The Thing about Music in Indian Movies is that, we are more accustomed to it. We like it and it helps the situations more tennse or fun or emotional. I think, Jaby, more 10 years of indian movies, your music issue will be solved.
what i think is if acting and screen olay is enough strong..there no need of music.. nd this movie had that..it would have looked more intense and real ..
@@saurabhashish15 agree bro. Take any action scene from saving private Ryan. It's just gun and blast sounds which make us be in the moment more. But we're transitioning from typical bollywood to realistic and I think eventually we're gonna make these changes- this is evident from the fact that there was no lip syncing to any song in the movie.
But this is also correct that we don't need random music videos in between the movie. The only example I could think of is Jai Jai Shiv Shankar song in war, which has no context with movie. And we don't want so many item numbers like we even have it in latest Ajay Devgan's flop, I don't remember the movie.
@@bratindas5814 Sometimes, when stakes are high enough, the best choice for a background music is to put NO MUSIC in the scene. I've seen it used sparingly in an Anime called Attack on Titan a.k.a. Shingeki no Kyojin. Silence in one particular scene was the perfect choice, despite the fact that Attack on Titan has some of the best background music ever created on Earth.
Ye Dil Mange more was a popular Pepsi slogan those days as it had a cast of Khuch Khuch Hota hai in that ad and it was aired during cricket world cup 1999. During the same time, Kargil war started and Capt Vikram Batra made that slogan immortal. And the razor blade thing, soldiers used to carry razor blade to keep them clean shaved. Being Clean shaved is part of discipline in the indian army. We didn't have the kind razors back then which we have today.
For music connection, knowing lyrics and vocabulary is really important. which we as an indian feel a lot more as we speak the language. B Praak words in man bharya just kills me from inside.
@@govindsharma9627 i understand at times sounfs effects are cringey ....but many time there are lyric songs in background like i gave man bharya example ...scene was going was in back only ...but it gave us feeling coz we know our indian music ...same with some backgrouns plane tunes as we are familiar with them it just trigger our emotions not theirs...thats mah point.
BRUH, REAL THING IS, INDIAN ARMY HAS THERE OWN BANDS, PROFESSIONAL ONES, CHECK OR LISTEN THEM IN BEATING RETREAT CEREMONY, ALSO, OUR ARMY USED TO PERFORM ROCK LIKE MUSIC, OUR PARADES ALWAYS HAS DRUMS IN SYNC... ALSO INDIAN WARS HAD DHARMA, WE USED SHANKH TO START WAR DAY AND REST AT EVENING ALL SIDES... SO USING ROCK LIKE MUSIC IN INDIAN ARMY BASED MOVIE IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, TRUE AND LOGICAL..... MAKE JABY KNOW ABOUT THIS.... HE HAD SAME ISSUE IN URI...
That's he said if you'd have watch whole video & understood him clearly you'd know said exactly what you are saying. That music in ending (I.e B praak's song) wasn't distracting or it was at right time & even he felt the emotions. But the music at war scenes were too distracting, that I also felt when I was watching the movie.
one thing to add is that officers and soldiers refused to go back from the frontline even after they were injured because they knew it would require 2 men to carry one person in those mountains, effectively losing 3 men and they couldn't afford to weaken their attack
Dimple in real life never married, as she feels she is already married to him, minus any pension benefits ofcource, as it was not legal. And she decided to live her rest of life holding on to that what they had rather than move on and have her own family. Genuine honest people with sacrifices everywhere. there is no pressure, as she never comes in front of camera and average people on street wont know her, so there is no societal pressure to not marry, on the contrary knowing Indian parents, there would have been a lot of pressure from her family to move on, and i mean a lot like constant.
No, but it is more reliable and dependable to have another person's perspective or source to prove it correct other than vikram himself. Like a witness or evidence in judicial system
@Pop Pop BRUH, REAL THING IS, INDIAN ARMY HAS THERE OWN BANDS, PROFESSIONAL ONES, CHECK OR LISTEN THEM IN BEATING RETREAT CEREMONY, ALSO, OUR ARMY USED TO PERFORM ROCK LIKE MUSIC, OUR PARADES ALWAYS HAS DRUMS IN SYNC... ALSO INDIAN WARS HAD DHARMA, WE USED SHANKH TO START WAR DAY AND REST AT EVENING ALL SIDES... SO USING ROCK LIKE MUSIC IN INDIAN ARMY BASED MOVIE IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, TRUE AND LOGICAL..... MAKE JABY KNOW ABOUT THIS.... HE HAD SAME ISSUE IN URI...
@Pop Pop its fine, But all Indian Bollywood Movies, TV shows or even real shows on Independence day or republic day has beat based, Dhol based Trumphet based music. So its natural to use it. In school parades we had same, if u remember how school parade had music based walking.. m not offended bro, just telling reason behind using music.
Jaby I get what u mean when you say they were joking on the battlefield.. if not for the war they would have been friends cracking such jokes over beer. However, I disagree. The scene probably looks n sounds as if it's a joke but the intent of the Pakistani soldier was not to make the situation light with a few jokes.. I think its because you don't get the insult in his tone since u don't speak the language. His intention was to insult indian women especially the actress. To be honest it was a very indecent thing to do to joke n bring an actress in the middle of a war n say something so derogatory.. it only shows that the pakistani soldier wasn't doing this as his duty towards his country but was gaining pleasure out of the war. Pls note that he didn't ask for Madhuri dixit in an innocent manner out of respect for her. It was meant as an insult n in a derogatory manner towards the actress n it clearly provoked Cap. Batra. Since he was a funny guy himself, he replied jokingly but it was not something that was taken lightly. If u ask me, if they were not in War and were simply two guys at the bar and had this guy said smth so derogatory about a woman belonging to other guy's country, religion o ethnicity, they wouldn't be sharing a drink to that instead it would start a fight between them. Imagine how it will feel if the bartender says to you that I'll give u the booze for free if u let me have ur hot friend over there.. it was almost like that.
@@gauravyadav-bg1bz what the hell does that even mean? look up the history. they raped hindus in kashmir in 48 and in bangladesh in 71. Its no fiction. You're the one who's brainwashed. And don't even get me started on history before that.
