Joseph Edwards Yeah, they're vocals alright, but as far as his actual singing voice goes, it's complete shite. He can't even get close to the high notes. That's the thing about Oasis fans, they're willing to tolerate Liam's terrible vocals because he's a character, but if some bloke on X-factor sounded like this, he'd be slagged off by everyone.
Joseph Edwards i compared this with 1996 live well it's almost not fucking different he's just short his word don't know why many people said his voice's sucks his age there almost 40 and still can sing pretty fine.
+Joseph Edwards hes anger is okey and yes it means something but the problem is the clarity on his voice his throw is shet at least not as shet as he had it in 2004
It is epic it is a total piece of history all things concerned. The song can not be but great, the sheer aggression and desperation this is distorted with is raw and rare. F great.
A vocal coach would say that the way Liam sings will eventually wreck his voice. But he's a natural talent, not a trained singer. He sings from his throat/larynx, a vocal coach would teach a singer to sing from their diaphragm. To be honest, I don't know how he didn't lose his voice during any of the touring. It's got to take it's toll that way of singing. I'm surprised it lasted as long as it did.
love the band..seems liam is pissed here, but, hes used that style of like attacking the mic with beady eye quite a bit. Extension of being angry, maybe bitter that his band split? Kinda reminds me a lot of my relationship with my bro. Mustve been tough keeping it together all those years.
If noel sang the songs oasis would of been complete Liam a good front man but didn't no the meaning behind the songs so just shouted words with no meaning
"6 done, 9 to go"...Noel couldn't wait for the tour to be over by that point. The whole band looked like they were going through the motions, and liam just trying to fight his way through it
Nope. Liam had a pint thrown at him earlier in the performance (hence why he's wet) that's why he's angry. Nothing to do with noel. Everyone always looks way too far into this performance.
I remember staying up at my Grandma's house to watch this and being so confused 😂 Liam furious and cutting off his vocals, Noel looking miserable 😣 it all made sense when they broke up 😂
I remember riding the bus and feeling really down while listening to "Half The World Away" for the first time. I swear I felt like Noel was actually talking to me in the last part of the song when he says: "Don't feel down, don't feel down..." Amazing song, amazing songwriting, amazing band!!
This is the gig where Liam was hit with pints and pound coins at the beginning. Search 'moody liam gallagher' and there's some frankly hilarious sound bites. They don't make frontmen like this anymore. Anyway, Champagne Supernova is sung well. Half The World Away, obviously brilliant from Noel. Slide Away - well, Liam is too pissed off, but I quite like the attitude. He can still sing that song well (well, at least he did on this tour). I suppose the anger is still there during Champagne, but for the first half he's pretty restrained! In any case, I miss this band!
noel is in tears, liam is going to fucking kill someone with anger, oasis are my life but these two have a relationship beyond repair. thank god noel quit, because any more performances like this wouldve been a disservice to the best band ive seen in my lifetime. if you want to see the sadness of the crumbling of two brothers who had nothing and found their genius and conquered the music world together, watch this video. i am in tears.
You can see the tension. He's almost completely ignoring the music in champagne supernova. They don't look like a band that's working together. His voice lacks power. It's incredible how he's managed to improve so much again. How good would they be together now.
Just for some context: He's so angry because he had a pint thrown at his during the first song. It's not because they were about to break up. Hope this helps.
@@markythompson Nope,never,no..At almost every big gig,he had objects thrown at him,yet he never had such an angry attitude. It's not about a freaking pint,the band's about to break up.
@@george_karamperis7 What you're doing here is spreading misinformation. I'm forever reading comments saying "this is so sad. You can see in Liam's eyes that oasis are splitting up". He was hit with a pint of beer, or perhaps piss which you can hear in the audio version of the gig during the first song. Don't "Nope, never, no" when in fact you don't know. Liam had absolutely no idea they were splitting up. I don't know if you're familiar with Liam Gallagher's intelligence but he's not that bright.
This is so o o o fucking beast. The best oasis performance of all time . You need to wake up. The passion and agression in liam in that first song, is timeless. A strugle thru the molten rock of earth. A strong man. With passsion, Hes a warrior. Fuck yes. Go my son.. Fuck em , Destroy lads
I know that some people are pointing out the faults in the audience for looking bored, but I would too. There’s just not a lot of heart in their performance, just anger and it looks like sadness in Noel. Plus there were plenty of bands out in 09 that were much better than Oasis at that time.
