SNOW COMPARISON: 2017 BMW X3 xDrive20d F25 VS 2004 BMW X3 3.0d E83 | 20% INCLINE | DSC OFF | xDrive
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- 2017 BMW X3 xDrive20d F25 Facelift
4.cylinder engine
190 hp / 400 Nm
0 - 100 km/h in 8,1s
Top Speed: 210 km/h
6-Speed Manual Transmission
Kerb Weight: 1805 kg (EU)
VS
2004 BMW X3 3.0d E83
3.Liter straight-six turbo engine
204 hp / 410 Nm
0 - 100 km/h in 7,9s
Top Speed: 210 km/h (electronically limited)
6-Speed Manual Transmission
Kerb Weight: 1925 kg (EU)
#xDrive #BMW #BMWX3
All Videos are (c) by CARS EXTREM - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
it's very obvious the driver doesn't have much experience driving in snow/icy conditions, I've driven my Xdrive in worse conditions with all season tires and never really had any issues. Pathetic test to say the least.
It's ALL about the tires.
Great video not many commenters understand that most awd vehicles would've gotten stuck going up an icy incline with deep snow even with winter tires as shown.
Bob Boi Thanks! You are absolutely right!
Those are shit, try hakka r2. Evry car will climb up that hill...
Mr I have seen the new vid of @Tyre Reviews too.:) Nokian Hakka R2/R3 are not available in the size I need for my car. Besides I have to buy tires, which are recommended by BMW (the same at Audi, Mercedes, Porsche,...), otherwise I get problems with warranty/accommodation.
@@CARSEXTREM i see, but do you use those tires like all season or you change to summer tires to?
Mr For summer I have an own set of rims with summer tires.
This is comparison of the tires and not of the two BMWs. I wasted 5 minutes.
I’m confused by this video. I live in Minnesota and we get snow like this all of the time and I have no issues making it up hills like this with snow tires and the traction control enabled. Turning it off just seems to be counter intuitive.
Sometimes the conditions simply overwhelm the equipment... You need a quality snowblower or plow and barrel of sand. ; )
Bubba Farmer You can see the tires at: 4:55
This is when a good set of chains might make a difference. They won't help in really deep off road snow but they might just work here.
ianrkav Yes, you are right. On this icy driveway chains would certainly help. Thanks for the advice.👍 I‘m going to buy one for the next onset of winter and will make a video of it.
@@CARSEXTREM Also, would turning dsc on once you are moving help? I understand turning it off when stuck to help get rolling without dsc killing the power but once you are rolling might it help? Check out this vid with Tiff Needell. In one section he goes up a 10% ice covered incline, half as steep as yours, with dsc on with just a fwd jag. That bit starts at 4:40 mark. th-cam.com/video/wR1SSxpKitE/w-d-xo.html
ianrkav When he turns traction control on, he takes a lot of momentum and gets up the hill, but he also gets slower and slower as fare he goes up the slope. If the slope would be longer or/and steeper, in my opinion he wouldn’t make it. Why he didn’t show traction control working from a standstill short before the slope like he did without traction control?
Exactly this is my problem. My driveway starts with a 90 degree curve before the slope. I need to drive very slow, otherwise the car understeer and I would drive into the driveway lamps. So I cannot take any momentum up the incline. I need to dig through the snow from the beginning to get somehow momentum and up the hill. With traction control this is not possible. Do you know my Side by Side Video DSC on vs off: th-cam.com/video/I0Ca4gcicBw/w-d-xo.html
If I turn DSC back on in the moment, when I have a bit traction? 🤔I think my driveway is too steep for traction control. Up to a certain point traction control can help in normal road traffic with slight incline, but in my case I think traction control would reduce power that much, so that I get stuck immediately again. But I’m gone try it next time and make video of it. Thanks for your suggestion!
