@@dpg957 So, everything about the South and our culture is all reduced to slavery? That is what you call ideological fanaticism that dates back to the original Abolitionists who ran out Southerners who opposed slavery in the 1830's. And there were more Southern abolitionist societies at the time than Northern ones. As historian H.W. Brands has correctly observed, the Abolitionists, i.e. the Northeastern fanatical variety, gave the South no where else to go.
@@christophergraves6725 you make a strange out of context argument , the context is REBEL cessasionist soldiers singing a rebel song, for states who rebelled to keep their own " particular instituion" SLAVERY , but the lost cause myth dreamed up by the daughtrs of the south doesnt wash , and the intellectual corruption of we ahd more abolitionist societies , ah yes and as they opened the door and went back to their society based on salvery wise up christopher brands boook the zealot and the emancipator isnt bad nbut the south certainly had choices and it choose treachery and slavery and eventually defeat
Saw The Hunley when it first came out all those years ago and thought what a fine movie and what an emotional ending. One of the best Civil War Films period.
I sat there at the ending and wept like a child when Dixon's bride reached for the floating coin and she embraced him as the others saw those dear ones who had passed before. The song still brings tears when I remember our fallen Constitutional Republic Lincoln destroyed.😢
Hearing a GENERAL in PGT Beauregard starting to sing "Bonnie Blue Flag" had to be an absolutely incredible sight that made it impossible not to sing along That would damn sure make everyone forget about the fact that they were under attack by Union forces. That would've made me cry tears of joy as I sang along with Beauregard😢😇
Sadly he had been continuosly recruited as the BAD guy, as Gary Oldman, pity bcz they'll both be great as good ones (look at Oldman 's commissioner Gordon, f.e.)
@@alessiodecarolis or look at the actor of Joffrey Baratheon. People hated him and really thought he is evil like his character in the show. They even attacked him.
It was. Dixie was more popular in the North ironically but The Bonnie Blue Flag was the unofficial anthem of the Confederacy (there was no official anthem, they only lasted like 5 years)
At the time the US didn't have an anthem either. Chester, Defense of Fort McHenry (Star Spangled Banner) and Yankee Doodle were the common tunes at state and military functions....along with Battle Hymn of the Republic. The Anthem got codified in the early 20th century if I remember correctly. Might have been the 1890s.
@@odysseusrex5908THANKS. as I recalled it became popular again after a pre WW1 olympics as the band had several to choose from and chose that tune. Many of our modern flag codes and ceremonial customs got enacted as law or military practice in the peacetime era between WW1 and 2. Thought it was the late 20s or early 30s, but couldn't be definitive without looking it up. Knew it was before FDRs election. Our society now spends too much time looking up online trivia instead of committing approximations to memory. That was about the time the county and state volunteer militias were conflated with the new National Guard...and definitions fabricated to join it to the minutemen and even the early 17th century America town militias. Patriot militias were not a National Guard in 1775. The Royal Americans 60th of Foote were a continental guard (equivalent to a national guard today) answering to the governors and under the Crowne, receiving pay for part time service. The Royal Americans shot at the patriot and town militias.
I am always surprised as to the different movies i find him in, that i wouldnt have expected and he does an amazing job of colloquial voice , accents etc.. i sometimes dont realize its him at first. Ive never seen this movie.
Enjoy reading the nice comments about Mr. Sutherland. I have been blessed to have met and known him for a short while a long time ago (he now lives on property adjacent to where I grew up). He is truly a warm, caring and decent person. The real deal. And a real blast to get to know, even a little bit. If you read this, Mr. Sutherland, I hope you are doing well. And Mercury outboards still stink -- Johnsons rock!
They would never dare make a movie like this these days, portraying the Confederates in a sympathetic yet fair light. Back then the film industry at least had some capacity for nuance, but no longer do the polarizing times we live in. Say what you will about the Confederates and condem them if you want(slavery was a great evil), They were indeed brave and were willing to die for the things they believed in.
"It aired on TNT on July 11, 1999." Well, that explains that. Ted Turner must really like this song; Pretty sure it's heard in Gettysburg, they have the whole sing along in Gods and Generals, and I just found out about this....because I watched the sing along -__- . But hey, I guess Sutherland as Beauregard is kinda neat. Looks the part.
