I have just finished this book around 30 minutes ago. I have never read a more captivating book that is still relevant today. Absolutely an amazing read 10/10
Thanks Gareth. Reading this as an adult had more of an impact on me than when I read it as a teenager. An incredibly depressing, yet phenomenally powerful story.
Literally correcttt, but i didn't regret reading it, he can really express almost everything with a word, the beggining, middle of story and the end is literally... idk what to say
8:31 orwell admits that the whole julia/winston love angle was orwell engaging in a bit of middle aged male fantasy. I think the reason to me personally at least, that the reason why julia's motivations and actions are 2-d, kinda static, and dont make logical sense is because, quite frankly, orwell wrote her more as a fantasy for him, than a character for his book... I mean look im not a great author or anything, feel free to take what i say as dismissively as you like, or take it seriously, up to you.. (readers discretion) but i mean... Doesnt julia feel like a character written by say, a incel male trying to highlight what he values about feminine traits, instead of, well, actual character dev? It feels like when he wrote julia he had little interest in stepping into her shoes, and instead focuses on the feelings she illicits from winston. But thats just my feeling, i welcome opposing opinions (seriously, im in college studying english lit, it would actually be beneficial to me to hear opposing opinions about this book's characters, so go ahead... lemme have it! 😁👍)
The novel would have benefited from Julia's perspective as a woman on the oppression she faced, and the feelings behind her choices. I just assumed that Orwell wanted us to focus solely on Winston's plight as the main character, and everyone else was complimentary to that plight. Your feelings and views are appreciated, and 100% valid on this channel - thank you for sharing :)
I read this as an adult. Phenomenal book… I think there are few books as important as this one. Some of what’s going on today makes me think of it, actually. Great, great review.
That was a compelling review. I’ve read it, not as a student but long enough not to remember it well. I’ve also read _We_ so I suppose the only major dystopian classic I have yet to tackle would be _Brave New World._
Great analysis. It was also great having you as part of our 1984 Voxer Group. I hope MJ does a Live Group Chat at month's end, and that youre a oart of that, too 😮🎉😅 Thanks, Fred.
Love your review. I also read it long ago in school. I don't remember much except it was depressing. Recently, I read the graphic novel version. I can't say I really enjoyed it. It was grim. It was interesting. The art was well done. Based upon your review, I now know that the graphic novel version was accurate to the original novel. After reading the graphic novel, I am not planning on reading the original novel again.
1984 was definitely grim. I need to really read up on George Orwell - this novel and Animal Farm were depressingly amazing - I need to understand his mindset.
As the novel nears its end and Winston is captured, the pages are running out. It’s as though the book itself is conspiring with the Party, physically giving you less and less space for hope or resolution. You gradually come to realise Winston's fate is inevitable.
There really are some stories that stick with you and don’t need re-reading. As far as belief goes, I think Orwell had the same insight as Hannah Arendt - in a total propaganda environment, people come not to believe in anything. They say and do what they need to and otherwise just disengage.
I'm reading it for probably the 3 rd time and I understand more every time. Your constantly watched with at least your cell phone and pay to be monitored.
The third time?! Wow, I think twice is enough for me. I really appreciated it more now as an adult. Having a better understanding of the world today really makes this novel an important read.
This book should be a warning sign of when things start to go bad, but unfortunately seems to be used as a guide book in some countries. Such as shame.
I have just finished this book around 30 minutes ago. I have never read a more captivating book that is still relevant today. Absolutely an amazing read 10/10
I'm happy to hear you enjoyed it. :)
Great review! The free world needs a reminder now than ever. Good old Orwell is doing just that.
Thanks! I really appreciated this novel - a must read indeed :)
I think you're right; it's important to read it as an adult. Great review. It's an incredibly important book. Great video Fred.
Thanks Gareth. Reading this as an adult had more of an impact on me than when I read it as a teenager. An incredibly depressing, yet phenomenally powerful story.
Literally correcttt, but i didn't regret reading it, he can really express almost everything with a word, the beggining, middle of story and the end is literally... idk what to say
Great review, thanks for sharing your rereading experience.
Thanks! The novel was so much better for me reading it as an adult.
