Who were the Sea Peoples? | The Bronze Age Collapse
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 พ.ค. 2024
- Signup for your FREE trial to Wondrium here: ow.ly/8J1C30spaZa
Join our Patreon community!: / religionforbreakfast
One-time donations here!: www.paypal.me/religionforbrea...
Check out my favorite religious studies books by following this affiliate link to my Amazon page: www.amazon.com/shop/religionf...
Signup for your FREE trial to Wondrium here: ow.ly/8J1C30spaZa
Make videos about hinduism
This is why invaders are to be eradicated
Report something new or my board game about the Bronze Age or the Bronze Age Collapse will arrive and confuse players. You have ten years!
The first is simply a Bronze Age in equilibrium and the second is the Bronze Age constrained with disasters adding to limited resources. I could send anyone the map and rules if their interested, but if I ever go anywhere it’ll be for space games.
So fundamentally Jews are a Greek like SeaPeople who’s heritage is Mediterranean and have invaded coastal groups of the continent?
th-cam.com/video/Arz4az52WDs/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/OXpvqoog8iM/w-d-xo.html
I love that one of the great mysteries of all of history is just "Sea people"
At least they are not called "Sea Men"
@@DzinkyDzink Good. One. Lol.
I don't know any "mystery" without a simple name.
The sea is full of misteries 🤫🤫🤫
Lol yea. I think the fact that we are only able to call them the "Sea people" really shows how much we don't know about them, which, for me, makes it more interesting.
“Hittite, Assyria, Canaan, Egypt. Long ago, these four nations lived together in harmony. Then everything changed when the Sea People invaded.”
😂😂 a TV series following the lives of multiple families, one of each civilization at the same time would be amazing
@@wawaweewa9159 i love that idea bro
i know it is an avatar reference but canaan and egypt lived in anything but in peace
Obviously Egypt did an excessive amount of earth bending.
But in the end all the bronze age dudes vanished when the metal benders entered the stage ....
@@wawaweewa9159I second this
The "Sea Peoples" and the Late Bronze Age Collapse is quite possibly one of the most engrossing historical mysteries there is. The high-level view of the basic facts is intriguing and the more you drill down and the more you learn, even after dispelling myths, it just gets more and more interesting. It also doesn't hurt having a charismatic guy like Eric Cline do presentations about the archaeology and scholarship he does about it.
Libya was a Phoenician Principality.
Phoenicians were also the Priest Class of early Egypt. Israel is the Phoenician word for Saturn, or El, Fruit of Isis and Ra
@@uncannyvalley2350 israel is a hebrew word
@@tudoraragornofgreyscot8482 Google
@@uncannyvalley2350 Google can tell you vaccines can cause autism
@@tudoraragornofgreyscot8482 I wasn't telling you to Google vaccines champ
Red herring
This was excellent. My undergrad thesis in 1994 was on who the Sea People might have been. My conclusion- they were Greeks (when I say Greeks I am referring to the entire Greek world, the mainland, the Aegean Islands and Crete, what is generally lumped in as Mycenaean).
The basic facts I found persuasive for coming to my conclusion were:
- Moshe and Trude Dothan’s archaeological work on the Philistines which even back then convinced me they were of Greek origins. The pottery and writing similarities were too convincing. I’m glad to see that DNA evidence has pretty much proved this now.
- The fact that the Greeks/Mycenaeans were not a homogeneous people and would have been viewed by the Egyptians (and themselves) as separate groups with different names.
- The similarities of the depictions of the helmets and armor of many of the Sea People by the Egyptions to the depiction of Greek warriors on late Bronze Age Mycenaean vases and pottery.
- The fact that during the bronze age trade was wine and olives and olive oil from Greece to Egypt and grain from Egypt to Greece.
- The changes in climate that would have caused crop losses and likely famine just before the Sea People’s appearance
- The fact that during the Bronze Age (and even during the Classical Period) Greece could not feed itself without importing grain from Egypt. Egypt was known as the bread basket of the Mediterranean after all.
- The fact that the vast majority of the Sea People were uncircumcised- in addition to cutting of hands for the body count the Egyptians cut off the phallus and kept detailed descriptions of whether the severed phalli were circumcised or not- Greeks would have been uncircumcised.
- The fact that prior to the big battle with Ramses cities and lands from the Hittites all along the Levantine coast were being sacked.
- The were said to be from the North and came by Sea on boats.
- The remembrance in the Iliad and in Odysseus’s journeys in the Odyssey of general eastward and southward migration of Greek warriors and people.