Just to note I come from a river town in the North of England called North Shields. At Preston Cemetery in the town 5 Confederate sailors are buried there. I never got to the bottom as to why they are there. Tomb Stones are dated between 1867- 1881. All have weathered stones and you can make out 1 or 2 Saying, in Service of the CSA lay. I can only assume they jumped ship at some point to end up in England . Beautifully looked after graves as everyone is there in that place.
The last unit of the Confederacy to haul down its flag was the commerce raider ship, the Shenandoah, to a Royal Navy warship in Liverpool in 1865 - months after the war had actually ended. They didn't fancy being accused of piracy back in the USA so the crew scattered throughout Britain. Maybe they were some of them!
Have always really admired Donald Sutherland as an actor. From "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" to "The Hunger Games", he's a haunting and mysterious figure. And in this film, he plays a man, who seems to personally take credit for this event, like the shaman, in Mel Gibson's "Apocalypto".
Fun fact: General Beauregard’s first language was French and he didn’t learn English until he was 12. Contemporary sources also always noted his French accent so while Sutherland’s performance is good, it’s not entirely accurate.
@@nwofoe2866 Monsieur, I am French and your comment piqued my patriotic fiber and my pride. The French are not losers in view of their rich histories. I come from an old country which has also known wars, revolutions, invasions and occupations. King Louis XIV in his time, made France a superpower in Europe. His grandson Louis XVI, helped America win its independence. Napoleon conquered Europe and led expeditions to Russia and Egypt. In 1918, we emerged victorious against Germany after 4 years of hard fighting in the trenches. In 1940 we collapsed for many reasons in the face of the Nazis, but certainly not for lack of courage. Today, France is the leading European military power. She fought in Iraq, Afghanistan, Africa. You know, our nation has been fighting for 2000 years, and we don't have to be ashamed of our history admired throughout world. Cordialement.👋 Vive la France ! 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@@Tark75ifty ,Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier Marquis de La Fayette, General Jean-Baptiste-Donatien de Vimeur Comte de Rochambeau and Admiral François Joseph Paul Comte de Grasse Marquis of Grasse-Tilly are still held in fond regard by those Americans that know their own history for without the military help of France the American colonies' Independence from the English Crown was unlikely to succeed without a great deal more struggle and suffering. The false impression many American have of France's fighting prowess is due to ignorance of France's long history and particularly of her historical military prowess combined with poor understanding of events of WWI and WW2.
And Beauregard was the highest ranking Catholic on either side. (Sheridan was on the Union side.) It’s somewhat ironic that the oh-so prejudiced South had a Catholic full general and a Jewish cabinet member (Judah Benjamin).
@Jake None, because I live in the UK, and don't need to be armed. I do live on the edge of the Greens-OFB drill war area, admittedly, which is something you've kindly exported, so might need alternative IW, and do carry two knife wounds, from my time in service, so I have a clear idea of what I'm up against.
One of the most AMAZING CIVIL WAR films, portraiting the incredible story of the FIRST HUMAN SUBMARINE SUCCESSFUL operation! And and amazing emotional moment, singing the "Bonny Blue Flag".
The museum is a must-see. I talked with a man who watched the sub be removed from the water and carried to the research facility. He said it was chilling
Actually, if you go to the submarine museum in Connecticut (highly recommend), you'll see a submarine from the Revolutionary War. It couldn't totally submerge. So you might not consider it a true submarine but consider the courage of the man who operated it. They used it to sneak up on British ships in the harbor, attach a limpit mine then paddle away.
@@markshaw7253 That was the Turtle. The British ship it attempted to attach the mine to had a copper bottom sheath. This was because it had done duty in the Pacific Ocean where some kind of borer worm damaged wooden hulls. Thee mine floated free and exploded causing no damage. However, the British fleet sailed the next day.
TD again Armand Assanti was wonderful as the captain, that they found his bent coin inside says it all, those men, confederates that they were, they were still serious heroes and pioneers in submarine technology....
