The only times when Hanbin cried was when his friends got eliminated. No matter that he got so much criticism, no matter he went through such frustrating moments, no matter how down he felt, he never cried again. Even in the end he gave us his widest smile..
@@ophaniepe87 TRULLY RIGHT.usually i smile whe he smile. The fact that he smile while getting eliminate is just hurt my heart. Your smile make me cry last night. And IM not GONNA lie. I can't sleep last night too😭😭
@@yardanzaki8 I dreamed about him (in the show, haha) a lot last night. Cannot remember exactly but I think there was some twist. God, I was obsessed about him.
But like the judges do realized that Hanbin be hitting them high notes in every episode, and his vocals is sure very unique and when he sings its just so clear and satisfying. Honestly Belift lost another talented person, shame on them. 😔
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
you can hear Hanbin mics was adjusted like LOUDER than others, he sang like HALF of the song LIVE while dancing powerfully the hell out .. and PDs said his voice didn't fit ???? This is a Burning song, then it supposed to "got the felling like it's burning down" PDs,,, see other contestants fancam, they didn't even try to lip sync. that pisses me offff
This man should not be wasted...we all want him..he will become a great artist..If not KPOP artist than a VPOP artist..or maybe both..but he will debut soon
I brawled my eyes out when he smiled as he said goodbye to the producers. He is such a happy and bubbly person, he held his tears back so well. He is the sunshine on my bad days. He worked hard. I’m glad he made it at least this far into the show...
Imagine Hanbin conditioning himself for the worst before their real stage because he could feel that this could be his last performance and just gave his best on this stage so no regrets would linger. That's why, I think, he didn't shed a tear because he knew he did his best.
they literally NEVER showed him on screen only when he was having a hard time or when he was frustrated. He also NEVER got his feedback only when they thought he did "bad". I just think he deserve so much better. I also feel like the camera made it seem like he wasn't that close with the others contestants but you could clearly see that when he got eliminated they were crying so hard literally all of them. Hanbin just know that we all support you and that you're amazing.
Exactly! Jay, Niki, K, Sunoo, Jake, Daniel, Heeseung...literally all of them were so upset when he was eliminated. Hanbin was definitely very close to them
Every one comes here for Hanbin, could you join with us s.t.reaming Hanbin fancams, please ? Bcz just a month, his birthday will come. All guys love him want to prepare some surprise gifts for him. And the first gift for Hanbin is s.t.ream all of his fancam reaching 1M. And one person couldnt do it but we all can do it easily. Not debut yet. But everything he did, we saw. We just want his effort to be recognized and in the future, he will get better chances.
한빈이가 눈을끌어서 여길 끌어왔네 ㅋㅋ 아이랜드에서 나 한빈이떄도 좋았는데 역시 원래 이렇게 잘 웃는애였는데 아일랜드 쪼는 오디션이라서 자신감 엄청 없어 보였는데 ㅠ 얼마나 전소속사??가 힘들었는지 알겠따 지금은 엄청 방끗방끗 웃는데 원래 잘웃고 그러는데 ㅋ 목소리가 카랑카랑해서 튐 얼굴도 키 같음 ㅋㅋ 김기범목소리비슷함 ㅎㅎ 그래서 지금 ㅁ그룹에서도 킬링파트 리드 싸비 그런부분 하던데 ㅎㅎ 한빈이 부분이 기억에 남음 다른멤버도 목소리는 좋은데 한빈 얼굴 허스키한목소리가 각인ㅋㅋㅋ의기소침한데 이떄도잘생겻네 ㅋㅋㅋ
Hanbin took all the highnote in this, and GOD, this song’s too much highnote, strong choreagraphy. That make him tired, although he took many vocal part before, he’s never been trained to become a main vocal? But he still SLAYED all his part.
hanbin sang almost half of the song but he recieve bad comment about his vocal. no way! hanbin voice is amazing noticable. actually his voice was kind of refreshing.
I asked my friend her honest opinion , and I sent her this video link , and she told me he did very good and that she LOVED his voice , his movement were very powerful , this is unfair , there is a rumor saying hanbin got 2 M votes that's why he was voted out ...that's so dirty , I will support niki now even though I feel he might be an other victim as well
@@ndj9576 if it is your opinion then go for it. everyone has freedom to say what opinion it is. but pls be a human give at least small amount of respect to hanbin. he did nothing to u but here u are saying hurtful words. tsk
He has a very unique vocal range. Even K was feeling anxious when Sunoo was looking for someone to fill Ta-ki’s place. K even said that he can’t afford Hanbin to lose in their group because he know that Hanbin has a great voice and he can dance well! I’m really sad and disappointed. But what can i do this is how the reality show works. ☹️
If Hanbin wasn’t eliminated by producers, he would have debuted with global votes and that is what made producers SCARED out of their mind. Anyways supporting where’ve you go Hanbin!
He always in charge of the most difficult singing part. His voice is really unique and he has accent because he is not Korean.Why didn’t producers commentand help him? They only discouraged him then freaking eliminated him
BTS IS MY YOUTH I don’t think they had plan for him to make it this far. No one is perfect but they had to choose him. The guy that work his way from the ground up to rank 4 only to be put down to last before global vote. Because they said his voice didn’t fit? All for that? It made me sad
They don't even focus on vocal. Only 1 time i see the female vocal trainer. And obviously they don't want Hanbin to debut, 'cuz they already have the group in their mind. They use Hanbin just to gain views from international fans, because i-land is flop in Korea.
Minh Hằng Nguyễn yeah honestly it’s all about fate but their all biased, I found out that they might of saved Jake in the past by letting him win because although he deserved it if he didn’t win people said he could have gotten eliminated, I don’t think he could but I think they wanted to focus on the spotlight for Jungwon since he told them that it was a wake up call and that he wants to do better. I’m worried for the group, they have good vocals but it’s mostly with dancers, people are saying their going to kick Niki and K so that it can be a only Korean group which is like wtf
Yup. They were only focusing on dance and stage presence and now all of a sudden they care about vocals?? Hanbin has one of the best voices there and in this episode you can see that he took the advice from that one dude. He improved and was able to show more power on stage. It's so unfair that they eliminated him.
If his vocals were bad why didn’t you mention it episodes ago? Why not show how a vocal coach could have help him fix his vocals? Y’all had to go there when he literally did the high notes in every damn episode and yet us as viewers never saw any feedback (good or bad) about his voice. The only feedback Hanbin received in this rigged show was when he wasn’t doing so good with the choreography, y’all disgust me.
1st fact: Into the iland studio version hanbin got many lines. 2nd fact: I & cridible studio version hanbin got many line . 3rd fact: Hanbin hit high notes. Now fun fact: He got eliminated b'coz of his voices.
Hanbin is not really my bias but his vocals captured me that is why I supported him, he's a very kind person because even tho he's eliminated he kept on smiling. I'm proud of you, Hanbin!
@@ndj9576 my ult bias is K but I never badmouthed the other i-landers. Better keep that hate speech of yours on your own, you just spread toxicity and immaturity.
i'm still so so mad at the fact that they didn't even compliment hanbin in this performance. HE DID SO WELL PLEASE 😭 i cant and will not move on from this 😭
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
Usually, Hanbin‘s fancams always have the highest views. But not this time, because a lot of fans stopped watching I-Land and lost interest in streaming Hanbin‘s fancam when Hanbin got eliminated. Hanbin‘s fanbase is really no joke! You can see that in the views of Hanbin‘s thank you message on C.A.C‘s youtube channel that we moved to him instead to show our support to him outisde of I-Land. The video there has already over 400.000 views after one day! :O
Hanbin was never appreciated or acknowledge for his efforts he puts in every stage performance that he is in, Hanbin deserved better, best I can do right now is stream Hanbin's cams and continue to support him in his debut.
The only time he ever got a chance to shine they took it away from him, Hanbin deserves to debut in a company that respects and appreciates him, not a show where he was given false hope of debuting. Everyone if your reading this Let's continue to support Hanbin.
I can't stop crying. Why...? Mnet gives Hanbin more screentimes 'cause they want we know he will get eliminated? Mnet is Mnat, the way they edit is the same as Produce. Mnet hates Hanbin so much and they want him to get eliminated as soon as well but also want to keep him because of views. After this I will BURN YOU, MNET! Through he gets eliminated but he still keeps his bright smiles untill the end, it makes me cry more. When he cry, I cry. He smiles, I smile. But now, he smiles, I cry...It hurts me to see him like that, why can he still smile like that? Thanks for being a part of my youth...or even my life, Hanbin! I always support you no matter what. Just remember, I and Hannies always by your side. HANBIN FIGHTING!!
I still cry... Why? Hanbin gets more screentimes because he would be eliminated?! I will burn Mnet after this. Mnet is Mnat, the drama is where, Mnet is there. The votes is okay, but the way they edit is the same as Produce. Hanbin smiles when he gets eliminated, cried when his friends get eliminated. He keeps his bright smile untill the end. He cried, I cry. He smiles, I smile. But now, he smiles, I cry. Follow you from ep 1 untill now, spend all of my time to watch your fancam and vids about you. Thanks for being a part of my youth...or even my life, Hanbin. I and Hannies always support you, I hope you will debut soon. HANBIN FIGHTING!!
"If non-koreans want screentime, either show badboy concept or non-perfection in performance. If u don't do that, we still have option- evil editing" thats Mnet logic.😑 mnet's way of saying we don't want him to debut.
