TOP "FINAL BATTLE" Reactions in Saving Private Ryan Movie | Movie Reaction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- Subscribe For More: / @cinema_reactions_hub
Best Reactions on Captain Miller and his squad together with Private Ryan's group defending the bridge in Ramelle in Saving Private Ryan Movie (1998) | Movie Reaction | First Time Watching
Action Movies Reactions: • ACTION MOVIES REACTIONS
The Lord of The Rings Movies Reactions: • Lord of The Rings Movi...
Star Wars Movies Reactions: • Star Wars Movies React...
Action Movies Reactions: • ACTION MOVIES REACTIONS
If any creator or movie reactor would like their content removed from our video, please contact us at tft10901@gmail.com, and we will promptly remove it. Thank you!
Video Credit goes to these channels, please make sure to subscribe to these channels for full reaction videos:
@camillascorner
@Whimsory
@PopcornInBed
@OfficialMediaKnights
@alexhefnerstvmovievault
@popcornroulettereactions
@NatalieGoldReacts
@maplenutsreact
@DosCavazos
#cinemareactionhub
#moviereaction
I worked on Saving Private Ryan and was on set for the filming of this whole scene. The single greatest experience of my life.
based as hell
@zackrodriguez6653 What does that even mean?
@@johnnailon588It’s a good thing lol
That’s awesome! Any stories?
Watched this movie when I was in the Army and in a theater full of GIs and I could feel the silence in the place in the opening scenes. Shocking realism.
My grand uncle was a WWII Army Ranger (same as Tom Hank’s outfit).He watched this with me when the DVD came out. The only thing he said afterward was the “chewing gum” scene was accurate-they had to live at that very basic level of existence…
"Oh Captain, My Captain. "
I’m a combat vet and can tell you this is similar in some ways but it’s a lot more chaotic in a fight like this.
One of the last commentators says it has to feel so good knowing that it meant something, that they lost so many men but held the bridge. It would be the exact opposite IMO. I think soldiers would tell you that if they lost a friend, not to mention several friends at that, they wouldn't feel good about anything. I'm sure they would go through life thinking how meaningless it was to lose so many over something like a bridge.
The lesson here is "don't release prisoners"
People seem confused about why the German soldier walks right by Upham, without killing him. It's because weird things like that just happen in war. Sometimes, a guy just doesn't kill another guy when he has a chance, even though he's done it a hundred times before. The same thing happens at the end of "Fury" - when a German soldier sees an American hiding under a tank, but just walks away instead of calling him out or shooting him. Things like that happen.
But that guy, who walks by Upham? Wasnt that the guy they released earlier?
No. the German in the hand to hand combat scene, who walked by Upham, was not the same guy they let go. The German they let go, though, was the same guy who shot Tom Hanks and was, in turn shot by Upham.
@@Jer-7007 I´ve to watch that scene again, becouse I could swear that was the same guy they released. I thought "that´s why he just past Upham becouse he recognized Upham and thus want to spare him". Guess I was wrong ..
No they're different guys - but they do look pretty similar. In fact, all the Germans in the movie look similar, with that same skinhead-type haircut. I think all the actors playing them were recruited from a British soccer team, if I remember right. That's actually one thing that the movie got wrong. Most German soldiers of the time had relatively long hair, actually. One popular hairstyle for them was kind of mod looking, with a longish mop of hair in front, but shaved close up the neck in back. Some of them kind of looked like members of a new-wave band, without their helmets on!
Google: German ww2 hairstyles for men and you'll see what I'm talking about. I think Spielberg was going for our modern idea of what a Nazi should look like, in the image of skinhead.
No. the German in the hand to hand combat scene, who walked by Upham, was not the same guy they let go. The German they let go, though, was the same guy who shot Tom Hanks and was, in turn shot by Upham.
The MediaKnights channel was cool to watch for this movie due to her speaking German and translating things us English speakers would otherwise be completely unaware of
Genuine reaction indeed...
Here's an example of my previous comment from a true story I've been told by a veteran I knew (which is featured in the history book "A Hundred Yards of War"). He was a sniper, in position with his platoon, to block a certain road during the Battle of the Bulge. When a huge German column came down the road, he had the enemy commander right in his sights. He could see the man's face clearly in the crosshairs of his telescopic scope. But for some reason (which he still can't explain) he just didn't pull the trigger. A battle ensued and the Germans won, despite heavy losses to them (this is a famous action, and I actually knew the guy, who lived in my neighborhood and signed my copy of the aforementioned book). Most of the Americans were killed and he was badly wounded. Afterwards, an enraged German soldier, checking the area, found him and was about to shoot him dead, when an enemy officer suddenly ordered the soldier not to kill the wounded - but to take them prisoner, instead. This officer was the very same German commander that my friend, Lyle Bouk, didn't shoot when he had the chance. The same officer who, in turn, saved my friend's own life. This is the strange way that things sometimes happen in war.
