The song is about a desperate cry, a last ditch attempt at reaching out to some form of human connection (from someone on the other side of the wall). The whole theme of The Wall is about excruciating loneliness, isolation and mental illness, which comes to a crescendo in "Hey You" "Comfortably Numb" and "One of my turns". Hey You is also about Waters' first divorce, at a personal level...
Even though the band was in such a tense state during the recording sessions of the wall they still managed to create one of the best selling albums of all time. I recommend listening to the whole record to fully understand the concept. The Wall is metaphorical, It refers to a barrier that you build around yourself during the course of your life and each brick in the wall represents a different event, thing or person.
The song is about a desperate cry, a last ditch attempt at reaching out to some form of human connection (from someone on the other side of the wall). The whole theme of The Wall is about excruciating loneliness, isolation and mental illness, which comes to a crescendo in "Hey You" "Comfortably Numb" and "One of my turns". Hey You is also about Waters' first divorce, at a personal level... M
This song really does underline how good a drummer Nick Mason is, perfect timing and sumptuous fills, so good, as good as Gilmour is as usual on this it is still Nick that steals the show for me
Whenever you are lonely and feeling old, just listen to Pink Floyd. They take you away on a journey with their masterpieces and you come back feeling complete again.
GREAT REACTION to one of the GREATEST songs ever (imho)!!! And NO PAUSES!!!!!! I thank you for allowing me to witness the growth of your musical awareness, and share in the musical story of my life. Welcome! Congratulations!!
I love this song and this album, and Pink Floyd were at their peak when Roger Waters was in the band, but don't discount all the great songs PF made after he left, such as: "On the Turning Away" "Keep Talking" "High Hopes" "Learning To Fly" and more. All great songs. That being said, please play more Yes! They have many awesome Progressive Rock songs.
Please don't underestimate what Roger did after leaving a band where no one, but him, proposed anything other than "solo albums" that "almost" everyone has forgotten. A review in one of the concerts with "more class" than "effects": m.th-cam.com/video/NDTWsuyDYRM/w-d-xo.html
Another incredible song by Pink Floyd - I haven't actually heard it before so I really want to hear it a few more times. Really like it though, it's got a power to it and an emotion also which such a lot of Pink Floyd songs have. They were amazing with their songwriting and performances, totally unique. One of my favourite tracks from The Wall is Run Like Hell - I have the live Pulse concert version downloaded and I love it. Really enjoyed your reactions as usual, guys, many thanks.
@@TheSmittenman You misunderstand, I haven't downloaded the full Pulse concert, I downloaded the song Run Like Hell from the concert. So, there are songs there from the concert I haven't heard before. Cheers.
You really should consider reacting to "The Wall" in a single video... The whole album is a masterpiece, probably the greatest album ever. It's 1h20 of pure joy and I am sure your followers would love. You could even do a live ;)
I agree and submit the same suggestion with: Dark Side of the Moon album. Start to finish- great and MEANT to be listened-to straight thru in one piece.(As all their works are). However, YES, you most certainly CAN listen to each individual “song” separately and still enjoy - that’s how most people have enjoyed Floyd on a large scale.
The wall my absolute favorite Floyd album in the 80s as a teen I would put headphones on and fall asleep to ( the Wall )there’s not one song I dislike on that Album ..Thanks guys for this great reaction to Hey You !
Your reviews are so detailed and analytical whilst at the same time highly entertaining, amusing and involving. Many folk are increasingly doing reaction videos but I genuinely rate your channel as my favourite. Keep up the great work 👍🏻 I've followed Pink Floyd for around fifty years now and, as a young student, had the great, good fortune to see and experience the 'Dark Side of the Moon' tour in Liverpool, UK. It was incredible and like all their work epitomizes how their unique sounds, instrumentation, production, imagination and presentation developed through all their experimentation, self- belief and albums (as you both noted). Thanks again guys.