There may have a few more but these were most of the big ones that I can recall. My hypothesis was that we know that Greece needed to import food, we know that just prior to the Sea People’s appearance climate was changing, Mycenae and the Greek world was facing wars (maybe with invaders, maybe among itself, or maybe both) but had both famine and a political upheaval issues, we know that Greeks were getting fed by Egypt, we know that the destruction started in Asia Minor along the coast and along the Levantine coast prior to battle with Egypt, and we know that right around the time of Ramses battle with the Sea People the Philistines, who are Greeks, pop up settled in the Levant. We also have similarities of the armor and helmets from the drawings and vases, and this remembrance in Greek culture of a vast migration of warriors and people to Asia Minor and further south along the Levant in the Iliad and the Odyssey. So my hypothesis was that there was famine, war and turmoil in the Greek lands, that as a result people from different city-states got together at different times and went eastward and southward, either to migrate or get what they needed and bring home, that they started with the closest lands in Asia Minor and proceeded down the Levantine coast until ultimately coming to Egypt’s borders (it would make sense that if an inability to feed itself due to harvest disruptions from war and climate change and trade route interruptions, they would eventually go where they knew the food came from- Egypt) and having the battle with Ramses. Along the way, and particularly after the battle with Ramses, they either settled, or perhaps were encouraged to settle by Ramses as a sort of vassal buffer states, in Canaan and quickly commingled and became the Philistines. All of which is remembered in the Iliad and the Odyssey.
Great work 👏
The mycenean were of Yamnaya ancestry haplogroup J-L283 huntergatherers same as illyrians the sea people have been E-V13 farmers these haplogroup should belong to pelasgians, ancient grandfathers of greeks and albanians, same as J-L283, and R1b the three haplogroups dominate nowdays in albanian and greek populations haplogroup E entered Balkan peninsula from Levant and had a strong presence in Egypt and the rest of north Africa besides Balkans and the rest of Europe it has been before J-L283 and R1b haplogroups in Balkans so its the main candidate for being the pelasgian haplogroup
philistines are native to canaan, phonecians are the sea peoples of modern libya..
@@bledarndreu2895 typical delusional Albanian
Found potery from Cyprus and Crete in Ashkelon the Philistine City.Also DNA from the pigs found to be South Europeans.They were Achaias and Myceneans.
I think regarding the Sherdana/Sardinia connection, as well as the linguistic link, they've also found carved warrior figurines in Sardinia whose armour, in particular the distinctive horned helmets, match up with the Egyptian depictions of the Sherdana in the battle reliefs.
The sea people were probably Greeks or southern Italians invading the eastern Mediterranean
Yes, but we already know about that connection. What you don't know is who were they. I will reveal to you. The sea peoples, were Egyptian races (from which came Philistines), along with others in a coalition against Egypt, and this is their origins:
*MITSRAYIM* (Egyptians):
*Ludim* (Lukka, Lycia- Lod/Lydda, levant)
*Caslukhim* (Tjekker- Dor/Sicani, Sicily)
--> -*-Philistines-*- (Cretes>PELESET- Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Ekron, Gath, Jaffa)
*Caphtorim* (Sherden: Cretes-'Minoans'+Sardinians)
*CANAAN* (Natufians/Phoenicians{Tyre}):
*Yebusites* (Weqshesh- IBIZA/Levant)
*Girgashites* (Weshesh, Karkisha/Caria- levant+Hatti●)
*Hivites* (Ahhiyawa, anatolia, Lebanon, Hermon)
While the horned helmets are quite distinct, the feathered headgear was quite common throughout Greece, Sicily and Sardinia and is a vaguely South European feature of warrior attire in the bronze age. That is one of the reasons why scholars are convinced that we can be almost entirely confident that the Sea Peoples came broadly from southern Europe. Where exactly in southern Europe is anyone's guess.
little factoid: there shardana on both sides of the battlefield.
what other culture was known for horned helmets and raiding coasts with ships? hmmm looks ancient Scandinavia
It seems to me that the "Sea Peoples" were simply aggressive outsiders who took advantage of the weakened and fragile state of the Bronze Age societies of the eastern Mediterranean. An empire at the height of its power is unlikely to be toppled by "barbarians". It's much like how someone with a compromised immune system might die from an infection that would be a brief inconvenience for an otherwise healthy person. Yes, the infection killed them, but that's not the best explanation for why they died.
I find it interesting to consider the similarities between the Bronze Age collapse and the end of the western Roman Empire.
There's also the Minoan collapse and vulcanism that kicked off the Greek Dark Ages
Why does everything have to be about the covid pandemic?
@@nosuchthing8 , well played. :)
"simply aggressive outsiders"
With all due respect you sound like an american. :)
I can imagine a bronze age W figure who says: "You either with us or with the Sea People..."