@@CARSEXTREM You're welcome, and I do believe you are correct. It was only a 10% short straight incline and not the 20% curved one you were dealing with. Also, the points you raise are valid and I thought the same too. He did seem to take a much longer faster run at it with dsc on than he did with it off, and if it had been longer he would have eventually came to a halt! I would have liked to see him start from a standstill with it on too:-) The technique I mention does seem to work in normal traffic as you say as I have done it myself. A little bit of snow with ice underneath and I couldn't get moving, turned dsc off and I dug out a bit of traction and got rolling but was fish tailing a bit, turned dsc back on and that settled down and kept me rolling along nicely. Incline was only about 1%. Anyway good video. It was interesting to see there was no real difference between the older and newer manual cars.
ianrkav Thank you for the nice conversation and your experience report! 😃👍
Tyres, at lease front one at 04:56, are mounted wrong, direction is pointing backwards :) rotation arrow should point forward. Also these Dunlop winters are shit.
Studded winters would make it up that... Would also be an interesting test.. 👌
Clint Lundie Yes, but sadly studded tires are not allowed in Germany.
The one made in 2017 seems to be easy to use, but it looks quite worn out.What do you think?
Surprisingly, the 2004 version looks easier to use.
I dont know how you drive but I in my e83 3.0d 218HP dont have any problems on Winter tires Pirelli Scotto Zero
Ice under the snow is perfect :)
In this case studded tyres or chains can help.
Your tyres we call "eurowinter" ,not good enough for condition like you show.
Thanx for video.Now i realise i never buy those tyres :)
Alexdj44 Thank you for your feedback!:)
@@CARSEXTREM th-cam.com/video/gQxrXHdalE8/w-d-xo.html
You can see the differences of tyre on ice.If you want :)
Alexdj44 I have already seen the new vid of @Tyre Reviews.:) Sadly Nokian Hakka R2/R3 are not available in the size I need for my car. Besides I have to buy tires, which are recommended by BMW (the same at Audi, Mercedes, Porsche,...), otherwise I get problems with warranty/accommodation.
its all about momentum and lefty righty
It is the ice who definitely stop this bouth BMW's
Good work cleaning out the internals of that diesel engine :)
@cars extrem, can you please tell me when you turn OFF the DSC will the AWD be used (50/50 front and rear) or not? And also, even then you turn it OFF i can see in the video that sometimes front wheels rotate and rear are not, they run kinda individually...? Im trying to understand how this DSC affects the transfer case and power distribution. Thanks 😁🙏
alex89bmw If you have DSC deactivated AWD is going to be distributed 50/50 (on X3 E83 and X3 F25, on some BMWs like the X6 E71: 40/60 front/rear). BMWs have an electronically middle differential so that the 50/50 distribution is possible. But BMW has no front and rear differential, so that both wheels on each axle are spinning always the same. This means, that sometimes only one wheel per axle is spinning. This is, what you are seeing in the video. In this cases BMW‘s xDrive try to brake the spinning wheel electronically to get the other wheel back spinning again. With an an mechanical front and rear differential you wouldn‘t have this situation, that sometimes one wheel is not spinning, but on the other side you also wouldn‘t get the great driving performance on dry and wet roads, which BMW‘s are known for. I hope this explanation helps you a little bit.:)
Cars, thanks for such a great explanation 🙏. I'm having this strange vibrations and difficulties when driving slowly and turning (for example on a parking lot, when you drive in 1st gear), and while accelerating feels like something is holding back (like brakes maybe), however this stops when DSC is turned OFF.. Do you have any idea why and how this might be related to DSC (or ABS maybe)... 😀
alex89bmw You are welcome!:) Do you have a BMW X3 E83 (2003-2010)? Than it is probably the transfer case. This is a vulnerability of the E83. First try to change the oil of the transfer case. It costs you around 100 Euro and often it helps. If this shouldn’t solve the problem, the transfer case is damaged or broken. Sometimes only the actuator motor gear of the transfer case is worn. It is made of plastic, which wears with time. The part costs only a few Euro, but it needs time to get switched. In the worst case the hole transfer case is broken. Than it costs around 2500 Euro (parts and labor). I would switch the transfer case oil as soon as possible. Hopefully that helps. Search on youtube for „BMW X3 E83 transfer case“. People made a lot of good videos, how to repair it.