Pink Floyd was formed in 1965... their (most likely) last album was "The Endless River" in 2014. PF had 15 studio albums... 3 live albums, 9 compilation albums not to mention multiple live dvds and solo albums performed by below members of the band. Syd Barrett (short-lived founder; guitar plus) the originator and quirky eccentric; inevitably the consequential muse. * January 6, 1946 (rip 2006) Roger Waters (bass) was the cultivator (seed sower), the lyrically conceptual prodigy, secondary vocal and co-maestro of songwriting * September 6, 1943 (age 78 years) David Gilmour (guitar) was the placidity, guitar virtuoso, the silky smooth voice and co-maestro; the equilibrium. * March 6, 1946 (age 75 years) Richard Wright (keyboards) was the essential underlying symmetry; musical nurturer. Occasional singer. * July 28, 1943 (rip 2008) Nick Mason (drums) was the heartbeat, structure and foundation; the sole member involved from the emergence of PF to the last recording. * January 27, 1944 (age 77 years) FYI: The following Pink Floyd albums are Concept Albums (all songs together tell a complete story)... Dark Side Of The Moon (1973), Wish You Were Here (1975), Animals (1977) and The Wall (1979); The Final Cut (1983) is a maybe, as it was the last album with Roger Waters being in the band. *search on Wiki the album title to get the story behind the concept.
The part about “The worms ate into his brain”. I interpret as the walls built up over time & became so high, the heart & soul of the person starts dying ( how else do worms eat ate into his brain”, death of some sort. It’s about being physically alive but dead inside. if you can’t reach anyone, have no one to help carry the weights of life, “the stone” becomes too heavy. So it’s sad & positive at the same time because their message is about hope. If you have that you can get through anything. The song lifts up, like uplifts you then. Remember listening to the whole album helps, as some of the lyrics are metaphorical, but the songs tie in together. The line, “ Don’t give in without a fight, and how David Gilmore emphasizes the word “Fight”. Like hey, no matter how high the wall gets built, break down that wall, don’t give up without a fight. Live life happy. This album got me through a difficult period of my life. It’s my “go to” album when I’m struggling”. But I love them anytime. I just listened to your reaction video of their song “Mother” first, hit the like button, went to your channel, started to play this video of “Hey You”, had to stop, hit the like button and subscribed right away. Absolutely loved it. I can’t wait to check out more of your videos!
This album is so incredible. A masterpiece from beginning to end. Many years ago when I first discovered this album and the film, I became incredibly obsessed with it. I would leave the house with it in my car and just drive for hours. Listening to it over and over again. I can’t even explain it. This album affected me to a point where it has stuck with me to this day as one of the most important albums ever made. I can’t even put into words what this album means to me. Great reaction to this masterpiece of a song guys. Amazing.
David Gilmour's wife took over as the main lyric writer for Pink Floyd soon after Roger Waters left in 1985. * lot's of great lyric writing after he left. \m/
Great reaction, as ever! The bass, in this song, is played by Gilmour! Please guys, react at an instrumental song... Try with MAROONED, masterpiece. Bye
Nice reaction. Bros please listen to the studio version of Space Truckin' by Deep Purple. Another popular one you'll really like. And it's got some screams in it. 😆 Thank you.
You are right guys, Pink Floyd is one of the best progressive bands ever, besides.....the early Genesis, area 1973-1976.....this is my number one - I strongly recommend to listen Trespass, Nursery Crime, Selling England by the Pound, Wind & Wuthering, The lamb lies down on Broadway, etc......this is high class ,,,,
Wore out two cassettes on the frozen Arctic Ocean and watched the Northern Lights come through the hole in the atmosphere at the north pole a few miles away, and shoot down the Rocky Mountains, while listening to Gilmore play this and Dark side of the moon. - un---?
I love that you talked about education. Knowing history is the best education. You are doomed to repeat mistakes made by others before you if they don't teach you the mistakes that they made. You are also doomed to make the same mistakes others made before you when you don't pay attention and listen to what they are trying to teach you. History is valuable and it needs to be protected and preserved for others to see in the future.
Since you’re into melodic progressive rock, I suggest listening to Genesis Carpet Crawlers if you haven’t already. Make sure it’s the 1974 version with Peter Gabriel in the lead. You will be confused by the lyrics in the beginning, but by the end, you will be so fully immersed in the song that it won’t really matter. Pink Floyd is my favorite band, but early Genesis is high on my list as well for their level of musicianship.
This is the quintessential Pink Floyd song.. you have both Gilmour and Waters vocals, fantastically powerful bass and drums, your typical spine tingling guitar solo.. and that eerie buzzing bee sound which no other band would have the creativity to pull off. Great stuff.
