I like that these videos are not rehearsed, mistakes are made and then are corrected. So, it is more realistic than when presentation goes perfectly. It has more value for me.
At lastttt.. Thank you brother for this helpful video👍👍👍 been trying to make the spring works in the sw for weeks already... Watched many other tutorial videos but still couldn't do it.. Thank you very much.. God bless you🤲
Great tutorial! the only method I knew to make springs was creating a helix spiral feature and then sweeping. Using the "keep normal" sweep is so much easier! and allows that tension and compression motion. That's awesome! also Solidworks bugging out on a pro twice is so relatable. "Ok. Um. Thats... fine..." Is the most relatably thing I've heard when dealing with it, and I am a CSWA lol!!! Always awesome to learn more about such a powerful, albeit finnicky, program haha.
Thank you for this very helpful video. 25:56 Unfortunately, mechanism behaves as if spring is already in place, so your design is misleading. I believe the realistic version would account for the spring constant, so the spring would actually compress by real-time physics rather than by numerical boundaries from the moving shaft. I think this means you'd have to mate the spring onto the shaft first and set the spring compression boundaries if possible, before mating the cam and the shaft together. Will you please upload such a tutorial? So for future reference, please demo how to design according to the physics if possible. Would be super helpful for future engineers. Once again, thank you for all your help!
28:32 Also, your design assumes the spring is always in compression, which is fine if that's the case. In case it wasn't, then although the spring may stay coincident to a surface on one end, when the spring is relaxed then its other end may no longer be in contact with the other surface, rather than constantly staying 5 mm apart the way you had set it. 28:32
there is a problem with cam mate..... after selecting cam face and follower face its showing " the selected faces do not form a closed and continuous cam extruded from a single profile
Hi. Thank you for the video. It's great. Unfortunately i can not stretch the line in the spring in feature mode. I am using 2018 version. Would you please advise me?
thank you very much... that is really helpful. but I wanna something. does this mechanism have some function in real life or is it just for solid excersise
Can you do a consecutive motion animation going clock wise and anti- clock wise in sequence in the same motion study session?or do I need to do a separate motion study for each?
Everything I am trying as described but in last follower is not following cam in animation, before animation it's going with cam but in animation time it reaches beyond cam center
When i choose two points to define a relation , suppose i want two points in horizontal or i want to add tangential relation so after choose specific points i don't get the options of make it tangent or in some case to make it perpendicular or horizontal..i just get the fix option. It is happening in my every sketech. Can u help me solve my issue plz!!
Hello, it's because with helix tool, you have no control over length of spring. Here it does - how do you choose the height of the helix, is it fastened to the assembly? But with central line, yes it is.
Any tips for getting the spring to compress? My spring doesn't compress/expand at all during motion, do you know any other way to make the relations s.t. it does? Could I use mate relations instead of relations within the sketch of the spring middle line?
I ended up making 2 coincident relations within the spring-middle-line-sketch2, one coincident with the rod edge as in the video and another coincident relation between the other (right) end of the line and the edge of the standing piece (little wall, same edge line from the video used). The spring goes into the wall a little bit, but this is the only way its worked so far.
Hello. You'd better watch videos that separately shows the spring development and come back here already prepared for the task. Probably, you making some mistake.
I had the same issue and I am using SW 2020 Student Edition. I got it to work with no errors when I made the end points of the spring coincidental to the edges specified in the tutorial. So swap the distance of 2MM for the coincidental relationship to the edge of the base and your animation should work. I get that this comment was made 2 years ago but if someone is digging through the comments with the same question (like I was) this should help.
oye we necesitamos de tu ayuda mi amix y yo no podemos ensamblar ayuda, help me please socorro this is important anwear my comentary baby i love you video
I like that these videos are not rehearsed, mistakes are made and then are corrected. So, it is more realistic than when presentation goes perfectly. It has more value for me.
Wasted 7 years to study engineering and ended up unemployed for 7 years! Finally, i had the audacity to change my career. Don't regret it though
Thank you so much for this step by step tutorial sir!
Completed the entire model along with simulation.
One thing we liked about your tuts. is that you also provide 2D drawings with the lectures. :)
keep up the good work!
At lastttt.. Thank you brother for this helpful video👍👍👍 been trying to make the spring works in the sw for weeks already... Watched many other tutorial videos but still couldn't do it.. Thank you very much.. God bless you🤲
Great tutorial! the only method I knew to make springs was creating a helix spiral feature and then sweeping. Using the "keep normal" sweep is so much easier! and allows that tension and compression motion. That's awesome!
also Solidworks bugging out on a pro twice is so relatable. "Ok. Um. Thats... fine..." Is the most relatably thing I've heard when dealing with it, and I am a CSWA lol!!! Always awesome to learn more about such a powerful, albeit finnicky, program haha.
Thank you for this very helpful video.
25:56 Unfortunately, mechanism behaves as if spring is already in place, so your design is misleading. I believe the realistic version would account for the spring constant, so the spring would actually compress by real-time physics rather than by numerical boundaries from the moving shaft.
I think this means you'd have to mate the spring onto the shaft first and set the spring compression boundaries if possible, before mating the cam and the shaft together. Will you please upload such a tutorial?
So for future reference, please demo how to design according to the physics if possible. Would be super helpful for future engineers.
Once again, thank you for all your help!
28:32 Also, your design assumes the spring is always in compression, which is fine if that's the case. In case it wasn't, then although the spring may stay coincident to a surface on one end, when the spring is relaxed then its other end may no longer be in contact with the other surface, rather than constantly staying 5 mm apart the way you had set it. 28:32
Yeah. That isn't right.
