 Not even close! A sociopath,liar,thief who enjoys doing this does not regret anything, except getting caught! His performance is rehearsed. He knows how to act,how to manipulate ppl as that's exactly what he does or did for a living. He has prosecuted cases,chose juries,gave openings,closings,questioning witnesses etc. He does not regret it one bit. He his wife supplied alcohol to underage kids all the time. None of Paul's "friends"spoke up about how wonderful he was. He wasn't. He & his dad had hunted and killed animals & birds for his entire life. Paul killed the housekeeper of 25 yrs. watch the docu. on Utube. What happened when he killed Mallory Beach...Buster killed his lover to make sure no one knew he was with a guy. His friends had begun to question him & taunt him. So he had to go. The power the lack of emotions for the entire family through out decades is well known. He knows exactly how to act! ACT!
Very good cross, going with the actual answers, no way to prep for this hard to do on the spot, great job.
What! This cross was terrible! After watching this entire trial, I am convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Alex Murdaugh is guilty of both murders in this case. That said, the prosecution was only allowed to bring in evidence of his financial crimes to establish a motive. They were not allowed to use evidence from these crimes to establish Alex’s character. It’s obvious that’s what is happening during the majority of cross. That lawyer handed the defence grounds for appeal on a silver platter by fixating so much on every client he stole from. Alex’s lawyers are likely holding back their objections to such clear character defamation precisely so they can use it to appeal the verdict.
I understand this is not a good man on trial. But I’m annoyed the prosecution actively chose to break the rules laid out in this case. They had more than enough evidence of the actual murders to have won without making this into a inquiry into dozens of financial crimes he’s not even denying.
@@katewilson9183 not saying the overall strategy was executed well, I am a trial lawyer and think the cross was good. If you do it too you know how hard it is.
@@ChristieColeman-uc5dd I can definitely appreciate how hard it is. Not to mention the added pressure of such a high profile case. I think overall the prosecution did a decent job. It was just this specific cross that grated me. I think he even realized that he got carried away with the “look in the eyes and lie to” line, considering he apologized to the jury the next day for how long he went on with that line of questioning.
To the Prosecutor....When Alex Murdaugh is saying he doesn't believe the person was even there is because they were incapacitated in some form from their Injuries, therefore they were not able to come info the office or lacked the mental capacity. That made it easier for him to carry out the criminal offenses as often as he did. This is why he can give the same response over and over..I almost forgot to mention Certified Mail was a way to do things back in the day.
Early signs of bipolar manic black outs , scitzo by drug use (can also be caused by alcohol) , alzimhers , mpd, borderline personality disorder, a million things I don’t think he is guilty , I think drugs have damaged his brain by abuse of prescription medication that wasn’t ment for him . Just not enough pointing to him
Buster was next in line to inherit the “thrown” of that town, that’s the only reason he didn’t die too
Paul messed busters $ up
Buster-ass is too stupid to carry on the family tradition.
"When you cry, let some snot drip outta your nose. No one would think someone would fake THAT!"
^ probable advice for Alex
Very gross, and he didn’t even ask for more Kleenex so def seemed intentional
It was his lame attempt to convey “I’m snot guilty.”
@@CynthiaDyer-qr7jb 😂😂😂 LMFAOOOOO
He had no distrust in SLED when he flashed his “badge” at the hospital with the boat case. Actually he had a ton of trust in sled. Funny defense wants to use that narrative.
Is it me or are a lot of the questions these lawyers ask him pointless
Too much time on bubba and the chicken
it was about motive
He just keeps talking………….prosecutors love it..,
This is his lawyers giving him timelines about what to say when asked. He’s tying himself in a mess……yeah give them all the unnecessary information. It’s called distracting the jurors with fillers.
What did he do with all that money? It wasn’t all for drugs. There is some other situation going on when they’re stealing 10’s of millions and can’t pay it back. It’s not like his entire family and friends were buying pills also. This reeks of hidden money for Buster somewhere else.