Guys , i love the Music of pink Floyd too, you dont like to check out Roy Buchanan 😉but you should check out his song , you’re not alone , and then remember it’s from 1978 , like ufo. Way ahead of it’s time , great reaction guys 👍have a Nice Day, Amazing guitar on this song like many other of his album👍come on guys , how Can it come you havent check out on Roy Buchanan 😊
I love Waters, of course, but definitely give the post-Waters albums a try. They are very beautiful. Also, I just bought tickets to Waters' "This is Not a Drill" concert. It might be his last (although that's been said before). I wouldn't miss it either way. Go see it if you can! His concerts are epic.
btw, there's sorta a PULSE version of this song also :) it wasn't recorded at PULSE itself (which is the 1994 concert at Earls court, London) but it was recorded at one of the other venues of the same Division Bell tour - th-cam.com/video/Bxpo2_BC_gg/w-d-xo.html The song itself does however feature on the PULSE album. The video above I believe was created using the song from the album and various different cameras from this live performance.
One of their best songs and sadly without Richard Wright as a member of the band. He got fired by Waters during the recording of this album, for having no inspiration because of going through a personal crisis and an ongoing battle for power within the band. And Waters wanted a full blown orchestra for this album.
I'm not sure where you got your info but according to the credits , Rick is playing the Fender Rhodes electric piano on this track ? Not trying to call you out just stating the facts ????
@@dyanyork5027 Richard Wright was a member of the band during the most of this album, Waters fired him during the final sessions of The Wall and hired as a session musician for the Is There Anybody Out There 1980-1981 Tour.
All the Pink Floyd's song are a masterpiece
Pink Floyd is a masterpiece
No lies detected.
TRUTH
Not all. C'mon.
True story that :)
This group always produces masterpieces. For me they are the world's best band ever.
One of the best solo in history, on par with the 2nd of comfortably numb.
To me it's the best solo ever... the emotion to note ratio is out of this world :/
The song is about a desperate cry, a last ditch attempt at reaching out to some form of human connection (from someone on the other side of the wall). The whole theme of The Wall is about excruciating loneliness, isolation and mental illness, which comes to a crescendo in "Hey You" "Comfortably Numb" and "One of my turns". Hey You is also about Waters' first divorce, at a personal level...
Even though the band was in such a tense state during the recording sessions of the wall they still managed to create one of the best selling albums of all time. I recommend listening to the whole record to fully understand the concept. The Wall is metaphorical, It refers to a barrier that you build around yourself during the course of your life and each brick in the wall represents a different event, thing or person.
The song is about a desperate cry, a last ditch attempt at reaching out to some form of human connection (from someone on the other side of the wall). The whole theme of The Wall is about excruciating loneliness, isolation and mental illness, which comes to a crescendo in "Hey You" "Comfortably Numb" and "One of my turns". Hey You is also about Waters' first divorce, at a personal level... M
Such a profound and ethereal tune. A masterpiece, indeed.
Together we stand , divided we fall .. a powerful line to end a song .. 😎👍✨
We fall , we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall we fall
These guy's understanding of the meanings and the music that Pink Floyd wrote are unparalleled!!!!
Utterly fucking brilliant BRO'S🔥👍👍
This whole album is a masterpiece.😀👍❤️✌️🌼
This song really does underline how good a drummer Nick Mason is, perfect timing and sumptuous fills, so good, as good as Gilmour is as usual on this it is still Nick that steals the show for me
The unsung hero of Pink Floyd
yeap. good note
Reacts to Pink Floyd - Marooned. This song is a masterpiece!!!
Pink floyd and The Beatles. Two of the greates bands ever
1. The Beatles
2. Pink Floyd
3. Led Zeppelin
4. Queen
@@martsforrell though I totally agree I would probably add some other bands as The doors and The kinks
Also Jimi Hendrix (both The Experience and Band Of Gypsys)
@@greghartshorne6621 yeah, they're great
My Favourite PF song ❤️❤️🎶
Whenever you are lonely and feeling old, just listen to Pink Floyd. They take you away on a journey with their masterpieces and you come back feeling complete again.
One of my favorite songs from Pink Floyd, great reactions guys!! George your on another level love how you feel the music 🎶🤘❤️✌️🎸
You know why I like you guys, and this amazing channel of yours? Because you know what you're talking about.
"Together we stand, divided we fall" Is so true that they split because of this, and i love this song, it's so good, my favorite of them! Amazing
You guys should really watch their Pulse concert it's nothing short of amazing. I saw them and hands down the best concert I've ever been to.
GREAT REACTION to one of the GREATEST songs ever (imho)!!! And NO PAUSES!!!!!! I thank you for allowing me to witness the growth of your musical awareness, and share in the musical story of my life. Welcome! Congratulations!!