@@siddhantkumar1028 yes that way it is, but the girls above are not offended because the love india or anything , the are only pintched because how come girls being made fun of in a war , feminism is like a woman who is charmed by a bad dude , I.e, Islamic fringe elements 😂, you have much to catch up my boy
We Indians LOVE music, it helps us feel the moment more and relate and connect more. The movie wouldn't have had an impact it had if it didn't have the music.
Your statement somehow implies that is never the case with American cinema. It happens in American cinema to. It just depends on the scene, tone and overall style. Plenty of films here use music with the same intent in mind.
Actually, it could be done both ways. Because indian audiences also watch Hollywood movies with serious stories and less music and still feel the emotions conveyed in them. It just depends on the creators vison.
Jaby dude why are you offended he just talked about Indians and we all know there are lots of differences in Indian & American cinema and that's including use of music & dance
I think we indian love the music and it is the most we connect to that's why every film has several songs and you would've like it also if you would have known the lyrics and this film has 3 grea singers - Jubin Nautiyal, Darshan Raval and B Praak and all songs are great.
BRUH, REAL THING IS, INDIAN ARMY HAS THERE OWN BANDS, PROFESSIONAL ONES, CHECK OR LISTEN THEM IN BEATING RETREAT CEREMONY, ALSO, OUR ARMY USED TO PERFORM ROCK LIKE MUSIC, OUR PARADES ALWAYS HAS DRUMS IN SYNC... ALSO INDIAN WARS HAD DHARMA, WE USED SHANKH TO START WAR DAY AND REST AT EVENING ALL SIDES... SO USING ROCK LIKE MUSIC IN INDIAN ARMY BASED MOVIE IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, TRUE AND LOGICAL..... MAKE JABY KNOW ABOUT THIS.... HE HAD SAME ISSUE IN URI...
No, he particularly said about the war scenes if you have watched his movie review. I felt the same during war scene music wasn't necessary and was too distracting
@@hardybouy omg stop with this same ass long comments . I have seen your same comment three times already . You already said your point , what's the use of copy and pasting stuff everywhere you disagree ? People have different opinions , move along .
@@CineDesi it wasn't a war Jaby, Pakistan captured some points, our Army fought for it and defended successfully. It can be called a warlike situation. So no, it wasn't a war.
9:00 It wasn't a fun, bro-joke witty wartime banter. It was a threat from the Pak soldier and had very dark connotations around it if you can understand. It's actually surprising that Captain Batra didn't lose his temper at that. Jaby I share your frustration but one state is fundamentalist, islamic military autocracy that uses terror and terrorists as major tactic. What is the other democratic state supposed to do?
19:22 I had the same feeling about it...cant imagine the pressure she might have to not change her mind if she wants coz people have put her on pedestal for not marrying again but if she has a change of mind as she is a human being first then i dont know how will she handle the resistance but if shes genuinely happy being alone then its completely her choice and more power to her !!!
3 ปีที่แล้ว +2
It’s her life. Even Vikram’s parents wanted her to move on. But she is happy with her decision. Again this is as per his parents, as she doesn’t like to be in media. I guess that’s good, considering hawkish media we have.
dumbo she clearly has mentioned that she didnt want to marry after vikrams death she was not even married with vikram why would anyone stop her from marrying
The fact is bikram batra got selected in army in his 13th attempt must also have been included in the movie ...it's shows his determination to join army
It is good to see that in India too realistic films are made. Biopics are normally very boring and hence they are dramatised to make it appealing for the audience. Dhonis biopic is example which became a huge part hit and on the other hand Sachin's biopic was made as a documentary and flopped. Vikram Batra's biopic is very realistic and very emotional. Feel proud of army as an Indian to have heros like Captain Vikram Batra .
Adding to this... *Small little details were also kept in mind like there's a scene where a pakistani flag is on the ground nd our soldiers don't step on it.. *when pakistanis refused to take the bodies of their own soldiers, our indian soldiers did their last rites.. *dimple is really unmarried by choice nd still calls herself the widow of vikram batra..
When I See him. My eyes are filled with tears and my heart is filled with Pride. He is the best example of bravery. He will always be liVE in my heart. I just love him. Jay Hind.
This was literally the hardest war in the history of mountain warfare. Indian army had to climb Himalayas while enemy where hiding on peak at a vantage point. They fought in adverse environmental conditions like extreme cold, lack of oxygen, fatigue etc.
Music is bollywood or in india is not just to listen and enjoy it as just as piece of art, but moreover a way to relate and go through that particular moment with the lyrics and music composed. We are familiar by the language and the words which actually mean and relate to that emotion. That's why music can't be excluded but has to be included as a emotional connect with audience
3 ปีที่แล้ว +1
Even after 8 yrs of Indian film reactions, he still doesnt know anything about Indian emotions, art and culture. He knows only to do technical analysis with hollywood films and act as he is a oscar famous director🤣🤣
Without the music it wouldnt be as emotional atleast for me. Once u understand the lyrics it all makes sense and i always cry when the songs come up 😢❤
What you need to react next: 1. Shershaah behind the scenes (All parts) 2. Dimple Cheema's interview 3. Captain Naveen Nagappa's "Shershaah saved my life" 4. My Brother, My Pride: TedX Talk by Vishal Batra 5. Kargil - A Matter of Honour | Patriot with Major Gaurav Arya
The quote "this heart desires more (yeh dil maange more" must be funny in the movie cuz it was pepsi's slogan and was unexpected to remember pepsi during a war.
Jaby said "you guys should end up this war cuz u r from same roots". jaby we did it so many times but their govt consistently did attack on india including terrorist attacks so how we could forget and move on? Last peace talk was beautifully done by late PM Atal bihari Vajpayee but within few months Pakistani army captured bunkers in Indian land. They want kashmir but invade on kargil which is in ladakh😅(attack on wrong place) so shershah movie is based upon kargil war.
Dimple mam is very happy cherishing the memories of their relationship........ Kiara Advani told in an interview that she was very happy telling theur story to her.
According to me Jaby has every right to say what he did beacuse it is HIS REVIEW. Just wish Jaby had more belief behind the idea of a scene or a dialogue and trusted the maker's style of doing it
Mostly songs are a way to convey the feelings of a character or scene to a audience which makes easier for a viewer to understand 'em deeply or connect with 'em in that short running hours.
