@caseycoleman394 That's exactly how it should be.....it shouldn't matter who we stan, we should respect each orhers choices , and appreciate each other's love for K-pop
Been a kpop fan since. But to be honest, this group is the first group that I fell completely inlove and connected emotionally in every song. Even though they are going through some time now, I just cant stop going back to their song whenever I feel down. If you are not convinced, try to listen by yourself. Thank you for this new song to embrace, astro!!
Watching Jinjin and Sanha wandering the streets brings back memories of their reality show, where they were the last two to wake up and had to navigate their way to the studio. How time flies!
Eulnglidis curbani ela e uma benção na vida do hhomem a quem ela escolheu para amar e dividir a vida com ela porque ela e diauina de um verdadeiro amor Com que ela deseja prosseguir o caminho escolhido por Deus esse namorado do braço tatuado lindo noivo efuturo marido de quem ela fala tanto e não escondo de ninguém
"Unbreakable friendship" and brotherhood. I'm so happy to see you reunited again, singing and being happy, and I know he's with you too. I wish you the best my beautiful STARS.
I'm not an AROHA, I'm an ARMY. I don't know much about Astro but I listened to them in 2019 for the first time, I've listened to a few songs and I liked all of them but I can't stop crying right now.. I hope they're healing, I wish them the best 🥺❤❤🌟
The part where it goes as the moon comes after the sun hits different 🌙 we're always be by your side and support the brightest star. Happy 8th anniversary ASTRO! 💜💜💜💜💜💜
Astro please come back!! Without you, life is less happy. I fully dream that you will get on the same stage together and sing and dance!! We will always support you❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I really missed the sound of their four voices singing together ... I hope that all Arohas get comforted as I was listening to Circles💜 Thank you Astro for this amazing gift
To all Arohas, to all listeners and to myself, I hope you find a little bit of comfort in this song. We are all living in this world for the first time, so it is okay to struggle sometimes. We will find out way back slowly, but surely. Your Aroha and friend.
This song made me so emotional listening to it. Even though I’m not a big fan of Astro I do have to say they have amazing music indeed. This song made me think of Moonbin & I hope wherever moonbin is , I hope he’s watching over his members & listening to their music. I truly pray Astro gets all the attention they deserve & all the views & likes.
I am an ARMY, but ASTRO is the first group that I stanned, i am not AROHA now but i fully support ASTRO. I hope for them the best , and AROHA stay strong and never give up. Let's all stream their songs, especially this one. Miss you bin-i...
I am a ARMY/CARAT/BLACKROSE but to be completely honest I love ALL K-pop. From BTS, Seventeen, the Rose, Ateez, Stray Kids, SHINEE, TXT, Astro, FT island, and many more. I have always liked Cha Eun Woo in kdramas and became a fan of Astro through him. But being a fan of Seventeen, I became a fan of MOONBIN through his friendship with Seungkwan. I think he was an amazingly talented young man and was very saddened by his passing. He will be remembered for a long time thanks to AROHA and the many fans he has WORLDWIDE. Songs like CIRCLES (Astro) FLY (JinJin and Moonbin) and DANDELION (Seungkwan) will definitely keep him in our hearts forever.
My heart can't take the emotions everyone poured into this song, it's so beautiful❤️❤️. My boys went throught a lot, so much pain that we lost two of them in the way, one to take off in solo and the other became a star in our sky😭😭. Moonbins 1 year anniversary is coming, so let's keep a promise to take care of our precious stars and give them all the love they need to continue their journey. LETS DO IT AROHA!!💜💜💜✨️✨️
anybody prefers such type of chill and everyday life 'mv's compared to the high budget + no context or hard to get storyline mvs? I think is a good match for this song! fighting Astro!
Eso mismo me he preguntado tenemos que tener metas y demostrarles a los chicos que aunque ya no sean 6 para nosotros siempre lo serán y tendrán aroha para rato siento que hay desánimo no nos rindamos por amor a ellos así como ellos no lo han hecho pensando en aroha y más con la canción circles
Totally agree! Let's keep streaming at least three times a day. Also JinJin's song Wave in my heart, Rocky's Rocky Lucky, Sanha's cover, all of the need streaming please!
