@@thinkingowl532 Yeah, they do lip sync, it's to not strain their vocal chords or ruin their health. However, we're not sure if they were lipsyncing, don't assume.
HELLLOO?? WHO DOES IT LIKE KYUNGSOO AND BAEKHYUN ON THEIR FIRST DAY OF WORK??? THEY SOUND LIKE MUSIC GENIUSES FROM THE FIRST DAY- I'm done. I can NEVER love any other artist. THEY are my standard
C'est tellement vrai, après avoir entendu la voix de Baekhyun, on sait qu'on en a besoin toute sa vie. Seigneur !!!!!! Ces deux voix ensemble sont magnifiques, extraordinaires !
+Sonya Mataz hahaha IKR! I had to put it back a couple times to be sure but wow, they were so in sync it was almost creepy, they were really feeling the song :)
Baeksoo is a really perfect kind of mix! Their voice make me feel like listening to the beautiful angel's song. Better than, their imotional faces so attractive and a little bit cute! I love Baeksoo!
I'm pretty sure after all those years of training they were confident and ready enough to do a rap song without synching. I just question the management's decision to make them synch =/
Elyzha Paule Yeah, I read some of the comments in the videos, and it is obvious now that SM did tailor the audio AFTER the performance for the YT upload. You can hear at 0:09 - 0:10 when the audio mutes and they switched the live audio to the fixed one.
2:50 is the minute where I died and it s so important. D.O. in this register sounds amazing and Baekhyun singing high is heavenly.He needs more highnotes and Chen needs to go low (his low vocals are superb and so underrated).
I'm here even after 9 years. When Baekhyun is a double million seller soloist. Ksoo will be realising his solo album this month. I feel so proud of what they are today :)
1:12 that thing Baekhyun does to soften the line is definitely not something commonly seen in rookies They were angelic vocals since debut and till date they are one of the best vocals in the industry But seriously, it's been so long since we heard this type of song from EXO (I understand as this was quite common around 2010-2014 but we need more of this types of songs from exo)
Ok, they weren't lipsyncing during the actual live but sm has a stupid habit to add on the track afterwards when they edit it, which is why all we actually hear is the recorded track + fans screaming. which sucks because i really want to hear this actually live..
Diane Contreras your veins dont pop out your neck if youre lip syncing. a track was obviously added because its so clear whereas if they were lip syncing we would hear a backtrack playing.
2:50 Cannot comprehend this god's vocals to this day. Both of these cuties have honestly the most natural voices. Like Baekhyun only had 8 months of training. Now that is insane
the high notes of Baekhyun and D.O's singing english lyrics from the start is so damn gorgeous & amazing.. it's been 7yrs. who else still watching here in 2019???
I come back here whenever I need my ear and soul cleansing. They're like singers who've been in this business for like 20 years, but they were just 20 when they sang it. Can't believe even after 9 years.
New 4 month baby EXO-L thanks to Kai's Rover remake and it was this video that made me become an EXO-L! Then is was D.O.'s Tell Me What Is Love live is when he became my biased! It blows my mind that Baekhyun was 20 & D.O. 19 and this was their first day on the job as rookies!? I have never seen or heard anything like this in K-pop! 2 weeks ago EXO were on Killing Voice Dingo and after 11 years they are STILL thee best live, power, vocal group in K-pop! I'm just sorry I didn't really know about them sooner. It's unhealthy how much EXO content I've been consuming! I've got 11 years to catch up on and it's been the best few months I've had as a K-pop fan! Thank you for existing EXO :)
i love D.O's facial expressions when he's singing he's so expressive lol but when he's not singing it's like he's not feeling anything he's just there not giving away any emotions
I was once an exo fangirl, but it slowly faded away. But now it's coming back. Exo was the first kpop group that caught my life. Without them, I don't think I'll ever enter the wonderful world of kpop. And I think I'm beginning to love exo again. And I won't regret it. Exo is just so.. idk.. it's unexplainable. From the first word they sing, I might faint. They are just.. AMAZING AND AWESOME. :) I'm proud to be exo-l
Macces Macalisang same..!! XD My first Kpop group was EXO... lol then I got into other groups such as BTS, B.A.P., WINNER, etc... XD the EXO feels are slowly coming back tho haha EXO SARANGHAE!!