Great Reaction !!! Marooned-Pink Floyd next :)
Yes amazing instrumental piece! I hope together the official video that is amazing
@@chicharitodelta7672 yeah...Marooned in official video it's top... amazing very deep and emotional
Love Marooned! There’s an hour long loop of it here on YT I listen to every night when I go to sleep.
I love this song and this album, and Pink Floyd were at their peak when Roger Waters was in the band, but don't discount all the great songs PF made after he left, such as: "On the Turning Away" "Keep Talking" "High Hopes" "Learning To Fly" and more. All great songs.
That being said, please play more Yes! They have many awesome Progressive Rock songs.
Please don't underestimate what Roger did after leaving a band where no one, but him, proposed anything other than "solo albums" that "almost" everyone has forgotten.
A review in one of the concerts with "more class" than "effects":
m.th-cam.com/video/NDTWsuyDYRM/w-d-xo.html
Another incredible song by Pink Floyd - I haven't actually heard it before so I really want to hear it a few more times. Really like it though, it's got a power to it and an emotion also which such a lot of Pink Floyd songs have. They were amazing with their songwriting and performances, totally unique. One of my favourite tracks from The Wall is Run Like Hell - I have the live Pulse concert version downloaded and I love it. Really enjoyed your reactions as usual, guys, many thanks.
You have really never heard this song before, but have downloaded the PULSE concert????
@@TheSmittenman You misunderstand, I haven't downloaded the full Pulse concert, I downloaded the song Run Like Hell from the concert. So, there are songs there from the concert I haven't heard before. Cheers.
You really should consider reacting to "The Wall" in a single video... The whole album is a masterpiece, probably the greatest album ever. It's 1h20 of pure joy and I am sure your followers would love. You could even do a live ;)
I agree and submit the same suggestion with: Dark Side of the Moon album. Start to finish- great and MEANT to be listened-to straight thru in one piece.(As all their works are). However, YES, you most certainly CAN listen to each individual “song” separately and still enjoy - that’s how most people have enjoyed Floyd on a large scale.
Never heard the wall bring joy , it's a pretty heavy album.
Thanks guys
all the album is perfect, the roger waters history
Now you are ready for " The Final Cut"
Pink Floyd is so great. Fantastic music and musicians
The wall my absolute favorite Floyd album in the 80s as a teen I would put headphones on and fall asleep to ( the Wall )there’s not one song I dislike on that Album ..Thanks guys for this great reaction to Hey You !
Pink Floyd's music 🎶 is timeless
So much sheer dispair in that solo. It's quite unbelievable
Your reviews are so detailed and analytical whilst at the same time highly entertaining, amusing and involving. Many folk are increasingly doing reaction videos but I genuinely rate your channel as my favourite. Keep up the great work 👍🏻
I've followed Pink Floyd for around fifty years now and, as a young student, had the great, good fortune to see and experience the 'Dark Side of the Moon' tour in Liverpool, UK. It was incredible and like all their work epitomizes how their unique sounds, instrumentation, production, imagination and presentation developed through all their experimentation, self- belief and albums (as you both noted). Thanks again guys.
Pink Floyd was formed in 1965... their (most likely) last album was "The Endless River" in 2014. PF had 15 studio albums... 3 live albums, 9 compilation albums not to mention multiple live dvds and solo albums performed by below members of the band.
Syd Barrett (short-lived founder; guitar plus) the originator and quirky eccentric; inevitably the consequential muse. * January 6, 1946 (rip 2006)
Roger Waters (bass) was the cultivator (seed sower), the lyrically conceptual prodigy, secondary vocal and co-maestro of songwriting * September 6, 1943 (age 78 years)
David Gilmour (guitar) was the placidity, guitar virtuoso, the silky smooth voice and co-maestro; the equilibrium. * March 6, 1946 (age 75 years)
Richard Wright (keyboards) was the essential underlying symmetry; musical nurturer. Occasional singer. * July 28, 1943 (rip 2008)
Nick Mason (drums) was the heartbeat, structure and foundation; the sole member involved from the emergence of PF to the last recording. * January 27, 1944 (age 77 years)
FYI: The following Pink Floyd albums are Concept Albums (all songs together tell a complete story)... Dark Side Of The Moon (1973), Wish You Were Here (1975), Animals (1977) and The Wall (1979); The Final Cut (1983) is a maybe, as it was the last album with Roger Waters being in the band. *search on Wiki the album title to get the story behind the concept.