You can literally hear him breathing hard He sang 100 % live Literally he trained to be a rapper but sang all the time in iland I’m sooo proud of him !!!! We can agree that something was off about this stage Others had autotune Or lip sync sometimes but Hanbin literally didn’t have all that Fuck Mnet literally I’m so done Hanbin voice is addicting unique and powerfully more vocal training he will be unstoppable for sure I’m so happy he will debut soon He deserves it
you can hear Hanbin mic was adjusted like LOUDER than others, he sang like HALF of the song LIVE while dancing powerfully the hell out .. and PDs said his voice didn't fit ???? If he sang like 50% then he's not the one that had to fit, it/s the others! This is a Burning song, then it's supposed to "got the felling like it's burning down" PDs,,, see other contestants fancam, they didn't even try to lip sync. that pisses me offff
Agreed. I've watched all the fancams now and it is hard to believe anyone else is even singing live. That's not to say they couldn't, there are a lot of good singers in the group. But I-land has regularly auto tuned people who were off throughout the competition (like fake love). Why not do that here? Well we already know it's because they wanted an excuse to eliminate him
@@defrost1027 his voice was too strong bc he had to sing without backup voice, yes his vocal was cracked but the fact that he was the only one who didn't lip sync. I mean, what are they trying to create? A dance group or a idol group? They didn't even show us if the boys had a vocal coach or something related.
Hanbin has never been trained to be a main vocal, maybe even a vocal. But he always took main vocal part and did it so well. Just this time, the dance was to hard 😠
He was prepared to be a rapper, in fact in his first performance he rapped.. But in Iland he had to take the vocal parts, the high notes because even the guys said that Hanbin was the only one who could hit those notes and was stable when dancing and singing, K said Hanbin was the only one who could do it live! And then the producers have the nerve to say that to our faces, like, seriously? Who are they kidding? They just wanted to give an excuse to get him off the show.
Exactly and the only reason he got all the high notes was because no one else could do them. If you look at previous episodes Hanbin always got stuck with the position with the most high notes because no one else wanted it. And plus of course his voice is going to stand out he’s freaking Vietnamese and he has an accent.
Yeah I don't think this was his best singing but it sounds like he's the only one singing live. I think they turned his mic up too. It's frustrating to me because the show has pretty much only focused on dance, but all of a sudden they are talking about vocals. If they really cared about vocals Geonu would probably still be there. They were just looking for a way to get him out.
Why hannies doesn't really stream this fancam 1.Hannies are still crying 2.Hannies are busy Building a zoo 3.Hannies are planning to have a corn field in the moon 4.Hannies are planting trees 5.Hannies are busy donating for people who needs help 6.Hannies are busy collecting the stars for hanbin
So the producers said that Hanbin‘s voice stood out too much in a bad way. Well, it‘s his voice. He can‘t change it. At least it‘s unique and you can always tell that it‘s Hanbin‘s voice. I-Land doesn‘t deserve him!
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
I hate the way Bang PD said Hanbin got a lot of things from this show. He earned his chance to shone on those stages dude, everyone wants to see him more. He played fair the whole show, always being supportive of his fellow contestants. We Hannies knew your devil plan from the start but still support Hanbin with all our hearts because Hanbin deserved the support and the love. You didn't do him any favors Bang PD, he earned it all. You didn't even spare him any screentime how could you said he got a lot from this show?? Hanbin being Hanbin, you criticized it, but it is all viewers want. I just wish I have a chance to see Hanbin being him more in the future, I will be here waiting for him.
Are u deliberately unable to realize that every editing is done by mnet and not bighit?.. Bighit manages only trainees....production is from mnet.... And next thing....Bangpd knows better than u...coz without any VOTING he made BTS,TXT...so u must realise that they want best from the best...not the one who still learning... Heesung didn't debut with txt but he is an ace....he trained a bit more and debuting now...so... everyone has its own time
@@chile-hy8jm i mean mnet can't do without bang pd becoz bang pd was paid all those money heesueng is not an ace when txt was formed becoz those 5 have chosen based on thierr top 5 rankering in monthly evaluation test
Excuse me, but... since when Bang Sihyuk is the one in charge of filming and editing? I didn't know the millionare CEO of one of the most big companies is now doing evil editing to his show. Woah.
I was so mad when judges said that hanbin´s voice was sticking out too much and that he had to work on it.....like he is a STAR he is meant to sticking out
The thing which makes me frustrated the most isnt that Hanbin was eliminated. It's that Hanbin received nothing but pain from the producers. Let's imagine how much he was down and lost his confidence but still had to hold it in and fight till the end. And yeah till the very end, he didnt receive a single compliment or supportive speech from The PDs. Bang PD said sth as if he should feel thankful coz he got this far while his rivals are way stronger than him. But nope, they're equally good. Hanbin didnt lack that much in comparison.
Bang pd must be kidding. What the hack does mean ''he got this far while his rivals are way stronger than him''? They didn't even give him a chance to shine in the show. How could he said that, he dont even rights to say this!
@@seok2131 sorry I didnt make it clear enough, my bad English 😂 He didnt say exactly that, just it made me feel that way. He said something like you got to the semi-final with really strong candidates, you've got many from the show (or this chance, I'm not sure and not brave enough to watch again) which normal trainees cannot experience, or something similar...
@@minniebl He really tried his best and fight for every chance he had yet still managed to show his bright and happy virus side. Hard-working, sincere, and humble. He deserves to be loved and supported ❤️
I'm just new to the whole iland show due to Hanbin hashtags trending on Twitter. I've seen some cams of him and other performers and this guy stood out the most. Other members' performances are kinda underwhelming. Harbin's movements are sharp, 100% present, the facial expressions are on point... too bad he was eliminated
When the producers treated him as if he was the black hole and inferior one to the others in the Flame On group, the Flame On team members actually saw his skills and abilities, and entrusted Hanbin with lots of essential and hard parts and believed Hanbin was essential to the group. Even when Sunoo was choosing a member to replace Taki in Chamber 5, Sunghoon and K did not want to lose Hanbin. When someone suggested that Hanbin could have been chosen by Sunoo, Sunghoon said "That shouldn't happen", and K said "We can't let Hanbin go".
I know that every shows like this has already planned and honestly this result is not surprising me. At the beginning Hanbin is not in the line so this is the last "chance" to eliminate him. It's easy to realize that Hanbin's parts always cut and he had the least screentime. There almost have no PD comments for him. When he did well, they just ignored. But in this ep, they spent so much screentime for him like showing us why they gonna eliminate this guy. K-pop likes giving no chance for Vietnamese. Sound negative but it's true (at least at this moment) :) but who know if Hanbin could debut in the future like he said bc his talent is real ! Just keep supporting him guys
Hanbin is someone who can help increase the ratings every week, that's why they keep him until the end of the show, I think this is just using the view sentence.
HE HAS NEVER TRAINED AS A MAIN VOCALIST. JUDGES/OTHER PEOPLE HATE HIM BECAUSE OF HIS ACCENT. LIKE TF? HIS DANCE HIS FACIAL EXPRESSIONS? THERES ONLY DANIEL WHO HAS THE BEST VOCAL IN THE GROUP AND HANBIN TRIED. BUT HE GOT ELIMINATED JUST FOR THAT??? SAME THING WITH GEUNO BC OF HIS EXPRESSIONS??? OMG...
Is happened with felix stray kids too ,he got eliminated because his korean not so good, luckily he still can debut with stray kids, I feel the same here too
Compare to felix hanbin can hit highnote dance well can rap but i live felix tooo i wish hanbin would have gone jyp instead of bighig i love bighit becoz of txt and bts but somehow i lost trust in bighit
Oh gosh, can we accept a fact that Hanbin sang live 100% without any help of autotune? That's why he's the only person whose voice stands out too much, esp with full of high notes like this.
Hơn 3 năm rồi, bây giờ mới có cảm giác thoải mái khi xem lại fancam này của Hưng. Hồi trước cứ mỗi lần xem đều cảm thấy ko vui, thậm chí là nhói lòng vì nó gắn với kỷ niệm ko mấy vui vẻ. Nhưng mà thời gian trôi qua, giờ tất cả đều trở thành kỷ niệm đẹp. Hanbin I-land giờ đã là Oh Hanbin của Tempest, nhưng vẫn là Ngô Ngọc Hưng của tụi mình.
I know right...like his vocals are so unique and beautiful.. Like I am an ARMY and my bias is J-Hope and V is my bias wrecker...and I love them because of their personalities but also the uniqueness of their vocals...So Bighit definitely knows how to manage unique vocals,but deciding to let go of Hanbin based on that is just absurd!
It's so powerful! And when Bang PD said that I was like WTH?! Jimin has a very unique voice but look at him! his in the biggest boy band now! How can they eliminate someone who nailed high notes while doing a hard choreo. I am still very upset with this.
Yeah, I didn’t really get why “Hanbin is always Hanbin” could be a criticism. His vocals seemed to fit in well with the group. I think he just followed how he was told to sing. If he wasn’t fitting in K or the other members would have addressed it.
I'll try to explain their criticism. It's bec Hanbin sounds the same every single song. Tbh it's like he's still singing DIY while singing FO. There's where the 'vocal placement' takes place. Hanbin should make different attacks and impressions to different songs. I still love Hanbin tho. And I will wait til he debut.
Exactly, I am so agree with u! This is literally «a bad workman blames his tools», them producers blamed Hanbin on having a unique voice?? That is so stupid, I would not be suprised if their future boy groups appear to be plain like any other groups, if they cant even step out of the comfort zone then they will never see the gems.
this is gonna sound so bitter but I don't even care... seeing how both my biases got eliminated from the producers's vote just got me so hollow right now... i'm still bitter over Geonu but now I cannot contain it anymore... - having less to almost none screen-time for the whole part 1 & 2 - just got his most screen-time on his last episode - we still didn't get that feedback when he performed Dive Into You, where the hell is it??! - got shown his feedback now when they deemed him performing bad & not matching up with the others vocally - don't even get me started with the obvious cut on his Nano Dance part in eps 9 the way the producers' criticizing Hanbin's vocal just left me speechless, like wow are they kidding me?? coming from a show that BARELY give attention to vocal (no vocal training scenes, vocal teacher came for just a couple second not even shown training them or anything, also STILL NO RAP??!), make it make sense??? THEN TRAINED THEM VOCAL PROPERLY GODDAMNIT!! Arrrgghh i'm so pissed!! Hanbin baby you do deserve better, your unique voice deserve better~ We will wait for your debut to happen! (imagine if Hanbin debut together with Geonu, Nicholas, Jaebeom? maaannn it's gonna be so epic!) Hanbin fighting!! Hannies let's stay strong!