8:45 it was not a joke made by random fellows its kind of sledge and more like insult. In India we take seriously when some one bad mouth especially on women. The Pak soldier indirectly says that they can't be moved of that peak only way to do it is to give away that actress. Indian army is not a pimp exchange a women for victory. To counter his bad mouth he gave a fitted reply like a man.
12:05 They do carry paper cutting blades. I can tell you that for sure, my brother is in armed forces and he carry paper cutter, 6' knife, kukhri and what not. even in malls (off duty) he would not keep away his paper cutter. he always have a blade.
10:39 correction. In the movie it is shown that Vikram ji held the duppata of his finance while doing parikarma of Guru Granth Sahib ji but in actual he held her duppata while doing parikrama of Nishan Sahib. So the fact is not told right. You can listen his fiance telling that while doing parikarma of Nishan Sahib....
the songs are not just the songs, through them we Indians feel strong emotions and all the singers in this movie have a very strong voice..btw, loved your reaction..
Well it is common for a Defence personnel to keep shrap tools... My dad is also an Airman ( Indian Air Force) he always carries one or two blade in his wallet, he always say don't take it out.. !!
The main problem is you are not accepting the fault of your review, and want to justify your review. After knowing this movie is a good tribute to Vikram Batra ji , you told that you like his story but not the movie. By the way if you recognise the meaning of these songs then you can also appreciate this. I just want to say that accept your faults.
What are you talking about? I think you're misinterpreting what I said.
3 ปีที่แล้ว +32
@@CineDesi he is talking abt when u wanted to double check vikram's own words he said in front of tv camera. Do u think an officer was lying in front of tv camera where is CO sitting beside?
@@CineDesi just wish you could understand the god level lyrics of the songs. Without those lyrics you cannot connect to the music and its only cuz of that you are even saying all that
@@khushigupta3779 many of the people knows that @roughnotes00 family have some problems with dimple ma'am family.That's why this person spreads rumours on every vidio. Nd once exposed ... deleting the comment....nd used abusing comments about batra family.
@@allroundentertainment8821pls don't believe this fake person @roughnotes00 . Bahat sare vidio me isne dimple ma'am n batra sir ki familey ke bareme bad comments kiyatha .he was lying about them coze roughnotes00 have some problems with Cheema familey n batra family. Jab uska jhut pakar gaya tab comments delet kardetehe.
People used to keep Razor blades in Indian during the 90's as we didn't have Razors like we do now in Modern times. It used to be the older ones in trend that time, that people had to switch blades for each shave.
HOLLYWOOD:Let's make a movie to GLORIFY the USA as our SAVIOR(In Frictional World) BOLLYWOOD: Let's make a Movie base on REAL STORY OF INDIAN ARMED FORCES
@@CineDesi now, you see how subtly music plays an important role to a moment to precisely connect with the character's emotion and sometimes, silence between the characters with a background music leaves the impact which only a viewers can feel or know. I also feel if you knew hindi you wouldn't have this complain but i respect your honest opinion. Journey without song is boring 😁
Music is inseparable part of commercial Indian movies. But the fact that the movie was not overly dramatized or fictionalized is very unique to Indian cinema. Few Indian cinemas are only made for art and their objective is not to make money but to showcase the art of cinema. Such kind of cinemas which are called as art cinema or parallel cinema mostly doesn't contain any music, even if it is there then it will be like a radio or a gramophone or a stuff like that playing in the background. In India, an actor who works in art cinema is called a real actor and hence several actors, who wants to prove themselves as good actor at least once in a lifetime work in an art film. Anyhow, art films or parallel cinema is almost dead in India and if at all they are made then it will be mostly or primarily for national or international awards. This is because of two things, first because of multiplexes which do not show such movies and secondly because of too many TV channels. In good old days when only two channels DD national and DD metro were available then people were forced to watch art movies because there was no third choice, either they watch the movie or shut the TV.
Shershaah is the best movie in this year.........it makes all Indians feel more proud for our nation and soldiers ....and their family who motivates their children 🙏❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Music and songs are extremely important part if the storytelling. And because of the difference in culture and language it is justified that you can't connect and understand the movie, which is okay. But honestly people who understand the movie and songs would definitely appreciate the movie.
@@CineDesi you don't have to joke about it verbally to actually make a mockery out of it just because you're unfamiliar with it. Your behaviour / body language / eyes told the truth.
7:05 sorry they didn’t have phone recorders in 1999 at 16000ft and the other side didn’t even accept their bodies so, i don’t know a way to corroborate that other than believing him and his fellow soldiers.
We can't connect without music the same way you can't connect with music. It's sad to see you saying this again and again even after reviewing so many bollywood trailers and movies. Every country and its people are different I just wish you'd respect that. The film is made in Bollywood and music plays a vital role.
I'm not disrespecting that. I'm saying what I would have done different. It's that simple. I don't see why it's not okay to give my honest feelings.
3 ปีที่แล้ว +8
The point is that he keep on saying the same thing from the last 8 yrs from the time he started reviewing bollywood and Indian movies. There is nothing new or interesting in his reviews nowadays. Even he knows music is an integral part of Indian movies
@meghana Songs disturb flow of story in almost every movie and atrocious background score destroys any movie for example, when @JabyKoay slammed RUSTAM for it's background score, he was right.
@@CineDesi 😅 don't worry lady didn't offended she just saying after 4 5 years of consuming Indian content still it's hits you Defrently than indian and it's Facinating to see that after this all years the place where you grow up 100% matter with how would you react to certain things😁 💚 Sorry for spelling mistakes
Jaby and Achara I would like to add on to the dil mange more line.. This advertisement came during 1999 cricket World Cup in the UK. On 16th June 1999 india faced Pakistan in the World Cup match which india went on to win… Indian Army was on a war against Pakistan during that time..
no offence to jaby, but restoring peace between India and Pakistan is not easy as it seems. Previous attempts to reach an agreement have all faltered, often after highly-charged summit meetings.
@@CineDesi with Pakistan? Hell no The country who supports terrorism and all the bad stuffs will never agree upon peace. Can't have false hopes.
