Sorry Scott. I very much hope the Yanks don't "get out of there quietly". To survive long term Russia must remove NATO. Showing the world their attrocities and war crimes very publicly, to educate the Global South.
America broke the world. All the mechanisms of justice have been pissed on and short circuited by America. One year later the ICC and ICJ and UN can not stop a genocide. Where would Russia go, half the world wants to arrest him? He can not go to the Haig now can he because they have a warrant out for his arrest.
The US was a good country, until the political class turned to the agenda of the WEF elites. The reason so many Western citizens support Israel is because of their experience with the Muslims that are being imported by Western globalist politicians.
Mick! Do not lose your faith in America! "We're the United States of America for God's sake, the most powerful nation in the history - not in the world, in the history of the world. The history of the world." President of America and the leader of the Free World Joe Biden (October 15, 2023) Enemies of The United States, sooner rather than later you will be dealt with by our all-mighty, invincible American heroes: Superman, Spider-Man, Batman, Captain America, Iron Man and Mighty Mouse . Not to mention John J. Rambo, Rocky Balboa, Chuck Norris, Jason Bourne, Ethan Hunt, his British apprentice - Bond... James Bond... and - last but not least - the first transatlantic Wonder Woman, admirable Admiral - Rachel L. Levine.
The US has the most (by orders of magnitude) military bases all over the world, has the largest navy (in tonnage, not in number of ships), controls the world's dominant reserve/trade currency, and has the largest satellite constellation. It's not about fascination and envy, it's about pragmatically dealing with the dominant superpower.
Before calling a referendum in Odessa, it is necessary to remove the Nazis. In 2014, demonstrations with huge Russian flags were held in Odessa. Then the Nazis came and burned down the House of trade Unions. This was done intentionally openly as a sign of intimidation. There are thousands of missing and tortured people of the Odessa underground after the coup.
I agree, if you look at the two central EU treaties (of 4) that amalgamate all previous EU and EEC treaties, their are entire sections on Nato membership. These treaties are the TEU (treatie of the economic union) and the TFEU (treatie of the functioning of the economic union). The economic union of Europe was always a CIA project. William Donovan (former head of the OSS) and his deputy Allen Dulles as the American committee for a united Europe funded the two central European organisations pushing for European integration the Action committee for a united States of Europe, and the precursor to the European movement with CIA money via the Rockafella and Ford foundations.
The Russian people want all this to stop but not if it means leaving Odessa to the US. It is a Russian city, the city of Catherine the Great. Turning it over to the US Navy would make the entire SMO a failure and destroy any hope of security of southern Russia.
It's not cool to say that, dude, they don't say that in Russia - "they'll come back with Odessa in their pocket," it's like we stole something and brought it in our pocket like a thief. This is not the case at all.
@@f.e.dzerzhinskythey've been literally grooming their leaders forever. Putin was in the game long before anyone ever heard of him as a political figure, I wouldn't really be so sure that they don't have several options at least
Sometimes Scott says stuff that I just think is dumb or self contradictory, and today is one of those days ... because you can't on the one hand claim you're going to get rid of the US policy of "the strategic defeat of Russia", and then on the other hand say you're going to get Russia to agree that NATO is at where NATO is at ... Scott, you know very well that NATO's very first leader was a Nazi rescued from facing justice at Nuremberg, and that it's entire purpose has been to attack Russia, so by arguing this case you're proving to the Russians that you are LYING when you claim that you're getting rid of policy of strategic defeat of Russia ... you further prove this by saying the USA should have any business in whether Odessa joins Russia, again, this is none of your business and proof that you are lying when you claim to be backing off from the strategic defeat of Russia .:: and then you openly admit the lie again moments later when you talk about a Russian collapse after the departure of Putin at which time you again state your intention to be in the best position to take advantage ... your whole position is 100% disingenuous and I do not trust you for a single second if this is your position, neither will the Russians
Yes, NATO has to be dealt with if Russia is going to have long term security. Sorry but if they are left they will rearm and try again, they have even said so publicly.
Thanks Andrei!!! At 32:00 the way you shut down Ritter when he goes macho. Perfect. I've been following him since 2003 and always hate it when goes to macho marine lecture expert mode. It actually hurts him and his credibility. So IMO this was a perfect "constructive feedback" from a true friend. Big fan Andrei - it's the honesty. Keep up the great work!
I agree. Scott gets mean and belligerent at a drop of hat. He's always mean to Nima on dialogue works. He acts like he knows everything about everything. Annoying!
@@WWStorm What do you know, delicate cupcake, nothing? He acts courageously, like he knows everything about almost everything, because he does know more than just about everybody in the U.S. of Sodom and Gomorrah. If you have anyone of note, that's better; let's set up a debate ASAP!
Scott is the point of the spear epiphany that the sheeple population desperately needs to understand and act on in order to recover their liberty. The irony of the necessary destruction of the United States of Sodom and Gomorrah for the survival of the true U.S. republic now depends on the entirely rational hegemony of BRICS Russia and China peace through development as the new beacon on the hill. Only Lyndon H. LaRouche was always correct!
Andrei definitely has more of a grasp on the situation between the west (US) and Russia than Ritter, and that's because Ritter loves to put on his 24 year old, marine exceptional American hat, when that train left the station a while back. But he is real good at finding scuds😊
American corruption and world wide endless murder and war is maddening so it's understandable. He is very dedicated and passionate but not "losing it". Don't mistake righteous anger and frustration and fatigue for "losing it".