If they had a vocal coach on the show, he would've improved so much. We barely saw 100% live vocals from most of the trainees too. It's obvious what they prioritize cause it ain't vocals.
bang pd has his own vocal style prefrence, anything outside that is not welcome, v has consistently the least amount of lines in bts songs, and they make him sing high notes even though he is not a soprano, meanwhile he got SO MANY compliments orm teacher alice in american hustle life, she said you have a voice that makes people listen. honestly hanbin is better off without them, I will wait until he debutes and support him there. hope he finds a good company and good teammates.
hanbin deserved better. I don't understand why they eliminated him. I ofc don't wanna explicitly say there are members that are worse that Hanbin or that Hanbin is better than x member but episode 11 felt so uncalled for. The only episode was Hanbin was allowed to shine with his part he's also eliminated it. They never showed Hanbin getting feedback for DNA of Dive Into You. He has strong vocals and an incredibly unique vocal tone plus his clean dance moves. Maybe it was because he didn't perfectly match the concept but he tried and improved non the less.
I miss him so much, He hasn't posted anything on Twitter in over a month. I'm waiting for your debut. I love you so much, and hannies always beside you,
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
Everyone can see that when Hanbin was eliminated, his expression was not very surprised like he knew he was eliminated, in the last picture everyone can see that he was sad, I don't know Is it because of the gimmicks of the organizers, but I feel very disappointed in how this show works
Hanbin sang the highest notes of the song and the producers tell him he didn't sing good??? They couldn't say anything about his performance because it was flawless! And also, they never even commented about the singing part to the other contestants. They just care about dance...but this time is the reason Hanbin is leaving??? Absurd. The moment I saw Hanbin was finally getting screentime I knew something was off
So the only complaint they had about the performance was his singing, like this is the ONLY time they've judged singing and of course it's Hanbin...like you've got other members of the group who sang two low pitched lines that got praise but Hanbin is hitting those HIGH notes but bc his voice was shaky at times bc he's actually singing live unlike many other I-land performers he gets negative feedback...
They never cared about vocal but then all of a sudden they be talking about vocal to eliminate trainee and of course that trainee happened to be Hanbin
Yeah, that was suspicious. During the practise Mr. Son critized Hanbin‘s dancing skills. And then suddenly after the real performance they critized Hanbin‘s voice. Like wtf... They really just tried to find reasons to eliminate him... -.-
To be honest, they didn’t even complaint about his singing. It wasn’t even about his singing was bad or what. They said was his “ACCENT”, said it was too harsh so he sounded “too distinguished” from others. Like isn’t that what make an idol unique? They prefer 10 similar voices rather than 1 unique voice. I don’t get the PDs tbh...
I agree and if they help him more regarding his vocals i know 1 week will help not that much but it will definitely help him if only they didnt focusmuch on his dancing
@@Shiragami0981 Apart from that I thought they are planning to create a global group for global fans, and it means members should be from different countries, rather than more Korean members. And foreign members might sing with a little accent. That's normal! In addition to that Korean members always have this military service problem, they have to interrupt their career to do their military service. And this not a problem for foreign members. Also I want to mention the fact that a lot of members who remained in the show now are 14-15-17 yo singing songs with sexy lyrics like "Dive into me, I'll dive into you" or "touch me like this, I'll touch you like that"... I mean wtf!
I was so shocked when their critic to Hanbin was that his voice wasn't very good and that his voice didn't fit with the others, when I thought he was the best out of all of them, when I didn't even have him as my top pick. Like he stood out in a really good way and made the whole group seem a lot better than they would've without him.
There is a guy who worked in vocal training and music field pointed out that in the performance, other members voice got autotuned filter while Hanbin's didn't. Also, Hanbin had to carry all the hardest vocal parts. He basically sang half of the song.
He is too good for Mnet’s shit.. They didn’t know that they just lost someone that talented. Mnet always make him so dirty, never give him chance to shine like others. Giving others a good feedback but not on him. Tried to hide him behind others. Without HANBIN, I LAND are totally different now.. IT’S OKAY HANBIN, I WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT YOU NO MATTER WHAT. YOU DESERVE WORLD MY BABY❤️
Big Hit will regret that they let HANBIN go! He’s so talented and unique. He’ll definitely debut in a different label. I will wait for him, because he’s my ultimate bias
Honest question- if Hanbin wasn’t eliminated, who do you think should’ve been? Someone had to leave, and only based on these two performances? (Ps I do love Hanbin, no hate actually curious) 💖
Mai Lan so who in your opinion deserved to be in last? (I love them all and don’t want to see any go- but if you had to pick JUST base on these last two performances, who would you say?)
Hanbin, we’re here. We got your back. Don’t worry, just shine like you always are. And thank you to those who voted for Hanbin even just one vote. Thank you. From the bottom of every Hannies heart, we know HANBIN MATTERS AND DESERVE ALL THAT LOVE. Thank you Hannies, we will meet again.
I can't help but think that they never wanted Hanbin to debut. After seeing how much fans are voting for him, and this is the last round for the judges to get someone out before fans decide the final 7, they have to get him out. I really don't wanna think it like that.. but the editing of Hanbin throughout the show has really sent my mind to dark conspiracy theory areas. I'm so sad he's gone....
the amount of screen time he got was very telling in my opinion :/. I'm really mad because he was very close to the other i-landers and we rarely got to see that on the actual show. And we didn't know about his feedback in DNA and DIY when he did amazing! I'm very sad and mad at how they treated him :(
I still can't believe that he got eliminated. My heart is so broken up until now.. I will surely miss his fancams, especially his smile, my favorite ones. Everytime he smile, I automatically smile too and I assure that everyone is like me. He kept smiling up until the end of his journey. I love him so much, and I believe that HE WILL DEBUT. I will wait for him.
Its fine, They didnt deserve him, He is way too good for them, I hope he debuts under a company that actually understands him and appreciates all his talents and never sleeps on him. I will wait for you~
Funny how he got criticized for his vocals, when they don’t even have a vocal producer... They showed that women once and that was it.... Also, notice how he is one of the few people that actually sing live! But maybe him leaving was for the best; I am sure the members will miss him, but surely no mnet... Hanbin, good luck! I will wait for you, so please don’t give up!!
Some people are wondering why his views is not on top its bc his fans still cant watch and accept the fact hes gone in iland.. but on his recent video it got over 400k 😭 i love this fandom so much! Hannies we got this ❤️
So they decide to eliminate him. Well no surprise since they always sleep on him like they have no interest on him. I love you hanbin, i will wait for your debut. Hwaiting!
They just don't deserve our hanbinnie.... that's it...I was actually a very big fan of his vocals...Not everyone can sing that much well and that too in live..Let's just feel positive about this bcoz if hanbinnie had debuted with this group he would have been seriously ill treated by the company. We are all already seeing how foreign idols are not treated well when compared to k-idols. So we'll hope hanbin debuts soon in a company where they really appreciate him and treat him well...
his voice was one of the reasons i loved him... his personality adds up too why i love him too... he draws attention because of his voice and how he can sing so well live... THE PRODUCERS LOST 2 DESERVING MAIN VOCALS... they wasted Geonu, and now Hanbin... really dissapointed...
His voice literally had the perfect tone to fit the song tho and his voice complimented the other trainees’!! I actually think the problem here was that K’s vocals didn’t really fit the vibe of the song, they were all incredible still tho
ok so now that i’m healed after hanbin’s message on cac’s channel, i can finally face this fancam and let me tell you: hanbin did amazing. some of ya’ll on twt and reddit are clearly untalented and don’t know what you’re talking about and it shows. hanbin is the only one who sang live without loud ass backtrack and post-production autotune but still remained stable most of the times. don’t come here for his technique if you’ve never tried to dance and jump around while maintaining your head voice or falsetto. mnet did him dirty again by putting in his raw vocals not realising he did such a good job as a trainee. some of your debuted idols lip sync the whole mf song when standing still. now compare that to a person who trained only for 11 months and entered this show with rapping. in other words, hanbin world domination 👋
Exactly. I'm not a professional but I think he did well for a trainee. He was trained only in 11 months but can rap, dance well and sing live without backup voice or autotune ❤️ Not to mention his expression and stage present 😌 He also said he wanted to be an idol that can do well many kinds of concept and I can't wait to see him on stage performing a cute bubbly song that would be suitable for him ❤️ P/s: he got me so emotional so sorry if I talked too much ha ha...
@@annap4466 Who wouldn't though... Whenever I think about it I'm getting anxious again 😥 but I'll try to be positive like him ❤️ Don't know what company he will debut under but I hope they treat him fair ❤️❤️❤️ P/s: I see some people think this video got so less view because fan don't want to watch him anymore because he's out but I think actually we can't stand seeing him trying his best and feeling so down after that 😭
You know the annoying thing!? He had the most parts with high vocals, he also had to focus on expression and dance. That's a lot of work, remember Niki in into the iland... That's literally same scenario. Hanbin will be back better and stronger, with a huge fandom behind him
Someone better get fired for this. It’s the composition of the song has weird low notes and weird adlibs. How come no one mention the off low notes? If they have a problem with Hanbins parts why didn’t the producers say anything while the trainees practice? Producers are the professionals. The problem is not HanBin.
Some questions I really want to ask: - They complained about his dancing all the time, even minutes before his real show. Why all of a sudden, they switched it to his voice? Where was the vocal trainer? Why didn't they comment on his vocal before? - Why did he never get any compliments? He barely got any screentime. And eventually, he got some, it was because they were his last moments. Why he always ranked the lowest in DNA and now Flame On? Do you really think he was the worst? - Why they never paid attention/complained about anyone's vocal but then Hanbin was eliminated because of something he can def work on?
And why no body say anything about the super low vocals? It don’t even match the song. Also, if they have probably with his voice why did they assign him the high important parts? This is producers bad. If they don’t think song turn out well it is their fault not HanBin. HanBin did good job.
