I think you made a mistake in your thumbnail....He is not the Penchen Lama.. You got the wrong Person, The real PENCHEN LAMA IS STILL MISSING....WHOLE THE WORLD KNOW THIS😢
The reason the Chinese rejected the Dalai Lama's choice is because the Panchen Lama chooses the next Dalai Lama, and the Chinese want control over this. They took the young boy away from Tibet and some say he is drugged and brainwashed. I know many lamas and monks who escaped the Chinese over the Himalayas while being strafed by war planes.
I am reading your comments with Sus: Seems to me you said the Panchen Lama featured in the video is the same one that China took away, drugged, brainwashed, and returned to Tibet as the current Panchen Lama. Did I read your comment correctly? PLA had some Russian war planes in Tibet at the time of exile. Those war planes would have had a tough time flying even the lower part of the Himalayas. Did those Lamas and monks tell you that they were strafed by war planes while they were crossing the Himalayas? The wartime exile took place in 1959. This is now 2024. It was 65 years ago. The minimum age for novice monks was 7 or 8 years old. So, the youngest monks you know are at least 72 years old. Correct? As for Lamas, meaning spiritual teacher or guru, they need to have decades of Buddhism training. By now, they must be at least in their 90's. And, you know many of these Lamas and monks who were strafed by war planes when they walked over the Himalayas? Did they say where they were going? Are they still alive?
@@hyung6999 My lama died a few years ago. His wife and children who escaped with him are still alive. His wife's biography details it; perhaps you should read it. Oh wait: you live in a country that won't allow it! I know many younger lamas who escaped in recent years. I'm sorry you've been brainwashed. I'm also really sorry China turned the holy city of Lhasa into a porn Disneyland for its soldiers, and that the Tibetan people are treated so badly that young people there have a high suicide rate.
@@hyung6999he is not panchen lama,the young panchen lama name is gendun chokey Nyima,Chinese imprison the real panchen lama and introduce Chinese version of oanchen lama.. May My real guru panchen rinpochen get freedom soon
@thinleyGyaltso-i1u What you said is the way I understand the situation. I asked OP to clarify because I couldn't understand what was written clearly. I don't take a position on the Free Tibet/Part of China argument. I can understand taking sides though, but I wish they would see a fuller picture before deciding which side to take, instead of blindly chanting the slogans. I have studied Tibetan and Chinese history a bit. My interest is not politics, but the well being of the People, and their Arts and Culture. For Tibetans, I especially like Gorshey and the neo Chupa fashion. I wish the Tibetan people all the happiness in the world!
That's right Chinese were just going along with you, who believe in reincarnation, the previous ones have forsaken you and escaped to a good life travelling around the world and getting pop star reception.
I spent a month in Tibet traveling from Lhasa to Mt Kailash and walked the 3-day pilgrimage during Saga Dawa. The Tibetans are a gentle people from a time past. Unfortunately even in the farthest reaches of the territory, the Chinese have set up businesses and slowly but surely turning it into a merchant economy. The Chinese are hyper competitive as individuals and as a society whereas Tibetans are generally more religious, family-oriented and do not see making money as a top priority. There are thriving Tibetan societies in Ladakh, Bhutan and other countries but in China, minorities that do not worship money are destined for servitude.
I try to see the world from different perspectives then come to a pragmatic view. Also, I am more interested in people than politics. So, please don't go totally one sided political on me. I agree with your comments in general, but I have one question and one request: 1) Are Tibetans not thriving in TAR and China nowadays? 2) Can you explain your last sentence: "...in China, minorities that do not worship money are destined for servitude."
Unable to resist the power of money, haha. Everyone in the world wants to immigrate to developed countries, so why haven't I heard of immigrating to so-called democratic countries, India, the Philippines, etc.? It seems that people all over the world cannot resist the temptation of money.
Sounds like you want them to be primitive and backward. Of course there are Ministry of cultural relics and Culture in Tibet that safeguards their culture there and many Tibetans have taken businesses seriously.