@@CARSEXTREM ок но п юли
What a way to waste the clutch! Need Bridgestone Blizzak tires. Have on my 05 x3 3.0 no trouble. Maybe it's the driver!!😂
Ohne Worte...
Hello, Is it safe to put a wool blanket over your engine in your battery in cold weather?
Sometimes it's the driver. I watched another BMW x3 video and the snow conditions were a bit deeper and the angle more pronounced. It took a moment or two but the driver made it up the hill.
Cheryl Houghton It is the question if they had ice underneath the snow like in my video. Pure powder snow is no problem also at 20 inches. The ice is the problem.
Did you forget the winter tires?
Roman Istomin No, winter tires are mounted. Take a look at 4:55 in the video.
J C You can store the tires at your BMW Dealer, if you do not have the space at home.
On full stop on snow up hill you start with second gear since is Manuel
The only thing that you pointed out with this video is that driver is equally incapable in both models 😂
As a Subaru owner its wierd how it cant go. X3 is a great car but shit tire set limiting you by 80%.
А dsc почему off??
Yes
Zacząłbym od nauki jazdy ...😬
5 Mins i have lost !
You have to see it that way: I‘m thankful for the watchtime!:)
😂😂😂 Если бы ОНО так ездило , в России бы НЕ ПРОДАВАЛОСЬ😊
Blinded may not see the ice below, which the producer hides under the snow. a quite unfair approach to blame BMW all-wheel drive competencies. With this tires in that slope, no 4WD will make it :)
tinofromberlin Exactly! If you do not have studded tires on ice, you have no chance, no matter which car you are driving.
My Jeep Cherokee Liberty 3.7 will pass from here without a problem
Rename the video to cleaning my bmw internals
😂👍
Summer tyres or pure ice below the snow.
Antares Take a look at 4:55. There you can see the winter tires. Yes, it was ice underneath.
Change tire and driver
Tyers !!!
1st off if it’s that bad go all the way back to the bottom turn around an try backing up the driveway you’ll be surprised to discover that the engine weight will get you to the top. Without making such a mess. 🙄
Benjamin Freeman Almost all BMWs have a more weight in the back, than in the front. 2004 X3 3.0d E83: in the front 1150 kg and in the back 1260 kg.
2017 X3 xDrive20d F25: in the front 1080 kg and in the back 1305 kg.
But I‘m gone try it. Thanks for your advice.
Its really hard to steer in reverse on ice. But it is easier going back down if you fail.
2004 the winner😍
Secondo me servono pneumatici invernali si che ruota di ❄️
Artan Pepushaj 4:55
conti is much better tire for conditions like these.
summer tyres? use nokian hakkapeliitta 9
YoKoDzUnA No, winter tires. Take a look at 4:55. I have heard, that Nokians are very good tires, but I only buy tires, which are recommended of BMW because of warranty and accommodation.
@@CARSEXTREM bad result because the tires are without studs. I use studded tires, I like it. but I live in Russia, here they are allowed ))
You're practically off road in that much snow lol I would stick to AT tires if where you live gets that bad
As far as I know are winter tires better in snow than ATs. I have a set of ATs for the E83 (Cooper Discoverer Sport), but they were not that great in snow.
Jesus christ.. If you're gonna make a comparison video then atleast put some freakin stud tires on the damn car.
Nostric Unfortunately studded tires are forbidden in Germany.
