Extrema Ratio RAO vs Cold Steel 4-MAX part 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Andrew Demko tests the new Cold Steel 4-MAX alongside the Extrema Ratio RAO!
A lot of people asked to see this side by side test
For more information about Cold Steel knives, please visit:
www.coldsteel.com
Watch this space for PART TWO!
I cant believe how people really believe these test without actually testing the two knives themselfs. I could be wrong but I really doubt a $400 dollar knife is gonna fail on the first test. I think cold steel set this whole gig up.
Agree
I love Extrema Ratio but all mine are fixed blade and this guy could have a fake counterfeit Extrema Ratio RAO . But I did see those two guy field test a genuine Extrema Ratio RAO and a fake one and they both folded in half when hit really hard. You need the pin in it.
Nice slight of hand, you are in the wrong profession. Someone who starts a test with as much verbal bias as this individual does should not be in a position of testing a product for consumer consideration.
Both knives are solid and will function as expected. Interesting how Cold Steel turned to Italy for their manufacturing of the 4Max 2017 edition. I own both knives and have not been disappointed with either, although I am not a fan of the screw lock pin on the Rao II, solid but just too much fiddling if you need to lock up in a hurry.
is cheaper to produce it in Italy!
A Jott it’s not... loads of italian companies produce in germany even because of how expansive producing in italy is
ummm its posted by cold steel so obviously the 4-max wins, I like cold steel but the Rao had to have been tampered with, there's no way a Rao failed that badly. I own 3 of them and several cold steel tri-ad-lock folders
the rao has an aluminuum frame which isn't a good pick since it‘s lacking hardness and most likely will deform from shock / strikes.
this why it's all wobbly after that test.
i wanna see a 4 max vs crkt xoc
Yes this atrocious overpriced shit must beat the dust.
The xoc has the deadbolt. Andrew ( the man in the video) has already tested a triad lock ( the lock here from cold steel). Both performed HONORABLY. And i mean HONORABLY. however the deadbolt lock edged it out... However the knife tested was like 100 bucks. Vs the xoc ....and well we know how much that crap cost...... Bottom line , both locks are awesome. And it should be noted, the cold steel 4max also has a secondary stop pin hole.. you can stick a nail or other similar sized pin thru it and even IF the triad lock failed, it wont close on your hand.... Also another reason the triad lock may be better to some, is the fact that it allows for a thinner, narrower knife.. vs the deadbolt having minimum thickness and width requirement... Crkt now has multiple knives with the deadbolt for real world prices ~100-150 bucks.. and that my friends cant be beaten .. if you got a triad , your golden... But after many many years or continuous hard use, once the lock surfaces wear out of spec , it becomes less safe. Not so with the deadbolt. Eventually it may develop play , like all knives that fold and lock, it doesnt change the safety...steel has to sheer or break for the deadbolt to fail..
lol this was the last hope. all the people waiting to see a cs loss wanted this. havent watched it yet im going to say cs wins.
@@gordonbombay6627 yet the 4max is made in Italy lol
@@hyssean12 I didn't say all knives made in italy are poopoo. I said "these" Italian knives are bad. Yes they moves production of the 4max to italy. That doesn't make it a bad knife and it doesn't discredit Andrew demko in the least. But I'll say it clearer for you. Extrema ratio knives are poopoo. Not all italian knives but extrema knives which also happen to be Italian suck poopoo.
@@gordonbombay6627 As this series of videos shows, the ER RAO II didn't support the same weight or lock test as the CS, but that doesn't mean the ER RAO II sucks as it withstood the tests very well.
Have you made any knife in your life?
@@marciolprado1 yes many. Also ER knives suck so much butt. They are big ugly scraps of shit.
Awesome knife, ingenious lock design. Can't wait to get my hands on the 4max, as well as the new 2016 throwers! go cold steel
Just bought one & received it today. A total beast of a knife! One has to feel it in-hand to really appreciate it! - Great vid. Thankyou Cold Steel 👍🏻
Anyone else flinch when the RAO blade fell on his fingers?
