Doc, *PLEASE* make these videos more frequently! (Maybe a video weekly) This is highly interesting as a medical student and to have your opinion about this makes it even better
Great video and idea by the doc, but that snap sound was soul crunching 😰 I immediately thought Broken Femur, the way his upper thigh collapsed was kinda the nail in-the coffin.
Hey everyone! I just wanted to share some good news with you all. Let's just put it this way, the Ten Commandments are called the Moral Law. Ask yourself this. How many lies have you told? Have you ever stolen anything? Have you ever used God's name in vein? Have you ever hated someone or ever looked with lust? This is for you to judge yourself, but chances are that you are a lying, thieving, blasphemous, fornicating, adulterer at heart and you HAVE to face God on judgement day. Now ask yourself this. If God judges you on judgement day by these Commandments, will you be innocent or guilty? Of course you'll be guilty because we've all done these things. The truth is that none of us are good people and we NEED God's grace to make it to heaven. We judt simply cannot do it on our own. These Commandments arecalled the Moral Law. You and I broke the law, Jesus payed the fine. So now what we must do to be saved is to repent of our sins and trust alone in Jesus Christ!! To repent doesn't mean to just say I'm sorry, but to turn to Jesus and let Him truly be our Lord continually. If He is our Lord, He will lead us away from sin and into righteousness. He said that many will say to Him, Lord, Lord I have done all of these things for you. And He will say I never knew you. Depart from Me, ye who work iniquity! And those will be cast into outer darkness and raging hellfire and loneliness for all of eternity!!! Because we broke His law, He is very, very just to send us to hell. If someone had murdered 4 people and said to the judge, I've done nice things too and have tried to treat people nice but it was just one time, the judge would then say, okay but you're going to jail. And the judge is very just to do that. One last thing, if you were 10,000 feet in the air and you had to jump, you wouldn't jump out and flap your arms and try to save yourself. That's ridiculous! You would put on the parachute. It is the same with Jesus. You must trust Him as you trust the parachute. We are not good and we cannot save ourselves with our own goodness. We must trust alone in Him to save us. In just a moment of time you can pass from death to life. Jesus said, "Verily, verily I say unto you, you must be born again." That is how we enter heaven. Through the blood and grace of Jesus Christ!!!!✝️If you ask someone how to enter Heaven, they will most likely say, "Be a good person." Well the Bible says that none is good, no not one. We like to compare ourselves to guys like Hitler and say, "Hey, I'm a pretty good guy compared to him." But when we compare ourselves to God's standard, we realize that the Bible speaks truth when it says that we all sinned and fallen short of the Glory of God!!! When we see this ( our sin in its TRUE light), we see how much trouble we are in and we say, "Well then there's nothing I can do. I'm going to hell for sure then." It's true that there is nothing that WE can do, but there is something that has already been done for you! God sent His One and Only Son to die on a cross as a sacrifice for our sins! So to recieve that eternal sweet sweet forgiveness, all we must do is repent of our sins (meaning to continually turn from them and confess them) and trust alone in Christ as you trust a parachute. If I was to push you out of an airplane, you'd want the parachute for sure! Don't try to flap your arms and save yourself, trust in the parachute! His finished work on the Cross IS ENOUGH!! He is the only way to Heaven, He said it Himself!! These other religions teach that we must he good and do good things and then maybe if we've been good enough, we will enter Heaven. But if that is true then we are all doomed to eternal hell because none of us are good. That's why this makes sense. Look at the Ten Commandments, they are written on your heart right now!! I promise that you have violated them. And you might still be doing that today. Therefore God is just to poor out His wrath on us because we deserve it!!! But Christ died for us so that we can spend eternity in Heaven with Him! Turn to Him today, and He and only He will save your soul "Verily, verily I say unto you, you must be born again ( to go to Heaven)."✝️The true joy of Christ dwells in me!!! Does it in you? I know where I'm going when I die! Do you? I have an ETERNAL victory! Do you? I have more joy than ever because of what Christ has done. I have been down both roads. The road of the wicked and the road of Christ. Christ is way better and my cup runneth over with true joy and salvation. If you do not know the One true God and are not sure of your salvation, I promise He will never fail you. Turn to Him in repentance and faith. Repent means to confess and forsake your sins, never turning back to them. I tried changing on my own but I couldn't. It took the power of Christ on the inside of me to do it for me. He will give you a new and clean heart with new and clean desires and you shall be born again. A new creation in Christ Jesus!!! Hallelujah!!!! Jesus said in order to enter the Kingdom of God, you must be born again!! Thank you Lord Jesus!✝️