@@temjenimchen7925 Yeah, I note that the common perception of Tibet and Tibetans is that of monks blowing Dungchens, commoners Prostrating to Mt Kailash, and Nomads herding Yaks. Modernity shouldn't exist. Cell phones and universities?! No way! The common belief is that Tibet and Tibetans ought to be preserved as a pet culture, keeping them as a living past to be experienced by outsiders to satisfy their adventurous urge when they can afford to trek there. Tibetans' desire for better health care and therefore longer life span, knowledge, and upward mobility be damned!
In the end of this video 50:52 the monk did not even mention people's republic of china he mentioned that he wished Tibet will become more prosperous in Tibetan language
It is entirely rubbish to say things have changed a lot implying because of the kindness of the Chinese government. If that's the case many parts of the should be absolutely grateful to the western colonization.
INTERESTING but this is an old film. The Chinese choice of Panchen Lama was born in 1990 so he would be 34 - in the film he is 17. Where is Gendun Choekyi Nyima Panchen Rinpoche chosen by HH the Dalai Lam?
Tashi dalek this tibetan story 100 percent right please I tell you first not believe China thinking very danger this time tibetan not freedom please support tibetan I love support tibetan ❤❤❤thank 🙏💟😭
@@kungadhundup5002 who said they want democracy or freedom of speech? And since when have Tibetans ever had freedom of speech? Their dalai lama was judge, jury and executioner so when have they ever had the right to speak? NEVER
In the end, good heart and wisdom is eventual and hope it prevails to throw light on him and see the truth... After all we are all human with potential of Buddha hood.
There can be controversy if any incarnation is recognised by two different high Lama. Here one Penchen Lama is recognised by the Dalai Lama and another by the non believer Communist Dictator. There is no question of controversial. Fake is fake. Tibetan has named him 'the fake one'
those Tibetan overseas ? they are different people from the original Tibetan on Tibet plateau ,too much oxygen had Changed them forever .I don't say it's not good ,only want to say they are different now .hope they have good lives in everywhere outside Tibet ,visit fake Tibetan temple or believe in a fake lama or something else ....
གངས་རི་ར་བས་བསྐོར་བའི་ཞིང་ཁམས་སུ།། ཕན་དང་བདེ་བ་མ་ལུས་འབྱུང་བའི་གནས།། སྤྱན་རས་གཟིགས་དབང་བསྟན་འཛིན་རྒྱ་མཚོ་ཡི།། ཞབས་པད་སྲིད་མཐའི་བར་དུ་བརྟན་གྱུར་ཅིག། In the land encircled by a ring of snow mountains Is the source of all happiness and benefit, All-knowing Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso. May you stand firm until samsara ends.
since he betrayed China he is done in China .no people in China will forgive him .hope he can live longer as he wishes ,but he still can't live longer than the smallest mountain in Tibet can last .
i worked at a truffle farm, and one of the most frequent issues was with Chinese tourists flushing things down the toilet. Here, we are not connected to the main sewer, so it caused big issues. I think this happened maybe 10 times in a year, and only happened when we had chinese tourists. the groups were small, 5- 10 people. It made me quite embarrassed as a 1/2 cantonese Chinese person
He is not the original Panchen Lama picture . which you upload on Thump nail. Please do good research first before you spread the wrong information though I subscribed your channel.
People in Tibet have to treat Panchen Lama recognised by the Chinese government. Or else they will be tortured by them. These people might be unaware of real Panchen Lama’s whereabout.
This is duplicate penchen lama. Where is real one is abducted since age of six . Nobody is giving respect only few who paid by Chinese to Tibetan people .
That is Chinese Panchen Lama the appropriated version of the original Tibetan Panchen Lama who’s where about is classified and possibly deceased due to communist chinas government whom captured the original Panchen Lama.
He is a victim of geopolitic and many Tibetans do not respect him because he was chosen byCCP,who do not believe in religion! real or not,I hopehe will become a good spiritual leader,who will help the spiritually orphaned citizens of China, especially the empty souls of the CCP-leaders…because leaders who have empathy are less dangerous….
