I Edited a Photo in Every Program.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 พ.ค. 2024
- I edited a photo in every single program. I discuss which ones are good, there shortfalls, quirks and benefits. Using this guide you can discover if you really need to be using the Adobe creative cloud suite.
Inspiration:
Elliot's Video - • i made the same design...
Emeral's Video - • I Made the Same Game i...
Lightroom & Photoshop - www.adobe.com/au/creativeclou...
Capture 1 - www.captureone.com/en
Luminar Neo - skylum.com/luminar
Sony Imagining Edge - imagingedge.sony.net/en-us/ie...
Darktable - www.darktable.org/
Photopea - www.photopea.com/
RawTherapee - www.rawtherapee.com/
Photomator - www.pixelmator.com/photomator/
AffinityPhoto - affinity.serif.com/en-gb/photo/
DXOPhotoLab - www.dxo.com/dxo-photolab/down...
ON1 - www.on1.com/
---
Socials:
Instagram: @harrisontong
Twitter: @ItsHarrisonTong
--------------------
Business inquires: [harrison@harrisontong.com](mailto:harrison@harrisontong.com)
Chapters
0:00 - Intro
1:03 - Lightroom&Photoshop
3:04 - Capture1
5:32 - LuminarNeo
8:09 - Sony Imaging Edge
10:46 - Darktable
13:08 - Apple Photos
14:41 - AffinityPhoto
16:56 - Photomator
18:57 - Rawtherapee
19:38 - Photopea
21:40 - DXOLabs
22:53 - ON1
24:01 - Outro - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![Mirrr x BUS5 - กี่เหตุผล (1000REASONS) [Live Session]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6Ta00hFr2qU/mqdefault.jpg)
Affinity photo has content aware fill right? I am confused :D I use it all the time.
Certainly does!
thank you very much ! looking forward to software, so helpful .
Thank you, very helpful video!!
A helpful overview, although I'm familiar enough with several of the editors you describe here to know that some of your critiques are incorrect. Taking Affinity Photo as an example, at 15:01 you say that Affinity Photo doesn't have HSL adjustments when it does (when you open Adjustment Controls at 15:29, HSL adjustments are third from the top). Did you just miss those adjustments in your quick review (or were you looking for something more? Similarly Affinity's Inpainting Brush Tool is pretty good at making things disappear even in area with complex patterns (like water or grass). Your critiques of Photomator and DXO PhotoLab left me with the same impression
Affinity does not give you control over the colors in the raw file only once it’s in the editor which can often not be pushed as far due to bit depth.
I found affinity’s brush to not work as good (compared to photoshop) on the handful of images I tried
I agree with your assessment!!!
Thanks for the video !
Very good comparison! Thank you!
Really great video, thank you.
Have you ever tried Pixelmator Pro?
Exactly, why only trial Photomator?
Apple Photos does support spot healing brush, also can import without uploading to iClouds, though the app is buggy and normally crash, and laggy UI when editing many big raw files
Agreed plus I use external ssd for library and it never crashes for me
Oh and it’s xtrans raw conversion is so much better on green foliage where LR is absolutely shite
Dark table UI is bad but can't look past that price
Pixelmator Pro?
Amazing! Thank you so much for this no-nonsense review and comparison. Surprised you didn’t include Darkroom in it (pretty good but new features were delayed last hear, hopefully they’ll catch up this year)
You've must have missed the latest Capture One. It has AI masking and is very snappy. Btw, I too play around with multiple editing tools. But do 80% in C1. Use NIK collection, ON1 plugins, Affinity photo, have the LR/PS for my astro panel
Their AI masking works great. If capture one gets the an AI denoise to be as good as adobe, that would be amazing.
Obviously you are so simplistic that you can only edit by sliding sliders. Learn before you criticize Darktable
As usual I was too quick an too short. My point was that to give Darktable a fair evaluation, you need to learn how to use it. I agree that is programmer based but that fits my mentality. Once you spend the time (several hours/days) learning Darktable you learn that it is powerful and can do almost everything that Lightroom can do but without the $240 per year ongoing cost. If your mentality is programmer and you are willing to learn Darktable is good.
Darktable is so freaking powerful, it amazes me sometimes.
This is a great video, can you please make updates on the photomator and maybe review pixelmator as an alternative for the photoshop
Thank you!
Still miss aperture, that was the best app
Finally my favorite TH-camr posted
Paint 3D users 🗿
where's pixelmator pro?
I use DXO photolab, or on1 photoraw (lightroom equivelant), instead of lightroom, and Affinity photo2 instead of Photoshop. Also use Neo, to do things like skin retouch...
Whatever gets the job done 🙂
You missed Radiant Photo and Boris Optics.
I got a shout out at 5:34 thanks bro... was a fun video in all seriousness
Take a look of camerabag pro and acdsee , also i loved photomator
What i love of photomator is the crop way
Good video man. Take care of the audio level throughout your videos.
Please include Pixelmator Pro in upcoming videos. Thanks.
RAW PHOTO PROCESSOR (RPP) = The best, highest fidelity, most film like result I've yet to encounter. And it's FREE.
The closest in color fidelity is the Exposure X7 Kodachrome 25 filter. But it's a distant second.
Haven’t needed adobe since Affinity came out ❤ Yes it does have content aware as the other company calls it
First up, great job covering these programs, In essence you have done exactly what I have done and tried all of theses apps to find the ones that suit your use and I feel you have covered them well as a user. I personally have settled on Capture One for most of my Raw processing, I find this app gives me the best overall ability to process large quantities of images with quality outcomes. I also am very impressed with Photomator and will be like you keeping an eye on its development. And lastly I have to react to the the person who was very upset about your comments about Dark Table, I like you found the app to be very difficult to use in any productive way with large quantities of images, it may well be the Bees Knees of professional programmers/photographers who get deep into the technology but for users who want quick accurate control and productivity it is not for us.
Cheers mate, yeah capture one seems solid all around. Thanks for watching :)
Darktable sliders lag on PC too. Typically if it's free, there's a reason.
Aftershot is cool, photomator too, luminar, camerabag pro, acdsee
what are your qualifications to make these comments/
I am sorry, but your comments on DXO and ON1 simply disqualify yourself.
HAHAHAHA #HARRYRAGES GOLD!!!!!!
Haha had to come out 🤣
What up with a big black mic being waved around in front your face...?
Sounds good :)
I agree, Darktable is THE worst program I have seen in 30 years of using graphics programs on any platform. Made as a torture device for people that won't fork out money for any of the really great pro level software like CaptureOne, LR or something similar. I would rather process still images in Nuke than Darktable.
Haha definitely, I’m sure it’s got some specific use case that it’s amazing for but definitely not the best way to work with images
Although I agree with you on Darktable, there are people out there 'claiming' Darktable is the Roles Royce, while everything else is a Chevy.
Darktable forces you to know what you re doing. In 6 month I went up the learning curve about the theory behind editing like not in 5 years CaptureOne and Lightroom before.
It's different, but can do some remarkable things. No, you are not likely to install it and immediately accomplish everything you want. Watch some videos of people who know what they're doing with it.
As I stopped using Adobe LR when subscription came in, I haven’t really found a good substitute but then again I didn’t try many alternatives. From my research Adobe whilst not the best at everything does a very good job all round which is hard to beat. The biggest issue is the lack of tutorials and help forums for other software, also bug fixes take time and sometimes you have to upgrade to get the bug fix. As you mentioned the heal/repair tool in most software is pretty rubbish. I noticed Topaz has this feature in Photo AI which is supposedly very good, perhaps you could do a video on that compared to photoshop. Thanks