@@jennifervan4375 That's what I have always wondered. I'm not a KPop fan so I don't know much how it works. Prob because I'm so used to VPop, the other members' voice sounds really weak to me tbh.
The whole episode was made to dedicate Hanbin's exit. They played really well by showing how he wasn't doing well. They expected massive energy from him. They expected angelic vocals from him. They only expected exceptional skills from him but failed to recognize his true talent. They had already planned Hanbin's exit. Period.
@@nhungtruong3574 tui cũng nghĩ vậy. Giọng mấy cậu còn lại yếu như con gà hen ấy. Có mấy đoạn đẩy mic to rất rõ. Mic của hưng bài này nhỏ hơn bình thường thì phải. Bài test trước, đoạn điệp khúc đồng ca giọng cậu ấy vang, cao, khỏe át cả giọng thành viên còn lại.
What, they eliminated Geonu for lacking at facial expressions and because he is not the best at dancing, and now Hanbin, who has great expressions, vocals and dance! Like wth!?? They really planned a line up already. They dont deserve a guy as good as him tho. He deserves so much better.... Edit: What some of ya'll are replying saying he doesnt belong to the debut team and something else, but like bruh- then why are you here watching his fancam?? XD
how come the producers thought his voice didnt suit this performance where he was the only one and can belt out his voice and at the same time can CAN SING WELL THAN OTHERS?????
I think it's because his voice is naturally higher compared to the other members. Personally it stood out to me in a really good way, I really really love his voice and I think it suited the energy of the song the most, but I guess the producers want the team to be more homogenous and cohesive? Idk man, in the end they did him so dirty
175 jnd lol u rly had to make an effort to make an acc just to spread hate about hanbin on ever comment on here huh 😂 i really hope karma will get you very soon. u betta watch out and regret everything
The fact that hanbin didn’t cry after getting eliminated hurts so much 😭 he stayed strong till the end & im so damn proud to have become his fan since day 1. WE WILL WAIT FOR YOUR DEBUT SOMEDAY!
Okeh so when they Finally gave him screen time thats when they decided to eliminate him and also the feedbacks. We never heard them give a positive feedback to hanbin (except for the his eyes shine thing) NOT EVEN ONCE AND WHEN THEY DECIDED TO SHOW THE FEEDBACKS THEY DECIDED TO SHOW THE BAD ONES.I DEMAND THE OTHER FEEDBACKS MNET
@@vtfulserendipityz6663 I do think he got complimented by producers on DNA for improving his vocals but mnet don't show it to us and now they show it as he improved but went down again...🙄
![[I-LAND/직캠] 아이컨택 l 케이 ♬Flame On @Part.2 세 번째 테스트 : 콘셉트 200911 EP.11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HCQ2X_RPFqg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[I-LAND/직캠] 아이컨택 l 케이 ♬Flame On @Part.2 세 번째 테스트 : 콘셉트 200911 EP.11](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG] [I-LAND/Behind] I-LAND cute morning zombies having breakfast ♥ 200821 EP.8](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eWD50HeU6Qs/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TEMPEST #3] Khi bạn là IDOL nhưng không quên mình cũng là một CHIẾN THẦN phố đi bộ Đông Lào (P3)](/img/n.gif)
The fact he called everyone his “friends” and mentioned his dream was being able to perform on stage and have fun with them as friends. >.
He soft wtf why am I crying a river like his smile EVEN WHEN HE WAS LEAVING WTF,, i land lost a sunshine.
The only times when Hanbin cried was when his friends got eliminated. No matter that he got so much criticism, no matter he went through such frustrating moments, no matter how down he felt, he never cried again. Even in the end he gave us his widest smile..
and that smile made me cry so much for him last night 😭😭😭
People think he is a soft person but he actually a tough guy, have a strong mind in a very young ages
@@ophaniepe87 TRULLY RIGHT.usually i smile whe he smile. The fact that he smile while getting eliminate is just hurt my heart. Your smile make me cry last night. And IM not GONNA lie. I can't sleep last night too😭😭
@@yardanzaki8 I dreamed about him (in the show, haha) a lot last night. Cannot remember exactly but I think there was some twist. God, I was obsessed about him.
@@nhungtruong3574 me too, i dream about hanbin would be a wild card and debut member is not 7 but 9😂😔, omg
HANBIN SAID AT THE END "I PROMISE DEBUT, EVERYONE WAIT FOR ME". Won't everyone be here waiting for him to be with me?
tớ! cậu ấy nhất định sẽ debut thôi!!!!
Yes, I’ve been waiting for him seen 2019 when he turn off everything, I get used to it, I’m with you
Jewel Sharling wow i admire your patience. we will do the same and wait for him! 🥺
YESSS
I will wait for him ✋
But like the judges do realized that Hanbin be hitting them high notes in every episode, and his vocals is sure very unique and when he sings its just so clear and satisfying. Honestly Belift lost another talented person, shame on them. 😔
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
you can hear Hanbin mics was adjusted like LOUDER than others, he sang like HALF of the song LIVE while dancing powerfully the hell out .. and PDs said his voice didn't fit ???? This is a Burning song, then it supposed to "got the felling like it's burning down" PDs,,, see other contestants fancam, they didn't even try to lip sync. that pisses me offff
The fact that Hanbin left Iland but still has that brightest smile on his face. Hanbin Best Boy indeed
he got eliminated?????
This man should not be wasted...we all want him..he will become a great artist..If not KPOP artist than a VPOP artist..or maybe both..but he will debut soon
Its break my heart. How strong he is that even in this sad situation he can manage to smile... Its hurt the most...
💔😢😢
@@ndj9576 if u hate him then find something else to watch stop spreading negativity here
Hanbin said "Why cry when we're fulfilling our dreams, singing and dancing - that's my dream" and in the end, he still smiled.
I hate he always smile until the end, because when he smile, my heart really brokeㅠㅠㅠ
I brawled my eyes out when he smiled as he said goodbye to the producers. He is such a happy and bubbly person, he held his tears back so well. He is the sunshine on my bad days. He worked hard. I’m glad he made it at least this far into the show...
💔😢
It’s sad.that he’s not one of the producers favorite
@@iyou9554 But he's one of our favorites,that's okay.At least some people still appreciates him.
Flame On Hanbin is underrated. This deserves 1m too
I try
It will be soon
Cùng cố gắng nào!👆
Cùng nhau cày lên 1M nào ❤️ Fighting
Imagine Hanbin conditioning himself for the worst before their real stage because he could feel that this could be his last performance and just gave his best on this stage so no regrets would linger. That's why, I think, he didn't shed a tear because he knew he did his best.
Yeah i think so
they literally NEVER showed him on screen only when he was having a hard time or when he was frustrated. He also NEVER got his feedback only when they thought he did "bad". I just think he deserve so much better. I also feel like the camera made it seem like he wasn't that close with the others contestants but you could clearly see that when he got eliminated they were crying so hard literally all of them. Hanbin just know that we all support you and that you're amazing.
Exactly! Jay, Niki, K, Sunoo, Jake, Daniel, Heeseung...literally all of them were so upset when he was eliminated. Hanbin was definitely very close to them
th-cam.com/video/zMvQDZ-w5Qk/w-d-xo.html
His DNA performance is here
Every one comes here for Hanbin, could you join with us s.t.reaming Hanbin fancams, please ? Bcz just a month, his birthday will come. All guys love him want to prepare some surprise gifts for him. And the first gift for Hanbin is s.t.ream all of his fancam reaching 1M. And one person couldnt do it but we all can do it easily. Not debut yet. But everything he did, we saw. We just want his effort to be recognized and in the future, he will get better chances.
yup how much more if the showed the clips after hanbin got eliminated, everyone seems really hurt
I was crying for a while after Hanbin's elimination was announced. My ugly crying could make Jay's ugly crying look good in comparison, tbh.
same , i literally cried for 30 minutes . hanbin are the only reason i watched iland until now
same 😭😭😭
I'm still crying right now and it's been 2 hours since the episode released, i just couldn't sleep 😭💔
한빈이가 눈을끌어서 여길 끌어왔네 ㅋㅋ 아이랜드에서 나 한빈이떄도 좋았는데 역시 원래 이렇게 잘 웃는애였는데 아일랜드 쪼는 오디션이라서 자신감 엄청 없어 보였는데 ㅠ 얼마나 전소속사??가 힘들었는지 알겠따 지금은 엄청 방끗방끗 웃는데 원래 잘웃고 그러는데 ㅋ 목소리가 카랑카랑해서 튐 얼굴도 키 같음 ㅋㅋ 김기범목소리비슷함 ㅎㅎ 그래서 지금 ㅁ그룹에서도 킬링파트 리드 싸비 그런부분 하던데 ㅎㅎ 한빈이 부분이 기억에 남음 다른멤버도 목소리는 좋은데 한빈 얼굴 허스키한목소리가 각인ㅋㅋㅋ의기소침한데 이떄도잘생겻네 ㅋㅋㅋ
Hanbin: slayed the high notes in every performance
But for the PDs: HIS VOCAL DIDN'T STAND OUT
Hanbin took all the highnote in this, and GOD, this song’s too much highnote, strong choreagraphy. That make him tired, although he took many vocal part before, he’s never been trained to become a main vocal? But he still SLAYED all his part.
I WONT WATCH I-LAND ANYMORE BECAUSE WITHOUT HANBIN , THERES NOTHING LEFT TO SEE
Same....
most nonsense event on iland: *eliminates hubi because he has an amazing voice*
hanbin sang almost half of the song but he recieve bad comment about his vocal. no way! hanbin voice is amazing noticable. actually his voice was kind of refreshing.
i'm very happy hanbin get eliminated he deserved it. his voice sounds like frog when he singing and his dance is nothing compare to Niki and K.
@@ndj9576 sisi, ya te escuchamos...