You´d probaply gotten up straight with dsc adjusted in middle, having too much revs just melts the ice and makes it slippier
Riku Perry The problem is the 90 degree curve before the slope. I need to drive very slow, otherwise the car understeer and I would drive into the driveway lamps. So I cannot take any momentum up the incline. But than I need to accelerate, to get a bit momentum on the flatter space on the beginning of the slope, otherwise i would come immediately to a standstill, which is the case with activated DSC. Furthermore the steepest part of the incline is the end. I tried to drive very slow, but than the car doesn’t move a bit and even slides backwards, because of the ice underneath. If you take a look at the video, every time I push the pedal, the car digs through the snow and moves a bit.
Колеса должны быть с шипами на обоих машинах. Но их нет. Можно счтать эксперимент неудавшимся.
Шипы не разрешены в центральной Европе и в Америке так что эксперимент не может считаться проваленным.
@@roheko5798 Я в курсе. Как бы там ни было, на такой резине встрянешь в любом снежном месте. Смысла ехать и перегревать автомат с раздаткой не было никакого, но у автора снег в голове в место мозга. Это надо было додуматься тестировать на городской резине, городской автомобиль в сугробах.
the E83 is so much more beautiful
Fait installer des pneux cloutés
These cars need goodyear ultragrip ice arctic😒
Studded tires are not allowed in Germany
You should buy an quattro and the problem is fix.😉
Give this man a tank he would still not pass 😂
These are NOT a real winter tires. These winter tires are designed for middle european customers and their cars. Good proper winter tires have studs / spikes and tires are always designed for real winter conditions like nordic countries (like in Finland, Sweden, Norway). Example these th-cam.com/video/hV05cIxwfMQ/w-d-xo.html
шипы решают!
eddi4x4 Studded tires are not allowed in Germany.
@@CARSEXTREM а какое обоснование у правительства?
eddi4x4 It damages the pavement surface too much.
@@CARSEXTREM я всегда думал что вес автомобиля разрушает дорогу. Например лендкрузер 200 на не шипованой резине или пежо 206 на шипах
@@CARSEXTREM не о тротуаре надо думать.....
Wie viel Gas gibt der im grauen WTF 😂
Mit Gewalt geht alles!😜😁
To jest kurwa Dramat!!!!!!!!!
Baca Bimbol 😂👍
second gear and easy
So after 13 years of development, nothing was really gained?
Jim Jams I wouldn‘t say so. Despite of the bigger and wider wheels on the F25, the cars get almost equally far up the hill. If there wouldn’t be ice underneath the snow, the difference should be more significant.
A Subaru forester would easily slice through that snow
Lada Niva.No-1.
Driver must learn s lot how to drive on snow/ice
Me parece muy mala la prueba. No tienen o no quieren aplicar técnicas de manejo lo que hace poco seria la experiencia
buy a winter tyres .....
4:58 both are equipped with winter tyres.
lub łańcuchy śnieżne
My Jeep Cherokee Liberty 3.7 will pass from here without a problem
Differt cars, same 💩. Panda forever
I have got both of them, x3 2017 and panda 2005, in this condition I m used to drive panda. 2 tons car are not good for those roads
La vecchia è superiore
So Quattro then ......
Zane Henderson I try to get an Audi for comparison, but it is difficult to get one, when it is actually snowing.
:D
buy a quattro nuff said
Audi Allroad Quattro in the autobahn 300 km/h . In off-road the best. I have x3 but it’s like a lighter
gucci mucci 300 km/h are possible with an Audi RS6, but this car is too expensive for me.:) But I do not think, that is good off-road.
Same shit after 13 years. Go and buy a Subaru Forester. They are champions
Hahahahaha
Hai cum Audi Q3 sau Q5
Fane Muntean I think all german cars are more or less the same
I can not beleve with winter tires you can’t go Uphills
Eddie Michael With ice underneath only studded tires would help, but sadly it is not allowed in Germany.
Lada Niva, Suzuki Jimny, Subaru Forester: Hold our beers.
Georg Friedrich Hendl These are surely great cars for off-road and daily driving, but if you also want to drive easily 200 km/h+ on Autobahn, they are not the right choice in my opinion.
More narrow tire works better at slippery. This "test" was stupid.
thetoughcookie These are the wheels, which you get from BMW out of factory.