Ukraine is a million miles from legitimately qualifying to join the EU. Illegitimately joining will collapse a bankrupt EU with Germany and France deindustrialised
NATO and the US must be shown that they have lost,and humiliatingly so.That is EXACTLY what they wished to do to Russia.Russia derserves her coming victory.It will be epochal.My own British ruling class and military have been despicable.
It's always been there. I got largely turned off on him when he got into his tiff with Carl Zha some time ago where he basically says the US doesn't lose and can destroy anyone we just choose not to.
As soon as the legal international casino that is the US economy collapses, the harder American "patriots" like Scott will get a healthy reality check. Slowly, too slowly, people are waking up to what the US really is, a military oligarchy masquerading as a beacon of democracy and freedom. America was never great to start with, they have to restart from scratch...
OK Scott, how about minding your own business; US is not the EU and is in no position to dictate terms and conditions with Russia and as far as a treaty goes, forget it because the US has a history of violating and cancelling any treaty. Russia needs to get rid of the US out of Ukraine and preferably out of Europe.
This is from the Cybernetics definitions: Subjects is that what producing actions toward Objects. In some sense, Subject is an Active element of system, Object is a Passive system element.
@@williamgianopulos636 , I remember that from my military academy lectures, Andrei, probably, as well... Yes, the cybernetics is not about computers, in its core (it was created even before first computers), it is about interactions between objects in a system and about messages/information they are transferring to collaborate/keep the system in the controlled/managed state. A lot of pure mathematics, actually...😉
Disagree with Ritter. Time to hold the USA to account. The USA has been doing this for 80 years and their deals are totally unreliable. Time to deal with them once and for all .
@@YangShaoqing778 You do realize that Russia has more nukes than the US and they have Hypersonic ICBM (Sumat) which has 0 which can't be countered, right? If anything, Russia can end the US and the collective west if they wanted to, the only reason why they haven't done it is because they aren't suicidal, unlike the people in Washington who are suicidal, thinking they can win and survive a Nuclear fallout.
The British media has tried to downplay that there's little regret or a desire to re-enter the EU. Sadly hardly anything changed in terms of divergence from EU policy, but the money that used to be given monthly to the EU has been indirectly rerouted in order to keep giving the EU some money. ... they stopped mentioning the EU in MSM because people might start asking questions about why the laws and policies were not fully implemented.... worse still they brought Farage in from the cold politically and are quietly working on him so he becomes the establishment and fully controlled.
Idk why Scott was caught off guard. There were signs that something was about to pop off in Syria. The night before it started, I even told my group chat I think Syria is about to ignite now that a cease fire is in Lebanon. That was because I paid close attention, to numerous channels and statements made by people over two months and the totality showed Syria was on the burner. Nobody could have predicted that Assad's government would fold in 12 days but the fact that Scott, a supposed "analyst" didn't see an HTS offensive coming, shows that he's not an "analyst" or at least very poor at his job.
Germany can go pastoral. Kind of ironic. Kaiser Wilhelm wanted to weaken Russia by going to war sooner rather than later because he was so fearful of Russian industrialization. That's why he kept egging on FJ to attack Serbia. World War One was also about weakening Russia. Russia Russia Russia always Russia!
Russia is undergoing a massive infrastructure programme. It needs man power and there would be plenty of work for Ukrainian people after the war is over. This would be a much better option for Ukrainians than joining the EU which is in terminal economic decline.
Really, well the US /Israel started this s.. t show in Ukraine, together with their vassal States the UK collective west, Russia never wanted this war, a war that should never have happened, they had a signed agreement, Negotiations between Russia and Ukraine, stopped the UK Boris Johnson, under the instructions of genocide Joe Biden, and now it's time the failing Empire of the US, their NATO puppets were held accountable, millions dead, wounded, they are not going to walk away as they did in the middle East, and given a short sharp lesson from Russia,
This war is not between Russia and Ukraine. It was arranged to provide an excuse for the Shock and Awe Sanctions to destroy Russia and steal the national resources
Я живу в Одесі і можу дати вам інформацію з перших рук. Багато одеситів страждають від стокгольмського синдрому. Bодночас переважна більшість одеситів і жителів південного сходу України все ще чекають на росіян. Ми просто хочемо, щоб вони пройшли через це місто і взяли його. Я щиро вірю, що опору буде дуже мало. На вулицях можна почути, як люди все ще говорять про боротьбу за виживання України, але здебільшого це просто плач, вимушений тим, що ми перебуваємо у воєнному стані, і все, що виходить за рамки офіційного наративу, може призвести до арешту. Ми тримаємо рота на замку і чекаємо, коли зачиниться кришка рояля.
The US and the whole of NATO should hope and pray that Putin can stay as Russian president for the longest time because Dmitry Medvedev has very little patience for Western nonsense and their illusion of grandeur.
They should do the math on how many ethnic russians from odesa were forced to die on the front lines and count them as russia votes because Odessa was might still be the city that had the most forced ethnic russian recruits.
I just love Andrei's humour and clear understanding of the absolute Corruption in USA. Refreshing to hear such truth..the yanks will scuttle off home as usual.