@@ndj9576porq vienes a tirar hate? ya esta eliminado, detente si porfavor, ve a las fancams de tus picks y dale apoyo en vez de tirar hate
I asked my friend her honest opinion , and I sent her this video link , and she told me he did very good and that she LOVED his voice , his movement were very powerful , this is unfair , there is a rumor saying hanbin got 2 M votes that's why he was voted out ...that's so dirty , I will support niki now even though I feel he might be an other victim as well
@@ndj9576 if it is your opinion then go for it. everyone has freedom to say what opinion it is. but pls be a human give at least small amount of respect to hanbin. he did nothing to u but here u are saying hurtful words. tsk
He has a very unique vocal range. Even K was feeling anxious when Sunoo was looking for someone to fill Ta-ki’s place. K even said that he can’t afford Hanbin to lose in their group because he know that Hanbin has a great voice and he can dance well! I’m really sad and disappointed. But what can i do this is how the reality show works. ☹️
Flame on members can see Hanbin as important role in this song but ... did not :))) I was like howww ?????
If Hanbin wasn’t eliminated by producers, he would have debuted with global votes and that is what made producers SCARED out of their mind. Anyways supporting where’ve you go Hanbin!
That's right. Me too, always will support such a very kind and super talented human being, Hanbin.
nhớ Hưng quá TT ai mà nhớ Hưng thì cũng cày view rồi comment ở đây nha, đừng lên twitter rồi vào bài của nghệ sĩ khác để hỏi về Hưng nữa :(((
He always in charge of the most difficult singing part. His voice is really unique and he has accent because he is not Korean.Why didn’t producers commentand help him? They only discouraged him then freaking eliminated him
BTS IS MY YOUTH I don’t think they had plan for him to make it this far. No one is perfect but they had to choose him. The guy that work his way from the ground up to rank 4 only to be put down to last before global vote. Because they said his voice didn’t fit? All for that? It made me sad
They don't even focus on vocal. Only 1 time i see the female vocal trainer. And obviously they don't want Hanbin to debut, 'cuz they already have the group in their mind. They use Hanbin just to gain views from international fans, because i-land is flop in Korea.
Minh Hằng Nguyễn yeah honestly it’s all about fate but their all biased, I found out that they might of saved Jake in the past by letting him win because although he deserved it if he didn’t win people said he could have gotten eliminated, I don’t think he could but I think they wanted to focus on the spotlight for Jungwon since he told them that it was a wake up call and that he wants to do better.
I’m worried for the group, they have good vocals but it’s mostly with dancers, people are saying their going to kick Niki and K so that it can be a only Korean group which is like wtf
Yup. They were only focusing on dance and stage presence and now all of a sudden they care about vocals?? Hanbin has one of the best voices there and in this episode you can see that he took the advice from that one dude. He improved and was able to show more power on stage. It's so unfair that they eliminated him.
If his vocals were bad why didn’t you mention it episodes ago? Why not show how a vocal coach could have help him fix his vocals? Y’all had to go there when he literally did the high notes in every damn episode and yet us as viewers never saw any feedback (good or bad) about his voice. The only feedback Hanbin received in this rigged show was when he wasn’t doing so good with the choreography, y’all disgust me.
Correct they should have shown before or at least said
Sujithamathvini .S yeah exactly 🤔
You are so right, I really have so much pain from how they treated it
i fvcking agree with you
From Hưng Bin with love
I’m the only one who think hanbin’s voice is amazing??
I really love his voice and I love how it hits different from the others
His voice sounds like heaven to me
I definitely agreeee
Yeahhg meeee
You're not alone
Ngày nào cũng vào twt ngóng tin mà chẳng thấy em đâu. Lần này lặn hơi lâu nhé! Nhớ nhớ em nhiều rồi đó BIN à
1st fact: Into the iland studio version hanbin got many lines.
2nd fact: I & cridible studio version hanbin got many line .
3rd fact: Hanbin hit high notes.
Now fun fact: He got eliminated b'coz of his voices.
Done, not thing to say any more. Let’s go, Hannies. Follow him wherever he goes. He deserves to get a better chance than this show
it hurts me :
Hanbin is not really my bias but his vocals captured me that is why I supported him, he's a very kind person because even tho he's eliminated he kept on smiling. I'm proud of you, Hanbin!
@@ndj9576 my ult bias is K but I never badmouthed the other i-landers. Better keep that hate speech of yours on your own, you just spread toxicity and immaturity.
@@ndj9576 spam clmm tin pay acc ko cl
@@ndj9576 Hanbin will be performing as the pre-opening performance for the BigHit 2021 New Year's Live on the same stage as Enhypen!
deserved way better... hanbin i will always support you and cant wait for your debut someday !!
Imma burn Mnet
@@pennymcsquee5584 can i join
Going to burn mnet wanna come anyone??
@seokjin myfeels Out of topic but I love your videos so much 💜
@@sujatasharma6037 I will gladly come
i'm still so so mad at the fact that they didn't even compliment hanbin in this performance. HE DID SO WELL PLEASE 😭 i cant and will not move on from this 😭
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
Regardless of the comments, everyone knows Hanbin made it great, Hanbin is SUPER VOCAL
Usually, Hanbin‘s fancams always have the highest views. But not this time, because a lot of fans stopped watching I-Land and lost interest in streaming Hanbin‘s fancam when Hanbin got eliminated. Hanbin‘s fanbase is really no joke! You can see that in the views of Hanbin‘s thank you message on C.A.C‘s youtube channel that we moved to him instead to show our support to him outisde of I-Land. The video there has already over 400.000 views after one day! :O
Iknow.. i have a group chat and all of them didnt want to watch this performance because its still heartbraking...
@@rosejane7535 I think we should continue to stream his fancam as a gift for his efforts and to encourage him always working hard for debuting soon.
And he got 116K likes there , it shows how Hanbin more popular than this show 🤣
as of now Hanbin's Thank you message is over 681,000 views and 124k likes wow 👏🏻
Hanbin there are many fans waiting for you 😻
I even deleted theweverse app 😂 Hanbin was my only reason fof watching Iland 🥺 now I'm so unmotivated to vote 😂
Hanbin was never appreciated or acknowledge for his efforts he puts in every stage performance that he is in, Hanbin deserved better, best I can do right now is stream Hanbin's cams and continue to support him in his debut.
The only time he ever got a chance to shine they took it away from him, Hanbin deserves to debut in a company that respects and appreciates him, not a show where he was given false hope of debuting.
Everyone if your reading this Let's continue to support Hanbin.
Thank you 🤧
Yes true let's just keep supporting him he's really strong minded hanbin is really talented someday he will debut in other group I hope so
The only video in part 2 of his that never gets 1M because we all know what happened there
and when Hanbin gets his Internet back and sees he's the most viewed I-Lander >>>>>>
I can't stop crying. Why...?
Mnet gives Hanbin more screentimes 'cause they want we know he will get eliminated? Mnet is Mnat, the way they edit is the same as Produce. Mnet hates Hanbin so much and they want him to get eliminated as soon as well but also want to keep him because of views.
After this I will BURN YOU, MNET!
Through he gets eliminated but he still keeps his bright smiles untill the end, it makes me cry more. When he cry, I cry. He smiles, I smile. But now, he smiles, I cry...It hurts me to see him like that, why can he still smile like that?
Thanks for being a part of my youth...or even my life, Hanbin! I always support you no matter what. Just remember, I and Hannies always by your side.
HANBIN FIGHTING!!
Let's cry together 🥺🥺😭😭😭😭😭😭
"I will debut I Promise,Just Wait(With A Bright Smiling face)" - Ngo Ngoc Hung(Hanbin) 2020
IM CRYING😭😭😭
Im crying too
@@samsadchowdhury6300 I'll definitely wait for this promise😭😭
I still cry...
Why?
Hanbin gets more screentimes because he would be eliminated?! I will burn Mnet after this. Mnet is Mnat, the drama is where, Mnet is there. The votes is okay, but the way they edit is the same as Produce.
Hanbin smiles when he gets eliminated, cried when his friends get eliminated. He keeps his bright smile untill the end.
He cried, I cry. He smiles, I smile. But now, he smiles, I cry.
Follow you from ep 1 untill now, spend all of my time to watch your fancam and vids about you.
Thanks for being a part of my youth...or even my life, Hanbin.
I and Hannies always support you, I hope you will debut soon. HANBIN FIGHTING!!
😥😭🤧💔
Continue to support him please. Hanbin fighting
😭
"If non-koreans want screentime, either show badboy concept or non-perfection in performance. If u don't do that, we still have option- evil editing" thats Mnet logic.😑 mnet's way of saying we don't want him to debut.
You can literally hear him breathing hard
He sang 100 % live
Literally he trained to be a rapper but sang all the time in iland
I’m sooo proud of him !!!!
We can agree that something was off about this stage
Others had autotune Or lip sync sometimes but Hanbin literally didn’t have all that
Fuck Mnet literally
I’m so done
Hanbin voice is addicting unique and powerfully
more vocal training he will be unstoppable for sure
I’m so happy he will debut soon
He deserves it
Watch Hanbin become the most famous after this bs of a show!
i will be waiting
hanbin will be a great idol one day
I will debut soon,I promise just wait - Ngo Ngoc Hung 2020
Yes
True and that’s on period
you can hear Hanbin mic was adjusted like LOUDER than others, he sang like HALF of the song LIVE while dancing powerfully the hell out .. and PDs said his voice didn't fit ???? If he sang like 50% then he's not the one that had to fit, it/s the others! This is a Burning song, then it's supposed to "got the felling like it's burning down" PDs,,, see other contestants fancam, they didn't even try to lip sync. that pisses me offff
So trueeeeeee. They didn't even give a little damn care for lip sync
True! The viewers should know this! :)
his voice kind of too strong and loud and also did not blend well with others. then, i think he should debut as solo. thanks
Agreed. I've watched all the fancams now and it is hard to believe anyone else is even singing live. That's not to say they couldn't, there are a lot of good singers in the group. But I-land has regularly auto tuned people who were off throughout the competition (like fake love). Why not do that here? Well we already know it's because they wanted an excuse to eliminate him
@@defrost1027 his voice was too strong bc he had to sing without backup voice, yes his vocal was cracked but the fact that he was the only one who didn't lip sync. I mean, what are they trying to create? A dance group or a idol group? They didn't even show us if the boys had a vocal coach or something related.