Him shaking his head yes, but say no to the killing of Maggie and Paul is an indication to me of guilt.
He is so full of it.if he had that badge hanging out staff would not have questioned him going in everyones rooms.
Alex has forgotten one HUGE human emotion:
💥ANGER!💥
Yes! Wheres the anger?? Where's the "I'm going to find who done this!?"
Yes!!
he definitely has anger, there are many times where you can see his jaw get tight because he’s angry or frustrated, but he isn’t mad because they are dead, he’s mad that his whole world is being revealed, there is a video of him where is face is blood red and the look of pure evil when he is sitting with his lawyers and that look is so horrific it scared me and made me cry.
His consistent lies and contradictions, the obvious use of cute nicknames to make him more relatable, the abuse or over extension of his position of power and the fact that he admits to being there at 8:44 and not having a positive alibi until getting to his mothers. The fact that the guns used were missing his gun was loaded the exact same way the hose was touched it, the GSR, the blood spatter, the fact that he was about to lose everything for fraud it really is an open and shut case. There being no specific person that threatened Paul to point the blame at. It’s unreasonable to think he isn’t to blame. Open and shut case in my opinion the prosecution did a beautiful job presenting this case.
Anyone else notice the 66 66 on the thermostat? Such a devil the thermostat even called him out. Such a sick person
You will notice that everytime he lies, he sniffs. Nearly everytime. When you begin to compare it with evidence we know contradicts, it is scary how telling that is.
He could of saved all that dripping snot! It’s not convincing.. it’s just gross.
He sits on a throne of lies
If he licks his lips or whatever he’s doing with his mount one. More. Time. Omg.
It’s Zoloft or Prozac-cottonmouth.
He only does it when talking about something he wants to avoid… my husband has been on Prozac for years and never has that issue.
Here we go, let’s cry a bit. We have to convince the jurors remember?!?
Murdaugh says "No I did not" while consistently nodding yes
True
I think that is a tremor related to his opioid addiction….there are great many side effects from “detox” and I have read about nose running…lots of sniffing and tremors. So he rocks back and forth as well.
What on earth is he doing with his mouth? 😳 Good grief!
I don’t understand how you could just walk off from your deceased family and speak normally in this manner on the phone to answer questions and walk to the house etc. The whole 911 call is very “off” for someone that just found their loved ones deceased. That’s just my personal opinion and observations. This is so unbelievably sad.
Yes, very sad for Malory and Stephen, and all the other teen agers he took advantage of.
@@geraldinepeckham3667 and the housekeeper who lost her life as well.
I do not find him speaking easily on the phone.
That says nothing to me.
There's many many innocent people out there whose calls are just as off, weird, odd, and calm and or distracted. Many. That call I don't take much out of-only the evidence.
@@dazzlingextremes389 Ok well I respect your opinion.
And what were the paranoid thoughts.. what did he think would happen...
How shocking to see you're dad holding the gun.did paul say anything to dad.what are your feelings for this. And Maggie. Betrayal to the max.she saw some one she thought she knew.no chance for either one.so sad, this whole saga of deceit and murder.
I definitely think he killed Paul quickly cause he could maybe fight back so he blew his head off but when it came to Maggie he had a little talk with her then blew her away. That Dr G TH-cam channel talks about it in his video on the third interrogation.
I always felt he was shocked paw paw didn't go down with the first shot. And had to get him again. I think with the wife he shot her but when he was going for the kill...I think he said a lot to her. He overkills Paw paw out of shock but Maggie's overkill, 2 shoots to the head....seem out of a passionate anger.
it would be nice if I could go two minutes w/ out ads popping up.
youtube premium is the best
OMG when he first sat down at the beginning talk about awkward
Fr 😂
Yes I was close to PawPaw. About 3 feet.
Waters out lawyered AM all day long.
He seems so prepared for answering specific questions, but what we don’t see is that authenticity of a grieving, father and husband there’s no reflections on how he felt and how he feels now with his world crashing down all around him I don’t know it’s just very robotic
Ppl grieve differently