Usually nothing is this simple. I think there is a chance Sea People were came from the answer to the destruction of Troy and the danger the Phoenicians faced in that time. I think they were mercenaries of the Phoenicians and they came from the lower Danube area.
@@Zodroo_Tint , that sounds like a description of outsiders who were aggressive -- nobody pays passive mercenaries. 🙂 So what is our disagreement?
I love the Sea People. I believe that the Shardana may really be the Sardinians. There's a lot of similarities between the iconography of Shardana in the Egyptian sources and the iconography of bronze statuettes of the Nuragic Civilization (horned helmets, same type of sword and more: the eponymous god Sardus wore a feathered hat)
Yes, clues are there: people seem to forget that language barriers are not new!
Just as, in English, we call them Germans, and they call themselves Deutsch!
And also (even barring derogatory epithets), different languages work differently, and there can be cultural effects.
For example: in English, we refer to Austria, and AustriANS; and, if you look closely, you can see the parallel as Germans call it Õesterreich, with Öesterreicher iving in it (Öesterreicherinen would be Austrian women.)
But, you can see it break down as 'eastern kingdom'...but, no matter what the deluded pseudo-purists will try to say, 'English' is really a messy mash-up of several languages, with a LOT if shortcuts taken, and mistakes made!
(Note: we made it even worse in the Americas!)
So, we shouldn't expect the Egyptians to pronounce the names for these peoples the same as they said it themselves, nor the same as the Hittites would!
Of course, the other issue is while it is clear that some of the 'Sea peoples' died and didn't go anywhere else, it is also pretty clear that the 'Philstines' did NOT go back from when they came!
Others may have, but might also have escaped the battle(s) in Egypt, and gone on to other, 'new' places to settle.
So, it's a little hard to say whether they got called 'Shekelesh' because they came FROM 'Sicily'* or WENT there...
* (or whatever the Egyptian pronunciation...)
Same with 'Sardinia' and 'Sardinians'...
Personally, it would seem to me that just as we call people from Virginia, Virginians, or from Florida, FloridIANS, and we see this sort of modification on other languages, that ' 'Peloset' are people from 'Pelos' which is not much of a linguistic stretch from Pylos, and who know how the people in Pylos pronounced 'Pylos' 3200 years ago!
Libya was a Phoenician colony, Phoenicians appear to be a collective of Celtic Tribes that stretched from Iberia to Ugarit and the island chains in between.
Iberia means Over, and has the same root as Hebrew, as in overseas. People with sails would've seemed magical and the Phoenicians pioneered maritime navigation using the stars. They were also the Priest class of Egypt, and among its founders. Israel is the Phoenician word for Saturn, or El, Fruit of Isis and Ra. The region of Georgia on the Eastern shores of the Black Sea where we find the Dolmens of Iberia was also called Iberia, and was home to the Colchians, who would eventually become the Armenians. Herodotus lists Colchians as one of the few to circumcise themselves, as well as the Egyptians. He makes no mention of Jews
@@uncannyvalley2350 Well, the Phoenicians got around; but don't forget that that there were already people there when they founded Carthage...I haven't read up much on their origins...
@@uncannyvalley2350 There is absolutely no evidence for Phoenicians being in any way Celtic. Celtic is an Indo-European people-group, whereas Phoenicians were Semetic culturally and linguistically.
@@uncannyvalley2350 Phoenicians spread out after the bronze age collapse and spoke a completely different language than Celts, not to say also different in genetics, religion, customs, etc. They were closer to the Israelites and other Canaanite groups than anything.
I've figured that a lot of Sea Peoples were likely Mykenaean in origin.
Poems regarding the Trojan War frequently state that the Mykenaeans raided and plundered several other peoples, and that the plunder of Troy was insufficient, which caused more plundering of the surrounding areas as well as many turning to piracy.
With the Hittites and Canaanites being allies of Troy, it isn't hard to imagine some members of the Mykenaean alliance turning their ire upon them for helping Troy drag out this war.
But the Egyptians already have trade relations with the Mycenaeans, The Egyptians would have named them instead of calling the invaders "Sea People" if that was the case.
@@haroldcruz8550 The Egyptians apparently did name the Mycenaeans as being one of the Sea People. The Sea People were more than one nation.
Both History Time and The Histocrat have created documentaries breaking down who the Sea Peoples might have been as well, I love learning about this kind of investigative archaeology, keep up the good work :)
Love The Histocrat before bed
Fall of Civilizations covered the Bronze Age Collapse as well. Highly recommend
Yeah don't forget to show epimetheus' bronze age videos some love
th-cam.com/video/Arz4az52WDs/w-d-xo.html
Wasn't Santorini goin nuclear a factor
This topic is absolutely fascinating, I’ve seen several other videos about it, but this one might be my new favorite. Thank you very much and congratulations!