Hanbin has never been trained to be a main vocal, maybe even a vocal. But he always took main vocal part and did it so well. Just this time, the dance was to hard 😠
Yeah.. He got into i-land based on his dancing skills
Tui cũng nghĩ vậy. Mong thời gian tới họ cho cậu ấy luyện thanh nhạc. Giọng cậu ấy rất triển vọng.
He was prepared to be a rapper, in fact in his first performance he rapped.. But in Iland he had to take the vocal parts, the high notes because even the guys said that Hanbin was the only one who could hit those notes and was stable when dancing and singing, K said Hanbin was the only one who could do it live! And then the producers have the nerve to say that to our faces, like, seriously? Who are they kidding? They just wanted to give an excuse to get him off the show.
@@hana_kimi seriously though
@@hana_kimi Tan cierto
Flame on hanbin hits me different it hurts ㅠㅠ
I may not know about vocal technique. But here, Hanbin is the only one who hit the high note, singing without backtrack and autotone.
They lost a gem
Exactly and the only reason he got all the high notes was because no one else could do them. If you look at previous episodes Hanbin always got stuck with the position with the most high notes because no one else wanted it. And plus of course his voice is going to stand out he’s freaking Vietnamese and he has an accent.
Yeah I don't think this was his best singing but it sounds like he's the only one singing live. I think they turned his mic up too. It's frustrating to me because the show has pretty much only focused on dance, but all of a sudden they are talking about vocals. If they really cared about vocals Geonu would probably still be there. They were just looking for a way to get him out.
All of them didn't use autotune tho...
True that
Why hannies doesn't really stream this fancam
1.Hannies are still crying
2.Hannies are busy Building a zoo
3.Hannies are planning to have a corn field in the moon
4.Hannies are planting trees
5.Hannies are busy donating for people who needs help
6.Hannies are busy collecting the stars for hanbin
To add, Hannies are busy streaming his Thank You video than this.
And now we are busy streaming this fancams we’re baaackkk!!😍
we're back on str34m1ngggg hehe.....
Back here 😉
Im glad im in this fandom ❤️
So the producers said that Hanbin‘s voice stood out too much in a bad way. Well, it‘s his voice. He can‘t change it. At least it‘s unique and you can always tell that it‘s Hanbin‘s voice. I-Land doesn‘t deserve him!
He'll debut soon!!!
I got a smile every time I watch Hanbin, it doesn’t matter how many time I’ve watched this. He’s amazing
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
Belift or bighit, please give k and hanbin debut soon, they deserve better,
I hate the way Bang PD said Hanbin got a lot of things from this show. He earned his chance to shone on those stages dude, everyone wants to see him more. He played fair the whole show, always being supportive of his fellow contestants. We Hannies knew your devil plan from the start but still support Hanbin with all our hearts because Hanbin deserved the support and the love. You didn't do him any favors Bang PD, he earned it all. You didn't even spare him any screentime how could you said he got a lot from this show?? Hanbin being Hanbin, you criticized it, but it is all viewers want. I just wish I have a chance to see Hanbin being him more in the future, I will be here waiting for him.
Agree!
Agree
Are u deliberately unable to realize that every editing is done by mnet and not bighit?..
Bighit manages only trainees....production is from mnet....
And next thing....Bangpd knows better than u...coz without any VOTING he made BTS,TXT...so u must realise that they want best from the best...not the one who still learning...
Heesung didn't debut with txt but he is an ace....he trained a bit more and debuting now...so... everyone has its own time
@@chile-hy8jm i mean mnet can't do without bang pd becoz bang pd was paid all those money heesueng is not an ace when txt was formed becoz those 5 have chosen based on thierr top 5 rankering in monthly evaluation test
Excuse me, but... since when Bang Sihyuk is the one in charge of filming and editing? I didn't know the millionare CEO of one of the most big companies is now doing evil editing to his show. Woah.
"hanbin's vocals didn't stand out" bro he sang like half the song tf
all of highnote :)) wtf PD lol
@@ndj9576 great would love to hear your voice then
@@ndj9576 Please shut up :) don't blame anymore
@@ndj9576 Also let's be real the other performance had a lot more autotune so at least we're hearing a live performance
@@ndj9576 Are you seriously. Who are you ?!?!??!I mean i see you everywhere 🤨🧐
I was so mad when judges said that hanbin´s voice was
sticking out too much and that he had to work on it.....like he is a STAR he is meant to sticking out
Well said Daniela. So true, most main vocalists usually have a stronger voice, but to the PD it is sticking out.
When he said "watch me".
So let's go 1M Hannies!
don't write" str..m "plz !
The thing which makes me frustrated the most isnt that Hanbin was eliminated. It's that Hanbin received nothing but pain from the producers. Let's imagine how much he was down and lost his confidence but still had to hold it in and fight till the end. And yeah till the very end, he didnt receive a single compliment or supportive speech from The PDs. Bang PD said sth as if he should feel thankful coz he got this far while his rivals are way stronger than him. But nope, they're equally good. Hanbin didnt lack that much in comparison.
Bang pd must be kidding. What the hack does mean ''he got this far while his rivals are way stronger than him''? They didn't even give him a chance to shine in the show. How could he said that, he dont even rights to say this!
The sigh in the end of Hanbin showed me that he had been through a lot and he knew that 😔
@@seok2131 sorry I didnt make it clear enough, my bad English 😂 He didnt say exactly that, just it made me feel that way. He said something like you got to the semi-final with really strong candidates, you've got many from the show (or this chance, I'm not sure and not brave enough to watch again) which normal trainees cannot experience, or something similar...
@@minniebl He really tried his best and fight for every chance he had yet still managed to show his bright and happy virus side. Hard-working, sincere, and humble. He deserves to be loved and supported ❤️
@@minniebl i am crying so much i am glad hes out in there iland shit theyre treating him like a mere trying hard trainee. #MNETXENOPHOBIC
They criticize his voice but use his voice consistently in the Spotify songs released. Kinda odd in my opinion.
This video even sounds different than the group performance video. I mean at least that's what I think
@@MinhNguyen-be5bf it was planned so he can get eliminated
Because hanbin is threatening their PLANNED debut lineup
This is so true :(
@@serena-lk7vh yes. I think they already have their minds set. Don't know why they ask for vote and all that.
Em nó đã đc 1 năm rồi ngày hôm đó vừa xem fancam này vừa khóc như một đứa trẻ.
I'm just new to the whole iland show due to Hanbin hashtags trending on Twitter. I've seen some cams of him and other performers and this guy stood out the most. Other members' performances are kinda underwhelming. Harbin's movements are sharp, 100% present, the facial expressions are on point... too bad he was eliminated
Thank you. He deserves better
Thank you.
When the producers treated him as if he was the black hole and inferior one to the others in the Flame On group, the Flame On team members actually saw his skills and abilities, and entrusted Hanbin with lots of essential and hard parts and believed Hanbin was essential to the group. Even when Sunoo was choosing a member to replace Taki in Chamber 5, Sunghoon and K did not want to lose Hanbin. When someone suggested that Hanbin could have been chosen by Sunoo, Sunghoon said "That shouldn't happen", and K said "We can't let Hanbin go".
I know that every shows like this has already planned and honestly this result is not surprising me. At the beginning Hanbin is not in the line so this is the last "chance" to eliminate him. It's easy to realize that Hanbin's parts always cut and he had the least screentime. There almost have no PD comments for him. When he did well, they just ignored. But in this ep, they spent so much screentime for him like showing us why they gonna eliminate this guy. K-pop likes giving no chance for Vietnamese. Sound negative but it's true (at least at this moment) :) but who know if Hanbin could debut in the future like he said bc his talent is real ! Just keep supporting him guys
From Hưng Bin with love
Totally true
Hanbin is someone who can help increase the ratings every week, that's why they keep him until the end of the show, I think this is just using the view sentence.
@@youngbbb2857 yea, i guess they planned to kick him sooner but they didnt expect that he got a huge support.
I'm here for you. Miss u
HE HAS NEVER TRAINED AS A MAIN VOCALIST. JUDGES/OTHER PEOPLE HATE HIM BECAUSE OF HIS ACCENT. LIKE TF? HIS DANCE HIS FACIAL EXPRESSIONS? THERES ONLY DANIEL WHO HAS THE BEST VOCAL IN THE GROUP AND HANBIN TRIED. BUT HE GOT ELIMINATED JUST FOR THAT??? SAME THING WITH GEUNO BC OF HIS EXPRESSIONS??? OMG...
A dance crew so vocal not that importance because you can edit the whole song 🤦
Apparently they do not need a main vocal, or vocalist, they are going to debut a dance group only... 😪🤦♀️
Is happened with felix stray kids too ,he got eliminated because his korean not so good, luckily he still can debut with stray kids, I feel the same here too
가장 재능있는 사람들을 모두 제거한 후
그래서 이것은 댄스 그룹입니다
Big Hig의 음악 큐레이터는 항상 그들을 숨기는 농담
처음부터 진짜 얼굴을 알았어
국제 태깅 프로그램 준비
Compare to felix hanbin can hit highnote dance well can rap but i live felix tooo i wish hanbin would have gone jyp instead of bighig i love bighit becoz of txt and bts but somehow i lost trust in bighit
Oh gosh, can we accept a fact that Hanbin sang live 100% without any help of autotune? That's why he's the only person whose voice stands out too much, esp with full of high notes like this.
Betty T. Baker agree
Agree
AGREE
Agree
Agree
Hanbin, on days when the practice process is hard and exhausting, think like this. Today, you are one step closer to your dream. You did a good job.
