國外聲樂老師對比 袁娅维 陈昊宇 林俊傑 尚雯婕《願與愁》Vocal Coach Comparison Reaction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2025
- Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili...
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on TH-cam: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia....
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #jjlin林俊傑 #jjlin #jjlin #tiaray #尚雯婕 #林俊傑 #陈昊宇 #袁娅维
I discovered JJ from this channel, and I really get to like his music a lot. Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts, as always. ❤
天啊！我的願與愁許願成真了 😍 好開心~ 下個願望就是看到老師和JJ本人合唱了 😆
橘老師的咬字好可愛xDD
I see JJ, I click
yay JJ!! 期待期待！！
JJ的歌曲永遠無人可以超越的❤❤❤
th-cam.com/video/u3ktw-zX-Vk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=v01SGTOPziIWfuEr
第34屆金曲獎頒獎典禮 -【林俊傑】表演節目『特別貢獻獎 林秋離 -聽海、哭砂、心痛、不為誰而作的歌』｜2023 GMA 34
一定要讓老師聽到這個!!!!
Yes! And also his 2018 MAMA performance in Hong Kong!
我也有重复看过好多遍呗，和他在台上献唱给Coco的❣🙏🏻✌🏻🤴🏻📀🎤🎼🥰👍🏻
JJ一上场，老师的表情马上😊❤😊❤😊
wow❤❤❤完美！
每次老师毫不掩饰她对JJ的喜爱的时候都特别可爱，而且特别的真实不做作❤
JJ 完全不同次元 ❤
橘老师估计很快学上中文了，中文歌唱得真不错！好感动这个节目一路走到现在，坚持初心，一定会产生更多共鸣。So proud of you guys to introduce Asian musics and cultures, while Rosette analyzes and explains it from a North American and Western perspective, and the collision of different perspectives creates fresh ideas and creative thoughts. Good job guys!
JJ粉簽 happy new year
Jj的影片出鏡率no1
我最喜欢的音乐人JJ❤
JJ!!! 💟😍
㊗️大家新年大快樂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
橘老師這件衣服超美，很適合美美的橘老師😊
橘老師唱中文歌很標準呢👍👍👍👍👍
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
JJ ❤❤❤
💜💜💜JJ
尚雯婕挑了一個極具未來感的風格，卻用著很古典的唱法，就好像搭著火箭去往外太空，但卻是50年前的火箭那種感覺
她骑着脚踏车去的😂🤣😂
粉丝会用“古典”来挽尊，但是只是因为橘老师比较委婉而已
老师看到JJ，那嘴笑得压不下去
他她的最爱❤
This is such a digression but I love your outfit Rozette! That pink coat with your pink lipstick! ❤
迷妹的笑容 😊
哇！！！！橘老师好棒啊！
JJ😍😍😍
Good song
渺小微肉像純愛漂流~
這是橘老師翻唱的第一首中文歌？
Where's your version of 願與愁? I definitely wanna hear how you react your singing!
You liked Singaporean singer-songwriters JJ and Stefanie..
you should listen to another really good Singaporean singer-songwriter... Tanya Chua!
She is really good and winner of multiple Golden Melody awards!
And Yellow covered one of her songs in Singer 2024!
I love the English version more. But this is also nice.
哇，最后最强合唱！
敲碗A-Lin《我等到花儿也谢了》
You will love this tribute to David Bowie, Prince, and George Michael. JJ sounds just like MJ when he performs.
th-cam.com/video/bqaF6beyn0w/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ltzhhlF9qsc-Fx27
The first pair is too incompatible. Sounds weird. These female singers are either opera singers or amateurs. That’s why people always say JJ’s songs are very difficult to sing, unless u have a certain standard of singing skills. Only JJ can sing his own songs well.
哇~ 我現在才知道，原來我會這麼愛尚雯婕的聲音是因為這種偏向古典，又不完全是古典....唱起來輕輕的但有力量🤔
這首我也特別喜歡她的改編版，讓我想到賽博龐克的畫風，聽完會反覆在腦海中迴盪
意外地看這支影片讓我發現我的愛好了!