I don’t think I’ll ever get enough of the sea peoples!
Well, this is the ultimate truth about it...The sea peoples, were Egyptian races (from which came Philistines), along with others in a coalition against Egypt, and this is their origins:
*MITSRAYIM* (Egyptians):
*Ludim* (Lukka, Lycia- Lod/Lydda, levant)
*Caslukhim* (Tjekker- Dor/Sicani, Sicily)
--> -*-Philistines-*- (Cretes>PELESET- Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Ekron, Gath, Jaffa)
*Caphtorim* (Sherden: Cretes-'Minoans'+Sardinians)
*CANAAN* (Natufians/Phoenicians{Tyre}):
*Yebusites* (Weqshesh- IBIZA/Levant)
*Girgashites* (Weshesh, Karkisha/Caria- levant+Hatti●)
*Hivites* (Ahhiyawa, anatolia, Lebanon, Hermon)
Maby you are right but you should keep in mind that Albanians consider themselves as they're sucsesors and refer to them as they're ancestor's
We know that Pharaons tended to embellish their achievements. Already Ramses II turned the battle of Kadesh, at best a draw and more likely a defeat, into a great victory in his account.
Based on the fact that Egypt abandoned its belongings in Asia Minor and retreated beyond the Sinai after the battle, again, it's unlikely it had been more than a hard fought draw.
The Sherden having settled Sardinia only after the battle is higly improbable. The Nuragic civilization doesn't show any significative break in 12th century BC, nor in pottery, burials, art, etc. The supposed invaders should have brought to the island nothing but their name.
The Battle of Qadesh is simultaneous with the Battle of Troy, the battle of Megiddo under Tutmoses III is analog with the battle of Jericho under Joshua.
The Battle of Urshu and Akkad is synchronous with that of Solomon, where Solomon enlists the Hittite General Uriah, and his Chariots
@علئ ياسر or maybe he was a Pharoah
@علئ ياسر No he was a Unicorn and a Hippopotamus
@علئ ياسر you don't have to be sorry, clearly you were dropped on your head, and think the only reality is the one in your head
The sea peoples, were Egyptian races (from which came Philistines), along with others in a coalition against Egypt, and this is their origins:
*MITSRAYIM* (Egyptians):
*Ludim* (Lukka, Lycia- Lod/Lydda, levant)
*Caslukhim* (Tjekker- Dor/Sicani, Sicily)
--> -*-Philistines-*- (Cretes>PELESET- Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Ekron, Gath, Jaffa)
*Caphtorim* (Sherden: Cretes-'Minoans'+Sardinians)
*CANAAN* (Natufians/Phoenicians{Tyre}):
*Yebusites* (Weqshesh- IBIZA/Levant)
*Girgashites* (Weshesh, Karkisha/Caria- levant+Hatti●)
*Hivites* (Ahhiyawa, anatolia, Lebanon, Hermon)
It sounds the Sea Peoples could be more a symptom of the Bronze Age Collapse rather than a cause. Large scale migration due to the various factors (plague, famine, and apparently large scale earthquakes, according to some scholars) that caused the Collapse. Dissatisfaction among the migrants and the disadvantaged may have led to invasions and uprisings across the various city-states, already weakened by whatever natural disasters had preceded. With each major settlement loss, part of the economic web that sustained the cultural complexity of the region was lost, which led to further losses, etc. Eventually most of the major nations besides Egypt fell apart, to the point that, famously, technology like pottery and writing were lost or became much more simplistic across the Mediterranean.
Sounds very contemporary
Precisely, why wouldnt they TRY to take advantage, when all these things were happening anyway outside of any doing with the Sea Peoples. With the bronze age collapse and sea peoples, Egypt and Assyria civ left intact but weakened
Very good point about fall of some cities dominoing others into disarray
11:50 Pigs bred by the Philistines also match that of European boars, not from near Eastern ones. Eric Cline's lectures in the Oriental Institute are awesome by the way.
Iberians, Iber has the same root as Hebrew, and means Over, as in Overseas. The same metonic calendar and Megalithic structures followed wherever they went. The Galatians were even Celts, from Galicia in Iberia
+1 re. historian Eric Cline! For the Cline-curious: I watched a great lecture of his, "1177 B.C.: the year that civilization collapsed" or similar, a while back, for free and right here on TH-cam. It turns out there are several such videos on YT now, but different lengths and from different academic events and venues, so just pick one that fits your schedule, and enjoy!
@@uncannyvalley2350 the place-names for celts, galicia-gaul-wales-kellatoi etc (g-w-k), are variations of the same name. i am not sure the galatians came from iberia. they were in greece since 300 bc, and the tribes' names were not celto-iberian ones it seems. most likely they came from the danube region.
