This is one of the most useful videos I've ever watched. I'm preparing for my Exam question tomorrow on International Security and R2P norm solely based on this video. Thank you so much for this golden information korczyk!!!!
This video really explains this difficult topic in an organized and well structured way, all the while delivering a certain amount of depht. Well done, thank you so much!
i have a copy of the responsibility to protect i worked with STand Canada a student anti genocide coalition i learned the six un languages Arabic Chinese English French Russian and Spanish انا اعملي في ستند كندا اتا ادرس يتحدي افي صبلة لغت امم المتحدة 我工种族节目决留于联合国阿拉伯语i中文英语法语恶露戏班与 je me etudes les six languesde s Dstand canads stand Canada Я учил станд канада дивижене против геноцид Yo estudiando sei siudiomas de naciones Arabes SInia Ingles Frances Rusia espanol stand anad acoalition genociido and stand canada
This is not R2P this is R2U Resposibility to protect europe. not to Asia....we feel like this is not l Responsibily to protect. us...Even myanmar is UN member...Shame on you R2P...
This entire R2P concept is predicated upon a huge category error. The decision for war is always - always - a political decision. It cannot be converted into a legal obligation by UN fiat. Political decisions are never consistent. Also, the concept of "international community" is a legal fiction. There is no such community with the military resources to respond. In practice, R2P was implicitly an American responsibility rooted in the US president's power to command over the head of Congress. The nations most in favor of this concept (Europe, Australia, NZ) simply will not develop the capability to enforce it. Thus they remove it to the realm of American politics where they may be safely isolated from its impacts.
Great video and explanation. Thank you very much. But I disagree with Kaddafi issue. They just used R2P as a weapon against a great leader who stayed on the path of the West.
thanks for this! I'm a junior at Princeton University writing my JP on R2P. This really helped jump start my understanding of R2P and think of questions I should address. Is it okay if I acknowledge you in my paper? All the best!
I'm so glad it was helpful! You certainly can... but depending on your assignment, I don't know if your prof would be too impressed with a TH-cam video in a citation. I do, however, have links to all the sources I referenced in the video posted in the comments - For your benefit I would suggest using those... especially the actual R2P document published by the ICISS would be a good source to reference in a paper. :) It's not too difficult of a read.
Hey thank you! It's so well explained and illustrated. I am teaching R2P in class today and this will really help my students. Keep up the great work 👍🏻
But there are important steps that need to be taken before a humanitarian mission can get on the way. Important discussions about other concerns need to take place first. Otherwise, R2P humanitarian missions can lead to disasters, like of which we have witnessed before. So sometimes, humanitarian issues have to be held back until those important questions have been addressed sufficiently.
@@KorczyksClass Another event to think about: 1) TEN YEARS AGO: THE GHOUTA CHEMICAL ATTACK • On August 21, 2013, a chemical attack took place in the Ghouta region of Syria. The attack killed hundreds of people and injured thousands more. The attack was carried out using sarin gas, a deadly nerve agent. • The GCA was a horrific event that reminds us of the stupidity of war. In war, people are manipulated to fight, die, and kill for unknown reasons. Innocent people are killed, and soldiers fight against what they think they are fighting for. • The GCA also proves that the US government's principles of defending human rights and democracy are a facade. The US government is more interested in protecting its corporate interests than in protecting human rights or democracy. The US government has supported non-democratic governments that violate human rights as long as those governments preserve the US's corporate interests. • The GCA is a sad and shameful example of what can happen when societies go to war. It is a crime against humanity that no one has taken responsibility for. The attack was an unnecessary action that did not solve the conflict. Instead, it made reconciliation harder to achieve. • The GCA is an event that we should remember and learn from. It is a call to find the real beneficiaries of preserving conflicts. It is time to make the final war: war against war. • The GCA is also a reminder of the importance of peace and reconciliation. We must work to find a peaceful solution to the Syrian Civil War and to prevent future conflicts. • Here are some additional thoughts on the GCA: • The GCA was a major turning point in the Syrian Civil War. The attack led to increased international pressure on the Syrian government and to calls for military intervention. • The GCA also led to a debate about the use of chemical weapons in warfare. The international community condemned the use of chemical weapons, and the Syrian government was forced to give up its chemical weapons stockpile. • The GCA is a reminder of the importance of preventing future chemical attacks. The international community needs to strengthen the Chemical Weapons Convention and to improve early warning systems. • The GCA is also a reminder of the importance of peace and reconciliation. We must work to find a peaceful solution to the Syrian Civil War and to prevent future conflicts. We must never forget the victims of the GCA. We must also never forget the lessons that this event teaches us. We must work to prevent future wars and to build a more peaceful world
This is one of the most useful videos I've ever watched. I'm preparing for my Exam question tomorrow on International Security and R2P norm solely based on this video. Thank you so much for this golden information korczyk!!!!
I'm glad it helped. I hope the exam went well!
This video really explains this difficult topic in an organized and well structured way, all the while delivering a certain amount of depht. Well done, thank you so much!
Glad it was helpful! Thank you!
That music❤❤❤just loved the sad background music.
I was feeling that music more than your info
😂
this helped me understand this topic so much more. thank you so much
Glad it helped!
Thank you. It helped me in my International Law course term-presentation.
Glad it helped! Best of luck in your course!
great ! it's a very good job !
Thank you! I'm glad you found it helpful!