“когда заходит луна, восходит солнце, точно так же, как весна приходит после зимы, все в этой вселенной имеет цикл, подобный кругам. Если вы пережили что-то плохое, в будущем произойдет что-то хорошее."давайте будем счастливы вместе с astro
How to describe what I feel for Astro? The truth is... I don't know. Astro is color, it is happiness, it is laughter, but it is also learning. Astro hugged me and didn't let go, he made me part of his home, he welcomed me and loved me. Thank you... because despite not knowing me, you have helped me a lot. I love them 💜
Astro siempre será un grupo que guardará un lugar muy importante en mi corazón. Desde el primer momento supe que eran especiales y llenos de amor y eso lo he reafirmado con todo lo que ha pasado en el último año. También pienso que Aroha es uno de los fandoms más bonitos, tranquilos y respetuosos que existen. Si estás leyendo esto, te envío un abrazo enorme y calentito. Me encanta esta canción y soy un mar de lágrimas pero, aún así, es muy reconfortante. Gracias Astro por compartir vuestro sueño y amor. Os quiero mucho.
With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility. It’s a Spider Man Phrase but it Applies to Astro as a Group. They have gone through so much but seeing them together in this Song is helping heal something in them and us and that is admirable. Thank MJ, Jin Jin, Sanha and Cha Eun Woo. May you Keep Shining Brighter.
Es un tesoro tan preciado el ser como el grupo #ASTRO, tener una sensibilidad, humor, fuerza, valentía, calidad humana y a parte ser talentosos, buenos cantantes, bailarines y a parte guapísimos. Denles el lugar que merecen y merecen mucho. Al mundo le dan miedo que le gusten las buenas cosas
Pain will ease with time. The good memories and love will remain. And Binnie boo will be there making easy to heal, for his brothers in every step of the way.
it kinda feels weird not hearing Bin's and Rocky's voice in an astro song, but atleast we may still get to see Rocky and hear him sing solo. this is still a good gift to arohas. waiting for your comeback Astro! currently rewatching your series bin-ah, I am missing you and your voice. I hope to hear you sing again in the future, in whatever universe, I hope we meet again as Astro Moonbin and as your fan, an Aroha. fighting Astro~ 가수해줘서 고맙다 아스트로! ❤
Moonbin’s name should have been lit trough out the songs for his memory and in honor of his hardwork for Astro and undying love for the Arohas. It must be really hard for these 4 singing and recording with just 4 of them left. It aches my heart just listening the song. And it even hurts watching them trying to be happy and have fun and trying to be strong for each other. You 4 nailed the songs! Moonbin is really happy up there. HOPE ASTRO WILL HAVE A TRIBUTE CONCERT FOR MOONBIN❤
No, that won't happen. They're not ready for it. And they certainly don't have the strength to do it. The video was just for the anniversary! Why else do they do so many solo projects? Think about it
@@michaelahornung7635 Umm, it was likely due to the fact MJ was in the military, they couldn't exactly promote Astro without him, or else it'd be 3 members covering 3 other people's lines and the choreo would have to be adjusted a lot anyway.
Bean's anniversary is coming up soon. I want to see all of Astro's videos now and remember the good old days, I recommend that you also remember!! I want them back so badly!! Please show up together again and support each other!!! Love you always❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mine is to watch Astro videos and shorts everyday is a necessity since it makes me happy. I find myself smiling in the office during breaks, in the car and at home...even if I keep on repeating videos that I have seen before. I miss the 6 members as a group, especially Moonbin. ❤
![[ASTRO DDOCA] 아스트로 또까 We Still (Be With U)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zyk2KpV6avk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] ฝันรักห้วงนิทรา | EP.1 (1/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g7F6i0ganRU/mqdefault.jpg)
I love this song so much.. missing MoonBin forever, but I'll stick forever as an Aroha..