![120712 여수 Expo Pop Festival - EXO-K 디오 백현 WHAT IS LOVE [쏭감독].mp4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Tc1u29zR6Kg/mqdefault.jpg)
BRO...... THEY WERE LITERALLY ROOKIES ON THEIR DEBUT DAY????? THEYRE INSANE NOBODY IS DEBUTING LIKE EXO ANYMORE
And this statement remains true until this day. They don't create rookies like this anymore!!
Very well said.
True rookies are not like this anymore
@@greenskies9645 Ateez are amazing ngl but I have to say no Rookies like Suju, SHINee or Exo are produced these days
True af
Still a legendary performance. Who's still watching in 2024 >>>>>>>
Omggg me😭❤
Me to ❤❤
I literally can't get over this performance
Me in july
Me
When baekhyun was just 20, and kyungsoo was 19, they were this incredible......
if this was April 2012, Baek was also still 19.
D.O is such a little man with such a big voice. Baekhyun freaking slay me. This song is everything.
Deme Da Costa you are in a good or in a bad way???😳😳😳Baekhyun best
Baekhyuns high voice and D.Os deep voice is just PERFECT *.*
Best rookie ever . Imagine if they sing this again live
WOW I- THEY WILL SOUND LIKE ANGELS
Rookie? They Debuted In 2012
@@blackprofile6393 at this time, they were rookies
@@luv3drea Oh Ok
@@blackprofile6393 lol this time they sonng since debut 2012
D.O and Baekhyun omg they still give me chills after 4 years 😍😍😍😍
IKR
Thay are sing very well
Sonia C them together is just flawless !! I need them to sing this again some day
They still give chills after 7 years
IN 2020 AS WELL
This is why EXO is the standard of vocals, imagine this is their pre-debut but they sing like they are a professional singers in 20 years.
this is lipsync
@@bletterd327 cleans your ears
@@mikaedwko-kv8ym why
@@bletterd327 is what bts known for
@@bletterd327 lmao this is live 100% Kyungsoo’s voice cracked here twice
Someday I want them to recreate this stage. The world deserves to experience this Baeksoo duet stage excellence once more
Same.
Kyungsoo's eyebrows has a life on their own. He's cute & baby faced and all but when his eyebrows do their work, my ovaries juat explode man.
True
i agree
Jaexx Rin same
lol yess
Felt that!
I love how the sync their bodies at 2:15
ikr??😁😭😭 i love them
lip sync
Jopet zur Espiloy Exo doesn't even know the words,,lyp synch" hell No !
Jopet zur Espiloy lip sync my ass
@@thinkingowl532 Yeah, they do lip sync, it's to not strain their vocal chords or ruin their health. However, we're not sure if they were lipsyncing, don't assume.
Anyone watching in 2020? This song still gives me chills and makes me wanna body roll😭😍
Same here 😭😭💖💖
And we all remember our youth
Seriously it fully puts me in the mood 🥴
🥺
Meeeee
Baekhyun's vocals are no joke its to the point where he seem like a 6 year trainee instead of one
booboo couldn’t agree more 😊😘😘😘
Not even 1 yr it's 4 month
@@gracyswargiary3599 thats crazy talent
4 months only
Wow, its already 6 years later! Who else is here in 2018?
I am here 😍
Me~~
yes here 😢❤
October 2018 😂
Me😁😁😁😁
SM literally has the best vocals in kpop... really mind blowing vocals....
2:15 dude the synchronization in that part was crazzyyyy
That's my favourite
I wish SM didn't cover up the actual live version with the studio VER. I want to hear this live :(
Here you can see their live version
th-cam.com/video/myOfp-Uq08s/w-d-xo.html
afriezal kamil thank you ♡♡
afriezal kamil y
@@afriezalkamil2892 oh wow geez, their live version is as flawless as the studio version..exo legends
CAN WE HAVE A 2021 VERSION OF THIS???🥺🙈❤️
Yes please.