Hơn 3 năm rồi, bây giờ mới có cảm giác thoải mái khi xem lại fancam này của Hưng. Hồi trước cứ mỗi lần xem đều cảm thấy ko vui, thậm chí là nhói lòng vì nó gắn với kỷ niệm ko mấy vui vẻ. Nhưng mà thời gian trôi qua, giờ tất cả đều trở thành kỷ niệm đẹp. Hanbin I-land giờ đã là Oh Hanbin của Tempest, nhưng vẫn là Ngô Ngọc Hưng của tụi mình.
I can't believe this, he did well and still was eliminated. I respected the producers a lot but I can't see the logic in this decision.
Logic is simple. If he was korean, he wouldn't have been eliminated and welcomed due to his popularity, just like Sunoo
I don’t think I’ll ever get over how they eliminate him for his vocals being unique. When I tell you I cried when he was eliminated....
I know right...like his vocals are so unique and beautiful..
Like I am an ARMY and my bias is J-Hope and V is my bias wrecker...and I love them because of their personalities but also the uniqueness of their vocals...So Bighit definitely knows how to manage unique vocals,but deciding to let go of Hanbin based on that is just absurd!
It's so powerful! And when Bang PD said that I was like WTH?! Jimin has a very unique voice but look at him! his in the biggest boy band now! How can they eliminate someone who nailed high notes while doing a hard choreo. I am still very upset with this.
Yeah, I didn’t really get why “Hanbin is always Hanbin” could be a criticism. His vocals seemed to fit in well with the group. I think he just followed how he was told to sing. If he wasn’t fitting in K or the other members would have addressed it.
I'll try to explain their criticism.
It's bec Hanbin sounds the same every single song. Tbh it's like he's still singing DIY while singing FO. There's where the 'vocal placement' takes place. Hanbin should make different attacks and impressions to different songs.
I still love Hanbin tho. And I will wait til he debut.
Exactly, I am so agree with u! This is literally «a bad workman blames his tools», them producers blamed Hanbin on having a unique voice?? That is so stupid, I would not be suprised if their future boy groups appear to be plain like any other groups, if they cant even step out of the comfort zone then they will never see the gems.
I felt like Hanbin is the only one who sings live here
The others is edited their voice. Bcs the producer want to eliminated Hanbin while he is better than others.
Why vocal voice of hanbin is so different 😭🥺 why is so nicee and beautiful. I really want his voice so much.😭😍
this is gonna sound so bitter but I don't even care...
seeing how both my biases got eliminated from the producers's vote just got me so hollow right now... i'm still bitter over Geonu but now I cannot contain it anymore...
- having less to almost none screen-time for the whole part 1 & 2
- just got his most screen-time on his last episode
- we still didn't get that feedback when he performed Dive Into You, where the hell is it??!
- got shown his feedback now when they deemed him performing bad & not matching up with the others vocally
- don't even get me started with the obvious cut on his Nano Dance part in eps 9
the way the producers' criticizing Hanbin's vocal just left me speechless, like wow are they kidding me?? coming from a show that BARELY give attention to vocal (no vocal training scenes, vocal teacher came for just a couple second not even shown training them or anything, also STILL NO RAP??!), make it make sense??? THEN TRAINED THEM VOCAL PROPERLY GODDAMNIT!! Arrrgghh i'm so pissed!!
Hanbin baby you do deserve better, your unique voice deserve better~ We will wait for your debut to happen!
(imagine if Hanbin debut together with Geonu, Nicholas, Jaebeom? maaannn it's gonna be so epic!)
Hanbin fighting!! Hannies let's stay strong!
You guys said all the truth 😭
If they had a vocal coach on the show, he would've improved so much. We barely saw 100% live vocals from most of the trainees too. It's obvious what they prioritize cause it ain't vocals.
True af
bang pd has his own vocal style prefrence, anything outside that is not welcome, v has consistently the least amount of lines in bts songs, and they make him sing high notes even though he is not a soprano, meanwhile he got SO MANY compliments orm teacher alice in american hustle life, she said you have a voice that makes people listen. honestly hanbin is better off without them, I will wait until he debutes and support him there. hope he finds a good company and good teammates.
im really disappointed with bang pd so obsessed with making the "next bt5" to the point they ignore fans emails and hashtags abt debuting ot12
Hanbin deserves more, and that's why Hannie will give him everything.
hanbin deserved better. I don't understand why they eliminated him. I ofc don't wanna explicitly say there are members that are worse that Hanbin or that Hanbin is better than x member but episode 11 felt so uncalled for. The only episode was Hanbin was allowed to shine with his part he's also eliminated it. They never showed Hanbin getting feedback for DNA of Dive Into You. He has strong vocals and an incredibly unique vocal tone plus his clean dance moves. Maybe it was because he didn't perfectly match the concept but he tried and improved non the less.
I miss him so much, He hasn't posted anything on Twitter in over a month. I'm waiting for your debut. I love you so much, and hannies always beside you,
Hanbin is currently a member of Tempest, Hanbin and his team will debut in 2022, here is their youtube channel : th-cam.com/channels/CViKQ1A1tXhIVKAVEazcaA.html
Everyone can see that when Hanbin was eliminated, his expression was not very surprised like he knew he was eliminated, in the last picture everyone can see that he was sad, I don't know Is it because of the gimmicks of the organizers, but I feel very disappointed in how this show works
Hanbin sang the highest notes of the song and the producers tell him he didn't sing good??? They couldn't say anything about his performance because it was flawless! And also, they never even commented about the singing part to the other contestants. They just care about dance...but this time is the reason Hanbin is leaving??? Absurd. The moment I saw Hanbin was finally getting screentime I knew something was off
i'm very happy hanbin get eliminated he deserved it. his voice sounds like frog when he singing and his dance is nothing compare to Niki and K.
175 jnd I hope you're joking cuz if not ill take it personally and Imma throw hands!!!
175 jnd I swear I'll report every single one of the comments!!!!!
So the only complaint they had about the performance was his singing, like this is the ONLY time they've judged singing and of course it's Hanbin...like you've got other members of the group who sang two low pitched lines that got praise but Hanbin is hitting those HIGH notes but bc his voice was shaky at times bc he's actually singing live unlike many other I-land performers he gets negative feedback...
They never cared about vocal but then all of a sudden they be talking about vocal to eliminate trainee and of course that trainee happened to be Hanbin
Yeah, that was suspicious. During the practise Mr. Son critized Hanbin‘s dancing skills. And then suddenly after the real performance they critized Hanbin‘s voice. Like wtf... They really just tried to find reasons to eliminate him... -.-
To be honest, they didn’t even complaint about his singing. It wasn’t even about his singing was bad or what. They said was his “ACCENT”, said it was too harsh so he sounded “too distinguished” from others. Like isn’t that what make an idol unique? They prefer 10 similar voices rather than 1 unique voice. I don’t get the PDs tbh...
I agree and if they help him more regarding his vocals i know 1 week will help not that much but it will definitely help him if only they didnt focusmuch on his dancing
@@Shiragami0981 Apart from that I thought they are planning to create a global group for global fans, and it means members should be from different countries, rather than more Korean members. And foreign members might sing with a little accent. That's normal! In addition to that Korean members always have this military service problem, they have to interrupt their career to do their military service. And this not a problem for foreign members. Also I want to mention the fact that a lot of members who remained in the show now are 14-15-17 yo singing songs with sexy lyrics like "Dive into me, I'll dive into you" or "touch me like this, I'll touch you like that"... I mean wtf!
hanbin soo talented
Oh, yes he is! :))
@@jessicathu :D
he sang like half the song. And producer said his vocal didn't stand out. Ok fine 😏
im angry istg
I was so shocked when their critic to Hanbin was that his voice wasn't very good and that his voice didn't fit with the others, when I thought he was the best out of all of them, when I didn't even have him as my top pick. Like he stood out in a really good way and made the whole group seem a lot better than they would've without him.
There is a guy who worked in vocal training and music field pointed out that in the performance, other members voice got autotuned filter while Hanbin's didn't. Also, Hanbin had to carry all the hardest vocal parts. He basically sang half of the song.
He is too good for Mnet’s shit.. They didn’t know that they just lost someone that talented. Mnet always make him so dirty, never give him chance to shine like others. Giving others a good feedback but not on him. Tried to hide him behind others. Without HANBIN, I LAND are totally different now..
IT’S OKAY HANBIN, I WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT YOU NO MATTER WHAT. YOU DESERVE WORLD MY BABY❤️
Imagine Hanbin watching the show now that he is free only to realize he only got 5 minutes screentimes overall from ep 1 to 11
Big Hit will regret that they let HANBIN go! He’s so talented and unique. He’ll definitely debut in a different label. I will wait for him, because he’s my ultimate bias
Honest question- if Hanbin wasn’t eliminated, who do you think should’ve been? Someone had to leave, and only based on these two performances? (Ps I do love Hanbin, no hate actually curious) 💖
Mai Lan so who in your opinion deserved to be in last? (I love them all and don’t want to see any go- but if you had to pick JUST base on these last two performances, who would you say?)
Yesss. He’s the SOUL , THE SUN OF THAT GROUP
I look for him in my dreams in old videos, sometimes when I fall, I wonder what he's been through
Hanbin, we’re here. We got your back. Don’t worry, just shine like you always are. And thank you to those who voted for Hanbin even just one vote. Thank you. From the bottom of every Hannies heart, we know HANBIN MATTERS AND DESERVE ALL THAT LOVE.
Thank you Hannies, we will meet again.
I can't help but think that they never wanted Hanbin to debut. After seeing how much fans are voting for him, and this is the last round for the judges to get someone out before fans decide the final 7, they have to get him out. I really don't wanna think it like that.. but the editing of Hanbin throughout the show has really sent my mind to dark conspiracy theory areas. I'm so sad he's gone....
because he is vietnamese
I agree. I’m heart broken
@@gonami2956 Delusional
the amount of screen time he got was very telling in my opinion :/. I'm really mad because he was very close to the other i-landers and we rarely got to see that on the actual show. And we didn't know about his feedback in DNA and DIY when he did amazing! I'm very sad and mad at how they treated him :(
I still can't believe that he got eliminated. My heart is so broken up until now.. I will surely miss his fancams, especially his smile, my favorite ones. Everytime he smile, I automatically smile too and I assure that everyone is like me. He kept smiling up until the end of his journey. I love him so much, and I believe that HE WILL DEBUT. I will wait for him.