3 ปีที่แล้ว +34
I urge any bollywood producer to give jaby a chance to make the 1st background scoreless and musicless bollywood movie😆😆🤣 I wonder what blood group he has that he doesnt feel the pump from the fantastic background score😉 Why dont Jaby realise that Vikram himself was a bollywood movie buff and a music lover
@@CineDesi in this movie, siddharth who has played His charecheter has conveyed so many famous iconic Bollywood movie dialogues of 80s and 90s Bollywood movies..ofcourse u couldn't understand because it was subtitled in English nd when u subtitle hindi dialogues in English it doesn't make sense nd ofcourse u are not familiar with 60s 70s 80s 90s and early 20s Bollywood movie culture so plz try to understand that u will not be satisfied with any Indian content fully because its quite impossible to catch up emotions about Indian content if u are not Indian...
3 ปีที่แล้ว +6
Music is an integral part of Indian people as such it well rooted to Indian culture, emotions and sentiments. You wont feel connected to the music becoz unlike Achara u are totally unware of the subtle nuances of hindi vocabulary, or seldom tries to understand the nuances. You only judge from ur own technical perspective which is not true for Indian movies. We are not here to compete with American films. Films here are made to connect Indian audiences.
3 ปีที่แล้ว +1
@bleh u r a bootlicker of jaby koay and a pakistani😉
Jaby you should watch LOC Kargil it's a full story and we'll described every character. We have many hero's of Kargil war and the movie was perfectly made to tribute their sacrifice.
Why jaby ,why are you not responding,we are asking response to Vikranth Rona glimpse please man please😫🙏🙏💓 also I think you don't read comments because iam trying since last 3 vedioes to reach you but.
In indian movies music is not used entirely for entertainment purposes…every situation in the movie.. has a happy song or a festive song for feel good scenes with lyrics expressing those feelings about dat particular situation same goes to the sad songs…as a South Indian i had a very hard time learning to speak hindi..these songs were a bridge for ppl like me to learn different languages..n understand the feelings..in a way its d promotion of culture n various other things…
12:05 earlier we used to use blades to open small packets cause we had less packets with those curves to open them! as my dad told, he used to carry one too in his wallet to open packets and stuff!
Music 🎶 is an integral part of Indians lives from centuries. We have so much variety of music. From centuries common people across villages sing folk songs to represent various emotions and stories. Even Vedic scriptures contain verses which have musical tones. Like Bhagwad geeta etc.
Yeah, about the 2 soldiers from opposing armies..it’s true, maybe they could have been friends, war horse has something like this too where 2 people from opposite armies come together to free a horse that’s in the trenches and have a heartwarming exchange but go back to fight again after the horse is freed😔
The Thing about Music in Indian Movies is that, we are more accustomed to it. We like it and it helps the situations more tennse or fun or emotional. I think, Jaby, more 10 years of indian movies, your music issue will be solved.
what i think is if acting and screen olay is enough strong..there no need of music..
nd this movie had that..it would have looked more intense and real ..
@@saurabhashish15 there's score anyways, so music is necessary
@@saurabhashish15 agree bro. Take any action scene from saving private Ryan. It's just gun and blast sounds which make us be in the moment more. But we're transitioning from typical bollywood to realistic and I think eventually we're gonna make these changes- this is evident from the fact that there was no lip syncing to any song in the movie.
But this is also correct that we don't need random music videos in between the movie. The only example I could think of is Jai Jai Shiv Shankar song in war, which has no context with movie. And we don't want so many item numbers like we even have it in latest Ajay Devgan's flop, I don't remember the movie.
@@bratindas5814 Sometimes, when stakes are high enough, the best choice for a background music is to put NO MUSIC in the scene. I've seen it used sparingly in an Anime called Attack on Titan a.k.a. Shingeki no Kyojin. Silence in one particular scene was the perfect choice, despite the fact that Attack on Titan has some of the best background music ever created on Earth.
Ye Dil Mange more was a popular Pepsi slogan those days as it had a cast of Khuch Khuch Hota hai in that ad and it was aired during cricket world cup 1999. During the same time, Kargil war started and Capt Vikram Batra made that slogan immortal.
And the razor blade thing, soldiers used to carry razor blade to keep them clean shaved. Being Clean shaved is part of discipline in the indian army. We didn't have the kind razors back then which we have today.
For music connection, knowing lyrics and vocabulary is really important. which we as an indian feel a lot more as we speak the language. B Praak words in man bharya just kills me from inside.
Exactly!
He is talking about the background music not the songs..
@@govindsharma9627 i understand at times sounfs effects are cringey ....but many time there are lyric songs in background like i gave man bharya example ...scene was going was in back only ...but it gave us feeling coz we know our indian music ...same with some backgrouns plane tunes as we are familiar with them it just trigger our emotions not theirs...thats mah point.
BRUH, REAL THING IS, INDIAN ARMY HAS THERE OWN BANDS, PROFESSIONAL ONES, CHECK OR LISTEN THEM IN BEATING RETREAT CEREMONY, ALSO, OUR ARMY USED TO PERFORM ROCK LIKE MUSIC, OUR PARADES ALWAYS HAS DRUMS IN SYNC... ALSO INDIAN WARS HAD DHARMA, WE USED SHANKH TO START WAR DAY AND REST AT EVENING ALL SIDES... SO USING ROCK LIKE MUSIC IN INDIAN ARMY BASED MOVIE IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, TRUE AND LOGICAL..... MAKE JABY KNOW ABOUT THIS.... HE HAD SAME ISSUE IN URI...
That's he said if you'd have watch whole video & understood him clearly you'd know said exactly what you are saying. That music in ending (I.e B praak's song) wasn't distracting or it was at right time & even he felt the emotions. But the music at war scenes were too distracting, that I also felt when I was watching the movie.
Jaby is that kind of a student in the class who tries to find fault in everything teacher says. But always has to accept failure🤣
he's so dumb most of the times man. idk where he would be without achara lol
Absolutely right 😂he criticises everything
@@ankitadhawan1642 achara has been carrying him for 5 years lmao
@@ankitadhawan1642 Aapki Maa ki age kitni honi Chahiye??💖💖
IGNORE = INSTANT DEATH🚫
SUBSCRIBE = 100 YEARS + GOOD HEALTH.💖💖...............