Astrooooo please come back😢😢😢 we miss you mj, jinjin, eunwoo, sanha❤❤❤❤❤❤❤we love you more
Thanks ASTRO for this beatiful melody... I miss you Moonbin💜🇲🇽
Stay Strong ASTRO ! Moon Bin is missed by all of us : fans, family, ASTRO group members and the crew. He is watching us from heaven.
remaining ASTRO members world tour comeback concert please 😭🙏
ARMY here! We’re here to support AROHA and ASTRO! Stay strong! You are not alone! We’re all family in this K-pop universe. Missing you, Moonbin
Gracias por el apoyo, son fantásticos.
From one ARMY to another….thanks for your support
شكرًا جدًا لكلامك الحلو والمشجع، أرمي ! 🥹🥹🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
Gracias💜
Beautiful. What a loving K-pop universe we live in(Army(BTS), Aroha(Astro), Shawols(SHINee), etc.). All here for support☺☺🥰🥰😍😍😚😚
After listening to Fly, I came to watch this clip again. Moonbin is always with you guys. I'm glad to have you, I love you so much.
Moonbin will not be forgotten! He’s so missed! It’s good to see Astro releasing new music!
Your not alone AROHA ….love and support from ARMY
Beautiful. What a loving K-pop universe we live in(Army(BTS), Aroha(Astro), Shawols(SHINee), etc.). All here for support 🥰🥰😍😍😚😚
@caseycoleman394 That's exactly how it should be.....it shouldn't matter who we stan, we should respect each orhers choices , and appreciate each other's love for K-pop
🤍
@@misty-eyes9520 Love one another. The "groups" are all wonderful in their own way.
Love and support you astro
I'M JUST MISSING MOONBIN'S VOICE 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
언제쯤 슬프지 않을까
많이 보고싶다...정말 많이
나의 전부 아스트로
Been a kpop fan since. But to be honest, this group is the first group that I fell completely inlove and connected emotionally in every song. Even though they are going through some time now, I just cant stop going back to their song whenever I feel down. If you are not convinced, try to listen by yourself.
Thank you for this new song to embrace, astro!!
Es tan reconfortante está canción, espero que algún día volvamos a tenerlos en un escenario
++
Astro is my example, they taught me that after winter comes spring. Thank you for comforting my heart.
When I’m falling apart, raise me up again……..stay strong AROHA’S x
Watching Jinjin and Sanha wandering the streets brings back memories of their reality show, where they were the last two to wake up and had to navigate their way to the studio. How time flies!
Ok ready.. memories 🥹🥹
何度聴いても切なさと悲しさに満たされるけど、たまにはムンビンを思って泣いてもいいよね…
1年たってまた春がきたよ、ムンビン。
道端に咲いてるたんぽぽを見てムンビンが脳裏に浮かんで思わず撮ったたんぽぽを、こんなに愛しいと思う日はなかった。
大好きだよムンビン♡ASTRO♡
今自分が出来る、精一杯の応援をこれからもしていくからよろしくね😌
I can't believe such a beautiful song exists. It's a hug for my heart, I love her vocals, JinJiin did a great job writing it and Astro singing it.
Army is here for support you Aroha and astro ❤❤❤❤❤💜💜💜💜💜💜
💜
Eulnglidis curbani ela e uma benção na vida do hhomem a quem ela escolheu para amar e dividir a vida com ela porque ela e diauina de um verdadeiro amor
Com que ela deseja prosseguir o caminho escolhido por Deus esse namorado do braço tatuado lindo noivo efuturo marido de quem ela fala tanto e não escondo de ninguém
@@Inglidis what you said please say in English
We, Aroha, will not disappoint you and will support Astro until the end💜🌌
This song has become my comfort song ever since its release. Thank you, Astro for releasing such a masterpiece.
Para igual está canción es mi consuelo para seguir esperándolos...
same here
ARMY here…..supporting Astro and AROHA’S…….let’s get it to 2M
Vamos por mucho más .. los chicos se merecen todo lo mejor del mundo
No se los apoya como debería tendrian q haber tenido muchas más vistas en este tiempo no soy aroha pero trato de verlos almenos tres veces al dia
Por favor escuchen también Jinjin Wave in my heart, está hermosa, fresca y alegre
@@Paula-ir2yc siii es preciosa canción hay que apoyar a nuestro líder Jin Jin
@@monicachaves8966 si por favor sigan apoyando Wave in my heart, y ahora más pues para el 20 de marzo va a sacar Good Enough....