My knee also pops like that first one from time to time. It's just the same as cracking your knuckles, so it doesn't hurt or anything at all. But people usually let go when it happens and give up positions, so I'm honestly finding it pretty nifty
That pop was incredibly different from just popping your knees like with your knuckles. That was the pop of damage being done. Not just gas bubbles escaping from a joint
Ruptured lateral femural ligament which encompasses balance and stability for the femur. I ruptured my rectus femoris and you could here similar things around the he knee and popping sound around the hip. Old soccer days
I went with hip dislocation initially since on first watch it looked like the torsion forces on the end of the femur caused it to pop out of the pelvis towards the mat, but as usual I suspect you were spot on. When you did the frame-by-frame, it does look like the injury occurred higher up in the thigh than I thought, which is definitely unfortunate for this gentleman
My Guess, at 1:30, based off of the reaction, seeing no leg snapped in half. I believe it was a snap of the fibula. Due to the excessive amount of compression going through the bone. I think a full snap of the fibula. There’s definitely damage to the tubular walls and connections to the ankle joint. This is me MD from TH-cam university. Irl i am a Certified EMR
I am thinking a hip dislocation because when I straighten my thigh out twisted it while flexing my thigh, I can feel a lot of tension in the joint. In addition, I do not think that the forces generated perpendicular to the bone or around its axis would be sufficient to cause either a transverse or spiral fracture respectively with the sound that it makes made me think it wasn't a fracture. Since the hip is the closest joint in the area we see the bone poking out, I believe it is that joint which was affected.
I would have said a femur break but the forces used for that to happen are usually quite large. To the point that I don’t know of many femoral breaks that didn’t happen due to catastrophic car crashes. I honestly thought that it was the sound of the femur leaving the socket, might be wrong though
This is great, it's a really engaging way to not just learn, but apply knowledge. I was thinking hip dislocation at first, but then saw where he grabbed and thought his femur just broke (which is wild).
Can you do a video on Carlos Correa ankle surgery? Last year when stealing a base he hit his ankle and said he was hit in the ankle hardware and felt it go numb and vibrate. And then he was fine. I am wondering if this is what spooked the giants
Green stick fracture or hip dislocation, was my first thought. Then saw the video, and went with the former. A neighbour, drunkly fell over outside my house a few years back. As he went down he put his right hand out on to the top of our wall - as he kept falling it trapped his arm between him and the wall. It forced it to externally rotate until it snapped the humerus, I heard the snap and the thud in the house. It sheared the bone about a 1/4-1/3 of the way from the shoulder. As I was trying to splint it and get it in a sling, he was so drunk that he could tell he was still trying to move it - it moved like that leg. If he’d been anymore sober, he’d have been in agony, but after the fact, he did himself a favour by being so black-out drunk as to have zero recollection of the whole incident. He just woke up in hospital with his arm set and in a side-brace cast. 🤷♂️
I thought initially femur fracture on first view, but was hoping for hip dislocation, but the deformation was too distal to the hip (Was I right to use distal here?) Femur fractures are scary!
I had been thinking there was a hip dislocation or a fracture to the femoral head. But it makes a ton of sense why it was probably more in the middle of the bone, rather than at the joint.
Portuguese med student here, a bit of a harder challenge here! My first guess would be a hip fracture/deslocation. We can clearly see his leg shift and hear a big *pop* sound, and the socket were the femur sits is a place that sometimes is susceptible to injury, specially through repetitive stress, like maybe in that wrestling position Second guess maybe a femur fracture, but the femur is a really strong bone and there doesn't seem to be enough force to break a bone like that. Hope I'm right ✌️ love your work Dr. Brian and happy holidays for everyone!