👇
@@anshuman5554 😂😂😂😍😂😂😂
one thing to add is that officers and soldiers refused to go back from the frontline even after they were injured because they knew it would require 2 men to carry one person in those mountains, effectively losing 3 men and they couldn't afford to weaken their attack
Dimple in real life never married, as she feels she is already married to him, minus any pension benefits ofcource, as it was not legal. And she decided to live her rest of life holding on to that what they had rather than move on and have her own family. Genuine honest people with sacrifices everywhere. there is no pressure, as she never comes in front of camera and average people on street wont know her, so there is no societal pressure to not marry, on the contrary knowing Indian parents, there would have been a lot of pressure from her family to move on, and i mean a lot like constant.
Interesting. Thanks for sharing that.
I think Shershaah used music perfectly. Everything about the movie is amazing, in my opinion.
Cool
Jaby doesn't believe what Vikram himself says but believes everything else 😂
Edit: . 👇
Haha 😂
Bruh!
No, but it is more reliable and dependable to have another person's perspective or source to prove it correct other than vikram himself. Like a witness or evidence in judicial system
@Pop Pop BRUH, REAL THING IS, INDIAN ARMY HAS THERE OWN BANDS, PROFESSIONAL ONES, CHECK OR LISTEN THEM IN BEATING RETREAT CEREMONY, ALSO, OUR ARMY USED TO PERFORM ROCK LIKE MUSIC, OUR PARADES ALWAYS HAS DRUMS IN SYNC... ALSO INDIAN WARS HAD DHARMA, WE USED SHANKH TO START WAR DAY AND REST AT EVENING ALL SIDES... SO USING ROCK LIKE MUSIC IN INDIAN ARMY BASED MOVIE IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, TRUE AND LOGICAL..... MAKE JABY KNOW ABOUT THIS.... HE HAD SAME ISSUE IN URI...
@Pop Pop its fine, But all Indian Bollywood Movies, TV shows or even real shows on Independence day or republic day has beat based, Dhol based Trumphet based music. So its natural to use it. In school parades we had same, if u remember how school parade had music based walking.. m not offended bro, just telling reason behind using music.
Jaby I get what u mean when you say they were joking on the battlefield.. if not for the war they would have been friends cracking such jokes over beer. However, I disagree. The scene probably looks n sounds as if it's a joke but the intent of the Pakistani soldier was not to make the situation light with a few jokes.. I think its because you don't get the insult in his tone since u don't speak the language. His intention was to insult indian women especially the actress. To be honest it was a very indecent thing to do to joke n bring an actress in the middle of a war n say something so derogatory.. it only shows that the pakistani soldier wasn't doing this as his duty towards his country but was gaining pleasure out of the war. Pls note that he didn't ask for Madhuri dixit in an innocent manner out of respect for her. It was meant as an insult n in a derogatory manner towards the actress n it clearly provoked Cap. Batra. Since he was a funny guy himself, he replied jokingly but it was not something that was taken lightly. If u ask me, if they were not in War and were simply two guys at the bar and had this guy said smth so derogatory about a woman belonging to other guy's country, religion o ethnicity, they wouldn't be sharing a drink to that instead it would start a fight between them. Imagine how it will feel if the bartender says to you that I'll give u the booze for free if u let me have ur hot friend over there.. it was almost like that.
AH. That makes a lot more sense.
Wow American ignorance is amazing
@@kabir9030 most americans are extremely naive and the rest are in CIA XD
@bleh when are you planing to do it 😎
Very correct characterization. Jaby is NOT that smart with compare to Achara. I don't know why smart girl like Achara wasting her time with Jaby.
When Jaby says he is still waiting for an epic love story... we're all like... look to your left Jaby, it is sitting next to you :D
Is it only me that felt the “Give us Madhuri” scene wasn’t supposed to be funny but was meant to be a disrespectful one?
Yes..it was not for sarcasm...it was genuine and disrespectful
And you guys are brainwashed millennials 😂👍🏻,.. living in Mangal Marry Land
@@gauravyadav-bg1bz what the hell does that even mean? look up the history. they raped hindus in kashmir in 48 and in bangladesh in 71. Its no fiction. You're the one who's brainwashed. And don't even get me started on history before that.
@@siddhantkumar1028 yes that way it is, but the girls above are not offended because the love india or anything , the are only pintched because how come girls being made fun of in a war , feminism is like a woman who is charmed by a bad dude , I.e, Islamic fringe elements 😂, you have much to catch up my boy
@@gauravyadav-bg1bz Kya phunke aaya be..kuch bhi bak raha hain
We Indians LOVE music, it helps us feel the moment more and relate and connect more. The movie wouldn't have had an impact it had if it didn't have the music.
Your statement somehow implies that is never the case with American cinema. It happens in American cinema to. It just depends on the scene, tone and overall style. Plenty of films here use music with the same intent in mind.
@@CineDesi American audience and Indian audience both are different. Cinema will give what it's audience like.......
Actually, it could be done both ways.
Because indian audiences also watch Hollywood movies with serious stories and less music and still feel the emotions conveyed in them.
It just depends on the creators vison.
Jaby dude why are you offended he just talked about Indians and we all know there are lots of differences in Indian & American cinema and that's including use of music & dance
what kind of a stupid name is yadavalli
I think we indian love the music and it is the most we connect to that's why every film has several songs and you would've like it also if you would have known the lyrics and this film has 3 grea singers - Jubin Nautiyal, Darshan Raval and B Praak and all songs are great.
Yeah
BRUH, REAL THING IS, INDIAN ARMY HAS THERE OWN BANDS, PROFESSIONAL ONES, CHECK OR LISTEN THEM IN BEATING RETREAT CEREMONY, ALSO, OUR ARMY USED TO PERFORM ROCK LIKE MUSIC, OUR PARADES ALWAYS HAS DRUMS IN SYNC... ALSO INDIAN WARS HAD DHARMA, WE USED SHANKH TO START WAR DAY AND REST AT EVENING ALL SIDES... SO USING ROCK LIKE MUSIC IN INDIAN ARMY BASED MOVIE IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT, TRUE AND LOGICAL..... MAKE JABY KNOW ABOUT THIS.... HE HAD SAME ISSUE IN URI...