"Unbreakable friendship" and brotherhood. I'm so happy to see you reunited again, singing and being happy, and I know he's with you too. I wish you the best my beautiful STARS.
This song was a band-aid for my heart!🥹😭♥️
I'm not an AROHA, I'm an ARMY. I don't know much about Astro but I listened to them in 2019 for the first time, I've listened to a few songs and I liked all of them but I can't stop crying right now.. I hope they're healing, I wish them the best 🥺❤❤🌟
I'm an ARMY and AROHA, thanks ARMY for supporting the AROHA's 💜💜💜💜
Thank u
شكرًا جدًا لكلامك الحلو عن أسترو، يا أرمي 💎🫶🏻
Gracias Army
I was crying? Your heart is ahora too... Welcome! ♥
Missing OT6 Astro so much…to our beautiful eunwoo, mj, Sanha, Jinjin, please continue to shine together for a long time 🥹🥹💜💜 AROHA forever
This song, just like their Aroha-dedicated song brings a lot of memories. Felt nostalgic. Missing OT6 but will always be thankful for Astro
4人になったASTRO…辛かった毎日、乗り越え様とする毎日、前を向こうとする毎日、メンバーの色々な思い葛藤が巡り廻ってるって感じと、そこにムンビンの声が無い事等に涙😢出て来た…しかし元気なASTROが見れた事ASTROの曲聴けた事は
とても嬉しいです。凄く良い曲です💕有り難う❤💕
I love my Astro. They had been through so much without Moonbin. They are staying strong as always. ❤Keep on fighting boys! Never ever give up!
The part where it goes as the moon comes after the sun hits different 🌙 we're always be by your side and support the brightest star. Happy 8th anniversary ASTRO! 💜💜💜💜💜💜
Str34m???
I cried listening to this song. My youth was filled with Astro 💜
This hits so hard, i love them with the whole life
Enfin une nouvelle chanson ensemble cela fait trop plaisir !! Une pensée pour moonbin🫰❤️
The friendship and love among themselves/the members makes Astro stronger and of course we will love you always...
A lovely tribute to Moonbin and celebration of Astro 💗💗💗💗💗 A lovely balance of the past and present 🌸 Well done 👏
Astro please come back!! Without you, life is less happy.
I fully dream that you will get on the same stage together and sing and dance!!
We will always support you❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yo estoy igual que tú, sueño con verlos sobre un escenario los 4 juntos.. ojalá no sólo sea un sueño
still coming to my favorite group.
I really missed the sound of their four voices singing together ...
I hope that all Arohas get comforted as I was listening to Circles💜
Thank you Astro for this amazing gift
Seeing them together makes my life happy, I missed their songs even more, I love how they complement each other in a beautiful way
I love seeing you together again for Aroha ❤
ASTRO FOREVER 💜 ♾️
To all Arohas, to all listeners and to myself,
I hope you find a little bit of comfort in this song.
We are all living in this world for the first time, so it is okay to struggle sometimes.
We will find out way back slowly, but surely.
Your Aroha and friend.
Thank you Roha for your words. We all surely have received much comfort through this song.
Thank you for such a beatiful message ! I really needed it today ! 💓
Thanks, Aroha for your words 🥹🥹💌🦋🫶🏻
@@Haru_vi I may not be there physically for you, but I hope you feel embraced. 💜
ステキな言葉を有り難う❤❤❤❤
어느 구간에서인가 빈이 목소리가 들려올것만 같아요
아스트로 힘내줘서 고마워요
빈이 너무 보고싶고 편안했으면❤
Even I feel like this. This song has that astro song vibe which is making me hear both Binnie's and rocky's voice ❤
I definitely love this song and I love seeing the boys singing together even more❤
have a soft heart in a cruel world is courage not weakness, stay strong ASTRO⭐️, take care, keep shining
Astro means family 🥺💓💓
This song made me so emotional listening to it. Even though I’m not a big fan of Astro I do have to say they have amazing music indeed. This song made me think of Moonbin & I hope wherever moonbin is , I hope he’s watching over his members & listening to their music. I truly pray Astro gets all the attention they deserve & all the views & likes.