I thought it was a hip dislocation, thought there was no way something so simple could break a femur! Lesson learned; bones aren’t good under rotational pressure
@briansuttererMD I don't know if you'll see this but can you do a video on Byron Jones popping his knee back into place during the Cowboys vs Jets game a few years ago
I thought he dislocated his knee. Also, what the hell submission was he going for? That's sooooo not how you secure a triangle choke or any other submission I can think of
I don't think that technique can cause a femoral fracture without a preexisting issue as well. I'm gonna go with hip dislocation. Proper application requires you to use your opponent's head, not your own leg as a lever. Basic white belt mistake. Great vids.
I thought it was an postero superior hip dislocation , but watching frame by frame i see that not the wholebone goes backwards so a fracture would be the better guess
Broken tibia or femur - femur is the biggest strongest bone in the body & if he broke that, he better get a round of blood tests taken for any malignancies or deficiencies.
I’m not even sure why he was trying to grab his ankle or foot? if he wants to finish this submission, he needs to get the good angle by grabbing under the leg or arm on the other side... (right leg or right arm of his opponent) The pressure he was putting on his own leg was probably painful even before the break.
Guessing hip dislocation because of that nasty backwards motion of the thigh, and I don’t think the forces are strong enough to actually fracture the femur….. Edit: damn, that was brutal. Learned something about bone structures today.
![UCF Professor Richard Quinn accuses class of cheating [Original]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rbzJTTDO9f4/mqdefault.jpg)
Comment below with what YOU think happened
I think he got hurt
Fracture of neck of femur, my best guess.
bronchitis
My wife - a family medicine doctor in residency and interested in sports medicine certification - loves these videos.
Either a hip dislocation or femoral fracture.
Doc, *PLEASE* make these videos more frequently! (Maybe a video weekly) This is highly interesting as a medical student and to have your opinion about this makes it even better
Great video and idea by the doc, but that snap sound was soul crunching 😰 I immediately thought Broken Femur, the way his upper thigh collapsed was kinda the nail in-the coffin.
Hey everyone! I just wanted to share some good news with you all. Let's just put it this way, the Ten Commandments are called the Moral Law. Ask yourself this. How many lies have you told? Have you ever stolen anything? Have you ever used God's name in vein? Have you ever hated someone or ever looked with lust? This is for you to judge yourself, but chances are that you are a lying, thieving, blasphemous, fornicating, adulterer at heart and you HAVE to face God on judgement day. Now ask yourself this. If God judges you on judgement day by these Commandments, will you be innocent or guilty? Of course you'll be guilty because we've all done these things. The truth is that none of us are good people and we NEED God's grace to make it to heaven. We judt simply cannot do it on our own. These Commandments arecalled the Moral Law. You and I broke the law, Jesus payed the fine. So now what we must do to be saved is to repent of our sins and trust alone in Jesus Christ!! To repent doesn't mean to just say I'm sorry, but to turn to Jesus and let Him truly be our Lord continually. If He is our Lord, He will lead us away from sin and into righteousness. He said that many will say to Him, Lord, Lord I have done all of these things for you. And He will say I never knew you. Depart from Me, ye who work iniquity! And those will be cast into outer darkness and raging hellfire and loneliness for all of eternity!!! Because we broke His law, He is very, very just to send us to hell. If someone had murdered 4 people and said to the judge, I've done nice things too and have tried to treat people nice but it was just one time, the judge would then say, okay but you're going to jail. And the judge is very just to do that. One last thing, if you were 10,000 feet in the air and you had to jump, you wouldn't jump out and flap your arms and try to save yourself. That's ridiculous! You would put on the parachute. It is the same with Jesus. You must trust Him as you trust the parachute. We are not good and we cannot save ourselves with our own goodness. We must trust alone in Him to save us. In just a moment of time you can pass from death to life. Jesus said, "Verily, verily I say unto you, you must be born again." That is how we enter heaven. Through the blood and grace of Jesus Christ!!!!