You must research before explaining about tibetist. Born, Sammy and Buddhist this three are different religions. They have deferent ways but Buddhist is dominated. Please research. Thanks
Thumbnail and most of u learn or said about Tibet country all mistake also misunderstood. U don't knw nothing abt history of Tibet country. Tibet never ever part of ccp China virus read learn more abt reality of ancient Tibet historical than Go on.... Ok.
ཏཱ་ལའི་བླ་མ་ཕྱོགས་མ་རེད། the current Dalailama himself had admitted this Panchen lama officially. I am shocked that ཏཱ་ལའི་བླ་མ is still alive ,let alone the HH live longer or not .
after had seen so many "fake panchen" comments that I think I have to tell you all ,he is very popular in Tibet now .in Tibet wherever he goes the whole town will be empty ,because all people in the town are lining up on the streets to wait for his coming .people love him .he is handsome ,wisdom ,young ,a huge star ,a real hero of Tibetan Chinese .this is the real situation in Tibet .it's the Tibetan people chose him ,not other reasons .
I think you made a mistake in your thumbnail....He is not the Penchen Lama.. You got the wrong Person, The real PENCHEN LAMA IS STILL MISSING....WHOLE THE WORLD KNOW THIS😢
Why not is he Penchen Lama? That boy is also from Tibet, is Tibetan ethnicity, studied Tibetan Buddhism. I guess his name is also Gyaltsen Norbu.
@@SKB394 oh!😟 fake pachan lama
i heard from the somewhere that the panchen lama is kept secret from the external chinese commumity.
He is chines 🐕
@@SKB394 because he is not and can never be
This is not Panchen Lama....he is Banquin iLama. Temu version of the real thing
Hope the followers of Tibetan Bhudhism across the globe raise the question of where is 11th Gendun Choekyi nyima Penchen Rinpoche 🙏
Indirect speech
...it states the same thing as you have stated and I also totally agree with you....lots of love from Kurseong, Darjeeling
He is not panchen lama bro
🤮🤮🤮🤮🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳👎👎👎🤛🏻🤛🏻🤛🏻🤛🏻That was not panchan lama Chinese puppy
He is not real panchan lama
The reason the Chinese rejected the Dalai Lama's choice is because the Panchen Lama chooses the next Dalai Lama, and the Chinese want control over this. They took the young boy away from Tibet and some say he is drugged and brainwashed. I know many lamas and monks who escaped the Chinese over the Himalayas while being strafed by war planes.
I am reading your comments with Sus:
Seems to me you said the Panchen Lama featured in the video is the same one that China took away, drugged, brainwashed, and returned to Tibet as the current Panchen Lama. Did I read your comment correctly?
PLA had some Russian war planes in Tibet at the time of exile. Those war planes would have had a tough time flying even the lower part of the Himalayas. Did those Lamas and monks tell you that they were strafed by war planes while they were crossing the Himalayas?
The wartime exile took place in 1959. This is now 2024. It was 65 years ago. The minimum age for novice monks was 7 or 8 years old. So, the youngest monks you know are at least 72 years old. Correct?
As for Lamas, meaning spiritual teacher or guru, they need to have decades of Buddhism training. By now, they must be at least in their 90's. And, you know many of these Lamas and monks who were strafed by war planes when they walked over the Himalayas? Did they say where they were going? Are they still alive?
@@hyung6999 My lama died a few years ago. His wife and children who escaped with him are still alive. His wife's biography details it; perhaps you should read it. Oh wait: you live in a country that won't allow it! I know many younger lamas who escaped in recent years. I'm sorry you've been brainwashed. I'm also really sorry China turned the holy city of Lhasa into a porn Disneyland for its soldiers, and that the Tibetan people are treated so badly that young people there have a high suicide rate.
@@hyung6999he is not panchen lama,the young panchen lama name is gendun chokey Nyima,Chinese imprison the real panchen lama and introduce Chinese version of oanchen lama.. May My real guru panchen rinpochen get freedom soon
@thinleyGyaltso-i1u What you said is the way I understand the situation. I asked OP to clarify because I couldn't understand what was written clearly.