Yes
but I don’t think so😭 since Baek is already in his military service😭 maybe after his service
@@baekhyuneeexo9411Yes of course
my god YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!! maybe 2022?
Baekhyun and D.O should make a subunit. Their vocals just complement each other so much
이게 처음이자 마지막 듀엣곡일 줄 알았겠냐고,,, 유닛 염불하면서 나는 오늘도 왓이즈럽을 듣는다,,
케이팝 1n년차... 이 정도로 개쩌는 보컬합 아직도 못 찾음 난 아직도 백도 유닛 존버하고 있다.... 최소 슴스테 듀엣곡이라도 내줘...
I love D.O last part of the song, so indescribable.just perfect.
Omg, can't believe Baek and D.O. are real 😂😂😂😂😂
HELLLOO?? WHO DOES IT LIKE KYUNGSOO AND BAEKHYUN ON THEIR FIRST DAY OF WORK??? THEY SOUND LIKE MUSIC GENIUSES FROM THE FIRST DAY- I'm done. I can NEVER love any other artist. THEY are my standard
"First impression is the best impression".
They proved this 🔪
I love baekhyun's high note
역시백현잉ㅠㅠ
Me 2 😂😂😂😂
Velet Ver I do, too.
me to 👍😍
Me too so much ❤❤❤
D.O's voice feels like heaven
While Baekhyun's voice is all i need in my life
C'est tellement vrai, après avoir entendu la voix de Baekhyun, on sait qu'on en a besoin toute sa vie. Seigneur !!!!!!
Ces deux voix ensemble sont magnifiques, extraordinaires !
EXO has the most perfect vocal line
BAEKSOO you guys are legends!!
D.O's voice is too beautiful to be real. His voice is so cute.
WOW Baekhyun's high notes tho! XO
It's 2022 and I'm still here ;___; can't get over this live performance
Truth!
Same here.. I really watch it every now and then. So inlove with this performance. Not to mention this was their debut. How good can they be?
me too
I'm probably not the only one who noticed this but at 2:16 D.O and Baekhyun literally turn the same direction and do almost the same hand action
Rin M and then return to their normal standing positions totally in sync with each other
+Rin M after reading your comment i checked it out wow...you're so detailed,they did it till 2:19 lol so cute they were so in sync
+Sonya Mataz hahaha IKR! I had to put it back a couple times to be sure but wow, they were so in sync it was almost creepy, they were really feeling the song :)
Baekhyun's high note omg 😍
Kyungsoo ya you're now a successful soloist with 2 mini albums on your belt. I'm so proud of you 😭
fall in love with kyungsoo all over again and again and again and again
hana
And with Baekhyun too.
Oh my goshh.. Baekhyun kill the high note! >
난 솔직히 이런 분위기 한번 더 나와줘야 한다 ... 나 뭐지...추억노래 듣는시간인가🤭🤭🤭숨듣명이 아니고 모든 사람들이 알았으면 하는 노래 오랜만에 들으니 심장이 나댄다
baekhYUN'S VEINS IM CRYING WHY.
D.O.'s voice is butter! Baekhyun's voice is chewy caramel!
When D.O. said "I can't explain what I feel"
Me too because this performance is just too beautiful and powerful
D.O voice at the beginning has me on the floor! His English is so sexy I'm dying 😍💦💦💦
i think sooo ♥️♥️♥️
Who’s here in 2021???? Please I love D.O. and Baekhyun but D.O.’s voice is something SPECIAL!!
돌고돌아 여기 ㅎ.....ㅠㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 왓이즈러브는 누가 뭐래도 쇼케 버전이 좋다 신인 풋풋함 느껴지는 게 너무 좋음... 둘 듀엣 바라는 건 이제 너무 늦었나요 흑
Baeksoo is a really perfect kind of mix! Their voice make me feel like listening to the beautiful angel's song. Better than, their imotional faces so attractive and a little bit cute! I love Baeksoo!
Kyungsoo's eye brow game though. 🌚
They don't make rookies like this anymore.
True
So true
Baekhyun and D.O are My baby.