✝️If you ask someone how to enter Heaven, they will most likely say, "Be a good person." Well the Bible says that none is good, no not one. We like to compare ourselves to guys like Hitler and say, "Hey, I'm a pretty good guy compared to him." But when we compare ourselves to God's standard, we realize that the Bible speaks truth when it says that we all sinned and fallen short of the Glory of God!!! When we see this ( our sin in its TRUE light), we see how much trouble we are in and we say, "Well then there's nothing I can do. I'm going to hell for sure then." It's true that there is nothing that WE can do, but there is something that has already been done for you! God sent His One and Only Son to die on a cross as a sacrifice for our sins! So to recieve that eternal sweet sweet forgiveness, all we must do is repent of our sins (meaning to continually turn from them and confess them) and trust alone in Christ as you trust a parachute. If I was to push you out of an airplane, you'd want the parachute for sure! Don't try to flap your arms and save yourself, trust in the parachute! His finished work on the Cross IS ENOUGH!! He is the only way to Heaven, He said it Himself!! These other religions teach that we must he good and do good things and then maybe if we've been good enough, we will enter Heaven. But if that is true then we are all doomed to eternal hell because none of us are good. That's why this makes sense. Look at the Ten Commandments, they are written on your heart right now!! I promise that you have violated them. And you might still be doing that today. Therefore God is just to poor out His wrath on us because we deserve it!!! But Christ died for us so that we can spend eternity in Heaven with Him! Turn to Him today, and He and only He will save your soul "Verily, verily I say unto you, you must be born again ( to go to Heaven)."✝️The true joy of Christ dwells in me!!! Does it in you? I know where I'm going when I die! Do you? I have an ETERNAL victory! Do you? I have more joy than ever because of what Christ has done. I have been down both roads. The road of the wicked and the road of Christ. Christ is way better and my cup runneth over with true joy and salvation. If you do not know the One true God and are not sure of your salvation, I promise He will never fail you. Turn to Him in repentance and faith. Repent means to confess and forsake your sins, never turning back to them. I tried changing on my own but I couldn't. It took the power of Christ on the inside of me to do it for me. He will give you a new and clean heart with new and clean desires and you shall be born again. A new creation in Christ Jesus!!! Hallelujah!!!! Jesus said in order to enter the Kingdom of God, you must be born again!! Thank you Lord Jesus!✝️
I second this!
Thought femur fracture, but also considered hip dislocation cause it was a bit high up. Great vid Doc
Same
My mind's eye saw the movement but couldn't believe that large of a bone was broken in such a way! Cool video for sure, more like this would be great!
Same thought it had to be dislocation, possibly with ligament damage, causing that pop sound (which caused me to spill some of my beer).
Keep this series up Doc please! i love the analyzing and interaction!
My knee also pops like that first one from time to time. It's just the same as cracking your knuckles, so it doesn't hurt or anything at all. But people usually let go when it happens and give up positions, so I'm honestly finding it pretty nifty
That pop was incredibly different from just popping your knees like with your knuckles. That was the pop of damage being done. Not just gas bubbles escaping from a joint
No, it doesn't. The knee and shoulder don't crack like knuckles do. Those noises are not good.
@@davidf2244 they definitely do. My knees do it every few times I do a full squat ass to grass. But there's nothing wrong with them
@@davidf2244 and by nothing wrong I mean I've had them x-rayed, MRI, and bone scanned. They're fine
Ruptured lateral femural ligament which encompasses balance and stability for the femur. I ruptured my rectus femoris and you could here similar things around the he knee and popping sound around the hip. Old soccer days
Look at the ref’s reaction! That’s how I reacted too!!
Love this style of video and the learning points summarised at the end! :)
I initially thought tib/fib fracture because of the force being put on the ankle.
I can’t believe the knee didn’t fail before the femur. Wild.
I'm curious what his prognosis is. Is his competitive career over? Is this something he can come back from...if so how long?
I went with hip dislocation initially since on first watch it looked like the torsion forces on the end of the femur caused it to pop out of the pelvis towards the mat, but as usual I suspect you were spot on. When you did the frame-by-frame, it does look like the injury occurred higher up in the thigh than I thought, which is definitely unfortunate for this gentleman
Absolutely love this channel..thanks very much..man what a break/snap..😯😯
Man, I’ve seen a bunch of people blow out their Acls’ weightlifting. It’s insane
The first thought I had was of hip dislocation.
But got why it would be a femur fracture.
Thankyou for these videos. I love them.