I'm here because I miss Astro ❤
Quiero y deseo de todo corazón que sigan cantando, bailando por ustedes, por nosotras! Juntos forever ♥️
i guess, happy anniversary to Aroha's all around the world? keep loving these boys, ASTRO deserves more beautiful and happy moments together
Love this song... 🤍
Astro got me into kpop... I'm waiting for their comeback..🥺..
I am an ARMY, but ASTRO is the first group that I stanned, i am not AROHA now but i fully support ASTRO. I hope for them the best , and AROHA stay strong and never give up. Let's all stream their songs, especially this one.
Miss you bin-i...
I’m ARMY to, thanks for your support
Gracias por su apoyo
Gracias
💜
It was Moonbin who reintroduced me to ASTRO. Eun Woo introduced me, but Moonbin reintroduced me. ❤😢
I am a ARMY/CARAT/BLACKROSE but to be completely honest I love ALL K-pop. From BTS, Seventeen, the Rose, Ateez, Stray Kids, SHINEE, TXT, Astro, FT island, and many more. I have always liked Cha Eun Woo in kdramas and became a fan of Astro through him. But being a fan of Seventeen, I became a fan of MOONBIN through his friendship with Seungkwan. I think he was an amazingly talented young man and was very saddened by his passing. He will be remembered for a long time thanks to AROHA and the many fans he has WORLDWIDE. Songs like CIRCLES (Astro) FLY (JinJin and Moonbin) and DANDELION (Seungkwan) will definitely keep him in our hearts forever.
Gracias por amar incondicionalmente a ASTRO
Same Same Same!! 💜💗🧡❤🖤💛💚💙😘
Life is not always fair, but know we're together strong as real AROHA
Armys here supporting astro ❤❤❤
Gracias Army por su apoyo incondicional
The lyrics is just so nice
Gracias x nuevamente escuchar sus voces juntas y hacer felices a sus arohas
Their friendship they shared with each other is what I fall for them at my initial journey to become Aroha ❤❤now they have become a part of my life ❤❤
It's 100% Astro....i love it....thow we miss Binnie and Rocky
I'm here. Still waiting for you. No one can replace your place in my heart. Forever Aroha❤
My heart can't take the emotions everyone poured into this song, it's so beautiful❤️❤️. My boys went throught a lot, so much pain that we lost two of them in the way, one to take off in solo and the other became a star in our sky😭😭. Moonbins 1 year anniversary is coming, so let's keep a promise to take care of our precious stars and give them all the love they need to continue their journey. LETS DO IT AROHA!!💜💜💜✨️✨️
日本のアロハです！
みんなの歌声が聴けてとても嬉しい…😢💖
ムンビンとラキが居ないのが寂しいけど、4人の姿が見れて幸せ₍ᐡˊo̴̶̷̤ ̫ o̴̶̷̤ˋᐡ₎
anybody prefers such type of chill and everyday life 'mv's compared to the high budget + no context or hard to get storyline mvs? I think is a good match for this song! fighting Astro!
I agree. I love these kind of videos. Such a great video for this song.