They are the best. :)
Who's smart idea was it for them to synch to a loud-ass back track? These two can sing PERFECTLY without this.
Maybe they wen't that confident yet... This is their showcase before their debut after all...
I'm pretty sure after all those years of training they were confident and ready enough to do a rap song without synching. I just question the management's decision to make them synch =/
maybe they are tired, sometimes stress and over working yourself can damage your vocal
that's why lip sync is necessary :3
Elyzha Paule
Yeah, I read some of the comments in the videos, and it is obvious now that SM did tailor the audio AFTER the performance for the YT upload. You can hear at 0:09 - 0:10 when the audio mutes and they switched the live audio to the fixed one.
they didnt lip sync. lmao do you not see baekhyuns veins popping out? 1:45 LOL
i can't believe i'm only hearing this masterpiece after 11 years of being released,, like??
2:50 is the minute where I died and it s so important. D.O. in this register sounds amazing and Baekhyun singing high is heavenly.He needs more highnotes and Chen needs to go low (his low vocals are superb and so underrated).
god damn it D.O your voice is music into my ears 😍😍😍 baekhyun too... arghhh they're perfect....
I'm here even after 9 years. When Baekhyun is a double million seller soloist. Ksoo will be realising his solo album this month. I feel so proud of what they are today :)
My favorite part is at 2:15 when both Baek and D.O. hit the high note together and did the same gesture right at the same time!
it’s been 9 years look at them now I’m so proud of them
백현 제대하면 디오랑 백현이 앨범 내주면 안되나요 이렇게 목소리 합 잘 어울리는 사람 처음 보는데
Yeah!!!! Go D.o!!!!!!!!!!!
go baekhyun!!!
My love is D.O.
My love is Baekhyun
EXO MYLUV el mio tambien :)
BaekSoo is so underrated!! That was an amazing duet. Their voices actually complemented each other. 👏🙌
d.o. oppa that time his face is v-shape ... but now that very round face ㅋㅋㅋ
and i love him forever
He was an ulzzang i Can die from his visual😭😭😭😭♥️
I like round d.o. more cause he is more squishy ❤
At first, I didn't care for this song, but after listening to it a few more times, I got hooked on it. D.O and Baekhyun's voices are AWESOME!
1:12 that thing Baekhyun does to soften the line is definitely not something commonly seen in rookies
They were angelic vocals since debut and till date they are one of the best vocals in the industry
But seriously, it's been so long since we heard this type of song from EXO (I understand as this was quite common around 2010-2014 but we need more of this types of songs from exo)
once I heard this song I began to fall in love with exo!!! seeing them sing gives me the chills
siii, cantan hermoso, tenian que ser de EXO!!!!!!!!!!
+Aniie Morgan si son exo a mi enqanta D.O.
Jessica Zavala Same!
I remember watching this back in their debut days and its always this performance that gives me chills when I see Baekhyun's neck veins...
2024 and I still love this song. What a masterpiece.
Damnn first time I've seen this and omg Baekhyuns voice and high notes are killing me :o
Ok, they weren't lipsyncing during the actual live but sm has a stupid habit to add on the track afterwards when they edit it, which is why all we actually hear is the recorded track + fans screaming. which sucks because i really want to hear this actually live..
Thanks for clarifying that for us n.n
yes i agree with you karuraable thank you metaaknight
I knew it! SM sucks my dick(if i had one)!!!
If they were actually singing, they would have earpieces. SM didn't add a track to this performance. It was originally lip synced
Diane Contreras your veins dont pop out your neck if youre lip syncing. a track was obviously added because its so clear whereas if they were lip syncing we would hear a backtrack playing.
they were rookies but they ate and never leave a crumb, i need a 2022 version of this masterpiece, the vocals is insanely good.
OMG!!! Love this song. Love Baekhyun💗💖💘💕💓💟💞💝
i like Baekhyun too love his voice
Hi
Wow
THIS IS ROOKIE FOOTAGE?? EXO VOCALS ARE INSANE 😭
Why isn't anyone talking about how kyungsoo easily put vocal runs effortlessly in an impossible and hard part to put those runs? 💯
Just W.O.W
Is why he is called R&B Prince in Korea!