8:31 orwell admits that the whole julia/winston love angle was orwell engaging in a bit of middle aged male fantasy. I think the reason to me personally at least, that the reason why julia's motivations and actions are 2-d, kinda static, and dont make logical sense is because, quite frankly, orwell wrote her more as a fantasy for him, than a character for his book... I mean look im not a great author or anything, feel free to take what i say as dismissively as you like, or take it seriously, up to you.. (readers discretion) but i mean... Doesnt julia feel like a character written by say, a incel male trying to highlight what he values about feminine traits, instead of, well, actual character dev? It feels like when he wrote julia he had little interest in stepping into her shoes, and instead focuses on the feelings she illicits from winston. But thats just my feeling, i welcome opposing opinions (seriously, im in college studying english lit, it would actually be beneficial to me to hear opposing opinions about this book's characters, so go ahead... lemme have it! 😁👍)
The novel would have benefited from Julia's perspective as a woman on the oppression she faced, and the feelings behind her choices. I just assumed that Orwell wanted us to focus solely on Winston's plight as the main character, and everyone else was complimentary to that plight.
Your feelings and views are appreciated, and 100% valid on this channel - thank you for sharing :)
I read this as an adult. Phenomenal book… I think there are few books as important as this one. Some of what’s going on today makes me think of it, actually. Great, great review.
Very happy I decided to re-read this as an adult. I definitely appreciate it more.
That was a compelling review. I’ve read it, not as a student but long enough not to remember it well. I’ve also read _We_ so I suppose the only major dystopian classic I have yet to tackle would be _Brave New World._
I've have rarely read a book which has impacted me so profoundly after I finished it. 1984 was such a book.
Great review, Fred. I read this in 1984, but it's long overdue for a reread.
It's a buzz kill, but wow, what a powerful message.
@@ReadbyFred it's a buzz kill that guys really close to home these days
Awesome review. I’ll have to read this soon. It does sound like a good book.
It will make you feel depressed and demoralized (at least it did with me), but the novel is so well written.
It is an important one. As the T shirt says to the effect of - 1984 wasn't supposed to be a manual!
It’s not worth it
Great analysis. It was also great having you as part of our 1984 Voxer Group. I hope MJ does a Live Group Chat at month's end, and that youre a oart of that, too 😮🎉😅 Thanks, Fred.
Thanks Allen! I'm glad I was able to take part and reread this novel 😀
@@ReadbyFred Cool. MJ's organizing a Live Show next Saturday (I think) and I hope you can take part in that, too. 😎🤔🤓
Love your review. I also read it long ago in school. I don't remember much except it was depressing. Recently, I read the graphic novel version. I can't say I really enjoyed it. It was grim. It was interesting. The art was well done. Based upon your review, I now know that the graphic novel version was accurate to the original novel. After reading the graphic novel, I am not planning on reading the original novel again.
1984 was definitely grim. I need to really read up on George Orwell - this novel and Animal Farm were depressingly amazing - I need to understand his mindset.
Cracking stuff. The crazy thing is that Orwell also wrote Animal Farm. How does one guy strike gold twice?
Both were excellent works. I've got to pick up his memoirs! :)
I love this! I just ordered this for christmas and I'm ready to read it! I'm 13 but passionate about the theme that 1984 is about!
I hope you enjoy the novel :)
Thanks
Reading it as 14 years old.. literally speechless for the book..
As the novel nears its end and Winston is captured, the pages are running out. It’s as though the book itself is conspiring with the Party, physically giving you less and less space for hope or resolution. You gradually come to realise Winston's fate is inevitable.
That's really good! I never considered it from that angle. Very powerful novel - I'm glad I re-read it as an adult.
I read 1984 when I was a teenager as well. It opened my eyes to the world and the Orwellian forces at work in the world as well.
It is definitely a powerful novel, and one that I appreciate more now as an adult than I did as a teenager in high school. Very happy I (re)read it :)
There really are some stories that stick with you and don’t need re-reading.
As far as belief goes, I think Orwell had the same insight as Hannah Arendt - in a total propaganda environment, people come not to believe in anything. They say and do what they need to and otherwise just disengage.
I am definitely glad that I re-read it as an adult.
George's brother was a raving communist. Can imagine what their Thanksgivings would be like.
I'm reading it for probably the 3 rd time and I understand more every time. Your constantly watched with at least your cell phone and pay to be monitored.
The third time?! Wow, I think twice is enough for me. I really appreciated it more now as an adult. Having a better understanding of the world today really makes this novel an important read.
lol the end of this is ironic in 8.3.2024
This book should be a warning sign of when things start to go bad, but unfortunately seems to be used as a guide book in some countries. Such as shame.