其實尚雯婕的唱法不是古典唱法，但是她本身音色結合唱法造成很多人會覺得聽起來像美聲（雖然我自己不覺得像啦），我其實原本也不瞭解，只是單純喜歡聽她唱歌，覺得聲音很醇厚特別
@@WENfavourite 對，但還好這邊沒有吵得很兇，b站那有點……
@user-余小孟 主要是這個樂評人評價的方式很不禮貌、冒犯歌手，並且成功把“顫音用於流行樂”塑造成是錯誤的、老派的、需要改進的“缺點”，一而再再而三的如此操作，其實不意外今天會有不同的聲音湧現，大家也是忍很久了
LaLa終於要出現了嗎❤
Rozette should join the sister show!
尚雯婕のスタイルがすごく好きで、機械的な時代やサイバーパンクの雰囲気があると思うんです。でも、彼女の名前が出るたびに、いつも『ビブラート』に焦点が当たってしまうのが理解できません。もちろん、ビブラートが苦手な人もいるのはわかりますが、それでも彼女の独自のスタイルであり、曲の解釈方法なんです。これを尊重すべきではないでしょうか？正直言って、ビブラートばかり取り上げられて、彼女のアレンジや表現が無視されているのを見て、少し失望しています。
尚雯婕這裡的風格讓我想起中島美嘉Glamorous Sky
老師可以評聲生不息大灣區季的幾個女歌手嗎！！！！拜託了～ especially Joey Yung, Fiona Sit, and Janice Vidal are very worth watching!!! (TBH the girls team are all really good)
And BTW 陳昊宇（Tia’s pair）is an actress not a professional singer.
She debuted in a Taiwanese singing competition and won first place, but she was never trained professionally for singing. (The show’s goal was to find potential talents among normal people, so finding people who are already perfect or a star is not their goal) Haoyu herself admit that she doesn’t have great technique, she’s just lucky and has a pretty voice.
Fun fact: Laure got eliminated in the first season of Singer because of a super weird song selection system-basically, they used a spinning wheel to pick songs. She ended up with SHE’s Super Star, but even by the competition day, she still wasn’t happy with any version she came up with. After getting eliminated, she made a comeback performance with Dog Days Are Over. 🤣
What can be also interesting is that her earlier electronic music didn’t have the heavy operatic vocals she uses now. That said, I totally agree with prof Rozette-her current classical singing style kind of hides the more raw, human side of her voice.
I ❤JJ,不過婭維個人唱得部份我也很喜歡
我覺得橘子老師用顫音的研究（大眾喜歡中淺快）說明了尚雯婕的唱法屬小眾非主流的口味，確實不是很多人的菜。橘子老師沒辦法，但幕後的女工作人員卻也表達她對尚音樂衝突性的喜歡、敬佩和欣賞。所以人們各有喜好。當聽到別人公開表示他們不太能接受自己所喜歡的人事物時，一定會有不舒服的感覺。但世界就是這樣，不會所有人都喜歡自己喜歡的事物啊！重點是自己喜歡就好吧！我自己是很喜歡尚雯婕自己製作的電子音樂作品，喜歡那種未來感和前衛衝突。而她上各大音綜節目所唱的流行歌曲則是有些驚喜、有些感覺是為了節目安排而得把個人喜好放一旁而唱。
First duet, you are right, not the right pairing for this song. Became too noisy and literally butchered the song at some point.