Excellent analysis (as always). I tend to study Far Eastern history more than Middle Eastern, and your quote of Cline's hypothesis reminded me of another hypothesis about why the Mongol army had been so successful in the 13th Century. Western scholars tend to credit the Mongols with superior weapons, horses, armor, etc--things virtually all their defeated opponents had (and in greater quantities and quality). However Genghis Khan successfully united his neighboring tribes at the same time literally all the major civilizations around him were busy infighting and imploding. In fact, it appears many (if not most) of his "horde" was made up of soldiers (and their families) who joined the Mongol side rather than continue to support their previous masters. Back to your video, it would make perfect sense if many of these "Sea People" were locals who saw no future continuing to serve their current leaders, and switched to the "Sea People" side in an effort to get out of the perceived downward spiral that existed in their own culture/government.
Iron age levantines and iron age eurasian settlers from the horn of africa (who reprsent the largest eurasian admixture the region ever had) have more similarities with minoans in terms of dna than they have with their neighboring semites , 80%anatolian neolithic and 20% caucasian huntergatherers(in case of the horneurasiasn) ,that's exactly the same with minoans.
how did anatolian neolithic reach north Eastern africa and the levant if Mediterranean people didnt migrate to those regions, most native semites have above 50% caucasian hunter gatherer ancestry (bedouin arabs have 60-90%), so yeah Mediterraneans did migrate to the those regions.
The sea peoples, were Egyptian races (from which came Philistines), along with others in a coalition against Egypt, and this is their origins:
*MITSRAYIM* (Egyptians):
*Ludim* (Lukka, Lycia- Lod/Lydda, levant)
*Caslukhim* (Tjekker- Dor/Sicani, Sicily)
--> -*-Philistines-*- (Cretes>PELESET- Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Ekron, Gath, Jaffa)
*Caphtorim* (Sherden: Cretes-'Minoans'+Sardinians)
*CANAAN* (Natufians/Phoenicians{Tyre}):
*Yebusites* (Weqshesh- IBIZA/Levant)
*Girgashites* (Weshesh, Karkisha/Caria- levant+Hatti●)
*Hivites* (Ahhiyawa, anatolia, Lebanon, Hermon)
There is archeological evidence that one group of the 'Sea Peoples' had come from the area of the Po River in Northern Italy. They had found evidence of widespread drought during the late Bronze Age, where many of the small villages had been abandoned and the few that weren't suffering from drought saw a large population boom. It is known that those people were actively trading with Sardinia, Sicily, and Greece at the time, so it is possible that some of the people that lived on or near the coast had decided to migrate to the Eastern Mediterranean after hearing about how bountiful the land was and how rich the people were.
If a group of people could destroy the Hittites, Egyptians, and Assyrians then it's more than just the Italians who did it
@@nope929 Do not underestimate the power of the Italians
Some were celts. No I won’t elaborate
It was aliens.
No, not space aliens.
@@GizzyDillespee wow you must be very intelligent
Thanks for doing an episode on the Bronze Age Collapse! I appreciate your take on the subject. It's one of my favorite historical eras, and I hope we'll dig up more evidence in the future.
I absolutely adore learning more about this topic. I'm writing a fantasy novel, with the Bronze Age Collapse actually playing into the mythos. So the more I can learn on the subject, the better. And that you come at this from an Egyptian perspective as well? *chef's kiss*
A Fantasy Novel based upon a Real Era?
@@bradleylaford1526 Heavily based on IRL folklore and mythology. So, no, not like a sword and sorcery of Medieval Europe. More taking the Ancient Egyptian pantheon, and extrapolating that with the bronze age collapse, giving a mass migration of 'the old gods' and they spread across the globe, giving a much more mixed and murky kind of 'where are you really from' feel...
It's hard to explain without actual specifics, bu that's the gist of it.
@@alexandrawilliams1801 that sounds REALLY interesting. Best wishes for your novel!
@@michaels.maguina6526 Thanks! Hope it turns out right.
I love historical novels! Good luck! 👍🏼
This is interesting but it only brings up a bigger mystery: What are Sea Monkeys?
"See People and me!!!"
the c people's pets?
A little different from your usual content, but as I have a huge interest in Ancient history, this was excellently done! Thanks!
Another great video-as usual-and I have my Tuesday Morning History Lesson under my belt. Andrew always does a perfect job of Narration so easy to understand. I appreciate all his work on these video classes~!!
I've seen dozens of videos about the sea peoples, and while I assume this won't be any different I just love RFB content so much Imma watch it.
Same! Love hearing about the Sea Peoples and Bronze Age collapse, and when one of my fave TH-camrs like RFB make a video about it I’m there!
the late bronze age is my favorite time period, the sea peoples are my favorite historical anomaly, and religionforbreakfast is one of my favorite youtube channels! super stoked about this!!