The live version on Pulse is AMAZING!!!
Hey George n Patrick, it's an ocean with no shore line and never ending depth. Keep on exploring👍🏽👍🏽💐💐💖💖
Addiction, in part.
The part about “The worms ate into his brain”. I interpret as the walls built up over time & became so high, the heart & soul of the person starts dying ( how else do worms eat ate into his brain”, death of some sort. It’s about being physically alive but dead inside. if you can’t reach anyone, have no one to help carry the weights of life, “the stone” becomes too heavy. So it’s sad & positive at the same time because their message is about hope. If you have that you can get through anything. The song lifts up, like uplifts you then. Remember listening to the whole album helps, as some of the lyrics are metaphorical, but the songs tie in together. The line, “ Don’t give in without a fight, and how David Gilmore emphasizes the word “Fight”. Like hey, no matter how high the wall gets built, break down that wall, don’t give up without a fight. Live life happy. This album got me through a difficult period of my life. It’s my “go to” album when I’m struggling”. But I love them anytime.
I just listened to your reaction video of their song “Mother” first, hit the like button, went to your channel, started to play this video of “Hey You”, had to stop, hit the like button and subscribed right away. Absolutely loved it. I can’t wait to check out more of your videos!
The Guitar God 🎸
ahh those days, smokey dark room, black light, brews, i mean drinks 😂 and pink Floyd turned way up! miss those days ;)
The Wall is about a musician who is having a nervous breakdown from a divorce
This is my ALL TIME favorite band.....
You NEED TO WATCH the Movie Pink Floyd the WALL! The songs are GREAT by themselves but a MASTERPIECE altogether !
Together we stand, divided we fall...we fall. We fall
This album is so incredible. A masterpiece from beginning to end. Many years ago when I first discovered this album and the film, I became incredibly obsessed with it. I would leave the house with it in my car and just drive for hours. Listening to it over and over again. I can’t even explain it. This album affected me to a point where it has stuck with me to this day as one of the most important albums ever made. I can’t even put into words what this album means to me. Great reaction to this masterpiece of a song guys. Amazing.
David Gilmour's wife took over as the main lyric writer for Pink Floyd soon after Roger Waters left in 1985. * lot's of great lyric writing after he left. \m/
They are pure genius, that’s it ❤🙏
Masterpiece 🥺 best song by PF in my opinion
That my friends is an eargasm
Run Like Hell Live - Pulse. Amazing guitar and lights.
Comfortably numb live in pompeii 2016. Best live version ever. Also one of the greatest guitar improvisations ever in my opinion
Pink Floyd are DEEP
Alter bridge - Blackbird. Amazing song one of the greatest!!!!
This is the concept album the Wall you dudes need to listen to the beginning of the album to understand it
Thanks for the reaction , well done guys
Your reactions are so real, i love it 💓
Awesome reaction! Brain Damage/Eclipse next👍🏻
And 'Any Colour You Like' first!
After this one! Coming back to life! Please!!
Great reaction, as ever! The bass, in this song, is played by Gilmour!
Please guys, react at an instrumental song... Try with MAROONED, masterpiece.
Bye
Più bella
run like hell
Temazo de Pink Floyd, con un solo espectacular de Dave, quien tambien toca el bajo fretless al inicio de la canción. Gracias por reaccionar!!
Love any Pink Floyd! 👍🏼🔥👊🏼
Nice reaction. Bros please listen to the studio version of Space Truckin' by Deep Purple. Another popular one you'll really like. And it's got some screams in it. 😆 Thank you.
You are right guys, Pink Floyd is one of the best progressive bands ever, besides.....the early Genesis, area 1973-1976.....this is my number one - I strongly recommend to listen Trespass, Nursery Crime, Selling England by the Pound, Wind & Wuthering, The lamb lies down on Broadway, etc......this is high class ,,,,
You guys really need to react to Pink Floyd at live 8 their very final performance as a group and their reunion after Gilmour and Waters fallout!
Must listen and see Run Like Hell from this album..! 1994 live Edition is Amazing. 😀❤️🎸
Uno de los mejores temas del disco, genial!!!
Notice the "pings" from Echoes at the bridge...the next song on the album "Is There Anybody Out There?" the "whales" form Echoes are heard....
I'm always glad to hear the best music with no video or lyrics videos. Good choice!
Probably my fave from them
These 2 😂❤ reacting Pf offers psychological education
I think it’s time for The gunner’s Dream.