Pierre Gustov Toutant Beauregard. I pray I spell his name correct. For he is a hero of mine. My First Golden Retriever was named Beauregard, My Second, JEB Stuart...I apso had two German Shepherd dogs, Jackson and Lee. My other dogs where Colt, and Dixie. They have all passed. My Two current dogs, Grsat Danes, are Kimber and Doc. Figure that out. My next dogs will be Hill, Hood, and Nathan. 😊
@@alessiodecarolis He was defending his home state of Louisiana, and again, the South did not fight for the preservation or expansion of slavery. They fought for the right of independence.
@@generalfeldmarschall3781 yea, but they didn't fully endorse the North because of the colony they once had in Texas, which still had a high german population. Also texas was under threat because of France's war with mexico.
Oh geez that brings back memories. I was a little kid back then but I remember it somewhat. Didn’t one of them drop his rifle on some rocks and he had to use leather to “glue” it back together?
@@tdirtyatl It is important to realise that Racism only exists in the eyes of the Racist. Or to put it another way, If you were offered a good deal for a car or what ever, you would be daft to turn it down right. Well consider those poor well meaning traders being offered by the Tribal chief no less, a load of no good, good for nothing wasters from his own tribe. They would have been daft to turn down the offer as well right. They were in actual face only doing the Tribal chief and in turn the tribe a good turn. You my friend are the true racist
Me I'm going to send it of the Burnett's First Texas Volunteer cavalry my ancestors were Irish and Scottish descent and they fought for the Confederacy like Gallant man they thought to be remembered forever I hial the South
Descendant of the 1st Texas. Until recently I didn't know much bout 1st Texas. I knew they fought in the East. But to know they were feared more the the Stonewall Brigade.
as insperational and heroic as this scene is it just demonstrates humanities base ability to deny reality and pretend everything is great! here is another telling and truer example: 'how are you today?' "fine"
LOVED this movie. Now go see the Hunley at the Hunley Museum in Charleston. Pray for those souls who proved, with their lives, that the submarine was going to be THE most devastating weapon system ever devised.
Very similar to the scene in the movie "Darling Lili" starring Julie Andres when during a musical performance, a German zeppelin bombs London during WWI.
R.I.P Donald Sutherland
R.I.P Donald Sutherland, thank you for your brilliant performances.
The Hunley was a great film and this scene was beautiful.
Can you imagine if they tried making a scene like this today with the confederates?
Rest In Peace Mr. Sutherland, and thank you for all the wonderful rolls you played for us.
The Hunley! Great movie and my favorite part of it! Hoorah for the bonnie blue flag. RIP Donald Sutherland who played General Beauregard
Its a very underrated movie, IMO one of the best factual events of the Civil War. The first in history of a sinking by a submarine.
Rest in peace Donald Sutherland! You were awesome in this film!
Inspiring! Makes me proud of my Southern heritage that we cannot and should not surrender.
I'm a darn Yankee but can not but praise such masterful performance. All of Mr. Sutherland's roles were believable. That is what made him great.
SLAvery just say the word
@@dpg957 So, everything about the South and our culture is all reduced to slavery? That is what you call ideological fanaticism that dates back to the original Abolitionists who ran out Southerners who opposed slavery in the 1830's. And there were more Southern abolitionist societies at the time than Northern ones.
As historian H.W. Brands has correctly observed, the Abolitionists, i.e. the Northeastern fanatical variety, gave the South no where else to go.
@@christophergraves6725 you make a strange out of context argument , the context is REBEL cessasionist soldiers singing a rebel song, for states who rebelled to keep their own " particular instituion" SLAVERY , but the lost cause myth dreamed up by the daughtrs of the south doesnt wash , and the intellectual corruption of we ahd more abolitionist societies , ah yes and as they opened the door and went back to their society based on salvery wise up christopher brands boook the zealot and the emancipator isnt bad nbut the south certainly had choices and it choose treachery and slavery and eventually defeat
RIP to the captain and his gallant crew and to Clive cussler who passed a few years ago....lest we forget...
Well said mate.
What is it we are not forgetting?
One of the finest Canadian actors, EVER!! RIP
Mister Sutherland partió hoy a la eternidad, pero su legado y trayectoria artística nunca morirá.
Saw The Hunley when it first came out all those years ago and thought what a fine movie and what an emotional ending. One of the best Civil War Films period.