It’s often useful to remember that anything left from ancient Egypt is literal state-religious propaganda. Immensely valuable but immensely biased.
It’s like trusting the death counts in Caesars journal :D
Yeah, but that goes for nearly all historic accounts.
On the one hand it's better than just a few bones. On the other hand it can be totally misleading.
But even if it was pure propaganda and total BS, they did it for a reason. Some parts must be true.
no it's not, there's literally letters between the great empires of the time
@@el_equidistante they don’t mean the whole thing didn’t happen, just that specifically what the Egyptians wrote about it were exaggerated to make Egypt and their Pharaoh look good lol
@@rtlgrmpf Absolutely, a biased source is a great way to learn the biases of people!
You always do such a great job with these videos. Thank you for being so thorough. ❤
This is the best video I’ve watched about them so far. Good work.
Literally just searched for Sea People.
My favorite channel releases a video 2 minutes ago.
My eternal gratitude for the well of information.
Absolutely in love with your content and way of presenting it. 10/10
Absolutely brilliant discussion on this subject. Have watched many of these but the research behind this and information gleaned in only 17 minutes is by far the most I’ve learnt. That lightbulb moment that the so called sea peoples were probably the effect of an already occurring collapse and not so much the cause of it was inspiring and makes more sense… seems like everyone was migrating at the time for food and resources due to famine, plague etc, resulting in conflicts along the way. Bravo on a great scholarly piece.
Love the Bronze age coverage! I bet the Iliad is somewhat inspired by the Greek/Sardinian coalitions attacking the Hittite kingdom during this period.
"Nifty feathered headgear" was my favourite part. The headgear looked Egyptian to me, but with feathers.
We most of us love a mystery and I love a good story. I have heard several historians and archaeologists speak on this topic
Thank you for your clear and concise summary of the main points. I liked your maps as well.
There are details of armor, especially feathered and horned helmets correspond between the Egyptian depictions of the invaders, statuary and and engravings in Sardinia and Sicily. The Egyptian inscription also mentions their islands. So, there is some archaeological support for the idea that at least some of the "sea peoples" may have come from the western Mediterranean.
It's always good to remember that just like the Bronze Age Mediterranean, our way of life is not certain to continue indefinitely. Especially these days. Parallels can be drawn RIGHT NOW, even if things are contextually different.
There is a major difference though - a concept of scientific method had been formulated and it yeiled exponential growth over the past 200+ years.
People know what it is and that it can bring tremendeous power with it. Any leader worth a damn will try to pursue it and it will make them stronger than the rest.
In a sense one could say that a new God was born. One that can challenge the primordial Gods of Elements and everpresent Gods of Social Laws...
Yes, if you get an eruption of the volcano in Santorini again (or Pinatumbo or any other large volcano) our way of life shall change dramatically...
"Sea people are coming!! Help!!"
"Just be strong bro."
Great advice.
Maybe it meant ab ancient state equivalent of "switch to war economy"?
"Hey, have you tried being stronger than you enemy?" - Thanks for the valuable advice, King Obvious I of Cyprus, that really helped a lot.
The best informational and concise video on the the "sea peoples". Thank you!
Great job, Dr Henry 👏
Awesome inclusion of archaeology! Fantastically narrated and illustrated and as usual your editing is 🔥🔥🔥🔥 Probably, maybe, possibly, the favorite words of Bronze Age scholars 🤣
Great presentation! I enjoyed it very much. I'm glad we're unwrapping the scapegoating and looking deeper into the archaeological evidence of these peoples.
I always loved the name "Sea People" because it reminded me of some fantasy story when you have the "People of the Forest" or "The Nation of Light"
Much more romantic than ''boat people."😆
As someone who is hoping to go to grad school to study the LBA Collapse, I really appreciate you making this video
great vid. i hope this turns into a playlist of similar topics
Great presentation. Concise, well illustrated, well spoken. Very interesting. Thanks.
As always: such a great presentation!
Excelente video. Este es uno de los temas más interesantes de la historia antigua. Una síntesis buenísima de un tópico muy complejo.
Science is careful, history is a science. Thanks Religion 4 Breakfast for your careful honesty.
Fast moving, informative video. Perfect.
This is the best video I watched about the sea people, amazing work
Very good presentation, well balanced, I do like Cline's work and feel he is probably more on the right track than most.
One thing I find interesting is that a substantial amount of the Mycaenean forces settling the Levant seem to have done so as a reaction to a similar societal collapse in their own homelands. The entire Bronze Age collapse seems to have been a chain reaction at multiple levels, both administrative and in terms of migration
in crete, they found 80 sites, or more, were entire villages moved to a mountain top to better defend themselves, around that time. it is very like that some of the cretans joined with the invders. if you cannot beat them...