Love how Liam sits around for the Half The World Away, just like the old days..they were back in the limelight, they were there, and Noel kinda threw it away.
Awful rendition of slide away. With Liam's voice being as it was by that point, I can't understand why they'd have it in the set. They dumped Some Might Say from the set in late 90s cause he couldn't sing the chorus anymore. should have done the same with this.
They played Some Might Say in Heathen Chemistry tour 02-03 with its key changed, still sounded pretty ace to my point of view. And yes Liam is shouting and lacking power here - but U can tell he puts all of his emotion in it even if the voice isnt as it was.
They played Some Might Say in Heathen Chemistry tour 02-03 with its key changed, still sounded pretty ace to my point of view. And yes Liam is shouting and lacking power here - but U can tell he puts all of his emotion in it even if the voice isnt as it was.
I do not get that opinion, to say this would be..but a moment, then I mean, really? This, is no fake, this is the end of a huge band. Horrible? It is like electric, f amazing piece of History. There and then, Who cares on the sound, this is like Pistols at Winterland 78. Say all on Liam but few can shine that bright on stage. The songs are just a treasure. Oasis was not another band. They made more good stuff than neither Beatles or Stones even came near of. At worst they were delivering a title or 2 of epic proportions on each release. They were really damn good.
because he spends most of his time on stage twiddling his thumbs (kidding) it's always been a power struggle between him and his brother. i think it was something to do with him looking to promote his "pretty green" clothing while on tour and noel told him where to go... but there's more to it than that (that's just one example without going on and on about it)
![Oasis [1994] Live at Gleneagles [Best AV Sources Combined]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gbtDjDAq1vk/mqdefault.jpg)
By far the best Champagne Supernova solo. The part when he used the Cry Baby Wah gave me chills.
I love it when Liam is angry.
Real emotion in real songs.
sounded awesome. Like watching the end of a scorsese movie, the big downfall part. We had it good once ! 🍏👌
Funny how Liam points at Noel when he sings 'how many special people change'
Am I the only one who thinks Liams vocals are really good here. The anger in his voice means something...
Joseph Edwards Yeah, they're vocals alright, but as far as his actual singing voice goes, it's complete shite. He can't even get close to the high notes.
That's the thing about Oasis fans, they're willing to tolerate Liam's terrible vocals because he's a character, but if some bloke on X-factor sounded like this, he'd be slagged off by everyone.
Joseph Edwards i compared this with 1996 live well it's almost not fucking different he's just short his word don't know why many people said his voice's sucks his age there almost 40 and still can sing pretty fine.
+Deathshuck Of course. However, we can appreciate how good he was on the first few albums. So powerful.
+Joseph Edwards hes anger is okey and yes it means something
but the problem is the clarity on his voice his throw is shet at least not as shet as he had it in 2004
It is epic it is a total piece of history all things concerned. The song can not be but great, the sheer aggression and desperation this is distorted with is raw and rare. F great.
Sad to see that Noel sounded so good and Liam didn’t but if they were to tour now you’d have them both on their best would sound amazing
17:28
the sound of a band cracking
Gem is cool as fuck
4:18 and 19:30 ... I love that man ;)
Ireiri Alonso tambourine liam I think we all love that even in 2017
liam singing not bad there im suprised at because was wrecked about 2004
A vocal coach would say that the way Liam sings will eventually wreck his voice. But he's a natural talent, not a trained singer. He sings from his throat/larynx, a vocal coach would teach a singer to sing from their diaphragm. To be honest, I don't know how he didn't lose his voice during any of the touring. It's got to take it's toll that way of singing. I'm surprised it lasted as long as it did.
5.15 my boy is feeling a lot.
Gotta be the first time liam has stayed during noels songs
That Stone Island parka is still fucking sold out
It wasn't a Stone Island one. It was a Pretty Green parka.
love the band..seems liam is pissed here, but, hes used that style of like attacking the mic with beady eye quite a bit. Extension of being angry, maybe bitter that his band split? Kinda reminds me a lot of my relationship with my bro. Mustve been tough keeping it together all those years.