Me quedo con este tipo de videos.. porque muestran exactamente como son ellos
I love you my OT6 forever and ever 💜💜 I love seeing you together and smiling 🥺🥰🥰🥰
ずっと重たくって苦しい気持ちに包まれていた、気がつくと泣いていた。。
この曲を聴いているうちに、私達が進んで行く道が開けて行くように、悲しみを抱いていても未来に向かって歩いて行く事が出来るように導いて貰える気持ちを感じ出した。
ビニが愛したASTROをもっと強く美しくしてビニに贈ってあげたい。
メンバーの気持ちと覚悟が伝わって来た。
私もそうなるようにAROHAとして側にずっといたい。
あなたは本物の AROHA です、そして他のすべての本物の AROHA と一緒に ASTRO をより強くすることができます
Me too 🫂
Can’t believe there are so few views!!! I’ve been watching the video every day a lot of times… where are the fans!! They deserve to have more views 😞😞
Eso mismo me he preguntado tenemos que tener metas y demostrarles a los chicos que aunque ya no sean 6 para nosotros siempre lo serán y tendrán aroha para rato siento que hay desánimo no nos rindamos por amor a ellos así como ellos no lo han hecho pensando en aroha y más con la canción circles
@@YoleidyVina-is3rs manca Moon Bin....
Totally agree! Let's keep streaming at least three times a day. Also JinJin's song Wave in my heart, Rocky's Rocky Lucky, Sanha's cover, all of the need streaming please!
@@Paula-ir2yc yes we should give all of them views
@@Paula-ir2yc you forgot about Eunwoo's songs
“когда заходит луна, восходит солнце, точно так же, как весна приходит после зимы, все в этой вселенной имеет цикл, подобный кругам. Если вы пережили что-то плохое, в будущем произойдет что-то хорошее."давайте будем счастливы вместе с astro
главное, что бы это не были бесконечные круги ада((
とても素敵な歌詞です。
心に響きました。
ずっとASTROを応援します❤
日本語訳を付けてくれてありがとう。
진짜.. 너무 너무 보고싶다 멤버들아..
빈이의 빈자리가 너무 많이 느껴져요 ㅠㅠㅠ 빈이의 자리만큼... 아스트로가 앞으로도 쭉.. 영원했으면 좋겠어요 ㅠㅠ
Astro is family, the connection they have will always be present at any time and in any dimension.
ずっとASTROが大好き💙
As the moon comes (It’s natural)
After the sun
We're going in circles, circles😭
How to describe what I feel for Astro? The truth is... I don't know. Astro is color, it is happiness, it is laughter, but it is also learning. Astro hugged me and didn't let go, he made me part of his home, he welcomed me and loved me. Thank you... because despite not knowing me, you have helped me a lot. I love them 💜
Couldn't have said it better myself 💜
your comment is beautiful, astro is unique 💜
For me,When they are together,the vibe they give is better than any other K-pop group
Astro siempre será un grupo que guardará un lugar muy importante en mi corazón. Desde el primer momento supe que eran especiales y llenos de amor y eso lo he reafirmado con todo lo que ha pasado en el último año. También pienso que Aroha es uno de los fandoms más bonitos, tranquilos y respetuosos que existen. Si estás leyendo esto, te envío un abrazo enorme y calentito. Me encanta esta canción y soy un mar de lágrimas pero, aún así, es muy reconfortante. Gracias Astro por compartir vuestro sueño y amor. Os quiero mucho.
1 million viewers , ASTRO Let's Stay Strong Together 💜💜💜💜💜
차은우 존경해요 당신은 훌륭한 사람이에요 절대 포기하지 않아요 당신은 아름답고 다른 멤버들에게도 최고예요 진심으로 사랑해요❤❤❤
With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility. It’s a Spider Man Phrase but it Applies to Astro as a Group. They have gone through so much but seeing them together in this Song is helping heal something in them and us and that is admirable. Thank MJ, Jin Jin, Sanha and Cha Eun Woo. May you Keep Shining Brighter.
Let's stay strong AROHAs and support ASTRO we love them no matter what ❤❤
i really love their voices and also of course their song ..the vibes is just different from other kpop group .. thank you astro for your existing ❤
Es un tesoro tan preciado el ser como el grupo #ASTRO, tener una sensibilidad, humor, fuerza, valentía, calidad humana y a parte ser talentosos, buenos cantantes, bailarines y a parte guapísimos. Denles el lugar que merecen y merecen mucho. Al mundo le dan miedo que le gusten las buenas cosas
NOW LET´S TAKE THEM TO 2 MILLION VIEWS AS SOON AS POSIBLE!!!