This channel never fails to be fascinating
Great break down! I can tell a lot of work, and research was behind this. Well explained. Well developed thoughts. Seriously really great video!
The bronze age just tickles the imagination like no other point in history!
Maybe because we are close to an information collapse
@@nosuchthing8 Erm... Probably not. I don't think anything short of nuclear war would cause a comparable decline.
Not to say things couldn't go very badly, just not "civilization disappears" bad.
@@monsieurdorgat6864 a coronal ejection from the sum could wipe out and and all electronics. No electricity anywhere.
That could do it.
@@nosuchthing8 Even if a significant EMP happened, it wouldn't really be the end of civilization since most of those electronics could be repaired, albeit it would be a hassle.
@@monsieurdorgat6864 it could be repaired, but it could take a long time to rebuild all those transformers and such
A Historical Perspective:
19 A D. Roman General Germanicus toured Egypt visiting
the ancient site of Karnak-Luxor, which was already as old
as many of the imperial Roman sites we visit today.
Germanicus ! That’s a hell of a name .
4:57
Than you very much, Cyprus! That is a very useful advice!
Mother of Mothers, Mistress of Delights, Lady of the Stars... Hathor has always been my role model. Thank you for making a great video i can share with newbies.
Ramses: You know what they say, history is written by the victors!
Sea Peoples: Written?
this is so fascinating!
A really great summary. Congrats!
Considering the brevity of the video, the scope of the subject matter, very nice.
Great video. More on BCE Sardinia and Mediterranean, please!
So incredibly refreshing to watch an educational video which does more than just recite a Wikipedia article.
Great Doc! Best Regards from Portugal ❤🇵🇹
Thoughtful, balanced and informative. I am impressed.
Not only do I agree that the Philistines may of sprung from the Sea Peoples, but maybe also the Phonecians.
Awesome information and wonderful work. This topic has always fascinated me since I studied a little bit of this for a book character background. Thanks!
Good Video. Boy as a retired Archaeologist living here in California, I sure wish there were symposiums or lectures around discussing topics like this. 🙂
Great editing and pleasant presentation
Eric Cline has a fantastic presentation on this topic found easily on TH-cam
@Epimetheus covered the Sea People extensively. Very worthwhile to watch.
I like to imagine that their identity was lost in the Library of Alexandria, but I’m not sure if there’s anything to that
I never get tired of hearing this stuff
Great video. You explain it very well. I enjoy your content on the ancient world. I studied ancient history in college. TFS.
Have you read the novel The Black Ships, by Jo Graham? It tells this very tale, the Bronze Age Collapse, through the aftermath of the Trojan War. I love fiction about the Bronze Age.
I remember reading a paper a few years ago that was emphasizing how superficial the links between Phillistines and Aegean culture was and that it was just as plausible that they were canaanites who had absorbed a lot of cultural influence. I thought their argument was convincing but I’m alway thrilled to hear new information has come out and the link is now more concrete
As I understand it there's a direct link between the Phillistines and Minoans, both sharing the same love for Purple Seasnail Dye as the Phoenicians
@علئ ياسر yes, and Canaan and Hebrew both spawned from Phoenician who share an awful lot of cultural connections with the Celts, another mysterious group that we know were skilled mariners from their many colonies. We also know the Galatians were Celtic, which is where we get the sea of Galilee
@@uncannyvalley2350 the Phoenicians had a burgundy color/dye, which they brought from the Arabian gulf. It is the same color on the Qatari flag 🇶🇦
@@user-lq7qj8ue1x Tyrian purple, also known as Phoenician red, Phoenician purple, royal purple, imperial purple, or imperial dye, is a reddish-purple natural dye. The name Tyrian refers to Tyre, Lebanon. It is secreted by several species of predatory sea snails in the family Muricidae, rock snails originally known by the name 'Murex'.
@@uncannyvalley2350 it was neither purple nor red, it was Burgundy. They extracted it from a species of Shellfish found almost exclusively in the Arabian gulf. Both Herodotus and 400 years later Strabo wrote that the Phoenicians come from eastern Arabian Peninsula.
Very nice History!! Did not know this about Cyprus notes and sea people in general.. very nice!! Please more Storys whats not already told 10000000times, like this one o.O
Love your content!
Speaking about the Philistines, can you please make a video about their religion? Who were their deities?
This is an excellent idea.
@@ReligionForBreakfast a video on this topic would be appreciated greatly! ♥️
@@ReligionForBreakfast weren't the Philistines from Mycenae? I read somewhere that they left their old relegion behind when they settled and mixed with the canaanites, you should def make a video about it
Would you ever consider doing a video on the Cathars? Or recommend any particular viewing/reading on the topic?