尚雯婕 - I like the music arrangement but the vocals could not support what was done with the music
JJ - This was not the best vid of him doing this song but still wins the comparison hands down
reaction to marilag (live at the cozy cove) - dionela 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
More JJ Lin please
th-cam.com/video/T8PIc1e1aSQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=c182e6_KhfrlEHtc
第二首怨與愁真的被改的很難聽….不用什麼東西都要加上電子音樂好嗎
另外如果要放徐嘉瑩的現場 有沒有沒修音版的啊
我確實也欣賞不了第2个，可能年代不同吧，我其實挺喜歡古典的，只是這種結合太過極端太多就。。。
老師很喜歡齊豫 建議她聽一下齊豫的stories 她唱得非常好的英文歌
🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
有徐佳瑩❤🥰🥰🥰🥰
I hope you can react to more Sisters Who Make Waves videos-there are plenty of good vocal performances! 😊✌
很好奇為什麼張韶涵從來沒出現過？？？？
女性的華人天后能走進世界
唱英文歌的 我只認coco李玟
男生的林俊傑 周深 及其他
願老師多播放其他李玟的英文歌
Plsss reaction to marilag (live at the cozy cove) - dionela😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Please react to "ALL BY MYSELF by STELL "❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
reaction to marilag (live at the cozy cove) - dionela plsss😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
reaction to marilag (live at the cozy cove) - dionela okay
PLEASE REACT TO MARK MICHAEL GARCIA SINGING JAMES INGRAM MEDLEY ... ❤️❤️🙏
终于要反应徐佳莹了吗？
you have to cover this singer called 宋念宇 (小宇). His ad-lib runs are just insane for a Chinese singer. He writes his own songs, he sings well, and I just love his tone. Please cover him! It's a pity he isn't as popular and well known. Here is an example of him re-doing an already popular song in the Mandarin songs industry: th-cam.com/video/-TKjvSsYEd4/w-d-xo.html
請放過尚雯婕🙂
想看老師評艾薇🥹🙏🏻🙏🏻
Marilag by dionela from Philippines next please
可以請老師講評陳淑樺的歌聲和技巧嗎？
24:41 When Rozette sing Chinese she sounds little countryish... is it just me? A tiny bit 民谣
張敬軒去哪裏了？
尙雯婕的聲音讓我想起有位日本歌手中島美嘉，好想知道老師會怎麼看
完全不像诶，日本流行歌手很少古典，if anything，反而“过于”speech like
想推薦老師聽聽動力火車唱的天空 如果可以再聽聽MATZKA-一朵花 哈哈 許願許願!!
徐佳瑩 Great trying
The guy in the background is so out of touch. I watched several of your videos and every time you ask him a question, his standard reply will be "I'm not sure", "I don't know", "Let me check".
This! !
yea, so? he is also watching the vid first time with the lady, why is he supposed to know everything?
你应该让老师看看70-80年代的港曲了，什么叫神仙打架的时代，谭咏麟，张国荣，林子祥，陈慧娴，梅艳芳，陈百强，好多好多
她试过了，受不了早期的大颤音
很像沙拉布莱特曼唱电子舞曲
Why are you still reacting to Laure if you can't stand her style?? You're always pointing out the same things; why not just simply leave it?? Pleasee. This not only frustrates you but also fans of her's on such an incredibly high level, like seriously 😅😭😭
Why is every single video so much about vibrato? Isn't there anything else that s worth talking about?
It’s because vibrato is very important in affecting whether a song sounds nice n appealing to listeners. This is the basic that every singer should understand. So if u want your song to sound appealing n acceptable, u should learn how to control your vibrato. It’s the basic technique in singing.
yea, go ask your chemistry teacher why you talk about the periodic table all the time 😂🤣🤣
伍佰
th-cam.com/video/OP8xEim-OFw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=7lAgL0Yh6QfwqbiM
Why do you hate vibrato so much, but have to re a singer you hate over and over again？This is very rude and arrogant.
尚雯婕一直都是我很喜歡的歌手之一
但總覺得這頻道一直挖不到尚雯婕比較好的歌曲給老師聽
像在我是歌手裡的「最終信仰」、蒙面唱將裡的「Big Up」這些都是尚雯婕很經典的場面，但始終沒有出現在這個頻道，還是覺得有點小可惜
你推荐的那两首，尚在颤音的处理上有什么不一样吗？尚的问题不在于颤音大，而在于她不论什么歌都用一样的颤音方式去处理，林志炫，李克勤这种年纪大很多的歌手都在学习怎么modernize自己的唱法，橘子的颤音可大可小收放自如，Jkai的颤音够大了吧？他想收起来也能收一些起来，尚的粉丝还在那里洗地说尚的颤音就这样，改不了？
@dwmobusa 我有哪一個字
是在洗地尚的顫音就是這樣改不了?