Three brilliant analysists Garland Nixon and Scott Ritter and Andrei martyanov love to hear the background history and indepth analysis of the whole situation over so many Conflicts
Andrei and Scott are both very intelligent they know their thing, despite different views. I am getting to like when they confort each other. THAT is real debate. It is always fascinating to listen to these giant minds, one American patriot and a true Russian heart and patriot. Always a threat when these big men confront. Thank you Garland for bringing both the same show. God bless you.
The Yankees Scott, you all speak as if the USA had nothing to do with the downward spiral of Europe USA trashed Europe, used it during the cold war, used it for NATO purposes and then pretend it's nothing to do with them 😢
Scott still looks at Russian politics through US eyes. Russia has lost military personnel and they have a totally different attitude to their veterans than the West. The Russians will not accept a deal that does not protect their interests, with no time limit.
@@arnoldsaunders6073 he knows. He’s playing dumb, to make the Russians more American like so the populace will side with Putin even if there is no deal made. He’s entire life is bought and paid for by RT, and Sputnik
i disagree with Mr. Ritter. ukraine must never be in Eu or nato. ukraine coming into Eu is just one step away to ne in nato, why? because if ukraine and Russia goes into conflict again, nato will be involved, most of the Eu countries are nato members. So ukraine never in EU or nato. NEVER.
I always thought Dmitry Medvedev was next in line to replace President Putin. Andrei hinted at this in this interview when he said that Medvedev already served as President and Prime Minister of Russia. Currently, Mevedev serves as deputy chairman of the Security Council of Russia which is involved in defense and national security matters.
Garland and Andrei; I have a distinct impression that Scott was disturbed by you both finding the suicidal Green Beret a matter for hilarity. I think he was about to share further thoughts on the matter but was drowned out by laughter and the sudden ending of the show. Just sayin'...
Scott will keep chiming in, he must be up to 10 interview's a day by now, and sometimes you have to chuckle it out, because what else can you do in the face of this H o r r o r show? Cast a vote for cackling k a m a l a or the d o n a l d?
I follow Scott since years, but here I have to disagree. I live in Europe, I don't want to see Adolf or Banderra again. And if an ef Country holds to this, this country must go completley or change in its core, beliefs. No more Banderra statue in Liew no more street Banderra street names, no more Fackelzüge in disguise of Nazi uniforms. This Europe had another history out of Banderras and Adolfs and it needs to come back in some sort of way to its past, not including Ukrainiens and Adolfs.
Thank you Garland, you're pod casts are very much appreciated, with knowledgeable guests in all areas, much needed, we love you for it,❤️ another great discussion, I just love Andrei Martyanov, his knowledge laced with wit, humour. Keep up the good work, Happy New year to you and yours, and to everyone watching.
Aw scot, you seem so devastated by your countries actions and you try to look for the good. I am a brit and am horrified by my own country, i empathize. There are many of us!
I can't agree with Andrei about Medvedev. But there will be another president who is probably a governor now. Putin will recommend him and it will be enough for him to win the elections.
If Medvedev was President in 2022 he would level whole Ukraine including civilian population of Ukraine .... something equal what USA have done in Iraq , and he would not tolerate any foreign interference ....
@@heimomoilanen9654 No, I don't think so. Russia is a multinational country. Not all are ready to accept a woman as a president. Also it's a very difficult job. It demands a lot of respect from people.
As very rarely, I disagree with you, Scott. Nothing you explain will be accepted by Russia. I think the best and quickest solution would be for me to hand him a long blank piece of paper signed at the bottom by Trump. It would be the only realistic way to deliver to his voters. The rest is pure fantasy.
Brilliant, thank my brother's, two real cold w a r r i o rs, Not of the chickenhawk variety, in the same place at the same time, courtesy of the beloved Garland.
I wish Andrei would stop slagging off us Brits,but I like him and can understand.Most Brits respect Russia ,it'd only our nasty ruling class who hates Russia.
I hope and wish you are right. Most of the Brit leadership makes Justin Trudeau look like Abraham Lincoln in comparison. Insecure twits who specialize in false flag, dirty trick operations and propaganda of outrageous proportions.
Все проще, убраться американцам на свою территорию и не лезть куда не нужно, американцы должны понимать что ракеты и до их территорий долетают и может случится все. сша привыкли лезть во все дыры, поверили в себя . А следующий Президент будет не меньше патриотом России
Happy New Year, I would like to have heard Scott Ritter be able to finish his comment at the end of the video about the Ukranian fanaticism of the 2 U.S soldiers who committed those despicable acts.
Scott is like a child, gets easily emotional and passive aggressive, then starts throwing his typical opinionated analysis everywhere all the time. This is why, although Scott is a good patriotic man, he rarely gets anything right. He always gets surprised after stuff happen.
It's understandable that americans still see their country as the big cheese. That has changed and Russia, China and India are now completely independant of US control.
You could defend Zelensky day 2 but not day 1002 after millions killed and injured and countless crimes against civilians committed. At the end we lost and not only Zelensky and now we are pretending that we are innocent and have some noble goals and not to dismember Russia anymore. We should negotiate security for Europe and Russia and get out from Ukraine's and Russia's border as far as possible. Russians and Ukrainians need truth and reconciliation in public so we can learn here in the US what our role in this war was.
Scott looks like he is not down with bashing US special forces. I wonder what would've happen if this podcast went on just for a couple minutes more ...