I don't take a position on the Free Tibet/Part of China argument. I can understand taking sides though, but I wish they would see a fuller picture before deciding which side to take, instead of blindly chanting the slogans.
I have studied Tibetan and Chinese history a bit. My interest is not politics, but the well being of the People, and their Arts and Culture. For Tibetans, I especially like Gorshey and the neo Chupa fashion. I wish the Tibetan people all the happiness in the world!
Chinese put him , fake panchen
That's right Chinese were just going along with you, who believe in reincarnation, the previous ones have forsaken you and escaped to a good life travelling around the world and getting pop star reception.
I spent a month in Tibet traveling from Lhasa to Mt Kailash and walked the 3-day pilgrimage during Saga Dawa. The Tibetans are a gentle people from a time past. Unfortunately even in the farthest reaches of the territory, the Chinese have set up businesses and slowly but surely turning it into a merchant economy.
The Chinese are hyper competitive as individuals and as a society whereas Tibetans are generally more religious, family-oriented and do not see making money as a top priority.
There are thriving Tibetan societies in Ladakh, Bhutan and other countries but in China, minorities that do not worship money are destined for servitude.
FREE TIBET ✊🏾 🐉 ✊🏾 TIBET BELONGS TO TIBETANS NOT CCP CHINESE!!! CCP CHINA THE DEVIL OF ASIA !!!!
I try to see the world from different perspectives then come to a pragmatic view. Also, I am more interested in people than politics. So, please don't go totally one sided political on me. I agree with your comments in general, but I have one question and one request: 1) Are Tibetans not thriving in TAR and China nowadays? 2) Can you explain your last sentence: "...in China, minorities that do not worship money are destined for servitude."
Unable to resist the power of money, haha. Everyone in the world wants to immigrate to developed countries, so why haven't I heard of immigrating to so-called democratic countries, India, the Philippines, etc.? It seems that people all over the world cannot resist the temptation of money.
Sounds like you want them to be primitive and backward. Of course there are Ministry of cultural relics and Culture in Tibet that safeguards their culture there and many Tibetans have taken businesses seriously.
@@temjenimchen7925 Yeah, I note that the common perception of Tibet and Tibetans is that of monks blowing Dungchens, commoners Prostrating to Mt Kailash, and Nomads herding Yaks. Modernity shouldn't exist. Cell phones and universities?! No way!
The common belief is that Tibet and Tibetans ought to be preserved as a pet culture, keeping them as a living past to be experienced by outsiders to satisfy their adventurous urge when they can afford to trek there. Tibetans' desire for better health care and therefore longer life span, knowledge, and upward mobility be damned!
The fake Panchen Lama
Free tibet
Chinese spy lama
This one is Fake Penchen. Real Panchen Lama is missing 😢
In the end of this video 50:52 the monk did not even mention people's republic of china he mentioned that he wished Tibet will become more prosperous in Tibetan language
no ,I understand Tibetan ,I have listened to that part several times ,he did say the same meaning with English subtitles .
@@malorybertie8046 you are right, he clearly said that in Tibetan
Fake flowers for fake Panchen Lama😂😂😂😂😂
It is entirely rubbish to say things have changed a lot implying because of the kindness of the Chinese government. If that's the case many parts of the should be absolutely grateful to the western colonization.
Fake panchen lama,
No fake it's real
@@DakpaDawoesadly, how unknown you are!
@@tenzinwangmo5149 any reason do you have ? About its
He is not Panchen Lama.
Ccp papet Tibetan Buddhism is not a joke give respect got respect
INTERESTING but this is an old film. The Chinese choice of Panchen Lama was born in 1990 so he would be 34 - in the film he is 17. Where is Gendun Choekyi Nyima Panchen Rinpoche chosen by HH the Dalai Lam?