2:50 Cannot comprehend this god's vocals to this day. Both of these cuties have honestly the most natural voices. Like Baekhyun only had 8 months of training. Now that is insane
I love Baekhyun's expressions from 2:47-2:50, the focus and emotion he expresses as he prepares for that final note
the high notes of Baekhyun and D.O's singing english lyrics from the start is so damn gorgeous & amazing.. it's been 7yrs. who else still watching here in 2019???
D.O. Has A clear voice ... i love it
D.O We Are One
9 years has passed but this song for me is still an iconic debut.
2023, but I still love this song 🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹
wow.. daebak! how amazing this two baekhyun my bias.. and d.o UBW.. ughhh
They were rookies but they sound like seasoned artist. ❤️
여전히 복잡하고 삶이 지칠때 들어주면 힐링되고 녹아들게 만드는 노래야 사랑해 영원히 엑소 해 줘 나도 영원히 엑소엘 할게❤️
My love is BAEKHYUN
I come back here whenever I need my ear and soul cleansing. They're like singers who've been in this business for like 20 years, but they were just 20 when they sang it. Can't believe even after 9 years.
New 4 month baby EXO-L thanks to Kai's Rover remake and it was this video that made me become an EXO-L! Then is was D.O.'s Tell Me What Is Love live is when he became my biased! It blows my mind that Baekhyun was 20 & D.O. 19 and this was their first day on the job as rookies!? I have never seen or heard anything like this in K-pop! 2 weeks ago EXO were on Killing Voice Dingo and after 11 years they are STILL thee best live, power, vocal group in K-pop! I'm just sorry I didn't really know about them sooner. It's unhealthy how much EXO content I've been consuming! I've got 11 years to catch up on and it's been the best few months I've had as a K-pop fan! Thank you for existing EXO :)
Same for me🥹❤
Same, discovered them a few days ago
A 6 month old EXO-L here❤...I am also consuming a lot of exo drugs 😂
i love D.O's facial expressions when he's singing he's so expressive lol but when he's not singing it's like he's not feeling anything he's just there not giving away any emotions
Still watching this in 2022 and still getting shocked at my babies' vocals 💕💕
Nov 2023 and I'm still watching this... cause no new songs can beat this artistic creation.❤
D.o voice amazing
2:43 Baekhyun's little smirk there takes me over the edge!
그래서 듀엣 언제 내냐… 10년째 기다리는 게 맞냐…..?
DO..ur my bias now..huhuhu
Who's still watching this in 2021?
This song was one of my fave , Baekhyun and D.O's vocal always give me chills:)
Still watching in 2022 :)
THE MIC WILL ALWAYS BE ON!! something 4th gen can't relate to
Baeksoo´s voice is pure heaven. I could stare at these two singing all day ... so handsome too...
D O. Baekhyun
Baekhyun. D O
Only EXO can sing this way🙅🙅🙅
The maturity in their voices it's insaaaneeeee
d.o and Baekhyun sing together and their move realy same In end
this song never make me feel boring and i just keep listen to it =))) love Baehyun and DO voices :* beautìul voices
I always watch this one. I'm so inlove with kyungsoo's vocals. After seeing this video I fell hard for exo. 😊
I was once an exo fangirl, but it slowly faded away. But now it's coming back. Exo was the first kpop group that caught my life. Without them, I don't think I'll ever enter the wonderful world of kpop. And I think I'm beginning to love exo again. And I won't regret it. Exo is just so.. idk.. it's unexplainable. From the first word they sing, I might faint. They are just.. AMAZING AND AWESOME. :) I'm proud to be exo-l
Macces Macalisang same..!! XD My first Kpop group was EXO... lol then I got into other groups such as BTS, B.A.P., WINNER, etc... XD the EXO feels are slowly coming back tho haha
EXO SARANGHAE!!
Kyungsoo looks so pale though.. Eyebrow game is strong in this one.
And Baek's high notes
Happy 9years Baeksoo 🥰
D.O.'s english lines will always be the death of me 😅😍
0.0 my BAEKHYUN & D.O wooww .. saranghae
baek