Sorry Scott. I very much hope the Yanks don't "get out of there quietly".
To survive long term Russia must remove NATO. Showing the world their attrocities and war crimes very publicly, to educate the Global South.
true Serbia is nato kryptonite when you speak about territory integrity and international law and their war crimes
Sorry Scott, Washington under Trump cannot agree to the removal of Banderite ideology simple because it is also the Washington ideology,.
Russia needs to seek damages from NATO nations as well. No free ride getting out of this one imo.
BESIDE-THEM-300-BILLION-STOLEN+interest-on-that!
Not just Russia, all of the nations that were bombed and invaded by NATO/US
Not happening. At best we can hope for a shakedown of the Banksters, everyone else is broke.
@@iRelevant.47.system.boycott I'm sure they will accept installments : )
America broke the world. All the mechanisms of justice have been pissed on and short circuited by America. One year later the ICC and ICJ and UN can not stop a genocide. Where would Russia go, half the world wants to arrest him? He can not go to the Haig now can he because they have a warrant out for his arrest.
The older I get the less I understand the world's fascination with the US and Israel.
As a child I thought both were enviable, but then I grew up.
they are depicable
The power of marketing and cultural imperialism.
The US was a good country, until the political class turned to the agenda of the WEF elites. The reason so many Western citizens support Israel is because of their experience with the Muslims that are being imported by Western globalist politicians.
Mick! Do not lose your faith in America!
"We're the United States of America for God's sake, the most powerful nation in the history - not in the world, in the history of the world. The history of the world."
President of America and the leader of the Free World Joe Biden (October 15, 2023)
Enemies of The United States, sooner rather than later you will be dealt with by our all-mighty, invincible American heroes:
Superman, Spider-Man, Batman, Captain America, Iron Man and Mighty Mouse .
Not to mention John J. Rambo, Rocky Balboa, Chuck Norris, Jason Bourne, Ethan Hunt, his British apprentice - Bond... James Bond... and - last but not least - the first transatlantic Wonder Woman, admirable Admiral - Rachel L. Levine.
The US has the most (by orders of magnitude) military bases all over the world, has the largest navy (in tonnage, not in number of ships), controls the world's dominant reserve/trade currency, and has the largest satellite constellation. It's not about fascination and envy, it's about pragmatically dealing with the dominant superpower.
To let the people of Odessa choose if they want to be part of Russia is a very good idea.
They would be stupid not to choose Russia.
Before calling a referendum in Odessa, it is necessary to remove the Nazis. In 2014, demonstrations with huge Russian flags were held in Odessa. Then the Nazis came and burned down the House of trade Unions. This was done intentionally openly as a sign of intimidation. There are thousands of missing and tortured people of the Odessa underground after the coup.
Russia was ok to have Ukraine join the EU in the past. But Russia has to be crazy to agree to Ukraine joining the EU after the war.
Yes
EU = NATO. NO EU FOR UKRAINE.
Sorry , NO DEAL Scott.
Cheers from Australia
& russia is not crazy any more, hence no eu or anything for ukrine
I agree, if you look at the two central EU treaties (of 4) that amalgamate all previous EU and EEC treaties, their are entire sections on Nato membership. These treaties are the TEU (treatie of the economic union) and the TFEU (treatie of the functioning of the economic union). The economic union of Europe was always a CIA project. William Donovan (former head of the OSS) and his deputy Allen Dulles as the American committee for a united Europe funded the two central European organisations pushing for European integration the Action committee for a united States of Europe, and the precursor to the European movement with CIA money via the Rockafella and Ford foundations.
Fascinating, thank you. @@regsmith5972
Russia can’t go home without Odessa in its pocket
The Russian people want all this to stop but not if it means leaving Odessa to the US. It is a Russian city, the city of Catherine the Great. Turning it over to the US Navy would make the entire SMO a failure and destroy any hope of security of southern Russia.
Like the way you Said it
Odessa is Russia
Scott is delusional on the level of America's power
It's not cool to say that, dude, they don't say that in Russia - "they'll come back with Odessa in their pocket," it's like we stole something and brought it in our pocket like a thief. This is not the case at all.
Scott is delusional if he thinks Russia is gonna accept that... the West's word is worthless, so why would Russia/Putin be bound ?
Even Scott Ritter is no exception to American exceptionalism.
He was a foot soldier for US Imperialism for most of his life.
That's why he keeps believing in voting and US Institutions. Lol.
I have stopped listening to him lately. Simply can't stand him anymore.
@@rashmigupta9 same here. There are many of us and it is growing
What makes you say that?
You cupcakes have lost the moral fitness to survive if you attack the truth of what Scott has to say to save this republic!
What Trump does or doesn't do is largely irrelevant: Russia is dealing the cards here.
Yes.
Thank you, Scott, Andrei, and Garland. You men have been tested in the cauldron and proven to be gold. I wish you all a very happy new year!
'Huh ?!? Did you even watch the video ?!?
@@Shryce You thirty pieces of silver agenda sheeple enjoy being fleeced and dragging others with you!
hahahaha Russia doesn't have a plan for when Putin is gone?????????? WRONG!!!! Ukraine in EU???? WRONG again!!!!
Soon there will be no EU especially after Romanian desaster
they mean west has no plan, besides being neo cone & that arnt working any more, so they are domed
I don't think they do, beyond the technical aspects. These are some pretty big shoes to fill.