I sat there at the ending and wept like a child when Dixon's bride reached for the floating coin and she embraced him as the others saw those dear ones who had passed before. The song still brings tears when I remember our fallen Constitutional Republic Lincoln destroyed.😢
@@thomasbunner5214 Agreed.
Thank you, Donald.
Holy Hell, Donald Sutherland looks almost identical to Beauregard!
Charlie Theanteater true
You're right. Good casting director.
Doesnt sound like him though
Does he have French-Canadian in him?
He does! 😮
Hearing a GENERAL in PGT Beauregard starting to sing "Bonnie Blue Flag" had to be an absolutely incredible sight that made it impossible not to sing along
That would damn sure make everyone forget about the fact that they were under attack by Union forces. That would've made me cry tears of joy as I sang along with Beauregard😢😇
The Hunley is one of the best movies about the Civil War. It's historically accurate and captures the favour of the period perfectly.
i did't see it, how does it compare to Gods and generals?
@@zazugee A lot better
To this day, such a brilliant, almost perfect performance... Donald is and always has been a truly unique and gifted actor...
He is a genius
Sadly he had been continuosly recruited as the BAD guy, as Gary Oldman, pity bcz they'll both be great as good ones (look at Oldman 's commissioner Gordon, f.e.)
@@alessiodecarolisyou need good actors as the bad guys. Because they can perform it realistic.
@@jarlnils435 Right, think how his portrait of C. Snow on Hunger Games was REALLY chilling .
@@alessiodecarolis or look at the actor of Joffrey Baratheon. People hated him and really thought he is evil like his character in the show. They even attacked him.
Donald Sutherland is one of Canada's treasures, and just recently had a Canadian postage stamp issued to honour him.
Very good!!!
Bonnie blue flag...the second most.popular song in the CSA
It was. Dixie was more popular in the North ironically but The Bonnie Blue Flag was the unofficial anthem of the Confederacy (there was no official anthem, they only lasted like 5 years)
At the time the US didn't have an anthem either. Chester, Defense of Fort McHenry (Star Spangled Banner) and Yankee Doodle were the common tunes at state and military functions....along with Battle Hymn of the Republic.
The Anthem got codified in the early 20th century if I remember correctly. Might have been the 1890s.
@@tylerbrewer9063 Four.
@@STho205 1931.
@@odysseusrex5908THANKS. as I recalled it became popular again after a pre WW1 olympics as the band had several to choose from and chose that tune.
Many of our modern flag codes and ceremonial customs got enacted as law or military practice in the peacetime era between WW1 and 2. Thought it was the late 20s or early 30s, but couldn't be definitive without looking it up. Knew it was before FDRs election. Our society now spends too much time looking up online trivia instead of committing approximations to memory.
That was about the time the county and state volunteer militias were conflated with the new National Guard...and definitions fabricated to join it to the minutemen and even the early 17th century America town militias.
Patriot militias were not a National Guard in 1775. The Royal Americans 60th of Foote were a continental guard (equivalent to a national guard today) answering to the governors and under the Crowne, receiving pay for part time service.
The Royal Americans shot at the patriot and town militias.
Rest in peace Donald Sutherland
RIP 🙏 Mr Donald Sutherland
Lt. Dixon's the one who led; Beauregard just took his cue from him.
"Get your men back in their chairs! Play Bonnie Blue Flag!"
A true leader knows when to defer to a wiser subordinate.
At last, a reasonably decent southern accent in a movie by a non-southerner, Armand Assante. Well done, sir!
I am always surprised as to the different movies i find him in, that i wouldnt have expected and he does an amazing job of colloquial voice , accents etc.. i sometimes dont realize its him at first.
Ive never seen this movie.
Enjoy reading the nice comments about Mr. Sutherland. I have been blessed to have met and known him for a short while a long time ago (he now lives on property adjacent to where I grew up). He is truly a warm, caring and decent person. The real deal. And a real blast to get to know, even a little bit. If you read this, Mr. Sutherland, I hope you are doing well. And Mercury outboards still stink -- Johnsons rock!