Probably the greatest war movie of all time.
R.I.P. Tom Sizemore. ✝️
Aside from the drama and emotion, the actual chaos, destruction, blood and guts is more realistic than most of the worlds population will ever understand or experience... and it was even more up close and personal for that generation!!
you are watching a movie and are shocked - think about what a soldier sees day after day after day.
Sadly. Even if the captain made it home, he would have lived the nightmares of the war. That is evident by his hand tremors.
The war was beginning to affect him.
One of them said, 'These guys are so skilled'.
Wonder if any of them have watched 'Band of Brothers', and realize that the Corporal who was in charge of Ryan introduced them as 'EASY COMPANY'.
Under Reserve, UCC 1-308
The realism of war is shocking. Gone ae the days of the Hollywood movies where the good guys always win.
They won but at a very high price. Brutally
They should do a reaction to black hawk down
The Captain getting killed by the man that let him go was deep @ a bit disturbing😔
Oops! In my previous comment, I miss-remembered the book I was talking about. It was "The Longest Winter", not "Fifty Yards of War" (which I read at about the same time, so I got confused). Anyway, any of you can read the aforementioned story in the correct book!
I more surprised that there people that haven't seen this movie😂😂
18 year old kids . No safe spaces .
empire of the sun reaction...enough said.
U should put the landing beach scene too
This was the Operation "Market gatden"
No it was not! This was just days after D Day! Market Garden was in September
This was operation overlord, market garden took place in the Netherlands
Upham is not a veteran like the others. Still you have to stand and do your job as a soldier, that's what his training was for. Got to say though, he kills the one they let go who killed his friend and then releases 5/6 others to go back and probably kill more Allies later on. So no sympathy, empathy whatever for him. Do your damn job or people die, simple. Not a veteran, it's just my armchair opinion.
You gotta remember not all of these kids were solders they were conscripted to fight in the war. Alot weren't there because they were part of the army and would not have had the years of training normal soldiers would have had so fear was a real thing here
@@Lizzie_3000 Agreed that not all of these Soldiers were there of their own free will due to the draft but that could be said of all of the Captain's men, yet they fulfilled their duties honorably and with distinction. Upham's problem was that he did not have the brotherhood that tied him into the rest of the squad. The training they are put through (as expedited as it was during that time) is what teaches you to form the bonds with those in the same situation. That sense of greater purpose and responsibility to protect the servicemembers to the left and right of you can give you the courage to overcome many situations that you would not have to fortitude to do otherwise. His inability to act in the moment as well as him only being able to pull the trigger when overcome by anger against an enemy that posed him no threat at the time is why I believe he is a coward. His character is expertly written though because in the beginning, he was eager and was willing to help but, in the end, as the writing showed, not everyone in war gets to be a hero.
@Marinebrother159 I agree with some of what you've said and I think Upham not having the field experience that the others did, did play a big factor in why he was inexperienced in combat and whilst I get why you feel he was a coward I think he was scared so bad he couldn't move and I think when he saw that nazi shoot the captain knowing the captain had spared him he really lost his innocence I don't think he did shoot the Nazi out of Anger I think he shot the Nazi because that battle changed him and his point of view, he lost his innocence so to speak, but I understand why you feel how you feel and I accept and respect your point of view I just see it a little differently
@@Lizzie_3000 You are absolutely correct at his loss of innocence. I don't believe Upham could have known Willie was the one who shot the Capt Miller, though. From his point of view, ~90 degrees to the side, you cannot precisely tell what someone is aiming at. A shift of 2 inches at the barrel means a target 30 yards to the left or right (I use my own experience in this having been on countless live fire ranges). The assumption I made of firing out of anger was anger towards himself. The Captain gave the order to free him but Upham was the one fighting vehemently on Willie's behalf to make the Captain intervene. Willie says in German "I know this soldier, I know this man......Upham" before being shot. It was this overfamiliarity I believe that caused him to cross the threshold into the darkness of war and lose his innocence. In my eyes, though, it was "too little, too late". I could have done a better job explaining it in my first comment so thank you for responding. Everyone sees things in this scene a little differently and I know I didn't catch half the things on my first viewing as I do now after my ump-teenth time seeing it. I rarely get to go in depth over this particular subject. Hope you have a wonderful day/evening😄
@Marinebrother159 I honestly thought Upham recognised Willie cos when Willie shoots the captain the camera cuts to Upham looking shocked but I understand you have experience that I don't so I defer to your experience on that and I do thank you for sharing your point of view and being respectful that mine might be slightly different, I find that refreshing on TH-cam lol. You have a wonderful day too 😊
That kid just did nothing while his mate got stabbed
Alright enough of that, for one it is clearly stated before Tom hanks character even left the beaches that Upham was not trained for actual combat, yes he did basic but he wasn't a vet or anything he was just a desk jockey that sat behind a desk and typed and most of the film he was a pack mule for the squad and translator and always was behind the front lines. People can relate to him because he was just a kid that had never seen combat or even was told to shoot a single round at another person he was terrorfied and succumbed by fear that's why he couldn't move and instead cried even after the German soldier stared down at him coming down the stairs it was like a wolf growling at a afraid sheep. But later killing him and letting the other POW's go was a bit shameless, that I didn't agree with.