My Guess, at 1:30, based off of the reaction, seeing no leg snapped in half. I believe it was a snap of the fibula. Due to the excessive amount of compression going through the bone. I think a full snap of the fibula. There’s definitely damage to the tubular walls and connections to the ankle joint. This is me MD from TH-cam university. Irl i am a Certified EMR
i thought it was an MCL tear until i heard the pop!
We need a poku injury report
love your videos brian!
I am thinking a hip dislocation because when I straighten my thigh out twisted it while flexing my thigh, I can feel a lot of tension in the joint. In addition, I do not think that the forces generated perpendicular to the bone or around its axis would be sufficient to cause either a transverse or spiral fracture respectively with the sound that it makes made me think it wasn't a fracture. Since the hip is the closest joint in the area we see the bone poking out, I believe it is that joint which was affected.
I would have said a femur break but the forces used for that to happen are usually quite large. To the point that I don’t know of many femoral breaks that didn’t happen due to catastrophic car crashes. I honestly thought that it was the sound of the femur leaving the socket, might be wrong though
This is great, it's a really engaging way to not just learn, but apply knowledge. I was thinking hip dislocation at first, but then saw where he grabbed and thought his femur just broke (which is wild).
I feel like his hip was dislocated
Because I don't think the pressure was enough to break his femur
I'd say femur break with the torque and the head acting as the fulcrum is where the break happened.
Can you do a video on Carlos Correa ankle surgery? Last year when stealing a base he hit his ankle and said he was hit in the ankle hardware and felt it go numb and vibrate. And then he was fine. I am wondering if this is what spooked the giants
that was brutal.
THE LEGENDARY TRIPLE BOX!!! Great video as always, love the content!
Green stick fracture or hip dislocation, was my first thought. Then saw the video, and went with the former.
A neighbour, drunkly fell over outside my house a few years back. As he went down he put his right hand out on to the top of our wall - as he kept falling it trapped his arm between him and the wall. It forced it to externally rotate until it snapped the humerus, I heard the snap and the thud in the house. It sheared the bone about a 1/4-1/3 of the way from the shoulder. As I was trying to splint it and get it in a sling, he was so drunk that he could tell he was still trying to move it - it moved like that leg.
If he’d been anymore sober, he’d have been in agony, but after the fact, he did himself a favour by being so black-out drunk as to have zero recollection of the whole incident. He just woke up in hospital with his arm set and in a side-brace cast. 🤷♂️
Spiral fracture of the femur, bones are weakest to torsion forces, great videos 🙏
Doc u are 💯amazing! Thank u!
I’ve been thinking about this one for a while saw it weeks ago, thank you !
I thought initially femur fracture on first view, but was hoping for hip dislocation, but the deformation was too distal to the hip (Was I right to use distal here?) Femur fractures are scary!
yep, distal is correct. proximal means closer to the centre of the body, distal further away
I had been thinking there was a hip dislocation or a fracture to the femoral head. But it makes a ton of sense why it was probably more in the middle of the bone, rather than at the joint.
I feel like he ripped a hip flexer. Tendon near lateral hip. Possibly tendon actually popped hip joint out of place too?
If you do more of these, I'd prefer to see ones where it's harder to tell what the injury was! :)
That first video made me cringe so hard. Mans knee exploded 🤢😬
when you slow it down you can clearly see the deformation. super weird that the bone would snap before the ligament would give.
I thought it was a hip dislocation with a femur fracture being possible but unlikely.
Very informative.
This reminds me of the spiral fractures that occur in arm wrestling.
Portuguese med student here, a bit of a harder challenge here!
My first guess would be a hip fracture/deslocation. We can clearly see his leg shift and hear a big *pop* sound, and the socket were the femur sits is a place that sometimes is susceptible to injury, specially through repetitive stress, like maybe in that wrestling position
Second guess maybe a femur fracture, but the femur is a really strong bone and there doesn't seem to be enough force to break a bone like that.
Hope I'm right ✌️ love your work Dr. Brian and happy holidays for everyone!
My guess was a fibula fracture down by the ankle
Possible compound fracture of the proximal femur, can’t even imagine the type of pain he was in after that
Please do Josh Wells from TB Bucs!! Patellar tear
I'm guessing a dislocation. That pop sounded very distinct.
initial diagnosis - hip dislocation.