This was the most best song I ever heard
RIP Donald Sutherland
They would never dare make a movie like this these days, portraying the Confederates in a sympathetic yet fair light. Back then the film industry at least had some capacity for nuance, but no longer do the polarizing times we live in. Say what you will about the Confederates and condem them if you want(slavery was a great evil), They were indeed brave and were willing to die for the things they believed in.
My guy, lost cause propaganda is alive and well.
"It aired on TNT on July 11, 1999."
Well, that explains that. Ted Turner must really like this song; Pretty sure it's heard in Gettysburg, they have the whole sing along in Gods and Generals, and I just found out about this....because I watched the sing along -__- . But hey, I guess Sutherland as Beauregard is kinda neat. Looks the part.
I'm not the only Canadian that sings this one lol
Bro i am German 😂🤝
I am Canadian and I sing it produly
The power of music
Definitely
Just to note I come from a river town in the North of England called North Shields. At Preston Cemetery in the town 5 Confederate sailors are buried there. I never got to the bottom as to why they are there. Tomb Stones are dated between 1867- 1881. All have weathered stones and you can make out 1 or 2 Saying, in Service of the CSA lay. I can only assume they jumped ship at some point to end up in England . Beautifully looked after graves as everyone is there in that place.
The last unit of the Confederacy to haul down its flag was the commerce raider ship, the Shenandoah, to a Royal Navy warship in Liverpool in 1865 - months after the war had actually ended. They didn't fancy being accused of piracy back in the USA so the crew scattered throughout Britain. Maybe they were some of them!
As a non American I do love rhe civil war songs from both sides
Superb emotion- Assante looks like he's ging to explode! Hurrah !
I love the south, greetings and every good wish from the UK 🇬🇧
Donald Sutherland is amazing
Have always really admired Donald Sutherland as an actor. From "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" to "The Hunger Games", he's a haunting and mysterious figure. And in this film, he plays a man, who seems to personally take credit for this event, like the shaman, in Mel Gibson's "Apocalypto".
Beauregard was a publicity seeker so it is in keeping with his character and historically accurate.
@@smhmay1973 He was also a battle winner.
@@gingerninja498 Indeed,he was !
Oddball, is his best Character...
I liked him in Eye of the Needle... and The Eagle Has Landed. And of course ANIMAL HOUSE!
Fun fact: General Beauregard’s first language was French and he didn’t learn English until he was 12. Contemporary sources also always noted his French accent so while Sutherland’s performance is good, it’s not entirely accurate.
Interesting fact, well there is nothing but french nobility in his name: Pierre Gustave Toutant de Beauregard
@@nwofoe2866
Monsieur,
I am French and your comment piqued my patriotic fiber and my pride.
The French are not losers in view of their rich histories.
I come from an old country which has also known wars, revolutions, invasions and occupations.
King Louis XIV in his time, made France a superpower in Europe. His grandson Louis XVI, helped America win its independence.
Napoleon conquered Europe and led expeditions to Russia and Egypt.
In 1918, we emerged victorious against Germany after 4 years of hard fighting in the trenches.
In 1940 we collapsed for many reasons in the face of the Nazis, but certainly not for lack of courage.
Today, France is the leading European military power. She fought in Iraq, Afghanistan, Africa.
You know, our nation has been fighting for 2000 years, and we don't have to be ashamed of our history admired throughout world.
Cordialement.👋
Vive la France ! 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@@Tark75ifty ,Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier Marquis de La Fayette, General Jean-Baptiste-Donatien de Vimeur Comte de Rochambeau and Admiral François Joseph Paul Comte de Grasse Marquis of Grasse-Tilly are still held in fond regard by those Americans that know their own history for without the military help of France the American colonies' Independence from the English Crown was unlikely to succeed without a great deal more struggle and suffering.
The false impression many American have of France's fighting prowess is due to ignorance of France's long history and particularly of her historical military prowess combined with poor understanding of events of WWI and WW2.
And Beauregard was the highest ranking Catholic on either side. (Sheridan was on the Union side.) It’s somewhat ironic that the oh-so prejudiced South had a Catholic full general and a Jewish cabinet member (Judah Benjamin).
@@Tark75ifty Yet Napoleon got his arse kicked. Let’s not forget you got your arses kicked by little men wearing Pyjamas before the Yanks did.