Marvelous work, succinct!!
In my ancient bronze age history class in college I actually attempted to write a research paper aboit the sea peoples but quickly realized my university just didn't have enough sources to do so. All our data bases only had a couple of references. Very fascinating topic that really shows how sometimes, with history, we just don't know.
Sounds like the Vikings were around a lot longer than we thought 🤣🤣
I attended UC Santa Cruz c.1976 and took classes in "Greek history, myth, etc" every quarter but got a psych degree. The "maybe, possibly, could indicate...." has not changed
Very well done and Thanks. I learned a lot.
Very interesting. Thank you for sharing.
A soulslike game taking place during the Bronze Age collapse would be a gold mine.
Probably a new assassin's creed
Most of our monuments and archaeological finds in Sardinia are from the bronze age, so it was probably our wealthiest age in ancient history not only because of commerce, many of those finds are "military" related
I was waiting for you to mention Eric Cline He's great I love his work.
Excellent work!
According to a documentary I saw on TV a long time ago, a serious lead pollution problem occurred in the Northern Hemisphere as a result of Santorini's ancient undersea volcanic eruption. Perhaps the BBC documentary in the UK.
At that time, Santorini had a Mediterranean international trade market, where lead was used as a weight.Those weight were vaporized by the heat of volcanic eruptions and spread to the northern hemisphere with volcanic ash. Then even in Ireland(?Iceland) and elsewhere, the growth of trees almost stopped for several years. People who deal with the collapse of the Bronze Age on TH-cam don't really mention this.
Of course, there's dispute about the time of that eruption, but it's said that the trees didn't grow around 1500 bc, maybe.
Before and after the Hyksos era, there were signs of eruptions of volcanos in Ethiopia, which could have caused pests and drought in Egypt.
And I think this is important, after that disaster people around santorini stopped believing "old God". Sadly I cannot provide evidence now, but there should be, guess.
//////
Although the cause of the sinking is unknown, a huge amount of copper was found on a ship that sank during that time. If the raw material of thousands of bronze swords was on its way to cities that were trying to arm themselves to survive in chaos, the cities that didn't get the copper would have been destroyed.(From "Study of Antiquity and the Middle Ages")
the hekla 3 eruption in iceland is more significant
Don't forget, Iceland has its own volcanoes...in addition to volcanoes in Italy, Sicily, and somewhere else, in between...and other mega-eruptions across the world have affected weather and plant growth, world-wide...
Shardana warriors also display some weapons and helmets similar to iron age warriors from Sardinia. But, like you said they could have settled there after the collapse.
there is no evidence of an invasion or political instability in Sardinia until much later
I went to the Medinet Habu Temple and at the time I was told the temple’s design was based on a Near East fortress. The main pylon really is unlike other temples. The temple is full of war scenes: the mutilated hands you mentioned, and also decapitaded heads, and taking captives for slavery. I didn’t notice that in other temples. I feel like that period of Egyptian history might have been one of the most brutal in terms of war.
Great job!!!!!!! keep doing it. I want more
This is just long enough to get me through the rest of my trail ride home from an exhausting convention day lol. Perfect timing! :D
I don't quite remember which one but I'm pretty sure one Greek source mentioned Sardinia taking its name from the Shardana, since it was one of their major ports but not necessarily their place of origin. It's also noticeable that greek lacking a SH sound would make Shardania and Sardania the same.
Also, pre-roman sardinian bronze figurines often display headgear with feathers or horns and some other artifacts are shared with the rest of the mediterranean but that a lot of commerce was taking place at the time is no secret
little factoid: the ancient hebrew sources would write the "plst" name with "Ph" or "F" sound character. hence the filistine-palestine (as the romans called them) dicotomy.
Thanks for this.
Fascinating stuff!
The horned helmet's are key,and the description of them as an island confederation,and the plausible story involves the tin trade empires (Sardinia being an ancient source,and trading empire)Corsica had an advanced horn Helmut and metallurgy and trade(look for bronze statuettes wearing horned hats,also in common with Greece)great show,thanks
This is a good historical example of correlation not being causation. The relationship between the invasion of the sea people and the bronze age collapse are not simple causation. They could be reversed, both caused by other factors, or entirely coincidence! Data inconclusive.
Very well there may be causation behind the correlation. You just don’t know if A caused B or B caused A. A common problem in my field of science which is geology.
I prefer the peaches and poison ivy example. Poison ivy blooms when peaches do, but eating peaches doesn't give you poison ivy.
That orbital shot of Cyprus/Anatolia/Levant was super cool.