I hated him so much
Cut him some slack. He wasn’t a combat veteran. Next to no training. He was scared.
@@davidcook680his actions caused his death. He wasn't a man. This is why we should not haven women in combat. Guy was basically a emotional lil girl.
Okay no one seems to really understand why white Oppam can do it because he was scared and here's the thing he now has lived with the guilt of knowing that he let one of his best friends die you're the worst thing you can have in your head is guilt especially killing someone CenturyLink someone that you letting someone die all right that's the thing about it people don't realize this fact that you you can't really do much when you're scared see a lot of people like to say oh I wouldn't do that yes he would you be just like him skirt scared shaking so badly that you been in the same situation as him here's the thing to see when your own fellow military buddies dying that's a guilt you just can't overcome that's a guilt that essentially haunts you to your grave cuz there's no worst enemy than your own guilt see you think I could've done something better but here's the truth about it you couldn't cuz you were scared and you couldn't do it and now you have to live with the consequences of that knowing that you allowed him to die cuz you could have done something and yet you didn't cuz you allowed that man to be killed that's that's why people don't understand that you would be scared if you were in a situation
Good life lesson, doesn't matter how good your team is, all it takes is one coward to ruin it all.
I couldn't watch some of these close combat scenes it's just too brutal
Poor Upham, I always felt sympathy for him.
I didn´t. I really dislike cowards.
For what? Completely failing when it mattered most?
@@StimParavane not his fault he was put in a situation he couldn't possibly handle, the first thing he said was he hadn't had any training or experience
Reading various replies in the comments about Upham, I too understand the frustration with his inaction, but I am also disheartened by the lack of empathy toward it. Even the most rigorously trained infantryman doesn't REALLY know how he will fare in combat until he experiences it first hand; Upham's experience is essentially the audience's. And on a personal note from this middle aged man: it has been my experience that those who are particularly hateful towards what they perceive as weakness and cowardice are weak cowards themselves, their fury being just a smokeshow distraction for what is lacking in themselves.
@@somedude7938 Nevertheless, this was an extreme case of cowardice when it really mattered.
10:39 oh my God it's like they're fighting a war
Hello my Indian friend, as always you are magnificent
7:34 does that big puff a hair block your thinking to think that he was probably scared or a coward
12:31 The vortex strikes me as how stupid selfish people are when they ask is Tom Hanks character dead no he's just sitting very still posing for a picture
More snowflakes sitting in comfortable chairs, watching other people doing dangerous things, and have the gall to complain about it.
So what ACTOR did the "dangerous" things?
@@Giunta_Media he was talking about upham like characters exist in real world and real wars. You cant just say ''do something!'' to people like upham while 1500 bullets flying above his head. Btw this is probably the most reallistic war movies i ever saw.
@@MustafaErtem It's certainly not like the films shown at the time that's for sure. Everyone thinks they will cope but really no-one knows until it's real life. I'm no military man, so I sometimes wonder who I would be, John Wayne or Upham.
Couldn't agree with you more, nobody should be saying nothing cause they would probably do the same real life combat is a lot different then that of the movies, cause people only have one life and its scary because people don't want to die so some crack quicker then most who are used to it. Whenever I saw anyone react to this or even make a comment on that scene I just shake my head at them, cause they think that they can judge what others do in the heat of battle when they themselves sitting in comfortable chairs without a care in the world.
10:15 oh my God they're fighting water like everyone's dying why can't they shot rainbows and butterflies out of there guns instead
Could you finally shut up ffs
I'm almost out none of these people have been shut up and just watch the movie and they assume the person the beginning of the movie is Tom Hanks and all I have to do is shut up and watch the movie they'll figure out who the guy in the beginning is so my point is the movie reactors shut up and watch the movie
I hate saving pravite ryan detele videos
I personally like this movie, it shows why there should be no more wars.
@cinema_reactions_hub people dies movie
Exactly why these types of movies need to exist, people lived shit like this
@andreagresser7848 get out my comment
Not sure why but reading this comment made me feel like i was doing something inappropriate lol, like reading someone's diary.
It’s a damn war movie, what did you idiots expect to happen
GOAT film
The U.S. foght the good guys smh
A lot of these reactions are so forced like at 5:25. Wow, shut up and watch the movie