Without the slow motion video, I would not have thought about a bone break. Clearly, his bone density was compromised.
there were major temwisting forces along with the fulcrum which made it easier to break but yeah I hear ya
You will continue to see injuries in BJJ and other mixed martial arts just because athletes are more trained and stronger than they use to be.
I thought it was a hip dislocation, thought there was no way something so simple could break a femur! Lesson learned; bones aren’t good under rotational pressure
Could you cover the 2012 Derrick rose ACL injury
I started Jujitsu at 48 years of age……i still haven’t had a bad injury 18 months later , it’s only a matter of time !
Sorry, Dr. Bri. Heard the "POP" and had to switch it off. Love your stuff.
@briansuttererMD I don't know if you'll see this but can you do a video on Byron Jones popping his knee back into place during the Cowboys vs Jets game a few years ago
Oh golly ouch. Thanks doc for the challenge . I am deeply humbled
I thought he dislocated his knee. Also, what the hell submission was he going for? That's sooooo not how you secure a triangle choke or any other submission I can think of
I suspected either a femur fracture or a hip dislocation after the loud crack though it must be a femur fracture
I don't think that technique can cause a femoral fracture without a preexisting issue as well. I'm gonna go with hip dislocation. Proper application requires you to use your opponent's head, not your own leg as a lever. Basic white belt mistake. Great vids.
I think it's a dislocated hip or some sort of fracture of the femur
I thought it was an postero superior hip dislocation , but watching frame by frame i see that not the wholebone goes backwards so a fracture would be the better guess
Either broken femur or hip dislocation
Can you cover knifes edge
Hip dislocation was my first guess
Some sort of left hip dislocation?
Femur fracture I guess. Sounds absolutely awful. The dude has a long painful recovery ahead of him. May never be quite the same.
Fractured leg and knee injury.
How did you not cover the Jalen Hurts shoulder injury? Waited for days on that.
it’s a sprain of the SC joint
snap, crackle and POP!
He broke his damned leg this is an easy one Doc
How is this even possible? Femur is one of the strongest bones of the body.
I’m in real estate so I know shit but I train bjj and I’d make a large wager that’s a hip dislocation not a bone break
Omg, I think he dislocated his hip, ouch
Never seen a Triangle pop the femur like that. The shin bones, foot, knee. Sure. Never like that.
Broken tibia or femur - femur is the biggest strongest bone in the body & if he broke that, he better get a round of blood tests taken for any malignancies or deficiencies.
not to be that guy or anything but jiu is spell wrong in the title, love the videos
Bucs lineman knee injury!!
Does bone smashing work?
Is that a broken FEMUR??? 🤢🫠 big time ouchie
initial thoughts are broken femur or dislocated hip
Bro really put himself in a sub
I’m not even sure why he was trying to grab his ankle or foot? if he wants to finish this submission, he needs to get the good angle by grabbing under the leg or arm on the other side... (right leg or right arm of his opponent)
The pressure he was putting on his own leg was probably painful even before the break.
Well, I got that wrong. I thought broken femur then thought, no the femur is too big of a bone. Sounds like I was wrong.
Fractured leg
You should make another channel for these videos. I think the audience for them is different and would benefit from a different channel.
LET'S GOOO, I FINALLY GOT ONE RIGHT XD
I'm learning 😎
I knew right away when I heard the pop that he broke his femur
MOREE
Femur fracture is my guess
Guessing hip dislocation because of that nasty backwards motion of the thigh, and I don’t think the forces are strong enough to actually fracture the femur…..
Edit: damn, that was brutal. Learned something about bone structures today.
Same...on all accounts.
Anyone knows if this was poor technique? If so, how?
Acl mcl or tcl
Acl tear
It looks like something in the upper leg but it probably one of the the bones on the lower leg that popped.
UPDATE: I saw it. I was wrong. LOL!
Femur FX
Prelim dx without watching the video, bicep femoris rupture
Wow I was horribly wrong haha
That’s the classic “f’ed ‘er bud”
Definitely got an eyelash in his eye, and his femur was like "yo I want no part of this anymore."
Femure fracture?!
A broken hip
("the end of the femur, 'medially?', broke off"?)
Femur broke ?
Ouch