It seems like the Gallaghers are extremely disgusted at each other
days before #plumgate
I'm not so sure about that
If noel sang the songs oasis would of been complete Liam a good front man but didn't no the meaning behind the songs so just shouted words with no meaning
+davidatkinson56 what utter bollocks, oasis would never have been the band they were without liam's iconic voice
Shut up you clueless pratt
Liam brought the sound, attitude and everything that makes oasis badass and unique
Liam sat down In the background giving noel full on evils
"6 done, 9 to go"...Noel couldn't wait for the tour to be over by that point. The whole band looked like they were going through the motions, and liam just trying to fight his way through it
Liam between 5:10-5:15 told you everything. It was basically over.
Like a movie isnt it..
Like the downfall part of a scorsese movie. To much coke and alcohol 😯
Brings a genuine tear to the eye
Those lads could b still having it
Nope. Liam had a pint thrown at him earlier in the performance (hence why he's wet) that's why he's angry. Nothing to do with noel. Everyone always looks way too far into this performance.
I remember staying up at my Grandma's house to watch this and being so confused 😂 Liam furious and cutting off his vocals, Noel looking miserable 😣 it all made sense when they broke up 😂
I remember riding the bus and feeling really down while listening to "Half The World Away" for the first time. I swear I felt like Noel was actually talking to me in the last part of the song when he says: "Don't feel down, don't feel down..." Amazing song, amazing songwriting, amazing band!!
Sorry to spoil your dream but he says "I don't feel down" Hes talking about himself.
Bit gay that matey boy
Bill Grundy And whats gay about it ole Billy?
I get the same feeling when I listen to Stop Crying Your Heart out.
This is the gig where Liam was hit with pints and pound coins at the beginning. Search 'moody liam gallagher' and there's some frankly hilarious sound bites. They don't make frontmen like this anymore. Anyway, Champagne Supernova is sung well. Half The World Away, obviously brilliant from Noel. Slide Away - well, Liam is too pissed off, but I quite like the attitude. He can still sing that song well (well, at least he did on this tour). I suppose the anger is still there during Champagne, but for the first half he's pretty restrained! In any case, I miss this band!
that guitar noels playing, i had a tinkle on that when it was in for repair.
full of students who love their EDM. dont kno music if it hit em in their gurning mandy faces.
thats guy look like paul mccartney 12:26
yeah looks like him. but his nose is bigger
therotiv4 if Paul and Ringo had a kid
could tell from this gig something was going on
Noel playing all through this gig thinking "when is the twat going to do storm off or do something stupid"
17:35 I know he's mad but this just makes me fookin' lose it.
3:28-3:37 Noel looks as if he were about to cry?
A plum threw a plum at a plum.
He actually sings champagne supernova really well here
www.nme.com/news/music/oasis-356-1311615 for those like me who are wondering what the fuck was going on during this gig
Liam looks like he wants to kill Noel @ 4:34 what a sad sad way for it to end
Liam actually sounds really good during Champagne Supernova.
What a great guitarist Noel Gallagher is up he makes that guitar talk!!!
Noel "you can't sing anymore Liam"
Liam "oh yeah watch this knobend"
He's singing so well here
He's really, really not
Come on mate, he was in a constant fucking tear up with his vocals here. He sounds so much better now.
The part noel sang in slide away was sommet else seriously biblical
Noel makes that Gibson ES 355 sing.
Anyone wanting to listen to the full gig search for Oasis Jay Darlington and it comes up 👍. Great gig
Is gem where pretty green top?
No wonder Noel was dismissive with Liam promotion his clothing line in gigs.
00:10 Slide Away, 05:53 Interview, 09:51 Half the World Away, 13:43 Champagne Supernova
outstanding band. their will be nothing like them ever, had the lot. Live forever
noel is in tears, liam is going to fucking kill someone with anger, oasis are my life but these two have a relationship beyond repair. thank god noel quit, because any more performances like this wouldve been a disservice to the best band ive seen in my lifetime. if you want to see the sadness of the crumbling of two brothers who had nothing and found their genius and conquered the music world together, watch this video. i am in tears.