我的意思是他的顫音配上他這兩首歌，就很適合
老師覺得不適合的點，最主要就是因為顫音跟他聽到的音樂不合。
那我覺得這兩首，配上尚的顫音就很棒，也可能因為這兩首就是尚自己的歌，所以比較搭配。
@@dwmobusa？ 橘子为什么一直追着尚雯婕的颤音不放呢？而且都是一直一直的re那些烂大街的翻唱，而不是去了解原创的电子乐？ 分明是玩针对呗~
橘子旧时光国外的淘汰品，到亚洲变成人人追捧的东西？
@@神奇嗨賴 我觉得尚雯婕的颤音很高级很好听，难听的是橘的颤音像吃屎一样难听😂
@@shiny330good 因为特征突出把特么其他的东西都盖下去了啊，所有人提到姚明不是都第一点提他的身高吗，你怎么不问为啥大家都提姚明的身高？问题是身高就是姚明最突出的一个特征，说他高不等于说他不好对不对？你喜欢高的就喜欢高的就是了，别人有自己的喜好就是喜欢袖珍型的，说一句姚明不是她的菜你跳什么跳？
同样的，尚自己颤得那么厉害，她自己的唱法造成的她所有的歌第一听感就是大颤音，把其他唱歌特色都盖住了啊，还不许人说了？
推薦華晨宇認證的魔王Rapper
(橘子老師可能也會覺得滿狂的演唱方式、演唱狀態，
敢無所畏懼地靠近吳青峰老師、李宇春老師演唱，提高舞台張力)：
th-cam.com/video/BTKO6kJ2a54/w-d-xo.htmlsi=nazYlGnU_A9ML1b5&t=5286
这位大妈，你在自己国家止步于36强的64强，在自己国内混不下去跑来霍霍华语乐坛，是几个意思啊，批个外国皮变老师了，对着一帮专业音乐人指指点点也配？ 😅 你自己国家才几千万人口呢，你都进不去36强，是怎么有脸在这点评中国的超女冠军的？😅
凭她随口就可以复制歌手的演唱技巧？西方歌手的平均演唱技巧，可不是大部分非科班出身的东方流行歌手可比拟
@@shihyuinchew8494 别跪舔了😅 jj和尚雯婕、哪个不比她专业牛逼？ 你自己在youtube搜一下 2005Canadian Idol rozette，看看她的实力多差、再看看尚雯婕超女时期的唱功，吊打她好吧？ rozette真这么厉害怎么不见她拿一个奖项啊？这么厉害没人找她合作啊？ 光靠骗骗你们这些崇洋媚外的东西获得的流量，还真以为自己是个东西了😅
怎麼都是這些人，可以做點別人嗎，蔡依林 張惠妹都好😮
不喜歡尚雯婕的唱法就不用一直一直一直re了，總是把顫音當作審美霸凌標的，惡意嘲弄模仿，這種行為真的蠻噁心的
P.S.會點進來看是因為這部影片標題帶了尚雯婕大名，只是搜尋尚雯婕就被推播到囉，點進來以為可以看到專業的樂評，結果依然只有“討厭顫音”的嘲諷
It’s a comparison in singing techniques. Not meant to criticise. U can never improve in your vocal if u cannot accept a professional’s advice. Don’t look at it in a negative way. If cannot accept Rozette’s opinion, don’t come in to her channel.
@@amyg1073If she dont like vibrato, why did she focus so much on Shang's singing reaction? Is that the only thing that she can critisize on? Hrmmm, why did she is not doing any reaction about Shang's original electronics music? This is so disgusting.
为什么会被称为“霸凌”😢外人觉得这位老师相当礼貌委婉，只是你们的粉丝心态放大了这种感觉而已，说白了就是……玻璃心了一点
这位橘自己唱歌就有颤音而且是很难听的颤音，还一直嘲尚雯婕的颤音真的很恶心，难道不是收钱黑尚吗？好恶心好low的人。她的颤音恶心尚的颤音好高级
@@lwilliam4990 如果她是第一次聽尚唱歌，我覺得她明確表達不喜歡完全沒有問題，尊重個人喜好；今天的問題在於她已經表達了不喜歡，卻還一直一直一直聽尚，並且每次聽每次嫌棄嘲諷，至少我只看到她成功地把“顫音使用於流行樂”這件事塑造成“不對的、需要改進的”缺點，引導大眾對於流行歌手使用顫音進行審判，這不就是一種“霸凌”的行為嗎？
看這聲樂老師re的反應不是很尊重個別音樂人，如果不喜歡可以不re。
JJ❤❤❤
reaction to marilag (live at the cozy cove) - dionela plsss😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
PLEASE REACT TO MARK MICHAEL GARCIA SINGING JAMES INGRAM MEDLEY ... ❤️❤️🙏
JJ❤❤❤