No, he particularly said about the war scenes if you have watched his movie review. I felt the same during war scene music wasn't necessary and was too distracting
@@hardybouy omg stop with this same ass long comments . I have seen your same comment three times already . You already said your point , what's the use of copy and pasting stuff everywhere you disagree ? People have different opinions , move along .
@@crimsypatel3881 freedom of 💬 speech bolte... u could have ingored other 2 times
The music plays an important part because of the true and pure love story.
Jaby has issues with everything🤣🤣
What was the blade doing in the wallet, Madhuri Dixit scene didn't happen exactly as told🤣🤣
Vikrant rona glimpse why he is not responding 😭😭😭
8:45 Jaby, it wasn't meant for a Joke.
They were trying to Insult Indian Army.
i understand
@@CineDesi it wasn't a war Jaby, Pakistan captured some points, our Army fought for it and defended successfully. It can be called a warlike situation. So no, it wasn't a war.
9:00 It wasn't a fun, bro-joke witty wartime banter. It was a threat from the Pak soldier and had very dark connotations around it if you can understand. It's actually surprising that Captain Batra didn't lose his temper at that.
Jaby I share your frustration but one state is fundamentalist, islamic military autocracy that uses terror and terrorists as major tactic. What is the other democratic state supposed to do?
Lol secular country run by the butcher of gujarat. Killer of muslims
It's shows how stupid jaby is. How well he can understand.
19:22 I had the same feeling about it...cant imagine the pressure she might have to not change her mind if she wants coz people have put her on pedestal for not marrying again but if she has a change of mind as she is a human being first then i dont know how will she handle the resistance but if shes genuinely happy being alone then its completely her choice and more power to her !!!
It’s her life. Even Vikram’s parents wanted her to move on. But she is happy with her decision. Again this is as per his parents, as she doesn’t like to be in media. I guess that’s good, considering hawkish media we have.
dumbo she clearly has mentioned that she didnt want to marry after vikrams death she was not even married with vikram why would anyone stop her from marrying
Vikrant rona glimpse 😌
Yess plssss
💯
VIKRANT RONA GLIMPSE 🔥🔥🔥🔥
come on guys now!!!!
React to it...
waiting 😵
No one wants to watch that movie...plz stop it 🙏
@@groot3535 Buddhu aadmi
@@groot3535 no one wants your comment plz Stop it🙏🤣
Vikrant Rona 🔥🔥🔥 glimpse
The fact is bikram batra got selected in army in his 13th attempt must also have been included in the movie ...it's shows his determination to join army
It is good to see that in India too realistic films are made.
Biopics are normally very boring and hence they are dramatised to make it appealing for the audience. Dhonis biopic is example which became a huge part hit and on the other hand Sachin's biopic was made as a documentary and flopped.
Vikram Batra's biopic is very realistic and very emotional. Feel proud of army as an Indian to have heros like Captain Vikram Batra .
⭐ Vikrant Rona glimpse ⭐
Adding to this...
*Small little details were also kept in mind like there's a scene where a pakistani flag is on the ground nd our soldiers don't step on it..
*when pakistanis refused to take the bodies of their own soldiers, our indian soldiers did their last rites..
*dimple is really unmarried by choice nd still calls herself the widow of vikram batra..
Sully's cockpit scene is also without music and really helps you to feel the emotions of that moment.
Apparently, Jaby needs a fact check for the fact checked video 😂
The music gives it a more emotional connection to the story
When I See him. My eyes are filled with tears and my heart is filled with Pride. He is the best example of bravery. He will always be liVE in my heart. I just love him. Jay Hind.
No music being a risk is true as the music is a big part of the promotions for movies here
Yeah, I noticed that.
This was literally the hardest war in the history of mountain warfare. Indian army had to climb Himalayas while enemy where hiding on peak at a vantage point. They fought in adverse environmental conditions like extreme cold, lack of oxygen, fatigue etc.
Music is bollywood or in india is not just to listen and enjoy it as just as piece of art, but moreover a way to relate and go through that particular moment with the lyrics and music composed. We are familiar by the language and the words which actually mean and relate to that emotion. That's why music can't be excluded but has to be included as a emotional connect with audience
Even after 8 yrs of Indian film reactions, he still doesnt know anything about Indian emotions, art and culture. He knows only to do technical analysis with hollywood films and act as he is a oscar famous director🤣🤣
Without the music it wouldnt be as emotional atleast for me. Once u understand the lyrics it all makes sense and i always cry when the songs come up 😢❤
Jaby had a typical male ego 😂 too much fragile, never accepting that he might have got wrong, chill Jaby! Cool your jets mate! 😬
Exactly he tries to defend so much even if he knows he made a slip of tongue.he never admits
Exactly...
Σ male mindset
How male ego came in between if a women had done this would you call that women ego just stupid he has that kind of personality
I've been watching jaby for years I've never seen him saying I am sorry I made a mistake , that was wrong . So yeah , he has too much pride .
What you need to react next:
1. Shershaah behind the scenes (All parts)
2. Dimple Cheema's interview
3. Captain Naveen Nagappa's "Shershaah saved my life"
4. My Brother, My Pride: TedX Talk by Vishal Batra
5. Kargil - A Matter of Honour | Patriot with Major Gaurav Arya
With due respect to all these stories, they're not gonna watch 5 videos on the same topic, jeez.
Vikrant rona glimpse why he is not responding 😭😭😭😭
The quote "this heart desires more (yeh dil maange more" must be funny in the movie cuz it was pepsi's slogan and was unexpected to remember pepsi during a war.
Jaby said "you guys should end up this war cuz u r from same roots". jaby we did it so many times but their govt consistently did attack on india including terrorist attacks so how we could forget and move on? Last peace talk was beautifully done by late PM Atal bihari Vajpayee but within few months Pakistani army captured bunkers in Indian land. They want kashmir but invade on kargil which is in ladakh😅(attack on wrong place) so shershah movie is based upon kargil war.
I understand. I'm not blaming India by ANY means. I'm just saying I wish peace could be found.
The next India's best masterpiece Pan Indian movie Vikrant Rona teaser
Vikrant rona glimpse dead man anthem 💥💥💥
Dimple mam is very happy cherishing the memories of their relationship........ Kiara Advani told in an interview that she was very happy telling theur story to her.