Tashi dalek this tibetan story 100 percent right please I tell you first not believe China thinking very danger this time tibetan not freedom please support tibetan I love support tibetan ❤❤❤thank 🙏💟😭
Long live free Tibet🌈
He is not penchan lama ..our real penchan lama is still missing and the whole world knows
Free Tibet ♥️
They are free in Tibet, People's Republic of China.
@@tuputapu877CCP puppet .. using VPN to jump CCP Firewall to spread false info 😂😂😂 I pity u .. CCP don’t give u & ur family basic human rights
@@tuputapu877freedom of tibet. Democracy.. Independent. Freedom of speech
@@kungadhundup5002 who said they want democracy or freedom of speech? And since when have Tibetans ever had freedom of speech? Their dalai lama was judge, jury and executioner so when have they ever had the right to speak? NEVER
@@tuputapu877Chinese are not free in China.You think Tibetans will be free.😂
He is not panchen lama😢😢😢
他不是你是？人家藏民都信，你算什么东西。
In the end, good heart and wisdom is eventual and hope it prevails to throw light on him and see the truth... After all we are all human with potential of Buddha hood.
There can be controversy if any incarnation is recognised by two different high Lama.
Here one Penchen Lama is recognised by the Dalai Lama and another by the non believer Communist Dictator.
There is no question of controversial.
Fake is fake. Tibetan has named him 'the fake one'
those Tibetan overseas ? they are different people from the original Tibetan on Tibet plateau ,too much oxygen had Changed them forever .I don't say it's not good ,only want to say they are different now .hope they have good lives in everywhere outside Tibet ,visit fake Tibetan temple or believe in a fake lama or something else ....
You got wrong one.
Thank you ❤
He is not penchen lama. He is money lama
གངས་རི་ར་བས་བསྐོར་བའི་ཞིང་ཁམས་སུ།།
ཕན་དང་བདེ་བ་མ་ལུས་འབྱུང་བའི་གནས།།
སྤྱན་རས་གཟིགས་དབང་བསྟན་འཛིན་རྒྱ་མཚོ་ཡི།།
ཞབས་པད་སྲིད་མཐའི་བར་དུ་བརྟན་གྱུར་ཅིག།
In the land encircled by a ring of snow mountains
Is the source of all happiness and benefit,
All-knowing Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso.
May you stand firm until samsara ends.
since he betrayed China he is done in China .no people in China will forgive him .hope he can live longer as he wishes ,but he still can't live longer than the smallest mountain in Tibet can last .
@@malorybertie8046And who are you to decide, Big mountain
@@pemanordenbhutia6506 didn't get what were you trying to say .....
Real Penchen lama is with Chinese hand from the age of 5......
i worked at a truffle farm, and one of the most frequent issues was with Chinese tourists flushing things down the toilet. Here, we are not connected to the main sewer, so it caused big issues. I think this happened maybe 10 times in a year, and only happened when we had chinese tourists. the groups were small, 5- 10 people.
It made me quite embarrassed as a 1/2 cantonese Chinese person
He is not the original Panchen Lama picture . which you upload on Thump nail. Please do good research first before you spread the wrong information though I subscribed your channel.
False information.... Please research well before publish.. he is not a real penchen lama
OM MANI PADME HUM
Please sir stop lier. News i am report you police 🚨🚨🚨
People in Tibet have to treat Panchen Lama recognised by the Chinese government. Or else they will be tortured by them. These people might be unaware of real Panchen Lama’s whereabout.
This is duplicate penchen lama. Where is real one is abducted since age of six . Nobody is giving respect only few who paid by Chinese to Tibetan people .
That is Chinese Panchen Lama the appropriated version of the original Tibetan Panchen Lama who’s where about is classified and possibly deceased due to communist chinas government whom captured the original Panchen Lama.
Fake Panchen Lama
Yes fake panchen lama😂😂😂
This channel gives us wrong information about Pachen Lama . Real pachen lama is still in Chinese prison
This fake Penchen lama will kick from his seat once real Penchen lama will found.