A Russian Blinken?
@@f.e.dzerzhinskythey've been literally grooming their leaders forever. Putin was in the game long before anyone ever heard of him as a political figure, I wouldn't really be so sure that they don't have several options at least
IMPOSSIBLE IMPOSSIBLE IMPOSSIBLE for America to pull out a victory in Ukraine. The sooner we get out, the better
and face a War Crimes Tribunal!
Scott, blink twice if you are being blackmailed😢
Andrei is correct,imho.
Sometimes Scott says stuff that I just think is dumb or self contradictory, and today is one of those days ... because you can't on the one hand claim you're going to get rid of the US policy of "the strategic defeat of Russia", and then on the other hand say you're going to get Russia to agree that NATO is at where NATO is at ... Scott, you know very well that NATO's very first leader was a Nazi rescued from facing justice at Nuremberg, and that it's entire purpose has been to attack Russia, so by arguing this case you're proving to the Russians that you are LYING when you claim that you're getting rid of policy of strategic defeat of Russia ... you further prove this by saying the USA should have any business in whether Odessa joins Russia, again, this is none of your business and proof that you are lying when you claim to be backing off from the strategic defeat of Russia .:: and then you openly admit the lie again moments later when you talk about a Russian collapse after the departure of Putin at which time you again state your intention to be in the best position to take advantage ... your whole position is 100% disingenuous and I do not trust you for a single second if this is your position, neither will the Russians
He was conducting a narrative exercise playing the devil's advocate
Yes, NATO has to be dealt with if Russia is going to have long term security. Sorry but if they are left they will rearm and try again, they have even said so publicly.
Возможно, он имел в виду сохранение НАТО как сдерживающей силы - т.е. возвращение к статус-кво холодной войны
Thanks Andrei!!! At 32:00 the way you shut down Ritter when he goes macho. Perfect. I've been following him since 2003 and always hate it when goes to macho marine lecture expert mode. It actually hurts him and his credibility. So IMO this was a perfect "constructive feedback" from a true friend. Big fan Andrei - it's the honesty. Keep up the great work!
I agree. Scott gets mean and belligerent at a drop of hat. He's always mean to Nima on dialogue works. He acts like he knows everything about everything. Annoying!
@@WWStorm What do you know, delicate cupcake, nothing? He acts courageously, like he knows everything about almost everything, because he does know more than just about everybody in the U.S. of Sodom and Gomorrah. If you have anyone of note, that's better; let's set up a debate ASAP!
Scott is the point of the spear epiphany that the sheeple population desperately needs to understand and act on in order to recover their liberty. The irony of the necessary destruction of the United States of Sodom and Gomorrah for the survival of the true U.S. republic now depends on the entirely rational hegemony of BRICS Russia and China peace through development as the new beacon on the hill. Only Lyndon H. LaRouche was always correct!
@@WWStormwell Nima can be sort of a dullard 😂
Agree. Scott needs to lose the US marine style bluster - it’s lost it’s shine/credibility.
Andrei definitely has more of a grasp on the situation between the west (US) and Russia than Ritter, and that's because Ritter loves to put on his 24 year old, marine exceptional American hat, when that train left the station a while back. But he is real good at finding scuds😊
Scott is losing it.
It seems the multiplicity of evil machinations of his beloved America has overwhelmed his capacity to process with rationality.
wtf are you talking about?
hegemonic violence and lies are still powerful...corporations of america murder Americans!🙄....how is mr ritter wrong?...your explanation please...
American corruption and world wide endless murder and war is maddening so it's understandable. He is very dedicated and passionate but not "losing it". Don't mistake righteous anger and frustration and fatigue for "losing it".
U poor delicate flower!
Anybody else noticed a softer stance of scott towards Israel and the usa after the FBI visit to his house?
He also has changed his stance on Iran. All of a sudden it will be a simple bombing of Iran's nuclear sites that would be game over for Iran.
He's doing a job interview... Scott somehow wants to be part of trumps regime.
UKRAINE SHOULDN'T BE ALLOW EU MEMBERSHIP
The curruptocracy decides
Ukraine is a million miles from legitimately qualifying to join the EU.
Illegitimately joining will collapse a bankrupt EU with Germany and France deindustrialised
NATO and the US must be shown that they have lost,and humiliatingly so.That is EXACTLY what they wished to do to Russia.Russia derserves her coming victory.It will be epochal.My own British ruling class and military have been despicable.
And even more so... the EU has to be forced to recognize they are a force of evil and not a union for the betterment of its people.
Martyanov, super!
Get into your problems, Scott! And don't get into ours with your American snout!
Omg I used to respect Scott but his American exceptionalism has polluted his mind!
It's always been there. I got largely turned off on him when he got into his tiff with Carl Zha some time ago where he basically says the US doesn't lose and can destroy anyone we just choose not to.
@@goodplenty534I remember that and Carl wasn’t backing down at all. Scott showed his ass that time and it was embarrassing!
It's disgusting to behold, but yeah.. his I don't care attitude took over in this video... he's been trumpified.
As soon as the legal international casino that is the US economy collapses, the harder American "patriots" like Scott will get a healthy reality check.
Slowly, too slowly, people are waking up to what the US really is, a military oligarchy masquerading as a beacon of democracy and freedom.