United Nation Security Council to consider
「上記のギフトのいずれかを選択できます」、
i have a copy of the responsibility to protect i worked with STand Canada a student anti genocide coalition i learned the six un languages Arabic Chinese English French Russian and Spanish انا اعملي في ستند كندا اتا ادرس يتحدي افي صبلة لغت امم المتحدة 我工种族节目决留于联合国阿拉伯语i中文英语法语恶露戏班与 je me etudes les six languesde s Dstand canads stand Canada Я учил станд канада дивижене против геноцид Yo estudiando sei siudiomas de naciones Arabes SInia Ingles Frances Rusia espanol stand anad acoalition genociido and stand canada
This is not R2P this is R2U Resposibility to protect europe. not to Asia....we feel like this is not l Responsibily to protect. us...Even myanmar is UN member...Shame on you R2P...
အာတူးပီ ဆိုတာ ကုလ စစ်တပ် ဆိုပြီး ဘာဖြစ်လို့ လူသတ် လက်နက် ကိုင်ဆောင်ထားပြီး တစ်ကမ္ဘာလုံး ကို ဝင်ရောက် စွတ် ဖက် ရတာလည်း စိတ်ခံစားမှုဖြင့်ဆက်သွယ်ပြီး အဖြေပေး ပါ
This entire R2P concept is predicated upon a huge category error. The decision for war is always - always - a political decision. It cannot be converted into a legal obligation by UN fiat. Political decisions are never consistent.
Also, the concept of "international community" is a legal fiction. There is no such community with the military resources to respond. In practice, R2P was implicitly an American responsibility rooted in the US president's power to command over the head of Congress. The nations most in favor of this concept (Europe, Australia, NZ) simply will not develop the capability to enforce it. Thus they remove it to the realm of American politics where they may be safely isolated from its impacts.
Great video and explanation. Thank you very much. But I disagree with Kaddafi issue. They just used R2P as a weapon against a great leader who stayed on the path of the West.
I am Rohingya I must give security R2P.
Welcome back! Love this video. Thanks for the document sourced you write under the video. It helps mi to find this in polish
Awesome, thank you! It's been a busy summer. 😉
thanks for this! I'm a junior at Princeton University writing my JP on R2P. This really helped jump start my understanding of R2P and think of questions I should address. Is it okay if I acknowledge you in my paper?
All the best!
I'm so glad it was helpful! You certainly can... but depending on your assignment, I don't know if your prof would be too impressed with a TH-cam video in a citation. I do, however, have links to all the sources I referenced in the video posted in the comments - For your benefit I would suggest using those... especially the actual R2P document published by the ICISS would be a good source to reference in a paper. :) It's not too difficult of a read.
A general acknowledgement is definitely totally fine though! :)
Sounds great and thank you for the advice!
UDHR Protects All the Nation under human crisis
Hey thank you! It's so well explained and illustrated. I am teaching R2P in class today and this will really help my students. Keep up the great work 👍🏻
So glad you found it helpful! :)
love your content!! Making my learning more interesting
Happy to hear that!
R2P
Thank you very much. This video was really helpful in explaining (R2P).
Glad it was helpful!
But there are important steps that need to be taken before a humanitarian mission can get on the way. Important discussions about other concerns need to take place first. Otherwise, R2P humanitarian missions can lead to disasters, like of which we have witnessed before. So sometimes, humanitarian issues have to be held back until those important questions have been addressed sufficiently.
Thank you so much, well explained.
Glad it was helpful!
I am so glad to find you on youtube!
Glad it was helpful!
Quite clear. Thank you. Thank you so much.
You're very welcome! Thank you!
@@KorczyksClass Another event to think about: 1) TEN YEARS AGO: THE GHOUTA CHEMICAL ATTACK
• On August 21, 2013, a chemical attack took place in the Ghouta region of Syria. The attack killed hundreds of people and injured thousands more. The attack was carried out using sarin gas, a deadly nerve agent.
• The GCA was a horrific event that
reminds us of the stupidity of war. In war, people are manipulated to fight, die, and kill for unknown reasons. Innocent people are killed, and soldiers fight against what they think they are fighting for.
• The GCA also proves that the US government's principles of defending human rights and democracy are a facade. The US government is more interested in protecting its corporate interests than in protecting human rights or democracy. The US government has supported non-democratic governments that violate human rights as long as those governments preserve the US's corporate interests.
• The GCA is a sad and shameful example of what can happen when societies go to war. It is a crime against humanity that no one has taken responsibility for. The attack was an unnecessary action that did not solve the conflict. Instead, it made reconciliation harder to achieve.
• The GCA is an event that we should remember and learn from. It is a call to find the real beneficiaries of preserving conflicts. It is time to make the final war: war against war.
• The GCA is also a reminder of the importance of peace and reconciliation. We must work to find a peaceful solution to the Syrian Civil War and to prevent future conflicts.
• Here are some additional thoughts on the GCA:
• The GCA was a major turning point in the Syrian Civil War. The attack led to increased international pressure on the Syrian government and to calls for military intervention.
• The GCA also led to a debate about the use of chemical weapons in warfare. The international community condemned the use of chemical weapons, and the Syrian government was forced to give up its chemical weapons stockpile.
• The GCA is a reminder of the importance of preventing future chemical attacks. The international community needs to strengthen the Chemical Weapons Convention and to improve early warning systems.
• The GCA is also a reminder of the importance of peace and reconciliation. We must work to find a peaceful solution to the Syrian Civil War and to prevent future conflicts.
We must never forget the victims of the GCA. We must also never forget the lessons that this event teaches us. We must work to prevent future wars and to build a more peaceful world
Guin maynmmar R2P Or Rohingay
Maynmmar Rohingay in junsit r2p oaka
Awsom video.
Thanks!