According to me Jaby has every right to say what he did beacuse it is HIS REVIEW. Just wish Jaby had more belief behind the idea of a scene or a dialogue and trusted the maker's style of doing it
Mostly songs are a way to convey the feelings of a character or scene to a audience which makes easier for a viewer to understand 'em deeply or connect with 'em in that short running hours.
8:45 it was not a joke made by random fellows its kind of sledge and more like insult. In India we take seriously when some one bad mouth especially on women. The Pak soldier indirectly says that they can't be moved of that peak only way to do it is to give away that actress. Indian army is not a pimp exchange a women for victory. To counter his bad mouth he gave a fitted reply like a man.
I understand.
@@CineDesiif you understood the things you wouldn't be saying such things. Please behave like a matured guy in such emotional instances
12:05 They do carry paper cutting blades.
I can tell you that for sure, my brother is in armed forces and he carry paper cutter, 6' knife, kukhri and what not.
even in malls (off duty) he would not keep away his paper cutter.
he always have a blade.
Ok, that makes more sense of the scene then.
From next time jaby will be assistant director for every biopic.
Vikrant Rona Glimpse 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Vikrant rona trending at 1 from yesterday
10:39 correction. In the movie it is shown that Vikram ji held the duppata of his finance while doing parikarma of Guru Granth Sahib ji but in actual he held her duppata while doing parikrama of Nishan Sahib. So the fact is not told right.
You can listen his fiance telling that while doing parikarma of Nishan Sahib....
Dude the point is that it happened in a holy place, in gurudwara
@@vanshitasingh4523 here they were talking about facts. So I made the difference clear.
React to vikrant rona glimpse
This is also rarest for a man to be like Captain Vikram Batra PVC .
Vikrant rona glimpse reaction why he is not responding 😭😭😭😭
the songs are not just the songs, through them we Indians feel strong emotions and all the singers in this movie have a very strong voice..btw, loved your reaction..
Well it is common for a Defence personnel to keep shrap tools...
My dad is also an Airman ( Indian Air Force) he always carries one or two blade in his wallet, he always say don't take it out.. !!
when a Indian soldier says something about the war, its a line on stone😎
These are OUR soldiers, These are the soldiers who Smashed the Chinese troops in Galwan valley bare handed ❤️🔥
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
how about you shut up if you are not in the army?the soilders and there units and family can be proud of it. you on the internet just sound stupid.
Deep condolence for the US soldiers who died in Afghanistan airport bomb attack. May there soul rest in peace 🙏
You gave out condolences to the very people who destroyed the country ??
React to vikranth rona dead man's antham
The main problem is you are not accepting the fault of your review, and want to justify your review. After knowing this movie is a good tribute to Vikram Batra ji , you told that you like his story but not the movie. By the way if you recognise the meaning of these songs then you can also appreciate this. I just want to say that accept your faults.
Vikrant Rona 🔥🔥👍👍
Hi jaby react Vikrant Rona glimpse dead man's anthem 🔥 you got Goosebumps ❤️ 🤯. Hollywood level visual
Let's see how Jaby directs the movie without the music, he doesn't even believe some of the things in the movie which are facts.
What are you talking about? I think you're misinterpreting what I said.
@@CineDesi he is talking abt when u wanted to double check vikram's own words he said in front of tv camera. Do u think an officer was lying in front of tv camera where is CO sitting beside?
@@CineDesi just wish you could understand the god level lyrics of the songs. Without those lyrics you cannot connect to the music and its only cuz of that you are even saying all that
Dimple cheena was not his fiance. She herself clarified this misconception. They never got engaged.
@@roughnotes0033 pls dont spit lies..respect dimple maam and pvc vikram batra
@@roughnotes0033 mona? Dimples sister?
@@khushigupta3779 many of the people knows that @roughnotes00 family have some problems with dimple ma'am family.That's why this person spreads rumours on every vidio. Nd once exposed ... deleting the comment....nd used abusing comments about batra family.
@@allroundentertainment8821pls don't believe this fake person
@roughnotes00 . Bahat sare vidio me isne dimple ma'am n batra sir ki familey ke bareme bad comments kiyatha .he was lying about them coze roughnotes00 have some problems with Cheema familey n batra family. Jab uska jhut pakar gaya tab comments delet kardetehe.
@@allroundentertainment8821 mona is dimple mam n Vikram sir 's common friend .now she is in out of india
People used to keep Razor blades in Indian during the 90's as we didn't have Razors like we do now in Modern times. It used to be the older ones in trend that time, that people had to switch blades for each shave.
HOLLYWOOD:Let's make a movie to GLORIFY the USA as our SAVIOR(In Frictional World)
BOLLYWOOD: Let's make a Movie base on REAL STORY OF INDIAN ARMED FORCES
Music was so good .. Cause of music i cried so much. I not cry generally even in pain .. but music was really best
Wow. That's actually really cool to hear. The music in the last part of the film made me cry too actually.
@@CineDesi now, you see how subtly music plays an important role to a moment to precisely connect with the character's emotion and sometimes, silence between the characters with a background music leaves the impact which only a viewers can feel or know. I also feel if you knew hindi you wouldn't have this complain but i respect your honest opinion. Journey without song is boring 😁
Vikrant rona glimpse trending at 1 from yesterday 🔥😎
Guys your way of choosing stuff for reaction is very good .
Keep on doin it .
Music is inseparable part of commercial Indian movies. But the fact that the movie was not overly dramatized or fictionalized is very unique to Indian cinema.
Few Indian cinemas are only made for art and their objective is not to make money but to showcase the art of cinema. Such kind of cinemas which are called as art cinema or parallel cinema mostly doesn't contain any music, even if it is there then it will be like a radio or a gramophone or a stuff like that playing in the background.
In India, an actor who works in art cinema is called a real actor and hence several actors, who wants to prove themselves as good actor at least once in a lifetime work in an art film.
Anyhow, art films or parallel cinema is almost dead in India and if at all they are made then it will be mostly or primarily for national or international awards. This is because of two things, first because of multiplexes which do not show such movies and secondly because of too many TV channels. In good old days when only two channels DD national and DD metro were available then people were forced to watch art movies because there was no third choice, either they watch the movie or shut the TV.