This scene clearly shows why the South was a formidable foe. They were firm in their resolve and it took a lot to defeat them.
Strikes me you didn't defeat them, from the anarchy now afoot.
@@JelMain I don't see you defeating them either.
@Jake And your factories were burned.
@Jake None, because I live in the UK, and don't need to be armed. I do live on the edge of the Greens-OFB drill war area, admittedly, which is something you've kindly exported, so might need alternative IW, and do carry two knife wounds, from my time in service, so I have a clear idea of what I'm up against.
@Jake More than enough.
One of the most AMAZING CIVIL WAR films, portraiting the incredible story of the FIRST HUMAN SUBMARINE SUCCESSFUL operation!
And and amazing emotional moment, singing the "Bonny Blue Flag".
The museum is a must-see. I talked with a man who watched the sub be removed from the water and carried to the research facility. He said it was chilling
Actually, if you go to the submarine museum in Connecticut (highly recommend), you'll see a submarine from the Revolutionary War. It couldn't totally submerge. So you might not consider it a true submarine but consider the courage of the man who operated it. They used it to sneak up on British ships in the harbor, attach a limpit mine then paddle away.
@@markshaw7253 That was the Turtle. The British ship it attempted to attach the mine to had a copper bottom sheath. This was because it had done duty in the Pacific Ocean where some kind of borer worm damaged wooden hulls. Thee mine floated free and exploded causing no damage. However, the British fleet sailed the next day.
@@silverstar4289 I haven’t made it to the museum but visited the cemetery where the men are buried near Charleston
Successful might be a slight overstatement in terms of attacking the enemy... But A+ for effort indeed.
Remind anyone else of the La Marseilles scene in Casablanca?
*Tego DONALDA to ja lubie najbardziej ze wszystkich DONALDOW !!!!*
Dokładnie to jest prawdziwy Donald a nie co ten rudzielec z PO xd
Saludos de chile y que viva el sur
Hurrah for the Bonnie Blue Flag
Oddball making with them positive waves.
Such a matchless courage..
Beautiful song
R.I.P. Donald Sutherland 😥🕯️🕯️🕯️💔
De las mejores en este tema y cancion😊
So many positive waves in this video
I’m one of the few that get it lol.
if there is a more inspiring scene in any movie, i've yet to see it.
Una escena muy icónica de este filme sobre el submarino de la confederación "Hunley" en quedar en la historia del cine.
I've seen a Picture of Geneneral Beuaregard,Donald Sutherlannd seems to be the Twin.
... great movie.... pretty accurate too.... I'm a cussler reader and his group Numa found the Hunley... Armand Assanti
Watched this scene 30 times in a row
Donald Sutherland as Beauregard looks like Napoleon III
TD again Armand Assanti was wonderful as the captain, that they found his bent coin inside says it all, those men, confederates that they were, they were still serious heroes and pioneers in submarine technology....
Pierre Gustov Toutant Beauregard. I pray I spell his name correct. For he is a hero of mine. My First Golden Retriever was named Beauregard, My Second, JEB Stuart...I apso had two German Shepherd dogs, Jackson and Lee. My other dogs where Colt, and Dixie. They have all passed. My Two current dogs, Grsat Danes, are Kimber and Doc. Figure that out. My next dogs will be Hill, Hood, and Nathan. 😊
Music with a light show !
Great video! Regards from Spain
Hurrah for the Bonnie Blue Flag!
Extraordinario Donal
Como en todassus peliculas
The Army of Northern Virginia was one of the greatest armies that ever marched!
God Bless you General Beauregard! Excellent work defending the Cradle of the Rebellion!
Fighting for the property we gained by honest toil,
or perhaps those who toiled were the property.
@@Mdebacle The South wasn't fighting purely for slavery. Beauregard was opposed to slavery.
@@stonewalljackson5692 REALLY? So why did he fought for the slavers?
@@alessiodecarolis He was defending his home state of Louisiana, and again, the South did not fight for the preservation or expansion of slavery. They fought for the right of independence.
@@stonewalljackson5692 Damn right sir!
R.I.P my boy donald 😔
Such a talent rip
Love it!
Long may this song of Freedom be taught to youngsters and in doing so, it live long into the future.