He is a victim of geopolitic and many Tibetans do not respect him because he was chosen byCCP,who do not believe in religion! real or not,I hopehe will become a good spiritual leader,who will help the spiritually orphaned citizens of China, especially the empty souls of the CCP-leaders…because leaders who have empathy are less dangerous….
CCPs fake penchchen lama😂😂 ! Even if western countries nothing knows, under cover of CCP😂😂😂😂
You must research before explaining about tibetist. Born, Sammy and Buddhist this three are different religions. They have deferent ways but Buddhist is dominated. Please research. Thanks
Hope real Panchen Lama be in good health condition.
Fake 😡 panchen lama
I am positive..this fake panchcen lama....but he is a real tibetan...he will do good for tibetan...❤❤
We know our tibetan pachen lama....he is not the real one....fake
This is Chinese fake panchin lama.....👎👎👎
Fake product
the dude spit on the ladys face. wow.
Chinese fake panchen lama
These Tibetan,s are no problem at money.... under Chinese
Brilliant documentary! Love this narrator!! Thank you ❤❤ p.s. have had to come back to add, that this has been the best doc I’ve seen in a long time!
This is fake Panchen Lama the real one which is recognised by Dalai Lama is missing or lost from Tibet
We are not accepting fake panchan lama,
ང་བོད་པ་ནམ་ཡང་མི་ནུབ་ཤོག་
Thumbnail and most of u learn or said about Tibet country all mistake also misunderstood. U don't knw nothing abt history of Tibet country. Tibet never ever part of ccp China virus read learn more abt reality of ancient Tibet historical than Go on.... Ok.
🌹🌹🌹
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
This video helps in propagating CCP's devious trick to earn respect for the fake Panchen Lama from the ordinary ignorant Tibetans.
❤
This is the fake Pencben Lama, .
we Tibetans do not recognise him ,
🙏🙏🙏🌹💮❤️🌺
🎉🎉🎉
🎉🎉🎉🎉
😳😳😯
Duplicate PENCHEN LAMA.
Buddhism is from nepal
Indian claim from India.
@@Utube1024 no worries 😂
It's not about who's is who, it's about practicing the buddhism and we know who is practicing the real buddhism now a days
Hinduism is from India and Christianity from West
ཏཱ་ལའི་བླ་མ་ཕྱོགས་འཛིན་བོད་པ་ཚོ། ཁོང་པན་ཆེན་དངོས་མ་རེད་ཟེར་ནས་ག་ཚོད་སྐད་རྒྱག་ནའང་ཕན་གྱི་མ་རེད། བྱེད་ཐུབ་ཡ་ནི་ཅང་མེད་པ་བོད་ཕུང་སྐྱག་པ་ཚོ་ལ། ཧི་ཧི་
ཏཱ་ལའི་བླ་མ་ཕྱོགས་མ་རེད། the current Dalailama himself had admitted this Panchen lama officially. I am shocked that ཏཱ་ལའི་བླ་མ is still alive ,let alone the HH live longer or not .
after had seen so many "fake panchen" comments that I think I have to tell you all ,he is very popular in Tibet now .in Tibet wherever he goes the whole town will be empty ,because all people in the town are lining up on the streets to wait for his coming .people love him .he is handsome ,wisdom ,young ,a huge star ,a real hero of Tibetan Chinese .this is the real situation in Tibet .it's the Tibetan people chose him ,not other reasons .
😂😂😂😂 do you know real penchan lama..
@@jamessherpa4136 he is the real penchan lama ,I believed the result of what the gold urn told us .
he also eat urine boil eggs and bat soup?🤣🤣
@@Zoogy_zoo please respect our panchen lama ,if you are not a Tibetan but you are still a human right ?
@@malorybertie8046 🤣🤣🤣🤣khatsum gyarkok chamgadar...they have alot like him in AliExpress
Fake Panchen Lama🥸
Don’t watch such misinformation channel
Everyone should give dislike for this information spread
We respect you as a monk but we never accepted you are Panchen Lama , Chinese fake penchen lama ,
Free Tibet❤
Free tibet