Shershaah is the best movie in this year.........it makes all Indians feel more proud for our nation and soldiers ....and their family who motivates their children 🙏❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Only for bollywood... For South there are other movies
Pls Vikrant rona glimpse 😭😭😭😭😭
Make a video on vikrant rona glimpse the dead man's anthem pure goosebumps 🙏💯💯💯💯💯
Music and songs are extremely important part if the storytelling. And because of the difference in culture and language it is justified that you can't connect and understand the movie, which is okay. But honestly people who understand the movie and songs would definitely appreciate the movie.
Vikrant rona glimpse why he is not responding
Vikrant Rona dead man's anthem glimpse reaction please 🔥
Shershah is throwing a hand grenade and jaby thinks that he was joking 🤦🏻♂️
Never said he was joking.
@@CineDesi you don't have to joke about it verbally to actually make a mockery out of it just because you're unfamiliar with it. Your behaviour / body language / eyes told the truth.
7:05 sorry they didn’t have phone recorders in 1999 at 16000ft and the other side didn’t even accept their bodies so, i don’t know a way to corroborate that other than believing him and his fellow soldiers.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🤣 Vikrant rona glimpse reaction
We can't connect without music the same way you can't connect with music. It's sad to see you saying this again and again even after reviewing so many bollywood trailers and movies. Every country and its people are different I just wish you'd respect that. The film is made in Bollywood and music plays a vital role.
I'm not disrespecting that. I'm saying what I would have done different. It's that simple. I don't see why it's not okay to give my honest feelings.
The point is that he keep on saying the same thing from the last 8 yrs from the time he started reviewing bollywood and Indian movies. There is nothing new or interesting in his reviews nowadays. Even he knows music is an integral part of Indian movies
@meghana Songs disturb flow of story in almost every movie and atrocious background score destroys any movie for example, when @JabyKoay slammed RUSTAM for it's background score, he was right.
@@CineDesi 😅 don't worry lady didn't offended she just saying after 4 5 years of consuming Indian content still it's hits you Defrently than indian and it's Facinating to see that after this all years the place where you grow up 100% matter with how would you react to certain things😁 💚
Sorry for spelling mistakes
Speak for yourself please. Not everyone is fine with 'dhoom tananaa' in the background or unnecessary songs in the middle of the story.
Bollywood movies without music., impossible.
Come on dude react to Vikrant Rona Dead man's anthem glimpse 🔥
My favorite reaction video from my 3 yrs association with this channel. Love
Vikrant rona glimpse reaction
Jaby and Achara I would like to add on to the dil mange more line.. This advertisement came during 1999 cricket World Cup in the UK. On 16th June 1999 india faced Pakistan in the World Cup match which india went on to win… Indian Army was on a war against Pakistan during that time..
no offence to jaby,
but restoring peace between India and Pakistan is not easy as it seems. Previous attempts to reach an agreement have all faltered, often after highly-charged summit meetings.
Oh by no means do I think it is easy. By no means at all. But one can hope.
@@CineDesi yeah.. one can hope tho☺
@@CineDesi hope that only a fake thing we can "Hope"
@@CineDesi with Pakistan?
Hell no
The country who supports terrorism and all the bad stuffs will never agree upon peace. Can't have false hopes.
I urge any bollywood producer to give jaby a chance to make the 1st background scoreless and musicless bollywood movie😆😆🤣
I wonder what blood group he has that he doesnt feel the pump from the fantastic background score😉
Why dont Jaby realise that Vikram himself was a bollywood movie buff and a music lover
I wish they showed that in the movie.
@@CineDesi the movie would had been dragged beyond 2.5 hrs and critics might had given a spoiler that the movie could had been cut short.
@@CineDesi in this movie, siddharth who has played His charecheter has conveyed so many famous iconic Bollywood movie dialogues of 80s and 90s Bollywood movies..ofcourse u couldn't understand because it was subtitled in English nd when u subtitle hindi dialogues in English it doesn't make sense nd ofcourse u are not familiar with 60s 70s 80s 90s and early 20s Bollywood movie culture so plz try to understand that u will not be satisfied with any Indian content fully because its quite impossible to catch up emotions about Indian content if u are not Indian...
Music is an integral part of Indian people as such it well rooted to Indian culture, emotions and sentiments. You wont feel connected to the music becoz unlike Achara u are totally unware of the subtle nuances of hindi vocabulary, or seldom tries to understand the nuances. You only judge from ur own technical perspective which is not true for Indian movies. We are not here to compete with American films. Films here are made to connect Indian audiences.
@bleh u r a bootlicker of jaby koay and a pakistani😉
Jaby you should watch LOC Kargil it's a full story and we'll described every character. We have many hero's of Kargil war and the movie was perfectly made to tribute their sacrifice.
I studied in the same college and I feel proud of that
Why jaby ,why are you not responding,we are asking response to Vikranth Rona glimpse please man please😫🙏🙏💓 also I think you don't read comments because iam trying since last 3 vedioes to reach you but.
You cannot understand the significance of music in Indian movies, especially in this movies without knowing the language and without being INDIAN.
In indian movies music is not used entirely for entertainment purposes…every situation in the movie.. has a happy song or a festive song for feel good scenes with lyrics expressing those feelings about dat particular situation same goes to the sad songs…as a South Indian i had a very hard time learning to speak hindi..these songs were a bridge for ppl like me to learn different languages..n understand the feelings..in a way its d promotion of culture n various other things…
12:05 earlier we used to use blades to open small packets cause we had less packets with those curves to open them! as my dad told, he used to carry one too in his wallet to open packets and stuff!
Vikrant Rona glimpse the dead man anthem 🔥🔥🔥
Music 🎶 is an integral part of Indians lives from centuries. We have so much variety of music. From centuries common people across villages sing folk songs to represent various emotions and stories.
Even Vedic scriptures contain verses which have musical tones. Like Bhagwad geeta etc.
See Vikrant Rona glimpse on T Series. Its ultimate
Whew, I am so relieved that Sid played this role, instead of Salmaan's bro-in-law
react on vikrant rona glimpse please
My grandfather was in the army and he always still carries blade in his wallet. Maybe it's a thing.
Yeah, about the 2 soldiers from opposing armies..it’s true, maybe they could have been friends, war horse has something like this too where 2 people from opposite armies come together to free a horse that’s in the trenches and have a heartwarming exchange but go back to fight again after the horse is freed😔