Hanbin will debut under Yuehua ent upcoming boy group’ Tempest’ they have a yt channel check them out
he has a very good singing voice especially he's super warm and dancing. oh he's amazing. he's so handsome. i fell in love with him at first sight
Its fine, They didnt deserve him, He is way too good for them, I hope he debuts under a company that actually understands him and appreciates all his talents and never sleeps on him. I will wait for you~
Funny how he got criticized for his vocals, when they don’t even have a vocal producer... They showed that women once and that was it.... Also, notice how he is one of the few people that actually sing live!
But maybe him leaving was for the best; I am sure the members will miss him, but surely no mnet...
Hanbin, good luck! I will wait for you, so please don’t give up!!
From Hưng Bin with love
가장 재능있는 사람들을 모두 제거한 후
그래서 이것은 댄스 그룹입니다
Big Hig의 음악 큐레이터는 항상 그들을 숨기는 농담
처음부터 진짜 얼굴을 알았어
국제 태깅 프로그램 준비
i have feeling he'll do better out there, let's just support him and people rlly need to stop blaming bighit no one is at fault for this:))
@@huongphamthu2573 from Hannies with love
Some people are wondering why his views is not on top its bc his fans still cant watch and accept the fact hes gone in iland.. but on his recent video it got over 400k 😭 i love this fandom so much! Hannies we got this ❤️
I miss hanbin
So they decide to eliminate him. Well no surprise since they always sleep on him like they have no interest on him. I love you hanbin, i will wait for your debut. Hwaiting!
"I will debut I Promise,Just Wait(With A Bright Smiling face)" - Ngo Ngoc Hung(Hanbin) 2020
:(
@@samsadchowdhury6300 i cried please that was so sad, our hanbin 😭
Support Hanbin from Bangladesh..alwys and forever rooting for this man
I feel cheated in this episode
They just don't deserve our hanbinnie.... that's it...I was actually a very big fan of his vocals...Not everyone can sing that much well and that too in live..Let's just feel positive about this bcoz if hanbinnie had debuted with this group he would have been seriously ill treated by the company. We are all already seeing how foreign idols are not treated well when compared to k-idols. So we'll hope hanbin debuts soon in a company where they really appreciate him and treat him well...
Yes his voice so good.
So true
Agree! I actually feel relieved when he is not debut in this group since the mistreatments from episode 9
his voice was one of the reasons i loved him... his personality adds up too why i love him too... he draws attention because of his voice and how he can sing so well live... THE PRODUCERS LOST 2 DESERVING MAIN VOCALS... they wasted Geonu, and now Hanbin... really dissapointed...
Of course his voice stands out, he sang like almost this song, how could you wish his voice won’t stand out?
IKR !😤
His voice literally had the perfect tone to fit the song tho and his voice complimented the other trainees’!! I actually think the problem here was that K’s vocals didn’t really fit the vibe of the song, they were all incredible still tho
I don't know why his voice is my favorite 😭 because his voice is different and very beautiful
ok so now that i’m healed after hanbin’s message on cac’s channel, i can finally face this fancam and let me tell you: hanbin did amazing. some of ya’ll on twt and reddit are clearly untalented and don’t know what you’re talking about and it shows. hanbin is the only one who sang live without loud ass backtrack and post-production autotune but still remained stable most of the times. don’t come here for his technique if you’ve never tried to dance and jump around while maintaining your head voice or falsetto. mnet did him dirty again by putting in his raw vocals not realising he did such a good job as a trainee. some of your debuted idols lip sync the whole mf song when standing still. now compare that to a person who trained only for 11 months and entered this show with rapping. in other words, hanbin world domination 👋
this comment is so underrated omg
This sum up what I'm trying to say lmao
Exactly. I'm not a professional but I think he did well for a trainee. He was trained only in 11 months but can rap, dance well and sing live without backup voice or autotune ❤️ Not to mention his expression and stage present 😌 He also said he wanted to be an idol that can do well many kinds of concept and I can't wait to see him on stage performing a cute bubbly song that would be suitable for him ❤️
P/s: he got me so emotional so sorry if I talked too much ha ha...
Pacifique Ciel totally agreed, hanbin’s so versatile it’s kinda crazy for a newbie like him... i’m also still sad but let’s wait for him together
@@annap4466 Who wouldn't though... Whenever I think about it I'm getting anxious again 😥 but I'll try to be positive like him ❤️ Don't know what company he will debut under but I hope they treat him fair ❤️❤️❤️
P/s: I see some people think this video got so less view because fan don't want to watch him anymore because he's out but I think actually we can't stand seeing him trying his best and feeling so down after that 😭
You know the annoying thing!? He had the most parts with high vocals, he also had to focus on expression and dance. That's a lot of work, remember Niki in into the iland... That's literally same scenario.
Hanbin will be back better and stronger, with a huge fandom behind him
This fancam proves he is 100% live while the others have added autotune. Mnet is just too bad
Someone better get fired for this. It’s the composition of the song has weird low notes and weird adlibs. How come no one mention the off low notes? If they have a problem with Hanbins parts why didn’t the producers say anything while the trainees practice? Producers are the professionals. The problem is not HanBin.
@@jenniferamazon1437 who knows if they intentionally did it for his part..
Hanbin doesn't need autotune his voice is already clean and he can also reach high notes.
Still find it hard to believe that it was his last performance 😭. How much I miss him.
Some questions I really want to ask:
- They complained about his dancing all the time, even minutes before his real show. Why all of a sudden, they switched it to his voice? Where was the vocal trainer? Why didn't they comment on his vocal before?
- Why did he never get any compliments? He barely got any screentime. And eventually, he got some, it was because they were his last moments. Why he always ranked the lowest in DNA and now Flame On? Do you really think he was the worst?
- Why they never paid attention/complained about anyone's vocal but then Hanbin was eliminated because of something he can def work on?
And why no body say anything about the super low vocals? It don’t even match the song. Also, if they have probably with his voice why did they assign him the high important parts? This is producers bad. If they don’t think song turn out well it is their fault not HanBin. HanBin did good job.
@@jennifervan4375 That's what I have always wondered. I'm not a KPop fan so I don't know much how it works. Prob because I'm so used to VPop, the other members' voice sounds really weak to me tbh.
Nhung Truong everyone sounds the same. I like HanBin’s voice the most. That’s why HanBin has the most views and fans.
The whole episode was made to dedicate Hanbin's exit. They played really well by showing how he wasn't doing well. They expected massive energy from him. They expected angelic vocals from him. They only expected exceptional skills from him but failed to recognize his true talent. They had already planned Hanbin's exit. Period.
@@nhungtruong3574 tui cũng nghĩ vậy. Giọng mấy cậu còn lại yếu như con gà hen ấy. Có mấy đoạn đẩy mic to rất rõ. Mic của hưng bài này nhỏ hơn bình thường thì phải. Bài test trước, đoạn điệp khúc đồng ca giọng cậu ấy vang, cao, khỏe át cả giọng thành viên còn lại.
This is so heartbreaking, Hanbin deserves better.
What, they eliminated Geonu for lacking at facial expressions and because he is not the best at dancing, and now Hanbin, who has great expressions, vocals and dance! Like wth!?? They really planned a line up already. They dont deserve a guy as good as him tho. He deserves so much better....
Edit: What some of ya'll are replying saying he doesnt belong to the debut team and something else, but like bruh- then why are you here watching his fancam?? XD
I'm worried about his future now. They just used him
Masha B he still will be successful. We should just have to be patient and continue to support him
Hopefully he can debut elsewhere. He is a gem
@Chí Phèo nguyễn exactly.
Shouting doesn't make his voice sounds powerful. He need to improve more.
I'm feeling so proud for being a Vietnamese everytime I see him:((
how come the producers thought his voice didnt suit this performance where he was the only one and can belt out his voice and at the same time can CAN SING WELL THAN OTHERS?????
Ikr
I think it's because his voice is naturally higher compared to the other members. Personally it stood out to me in a really good way, I really really love his voice and I think it suited the energy of the song the most, but I guess the producers want the team to be more homogenous and cohesive? Idk man, in the end they did him so dirty
i'm very happy hanbin get eliminated he deserved it. his voice sounds like frog when he singing and his dance is nothing compare to Niki and K.
175 jnd bruh just leave
175 jnd lol u rly had to make an effort to make an acc just to spread hate about hanbin on ever comment on here huh 😂 i really hope karma will get you very soon. u betta watch out and regret everything
The fact that hanbin didn’t cry after getting eliminated hurts so much 😭 he stayed strong till the end & im so damn proud to have become his fan since day 1. WE WILL WAIT FOR YOUR DEBUT SOMEDAY!
Yes
He showed us the huynh material, strong and warm for his brother :(((( so sad
Okeh so when they Finally gave him screen time thats when they decided to eliminate him and also the feedbacks. We never heard them give a positive feedback to hanbin (except for the his eyes shine thing) NOT EVEN ONCE AND WHEN THEY DECIDED TO SHOW THE FEEDBACKS THEY DECIDED TO SHOW THE BAD ONES.I DEMAND THE OTHER FEEDBACKS MNET
He got complinted in the DNA stage ryt?
Vtfulserendipity Z Nope!!
@@vtfulserendipityz6663 Nope. His part always got cut off by rasist MNET.
@@vtfulserendipityz6663 nope they always cut everytime its his turn
@@vtfulserendipityz6663 I do think he got complimented by producers on DNA for improving his vocals but mnet don't show it to us and now they show it as he improved but went down again...🙄
Still cant process how they thought hanbin ruined this performance with his voice he has such a great vocal tone
I also really like his voice