America was never great to start with, they have to restart from scratch...
Normalizing relations with IsCruel is like asking Hannibal Lector over for supper
😂😂
With a bottle of Chianti wine also
OK Scott, how about minding your own business; US is not the EU and is in no position to dictate terms and conditions with Russia and as far as a treaty goes, forget it because the US has a history of violating and cancelling any treaty. Russia needs to get rid of the US out of Ukraine and preferably out of Europe.
Cold hard logic would seem to suggest you are broadly seeing how it will be.
Scott is turning full on American Exceptionalism... it's like he's applying for a job under trump... it's disgusting to see.
Love Andrei 's quote--Germany is an object-not a subject. Brilliant.
This is from the Cybernetics definitions: Subjects is that what producing actions toward Objects. In some sense, Subject is an Active element of system, Object is a Passive system element.
@maksimluzin1121 Thank you for the grammar lesson.
@@williamgianopulos636 , I remember that from my military academy lectures, Andrei, probably, as well... Yes, the cybernetics is not about computers, in its core (it was created even before first computers), it is about interactions between objects in a system and about messages/information they are transferring to collaborate/keep the system in the controlled/managed state. A lot of pure mathematics, actually...😉
Disagree with Ritter. Time to hold the USA to account. The USA has been doing this for 80 years and their deals are totally unreliable. Time to deal with them once and for all .
I think you greatly underestimate how powerful the United States is in reality.
@@YangShaoqing778We all saw how powerful they are in Ukraine. Not impressed to say the least.
Something like that, yes.
Scott is arguing like the USA should stay the predator terrorist country that it is.. not a strong argument.
@@YangShaoqing778 You do realize that Russia has more nukes than the US and they have Hypersonic ICBM (Sumat) which has 0 which can't be countered, right? If anything, Russia can end the US and the collective west if they wanted to, the only reason why they haven't done it is because they aren't suicidal, unlike the people in Washington who are suicidal, thinking they can win and survive a Nuclear fallout.
Garland only has 76.5K subscribers? TH-cam suppression much wow - Guy is a legend!
Я из Новосибирска. Сначала хотела возмутиться и защитить город, но стоит признать, что есть немалая доля правды в том, что было сказано
We Brits,myself included voted out of the EU,and I now have not the slightest regret.
The British media has tried to downplay that there's little regret or a desire to re-enter the EU. Sadly hardly anything changed in terms of divergence from EU policy, but the money that used to be given monthly to the EU has been indirectly rerouted in order to keep giving the EU some money.
... they stopped mentioning the EU in MSM because people might start asking questions about why the laws and policies were not fully implemented.... worse still they brought Farage in from the cold politically and are quietly working on him so he becomes the establishment and fully controlled.
Scott has been sitting on a beehive ever since he was caught off guard and surprised after Syria fell. Been grumpy, defensive, contrary and soured.
Idk why Scott was caught off guard. There were signs that something was about to pop off in Syria. The night before it started, I even told my group chat I think Syria is about to ignite now that a cease fire is in Lebanon. That was because I paid close attention, to numerous channels and statements made by people over two months and the totality showed Syria was on the burner. Nobody could have predicted that Assad's government would fold in 12 days but the fact that Scott, a supposed "analyst" didn't see an HTS offensive coming, shows that he's not an "analyst" or at least very poor at his job.
Germany can go pastoral. Kind of ironic. Kaiser Wilhelm wanted to weaken Russia by going to war sooner rather than later because he was so fearful of Russian industrialization. That's why he kept egging on FJ to attack Serbia. World War One was also about weakening Russia. Russia Russia Russia always Russia!
EU membership entails total subservience and loss of sovereignty, total obedience to the unelected commission.
Yes.
Come on. I would recommend to Trump to get out of Ukraine and let Russia and Ukraine to work out.
Russia is undergoing a massive infrastructure programme. It needs man power and there would be plenty of work for Ukrainian people after the war is over. This would be a much better option for Ukrainians than joining the EU which is in terminal economic decline.
Really, well the US /Israel started this s.. t show in Ukraine, together with their vassal States the UK collective west, Russia never wanted this war, a war that should never have happened, they had a signed agreement, Negotiations between Russia and Ukraine, stopped the UK Boris Johnson, under the instructions of genocide Joe Biden, and now it's time the failing Empire of the US, their NATO puppets were held accountable, millions dead, wounded, they are not going to walk away as they did in the middle East, and given a short sharp lesson from Russia,
This war is not between Russia and Ukraine. It was arranged to provide an excuse for the Shock and Awe Sanctions to destroy Russia and steal the national resources
Я живу в Одесі і можу дати вам інформацію з перших рук.
Багато одеситів страждають від стокгольмського синдрому. Bодночас переважна більшість одеситів і жителів південного сходу України все ще чекають на росіян. Ми просто хочемо, щоб вони пройшли через це місто і взяли його. Я щиро вірю, що опору буде дуже мало. На вулицях можна почути, як люди все ще говорять про боротьбу за виживання України, але здебільшого це просто плач, вимушений тим, що ми перебуваємо у воєнному стані, і все, що виходить за рамки офіційного наративу, може призвести до арешту.
Ми тримаємо рота на замку і чекаємо, коли зачиниться кришка рояля.
This war is not between Russia and Ukraine.