Vamos
ASTROメンバーが４人になり、色々とあった事を思い出すと、ただただ辛くて涙が出てくることが多かったけど、、でもこうして４人で新たな道を示してくれたおかけで、私も前を向いて頑張ろうと思えた！
素敵な曲を届けてくれて、ありがとう🩷
歌詞に心が救われました😭
I really admire each one of you, I know you are going to go very far, especially if you continue united as until now. ❤❤🥹☪️✨💓
Pain will ease with time. The good memories and love will remain. And Binnie boo will be there making easy to heal, for his brothers in every step of the way.
I Miss moonbin and Rocky voice😭😭😭😭😭
Me too 😭😭
Я особенно за роки 😢
사람을 가슴에 묻는것도 노력이야 웃으며 울고있는 것처럼 보이는 모습이 더 가슴을 먹먹하게 만든다,
Bellísima canción... Los abrazo fuerte siempre.. Gracias mis niños hermosos ASTRO forever
it kinda feels weird not hearing Bin's and Rocky's voice in an astro song, but atleast we may still get to see Rocky and hear him sing solo. this is still a good gift to arohas. waiting for your comeback Astro! currently rewatching your series bin-ah, I am missing you and your voice. I hope to hear you sing again in the future, in whatever universe, I hope we meet again as Astro Moonbin and as your fan, an Aroha. fighting Astro~ 가수해줘서 고맙다 아스트로! ❤
Astro is making a comeback?🤩🤩🤩
아로하라면 누구나 이 노래의 의미를 알고 있으니 계속 응원해주세요💜💜
문빈님을 생각하는 노래
Moonbin’s name should have been lit trough out the songs for his memory and in honor of his hardwork for Astro and undying love for the Arohas. It must be really hard for these 4 singing and recording with just 4 of them left. It aches my heart just listening the song. And it even hurts watching them trying to be happy and have fun and trying to be strong for each other. You 4 nailed the songs! Moonbin is really happy up there. HOPE ASTRO WILL HAVE A TRIBUTE CONCERT FOR MOONBIN❤
❤🩵🦋💜agree for that 👍😢
No, that won't happen.
They're not ready for it.
And they certainly don't have the strength to do it.
The video was just for the anniversary!
Why else do they do so many solo projects?
Think about it
@@michaelahornung7635 just a wish though. But never say never doesn’t exist in show business. Not now or next year but i’m sure it will happen.. ☺️
@@michaelahornung7635 Umm, it was likely due to the fact MJ was in the military, they couldn't exactly promote Astro without him, or else it'd be 3 members covering 3 other people's lines and the choreo would have to be adjusted a lot anyway.
I hope too, some day 💜
Vermont army here to support Asto. I love this song!!❤
Stay Strong Aroha
астро - группа, которая познакомила меня с к-поп и это действительно драгоценно. я буду всегда поддерживать их
MJ's vocals and harmonization since 2:57 is fire!!! OMG 🔝🔝🔝
Totally agree👍
Stay strong astro 💜
Imagine if our moon still here miss him so much😭😭
Bean's anniversary is coming up soon. I want to see all of Astro's videos now and remember the good old days, I recommend that you also remember!!
I want them back so badly!! Please show up together again and support each other!!! Love you always❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Forever ASTRO💜 MJ your voice is amazing!
My bias MJ
Se convirtió en una necesidad escuchar Circles todos los días 🥺❤️🩹
Lo siento igual, es como un ritual que me cura 🥺
Mine is to watch Astro videos and shorts everyday is a necessity since it makes me happy. I find myself smiling in the office during breaks, in the car and at home...even if I keep on repeating videos that I have seen before. I miss the 6 members as a group, especially Moonbin. ❤
Sii es como una curita a mi corazon...escucharla me reconforta mi alma.
Me encanta no ser el único aroha español
Happy birthday to Cha Eun Woo ❤❤❤❤❤
STAYS have arrived! Love you Astro keep FIGHTING! I love your songs and you ofc. ☺ Miss you Moonbin. Lots of love all around the world. ☺☺