A little, but they take the edge and tip off for these tests, for safety.
Scary stuff.
Yes, sir. I've been bitten a few times. Once, I took stitches at the ER.
I just gave my girl friend a spine whack for tell me to stop watching these knife videos lol
I hit the thumbs up button
+TheIrcbully
should've used the overstrike
+James Milton (Jay) lol
Finally another amazing video. Please can the next video be on the benchmade adamas?
+jonny cola THIS
It'll lose.
Look up the CS Talwar vs.the Benchmade Bedlam. It is CS hands down. A $40-$50 CS knife vs. a Benchmade Bedlam @ $200.
Non spenderei mai più di 15,00 € per un coltello Cold Steel
A parte fare fake video, sai fare qualcos'altro?
whilst I cant see any need for a lock to be that unsanely strong, these videos are entertaining
CedricAda Gear and Outdoors Better to be stronger than weaker.
I would never go to the bushcraft field or in a battle with a pit bull that attacked me with anything less than a Tri-Ad lock.
A big bush man needs a big bush knife 🎶
He was using a clone extrema ratio!!! Of course it's going to fail!!!
Jules Critelli that was also my Impression, as well as they did with Otter Tests. Once I saw him Talking an extrema ratio out of a brown box which is not ER but typical of chinese copies
Damn that 4max is sweet.
I own one. I had to tweak it a bit, but she is worth every cent.
Demko is the man. Without Demko, Lynn would still be selling Garden Tools🤫🤫🤫🤫
Mind Fuk’r 😀
so...how's that whole San Mai debacle going for you guys?
Sarebbe bello questo test farlo in italia e vedere se il risultato sarebbe diverso. Io ho diversi coltelli della cold steel e dell extrema ratio 1 solo e sono validi tutti e 2 i brand. Personalmente questo test mi sembra scorretto dato che il coltello non é un martello, e se si forza contro un ramo si fa dall altro lato.
Will you test Benchmade 275 Adamas vs Recon 1?
Take a shot everytime he opens and closes the RAO
Cold Steel 4Max won hands down the RAO broke plain and simple
lets face it, the cold steel lock is an ingenious design.
adamas! wanna see it break lol
I see your Extrema Ratio close up and sorry, it’s a fake counterfeit Extrema Ratio RAO, you can tell right away because of the lanyard, it’s just elastic string.
I'm Italian and I can say E.R. knives suck! they're just extremely overpriced tactical junk
Bell italiano che sei, di italiano non hai nemmeno il nome
I heard a $700 dollar EXTREMA Ratio will still fold when hit hard without the pin.
i talked about the RAO's lock on forum for years now...had one but after each use it had blade play. sold it...few months ago i bought the ER MPC, realy thought that was their strongest folder. looked great but after 1 wack on the back of a leather chair ( wasnt using any gloves or safety so it wasnt that hard) again it had blade play....i honestly think you can close the mpc with a good wack on the spine. so you pay lots of money for a cool looking knife that wil have a weak lock... all extrema ratios?...yes all of them. my guess is that the safety pin will rip the scales apart when the weight test reaches 400 pounds...the Max will still be going strong. in the wack test i think the rAO failed beacuse its loses its ability to be used without the safety pin...and putting the pin in is a real hassle...especially with the elastic cord still on...twists back after you screw it in...............theres more challenge in a BM adamas and more to laugh when you test a medford
That blade play WITH the pin… Just so sloppy. When does a knife with wiggle ever inspire confidence? Even with the second pin? I so need a 4max, I think I’ll get a scout very soon, then start saving for the real deal 😊
Extreme ratio? It's all about marketing ! Without the product to match. Fixed blade knife my arse! That is the most extreme fail I have seen! Ha! Ha!
i have the 4 max (made in USA) and it is worth the money!Strong as fuck and superb quality!THX Cold Steel and Andrew Demko
First Edge Knives folder shows a video being able to take 1200 pounds of pressure on there blade and still did not fail. I think this would be the battle of the titans that needs to be done.
i like the RAO because i need a hybrid knife,
a fixed blade can not be concealed where i live.