It was an excuse for the Shock and Awe Sanctions intended to destroy Russia and return to the 90's
There will be personal vendettas after this war not directed at nations but at individuals
Scott either doesn't get it or refuses to see it
As well there should be... it's called accountability.
But I doubt it will happen... the bad guys will get away with it because they are powerfull.
What scott said is totally bs
Everything he says is bs
If not for America, very little world wide military spending would be necessary. ❤ Russian soldiers ❤ Russia ❤ Putin ❤️ BRICS ❤ HUMANITY ❤ God
уважаемый Скотт, когда США держали своё слово и когда им мешало что-то нарушить свои же договорённости? мы не можем верить вашим президентам
Andrei is spot on about so called German engineering excellence.
Andrei, please do not interrupt Scott!
was gonna comment the same
SCOTT YOU ARE WRONG ABOUT UKRANIAN EU MEMBERSHIP
Although, to be fair, I'll be surprised if the EU and Nato remain in place for long.
The US and the whole of NATO should hope and pray that Putin can stay as Russian president for the longest time because Dmitry Medvedev has very little patience for Western nonsense and their illusion of grandeur.
They should do the math on how many ethnic russians from odesa were forced to die on the front lines and count them as russia votes because Odessa was might still be the city that had the most forced ethnic russian recruits.
Scott has a U.S military mindset. Believe they can do whatever they want around the world and dont get punished for the war Crimes
You must be new to Scott. Keep following
That's what he's arguing for yeah... American exceptionalism... proving he's just part of the problem.
I just love Andrei's humour and clear understanding of the absolute Corruption in USA. Refreshing to hear such truth..the yanks will scuttle off home as usual.
General Breakfast Cereal, Kellogg, is a joke
Report to Captain Crunch immediately Count Chocula 😂
Three brilliant analysists Garland Nixon and Scott Ritter and Andrei martyanov love to hear the background history and indepth analysis of the whole situation over so many Conflicts
Ukraine joining the EU should be of the table, the EU has become an arm of NATO.
Scott is really campaigning to be on that Trump cabinet...
Glory To The Russian Soldiers And Russian People ❤️🇷🇺🐻🌍🤠🇨🇦❤️
Скотт прекратите рассказывать сплетни которые до вас доходят от ваших друзей в России, Новосибирск не против Путина
Great stuff as always. Thanks for the updates. Peace and love
Andrei and Scott are both very intelligent they know their thing, despite different views.
I am getting to like when they confort each other. THAT is real debate. It is always fascinating to listen to these giant minds, one American patriot and a true Russian heart and patriot. Always a threat when these big men confront.
Thank you Garland for bringing both the same show.
God bless you.
The Yankees Scott, you all speak as if the USA had nothing to do with the downward spiral of Europe
USA trashed Europe, used it during the cold war, used it for NATO purposes and then pretend it's nothing to do with them 😢
Like what Europe did to everyone else?
With respect to you, Garland, I love your show but less Scott more Andrei.
Scott IS geting Out of touch.
Sputnik pays his bills. He’s admitted to this. He can’t and will not say a single word against Russia.
No, he is still indoctrinated. Patience, he is working on it.
Scott still looks at Russian politics through US eyes. Russia has lost military personnel and they have a totally different attitude to their veterans than the West. The Russians will not accept a deal that does not protect their interests, with no time limit.
@@arnoldsaunders6073 he knows. He’s playing dumb, to make the Russians more American like so the populace will side with Putin even if there is no deal made. He’s entire life is bought and paid for by RT, and Sputnik
Thank you Andrei and Scott
Thank you Mr Nixon great show keep up the good work
Good job Mr Nixon. Bringing those two together is always a highlight!
i disagree with Mr. Ritter. ukraine must never be in Eu or nato. ukraine coming into Eu is just one step away to ne in nato, why? because if ukraine and Russia goes into conflict again, nato will be involved, most of the Eu countries are nato members. So ukraine never in EU or nato. NEVER.
The reason: The West are treacherous LIARS.
I always thought Dmitry Medvedev was next in line to replace President Putin. Andrei hinted at this in this interview when he said that Medvedev already served as President and Prime Minister of Russia. Currently, Mevedev serves as deputy chairman of the Security Council of Russia which is involved in defense and national security matters.
Reading Medvedevs tweets (X's ?) I feel Medvedev is Putins little joker who says all the naughty things that are true, but statesmen can't say.
@@Shrycehe's "bad cop" to Putin's "good cop".
I imagine most Russians agree with Medvedev.
@@mik569 Yeah.. that's kind of what I was hinting at too.. the joker who can say anything Putin can't.
Garland and Andrei; I have a distinct impression that Scott was disturbed by you both finding the suicidal Green Beret a matter for hilarity. I think he was about to share further thoughts on the matter but was drowned out by laughter and the sudden ending of the show. Just sayin'...
Scott will keep chiming in, he must be up to 10 interview's a day by now, and sometimes you have to chuckle it out, because what else can you do in the face of this
H o r r o r show?
Cast a vote for cackling
k a m a l a or the d o n a l d?
Garland needs to realize that Elon, Vivek, and Israel are the real boss in the US!
Thanks andrie and Scott for bringing us this great content once again God bless you both stay safe and well
Garland and Andrei- great backing duo!Lol!
What happened to Scott and what is wrong with him? 🤦♂️
Maybe this is a cloned version of him.