I don't think pinning your foot to the floor is going help much.
Dad & Me Vi bllo Sadly studded tires are not allowed in Germany. The problem is the 90 degree curve before the slope. I need to drive very slow, otherwise the car understeer and I would drive into the driveway lamps. So I cannot take any momentum up the incline. Furthermore the steepest part of the incline is the end. I tried to drive very slow, but than the car doesn’t move a bit and even slides backwards, because of the ice underneath. If you take a look at the video, every time I push the pedal, the car digs through the snow and moves a bit.
Dafuq is this video about
First of all neither of the 2 drivers have a clue. Stupid test
Watt en Kack
Ill drive 2 wheeler better then you 😆
Bulls#it
tomas ZARUBA Why?
Just buy a subaru🤣
Doesn't matter in those conditions. Get real!
Wer würde auch so versuchen ein Berg so hoch zu kommen 😅
Schade aber sehr unrealistisch der Test.
Benjamin Bischoff Was daran genau is unrealistisch und was hätte ich besser machen sollen?
@@CARSEXTREM Fahrzeug vorsichtig runter rollen lassen eine Spur wählen wo frisch Schnee drauf ist, DSC an und langsam rauf fahren ggf bei Automatik sogar nur mit standgas hoch.
So wie auf dem Video ist klar dass das nichts wird.
Benjamin Bischoff Hab ich auch schon versucht. Bei wenig Schnee (5-10cm) funktioniert das. Aber ab 15 cm und mehr drehen so nur die Räder langsam im Stand durch. Und wenn ich es doch ein Stück den Hügel hoch schaffe, bin ich wegen dem Eis rückwärts unkontrolliert den Hang runter gerutscht, da ich keine Blockade vom Schnee mehr hinter den Reifen hatte, welche man durch das durchdrehen der Reifen aufbaut. Langsam mit Standgas hoch kann man bei einem Untergrund machen, auf dem man teilweise Grip aufbauen kann. DSC an vs aus hab ich auch ein Video gemacht: th-cam.com/video/I0Ca4gcicBw/w-d-xo.html
Sobald der nächste Schnee kommt, werde ich ein Video machen, in dem ich so versuche, wie du sagst.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💩💩💩💩
theres only one answer
audi and quattro 🤩
daczkes I think all german cars are more or less the same.
Летняя резина потому что это фейк
Александр Вагнер No, these are Central European winter tires. Take a look at 4:55.
Try a shovel
SLAM 😂👍
Dacă accelerezi ca un....... , poți să ai și cuie în anvelope. 😡😡😡 La ce dracu mai faceți filmulețe, vreți să denigrarați anumite mărci auto?
I just spent 3 minutes watching cars stuck in snow 🙄...
Chris T 2 minutes more watchtime and you would have seen, that maybe one car made it up the hill!:)
CARS EXTREM haha...indeed! Some people have an attention span of a gold fish! lol
Chris T 😂😂😂👍
Does not know how to use momentum on uphill. This video shows only 2 inexperienced drivers. I can drive a freaking civic up that hill lol
They are both terrible. Every audi quattro would have done that easily
Zenchilli In my opinion all german AWD-systems work pretty similar. They send power to wheel with the most grip. Some are more rear wheel biased, some more front wheel biased. Some have diff in the rear to send different power between the rear wheels. At some cars ESC and traction control are more aggressive intervening or it is not able to deactivate it completely. I‘m really not an expert, but I have driven almost alle brands in winter and the all feel pretty much the same. BMW and Porsche are more oversteering in snow. Audi, VW and Mercedes are more neutral understeering. At the end the tires decided, how far along I came.
So buy a truck
reid marchand A truck is much heavier. I do not know, if it would be much easier with it.