Andrew, is that a sig or glock?
Poor Ray Oh or RAO failed from the start Blackforstghost 1's take in this knife got me hear.
Cold Steel 4 Max vs CRKT XOC?
total fail you can hear shit rattling around like fucking maracas
Always happy to see cold steel crush the competition.
Hey Cold Steel, I have 2 questions for you. 1, how much for would it take to break a tri ad lock? Like if you did a weight hang test on a XL Espada or something like that what would the weight be needed to break it? And 2. I sent in two knives for resharpening, do I just need a $14 money order or something?
the blade will break before the lock does. Check the Tatanka vs Voyager video.
Extrema Ratio is Suck☝️
Finally a blade that's nearly one tenth as good as your $50 blades but it costs ten times as much, takes ten seconds to screw together, and rattles after a couple of good whacks.
Looking forward to the lift tests
please test the schrade sure lock!!!
RAO caput...
Extrema seems alright but nothing can beat cold steel
@@LXT43 well I mean it looks like cold steels lock beat the extrema ratio in this video. True can't really find a hard-core prying tip test video for cold steel. But I've got a recon 1 and I've pried open several 5 gallon paint cans my time on the river. That's a hell of a tip test, unfortunately I can't prove though. Also I paid 80 bucks for it
can anyone tel me what the factory edge angle is on the 4-max??
The face of Andrew Demko says it all while his holding the RAO after the test. This is trash hahaha!.
Extrema price for Extrema junk!!....Andrew makes a bad a** knife!!....keep it up brother!!👌💯👍
You doesn't have an angle impact point measurement from the axis of the blade,
I have all kinds of knives and I have been called a fan boy before and don't really care but if it can't take the same tests as a cold steel then it's a fail. Doesn't mean it's not a good knife just means it's not a cold steel tough knife. Let's play the aliens game. If aliens come today and you had to have one knife and only one knife for the rest of your life to fight them off what are you going to choose? Out of all the hundreds I have I'm grabbing a cold steel and running for the hills. But that's iho.
Do a test vs Medford, Shirogorov and Benchmade Adamas! Until then, I will still have doubt about your knives being the strongest.
How about Adamas though? It withstood Vininull's test.
All I'm saying - is they pick easy targets.
Hmm, they tested the Power Lock from Spydie, that's not an easy target. They've demonstrated multiple times that frame locks will normally fail this test and Demko is the first to point out why - it seems to be how it's engineered.
It would be neat to see a Shiro and Medord get beat up a bit though :)
lol you still have doubt about the tri-ad lock, keep doubting then
Benchmade..... lol
I’d like someone to describe to me. Why a lock needs to withstand a spine wack that hard? Falling bricks? Cutting with the spine of your knife? I go hard on my knives. But I just don’t get it. I cut down
Why does somebody need a car that does 180mph or a firearm that can hit targets at 500 yards plus etc etc, it’s either the piece of mind or knowing that a folding knife that cost way less then most the popular models can literally do anything you need if that’s the only knife you had on you in a bad situation, why not have a lock that strong give me a reason.
I live in another country but i would love buy some CSknives, i need know something, how it works buying knifes in my case ;
That test is more than inconclusive. Granted, these are pretty extreme tests but the lock on the RAO broke. You no longer have a fictional folder at that point. The pin gives you a makeshift knife but all the blade play and wobble doesn’t install much confidence in me any more at that point.