Meddling into the Russian politics is a bad idea for Ritter. It's not his business.
He gave an analyst's opinion... thats it
I follow Scott since years, but here I have to disagree.
I live in Europe, I don't want to see Adolf or Banderra again. And if an ef Country holds to this, this country must go completley or change in its core, beliefs.
No more Banderra statue in Liew no more street Banderra street names, no more Fackelzüge in disguise of Nazi uniforms.
This Europe had another history out of Banderras and Adolfs and it needs to come back in some sort of way to its past, not including Ukrainiens and Adolfs.
Thank you Garland, you're pod casts are very much appreciated, with knowledgeable guests in all areas, much needed, we love you for it,❤️ another great discussion, I just love Andrei Martyanov, his knowledge laced with wit, humour. Keep up the good work, Happy New year to you and yours, and to everyone watching.
US "allies and friends"?!?!? That would be hilarious if it weren't so utterly tragic.
I cannot listen to Scott anymore after listening to him for over 20 years
Great interview, great guests, and great host. Thank you, and Happy New Year to all. This was a real treat...
Andrei and Scott are the Kings!
Aw scot, you seem so devastated by your countries actions and you try to look for the good. I am a brit and am horrified by my own country, i empathize. There are many of us!
Lol
Love how Scott still believes Treaties that America signs matter.
Scott, pesos are in México; in Spain we had "Pesetas" 😇
I can't agree with Andrei about Medvedev. But there will be another president who is probably a governor now. Putin will recommend him and it will be enough for him to win the elections.
If Medvedev was President in 2022 he would level whole Ukraine including civilian population of Ukraine .... something equal what USA have done in Iraq , and he would not tolerate any foreign interference ....
Maria Zakharova will follow Sergey Lavrov when he leaves.
She would be a good president too, for me at least.
@@heimomoilanen9654Nope. She's just a good speaker, not leader materiel.
@@heimomoilanen9654 Noooooo
@@heimomoilanen9654 No, I don't think so. Russia is a multinational country. Not all are ready to accept a woman as a president. Also it's a very difficult job. It demands a lot of respect from people.
As very rarely, I disagree with you, Scott. Nothing you explain will be accepted by Russia. I think the best and quickest solution would be for me to hand him a long blank piece of paper signed at the bottom by Trump. It would be the only realistic way to deliver to his voters. The rest is pure fantasy.
Brilliant, thank my brother's, two real cold
w a r r i o rs,
Not of the chickenhawk variety, in the same place at the same time, courtesy of the beloved Garland.
I wish Andrei would stop slagging off us Brits,but I like him and can understand.Most Brits respect Russia ,it'd only our nasty ruling class who hates Russia.
“ chihauwas “…..😂
I hope and wish you are right. Most of the Brit leadership makes Justin Trudeau look like Abraham Lincoln in comparison. Insecure twits who specialize in false flag, dirty trick operations and propaganda of outrageous proportions.
Then do something about your ruling class
Все проще, убраться американцам на свою территорию и не лезть куда не нужно, американцы должны понимать что ракеты и до их территорий долетают и может случится все. сша привыкли лезть во все дыры, поверили в себя . А следующий Президент будет не меньше патриотом России
Happy New Year, I would like to have heard Scott Ritter be able to finish his comment at the end of the video about the Ukranian fanaticism of the 2 U.S soldiers who committed those despicable acts.
Agreed. I commented about that immediately at the end of the show. Scott definitely had something on his mind.
Godbless these gentleman for your ins nights often brought with humor - from South Africa
Great show tonight Garland.
FROM EUROPE NO MORE WAR SPEND THE MONEY ON THE WELLBEING OF COMMON SENSE
OKAAAY!!
Three of my favourite commentators. Thanks guys.
Finally! Scott and Andrei expressing their differences in each other's presence!! More!
You rock Garland!
Thank you ❤❤❤
Negotiating with the US is an exercise in futility. Russia can't trust them today any more than native Americans could in the 19th century
Забавно слушать разные акценты американского)))
WTF is happening to Scott Ritter?
Scott is like a child, gets easily emotional and passive aggressive, then starts throwing his typical opinionated analysis everywhere all the time. This is why, although Scott is a good patriotic man, he rarely gets anything right. He always gets surprised after stuff happen.
i stopped ritter ages ago...
It's understandable that americans still see their country as the big cheese. That has changed and Russia, China and India are now completely independant of US control.
... 15:56 ... LET SCOTT CONTINUE ... GARLAND ...
Very hard for anyone else to get a word in…..
Great show! Super informative.
You could defend Zelensky day 2 but not day 1002 after millions killed and injured and countless crimes against civilians committed. At the end we lost and not only Zelensky and now we are pretending that we are innocent and have some noble goals and not to dismember Russia anymore. We should negotiate security for Europe and Russia and get out from Ukraine's and Russia's border as far as possible. Russians and Ukrainians need truth and reconciliation in public so we can learn here in the US what our role in this war was.
Scott looks like he is not down with bashing US special forces. I wonder what would've happen if this podcast went on just for a couple minutes more ...
Yes, I thought so too. He’s got a face like a baby’s smacked arse😂
Mr. Ritter doesnt look very interested in the conversation unless he is talking. But thank you anyway for participation
#NoNATO
Scott Ritter has lost all of my respect.