@@CARSEXTREM The clearance off the snow may give an edge. I drive a 2011 x3 35i. This is my first winter and it feels great so far in the snow, cant wait for more snow challenges to test it
reid marchand Clearance is a important point, you are right. X3 in general is a great car in snow. On snowy mountain roads I never had any problems. Only on my steep driveway the car struggles.The problem is the 90 degree curve before the slope. I need to drive very slow, otherwise the car understeer and I would drive into the driveway lamps. So I cannot take any momentum up the incline. Furthermore the steepest part of the incline is the end. In my opinion even special offroad cars would have a hard time going up there.
Buy Audi quatro...😆
Sanel Šabanovič German car manufacturer are more or less the same in my opinion. They are all great cars.
@@CARSEXTREM The best AWD drive comes from AUDI engenirs. Even if Audi is a part of VW groop they hawe 3 diferent AWD sistems. VW 4-motion, Audi Quatro, Porsche 4X4, the Scoda and Seat use 4-motion but one generation older sistem than build in VW models. The only bether AWD drive in my opinion is Subarus.
Sanel Šabanovič But they all work pretty similar or not? They send power to wheel with the most grip. Some are more rear wheel biased, some more front wheel biased. Some have diff in the rear to send different power between the rear wheels. At some cars ESC and traction control are more aggressive intervening or it is not able to deactivate it completely. I‘m really not an expert, but I have driven almost alle brands in winter and the all feel pretty much the same. BMW and Porsche are more oversteering in snow. Audi, VW and Mercedes are more neutral understeering. At the end the tires decided, how far along I came.
@@CARSEXTREM Yes i agre. Some times the tyers and driving skill brings the diference. My Porsche has normal rear whel drive but when the rear tyers spin the transfer box sends power to front wheals. Just a month ago we did a test. My Cayenne Turbo/Techart Magnum 550hp 2005 year model VS Dodge RAM 1500 Mopar 400hp+ 2018. We hooked up the cars on gravel road and tested who will win in thug of war. Dodge was spining the all 4 wheals stedy. Porsche put more power to back whels. Even on gravel i hawe made smoke cloud when i poled that RAM. My friends hawe all sort of diferent AWD cars. Subaru is fucking crazy. AUDI is second to that all other ehhh... Close but way out of those to leage.
Sanel Šabanovič Porsche Cayenne has not all the time AWD? I‘m thinking about trading my 2004 X3 for a 2002-2006 Porsche Cayenne S. Preferably with manual transmission, but they are really rear. Are you happy with your Cayenne? Does it have any problems? I have heard the air suspension could be a problem?
Who does that!!!!!!!
4 mins is all I could endure.
Driving skills 👎🏻👎🏻
The L3 -Love,live ,Lift What should I have done better?
It would help if either driver actually knew how to drive in snow. SMH.
Alan Sawyer What should I have done better?
The snow need snow tyres is so simple..
Что новая что старая гумно.
Александр Зубакин Grey car old, white car new.:)
та ты тоже гумно
andrey ermakov Winter tires are mounted: 4:55
Worst driver ever!!!
Just get a Subaru!!!
waste of time
Afshin What should I have done better?
@@CARSEXTREM You have used two driving styles for two different cars, two different sets of tires too, basically the comparison was not effective. I appreciate you spent a lot time on creating this video but on my end I wanted to learn about these two vehicles in a fair comparison, which it did not happen.
Afshin I drove both cars the same way, which I drive them in these conditions every time. Please tell me, which I made different?
I bought the winter tires at my BMW dealer, which are recommended for each car with the „*“ symbol, so that I‘m on the save side in case of a warranty/accommodation issues. So I‘m not able to buy same tires for both cars, if I do not want to get in trouble in case of a technical failure. Also same size is not possible, because than one of each cars wouldn‘t be street legal anymore. Both are equipped with different tire sizes from factory.
I drove both cars how they are equipped from factory.
Einfach nur peinlich für BMW.
Kann die schlechten Eigenschaften auf Schnee bestätigen
Embarrissing to see how bad Bmw "works" in winter conditions. I am glad I didn't buy one.