I was shocked when I saw this video come up. Cold Steel’s got BALLS and a sick friggin knife to back it up.
make a ball bearing 4-max flipper then it's a instant purchase hahaha. will you guy's ever bring the arch angel back in production ?
they can fail
there not the ultimate knife.
ive had 3 folders fail on me, but i still like them, but there aesthetics arent to par with like a benchmade.
I want to see how much that 4 max can hold on the weight hang. I couldnt believe the results of the XL Voyager, and I am sure this blade is much stronger. Gonna be insane.
Cold steel will be my next folder. If i cant find a m4 manix2
Is it me or did he have a 1911 tucked in the back of his trousers??
Jeez. I remember when Coldsteel offered an amazing product at an amazing price... I guess there are different pockets in play these days. Awesome knife though.
+ShamelessTR Well there are a lot of people saying they wanted better steels that were USA produced and CS delivered. That stuff costs something though. I also believe they are making an effort to produce more of their products in the US, which also adds cost. I think there are still plenty of the AUS 8A blades available on Ebay and Amazon for now though. I personally never had a problem with any of their steels. I liked that I could get a lot of blade for the money, but I do appreciate that they are genuinely working towards producing higher quality blades
The 4Max is not typical of their usual offerings. It's their slightly step-down version of Demko's custom 4Max knife. People have been asking for some time for CS to offer a high end production version of the knife for years.
I just picked up a brand new Espada XL in G10 with CTS-XHP blade steel for my friend...for $210 from Amazon, brand new. 7.5" of CTS-XHP for that price is incredibly good value.
Extrema RATIO all the WAY!!! 4 max just ugly
Rao is weak
but worth the money.....the 4 max!😑
Lack cutting ability like your sr1
Dobar si majstor, bravo na triad bravi za čakije no ovo pljuvanje konkurencije je smiješno.
good knife 4max now I always carry it with me
you can buy it now at midwayusa.com I've ordered from them before
All this time, and I missed “if you’re a super mall-ninja”
How much heroine do I have to sell to buy a 4 Max?
Andrew, what are the 2 knives you carry in either pocket?
good vid. u guys gonna be at the parking lot sale?
I like the 4Max, give use a hollow grind version with hardened alluminum liners and call it the 4Max Lite.
there's already a 4max scout🤔
I really wait eagerly for part 2!
+Mathieu Bastien
I like your code 4 half g10 mod
Thank you ;)
And that's why I'm using cold steel
Still no adamas or hinderer tests. Cmon guys we are all waiting :)
+Mike D isnt the 808 Loco stronger than Adamas?
James Milton they're both very very close. Either one would be good for this test. Loco is basically a differently shaped adamas with a different blade grind. Lock strength should be on par.
both will lose no doubt especially the Hinderer, which is just another Ti framlock like the ZT300 they tested so why bother anyways.
Glenn056 yeah the hinderer for sure will lose, but wouldn't write off the adamas or loco too quick, ive seen vininul test the adamas and its liners are that thick it doesnt let that axis lock bar give way like others. Adamas is probably the 2nd strongest knife after cold steels offerings.
My knife snob friends think their hinderer is tougher than my 4 max. Still waiting on the vid.
Nice. Now, I challenge you to clamp the AD15 at maximum human grip strength, and spine whack it hard.. I have a feeling that scorpion lock mechanism is a finger guillotine in the right/wrong situation.
I know right. They test frame locks without holding them which is stupid, test the Scorpion lock like that too. Me? I don't really care that much, i prefer a back lock and like the Tri Ad but i like frame locks and other locks as well. I use a knife in a manner that the blade isn't being pushed in the closing direction anyway. I use common sense. Whacking the back of a blade to test a knife is like testing a car by droping a bowling ball on it. I support these stupid videos though because the knife world really will sell you some real garbage.
i Waited so long like years for the 4 max checked every where is preorder or back order, but you guy have the 4 max to wasted with these kind of test!! how long untill the 4 max aviable?
thx! im a big fan of Andrew design, the best design and lock stength on the market
what kind of 1911 is that in your waistband
Epic fail!!!