The final cut is another masterpiece. Come on guys!
Wore out two cassettes on the frozen Arctic Ocean and watched the Northern Lights come through the hole in the atmosphere at the north pole a few miles away, and shoot down the Rocky Mountains, while listening to Gilmore play this and Dark side of the moon. - un---?
I love that you talked about education.
Knowing history is the best education.
You are doomed to repeat mistakes made by others before you if they don't teach you the mistakes that they made.
You are also doomed to make the same mistakes others made before you when you don't pay attention and listen to what they are trying to teach you.
History is valuable and it needs to be protected and preserved for others to see in the future.
bro-heims! you are legend. Legend! 😎👍💥💯
my favorite song
Pink Floyd Songs are a Work of Art. They Have So Many Masterpieces.
Since you’re into melodic progressive rock, I suggest listening to Genesis Carpet Crawlers if you haven’t already. Make sure it’s the 1974 version with Peter Gabriel in the lead. You will be confused by the lyrics in the beginning, but by the end, you will be so fully immersed in the song that it won’t really matter. Pink Floyd is my favorite band, but early Genesis is high on my list as well for their level of musicianship.
This is the quintessential Pink Floyd song.. you have both Gilmour and Waters vocals, fantastically powerful bass and drums, your typical spine tingling guitar solo.. and that eerie buzzing bee sound which no other band would have the creativity to pull off. Great stuff.
Coming back to life. Pulse.....
You must play in order from where Syd Barrett began and full album at that welcome to Pink Floyd
Hey You!🥰
David Gilmore is indeed a God. It has been said that he doesn’t plug into an amp, he plugs his guitar into his soul.
Perfection!!
Guys , i love the Music of pink Floyd too, you dont like to check out Roy Buchanan 😉but you should check out his song , you’re not alone , and then remember it’s from 1978 , like ufo. Way ahead of it’s time , great reaction guys 👍have a Nice Day, Amazing guitar on this song like many other of his album👍come on guys , how Can it come you havent check out on Roy Buchanan 😊
I love Waters, of course, but definitely give the post-Waters albums a try. They are very beautiful. Also, I just bought tickets to Waters' "This is Not a Drill" concert. It might be his last (although that's been said before). I wouldn't miss it either way. Go see it if you can! His concerts are epic.
Love your reviews of these ‘old’ tracks. There’s nothing better than discovering an awesome band from the past, you guys are doing this.
HEY YOUUUUU, WHAT'S GOIN ON BRO'S!!! :)
Song writing is the rarest talent and the most important part of any music
Uriah Heep - Lady In Black 1971
My son loved this song as a chilf...but always said it was scary to him. Lol. He was right.
There’s this live version from pulse, but it’s not on Dvd, just on cd, that’s a very good one too.
Greetings.
Watching the film The Wall will really blow your motherboard
Geniuses for sure. Great reaction, rock on ! 🤘😎❤️🎼
Time Live Pulse - Great drums and guitar solo!
America is built on that idea
btw, there's sorta a PULSE version of this song also :) it wasn't recorded at PULSE itself (which is the 1994 concert at Earls court, London) but it was recorded at one of the other venues of the same Division Bell tour - th-cam.com/video/Bxpo2_BC_gg/w-d-xo.html
The song itself does however feature on the PULSE album. The video above I believe was created using the song from the album and various different cameras from this live performance.
Watching you guys is like listening to someone in stereo. What a trip!
Some of us have never given up.
One of their best songs and sadly without Richard Wright as a member of the band. He got fired by Waters during the recording of this album, for having no inspiration because of going through a personal crisis and an ongoing battle for power within the band. And Waters wanted a full blown orchestra for this album.
I'm not sure where you got your info but according to the credits , Rick is playing the Fender Rhodes electric piano on this track ? Not trying to call you out just stating the facts ????
@@Newfie-zc7ug Richard was just a paid musician and no longer a member of the band during this album. You are right, he was in the album and tour ~
@@Newfie-zc7ug you are correct about Rick contributing to the album, but at that time as a hired sessionmusician, not as a member of the band
@@dyanyork5027 Richard Wright was a member of the band during the most of this album, Waters fired him during the final sessions of The Wall and hired as a session musician for the Is There Anybody Out There 1980-1981 Tour.
@The Coca-Cola Company
This is 100% correct on the timeline. It's been documented multiple times
I like the comments ! Nice point of view
Love this song its my favourite Pink Floyd song