Shut up you soppy tart
You can see the tension. He's almost completely ignoring the music in champagne supernova. They don't look like a band that's working together. His voice lacks power. It's incredible how he's managed to improve so much again. How good would they be together now.
Just for some context: He's so angry because he had a pint thrown at his during the first song. It's not because they were about to break up. Hope this helps.
@@markythompson Nope,never,no..At almost every big gig,he had objects thrown at him,yet he never had such an angry attitude. It's not about a freaking pint,the band's about to break up.
@@george_karamperis7 What you're doing here is spreading misinformation. I'm forever reading comments saying "this is so sad. You can see in Liam's eyes that oasis are splitting up".
He was hit with a pint of beer, or perhaps piss which you can hear in the audio version of the gig during the first song.
Don't "Nope, never, no" when in fact you don't know.
Liam had absolutely no idea they were splitting up. I don't know if you're familiar with Liam Gallagher's intelligence but he's not that bright.
This is so o o o fucking beast. The best oasis performance of all time . You need to wake up. The passion and agression in liam in that first song, is timeless. A strugle thru the molten rock of earth. A strong man. With passsion, Hes a warrior. Fuck yes. Go my son.. Fuck em , Destroy lads
The basis of oasis splitting up is that Noel wanted to charge Liam money for advertising his clothing line in the tour programme. Seriously.
This is the end.
My favorite performance of 'Slide Away' in the 2000s
you can tell things where coming to an end. liam was so much better 10 years prior to this
18:28 Noel bro, super hot.
This a is about 2 weeks before Noel quit Oasis.
That solo at 17:40 Wow!
I didn't know brits had hot chicks like this.
I know that some people are pointing out the faults in the audience for looking bored, but I would too. There’s just not a lot of heart in their performance, just anger and it looks like sadness in Noel. Plus there were plenty of bands out in 09 that were much better than Oasis at that time.
3:35 POTATO
It shows me that you never should work with one of your siblings :-)
ladymay30 eh how exactly? One of the most successful bands of all time
Haha you fucking mug
is it their full show in iTunes Festival 2009?
very agressive
Oasis fabuloso
Lloyd xmas
Haha blow his tiny little mind
Winona Wu I started the interview at that point have a guess who I thought he was talking about
Noel is an excellent singer.
didnt know noel was on the roof for that song.
Champagne supernova
wow.
im in tears :(
Love how Liam sits around for the Half The World Away, just like the old days..they were back in the limelight, they were there, and Noel kinda threw it away.
Awful rendition of slide away. With Liam's voice being as it was by that point, I can't understand why they'd have it in the set. They dumped Some Might Say from the set in late 90s cause he couldn't sing the chorus anymore. should have done the same with this.
They played Some Might Say in Heathen Chemistry tour 02-03 with its key changed, still sounded pretty ace to my point of view.
And yes Liam is shouting and lacking power here - but U can tell he puts all of his emotion in it even if the voice isnt as it was.
They played Some Might Say in Heathen Chemistry tour 02-03 with its key changed, still sounded pretty ace to my point of view.
And yes Liam is shouting and lacking power here - but U can tell he puts all of his emotion in it even if the voice isnt as it was.
Sounds pretty decent tbh. Full of anger
Sounded amazing.should hav been there, i was
I may be wrong but by the end did Noel sing the high bits of live forever
slide away was fucking horrible!
Full of anger! masterpiece
I do not get that opinion, to say this would be..but a moment, then I mean, really?
This, is no fake, this is the end of a huge band. Horrible?
It is like electric, f amazing piece of History. There and then,
Who cares on the sound, this is like Pistols at Winterland 78.
Say all on Liam but few can shine that bright on stage. The songs are just a treasure. Oasis was not another band. They made more good stuff than neither Beatles or Stones even came near of. At worst they were delivering a title or 2 of epic proportions on each release. They were really damn good.
Why's Liam so pissed off here
because he spends most of his time on stage twiddling his thumbs (kidding) it's always been a power struggle between him and his brother. i think it was something to do with him looking to promote his "pretty green" clothing while on tour and noel told him where to go... but there's more to it than that (that's just one example without going on and on about it)
Is there a full video version of this please?????