Especially at that price
The cold steel Korean knives are a piece of crap in front of a extrema ratio Italian artisan knive as the RAO 180, is like to compare a Lamborgini next to a Hiunday mate.
Apparently not
This cold steel is made in italy dumbass
cold steel has told that +csknives
I totally dig my 4MAX. beefy. Anybody have any insight on Crusader Forge knives? Judging from the internet...they are hella expensive. Beautiful looking but expensive. Any quality in performance?
It's a framelock. They almost all will slip off the tang. I had 2 medfords close and cut me
Don't trust frame or liner locks.
Cold steel rules
#coldsteelmini4MAXplease
Thank you.
FAIL!!
awesome
primer comentario
First actual comment.
+Prism The Archangel Dragon
Irrelevant and off topic. Subject to deletion. Admin?
I was seriously considering the RAO at one point. Not anymore...
ROA failed. It no longer functions as intended.Pretty simple. Even though it did not fold on the spine whack, the primary locking system failed & no longer functions. If you loose the pin your knife is useless.Plus, its noisy now too, not good for tactical situations.
+Evil Droid The pin is not needed to lock the blade in the open position.
+neonightkiller it is after this test, which is his point. It helps to actually read the comment before you reply.
yep....that was a stupid fucking comment for sure...probly ripped......you win...
+neonightkiller stay lifted buddy!
Thor Smith hee hee, lifted,...that's a good one...=)
hey cs, what if i buy a 4max in germany and something is wrong with the knife ? Does germany have a cold steel customer service? i mean a 600 euro knife should be really worth the price lol
man this is so awesome benchmade and spyderco can learn from you guys
+Val Valiant benchmades service is really good. I love cs but my personal experiences with benchmade have made me a fan for life
ah benchmade is just to expensive for us in europe it is not worth at all buying any of these knives
Benchmade give out free pocket clips or if you broken anything from their product they will also replace it for free I think you will only spend the shipping fee
I'm curious, did you ever get any CS products? I don't know if it is even possible for a Cold Steel blade to fail lol, but they would probably make it right. They are literally the only single brand that I feel is worth such a hefty pricetag too honestly.
it's the 4 max out yet?
yes sir
Невероятно
Def a fail!! Go CS
Probably the locks of cold steel are strong , but their steels and materials are just cheap garbage materials
So how long till extrema ratio goes out of business? The sooner the better as far as I'm concerned.
It is a fail it broke end of story
i agree and im not a cs fan but they build tough as knives.
i seen other test the Rao is a piece of shit and try to stay away from extremaratio shitty company over price, reason i brought one of their fix blade $400 after i took the coating of the blade its full of perocity blubble on steels and they still let pass through production
***** yeah thats pretty shitty man. I know on the Chris Reeves knife that they tested all the comments where about the RAO and how they wont test it because it will beat their knives. Im not a huge fan but I will say coldsteel knives arent going to lose this test. Their knives are designed to pass this test others are not.
These tests are quite dumb. How often are we smacking the back of our blade that hard
Hahahaha 8:55-9:05 is my favorite part!! Great job, and the USA made 4max is a Daumn near indestructible, perfect knife and the craftsmanship is superb of course, it’s Coldsteel!! 👍👍
Taiwan made...
Please do a test of tri-ad lock vs. lionsteel "rotoblock" lock or whatever it's called. The tri-ad is the king of locks for sure, but the rotoblock lock looks ridiculously good too. Keep up the good work. I love these videos. Cold Steel for life!!
+DJHamburgla rotoblock closes fairly easy..lion steel makes good knives, love their thick blades and designs but sold my sr1 because the lock wouldnt hold..
well the rao is certainly not worth the price
cold steel is a copy from rao
Cold Steel why? Because is true?
How is it true? are you born dumb?
Dani marañon didnt demko make his custom 4max first?
Dani marañon which the cold steel is the production version