Hi, my spring doesn't compress/expand at all during motion, do you know any other way to make this so it does?
Thanks for video
the flower Jumped during motion study only I mean manual motion is OK.
thank you so much... i always see your step by step tutorial ... very usefull
Thank you so much....Your video really gives me will to start drawing mechanisms for myself !! :):
Animation has problem with SW 2018. Why?
Привет из Белоруссии! Отличный урок и спасибо за видео!
Hello, author. Thanks for awesome lectures. When you chose fillet, there has been pop up with three options 3:30, but I have no the same. SW 19-20.
Oh, I got it now. You have to check the box "show selection toolbar" within the function window.
Thanks you for tutorial, the tutorial make me a new animation for soldiwroks
there is a problem with cam mate..... after selecting cam face and follower face its showing " the selected faces do not form a closed and continuous cam extruded from a single profile
how do you fix it?
Wish I could give this a couple more thumbs up, very helpful!!
Plz make motion study basic tutorial for beginners like me ..tool based explaination one by one.
I'm not sure if its just me but a lot of the 2D drawings are either over-dimensioned or are missing dimensions.
Kindly show how to animate the assembly. after assembly
You've got a shaking ceiling fan 😃
Hi. Thank you for the video. It's great. Unfortunately i can not stretch the line in the spring in feature mode. I am using 2018 version. Would you please advise me?
thank you very much... that is really helpful.
but I wanna something. does this mechanism have some function in real life or is it just for solid excersise
Same configuration of Cam & Follower was used in Combustion engines for opening and closing of Valves during Firing and Exaust Stage.
I did not see how you locked the spring behind the washer and stop at the opposite end so it could compress ?
27:30
Hi, my spring doesn't compress/expand at all during motion, do you know any other way to make this so it does?
@@darovame9372 Hi, my spring doesn't compress/expand at all during motion, do you know any other way to make this so it does?
Can you do a consecutive motion animation going clock wise and anti- clock wise in sequence in the same motion study session?or do I need to do a separate motion study for each?
Hi! Is this bug on 29:05 foxed in modern versions already?
And what's the difference with option ~make a detail flexible ?
Thanks
Please how you resolve the ressort problem?
Everything I am trying as described but in last follower is not following cam in animation, before animation it's going with cam but in animation time it reaches beyond cam center
Looks like spring is not compressing, it's expanding
What are the specs of your pc
At 25:52 while rotating cam folower fall down to minimum position and it doesn't follow cam profile path,just like as 32:02 .pz solve this problem
same issue for me. I presume SW bug. One way to solve is to use the face at the opposite side of the part.
@@FrancisJamPaperjam doesnt work
@@FrancisJamPaperjam correct.
Sir how to download solidwork sir plz tell by making a video plz
sur, i ahve question is this four bar mechanisim?
When i choose two points to define a relation , suppose i want two points in horizontal or i want to add tangential relation so after choose specific points i don't get the options of make it tangent or in some case to make it perpendicular or horizontal..i just get the fix option. It is happening in my every sketech. Can u help me solve my issue plz!!
Shaft is not following CAM as like 32:05 while animation even after saving. Please help
how the spring got compressed during animation
how to make oscillation motion sir..
Hello sir can we use dimax in solid works animation
Sir will you teach NX sir
me encanta tus videos
Отличный урок! Спасибо за видео.
Thanks for wonderful tutorial :)
Really nice tutorial
21:22 why it didn't work if I make spring through helix tool ?
Hello, it's because with helix tool, you have no control over length of spring. Here it does - how do you choose the height of the helix, is it fastened to the assembly? But with central line, yes it is.
Any tips for getting the spring to compress? My spring doesn't compress/expand at all during motion, do you know any other way to make the relations s.t. it does? Could I use mate relations instead of relations within the sketch of the spring middle line?
I ended up making 2 coincident relations within the spring-middle-line-sketch2, one coincident with the rod edge as in the video and another coincident relation between the other (right) end of the line and the edge of the standing piece (little wall, same edge line from the video used). The spring goes into the wall a little bit, but this is the only way its worked so far.
No matter what I did, I couldnt get the spring to compress :-( SW 2018
Hello. You'd better watch videos that separately shows the spring development and come back here already prepared for the task. Probably, you making some mistake.
I had the same issue and I am using SW 2020 Student Edition. I got it to work with no errors when I made the end points of the spring coincidental to the edges specified in the tutorial. So swap the distance of 2MM for the coincidental relationship to the edge of the base and your animation should work.
I get that this comment was made 2 years ago but if someone is digging through the comments with the same question (like I was) this should help.
@@marsbooker1391 Yes, we are in fact digging. Thank you! I'll try this now.
@@marsbooker1391 When you say end points of the spring, do you mean the endpoints on the spring-middle-line coincident with the specified edges?
@@marsbooker1391 Also, did you edit the coincident relationship through "mate" or through the sketch as done in the video?
wich solidwork version youre using 🤔
2016
Thank you very much.
Thanks ,👍
thank bro
Cool, thanks
非常感谢
Bravo
Tanx it is good.
Please provide 2d drawings also
He did. 0:42 10:40 14:57
Upload catia tutorials
oye we necesitamos de tu ayuda mi amix y yo no podemos ensamblar ayuda, help me please socorro this is important anwear my comentary baby i love you video
Crank
21:10
Speak english please...
what the fuck???you kidding?
This animation has problem with SW 2018. Why?