He Loks like General Beauregard!
God Bless the old South
God bless the German Empire my brother!
But Prussia was on the union side
@@generalfeldmarschall3781 hardly
@@ToolBoxChevy there were
Bismarck even once meet Grant
@@generalfeldmarschall3781 yea, but they didn't fully endorse the North because of the colony they once had in Texas, which still had a high german population. Also texas was under threat because of France's war with mexico.
Aha, the "Property" version that I first heard in the "Centennial" (1978-1979) miniseries. Bufe Coker was singing to the cattle as a lullaby.
Oh geez that brings back memories. I was a little kid back then but I remember it somewhat. Didn’t one of them drop his rifle on some rocks and he had to use leather to “glue” it back together?
@@historyandhorseplaying7374 That was from Part 1, long before Levi Zendt came to Colorado.
Never Forget
The slavery.
@@tdirtyatl It is important to realise that Racism only exists in the eyes of the Racist. Or to put it another way, If you were offered a good deal for a car or what ever, you would be daft to turn it down right. Well consider those poor well meaning traders being offered by the Tribal chief no less, a load of no good, good for nothing wasters from his own tribe. They would have been daft to turn down the offer as well right. They were in actual face only doing the Tribal chief and in turn the tribe a good turn. You my friend are the true racist
Love the South ❤
Hoorah for the Confederacy!🇨🇦
Donald actually resembles a confederate general from old photos.
A few unique uniforms in this ... Confederate Navy, you do not see those often.
I never saw the movie. As usual in Hollywood. Only did the first verse. Like Panzerleid in Battle of the Bulge.
Makes me cry....a descendant, of the 6th Texas Volunteers under a General Granville.
Tears again had to watch Donald sing.
Im a Decendant of the Georgia 1st Infantry regiment God Bless you My friend!
Me I'm going to send it of the Burnett's First Texas Volunteer cavalry my ancestors were Irish and Scottish descent and they fought for the Confederacy like Gallant man they thought to be remembered forever I hial the South
Descendant of the 1st Texas. Until recently I didn't know much bout 1st Texas. I knew they fought in the East. But to know they were feared more the the Stonewall Brigade.
@@themandalorian6999 Thank mYou we keep the spirit alive.
Good film long ago, now I must watch it again where can I find it?
Woof woof!
as insperational and heroic as this scene is it just demonstrates humanities base ability to deny reality and pretend everything is great!
here is another telling and truer example: 'how are you today?' "fine"
Hey I didn’t know President Snow fought in the Civil war!!!
David Bushnell had the concept and demonstrated it first and yeah the Hunley did blow a mine but they all died in the process.
Wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LOVED this movie. Now go see the Hunley at the Hunley Museum in Charleston. Pray for those souls who proved, with their lives, that the submarine was going to be THE most devastating weapon system ever devised.
Bellissimo.
Muy buena
and it isnt so far away, that this great song will be blacklisted, I m afraid
🙏
Woof, Woof,Woof!
Very similar to the scene in the movie "Darling Lili" starring Julie Andres when during a musical performance, a German zeppelin bombs London during WWI.
Well done, sir.
Grandfathers when they drink one cup of water at Thanksgiving dinner
General Beuauregard!
Покойся с миром, Дональд.
А кем он был?
@@Дубидубидуба Актёр, поющий песню здесь. Я смотрел много фильмов с его участием .
Oddball's Great-granfather!
It's possible, given that Oddball is just prancing around with a German Iron Cross around his neck and nobody minds :D
ありゃサザーランドさんだ❗ボーリガード将軍役が似合うな。
i LOVE DONALD SUTHERLAND! I mean, he just steals Kelly's Heroes!
Thats perfekt!
Eu lembro de assistir esse filme no #fimdenoite do #sbt
Damn Oddball singing again...
He needs wine and cheese baby!
Canada loves our Confederate brothers!and sisters!
So Canada hates the USA...and supports rebels and insurrectionists?
yeah, you don’t speak for all of canada. we hate the confederates, and for good reasons.
The Saint Alban Raid is an example!
Tis time to prepare, my Canadian Brother and Sisters.
Nope.
Somebody pass me a bucket